FIRST NATIONS CHILD POVERTY: a Literature Review and Analysis Melisa Brittain and Cindy Blackstock 2015

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

FIRST NATIONS CHILD POVERTY: a Literature Review and Analysis Melisa Brittain and Cindy Blackstock 2015 FIRST NATIONS CHILD POVERTY: A Literature Review and Analysis Melisa Brittain and Cindy Blackstock 2015 Copyright © 2015. All rights reserved. Published by First Nations Children’s Action Research and Education Service (FNCARES) www.fncaringsociety.com/fncares Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................................. 5 A NOTE ON TERMINOLOGY ...................................................................................................... 6 CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION: ECHOES OF COLONIALISM IN FIRST NATIONS CHILD POVERTY ........................................................................................ 7 Colonial policy targets Aboriginal children ............................................................................... 8 Poverty rates for First Nations children .................................................................................. 10 Urgent action required .............................................................................................................. 11 References ................................................................................................................................ 13 CHAPTER TWO POVERTY BY DESIGN: THE CANADIAN GOVERNMENT’S MASTER PROJECT .................................................................................................................... 17 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 17 The deliberate impoverishment of First Nations: Displacement, assimilation and forced dependence ............................................................... 20 Land loss and displacement ........................................................................................................................... 21 The Royal Proclamation and “gradual civilization” ............................................................................. 25 The Indian Act: From self-governing to “wards of the crown” ....................................................... 28 Residential schools: The economics of stealing children ........................................................ 29 “Aggressive Civilization”: Industrial schools and Aboriginal child labour ................................ 31 “We didn’t learn anything”: A legacy of disadvantage ........................................................................ 36 References ................................................................................................................................ 37 CHAPTER THREE DEFINING AND MEASURING FIRST NATIONS CHILD POVERTY .............. 44 Poverty lines: Relative versus absolute measures ................................................................... 44 Standard measures and (un)available data ............................................................................. 46 Coming up short: Insufficiency of standard measures for First Nations ................................ 48 Culturally appropriate measures and interpretive models ..................................................... 50 References ................................................................................................................................ 55 FIRST NATIONS CHILD POVERTY: A LITERATURE REVIEW AND ANALYSIS 1 CHAPTER FOUR ENDURING LEGACIES: CHILD WELFARE, UNDERFUNDING AND SOCIO-ECONOMIC IMPACTS ............................................................ 60 Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 60 Section I .................................................................................................................................... 60 Exacerbating the risk factors: Contemporary child removal and the chronic underfunding of essential services ....................................................................... 60 “Not properly cared for”: Residential schools as child welfare institutions ............................. 61 Legacies of residential school and the growth of the child welfare industry ........................... 64 “Export products”: The socio-economics of the Sixties Scoop ........................................................ 67 Disturbing similarities, disturbing differences: Child welfare and residential schools ....... 69 Poverty major cause of overrepresentation in child welfare system .......................................... 71 Children as profit: More critiques of the child welfare industry ................................................... 73 Further consequences of foster and institutional care for children and youth ....................... 75 Chronic and ongoing government underfunding: Deepening poverty and heightening risks for children ..................................................................... 77 The Canadian Human Rights Tribunal: Inequitable funding in First Nations child welfare ........................................................................................................................ 78 Multiple funding inequities increase risks and removal under neglect portfolio .................. 79 Section II .................................................................................................................................. 81 Calculating colonial history: Multiple socio-economic impacts ............................................. 81 Inequitable education ....................................................................................................................................... 81 Highest unemployment and lowest income levels .............................................................................. 83 Substandard and inadequate housing ....................................................................................................... 86 Highest rates of homelessness ...................................................................................................................... 89 Health disparities: Historical and socioeconomic determinants ................................................... 90 Emotional stress and suicide ......................................................................................................................... 91 Experiences with disability ............................................................................................................................ 92 Food insecurity, past and present ............................................................................................................... 93 Violence .................................................................................................................................................................. 95 Sexual exploitation and criminalization ................................................................................................... 99 Incarceration ...................................................................................................................................................... 100 References .............................................................................................................................. 102 2 CONTENTS CHAPTER FIVE POVERTY INTERVENTIONS: ENSURING FIRST NATIONS CHILD WELL-BEING ................................................................. 118 Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 118 Section I ................................................................................................................................... 119 Poverty Intervention Criteria .................................................................................................. 119 Self-determination and adequate funding ............................................................................................. 119 Revitalizing tradition to strengthen self-governance ....................................................................... 120 Holistic and multi-faceted approach ........................................................................................................ 120 Creating respectful partnerships ............................................................................................................... 121 Paternalism and failure to consult: Government-imposed solutions ........................................ 122 Section II ................................................................................................................................ 125 Closing the funding gap ......................................................................................................... 125 A legal intervention: The Human Rights Tribunal on First Nations child welfare ............... 126 Educating the public: The role of social movements ........................................................................ 127 Differential responses in child welfare reduce poverty-related apprehensions .................. 128 Additional interventions for reducing structural risk related to poverty ............................... 129 Section III ............................................................................................................................... 130 First Nations economic development and its discontents .................................................... 130 Entrepreneurship and successful business models .........................................................................
