REAL LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 NYS 2017-2018 Assembly and Senate 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A255 A406 Dinowitz Time limits to complete repairs in Amd RPAPL L&T Passed A 1/9/18 S350 Peralta consent orders re: bldg. violations 777 A338 Braunstein Relates to increase in assessed values of NYC Ad Cd CCTax S5229 Stavisky cooperative apartments A353 A3391A Braunstein Relax restrictions on Add RPL 220-a Condo Passed A 3/6/17 S5219 S3148A Stavisky refinancing for co-ops built on long term Co-op ground leased land RP Fin A354A Braunstein Establishes new tax Add RPTL CCTax S5320 Stavisky classification for condominiums and cooperatives for assessment purposes A372 A10757 Richardson Clarifies use of electronic signature for Amd. Bank L 2 RP Fin Chap 20 of 2017 S982 Savino mortgage loans A581A Sepulveda Creates residential condo owner bill of Add RPL 339-11 Condo See also A5816 S510 Diaz rights Co-op A666 A5280 Rodriguez Prohibits rent increase without no Amd Priv L&T S2370 S3556 Alcantara violations certificate HousFinL Low Inc Hous A722 A6391 Perry Requires lenders negotiating mortgage Add BankL 6-n RP Fin S2223 S2752 Parker modification to continue even if loan PI sold A941 Thiele Require bank taking possession of Amd RPTL 425 CCTax S1602 LaValle STAR benefitted property to notify assessor A1089 A1156A Dinowitz Prohibits landlord from charging its Add RPL 234-a L&T S2377 S3591A Alcantara legal fees to tenant without court order & other A1186 A3272 Simanowitz Prescribes method of payment for Amd NYC Ad T&T S1576 Avella delinquent taxes, water/sewer etc. in Cd 11-322 NYC A1266 A10745 Weinstein To include reverse mortgages as "Home Amd RPAPL RP Fin See also S1992 S8177 Klein loan" for required prior notices 1304 A9593/S1992A A1371 A10373 Weinstein Applies affirmative allegations re: high Amd RPAPL S5928 Avella cost/subprime loans to all 1302

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 1 REAL SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A1382 A1728 Zebrowski Relates to property tax exemption for Amd. RPT L CCTax S2599 Lanza 1005 disabled veterans 458-a; A1387 A163 Weinstein No recording assignment of mtge. w/o Add S 291k to T&T OAR: RPLS S475 S1278 Peralta mtge. ownership doc. RPL RP Fin #1A 3/8/12 Memo #2 5/7/13 A1423 Weinstein Authorizes mortgage/lienor of Amd RPAPL RP Fin S6172 Hamilton abandoned multiple dwelling to request 1972 receiver A1498 A247 Weinstein No standing defense not waived if Add RPAPL RP Fin S6093 S5241 Savino omitted from answer 1302-a A1746 A837 Pretlow Fines co-op for failure to credit Amd RPTL 425 Condo S76 S2746A Hoylman tenant/stockholder with STAR Co-op exemption A1785 A6685B Perry (MS) Requires recorder of to send notice Amd RPL 291 T&T S2966 S7955 Golden of transfer to record owner [fraud protection] A1930 A10701 Joyner Creates /landlord fraud awareness Amd Exec L 94- L&T Passed A 2/6/18 S631 S7732 Boyle program re: fraudulent a Low Inc Hous A1953 Moya Removes mortgage guaranty insurance Amd Ins L 6503 RP Fin Passed A 6/13/17 S1478 S6693 Seward coverage limit Passed S 5/16/17 Chap 373 of 2017 A1980 Kavanagh In relation to MCI rent increases Add NYC Ad L&T S4312 S4423 Krueger Cd A2135 A10246 Dinowitz Permits reverse mortgage for persons 70 Amd RPL 280-c RP Fin S4712 S7844 Klein and over secured by co-op unit Condo Co-op A2188 A1900 Pretlow Require landlord to furnish rider Add RPL 223-c L&T S2970 S2241 Stewart- describing rights and duties of landlords Cousins and tenants A2490 McDonald Relates to redemption of property Amd RPTL CCTax S175 Marchione subject to delinquent tax line 1120

