Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
1
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sub Project: Incentivising Cultivation of Hybrid Maize in PPP Endeavour
Consolidated Report
Report prepared by
NABARD Consultancy Services Nabcons Cell, NABARD, Odisha Regional Office 2/1, Ankur, Nayapalli Civic Center, Bhubaneswar – 751015, Odisha, India, www.nabcons.com
2
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
STUDY TEAM
U.K.Mohanty, Senior Consultant
Prof (Retd.) Dibakar Naik, Mentor Consultant
Prof (Retd.) Bijoy Kumar Sahoo, Mentor Consultant
Binayak Dash, Lead Consultant
Asit Kumar Ghosal, Project Coordinator
DISCLAIMER The report has been prepared with all reasonable skill, care and diligence within the terms of contract with Director, IMAGE incorporating our general rules of business and taking account of the resources devoted to it by agreement with the client. We disclaim any responsibility to NABCONS/NABARD and others in respect of any matters outside the scope
of the study. At our level, this report is confidential to Government and we accept no responsibility of whatsoever nature to third parties to whom this report, or any part thereof, is made known. Any such party relies on the report at their own risk.
3
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
ABBREVIATIONS
AAO Assistant Agriculture Officer
ATMA Agriculture Technology Management Agency
DDA Deputy Director Agriculture
FYM Farm Yard Manure
MOU Memorandum of Understanding
MRP Maximum Retail Price
NABCONS NABARD Consultancy Services
N,P,K Nitrogen, Phosphorous, Potash
NGO Non Government Organisation
PD Project Director
PPP Public Private Partnership
RD Recommended Dose
RKVY Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojana
SC Scheduled Castes
ST Scheduled Tribes
VAW Village Agricultural Worker
4
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
CONTENTS
Page Section Title No. 1. Introduction 6
1.1. Overview of RKVY 6
1.2. Brief background of the study 6
2. Key Project features 7
3. Methodology of Evaluation 9
4. Findings of the study 9
4.1. Project target vis-à-vis achievement 9
4.2. Service Delivery Mechanism 10
4.3. Impact of the project 16
4.4. Perceptions of farmers 21
5. Conclusion 24
ANNEXURE
Abstract of Sample farmers surveyed for study I 26 purpose
II List of Sample farmers surveyed for study purpose 27
Copy of MoUs signed between Seed Companies & III 40 Implementing Officials
5
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
1. Introduction
1.1. Overview of RKVY
Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojana (RKVY) is one of the important flagship programmes of Government of India in agriculture and allied activities sector. The scheme was introduced in the year 2007-08 to provide incentives to states for increasing expenditure in agriculture & allied sectors. The entire assistance is in the form of a grant to the state. The scheme provides the states and union territories with the autonomy to draw up plans based on local requirements in their districts and ensure increased public investment in agriculture and allied sectors. Ultimate aim is to significantly increase the productivity and eventually maximize the returns of farmers.
In Odisha, RKVY is under implementation since 2007-08. Nodal agency is RKVY cell functioning under Department of Agriculture. Different implementing agencies submit need based project proposals to RKVY cell, which are thoroughly scrutinized, evaluated at different levels, then approved and funds are released for implementation.
1.2. Brief background of the study
As like other development projects, RKVY cell also undertakes third party evaluation every year and for the year 2014-15, the assignment has been entrusted to NABARD Consultancy Services (NABCONS), a subsidiary of NABARD. A list of 20 sub projects implemented during 2014-15 has been allotted to NABCONS for evaluation. “Incentivising Cultivation of Hybrid Maize in PPP Endeavour” is one of the allotted 20 sub projects.
The evaluation exercise aims at studying the service delivery mechanisms, actual delivery and its effectiveness, utilisation and maintenance of assets, extent of adoption by farmers, constraints and issues, remedial measures etc, so that the intended objective under Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojana could be met effectively for the agricultural growth of the State.
6
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
2. Key Project features
“Incentivising Cultivation of Hybrid Maize in PPP Endeavour” is one sub project taken up under RKVY in Odisha during 2014-15. Implementing agency is Directorate of Agriculture & Food Production including its field level offices. Total RKVY funding was Rs. 2010.00 lakhs, which includes Rs. 1875.00 lakhs as incentive to farmers and Rs. 135.00 lakhs towards contingent expenses.
Maize is one of the important cereal crop of the state grown in both kharif and rabi season. Area coverage is 2.90 lakh hectares; 93% in kharif and 7% in rabi season. Productivity in Odisha (24.07 q/ha) almost matches with all India average (25.53 q/ha), but there exists potential of increasing productivity up to 35 q/ha. Even though composite and synthetic varieties are grown in major areas, productivity is low due to poor management and failure to replace seed at regular intervals.
During the last one decade, the crop has attained paramount importance because of its increased demand for animal feed as well industrial uses. To grab this opportunity attempt has been made by Directorate of Agriculture to replace existing composite and synthetic varieties with hybrid maize varieties as well horizontal expansion of area coverage. Since 2010-11, every year about 30,000 ha of hybrid maize cultivation is being promoted through PPP mode. In 2013-14, the programme was taken up under RKVY and similar attempt has been made in 2014-15.
The objectives of this programme “Incentivising Cultivation of Hybrid Maize in PPP Endeavour” are
Area expansion of hybrid maize in the state through supply of good quality seeds and reducing the burden of production cost on farmers through incentive @ Es. 3750/ha. To acquaint the farmer with good agricultural practices (GAP) so as to increase productivity and better return to the farmers. The programme was planned during 2014-15 for execution in 50,000 ha covering 14 districts of the state with following operational guidelines.
7
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Selection of demonstration patches: The programme will be taken up in clusters of at least 50 ha contiguous patch. The Project Director, ATMA is given responsibility of selecting clusters with the help of seed companies and departmental staff. Implementation through PPP Mode: The programme will be implemented involving seed companies as well departmental staff. Total 10 seed companies were empanelled and allotted district wise area to be promoted under the programme. Maximum Retail Price of selected hybrid maize seeds are finalized by Directorate and seed companies can not charge more than approved MRP. Role of Departmental Officials: Project Director, ATMA will look after overall implementation of the programme in their district. One officer will be nominated as nodal officer for each cluster. The nodal officer along with field staff will work in close association with seed companies for successful implementation of the programme. Departmental officials will ensure proper documentation of the programme with the help of professionals. Role of seed companies: Seed Companies will take up massive awareness campaign, field days, demonstrations and facilitate marketing of the produce. Company sponsored demonstrations will be conducted in 0.25 acre each with full package of practices. One field day will be conducted for 2 to 3 clusters during harvesting time involving both beneficiary and non beneficiary farmers. Field days and awareness campaign will be conducted with the help of departmental staff. One flexi board depicting project details will be installed in each cluster. Mechanism to safeguard interest of the farmers: The Project Director, ATMA of the concerned district will sign an MOU with Seed Company to safeguard the interest of farmers and successful implementation of the programme. Incentives to farmers: Incentive @ Rs. 3750/- per ha will be provided to each farmer beneficiary who has purchased hybrid maize seed from the seed company empanelled for the cluster and has successfully raised the crop, duly certified by Project Director, ATMA. The incentives will be paid in cheque before 26th of July 2014.
8
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
3. Methodology of Evaluation
The evaluation study is based on primary and secondary data collected adopting scientific methods and appropriate research tools. Secondary data was collected from implementing agency and its district level Project Director, ATMA offices. Primary data was collected from sample beneficiary farmers using structured questionnaire. A total 694 randomly selected sample beneficiary farmers were surveyed in 61 villages of 34 blocks of 13 districts (Table 1). Detailed abstract and list of sample beneficiaries are presented in Annexure I & II.