Recommended publications
  • The Virtual Summit on Indigenous Postsecondary Education
    The Virtual Summit on Indigenous Postsecondary Education A report by The Assembly of First Nations and The Association of Universities and Colleges of Canada Association of Universities and Colleges of Canada Association des universités et collèges du Canada the virtual summit on indigenous postsecondary education, a report by the assembly of first nations and the association of universities and colleges of canada table of contents 2 Introduction 3 The conversation 3 question 1: “What does university mean to you?” 7 question 2: “Have you considered going?” 8 question 3: “What steps will you take to reach your education goals?” 9 The role of universities in First Nations success 11 Questions and concerns 12 Conclusion “ Everyone has a role to play. Everyone has a voice that must be supported and respected and we must try to understand.There are so many powerful things that we have to offer the world.There is a great resurgence happening. We need to facilitate greater understanding and you need to take on the responsibility. The universities have a great role to play.They have the potential, not only in relationships, but also to be a great transformer and to unleash the human potential and to unleash the potential of Aboriginal learners in Canada.” Shawn A-in-chut Atleo, National Chief to the Assembly of First Nations the virtual summit on indigenous postsecondary education, a report by the assembly of first nations and the association of universities and colleges of canada Introduction Despite that Indigenous education has had a tumultuous past in Canada, yet things are changing.
    [Show full text]
  • Full Circle Full Circle
    FULL CIRCLE FULL CIRCLE the aboriginal healing WAYNE foundation & the K SPEAR unfinished work of hope, healing & reconciliation AHF WAYNE K SPEAR i full circle FULL CIRCLE the aboriginal healing foundation & the unfinished work of hope, healing & reconciliation WAYNE K SPEAR AHF 2014 © 2014 Aboriginal Healing Foundation Published by Aboriginal Healing Foundation Aboriginal Healing Foundation 275 Slater Street, Suite 900, Ottawa, ON, K1P 5H9 Phone: (613) 237-4441 / Fax: (613) 237-4442 Website: www.ahf.ca Art Direction and Design Alex Hass & Glen Lowry Design & Production Glen Lowry for the Aboriginal Healing Foundation Printed by Metropolitan Printing, Vancouver BC ISBN 978-1-77215-003-2 English book ISBN 978-1-77215-004-9 Electronic book Unauthorized use of the name “Aboriginal Healing Foundation” and of the Foundation’s logo is prohibited. Non-commercial reproduction of this docu- ment is, however, encouraged. This project was funded by the Aboriginal Healing Foundation but the views expressed in this report are the personal views of the author(s). contents vi acknowledgments xi a preface by Phil Fontaine 1 introduction 7 chapter one the creation of the aboriginal healing foundation 69 chapter two the healing begins 123 chapter three long-term visions & short-term politics 173 chapter four Canada closes the chapter 239 chapter five an approaching storm by Kateri Akiwenzie-Damm 281 chapter six coming full circle 287 notes 303 appendices 319 index acknowledgments “Writing a book,” said George Orwell, “is a horrible, exhausting struggle, like a long bout with some painful illness.” In the writing of this book, the usual drudgery was offset by the pleasure of interviewing a good many interesting, thoughtful and extraordinary people.