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 2 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A2517 A1890 Englebright Authorizes local laws to permit late Amd RPTL 425 CCTax S3196 LaValle STAR applications A2633 A4315 Sepulveda Tenant gets atty. fees for service of Amd RPL 234-a L&T S2313 S3750 Alcantara notice based of on false facts A2681 A5635 Thiele Seniors can file for STAR after purchase Amd RPTL 425 CCTax S3228 S1593 LaValle subsequent to tax status date A2784B A9588A McDonald Relates to placing a lien for unpaid Add GenMunL T&T Passed A 6/20/17 S3691B Marchione property taxes against proceeds of fire Passed S 6/21/17 insurance policy on any real property in Chap 342 of 2017 a municipality A2803 A10116 Williams Expands definition of "tenant" for Amd RAPL RP Fin Passed A 6/21/17 S5655 S7792 Klein mortgage FC notice 1305 Workout BR A2874 Galef Relates to taxations of cooperatives Amd RPTL 581 CCTax S1191A Little & RPL 339-y Condo Co-op A3031 Englebright Provide local option to extend time for Amd RPTL 457 CCTax Chap 128 of 2017 S3530 LaValle exemptions for first time homeowners A3037A Skoufis Clarifies what records a HOA member Amd NPC L 621 Condo Chap 343 of 2017 S6648 Larkin may request from the HOA for review Co-op A3322 A997 Miller Requires residential mortgage bill of Amd Bank 35 RP Fin S2654 S6339 Hamilton rights be printed and posted on internet in 8 most spoken languages A3435 A2536 Kim Requires mortgage lenders/brokers to Add Bank L 35 RP Fin See also S7039 S2228 Kennedy provide consumer pamphlet prior to A5372/S334 application A3691 Galef Prohibits HOA from restricting Add RPL Art 9-c Condo S7735 Parker installation/use of solar power Sec. 342 Co-op A3765 A1237 Dinowitz Authorizes sale or mortgage of certain Amd Rel CorpL NFP S2935 Gallivan real property of religious corporation 12 T&T without leave of Supreme Court A3827 A613 Rosenthal Prohibits landlords from refusing to deal Amd ExecL 26 L&T S5240 S3560 Gianaris with persons involved in prior summary proceeding NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 3 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A3838 A5594 Sepulveda Prohibits collection of an administrative Amd GOL 7-103 L&T S2374 S3036 Alcantara expense by landlord and provides for the tenant to collect all interest paid on a security deposit A3927 Zebrowski Prohibits tax exemptions for Amd RPTL 420- CCTax S8133 Little violating laws a T&T A4127 Magee Authorizes county clerks to establish Amd RPL 334 T&T S7751 S2610 Marchone electronic map filing A4335 A3857 Gottfried Makes warrant execution, not issuance, Amd RPAPL L&T S3192 S2872 Krueger act which annuls relationship 749(3) A5006 A1067 Rosenthal Relates to tenant association first option Add Priv L&T S5836 S2779 Krueger to purchase HousFinL RP Fin A5039 A7324 O’Donnell Reduces maximum rent increase in one Add NYC Ad L&T S3715 Krueger year Cd A5064 A8121 O’Donnell Relates to housing accommodations for Amd ETPA & L&T S4378 S5840 Krueger senior citizens NYC Ad Cd A5085 A3260 Titus/Parker Provides for recordation of restrictive Add RPL 291-k T&T S2351 covenant modification documents where conveyance documents include language which violates civil rights law A5329 A4259 Cusick Makes some insurance provisions in Amd GOL 5- Const S5239 S2925 DeFrancisco construction contracts void 322.1 A5330 A4267 Cusick Makes certain indemnification Amd GOL 5- Const S3240 DeFrancisco agreements in construction contracts 322.1 void as against public policy A5372 A2536 Mosley Requires mortgage lenders and brokers Add Bank L 35 RP Fin See also S334 S2228 Peralta to provide consumers with mortgage bill A3435/S7039 of rights A5376 A1226 Titus Prohibit mortgagee from refusing to Add RPL 254-e RP Fin S4954 S233 Diaz accept partial mortgage payments A5472 A1426 Garbarino Appeal of dispute between shareholders Add Coop Corp Condo S637 Boyle and boards to AG appointed hearing L 78 Co-op officer

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 4 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A5500 Weprin Repeals tax exemptions to major league Repeal RPTL CCTax S8128 Kavanagh sports teams 429 A5685A Hunter Allows tenant to deduct water bill Amd RPL 235-a L&T Passed A 3/20/18 S4846A Valesky payments from rent A5700 Cymbrowitz Requires Landlord to grant access to NYC Ad Cd L&T S3643 Parker engineer to inspect MCI’s A5738 Hunter Requires landlord/owner contact Add RPL 235-h L&T S4847 Valesky information to be provided to tenants PI A5791 Cymbrowitz Prohibits warehousing of apartments and NYC Ad Cd L&T S5132 Bailey harassment A5792 Cymbrowitz Realtor to succession of rent regulated NYC Ad Cd L&T S2144 Alcantara apartment A5798 Cymbrowitz Relates to sale of limited profit housing Priv HousFinL Low Inc S3181 Kruger company project and reserve for MCI Hous A5821 Weinstein Relates to of home equity RPL 280-d Workout S4452 Klein reverse mortgages BR A5823 Wright Requires notices to adjacent owners of NYC Ad Cd T&T Passed A 3/20/18 S4519 Montgomery demolition A5953 Pichardo Provides for receiver & managing agent Amd RPAPL RP Fin S1072 S1425 Rivera in NYC foreclosures; 1325 Workout BR A6028A Hunter Permits individuals with disabilities to Amd RPL 227-a L&T Passed A 3/20/18 S4970 Valesky terminate under certain circumstances A6246A A10425 Walker Requires notaries public and Add & Amd T&T S5756A S8058 Lanza commissioners of to complete and ExecL 135-c/136 retain certain documents relating to the transfer of residential real property A6247 Walker Return sec. dep. w/in 30 days or provide Add GOL 7-104 L&T S3112 Parker written explanation PI A6248 Walker Requires assigned counsel in certain RP Add RPAP L PI S2230 Parker actions 722 etc. A6254 A10359 Walker Admin expenses allowed to be deducted Amd GOL 7-103 L&T See also A262 S3311 S2815 Krueger from tenant security deposits S2815 in 2015-16 NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 5 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A6257 A6749 Walker Records of proceedings on Add RPAPL 757 S2840 S2786 Parker foreclosed property to be sealed, with fines for non-compliance A6449 A9460 Buchwald Prohibits termination of tenancy without Add RPL 228-a L&T S767 S6883 Stewart- court approval in certain housing PI Cousins occupied by seniors and/or disabled persons A6608A A1053 Gjonaj Relates to renewal of lease upon tenant’s Add NYC Ad L&T S3559 Little failure to renew his or her lease Cd A6635 A3411 Titone Provides for alternative means for notice Amd Lien L 182 Com Leas S4992 Larkin of lien on self-storage unit occupant A6875 A3898 Dickens Establishes tenant’s right to offset rent Add RPL 235-b L&T S6253 Comrie by cost of certain emergency repairs A7095 Williams Require landlord facing imminent Add RPL 235-h RP Fin S5378 Persaud foreclosure to so advise tenant before PI new lease A7141 De La Rosa Allows tenants 60 or older to have pets Add PubHous L L&T Passed S 3/7/17 S793 Alcantara with certain limitations 223-c A7147 Galef Allows 2 year phase in for certain Add RPT L 485- CCTax See also A6302 S5547 Carlucci properties after town wide revaluation t Low Inc Hous A7226 Miller Authorizes DA to intervene in summary Add RPAPL 715 L&T S5467 Addabbo proceeding where occupancy is illegal A7373 Niou Relates to statutes of limitation based on Add NYC Ad L&T S2028 Squadron notices of deregulation Cd A7392 Niou In action for willful neglect of residential Add RPAPL 854 L&T S2023 S589 Squadron property, treble damages provided A7406 Dilan Imposes a tax on the transfer of certain Add NYC Ad L&T S6488 Hamilton real property within two years of a prior Cd transfer of such property A7520 Lentol Regulates short term rental units (e.g. Amd multiple L&T S7182 Bonacic Air BnB) laws