Table 1. Sample units surveyed for study purpose No. of sample farmers surveyed 694
No. of Villages 61
No. of Blocks 34
Districts covered 13
4. Findings of the study
4.1. Project target vis-à-vis achievement
In 2014-15, target was 50,000 ha covering 14 districts. Out of 50,000ha target, achievement is 32816.32 ha (65.63%) in 13 districts. Nuapada district has failed to conduct the programme. A total 38,980 farmers have been benefited in 6426 villages of 137 blocks in 13 districts.
Table 2. Physical Target & Achievement District Target Area (ha) Achievement Area (ha) % 1. Angul 1000 455.46 45.55 2. Bargarh 2500 370.05 14.80 3. Bolangir 2750 2265.32 82.38 4. Gajapati 7000 7000.00 100.00 5. Ganjam 5500 5158.00 93.78 6. Kalahandi 6000 5801.00 96.68 7. Kondhmal 2000 805.22 40.26
9
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
District Target Area (ha) Achievement Area (ha) % 8. Keonjhar 2000 705.40 35.27 9. Koraput 4000 2273.07 56.83 10. Malkanagiri 2000 2000.00 100.00 11. Mayurbhanj 6000 5543.23 92.39 12. Nayagarh 1000 328.57 32.86 13. Nuapada 5000 0.00 0.00 14. Rayagada 3250 111.00 3.42 Total 50000 32816.32 65.63 Source: Office of the Project Director, ATMA of programme districts
4.2. Service Delivery Mechanism
Selection of Cluster/Beneficiaries: Discussions with implementing officials reveals that while selecting clusters importance was given to existing maize growing belts in the district. Within selected maize growing belts priority was given areas where farmers are using composite/synthetic and local varieties and have not adopted hybrid maize cultivation prior to the programme. After selection of clusters, farmers were motivated to take up hybrid maize under the programme. The study team also observed smilar facts, but observed failure in implementing programme in contiguous patches of 50ha. Reason being unwillingness of some resource poor farmers to purchase the hybrid seed initially from own sources.
Group Discussions with sample beneficiaries in all the 13 districts reveals that VAWs and AAOs contacted them prior to cropping season and motivated to grow hybrid maize. In some of the locations village meetings were conducted to explain programme benefits, rate of incentives and willing farmers were listed out. Then the farmers were called to Block offices to purchase seed from seed companies. Even though village meetings have been conducted at some locations in some of the districts, the implementing officials have failed to document it.
Seed Companies engaged for promotion of the intervention: Seed companies were selected by Directorate of Agriculture and district wise allotment of area was communicated to DDAs vide letter no 276 dated 16.06.14. Variety wise MRP was also approved by Directorate of Agriculture.
10
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Table 3. List of Seed companies allotted to Districts District Seed Companies 1. Angul Syngenta, Shakti seeds 2. Bargarh PHI seeds, Nuzivedu 3. Bolangir BISCO-Bio Sciences, Monsanto, Nuzivedu 4. Gajapati Sriram Bio Seeds, Rasi seeds, UPL 5. Ganjam Sriram Bio Seeds, UPL, Syngenta, PHI seeds, Monsanto 6. Kalahandi Rasi seeds, UPL, Monsanto, Nuzivedu 7. Kondhmal Kaveri seeds, Nuzivedu 8. Keonjhar UPL and PHI seeds 9. Koraput PHI seeds, Kaveri seeds, Nuzivedu 10. Malkanagiri Sriram Bio Seeds, Monsanto 11. Mayurbhanj Rasi seeds, UPL, PHI seeds, Monsanto, Nuzivedu 12. Nayagarh BISCO-Bio Sciences, Shakti seeds 13. Rayagada Rasi seeds, Monsanto, Nuzivedu Source: Office of the Project Director, ATMA of programme districts
Mechanism to safeguard interest of farmers: Now day’s failure of seed in delivering specified germination %, resistance against insect/pest and productivity is a common feature and farmers are incurring heavy losses because of fraudulent activity by private sector seed companies. These issues were addressed in the guideline in the form of a directive to concerned DDAs to sign a MoU with Seed Companies.
In line with this directive of the guideline, MoU between PD, ATMA and officials of seed companies were signed and maintained in DDA offices. Separate MoUs have been signed with each of the seed companies. A copy of the MoU collected from Mayurbhanj district is attached in Annexure III. After assessing the performance of seed companies in line with the terms and conditions specified in the MoUs, the study team is of the view that MoUs need to be more stringent with detailed specification of each activity to be performed by seed companies along with penalty for failure in taking up each activity.
Clause 14 of the MoU indicate that in case of failure of seed variety in the farmers field, compensation @70% of cost of cultivation is to be reimbursed by seed companies. As against this clause, the MoU has not specified issues like ideal cost of cultivation of maize crop
11
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
and also not linked to different percentages of germination failure, failure to exhibit claimed resistance to insect pests, productivity etc. As a matter of fact, this compensation clause need to be linked to Seed Bill 2010, Consumer Protection Act, 1986 and other relevant Acts meant to deal with such cases.
Further, the MOUs need to be executed before sale of seed by seed companies. It was revealed from sample check of MOUs that in some cases MOUs has been signed late. For example, in Bolangir district MOU has been signed on 22.07.14, in Gajapati on 04.08.14 and in Ganjam on 14.07.14 after sowing and germination of crop.
Hence, it is suggested to prepare a “Template” of MoU at State level by involving an expert team and issue to implementing districts with a directive to execute the MoU before sale of seed. This will help in safeguarding the interest of farmers in case of failure of seed in delivering desired results.
Further, the farmers need to be adequately trained to keep the invoice of seed purchase from seed companies in safe custody, to claim compensation in case of crop failure. During field survey, an attempt was made by the study team to physically verify the invoice of seed purchase at farmers point. Out of 694 sample farmers, only 79 could show it to study team, 107 said that they have kept the invoice, but failed to show it to study team. Rest 508 sample farmers failed to recollect their memory about collection of such invoice during purchase of seed.
Activities of Seed Company in Awareness creation, publicity: Since this is a PPP mode project, seed companies were entrusted with awareness creation and publicity of the programme. The implementing officials and agents of seed companies claim that awareness meetings have been conducted in all the panchayats, supported by mobile van campaigns. The versions of sample farmers also corroborate that seed companies had conducted awareness meetings in selected villages. Primary data collected by study team in 61 sample villages of 13 districts reveals that awareness meetings by seed companies were conducted in 67% villages (41 out of 61 sample villages). In almost all the sample villages, farmers are of the view that seed companies had engaged mobile vans to campaign for their hybrid seed.
12
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
But, no proper record is maintained on date and place of such awareness meetings, campaigns by implementing officials. Only some photographs of meetings conducted by two seed companies were collected by study team from office of the PD, ATMA Mayurbhanj.
Awareness meetings by PHI Seeds in Mayurbhanj district
Awareness creation by Rasi Seeds in Myurbhanj district
Demonstrations by Seed Companies: Similarly, seed companies were entrusted to conduct “Demonstrations” in 0.25 acre in each cluster and conduct “Field Days” in programme clusters involving both participating and non participating farmers. The implementing officials and seed companies claimed that required number of demonstrations and field days have been conducted. But, limited record is maintained on date and place of such field days and demonstrations.
It is suggested to maintain detailed records of activities of seed companies in PPP mode projects. This will help in assessing
13
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
performance of seed companies and their eligibility for continuance in such type of projects in future.
It may be mentioned here that UPL has developed a unique and effective agro advisory service called “UNIMART”, a chain of farm advisory and solution centers to provide extension services to farmers round the clock. Similarly, Monsanto has its own system “Monsanto Farm AgVisory Services (MFAS)” to meet the extension requirement of farmers. But such extension mechanisms were not adopted by these seed companies for delivery of extension services to beneficiary farmers of this Hybrid maize programme.
