JUSTICE 2 COMMITTEE AGENDA 1St Meeting, 2002
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
J2/02/1/A (REVISED) JUSTICE 2 COMMITTEE AGENDA 1st Meeting, 2002 (Session 1) Wednesday 9 January 2002 The Committee will meet at 9.30 am in Committee Room 2, Committee Chambers, George IV Bridge, Edinburgh. 1. Declaration of interests: The new member of the committee will be invited to declare any relevant interest. 2. Items in private: The Committee will consider whether to take item 3 in private and whether to consider in private lines of questioning for witnesses on the general principles of the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill at Stage 1 at its future meetings. 3. Land Reform (Scotland) Bill: The Committee will consider lines of questioning for item 5. 4. Budget Process 2003/4: The Committee will consider its approach to the budget process 2003/4. 5. Land Reform (Scotland) Bill: The Committee will take oral evidence on the general principles of the Bill at Stage 1 from— Andy Wightman; Alasdair Fox and William Henry, Members of the Rural Affairs Committee, and Stuart Drummond, Law Reform Officer, Law Society of Scotland; John Kinnaird, Vice President and Craig Campbell, Senior Policy Adviser, National Farmers Union Scotland; Dr Maurice Hankey, Director and Robert Balfour, Convener, Scottish Landowners Federation; Professor Jeremy Rowan-Robinson, Main Board member, John Thompson, Director of Operations and Strategy (West), and John Mackay, National Strategy Manager, Scottish Natural Heritage. 6. Land Reform (Scotland) Bill: The Committee will consider the written evidence received on the Bill at Stage 1. Gillian Baxendine Clerk to the Committee, Tel 85054 The following papers are attached for this meeting: Item 4 – Budget 2003/4 Note by the Clerk J2/02/1/243 Items 3, 5 and 6– Land Reform Bill SPICe note on suggested questions for witnesses (PRIVATE) J2/02/1/244 (TO FOLLOW) SPICe paper on Community and Crofting Rights to Buy J2/02/1/245 (MEMBERS ONLY – available at www.scottish.parliament.uk or in Document Supply Centre) SPICe paper on Access (MEMBERS ONLY – available at J2/02/1/246 www.scottish.parliament.uk or in Document Supply Centre) Land Reform Bill submissions Full list of submissions received on the Bill (see list attached) J2/02/1/1 – (SUBMISSIONS CIRCULATED FOR MEMBERS ONLY – J2/02/1/242 copies will also be available in Document Supply Centre or on the committee webpage under papers for 1st meeting 2002 in due course) Submission from Andy Wightman J2/02/1/138 Submission from the Law Society of Scotland J2/02/1/141 Submission from National Farmers Union Scotland J2/02/1/49 Submission from Scottish Landowners Federation J2/02/1/142 Submission from Scottish Natural Heritage J2/02/1/143 Report of the Rural Development Committee – Land Reform J2/02/1/247 fact-finding visits (MEMBERS ONLY – available at Document Supply Centre or on the committee’s webpage: http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/official_report/cttee/rural- 01/rar01-lr-01.htm) Draft Access Code (MEMBERS ONLY – available in J2/02/1/248 Document Supply Centre or at http://www.snh.org.uk) Note by the Clerk (PRIVATE – TO FOLLOW) J2/02/1/249 Papers for information circulated for the 1st meeting, 2002 Minutes of the 36th meeting, 2001 J2/01/36/M Letter of 17 December 2001 from the Minister for Justice re J2/02/1/250 High Court working group Note on forward schedule of meetings J2/02/1/251 Papers not circulated: Members are reminded to bring with them copies of the Bill and Accompanying Documents, available from Document Supply Centre or at the following website: http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/parl_bus/legis.html#44. J2/02/1/243 JUSTICE 2 COMMITTEE Consideration of 2003/4 Budget Background 1. The Scottish Executive’s budget proposals for 2003/4 will be published around Easter and subject committees will be required to report to the Finance Committee around the end of May. 2. Last year, the two Justice Committees decided, with the agreement of the Bureau, to meet jointly to scrutinise the budget proposals. This decision took account of the fact that each committee gains a different range of information and expertise from its work during the year. 3. The committees also agreed in principle to appoint an adviser on the budget last year but were unable to identify a suitable person in the time available. This year there will be some support available from the Finance Committee’s adviser, Professor Arthur Midwinter. However, as he will be covering the whole of the budget, some subject committees are also proposing to appoint their own advisers. 