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 6 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A7523 Farrell Extends the transfer tax Amd Tax L T&T Chap 272 of 2017 S5739 Young reductions for conveyances of real 1201/1402 & property to existing real estate NYC Ad Cd investment funds A7550 A5860 Ortiz Landlord to provide receipt for paid rent, Amd RPL 235-e L&T S4432 S1285 Montgomery with rent reduction if not done A7852B Lifton Imposes an occupancy tax in the City of Add Tax L CCTax S5861B Seward Cortland 1202-ff A8065 Fahy Prohibits short term rental of private Amd/Add L&T S5978 Funke dwellings MultRes L & Tax L A8165 Niou Affects recovery of certain rental units Amd NYC Ad L&T S7020 S107 Hoylman by landlord in NYC Cd A8261 Cymbrowitz Regarding conflicts of interest for co-op Add RPL Art 9- Condo Chap 305 of 2017; S6652 Golden BOD members C Co-op see also A8993/S7279 A8331 Titone Authorizes temp occupancy for Add MultDwell L&T S5767 Lanza compensation of a Class A mult. L 4 dwelling that is a coop or condo unit under certain circumstances A8467 Cahill Defines inducement for title Amd Ins L 6409 TI TF S6704 Seward insurers/agents A8554 A5693 Kavanaugh Requires residential property managers Add RPL Art Condo S2027 S198A Squadron to be licensed by NYDOS 12D S448 Co-op L&T A8984 A9394 Magnarelli Relates to required notices in a Add RPAPL RP Fin S7977 S4895 Marchone residential foreclosure action 1303 A9039 Ramos Alter/study NY first time home saving Amd Priv RP Fin S7316 Little program HousFinL A9508C Budget Part HH to include reverse mortgages as Amd RPAPL RP Fin Chap 58 of 2018 S7508C "home loans" 1304 A9509C Budget Part T to amd. re: transfer tax refunds Amd Tax L T&T Chap 59 of 2018 S7509C and >$1 million additional tax 1402-a & 1412

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 7 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A9592 A10745 Weinstein Makes certain foreclosure provisions Amd RPAPL RP Fin See also S1992A S8177 Klein applicable immediately to reverse 1304 A1266/S1992 mortgages A9713 Williams Grants a tax deferment for persons 65 Add RPTL CCTax S6929 Persaud years or older who own and occupy real §467-k property in NYC A9734 A9225 Thiele Relates to extending benefits of STAR Amd RPTL 425 CCTax S1116A S6518 Akshar program to small business A9745 Paulin Authorizes shareholders to attend Amd BCL Condo Passed A 3/6/18 S7073 Kavangh meetings via remote communication and 602/605 Co-op to be deemed present for voting purposes A9757 A1180 Rosethal D Relates to limited-profit housing Amd RPTL & CCTax S5874 Stavisky companies and tax exemptions Priv HousFinL A9763 Weinstein Directs the department of financial Amd RPAPL T&T S7167 Klein services to periodically inspect 1307/1308/1310 residential real properties for which a lender has a duty to maintain A9965 Morelle Relates to leasing and licensing of Amd Pks & Rec T&T S8060 Helming property L 3.09 A9974A Lentol Extending time to file final application Amd RPTL & CCTax S8023A Dilan under industrial and commercial NYC Ad Cd abatement program A10017 Cymbrowitz Establish an affordable independent Add Priv Low Inc S7866 Little senior housing assistance program HousFinL Art.29 Hous Sec. 1260 A10053 Heastie Establishes NYC Housing Authority Add Pub Hous L L&T Passed A 3/12/18 S7963 Bailey Modernization Act (Part A); and 402-d provides for reporting on lead-based paint poisoning protection (Part B) A10059 Fahy Extends the effectiveness of Chapter 405 Amd Sec 2 of CCTax S7966 Breslin of the laws of 2005 for two years Ch. 405 of 2005 relating to authorization for the County of Albany to impose a mortgage recording tax NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 8 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A10084 Lavine Enacts the “fairness in cooperative Add RPL Art 11 Condo S7523 Hannon homeownership act” - 360-366 Co-op A10111 Rodriguez Establishes NYC Housing Authority Add Pub Hous L T&T S1990A S658 Klein Repair Certificate Program to grant & NYC Ad Cd zoning benefits to developers which perform capital improvements A10150 Carroll Extends to 1-1-2021 deadline to apply Amd RPTL 499- Green S8049 Lanza for solar tax abatement bbbb & 499-cccc A10168 O’Donnell Directs court to notify former owner of Amd RPAPL Workout S3948 Young foreclosed property that they have the 1354, RPL 1136 BR right to file a claim for excess funds A10244 Galef Requires reassessment every 20 years Amd RPTL 306 CCTax S8069 Little

NYS 2017-2018 Assembly - Note - Single House Bills Not Tracked after 2017 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A94 A1578 Cahill Allows creation of new cooperative Add RPTL Art. CCTax county full value assessment system 17 A125 A1684 Cahill Require assessment values to be updated Add RPTL 306 CCTax not less than every 5 years A142 A1388 Cahill Require assessor receipt for STAR Amd RPTL 425 CCTax application A354 A608 Weprin New assessment classification for Amd RPTL / Condo See also A3444 S4371 condos & co-ops NYC Ad Cd / Co-op NYC Charter A 547 A6350 Perry Exempts from BR proceedings debtor interest in rent stabilized lease A801 A1484 Crouch Repeal RPTL 735 which prohibits use of Repeal RPTL CCTax Small Claims proceeding testimony in 735 future action A1053 A10745 Weinstein To include reverse mortgages as "Home Amd RPAPL RP Fin loan" for required prior notices 1304