Market linkage by Seed Company: Since this is a PPP mode project, seed companies who have sold seed to farmers were entrusted with job of providing market linkage to the maize produce of the farmers. MoUs have been signed with seed companies accordingly. But in all the programme districts, primary data reveals that such market linkage has not been provided by seed companies.
Release of incentives to the farmers: In this project, an attempt was made by Government for “Direct Benefit Transfer” of input cost to farmers. Subsidy at 50% cost of inputs i.e. Rs.3750/ha were supposed to be paid to farmers in account payee cheques/RTGS mode. Guideline specified 25th July 2014 as the deadline for disbursement of incentives, so as to enable farmers to purchase inputs and apply in crop field in time.
Almost all the sample farmers complained before study team that incentives have been released much late, even after harvest of crop. Because of delay in release of incentives input application and ultimately productivity was affected. Data collected from PD, ATMA offices also corroborates with versions of farmers that incentives have been released much late. (Table 4) Table 4. Incentive release dates District Incentive release dates for Kharif Maize 1. Angul 17.10.2014 2. Gajapati 05.08.2014 3. Ganjam 08.12.2014 4. Kondhmal 17.12.2014 5. Mayurbhanj 29.12.2014 & 19.01.2015 6. Nayagarh 12.02.2015 Source: Office of the Project Director, ATMA of programme districts 14
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Gap in actual area coverage: One of the interesting findings of the study is gap between hybrid maize coverage areas indicated by implementing officials in records with that of actual area cultivated as per the versions of farmers recorded during field survey. Uniform area of demonstration like 0.4 ha, 0.8 ha, 1.00 ha was reported in majority of the cases in the beneficiary list submitted by DDA office to RKVY cell and to NABCONS. But in reality farmers have sown much less area. Since payment of incentive is based on area coverage, farmers have purchased higher quantity of seed with a motive to record higher area in govt record and get higher amount of incentives accordingly. But as fallout, farmers have sown higher doses of seed and could not harvest required productivity.
Seed companies have a motive to sell more quantity of seed for higher profit and grassroots implementing officials also have intention to meet the allotted area coverage target, resulting in such a scenario.
Inappropriate seed dose, High population density: Maize is a C4 plant and is more efficient in converting solar energy to grain production than wheat and rice. For hybrid maize, plant to plant spacing of 25cm in the rows at 60 cm apart is ideal to ensure 6 to 7 plants per square meter for getting desired productivity. But it was revealed from discussion with sample beneficiary farmers that such spacing was not maintained by them, as a result there was very high population density and poor crop growth. Such a situation has happened more in districts namely Angul, Bargarh, Kondhmal, Keonjhar, Mayurbhanj and Nayagarh. Lack of technical knowhow with farmers and inadequate extension support during sowing of seed is the main cause for such an unscientific cultivation of hybrid maize.
This would have been different, had there been access of farmers to “Seed Drill” a seed-cum-fertilizer multi-crop planter with an inclined plate seed metering system, which is essential for commercial cultivation of Hybrid Maize or required extension support to advise the farmers during sowing of crop.
15
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Engagement of Manpower/Nodal Officers: During 2014-15, hybrid maize programme was implemented in 137 blocks of 13 districts. Concerned block level AAOs were appointed as Nodal Officers and entrusted with responsibility of smooth implementation of the programme in their area of operation. NGOs have not been engaged in implementation of this programme. AAOs with the help of VAWs and Krushak Sathis have implemented the programme in the farmers’ field.
Forward Backward linkages: Since this is a PPP mode project, seed companies are supposed to provide extension and other services to farmers with the help of Krushak Sathis, VAWs and AAOs of implementing agency. Regular contact with the farmers during cropping season is essential to ensure forward backward linkage for successful implementation of the programme. But group discussions conducted by the study team with farmers in sample villages revealed that officials of seed companies have never visited their crop field during crop season. Farmers had last seen them during sale of seed at block office. This is a scenario in almost all the districts.
As per the version of farmers recorded during group discussion, VAWs and AAOs occassionally visit the crop field. Some more visits of AAOs & VAWs are required mainly during sowing, crop growth and pest attack to advice on dose and method of sowing, application of fertilizers and pesticides. Performance of seed companies in PPP mode projects need to be monitored regularly by implementing agencies.
4.3. Impact of the project
While collecting data on impact of hybrid maize programme on productivity, incremental farm return etc., wide variation between the districts was observed. Sample farmers surveyed in six districts namely Angul, Bargarh, Kondhmal, Keonjhar, Mayurbhanj and Nayagarh have reported much less productivity than their counterparts in seven districts namely Bolangir, Gajapati, Ganjam, Kalahandi, Koraput, Malakanagiri and Rayagada. So also there was wide variation in input use in maize crop. For clarity of the analysed data, former six districts have been grouped in to “Low productivity” and later seven districts “High productivity” group.
16
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Maize cultivation scenario is also different between these two groups of districts. There was higher target, so also achievement in high productivity districts than low productivity districts. (Table 2)
Incremental Productivity: The primary data collected from sample farmers on productivity recorded by them in non hybrid varieties usually cultivated by them and hybrid maize cultivated under the programme is presented in graphical form below. Higher productivity has been recorded in High productivity seven districts than in six Low productivity districts. Incremental productivity is about 19.45% in High productivity seven districts and only 12.50% in six Low productivity districts. Average incremental productivity taking data of all 13 sample districts is 17.82%. This is a good achievement. But in High productivity districts there was a good chance of reaching project target of 30q/ha, had there been 100% use of recommended inputs and good management practices adopted by farmers.
Inadequate input use: Hybrid maize is a input intensive crop with recommended requirement of 12.5t FYM, 100kg N, 60kg P, 50kg K, 2kg Azospirillum, 35kg of Zinc Sulphate (in Zinc deficient soils) for a hectare of crop to ensure desired productivity. This nutrient requirement is also to be backed by adequate need based pesticide, seed treatment chemicals and weedicides like atrazine or pendimenthalin.
17
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Analysis of primary data collected from sample farmers reveals failure of farmers to apply Recommended Dose (RD) of fertilizer. In Low productive six districts, about 60% sample farmers have applied less than 25% of recommended dose of fertilizer to the hybrid maize crop taken up under the programme. Scenario is little better in case of sample farmers of High productive districts.
Similar is the situation with regard to use pesticides, seed treatment and weedicide to control weed infestation, which is a serious problem in maize during kharif season. Farmers during group discussion revealed that since the incentives were paid late, they could not purchase inputs and apply to the crop. To some 18
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
extent this justification is correct. But, farmers need to be proactive in arranging inputs from some other sources and apply to crop in time.
This low fertilizer use is not unexpected considering the fact that average fertilizer consumption rate in Odisha is only 59kg/ha. In all the Low Productive districts except Bargarh, average fertilizer consumption rate is about 25kg/ha. In these districts, paddy is the staple crop and farmers give much importance to kharif paddy to earn food for the family for a year. More than 80% farmers are small and marginal and mainly from SC/ST community and can hardly afford to purchase input to meet the heavy input requirement of Hybrid maize without any additional support. Such a scenario put forth a big challenge to cost benefit of hybrid maize cultivation and its sustainability in Low productive districts after closure of project support.
Return to the farmers: The primary data collected from sample farmers reveals wide variation in disposal pattern of maize produce between High productivity and Low productive districts. In High productive districts, on an average 30% of maize produced in demonstration plots was consumed in own family of sample farmers as a staple food. This type of consumption as staple food in own family was recorded only 22% in case of sample farmers of Low productive districts.
Simarly, in Low productive districts sample farmers have sold on an average about 35% of produce in green stage as green cob, which is only 11% in High productive districts. In High productive districts, major chunk of the maize produced in demonstration plots of sample farmers is sold in the form of grain.
Average rate at which grain is sold is Rs. 8.45 by sample farmers of Low productive districts and Rs. 9.95 in case of sample farmers of High productive districts. Similarly, average rate at which green cob is sold by sample farmers is Rs. 85.25 per bunch of 100 cobs in Low productive districts as against Rs. 81.50 in High productive districts.