    [Show full text]
  • Proposal for a National Program of Reparation and Reconciliation-1
    ORIGINS INC SUPPORTING PEOPLE SEPARATED BY ADOPTION A Submission of Origin SPSA Inc in Response to Part (b) of the Terms of Reference of the Senate Inquiry into Commonwealth Contribution to Former Forced Adoption Policies and Practices A Proposal for a National Program of Reparation and Reconciliation to Address the Consequences of Forced Adoption 1 Introduction This proposal outlines a program of reparation and reconciliation to address the consequences on families -- mothers, sons and daughters, fathers, siblings, grandparents and grandchildren – who were separated from one another by past forced adoption policies. It follows and elaborates on previous submissions by Origins to the Senate Inquiry into Commonwealth Contribution to Former Forced Adoption Policies and Practices. Background Forced adoption practices which separated single mothers in Australia from their children have parallels to similar events in other nations and other cultures. Similarly, one can also look at global principles of redress and reparation for guidance on how to proceed with a program that will meet not only the needs of the mothers and their lost sons and daughters, but also the needs of their immediate and extended families, and of society as well. “16(3) The family is the natural and fundamental group unit of society and is entitled to protection by society and the State.” – Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) On December 16, 2005, the General Assembly of the United Nations adopted and proclaimed The Basic Principles and Guidelines on the Right to a Remedy and Reparation for Victims of Gross Violations of International Human Rights Law and Serious Violations of International Humanitarian Law.” This document gives direction to nations on how to address gross violations of human rights, including violations of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948).
    [Show full text]
  • Runners Arrive Home for Ahousaht Canoe Quest { by Denise Ambrose Shawn Atleo Left His Home in Surrey, Central Region Reporter BC on the Morning of July 1
    ` fir, i F r t , , r , .. ; , ' frlrr!1..I'íry,ri. Y r'., rr,+, ,h, fI'C/ , . , , . NJ,OR .nla4z 4 i r o .-y, 1 .:.. _ HaShiIth-Sa Serving Nuu- chah -nulth -aht for more than 25 years VOL. 26- NO. 14 - July 15, 1999 Canadian Publications Mail Product haasÍtsa Sales "Interesting News" Agreement No. 467510 Runners arrive home for Ahousaht Canoe Quest { By Denise Ambrose Shawn Atleo left his home in Surrey, Central Region Reporter BC on the morning of July 1. Cyril Louie and 14 year -old Inez Paul met %1 After a grueling ten -day marathon, him at the ferry in Saanich. Together .0,41u.ro, Shawn Atleo, Cyril Louie, Inez and they ran to Victoria where Inez's .,i;1ji Carleen Paul were welcomed to mother, Carleen, joined in the run. Tofino in grand style. Carleen and Inez said that they were { b quite lonely and homesick during the After a grueling ten -day mara- first few days of the run. Coordina- thon, Shawn Atleo, Cyril Louie, tor, Vina Robinson said that the Inez and Carleen Paul were entourage was quite small at the start welcomed to Tofino in grand of the trip but it grew and grew as style. they got closer to home. By the time the group arrived in Port Alberni on July 6, dozens had joined Hundreds of Nuu -chah -nulth people in the run. Hupacasath welcomed showed up to cheer on the group that their guests with a benefit dinner and ran (and wheelchaired) all the way auction that raised thousands of r/ '// /i' from Victoria to Tofino mow / 5 on Saturday, - dollars.