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 9 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A1084 A1789 Dinowitz Requires 2/3 member vote to allow Amd GenBusL Condo condo/conversion sponsor to be 352-33/eee/eeee Co-op managing agent A1201 A2344 Englebright Tax exemption for persons > 80 Add RPT L 465 CCTax A1204 A6699 Englebright Prohibits non-disclosure provision in Add RPL 222-a S1129 hydraulic fracturing leases A1212 A1713 Zebrowski Permits condo/co-op BOD to take action Amd RPL & Condo vs. objectionable tenant RPAPL Co-op A1353 A2152 Englebright Requires recording of PCDS with deed Amd RPL T&T and sending info to DEC 291/462 A1543 A1777 Zebrowski Full sch. Tax exemption for certain Add RPT L 407- CCTax persons > 75 k A1563 A9655A Magnarelli Allows municipality to compel Add RPAPL T&T S7295 mortgagee of abandoned property to 1392 either finish FC or discharge mortgage A1608 A2490 Mosley Free legal services in certain resid. FC Add/Amd RP Fin S3751 actions RPAPL & CountyL A1664 A3337 Hawley Limits mortgagee flood insurance Add RPL 283 RP Fin requirements A1917 A9670 Lifton Requires names of all LLC members in Amd LLC L 203 RP Fin Connecting Articles of Organization & State campaign contracts contributions and State contracts A2050 A574 Lentol Protects tenants of unlawful lofts from Add MultDwell L&T eviction L 286-1 A2052 A3979 Englebright Allows property tax freeze for owners 65 Amd RPTL 467 CCTax and up A2120 A2686 Pretlow Voluntary real property tax lien transfers Amd RPTL CCTax to assist homeowner in FC due to unpaid RP Fin taxes

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 10 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A2220 A4196 Montesano Makes mortgagee holding tax escrows Amd RPTL 953 RP Fin liable for late payment due to incorrect registration A2241 A543 Rosenthal Requires disclosure by auditor to Add RPL 339- Condo prospective buyers, owners and board of gg, Renumber Co-op evidence which would materially impact gg-ii professional findings about fiscal health of condo or coop A2249 A6442 Englebright Subdivision review requires school Add GenMunL Environ district confirmation that parcel is in 99-x district A2419 A5242 Paulin Establishes criteria for blighted Amd EDPL CCTax property/areas 103/204/206 & other laws A2498 A5383 Lifton All oil/gas/mineral leases to be recorded Amd RPL 291 Com Leas w/in 30 days A2499 A5377 Lifton Leases for oil/gas/minerals must be Amd GOL 5-333 Com Leas signed by all property owners & RPL 291-c A2511 A5391 Lifton Restricts memo of lease recording for Amd RPL 291-c T&T oil/gas/mineral leases Environ A2521 A5381 Lifton Notice requirements for assigning Amd GOL 5-333 T&T oil/gas/mineral leases Environ

A2593 A5502 Rosenthal Limits rent increase after vacancy of a S3741 housing accommodation and relates to the maximum allowable rent A2614 A6631 Perry Requires notification of balance Amd RPAPL RP Fin due/satisfaction after sale 1354 A2654 A5390 Lifton Requires certain statements re: value and Amd GOL 5-333 title to be included in oil/gas/mineral leases A2643 A3761 Ra Provides RP tax exemptions for first Add RPL 457-a CCTax time homebuyers

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 11 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A2715 A4126A DenDekker Requires brokers & salespersons to Add RPL 442-k T&T include license number when signing documents A2732 A5552 Sepulveda Extends time for tenants to purchase co- Amd GBL 352- Condo S271 op unit eeee Co-op A3186 A477 Ryan Requires giving notice to mortgagors in Amd RPAPL S765 default for 30 days or more 1304-a A3435 A2536 Kim Requires mortgage bill of rights Add Bank L 35 RP Fin pamphlet to be signed before application A3444 A422 Den Dekker Re: classifying condos/co-ops for Amd RPTL CCTax See also A354 assessment purposes multiple sections A3518 A573 Rosenthal Requires landlords to provide rental Add NYC Ad L&T S3585 history on DHCR form upon the signing Cd 26-517.2 Low Inc of vacancy lease Hous A3576 A588 Rosenthal Provides bankruptcy exemption for rent Amd D&C L L&T regulated tenants 282 A3636 A3325 Aubry Establishes a one year moratorium on Add RPAPL Workout actions to foreclose a mortgage 1392 BR RP Fin PI A3813 A6395 Perry Requires applications in condos and Add RPL Condo coops to be acted on within 45 days and Co-op failure is deemed approval A3874 A2234 Rosenthal Relates to penalties for owners of Add ETPA T&T property who fail to file a proper or timely rent registration statement A3901 A311 Dinowitz Governs election of board by residents Add GenBusL Condo of coops and condos Co-op A3931 A629 Rosenthal Relates to repealing provisions of NYC Add NYC Ad L&T Ad Cd relating to evicting tenants when Cd building demolished or substantially altered

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 12 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A4084 A5665 Hooper Requires owner in contract for home Add GBL Const improvements to have 15 days from estimated completion date for inspection A4085 A10213 Hooper Authorizes municipalities to impose a Add GenMunL T&T tax lien upon foreclosed property for CCTax unpaid building code & zoning fines and expenses A4094 A5681 Hooper Creates land banks for the acquisition of Add CountyL 55 T&T vacant & abandoned properties & & Amd. UDC authorizes the sale of such properties Act A4170 A696 Rosenthal Relates to requiring owners to provide Amd NYC Ad L&T tenants with notice if lead-based paint or Cd 27-2056.4 Environ dust has been found in the unit A4216 A5687 Hooper Relates to special proceeding to convey Add RPAPL T&T title to abandoned dwellings to individuals A4232 A807 Rosenthal Imposes civil penalties on landlords for Add RPL L&T including unenforceable provisions in residential leases A4803 A1316 Rosenthal Relates to unlawful tenancies under Add ETPA L&T ETPA A4888 A9329 Rosenthal Relates to MCI rent increased Add NYC Ad L&T Cd A4895 A9394 Kearns Requires notice to municipality of any Amd RPAPL RP Fin FC action 1303 A4931 A419 Rosenthal Prohibits fuel pass along in rent Add NYC Ad L&T controlled apartments Cd A4948 A916 Rosenthal Limits MCI rent adjustments Add NYC Ad L&T Cd A4966 A864 Rosenthal Exempts certain renter regulated tenants Add D&C L Workout from bankruptcy proceeding BR A4969 A9903 Rosenthal Incentives for residential green building Add Pub Auth L Green S3746 Griffo program 1872-a