19
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Regarding net monetary return accrued to sample farmers is Rs. 13,358/ha in High productive districts and only Rs. 10,231/ha in Low productive districts. It may be mentioned here that while calculating net monetary return, family labour engaged in cultivation has not been taken in to account. This difference in return between two categories of farmers is mainly due to difference in productivity.
Incremental return received by sample farmers in hybrid maize crop over non hybrid composite/synthetic/local varieties is 20.19% in High productive districts and only 5.95% in Low productive 20
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
districts. Such a huge difference can be attributed to less productivity, poor management and low market rate in case of sample farmers of Low productive districts.
4.4. Perceptions of farmers
Key perceptions of farmers recorded during field survey are delay in release of incentives, lack of forward backward linkage, absence of remunerative market etc. These issues have been discussed in preceeding paragraphs except absence of remunerative market, which is presented in paragraph below.
Absence of Remunerative market: Discussion with farmers’ reveals that rates offered by traders is much low, which can not make up the huge investment in input intensive hybrid maize crop. In hybrid maize crop, seed cost is high, almost 5 times of non hybrid seeds. Similaly, the crop requires heavy doses of fertilizer, presticides to ensure desired productivity. Analysis of market rate and return to the farmers is already discussed in preceeding sections. The incremental return available to the farmers is not that much alluring to ensure sustainability of hybrid maize cultivation. Such a perception was received mainly from sample farmers of Low productive districts. This may be linked to maize production scenario in different parts of Odisha, which is discussed below.
Maize Production Scenario: In Odisha at present there are two types of maize farming. One is intensive commercial farming in major pockets of district like Nawarangpur, Gajapati, Ganjam, Koraput, Kalahandi etc where farmers practice precision farming and have market linkage with traders from Chhatisgarh, Andhra Pradesh. Mechanistation, post harvest facilities have developed to a major extent. In these districts, productivity is high, mechanical threshers are available on hiring basis and sale is mostly in grain form. In these districts there exists better chance of sustainability of hybrid maize cultivation.
21
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Harvest of maize cobs for grain purpose
As against above, situation in districts like Mayurbhanj, Keonjhar, Angul, Kondhamal, Bargarh, Nayagarh is entirely different. Farmers cultivate maize traditionally in up and medium land and grow composite/synthetic or local varieties which has low input requirement. Farmers are more interested to sell green cobs as harvesting is easy and requires less labour. Harvest of dry cob is not remunerative because of difficulty in removing grain from the shank and lack of market linkage to industrial units, cattle feed plants. The farmers in these districts have little access to mechanical threshers to separate the grains from the shank. Manual removal is not economically vaiable.
Similarly, another important perception of farmers of these Low productive districts is that desi maize or open pollinated high yielding synthetic and composite varieties that they were cultivating since years are sweeter in taste and cook easily than hybrid maize. Hybrid maize is not that tasty as like earlier varieties. Unlike earlier varieties, seeds cannot be harvested and every year hybrid seed is to be purchased. Further, when green cobs are being sold in bunch of hundred numbers, there is hardly any difference in rates offered by traders for hybrid varieties that could match with high cost of seed and other inputs required for hybrid maize cultivation.
22
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Green Cob sale Manual threshing of maize
In fact, these district have low fertilizer consumption rate, farmers are poor in economic standard to afford high cost of hybrid seeds and other inputs for commercial cultivation. There is lack of access to mechanization, post harvest facilities, market linkage etc. Unless precision farming is adopted by maize farmers backed by large scale extension machinery and provision of post harvest facilities and market linkage, cultivation of hybrid maize may not be economically viable and sustainable.
Mixed cropping of maize
Maize for food....another scenario: Apart from above, tribal farmers in both high productive and low productive districts cultivate maize since generations for food as a mixed crop with cowpea, arhar and vegetables. In case of failure of one crop due to inclement weather or other reasons, the other crop provides both food and financial security. Major part of the produce is used for own consumption. Such a practice may not be practicable for commercial cultivation of hybrid maize. This is a perception received from tribals among sample farmers surveyed in the present study. 23
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
5. Conclusion
The above findings of the study and perception of the farmers from different maize growing pockets of the state justifies the need for a detailed study by an expert team to identify potential pockets for continuance of hybrid maize promotion programme in the state.
It is also suggested that initially pilot projects may be taken up in Low productive districts on cluster basis only among progressive farmers in some agriculturally developed pockets having assured irrigation facilities. Post harvest facilities and market linkage need to be developed on pilot basis matching with requirement. Public sector hybrids need to be promoted as seed cost is much less than hybrids of private sector multinational companies. Based on adoption rate in these pilot projects, area coverage may be expanded.
It is also suggested that in case of tribal farmers where major chunk of maize produce is providing food and nutritional security to the farmer’s family, use of Public sector QPM (Quality Protein Maize) varieties is essential. This needs to be looked in to by implementing agency on priority basis.
Regarding implementation of projects on PPP mode, the performance of seed companies is not satisfactory. It was observed that seed companies are interested mainly to sell the seed; hardly any attempt has been made to provide hand holding support to the farmers. It may be mentioned here that Department of Agriculture, Government of Maharashtra is implementing a project called PPPIAD (Public Private Partnership for Integrated Agriculture Development Programme) since 2012. The main objective of the PPPIAD was to facilitate large scale integrated projects led by private sector in the agriculture and allied sectors, with a view to aggregating farmers, creating critical rural infrastructure, introducing new technologies, adding value and integrating the agricultural supply chain. One of the components of PPPIAD is improving the productivity of maize. The project has performed well in some pockets of Maharashtra. Lessons learnt from this project may be used in finalizing PPP mode programmes in the state.