2003/4 budget process 4. The Committee is invited to agree that permission should again be sought from the Bureau to meet jointly to consider the budget proposals this year. 5. The Committee is also invited to agree in principle that an adviser should be appointed to assist with the budget scrutiny, assuming that a suitable person can be identified. If this is agreed, once a shortlist of names has been drawn up, the clerks will arrange a joint meeting of the two Justice Committees to consider it. Clerk to the Committee 20 December 2001 LAND REFORM BILL RESPONSES (as at 3 January 2002) J2 Paper no. Name J2/02/1/1 Dr R Byrne J2/02/1/2 J Gibbs J2/02/1/3 Benmore Outdoor Recreation Centre, A Beveridge J2/02/1/4 Lagganlia Outdoor Centre, R Arrowsmith J2/02/1/5 R Peters J2/02/1/6 D Rutherford J2/02/1/7 Ancrum Centre J2/02/1/8 A Melville J2/02/1/9 C Townsend J2/02/1/10 Dundee City Council, A Boffey, Outdoor Adventure Activities Safety Group J2/02/1/11 Pitlochry Angling Club, R Gardiner J2/02/1/12 C Smith, Outdoor Education Organiser, Midlothian Council J2/02/1/13 C Freshwater J2/02/1/14 PRIVATE PAPER J2/02/1/15 M Shade Spence J2/02/1/16 C Milligan J2/02/1/17 R Tomkinson J2/02/1/18 M Hulme J2/02/1/19 A Kimber J2/02/1/20 P Easson J2/02/1/21 A Maciver J2/02/1/22 T Ralphs J2/02/1/23 Off Beat Bikes J2/02/1/24 S Dickson J2/02/1/25 J Lee J2/02/1/26 K Stewart J2/02/1/27 RPM Guiding, R Potter, Director J2/02/1/28 Stuart Johnston Mountaineering J2/02/1/29 Highlander Mountaineering, Pete Hill J2/02/1/30 J Hair J2/02/1/31 Bowldown Farms Ltd, H and G Vernon J2/02/1/32 G Talboys J2/02/1/33 Association of Mountaineering Instructors, A Vowles, Chair J2/02/1/34 Rothiemurchus Estate, J Grant J2/02/1/35 H McCubbin J2/02/1/36 Alan Crichton Mountain Skills Ltd, A Crichton, Director J2/02/1/37 Scotways (The Scottish Rights of Way and Access Society) A Valentine, National Secretary J2/02/1/38 HF Holidays, A Berlyn, Head of Walking Operations J2/02/1/39 Rispond Estate, C Marsham J2/02/1/40 Clava Lodge Holiday Homes, M Smith J2/02/1/41 K Shade J2/02/1/42 Balnagown Estate, G Robertson, Factor – 2 letters J2/02/1/43 Dumfries and Galloway Council, J Smith, Planning and Environmental Consultancy Group Manager J2/02/1/44 Forss House Fishings, W Mustard, Salar Management Services Ltd J2/02/1/45 J Howe Guinan J2/02/1/46 Skelpick Partnership, G Lopes J2/02/1/47 Esk Board, M Halliday, Clerk J2/02/1/48 West Dunbartonshire Council, D Hill, Dept of Economic, Planning and Environmental Services J2/02/1/49 National Farmers Union Scotland (NFU Scotland), I Melrose J2/02/1/50 Seafield Estate, A Lewis, Chief Executive J2/02/1/51 Cyclists Touring Club (Scotland), D Adams J2/02/1/52 Aberdeenshire Council, A Garvie J2/02/1/53 Mar Estate, M Nicolson J2/02/1/54 Game Conservancy Trust , I McCall, Director Scotland and D Playfair, Public Relations Scotland J2/02/1/55 R Kershaw J2/02/1/56 Dr T Isles J2/02/1/57 Dr G Berry J2/02/1/58 Carnegie Club, Skibo Castle, A McLaren, Club Captain J2/02/1/59 G Roberts J2/02/1/60 R Stubbs J2/02/1/61 East Renfrewshire Council, A Ewen, Access Officer J2/02/1/62 Scottish Advisory Panel for Outdoor Education (SAPOE), N Scriven, Secretary J2/02/1/63 Scottish Law Commission (SLC), J Morrison, Project Manager J2/02/1/64 G Hickman J2/02/1/65 Scottish Sports Association, A Fraser, Executive Committee member J2/02/1/66 F Robertson J2/02/1/67 Scottish Countryside Ranger Association, T Wilson, Vice Chair J2/02/1/68 E Holttum J2/02/1/69 Adventure Scotland, D Horrocks, Director J2/02/1/70 D Bursnall J2/02/1/71 C Wimbush J2/02/1/72 Isle of Eigg Heritage Trust, J Chester, Reserve Manager and C Dressler, Director J2/02/1/73 R Woodwark J2/02/1/74 A McLean J2/02/1/75 I Frew J2/02/1/76 B Gilmour J2/02/1/77 G James J2/02/1/78 PRIVATE PAPER J2/02/1/79 I Wilson J2/02/1/80 M Herring J2/02/1/81 P King J2/02/1/82 P Mitchell J2/02/1/83 J Foote J2/02/1/84 J Wotherspoon J2/02/1/85 Inverclyde Council, Education Services, A MacDonald, Head of Support for Learning J2/02/1/86 M Newbury J2/02/1/87 G James, West Galloway Fisheries Trust (President) and River Baldnoch Fishery Board (Chairman) J2/02/1/88 The Grampian Club, A Boggon, President J2/02/1/89 Edinburgh Mountaineering Club, C Cook, President J2/02/1/90 J Holms J2/02/1/91 D Proctor J2/02/1/92 B Jones J2/02/1/93 J Matterson J2/02/1/94 I Knowles J2/02/1/95 C Park J2/02/1/96 H Cheape J2/02/1/97 J Roy J2/02/1/98 A Davidson J2/02/1/99 H Balfour J2/02/1/100 Dr G Mead J2/02/1/101 Independent Backpackers Hostels – Scotland, R Field, Secretary J2/02/1/102 E Mead J2/02/1/103 Ossian Guides, D Bulmer, Partner J2/02/1/104 Celtic Fringe: Wester Ross Tourist Association J2/02/1/105 S Mason J2/02/1/106 Garynahine Estate Partnership, C and P Buxton J2/02/1/107 T Jourdan J2/02/1/108 North East Mountain Trust, W Campbell, General Council Member J2/02/1/109 John Muir Trust, W Boyd-Wallis, Policy and Partnerships Manager J2/02/1/110 Transcotland Holidays, A Pointer J2/02/1/111 Inchree Centre, P Heron, Proprietor J2/02/1/112 Scottish Outdoor Recreation Network (SORN), F Nelson, Chairman J2/02/1/113 Scottish Countryside Alliance, A Murray, Director