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 13 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A4998 A5028 O’Donnell Establishes licensing for building Add NYC Ad L&T managers Cd A5011 A5027 O’Donnell Relates to buy-outs of Mitchell-Lama Add Priv L&T projects HousFinL A5155 A8340 O’Donnell Creates small business lease program Add NYC Ad L&T Cd A5202 A7241 Rosenthal Enacts tenant protection act of 2017 Add NYC Ad L&T Cd A5376 A3260 Titus (MS) Prohibits mortgagee from refusing to Add RPL Workout accept partial mortgage payments BR A5558 A3727 Cymbrowitz Relates to waivers of MCI rent Add NYC Ad L&T adjustments Cd A5771 Cymbrowitz Relating to recovery of housing NYC Ad Cd L&T accommodations by landlord A5772 Cymbrowitz Limits rent increases after vacancy NYC Ad Cd L&T A5775 Cymbrowitz Prohibits landlord from adding charges RPL L&T for additional services to base rent A5786 Cymbrowitz Relates to charges for application fees RPL L&T A5816 Cymbrowitz Establishes a residential condominium Add GenBusL Condo See also A581 owner’s bill of rights §352-eeeee Co-op A6143 Rosenthal Requires notification by mortgages Amd NYC Ad RP Fin commencing FC in NYC re: at-risk Cd properties A6302 Crespo Allows persons 60 or > in municipal Add Pub Hous L Low Inc. housing to keep pets 223-c Hous A6329 A5877 Finch Enacts wetlands homeowner's relief act Add EnConL Environ 24-303 A6393 A8112 Robinson Disclosures re refinancing of existing Amd Bank 595-a RP Fin S2919 Funke mortgage PI A6456 A2748 Titone Re: use of POA in banking transactions Add to S. 9 RP Fin BankL A6470 Magnarelli Requires mortgage servicer to pay Amd RPAPL RP Fin HOA/condo/co-op fees to maintain 1308 Condo abandoned unit Co-op NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 14 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A6575 O'Donnell Requires radon testing/disclosure before Amd RPL 240, T&T sale of real property 242, 444-b, 462 A6714 Zebrowski Provides priority for certain unpaid RPL Condo common charge liens Co-op A6819 Hunter Requires landlords to ensure rental Add RPL L&T properties have utility service prior to renting A6822 Hunter Relates to liability and penalties for Add MultDwell L&T illegal conversion L A6967 Zebrowski Requires residential landlords to mitigate Add RPL 227-e L&T damages after tenant vacates early A7111 A1120 Lavine 45 days to act on condo & co-op Add RPL 360- Condo OAR: RPLS See also 2015-16 S5644 purchase offer 364 Co-op #2 3/11/11 A6395 Memo #3 Passed S 6/14/16 6/3/13 A7211A A9546 Paulin Change in PILOT payments due to Amd RPTL 561 CCTax revised assessment does not apply to school district until its next fiscal year A7339 A3239 Fitzpatrick Provides for the de-regulation of rent- Add EmHous L&T stabilized housing accommodations RentCtrl A7341 A3763 Fitzpatrick Eliminates certain restrictions on the Add NYC Ad L&T right to an eviction for landlord’s Cd personal use A7348 A3097 Fitzpatrick Provides an alternative hardship Add NYC Ad L&T allowance based on 8.50% of assessed Cd value A7355 A2173A McDonald Relates to special proceedings to convey Add RPAPL T&T title to abandoned real property in cities, towns or villages A7661 A3303 Fitzpatrick Provides for reform and Amd EDPL, CCTax Home and Property Protection Act NPCL, GML, Pub Auth L

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 15 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A7664 A3925 Fitzpatrick Extends affordable housing development Amd Priv Low Inc loans to all NY municipalities HousFinL 1150- Hous 53 A7366 Walker Relates to protecting the rights of Add HousL L&T Mitchell-Lama residents A7420 A2968 Titone Relates to sales of r.p. by not-for-profit Amd NPC L 509 NFP corps A7520 Lentol Relates to regulation of short-term rental Add MultDwell L&T units L A8162 Bichotte Expands definition of seniors re: rights Amd GenBusL Condo in condo-co-op conversion 352 Co-op

NYS 2017-2018 Senate - Note - Single House Bills Not Tracked after 2017 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A9698 Relates to establishing the residential Amd Tax 606 T&T S14 S7542 Kaminsky real estate tax credit A7864 Includes, aunts, uncles etc. for Amd. Pub Hous L&T S91 S345 Hoylman determining rights of family members in L 14 public housing Penalties for property owners for not Amd ETPA & L&T S105 S6757 Hoylman filing rent registration statement NYC Ad Cd Protects non-purchasing seniors from Amd Ch 555 Condo See also S2309 S110 S3746 Hoylman eviction per a condo/co-op conversion 1982 §10 Co-op A9192 Penalties for property owners for not Amd ETPA & L&T S122 S6454 Hoylman filing rent registration statement NYC Ad Cd A5416 Increases maximum income eligibility Amd RPTL 467 CCTax Passed S 2/24/16 S237 S1074 Golden for seniors tax exemption Home Mortgage Bridge Loan Assistance Add PHFL RP Fin S433 S2239 Peralta Act 1250-56 Provides for obligations of parties in Add RPL 246-a T&T S551 S3921 Young land contracts

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 16 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A1426 Provides for hearing officers for coop Add Coop Corps Condo S637 S99 Boyle board/owner disputes 78, Amd Exec Co-op 63 Prohibits terminating tenancy without Add RPL 228-a L&T S767 S6883 Stewart- cause for seniors/persons with Cousins disabilities; Provides eviction stay for certain Amd RPAPL L&T S997 S1375 Bonacic holdover tenants 753 Allows tenants to decline amenities if Add RPL 226-a L&T S1217 S8213 Rivera rent will increase A4224 Creates separate assessment class for Amd RPTL, Condo S1408 S893 Avella condos/co-ops RPL, NYC Ad Co-op, Cd CCTax A6699 Prohibits non-disclosure provision in Add RPL 222-a S1581 S1129 Avella hydraulic fracturing leases Protects non-purchasing seniors from Amd Ch 555 Condo See also S110 S2309 S3746 Alcantara eviction per a condo/co-op conversion 1982 §10 Co-op A3260 Re: title company duty to set out illegal Add RPL 291-k T&T OAR S2352 S2528 Parker restrictive covenants in back title and RPLS #6 record modification 2/17/11 Memo #6 6/3/13 Allows offset of heating repairs agst. Amd MultDwell L&T S2365 S3609 Alcantara rent after certain notice to landlord L Grants tenants relocation costs from Amd RPAPL RP Fin S2443 S4357 Hamilton foreclosure sale up to $1500 1354 Prohibits LL from requiring animals to Add RPL 235-h L&T S2714 S7836 Comrie be de-clawed Disclose bedbug infestation for prior Add RPL 235-h L&T S2830 S528 Parker year to new tenant, incl. Co-ops and Condo condos (N. A. to cities > 1M) Co-op Certain lease modification agreements to Amd RPL 291- T&T S2902 S6980 Ritchie be recorded cc

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 17 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A3966 Prohibits LL from charging app. fees > Add RPL 220-a L&T See also S3321 S3074 S1563 Parker actual cost of credit check etc.