24
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
ANNEXURE
25
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Annexure-I
Abstract of Sample farmers surveyed for study purpose No. of sample Villages Blocks District surveyed covered Covered 1. Angul 13 2 2 2. Bargarh 12 7 3 3. Bolangir 52 4 2 4. Gajapati 117 2 2 5. Ganjam 100 8 5 6. Kalahandi 115 9 3 7. Kondhmal 27 3 2 8. Keonjhar 36 3 3 9. Koraput 55 7 3 10. Malkanagiri 25 1 1 11. Mayurbhanj 114 12 6 12. Nayagarh 12 2 1 13. Rayagada 16 1 1 Total 694 61 34
26
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Annexure-II List of Sample farmers surveyed for study purpose Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 1 Mayurbhanj Baripada Gohaldihi Gohaldihi Paresh ch. Naik 2 Mayurbhanj Baripada Gohaldihi Gohaldihi Maheswar Mohanta 3 Mayurbhanj Baripada Gohaldihi Gohaldihi Dambarudhar Mohanta 4 Mayurbhanj Baripada Gohaldihi Gohaldihi Bhurguram Mohanta 5 Mayurbhanj Baripada Gohaldihi Gohaldihi Ashok ku. Naik 6 Mayurbhanj Baripada Gohaldihi Gohaldihi Parabasia Naik 7 Mayurbhanj Baripada Budhikhamari Budhikhamari Parao Tudu 8 Mayurbhanj Baripada Budhikhamari Budhikhamari Sanbijay Majhi 9 Mayurbhanj Baripada Budhikhamari Budhikhamari Saiba Singh 10 Mayurbhanj Baripada Budhikhamari Budhikhamari Sankha Murmu 11 Mayurbhanj Baripada Budhikhamari Budhikhamari Dasaratha Singh 12 Mayurbhanj Baripada Budhikhamari Budhikhamari Dhuma Marndi 13 Mayurbhanj Baripada Budhikhamari Budhikhamari Kshetramohan Singh 14 Mayurbhanj Baripada Budhikhamari Budhikhamari Paro Tudu 15 Mayurbhanj Baripada Budhikhamari Budhikhamari Dhiray Majhi 16 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Harish Chandra Singh 17 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Aparna Singh 18 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Jitendra Singh 19 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Kamalalachon Singh 20 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Dukhiram Singh 21 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Birendra Singh 22 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Dhuma Singh 23 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Uttam kumar Singh 24 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Badal Singh 25 Mayurbhanj Baripada Bankisol Bankisol Santosh Singh 26 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Chinmay Kumar Behera 27 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Binod Behera 28 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Jogeswar Behera 29 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Bimal Behera 30 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Satyaranjan Behera 31 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Niranjan Behera 32 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Harish Chandra Behera 33 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Rabindra Mohanty 34 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Padmolochan Behera 35 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Pratap Chandra Behera 36 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Prahlad Behera 37 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Upendra Mohanty 38 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Sidheswar Behera 39 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Sushanta Kumar Mohanty 40 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Narendra Nayak 41 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Shiba Shankar Behera 42 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Bhagirathi behera 43 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Dhanurjay Nayak 44 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Satyananda Behera 45 Mayurbhanj Samakhunta Sinduragoira Ambadubhi Parameswar Behera 46 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Niranjana Mohanty 47 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Mangulu Lenka 48 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Sambhunath Naik 49 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Anjan Ku. Mohanty 50 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Solagadia Siban Majhi 51 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Majhigadia Srimati Naik
27
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 52 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Giridhari Bagal 53 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Kanakalata Lenka 54 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Basanti Sahoo 55 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Narendra Lenka 56 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Hadibandu Khillar 57 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Samarai Majhi 58 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Surendra Khilar 59 Mayurbhanj Kaptipada Salachuya Gendagadia Chaitanya Soren 60 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Balijoda Manmata Mahakud 61 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Balijoda Dillip Kumar Barsalia 62 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Balijoda Lusa Murmu 63 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Balijoda Purendra Barik 64 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Balijoda Hiramani Hansda 65 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Balijoda Sankar Naik 66 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Sunaram Murmu 67 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Rameswar Hansdah 68 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Laxmipriya Murmu 69 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Siban Marndi 70 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Anjan Ku Mohakud 71 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Shantilata Murmu 72 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Bajunath Marndi 73 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Biswanath Tudu 74 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Rameswar Murmu 75 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Antaryami Mohakud 76 Mayurbhanj Gopabandhu Nagar Silaghati Kenduamundi Sanatan Mohankud 77 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Kaira Purty 78 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Ramchandra Singh 79 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Chadru Singh 80 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Naba Singh 81 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Sukdev Singh 82 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Natha Singh 83 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Chaku Singh 84 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Guruba Singh 85 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Natha Singh 86 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Sania Singh 87 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Majhiram Ho 88 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Matal Singh 89 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Mandal Singh 90 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Lada Ho 91 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Damu Ho 92 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Budhuram Sayan 93 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Matay Ho 94 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Laxmidhar Sayan 95 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Brajamohan Karua 96 Mayurbhanj Jashipur Dhalabani Dhalabani Narendranath Karua 97 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI SIDA SOREN 98 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI BIRSING MARNDI 99 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI BHIM HEMBRAM 100 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI DEORAY MAJHI 101 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI MASA HEMBRAM 102 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI KARA HEMBRAM 103 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI BALEYA MAJHI 104 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI GOURA HEMBRAM 105 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI SALKHAN MURMU 28
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 106 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PATEPANI SINGRAY MURMU 107 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PURUNAPANI ASHOK KU. MOHANTA 108 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PURUNAPANI DADHISWAR MOHANTA 109 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PURUNAPANI ABANTI MOHANTA 110 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PURUNAPANI SWAGATIKA MOHANTA 111 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PURUNAPANI DASHARATH MOHANTA 112 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PURUNAPANI SNIGDHARANI MOHANTA 113 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PURUNAPANI MITHU MOHANTA 114 Mayurbhanj Rairangpur Purunapani PURUNAPANI RAMPRASAD MOHANTA 115 Kandhamal Khajauripada Dutipada Patrapada Gokula Chandra Patra 116 Kandhamal Khajauripada Dutipada Patrapada Narendra Patra 117 Kandhamal Khajauripada Dutipada Patrapada Birata Patra 118 Kandhamal Khajauripada Dutipada Patrapada Biranchi Patra 119 Kandhamal Khajauripada Dutipada Patrapada Satyabadi Patra 120 Kandhamal Khajauripada Dutipada Patrapada Rama chandra Patra 121 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Sirtiguda Sirtiguda Nilakantha Paika 122 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Sirtiguda Sirtiguda Sukanta Beherdalai 123 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Sirtiguda Sirtiguda Srikrishna Paika 124 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Sirtiguda Sirtiguda Ramesh Paika 125 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Sirtiguda Sirtiguda Pratap Pradhan 126 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Sirtiguda Sirtiguda Bijaya Ch. Beherdalai 127 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Sirtiguda Sirtiguda Jayachandra Beherdalai 128 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Sankara Pradhan 129 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Banabasa Pradhan 130 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Sundaram Pradhan 131 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Hadeswar Pradhan 132 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Eswar Ch. Pradhan 133 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Bake Pradhan 134 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Jayadev Pradhan 135 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Kaibal Pradhan 136 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Ladu Kishore Pradhan 137 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Sishir Nayak 138 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Rameswar Pradhan 139 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Shukra Pradhan 140 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Jugeswar Pradhan 141 Kandhamal K. Nuagaon Bandhaguda Dadi Sumitra Pradhan 142 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Kora Dakua 143 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Bhimasen Karjee 144 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Natia Goud 145 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Dandapani pujari 146 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Abhimanyu Gouda 147 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Santosh Gouda 148 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Chitrasen Gouda 149 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Judhistira Gouda 150 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Subashi sahu 151 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Gopinath Sahu 152 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Kabiraj Pujari 153 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Anirudha beherdalai 154 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Bhagban Nayak 155 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Krusna Ch. Goud 156 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Bhim Beheradalai 157 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Gopinath Patra 158 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Ajaya Kanhar 159 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Hari Gouda 29