    [Show full text]
  • 160 Argyle St. S. Caledonia
    LIBRARY AND ARCHIVES CANADA 1\fJ .OR N } Bib iotheq ie et Archives Canada t I 1,31181151,011,612111,1 3 38 54056 8 3 1111, ir- 11 r... - and Archives Canada , l Library `, Collection I II Newspaper St. y. I 395 Wellington ..y ON4 Ottawa, ON KIA i . Reg. No. 10963 North America's 4 Pub. No. 40016309 194 Celebrating 15 years Okarahshona kenh Onkwehonwene, Six Nations of the Grand Wednesday July 29, 2009 AFN National Chief Shawn. Atleo Atleo takes helm when Bellegarde concedes .^ a a, By Lynda Powless vri t. Editor +. Y... CALGARY- Shawn Atleo is the new national chief of the As- -444to,yt.3 sembly of First Nations (AFN) after a 22 hour marathon vote N .4* 'ISi . the crowd on a rollercoaster ride all night. that sent .r After the nerve racking election unity, as he addressed a crowd of night Atleo has already made his onlookers and dancers in colourful, t first appearance as head of feathered costumes. Canada's national First Nations or- "It's time to come together across y ganization. all of our territories and support His first stop was to the home one another - treaty and non - province of the man he defeated. treaty," Atleo said to loud applause. On Sunday, Atleo, was the guest of Atleo, who is from the Ahousaht honour at a pow wow on the Carry First Nation on Vancouver Island, ' the Kettle First Nation, which is wore a traditional pointed cedar hat T /7 about 85 kilometres east of Regina. and shawl, which were passed .
    [Show full text]
  • Tansi, Naonenow Nenu, “N’Too Tem Tik
    Voices of Urban Aboriginal Peoples with Diabetes by Moneca Sinclaire A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Leadership, Higher and Adult Education Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto © Copyright by Moneca Sinclaire June 2018 Voices of Urban Aboriginal Peoples with Diabetes Moneca Sinclaire Doctor of Philosophy Department of Leadership, Higher and Adult Education Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto 2018 ABSTRACT This art based research study is situated within an Indigenous research methodology. The goal of the research was to first, document the voices of Urban Aboriginal people with Type 2 diabetes and secondly, to bring together these voices into an updated oral format using the medium of radio. Four principles that grounded this research were Indigenous research paradigm, drawing from Indigenous scholars, critiquing the Euro-Western biomedical worldview of health, and reciprocity. Using an Indigenous research paradigm meant situating who I am as a Nahayowak (Cree) woman who used prayer, medicines and talking with Elders to carry out the research. Second, I ensured the bulk of the reference sources were Indigenous writers. Third, the research was undertaken knowing that health is situated in a colonial Euro-Western biomedical worldview and if the health of Indigenous people is to improve I must assert Indigenous ways of doing research. Finally, any work I do must have a component of reciprocity where knowledge and pragmatic tools, podcast of radio documentary, must be given back to not only the academy but to students and Indigenous community members.
    [Show full text]
  • Beyond the Sixties Scoop: Reclaiming Indigenous Identity, Reconnection to Place, and Reframing Understandings of Being Indigenous
    Beyond the Sixties Scoop: Reclaiming Indigenous identity, reconnection to place, and reframing understandings of being Indigenous by Sarah Wright Cardinal B.A., University of British Columbia, 1993 M.A., School for International Training, USA, 2003 A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in the Department of Curriculum & Instruction © Sarah Wright Cardinal, 2017 University of Victoria All rights reserved. This dissertation may not be reproduced in whole or in part, by photocopy or other means, without the permission of the author. Supervisory Committee Beyond the Sixties Scoop: Reclaiming Indigenous identity, reconnection to place, and reframing understandings of being Indigenous by Sarah Wright Cardinal B.A., University of British Columbia, 1993 M.A., School for International Training, USA, 2003 Supervisory Committee Dr. Helen Raptis, Supervisor Department of Curriculum & Instruction Dr. Wanda Hurren, Departmental Member Department of Curriculum & Instruction Dr. Anne Marshall, Outside Member Department of Educational Psychology & Leadership Studies Dr. Heidi Kiiwetinepinesiik Stark, Outside Member Department of Political Science ii Abstract This study used life experience methods to gather the narratives of seven adult Indigenous transracial adoptees who have reclaimed their Indigenous identities after experiencing closed adoption during the late 1950s through to the early 1980s. Participants had been members of Aboriginal (First Nations, Metis, Inuit) communities at birth but were then raised outside their Indigenous nations in non-Indigenous families. Through analysis of their stories, I identified four themes that marked their trajectories to reclamation: Imposed fracture (prior to reclamation); Little anchors (beginning healing); Coming home (on being whole); Our sacred bundle (reconciling imposed fracture).