Limits rent increase after vacancy Amd NYC Ad L&T S3107 S1178 Serrano Cd Requires written receipt for rent not paid Amd RPL 235-e L&T S3138 S590 Squadron by check Revises eviction proceedings re: notice Amd RPAPL L&T S3183 S2800 Krueger et al to prevent avoidable eviction multiple sections LL to pay penalty for failed eviction Amd NYC Ad L&T S3187 S2803 Krueger based upon primary residency Cd Permits NYC tenants to offset hazardous Add MultDwell L&T S3191 S2844 Krueger conditions repair agst. rent L 302-d Requires single point of contact for Add Bank L 96- RP Fin S3216 S3768 Sanders mortgage modifications e Relates to allowable expenses for tenant Amd GOL 7-103 L&T S3311 S2815 Krueger security deposit accounts Prohibits LL from charging app. fees > Add RPL 220-a See also S3074 S3321 S2852 Krueger actual cost of credit check etc. Allows withholding of rent if no heat; S3322 Krueger Add RPL 235-k; Old Bill S2871 Relates to publication fees and on line Amd LLC L RP Fin S3325 Avella data base for LLCs 206/209 T&T Requires landlord to check sex offender Add MultDwell L&T S3339 Bailey registry for new lease/sublease & notify L 301-a tenants w/ children Authorizes eviction of tenant < 62 from Amd NYC Ad L&T S3560 S2283 Little rent regulated premises for owner's Cd personal use Allows stay of up to 3 mos. for warrant Add RPAPL 754 L&T S3598 S2755 Parker of eviction and installment payments Plaintiff in FC must maintain property in Amd RPAPL RP Fin S3640 S1779 Parker "good faith" (defined) 1307

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 18 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A604 Requires a landlord to have clean hands Amd NYC Ad S3646 S593 Parker in action for rent or eviction in certain Cd cases, e.g., rent controlled units Creates "tenant rights act" re Add to RPL & L&T S3714 S2854 Krueger tenant/landlord requirements others Relates to primary residency of rent- NYC Ad Cd L&T S4395 Murphy regulated apartment Requires coop boards to provide written CivRtsL Condo S4551 Sanders statement of reasons when withholding Co-op consent to a purchase Relates to prohibiting mortgagors from RPL Workout S4679 Sanders recovering legal fees incurred in BR foreclosure actions A6549 Requires affidavit to court 30 days prior Add RPAPL RP Fin S4882 S265 Diaz to starting FC action 1304-a PI Allows enhanced STAR for property Amd RPTL 425 CCTax S4993 S2888 Larkin with at least one eligible owner Defines blighted properties/areas Amd EDPL CCTax S5001 S3868 Bailey multiple sections Requires bank to notify municipality Amd RPAPL RP Fin S5058 Kennedy when filing foreclosure lis pendens 1303 Zombie Housing Task Force Establishes affordable housing & Add Priv On Senate S5141 Little services program/housing trust fund corp HousFinL Art. Committee 28 1240-42; calendar for March Low Inc Hous 15th Tenant of multiple dwelling may repair Add to L&T S5026 S2420 Holyman habitability-impairing conditions and MultHous L & PI offset agst. rent MultDwell L Reforms statutory POA (repeals Gifts Amd GOL T&T S5501 Hannon Rider in GO L 5-1501/1514)) generally

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 19 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2017-18# 2015-16# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo Relates to the elimination of the Add Lien L T&T S5863 Bonacic requirement of serving a notice of sale upon an owner of property

NYS 2015-2016 Assembly and Senate 2015-16# 2013-14# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo Part N of Governor Changes service of process on & by Amend RPL Condo Negotiated out of Budget Dept. of State 339-s Co-op final budget bill Bill (beg. on pg. 112) A87 Dinowitz Requires limited profit housing company Amd. Priv S586 Squadron to show maintenance of essential HousFinL 12 & services before approval of rent increase 31 A99 Thiele Regarding underground utility districts Amd TownL Chap 389 of 2016 S321 LaValle A155 Thiele Financial institutions to notify assessor Amd RPTL 425 RP Fin Passed S 6/8/15 S326 LaValle re: taking possession of STAR CCTax exemption property A163 A1082 Weinstein No recording assignment of mtge. w/o Add S 291k to T&T OAR: RPLS S1278 S44 Peralta mtge. ownership doc. RPL RP Fin #1A 3/8/12 Memo #2 5/7/13 A167 Thiele Property tax exemption for certain Amd RPTL 458c CCTax S369 LaValle agricultural lands A204 Rosenthal Establishes the residential open green Add RPT L 499- S1469 Golden space tax abatement for certain aaaaa-ggggg properties in NYC A231 A692 Rosenthal Establish tax credit for personal prop Amd Tax 606 T&T, RE S3041 S511 Espaillat replacement as a result of bedbug Tax infestation

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 20 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2015-16# 2013-14# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A262 A858 Weinstein Relates to tenant security deposit Amd GOL 7-103 L&T S2815 Krueger accounts and administrative expenses to which a person may be entitled A275 Thiele Provides for certification and training of S504 Lavelle persons employed in the manufacture, sale, installation and repair of modular homes A313 A360 Dinowitz Relates to voting rights in cooperative Amd GenBusL Condo S1252 S54 Peralta apartments 352-ee/eee/eeee Co-op