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 160 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Bansidhar Dalabehera 161 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Biswanath Patra 162 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Niranjan nayak 163 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Kanhu ch. Dalai 164 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Pravakar Dalai 165 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Bipra Ch. Goud 166 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Jhunu Sahu 167 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Bapina Pradhani 168 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Narayan Gouda 169 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Gunu Pujari 170 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Abhay Pujari 171 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Panchanan Dalai 172 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Budhia Pradhani 173 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Sanatan beherdalai 174 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Gadadhar B.Dalai 175 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Santanu K.Patra 176 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Pratap Singpatra 177 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Adinarayan Patra 178 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Dibakar Dalai 179 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Prakas Dalai 180 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Sudhir Patra 181 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Rajeswar Pujari 182 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Bidesini Gouda 183 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Rubana B.Dalai 184 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Ghasi Gouda 185 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Santosh Pradhani 186 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Banamali Pradhani 187 Gajapati Mohana Adava Adava Hruidesi Pradhani 188 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri SANJUKTA PATRO 189 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri RADHA K. DANDASENA 190 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri PARUSURAM GOUDA 191 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri ABHIMANYU PATTANAYK 192 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri RAMCHANDRA PANDA 193 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri RAIBARIA GOUDA 194 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KANDHA GOUDA 195 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri PRADEP KU. MALABISOYI 196 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri MANAMOHANA G. PATRO 197 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KISHOR BADA KUMAR 198 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri SUBASH CH.PRADHAN 199 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri ARUNA CH. PRADHNA 200 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri SIMADRI PAIKA 201 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri RAMANATHA DAS 202 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KRUSHNA CH.MAHANKUDA 203 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KUNA BAHARA DALAI 204 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri DHIREN KUMAR SINGH 205 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri LOKNATH PRADHAN 206 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri RABI SANKAR PRADHAN 207 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KORA PAIKA 208 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KORA DALAPATI 209 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri PANCHANAN PAIKA 210 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KAMDHUNI PAIK 211 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri JUDHISTIR BEHERA DALAI 212 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri GOPINATH DANDASENA 213 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri SASANKA GHADAI PATRO 30
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 214 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri BIDYADHAR PAIKA 215 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri BAYA DHAR PRADHAN 216 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri DAMODAR GHADAI PATRO 217 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri JAGANATH BADAKUMAR 218 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri DURYADHON GOUDA 219 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri ABHIMANYU GOUDA 220 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri TARINI CHARAN GOUDA 221 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri BISWANATH BADAKUMAR 222 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri ARUN CHANDRA PRADHAN 223 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri SANTOSH KU. MAHANKUDA 224 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri SANTOSH KU. GOUDA 225 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri RAJEEV GOUDA 226 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri DASHARATHI GOUDA 227 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri GOURA CH. MAHANKUDA 228 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri BHASKAR PRADHAN 229 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri MANOJ KUMAR GOUDA 230 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri Bhaskar Pradhan 231 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri JHUNU GOUDA 232 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri DAUDA RAITA 233 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri PUSPANJALI GHADAI 234 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri NILAKANTHA B. DALAI 235 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri SUSANTA BADAKUMAR 236 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri NARAYAN M. DANDASENA 237 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri DUKHA PAIKA 238 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri BIKRAM PAIKA 239 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri JOSADA PRADHAN 240 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KANHU CHARAN GOUDA 241 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KRUSHNA CH. MAHANKUDA 242 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri BHISMA MAHARATHI 243 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri MANJARI PAIKA 244 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri NARAYANA GOUDA 245 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KRUSHNA CH. GOUDA 246 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri SASHI GOUDA 247 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri NAKSHETRAMALA GOUDA 248 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri GAYATRI GOUDA 249 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri BANCHANIDHI GOUDA 250 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri KHIROD KUMAR GOUDA 251 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri LAUSA RAITA 252 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri NARENDRA KUMAR DAS 253 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri TARUNA KUMAR TARASIA 254 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri BIJAYA LAXMI TARASIA 255 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri GADADHAR PALAI PATRO 256 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri ESWAR CHANDRA GOUDA 257 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri LAXMI GOUDA 258 Gajapati R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri R. Udayagiri RATANAKAN GOUDA 259 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari MISS ROJI GOUDA 260 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari PANCHA GOUDA 261 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari LADUKISHOR PADHY 262 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari BIJAY PRADHAN 263 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari B TRINATHA PATRO 264 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari PINKU PRADHAN 265 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari S.IGNESHU 266 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari ALOKA KUMAR GOUDA 267 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari DEEPAK KUMAR GOUDA 31
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 268 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari SIMANCHAL GOUDA 269 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari BIPRA GOUDA 270 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari MANGALA BEHERA 271 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari RAMESHA PRADHAN 272 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari DINABANDHU GOUDA 273 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari KUNI GOUDA 274 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari KIRTAN PRADHAN 275 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari D GYANENDRA KU. PATRA 276 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari BULU RAUTA 277 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari NILABATI GOUDA 278 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari KALANDI MAHAPATRO 279 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari SARAT CHANDRA GOUDA 280 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari S.SAMBARI 281 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari S.GORA 282 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari S.SAIBANI 283 Ganjam Sanakhemundi Pudamari Pudamari SARATHI PRASAD NAYAK 284 Ganjam Khallikote Bania Bania BANCHANIDHI GOUDA 285 Ganjam Khallikote Bania Bania SUBASH GOUDA 286 Ganjam Khallikote Bania Bania UDAYA JANI 287 Ganjam Khallikote Bania Bania PRAKASH JANI 288 Ganjam Khallikote Bania Bania PUSPANJALI JANI 289 Ganjam Khallikote Bania Bania PRATIMA JANI 290 Ganjam Khallikote Bania Bania BIPRA PRADHAN 291 Ganjam Khallikote Mathura Kharipalli MANGARAJ SETHY 292 Ganjam Khallikote Mathura Kharipalli PRAMOD KU.SETHY 293 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli KUMARI SABAR 294 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli DEBARAJ SABAR 295 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli SURENDRA SABAR 296 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli SUKANTI SABAR 297 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli NARAN SABAR 298 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli TULASI SABAR 299 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli BRUNDA SABAR 300 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli BIJU SABAR 301 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli PUNI SABAR 302 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli SUKLA SABAR 303 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli RAM SABAR 304 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli GANESH SABAR 305 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli ABALI SABAR 306 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli SUJANI SABAR 307 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli ADABANDHU SABAR 308 Ganjam Khallikote Badapalli Badapalli SRIRAM SABAR 309 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Prabhakar Mahapatro 310 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Indira Mahapatra 311 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Laxmi narayan Gouda 312 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Gouranga Gouda 313 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Pabitra Kumar Patra 314 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Pankaj Kumari Sahu 315 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Pramod Kumar Maharana 316 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Sabita Padhy 317 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Satya Narayan Sahu 318 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Sunil Kumar Panigrahy 319 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Sudhir Sethi 320 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Arakhita Bhanja 321 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Sunil Nayak 32