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 75 Number 2 Summer/Fall 2018 Jana
    Volume 75 Number 2 Summer/Fall 2018 The Ejusdem Generis Of A-B-: 65 Ongoing Asylum Advocacy For Domestic Violence Survivors Linda Kelly Racism in the Legal Profession: 82 A Racist Lawyer Is An Incompetent Lawyer Jana DiCosmo Measuring Mercy: Protecting 100 Patient Discretion In Terminal Care Under The Fourteenth Amendment Kelsey Nicholas editor’s preface The bigotries, phobias, and moral crimes of the Trump administration are too legion for any law review to examine completely, even in a special jumbo edition. The best we can do is expose and seek to correct them one obnoxious offense at a time. In “The Ejusdem Generis of A-B-: Ongoing Asylum Advo- cacy for Domestic Violence Survivors,” Linda Kelly zeroes in on an especially repellant Department of Justice (“DOJ”) opinion in which the misogyny and xenophobia of Trumpism coalesce into something close to pure cruelty. In Matter of A-B- then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions unilaterally reversed the policy established by the DOJ’s Board of Immigration Appeals that fa- cilitated protections to immigrant victims of domestic violence seeking asy- lum. A-B- narrows the rules, heightens the burdens, and otherwise worsens the already-hellish lives of some of the poorest, most desperate and forlorn refugees to arrive at our borders. These are mostly women who’ve already suffered indefensible gender-based cruelty and violence and are now far more likely to be redirected back for even more of it. Kelly’s article is a how-to manual for human rights attorneys advocating on behalf of these asylum-seekers. She provides insight and analysis along with practical, tactical suggestions for how to win these cases.
    [Show full text]
  • The Aboriginal Justice Inquiry-Child Welfare Initiative in Manitoba
    The Aboriginal Justice Inquiry-Child Welfare Initiative in Manitoba: A study of the process and outcomes for Indigenous families and communities from a front line perspective by Gwendolyn M Gosek MSW, University of Manitoba, 2002 BA, University of Manitoba, 2002 BSW, University of Manitoba, 1991 A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY In the School of Social Work © Gwendolyn M Gosek, 2017 University of Victoria All rights reserved. This dissertation may not be reproduced in whole or in part, by photocopy or other means, without the permission of the author. ii Supervisory Committee The Aboriginal Justice Inquiry-Child Welfare Initiative in Manitoba: A study of the process and outcomes for Indigenous families and communities from a front line perspective By Gwendolyn M Gosek MSW, University of Manitoba, 2002 BA, University of Manitoba, 2002 BSW, University of Manitoba, 1991 Supervisory Committee Dr. Leslie Brown, School of Social Work Supervisor Dr. Jeannine Carrière, School of Social Work Departmental Member Dr. Susan Strega, School of Social Work Departmental Member Dr. Sandrina de Finney, School of Child and Youth Care Outside Member iii Abstract As the number of Indigenous children and youth in the care of Manitoba child welfare steadily increases, so do the questions and public debates. The loss of children from Indigenous communities due to residential schools and later on, to child welfare, has been occurring for well over a century and Indigenous people have been continuously grieving and protesting this forced removal of their children. In 1999, when the Manitoba government announced their intention to work with Indigenous peoples to expand off-reserve child welfare jurisdiction for First Nations, establish a provincial Métis mandate and restructure the existing child care system through legislative and other changes, Indigenous people across the province celebrated it as an opportunity for meaningful change for families and communities.