A331 Rosenthal Establishes causes of action for Amd Penal and S3841 Espaillat harassment of rent regulated tenants St Fin Laws under penal code A335 A7027 Ryan Require plaintiff in mortgage foreclosure Amd RPAPL Finance S1779 S4055 Parker action to maintain property in good faith 1307

A397 Thiele Relates to manufactured homes S520 Lavalle certificate of title and the conveyance and of the same A407 Dinowitz Relates to notice and filing of Amd RPTL 467 S471 Diaz application for a real estate tax exemption for senior citizens A563 Rosenthal Provides for continuation of senior Amd NYC Ad S529 Parker citizen rent increase exemption Cd. A643 Rosenthal Establishes regional technology Add EcDevL S538 Gallivan development centers 361 A837 Pretlow Fines co-op for failure to credit tenant Amd RPTL 425 Condo S2746 Hoylman with STAR exemption Co-op A1152 Dinowitz Increases monetary requirement to Amd GOL 5-701 Passed A 3/9/15 S3135 Martins $250K for plain language in consumer Passed A 1/21/16 contracts

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 21 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2015-16# 2013-14# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A1170 A2779 Lavine Presumption of dismissal of residential Amd Jud 212, RP Fin A2779 S4636 S1478 Kreuger mortgage foreclosure actions for CPLR 3408 S1478 repeated plaintiff non-appearance or failure to meet readiness deadlines A1760 Magee Limits liability of land owners to certain Add Art 11/Sect. S5015 Seaward trespassers 350 to RPL A1763A A2817 Wright Requires Landlords to give access to Add NYC Ad L&T S1721 Parker engineer or architect hired to inspect Cd major capital improvements A1787B A8233B Wright(MS) Requires licensing of all persons Add Labor Law S1945B Bonacic involved in operation, repair and inspection of elevators A1816 Weprin Co-op property to be class one property Amd RPTL CCTax, S2846 Lanza for assessment 1802 Condo Co-op A1849 A3479 Gunther Residential buildings eligible for green Add TaxL 19 Green S1168 S1624 Parker tax credit A1855 A34 Farrell Creates the office of the cooperative and Exec, Tax, State Condo OAR: RPLS S2832 S3152 Krueger condominium ombudsman, authorizes Finance Co-op #13 5/5/11 the residential unit fee Memo #11 6/3/13 A1856 Farrell Limits mtgee. share of appreciation on Add RPL 280 RP Fin S864 Martins reverse mtge. PI A1865A Rosenthal Makes conforming technical changes to Amd Multiple Low Inc S4474 Stewart- the NYC Administrative Code and the Laws & NYC Hous Cousins emergency tenant protection act relating Ad Cd to vacancy de-control; repealer A1880 Mayer Caps rent increase for major capital Add ETPA L&T S3588A S7674 Espaillat improvements at 6% A2008 Mayer Imposes an occupancy tax in the City of Add TaxL 1202- Chap 62 of 2015 S549 Latimer Yonkers x A2148 Dinowitz Establishes procedure when condo or co- Amd GenBusL Condo S3593 Espaillat op conversion suspends sales in building 352-eeee Co-op

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 22 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2015-16# 2013-14# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A2422 Englebright Authorizes cities, towns and villages to Amd. S567 Latimer establish mixed-use age integrated Gen/City/Town/ communities, offer incentives to Village laws developers, and a tax exemption for such property A2635 Thiele Provides property tax exemption for Add RPTL 458c CCTax S534 Gallivan properties owned by persons called to active duty and reservists A3186 Fitzpatrick Establishes home equity protection Amd Pub RP Fin S2274 Young insurance program AuthL2404/add 2405f A3491 A2731 Wright Permits court to order rent abatement in Add RPAPL 757 L&T: OAR: RPLS S3089 S26 Espaillat actions to recover rent where court finds Com Leas #3 3/11/11 constructive eviction Memo #4 5/17/13 A4040A A3722 Robinson Requires notice to adjoining owners of Amd NYC Ad Const Passed A 6/15/16 S2814A Montgomery construction, excavation or demolition Cd. A4314 Brennan Exempts low income housing from local Add RPTL CCTax S7856 Avella real property tax in NYC A4555 Clark Authorizes stay and partial payments in Add RPAPL 754 L&T Also same as S2755 Parker proceeding to recover possession A9986 A4557 Clark Limits mortgage servicers re: force Add BankL 595- RP Fin S2358 Seward placed insurance d A4842 Kearns Requires notice to municipality from Amd RPAPL RP Fin S6256 Ortt plaintiff in FC action with contact for 1307 property maintenance A4949 A7155 O'Donnell Allows action for violation of SEQR Amd En ConL S885 S675 Avella even if injury does not affect general 8-0119 public A5347 Cusick Include school taxes in veterans tax Amd RPTL 458 CCTax Passed S 5/24/16 S2245 Carlucci exemption A5457 Rosenthal Counties & cities to provide legal CountyL S2061 Espaillat representation in and foreclosures NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 23 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2015-16# 2013-14# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A5484 A682 Galef Allow municipalities to value new coop Amd RPTL 581, Condo S618 S1000 Little & condo units as they would r.p. RPL 339-y Co-op A5566 A2181 Kavanagh Alternative hardship applications for rent Amd NYC Ad L&T S1783 S513 Espaillat stabilized properties Cd, ETPA A5567 A7343 Kavanagh Limits rent increases after vacancy Amd NYC Ad L&T Passed A 6/9/16 S951 S1040 Serrano Cd, RTPA, EHRC A5585 A2187 Kavanagh Allow rent reduction based on reduction Amd NYC Ad L&T S4164 S494 Stavisky in services to be retroactive Cd 26-514 A5592 Kavanagh Prohibits the discontinuance of utility Amd Pub Serv S3497 Stavisky service to multiple dwellings for non- Law payment of rent A5733 A251 Kavanagh Grants tenant right to withhold rent for Add RPL 235-h L&T S2871 S3168 Krueger failure of landlord to provide heat A5802 Kavanagh Grants private citizens broad Add to EnConL S1087 Parker authorization to commence civil judicial actions under certain titles of the environmental conservation law A6011 A6392 Galef Grant r.p. tax exemption, at local option, Amd RPTL 420- Nonprofit Passed S 6/9/15 S605 S2939 Hannon to nonprofits that purchase r.p. after a, 420-b Passed S 5/4/16 taxable status date A6041 Brook-Krasny Penal Law – relates to failure to obtain a Add to Penal L&T Passed S 6/15/16 S3239A Golden certificate of occupancy or alteration Law permit for a multiple dwelling. A6054 Kavanagh Relates to major capital improvement Amd. NYC Low Inc Passed A 6/17/16 S4423 Krueger rent increases and extending the time Code & Rent Hous over which major capital improvement Control Law expenses may be recovered. A6618 Walker Relates to willful neglect of real property Add NYC Chart S3990 Parker prevention 1896 A6752 Bichotte Recovery of economic development Amd EcDevL S555 Parker awards when recipient leaves state 100 A6854A Crespo Gift for preserving religions landmarks Add Tax Environ S255 Diaz NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 24 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2015-16# 2013-14# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A6878 Galef Relates to barring HOA from restricting Add RPL 339-11 Condo S7679 Marcellino solar power systems [Art 9-C 342] Co-op Environ A6932 Weinstein Mortgagee to maintain property with Amd/add RP Fin Passed A 5/24/16 S4781 Klein delinquent mortgage RPAPL 1307-08 Comment – AG's Bill A7078A A7193A Thiele Relates to sales tax on title searches Add Tax T&T S296B S3669A Martins A7239 Brabenee To better define organizational purposes Amd RPTL 420- CCTax S1679 Bonacic and property uses to qualify for non- a profit tax exemption A7408 Blake Requires LL to check sex offender Add MultDwell L&T S2035 Hassell- list/notify tenants L 301-a Thompson A7487 Cusick Requires C of O for certain 1-2 family Amd Gen CityL Chap 532 of 2015. S3472 Lanza homes on unmapped streets in NYC 36 See also A 9161/S6388 (Ch. 177 of 2016) A7571 A8783 Thiele Provides for lien for unpaid water Add Pub Auth L T&T Passed A 6/16/16 S4909 Croci authority bills in Suffolk County 1078-f Passed S 6/15/16 (statewide precedent) Comments from Onondaga County Bar provided to legislative sponsor Passed A 6/9/14 A7931A Weprin Relates to designating Queens as a cease Add RPL Environ S1379A Avella and desist zone and extending non- solicitation orders to 5 year periods A7970A Brindisi Relates to brownfield opportunity area Add GenMunL Environ Passed S 5/5/16 S5143A Avella program A8095A Benedetto Tax rebates in NYC for owner-occupied Add RPTL CCTax S5673-A Klein residential property