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 322 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Nishikanta Panda 323 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Brundaban Sahu 324 Ganjam Hinjlicut Hinjlicut, NAC Hinjlicut Durga charan Sahu 325 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada BRAHMA NAYAK 326 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada RAMAKRUSHNA GOUDA 327 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada TUKUNA PRADHAN 328 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada ARUNA KU. PRADHAN 329 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada SANGRAMLAL PATRA 330 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada NITYANANDA PRADHAN 331 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada TARINI PRADHAN 332 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada PRABHASINI PRADHAN 333 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada SAROJ BADTYA 334 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada KANGRES PRADHAN 335 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada ABHIMANYU NAYAK 336 Ganjam Sheragarh Takarada Takarada KABIRAJ NAYAK 337 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda SUBHRANSU KUMAR PADHY 338 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda SANGRAM KESHARI POLAI 339 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda BIBHUTI BHUSAN PALAI 340 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda DHANUDHAR POLAI 341 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda RAMAKANTA SAHU 342 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda ADITYA KUMAR POLAI 343 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda PRAKASH CHANDRA POLLAI 344 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda SUNIL KUMAR BHUYAN 345 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda ANIL KUMAR BHUYAN 346 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda SARADA POLAI 347 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda TRILOCHAN POLAI 348 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda RABINDRA SAHU 349 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda SUKURU SAHU 350 Ganjam Purusottampur Bhatakumorda Bhatakumorda SOUMYA RANJAN POLAI 351 Ganjam Purusottampur Sunathar Sunathar KISHORE CHANDRA NAHAK 352 Ganjam Purusottampur Sunathar Sunathar RAMAKRUSHNA NAHAK 353 Ganjam Purusottampur Sunathar Sunathar RABINDRA NAHAK 354 Ganjam Purusottampur Sunathar Sunathar SURENDRA BASTIA 355 Ganjam Purusottampur Sunathar Sunathar NALINI KUMARI BASANTIA 356 Ganjam Purusottampur Sunathar Sunathar SANTOSH KUMAR BASANTIA 357 Ganjam Purusottampur Sunathar Sunathar SANDEEP KUMAR BASANTIA 358 Ganjam Purusottampur Sunathar Sunathar SUNIL KUMAR BASANTIA 359 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Tularam Halba 360 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Bamadeba Halaba 361 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Nilabati Majhi 362 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Rupdhar Pujari 363 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Padman Halaba 364 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Damu Halba 365 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Chaitanya Gadaba 366 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Dasarathi Halba 367 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Arjun Halba 368 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Narayan Bhatra 369 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Lingaraj Halaba 370 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Debraj Bhatra 371 Koraput Borigumma Anchala Anchala Haribandhu Majhi 372 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Sanmati Pujari 373 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Hiramani Bhatra 374 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Kamali Naik 375 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Krushna Randhari 33
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 376 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Mana Bhatra 377 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Jayram Bhatra 378 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Krushna Bhatra 379 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Harekrushna Halba 380 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Bhagaban Nayak 381 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Purusottam Halba 382 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Bighna Halba 383 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Laxman Nayak 384 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Chhayanath Halba 385 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Hadibandhu Bhatra 386 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Ghanashyam Gupta 387 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Chaitu Majhi 388 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Goura Chandra Halba 389 Koraput Borigumma Aunli Aunli Jitru Bhatra 390 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Pujariguda Saita Pujari 391 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Pujariguda Benu Bhatra 392 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Pujariguda Sundra Bhatra 393 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Pujariguda Nilo Bhatra 394 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Pujariguda Laxman Bhatra 395 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Randhariguda Balaram Naik 396 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Randhariguda Ram Chandra Nayak 397 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Randhariguda Bhagabati Bhatra 398 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Randhariguda Laxman Majhi 399 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Randhariguda Krupa Majhi 400 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Kadamaguda Jagannath Gadaba 401 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Kadamaguda Shashimani Gadaba 402 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Kadamaguda Laxman Gadaba 403 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Kadamaguda Chaitan Gadaba 404 Koraput Jeypore Kanga Kadamaguda Parsuram Gadaba 405 Koraput Jeypore Jeypore Jeypore Nabin Chandra Bebarta 406 Koraput Jeypore Jeypore Jeypore Laxmikanta Panda 407 Koraput Jeypore Jeypore Jeypore Satyabadi Dash 408 Koraput Jeypore Jeypore Jeypore Kailash Chandra Bebarta 409 Koraput Jeypore Jeypore Jeypore Suresh Kumar Sutar 410 Koraput Laxmipur Burja Chilisankha Ramaswami Wadeka 411 Koraput Laxmipur Burja Chilisankha Sadana Wadeka 412 Koraput Laxmipur Burja Chilisankha Meali Wadeka 413 Koraput Laxmipur Burja Chilisankha Smt. Wendi Wadeka 414 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Jebekanta Laxman Rao 415 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Bidika Siba Prasad 416 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Minati Bidika 417 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Harish Bidika 418 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Rakesh Bidika 419 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Munindra Kalu Apparao 420 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Bommika Raja Rao 421 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Jagannath Rana 422 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Nalapura 423 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Budi Bidika 424 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Iswar Chandra Panda 425 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Narsingh Patra 426 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Shantilata Patra 427 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Kailash Chandra Labala 428 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Janardhan Labala 429 Rayagada Bissam Cuttack Hata Muniguda Hata Muniguda Gouri Prasad Senapati 34
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 430 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Dhabaleswar Mashra 431 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Upendra sahu 432 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Sripati Sahu 433 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Dustanasan Naik 434 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Kuni Sahu 435 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Khirendri Mashra 436 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Thabira Mashra 437 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Dhirendranath Mashra 438 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Debraj Bandichod 439 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Suresh Mashra 440 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Jiten Kumar Sahu 441 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kutrukhamar Sadananda Majhi 442 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kapsara Santosh Ku Behera 443 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kapsara Prafulla ku Mallik 444 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kapsara Arjun Nag 445 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kapsara Laxmipriya Nayak 446 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Kutrukhamar Kapsara Gitanjali Mallik 447 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Mohan Jhankar 448 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Bisam Jani 449 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Banmali Jani 450 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Genar Harijan 451 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Sasmita Jani 452 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Purna ch. Jani 453 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Niranjan Jani 454 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Kuanru Jani 455 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Gurubaru Jani 456 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Mallik Jani 457 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Jagadish Jani 458 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Tike Jani 459 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Gobinda Jani 460 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Jugeswar Majhi 461 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Rabi Jani 462 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Trilochan Jani 463 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Dhanu Jhankar 464 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Madhuram Jani 465 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Kailash jani 466 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Prabhakar Jani 467 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Braja jani 468 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Ramdas Jani 469 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Harishankar Jani 470 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Khairbhadi Sarita Praharaj 471 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Nandlal Padhan 472 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Ulapi Padhan 473 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Krushna chandra Padhan 474 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Subat Padhan 475 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Prakash Chandra sa 476 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Sunita Pradhan 477 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Rajanikanta Sa 478 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Upendra Sha 479 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Basanta Kumar Sa 480 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Braja jani 481 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Sudam charan Sa 482 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Santosh Dey 483 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Garudadhwaja Padhan 35
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 484 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Sambhunath Padhan 485 Kalahandi Bhawanipatna Deypur Deypur Lahadin Padhan 486 Kalahandi Kesinga TUNDLA TUNDLA DEBRAJ PADHAN 487 Kalahandi Kesinga TUNDLA TUNDLA SACHIN PADHAN 488 Kalahandi Kesinga TUNDLA TUNDLA BEDABARA SA 489 Kalahandi Kesinga TUNDLA TUNDLA ASHOK PADHAN 490 Kalahandi Kesinga TUNDLA TUNDLA PRAFULLA PADHAN 491 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI TANURAJ SAHU 492 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI BIDYADHAR SAHU 493 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI ANTARAM SAHU 494 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI GOURANGA SAHU 495 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI KALAKANHU SAHU 496 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI MOHANLAL SAHU 497 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI RAMAKANTA SAHU 498 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI SAHAJAN SAHU 499 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI KAUTUKA SAHU 500 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI ABADHUT SAHU 501 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI KAIBALYA SAHU 502 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI HARI KUMAR 503 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI DOLOMANI SAHU 504 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI GIRIDHARI SAHU 505 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI SURENDRA KUMAR 506 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI DUTESWAR KUMAR 507 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI BIMBADHAR SAHU 508 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI DALIMBA SAHU 509 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI HIRAMANI SAHU 510 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI HEMANTA SAHU 511 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI TARABATI KUMAR 512 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI BAIKUNTHA SAHU 513 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI PURNACHANDRA SAHU 514 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI PATRALATA KUMAR 515 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI BABITA KUMAR 516 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI SINDHUSUTA SAHU 517 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI HARISHANKAR SAHU 518 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI SARITA SAHU 519 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI PRASANNA KU. SAHU 520 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI MAKARANDA SAHU 521 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI YASHODA SAHU 522 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI PRAMANANDA BINEL 523 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI RENGALI SILA SUNA 524 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI PRAVAKARA SAHU 525 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI RAMAKANTA SAHU 526 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI ARJUN SAHU 527 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI MAHENDRA SAHU 528 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI MRS.NILAM SAHU 529 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI PANKAJA SAHU 530 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI LALITMOHAN SAHU 531 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI MALAYARANJAN SAHU 532 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI SADANANDA SAHU 533 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI CHINTAMANI SAHU 534 Kalahandi Kesinga BALSI BALSI DILESWAR SAHU 535 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Panjipadar Romanchal Naik 536 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Panjipadar Raghumani Naik 537 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Panjipadar Dhanurjaya Naik 36