    [Show full text]
  • THE ONTARIO CURRICULUM, GRADES 9 to 12 | First Nations, Métis, and Inuit Studies
    2019 REVISED The Ontario Curriculum Grades 9 to 12 First Nations, Métis, and Inuit Studies The Ontario Public Service endeavours to demonstrate leadership with respect to accessibility in Ontario. Our goal is to ensure that Ontario government services, products, and facilities are accessible to all our employees and to all members of the public we serve. This document, or the information that it contains, is available, on request, in alternative formats. Please forward all requests for alternative formats to ServiceOntario at 1-800-668-9938 (TTY: 1-800-268-7095). CONTENTS PREFACE 3 Secondary Schools for the Twenty-first Century � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3 Supporting Students’ Well-being and Ability to Learn � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3 INTRODUCTION 6 Vision and Goals of the First Nations, Métis, and Inuit Studies Curriculum � � � � � � � � � � � � � �6 The Importance of the First Nations, Métis, and Inuit Studies Curriculum � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �7 Citizenship Education in the First Nations, Métis, and Inuit Studies Curriculum � � � � � � � �10 Roles and Responsibilities in the First Nations, Métis, and Inuit Studies Program � � � � � � �12 THE PROGRAM IN FIRST NATIONS, MÉTIS, AND INUIT STUDIES 16 Overview of the Program � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �16 Curriculum Expectations � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
    [Show full text]
  • INDIGENOUS EDUCATION INITIATIVE at OISE
    THE GIFT In 2014, OISE received a $5-million gift Canada, government agencies, non-govern- While the focus will be the Canadian from an anonymous donor to strengthen ment organizations and the private sector context, the Initiative will generate new Indigenous education research in Canada. with the aim of pursuing vital avenues of knowledge that is relevant to educa- INDIGENOUS inquiry that will enrich all public education. tion, and the study of education, in both The gift, which is the largest donation Indigenous and non-Indigenous societies ever made to a Canadian faculty of edu- “The University of Toronto is already rec- around the world. The research is also cation for Indigenous education research, ognized as a world leader in Indigenous expected to have a signifi cant impact on EDUCATION establishes a prestigious fellowship and education thanks to the dedication of policy in Canada. launched a comprehensive fi ve-year ini- scholars at OISE who have made Indigenous tiative exploring the educational needs education a priority,” said U of T President and aspirations of Indigenous peoples. Meric Gertler. “This gift affi rms that stature INITIATIVE and provides the support required to The initiative will help forge new part- ensure that U of T continues to lead the nerships among Indigenous peoples in way. This is a wonderful accomplishment.” at OISE Advancing Leadership in BECOMING THE GLOBAL LEADER IN Indigenous Knowledge INDIGENOUS EDUCATION RESEARCH and Education Literacy as an Indigenous Right: understanding the role of indigenous language, culture and state responsibilities for respect, recognition and support Objectives Focus on Languages and Literacy UN Discussion 1.
    [Show full text]
  • History of First Nations People in Alberta
    Conversation Guide History of First Nations People in Alberta Big Idea: First Nations have a rich history. Their References relationship with the land has continued to evolve The Canadian Encyclopedia http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca since contact with Europeans. Despite attempts to assimilate, and diminish their culture, the Indigenous First Nations in Alberta people in this area known as Alberta have helped to https://www.aadnc-aandc.gc.ca/eng/1100100020670/11001 shape the provinces diverse identity over time. 00020675 Essential Terminology This conversation guide is designed for use https://www.teachers.ab.ca/SiteCollectionDocuments/ATA/ by instructional leaders and learning Publications/Human-Rights-Issues/Terminology%20%20%2 8PD-WT-16a%29.pdf communities or as a self-paced study. A Long History First Nations history in Alberta dates back at least 11,000 years and approximately 500 generations.The Milk River that runs through Writing-On-Stone Provincial Park in Alberta contains the largest concentration of First Nation petroglyphs (rock carvings) and pictographs (rock paintings) on the great plains of North America. Evidence like the rock carvings and a 10,000 year old spearhead found in Athabasca prove a lengthy and well established way of life for the First Nations in Alberta. First Nation Life Before the Arrival of Europeans Prior to the arrival of Europeans in North America, the land provided the First Nations with everything they required for their mental, physical, spiritual and emotional well being. Everything in nature was seen as living; therefore, First Nations people respected and took care of the land around them. The land took care of the First Nations by continually growing herbs and plants for healing and providing the wildlife they needed to survive.
    [Show full text]