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 25 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2015-16# 2013-14# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A8318 Weinstein Provides for summary action to Add RPAPL S4498 Funke foreclose upon vacant and abandoned 1308 residential real property A8340A O’Donnell Creates small business program for fair Add NYC Com Leas S1040A Avella negotiation in the commercial lease Ad. Cd renewal process A8492 A6711 Ortiz Requires NYC leases to contain rider re: Add RPL 235-h L&T S1042 S1292 Montgomery housing court rights and duties; A9128A Jaffe Exemption for installation of residential Add Tax Green Passed S 6/9/16 S6250A Ortt and commercial geothermal heat pump systems and equipment A9161 Cusick Requires C of O for certain 1-2 family Amd Gen City L Chap 177 of 2016 S6388 Lanza homes on unmapped streets in NYC (Chap 532 of 2015) A9474 Weinstein Requires applicants for broker/ Amd RPL 441 Chap 320 of 2016 S7248 Bonacic salesperson license to take agency course A9746 Richardson Defines "consummation of mortgage Amd Bank L S. Passed A 6/6/16 S7183 Savino loan" 2 Passed S 5/18/16

A9796 Benedetto Site selection of community facilities in Add GenMunL Environ S6758A Sanders cities with one million or more population

A9986 A2864 Richardson Authorizes stay in proceeding to recover Add RPAPL L&T S2755 Parker property in a non-payment proceeding A10072 Weinstein Requires NYS DFS to establish Add Bank L 37- RP Fin S7434 Klein electronic data base for FC property b; Amd RPAPL 1307 A10276 A529 Defrancisco Portion of construction contract sum in Add Gen Bus L Const S37 Braunstein be held in interest-bearing escrow account

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 26 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 2015-16# 2013-14# Legislator/ Subject/Statute Amends/Adds Referred RPLS Des/ Comments/Status Sponsor to Memo A10286 Russell Relates to interest on indebtedness Add Tax PI S7575 Lavalle incurred by tax payer to pay for higher education A10496B Nojay Provide for an exemption for capital RPTL CCTax Chap 279 of 2016 S7965B O’Mara improvements to multiples dwelling buildings within certain cities A10519 Palmesano Relates to leasing and licensing of Add Parks, PI Chap 159 of 2016 S6966A Nozzolio property by the office of Parks, Recreation & HP Recreation and Historical Preservation Law for Sampson State Park. A10651 Braunstein Relates to the eligibility of J-51 tax Add RPTL CCTax Chap 388 of 2016 S8095 Avella abatements to reflect cost of living adjustments A10741 Farrell Regarding foreclosures and creating data Amd multiple Part of 2016 S8159 Flanagan base for "zombie properties" sections of Budget Bill (Part Q) RPAPL and enacted as Chap 73 CPLR of 2016

List of Section Committees and Other Groups under “Referred to” - with Abbreviations Commercial Leasing Com Leas Condemnation, Certiorari and Real Estate Taxation CCTax Condominiums and Cooperatives Condo Co-op Green Real Estate Green Land Use and Environmental Law Environ Landlord and Tenant Proceedings L&T Low Income and Affordable Housing Low Inc Hous Not-for-Profit Entities and Concerns NFP Public Interest PI Real Estate Construction Const NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 27 REAL PROPERTY LAW SECTION - LEGISLATION CHART – 2018 April 18 Real Estate Workouts and Bankruptcy Workout/BR Real Property Financing RP Fin Title and Transfer T&T Task Force on NYSID TI Regs. TI TF

NC=No Comment; SAR=Support and Report; OAR=Oppose and Report; ONR=Oppose No Report; SIA=Support If Amended; OUA=Oppose Unless Amended Page 28