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 538 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Panjipadar Prahallad Naik 539 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Mandel Parimala Barik 540 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Mandel Gayatri Barik 541 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Mandel Champa Barik 542 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Mandel Sabitri Barik 543 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Mandel Nirmal Barik 544 Kalahandi Narla Mandel Mandel Makardhwaj Barik 545 Bargarh Bargarh Bargaon Bargaon Indrajit Khamari 546 Bargarh Bargarh Bargaon Bargaon Biranchi Pradhan 547 Bargarh Bhatli Bhatli Gopalpur Debendra Pradhan 548 Bargarh Bhatli Bhatli Gopalpur Tankadhar Barik 549 Bargarh Bhatli Bhatli Kusanpuri Chaitanya Meher 550 Bargarh Bhatli Tejagola Boulsingha Mitrabhanu Sahu 551 Bargarh Bijepur Bijepur Keutipali Chaitanya Pradhan 552 Bargarh Bijepur Bijepur Keutipali Sukadeb Sahu 553 Bargarh Bijepur Bijepur Keutipali Rohit Rana 554 Bargarh Bijepur Bijepur Bijepur Saroj Kumar Sahu 555 Bargarh Bijepur Bhatigaon Bhatigaon Bhismadeb Sahu 556 Bargarh Bijepur Bhatigaon Bhatigaon Birakishore Sahu 557 Bolangir Bolangir Bhundimuhan Bhundimuhan Karuna Naik 558 Bolangir Bolangir Bhundimuhan Bhundimuhan Biswanath Naik 559 Bolangir Bolangir Bhundimuhan Bhundimuhan Jogeswar Naik 560 Bolangir Bolangir Bhundimuhan Bhundimuhan Shantilata Naik 561 Bolangir Bolangir Bhundimuhan Bhundimuhan Shyama Meher 562 Bolangir Bolangir Bhundimuhan Bhundimuhan Mohana Ghibela 563 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Ramesh Chandra Patel 564 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Narayan Patel 565 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Shankarsan Patel 566 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Sarojini Patel 567 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Gitanjali Patel 568 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Chintamani Patel 569 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Sulochana Rout 570 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Sujata Patel 571 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Pramod Kumar Rout 572 Bolangir Patnagarh Ulba Ulba Swarnamayee Rout 573 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Bhainsha Jagat Kuanr 574 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Bhainsha Daitari Bisi 575 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Bhainsha Kamal Lochan Pradhan 576 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Bhainsha Kushadhwaj Sahu 577 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Laxmi Kumbhar 578 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Belamati Banchhor 579 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Uma Nag 580 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Dolamani Mallik 581 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Bharat Thanapati 582 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Kishore Kumar Mallik 583 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Binodini Meher 584 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Niranjan Podh 585 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Chudamani Meher 586 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Sumati Meher 587 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Sibananda Mallik 588 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Subash Bagarty 589 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Janja Bag 590 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Pramod Mallik 591 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Harekrushna Meher 37
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 592 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Ashok Kumar Meher 593 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Gouranga Meher 594 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Gobardhan Meher 595 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Amitav Prusty 596 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Fakira Meher 597 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Ghanashyam Meher 598 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Pankaj Padhariya 599 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Bhelasagar Meher 600 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Subodh Meher 601 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Sachidananda Meher 602 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Shiba Prasad Meher 603 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Kumar Meher 604 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Rashmirekha Meher 605 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Sarat Chandra Meher 606 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Shobhagini Meher 607 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Prafulla Kumar Meher 608 Bolangir Patnagarh Bhainsha Chingerbandh Rajendra Meher 609 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Bikash Chandra Ray 610 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Santosh Biswas 611 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Aswini Mandal 612 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Bipul Mandal 613 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Paresh Chandra Biswas 614 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Amla Mandal 615 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Harichand Ray 616 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Panchanan Biswas 617 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Jeeban Mistry 618 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Ramprasad Sarkar 619 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Manjit Biswas 620 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Dipankar Mandal 621 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Jagannath Mandal 622 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Subadha Mandal 623 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Ashok Mandal 624 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Amar Mandal 625 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Subash Sarkar 626 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Satyajit Ray 627 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Prakash Ray 628 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Ashok Mistry 629 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Nagen Biswas 630 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Subrat Sarkar 631 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Pagali Sarkar 632 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Balai Mistry 633 Malkangiri Malkangiri Tamasa MPV - 1 Puspa Mandal 634 Angul Angul Jagannathpur Jagannathpur Kulamani Sahu 635 Angul Angul Jagannathpur Jagannathpur Madan Sahu 636 Angul Angul Jagannathpur Jagannathpur Ramesh Sahu 637 Angul Angul Jagannathpur Jagannathpur Dibakar Sahu 638 Angul Angul Jagannathpur Jagannathpur Kailash Chandra Pradhan 639 Angul Athamallik Ambasarmunda Talamaliha Harihara Majhi 640 Angul Athamallik Ambasarmunda Talamaliha Bangura Pradhan 641 Angul Athamallik Ambasarmunda Talamaliha Khirendra Sahu 642 Angul Athamallik Ambasarmunda Talamaliha Bhagaban Majhi 643 Angul Athamallik Ambasarmunda Talamaliha Sahidananda Pradhan 644 Angul Athamallik Ambasarmunda Talamaliha Dillip Kumar Sahu 645 Angul Athamallik Ambasarmunda Talamaliha Sasanka Sekhar Pradhan 38
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Sl. Name of the Beneficiary District Block GP Village No. farmer 646 Angul Athamallik Ambasarmunda Talamaliha Sarangadhar Pradhan 647 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Ladukesharpur Mahendra Kumar Mishra 648 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Ladukesharpur Nakula Barik 649 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Ladukesharpur Gadadhar Swain 650 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Ladukesharpur Jatia Pradhan 651 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Ladukesharpur Trinath Rout 652 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Ladukesharpur Nilakantha Behera 653 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Barapalla Madhab Nayak 654 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Barapalla Nilamani Nayak 655 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Barapalla Bidyadhar Behera 656 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Barapalla Kailash Nayak 657 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Barapalla Dinabandhu Nayak 658 Nayagarh Naygarh Bhatasahi Barapalla Rankanath Nayak 659 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Pitambara Mahanta 660 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Rasananda Mahanta 661 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Laxmidhar Mahanta 662 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Netrananda Mahanta 663 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Banamali Mahanta 664 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Hadibandhu Mahanta 665 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Krushna Chandra Mahanta 666 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Kalami Naik 667 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Hrushikesh Naik 668 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Nirakara Naik 669 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Harsingh Naik 670 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Bhagirathi Mahanta 671 Keonjhar Ghatagaon Rutisila Ankalapada Upendra Kumar Naik 672 Keonjhar Jhumpura Balibandha Chingudiposi Bholanath Mahanta 673 Keonjhar Jhumpura Balibandha Chingudiposi Prafulla Mahanta 674 Keonjhar Jhumpura Balibandha Chingudiposi Parameswar Mahanta 675 Keonjhar Jhumpura Balibandha Chingudiposi Dolagobinda Mahanta 676 Keonjhar Jhumpura Balibandha Chingudiposi Dinabandhu Mahanta 677 Keonjhar Jhumpura Balibandha Chingudiposi Umakanta Mahanta 678 Keonjhar Jhumpura Balibandha Chingudiposi Srikanta Mahanta 679 Keonjhar Jhumpura Balibandha Chingudiposi Motilal Mahanta 680 Keonjhar Jhumpura Balibandha Chingudiposi Kadambini Mahanta 681 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Madhusudan Naik 682 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Jamini Naik 683 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Nabakishore Naik 684 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Naresh Chandra Behera 685 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Chanchala Naik 686 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Dhaneswar Naik 687 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Dusmanta Naik 688 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Maheswar Naik 689 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Dhyanaranjan Naik 690 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Kapileswar Naik 691 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Nirmal Naik 692 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Biswanath Naik 693 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Kulamani Naik 694 Keonjhar Champua Champua Godhuli Iswar Chandra Naik
39
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
Annexure III Copy of MoUs signed between Seed Companies & Implementing Officials
40
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar
Concurrent Evaluation & Monitoring Consolidated Report of RKVY Projects in Odisha 2014-15
41
NABARD Consultancy Services | Bhubaneswar