LAW RECORD COLLEGE OF LAW ALUMNI ASSOCIATION WINTER 1990

COLLEGE OF LAW UBMIW

MAR 091 90 omostMEiMKRsm

Alumni Receive Honors LAW RECORD Table of Contents

OSU Law Record is published by Dean's Desk ...... \ the College of Law, The Ohio State University, as part of its Admissions Trends...... 4 Alumni Services program. Thomas Receives Distinguished Alumnus Award 5 Editor Alum ni Earn K udos...... 8 Jenifer Bernard Rasor, '87 New Dimensions in CLE Programming...... 1 0

College Hosts NIDR Conference...... 11 Contributors Francis X. Beytagh Campaign Nears Goal...... 1 2 D arlene J. Brown Placement Points...... 1 3 John P. Henderson Ruth M. Kessler, '39 Clinic Takes Case To Supreme Court...... 15 Joanne Wharton Murphy, '58 Genoa Exchange Continues...... ;...... 1 7 » Send address changes and Library News...... 1 9 Alum note information to: Visiting Professors...... 20 Alumni Services OSU College of Law Faculty Highlights...... 2 1 1659 North High Street The Tax Reform Act of 1986: Columbus, Ohio 43210-1391 Rhetoric Or Reality?...... k...... 26

OSU College of Law Officers Goldberger Honored...... 27 Francis X. Beytagh, Dean Student Leaders...... 28 Gregory M. Travalio, Associate Dean In The Spotlight...... 3 1 John P. Henderson, Associate Class Reunions Reunite Friends...... 3 4 Dean Alan Holoch, Director of the Law A lum notes...... 3 8 Library David A. Goldberger, Director of Clinical Programs Joanne vW. Murphy, Assistant Dean John R. Meyer, Director of Development D arlene J. Brown, Director of Placem ent About The Cover OSU College of Law Alumni Association Officers Benjamin L. Zox, '62, President N ancy L. Sponseller, '77, President-elect David A. Ward, '58, Secretary The cover displays the College of Law Distinguished Alumnus Medallion presented this fall to OSU College of Law National Judge William K. Thomas, see Council Executive Committee story on page 5. Other awards Robert M. Duncan, '52, Chair to College alumni are reported Robert J. Watkins, '53, Vice-Chair in the story beginning on page Jacob E. Davis III, '63, Past-Chair 8. Benjamin L. Zox, '62 N ancy L. Sponseller, '77 Francis X. Beytagh Joanne Wharton Murphy, '58, Secretary

©1990 College of Law, The Ohio State University DEAN'S DESK B A CONVERSATION WITH DEAN BEYTAGH Q: You've been at Ohio State for five years now? in a year or so, our alumni and friends will have A: Yes, that's correct. I suppose that means I'm not committed in excess of $18 million to the College of the "new" dean any more. Law—more funds, I think, than any other public law school will have raised over that period of time. Our Q: It doesn't seem that long. building addition will be under construction, with A: Probably not. This is a large and fairly complex the prospect of badly needed new space soon to enterprise, and things move pretty fast. become a reality. At the same time, we'll have more chairs and professorships, a more generously Q: Any overall thoughts about those five years? endowed scholarship program, several A: Yes, although my perspective may not be the new academic ventures that will give us best, since I've obviously been very close to what's greater depth and distinctiveness, and been going on. Still, we've seen significant change in enhanced financial support for our fine a number of important respects, although much of it library. has been incremental. There has been dramatic success in the law school's first major private Q: Sounds pretty good to fundraising effort, with the help and support of me. some dedicated alums and staff. And we've attracted A: W ell, it is good, of some high-quality new people to our faculty and course, in a number of staff, strengthened and diversified our student body, respects, and we're both and developed or enhanced various programs. In grateful for the support and general, we've been building enthused about what it will on a solid base, but we're permit us to do. building an even stronger foundation for the 1990's and Q: Still, you said you saw a beyond. "mixed bag," externally speaking, didn't you? Q: That sounds good, but A: Yes, in several important there must also be some areas—resources and respect. problems, some weaknesses. We need better University- A: Of course there are. budgeted financial support to complement our successes in Q: Such as — private fund raising. Sadly, the A: Well, within the law State of Ohio has not as yet school, achieving the sort of committed itself to a top-flight community that will enable system of public higher everyone—faculty, students education, and, as an integral and staff—to contribute aspect of such a system, to importantly and to realize support its flagship their full potential. We're Dean Francis X. Beytagh institution—Ohio State—in the way it should be making progress on this, I with model of Law Building supported. Our tuition is too high to ensure access to believe, but it's slow, and Addition and Renovation Project. all, and last session, when the General Assembly there are lots of forces pulling imposed a cap on undergraduate tuition increases, in various directions. Don't the University raised graduate-level tuition by misunderstand me; dialogue, discussions, and approximately 15 percent. The law school hasn't differences of opinion, these are all valuable to any benefitted, at least thus far, from such a substantial enterprise, but so is a collective sense of self, a tuition increase. We continue to have pressing willingness to look at and think about what's good budgetary needs that go unmet from year to year, for the long term, not the short haul. As I said, largely because the University is restricted in what it we've been moving in the right direction, but we can do. still have some distance to go. Our strengths are evident; we need to keep pulling together to Q: So resources are a limiting factor. What's this maximize the possibilities. about respect? A: What I mean by that is rather simple. This is an Q: That's largely internal. What about the excellent law school, one of the best public law, University, and generally the world outside the law schools in the country, on the basis of measurable school? criteria and by reputation. Yet our efforts to provide A: What I see there, at least presently, is a mixed leadership in developing interdisciplinary and joint bag. The Centennial Campaign has gone better than programs within the University are usually met with almost any of us expected it would. When it's over, little interest or enthusiasm. No matter what our 2 DEAN'S DESK

talented faculty does, in the way of scholarship or and seek preeminence in those respects. For example, service, it seems not to be enough, at least for some. we are already embarked on one such effort, with We are more highly regarded in the company of our socio-legal studies center, in conjunction with other law schools than we are on our own campus. other departments of the University and working To my knowledge, there are no great universities, at cooperatively with Oxford University. Another such least in this country, with law schools whose law center, loosely described as being in the area of law schools are not also regarded as outstanding. That and finance, and probably encompassing a modest- respect must be earned, of course, but it must start at sized LL.M. program as well, will soon be taking home. Some lose sight of the value of a well- shape. regarded law school to the entirety of a complex and In addition, our involvement with and commitment comprehensive university such as Ohio State. to alternative methods of dispute resolution provides Lawyers in our contemporary society—like it (and another such example. There will be more such them) or not—have an effect disproportionate to opportunities, some we should embrace and others, their numbers on political and financial decisions. for various reasons, we should choose to forego. In We'll keep trying to do our part, but others need to terms of methodology, we should keep striving for a respond to and recognize what we're doing. greater integration of the approaches used in skills training with the more traditional classroom styles. Q: There are, of course, lots of differences In addition, I would simplify our grading system to between the role of a dean and that of a corporate some extent. It tends to be confusing to our own CEO, but if you were able to change some things students as well as to outsiders. We can accomplish about the law school on your own, what would you the same objectives it seeks to in a more do? straightforward way. A: To begin with, I sincerely believe in faculty Finally, we should be a public law school in every governance, as it exists in American law schools. sense of that phrase. A number of our faculty Strength and wisdom come more often from a currently render valuable service to the public, and collective sense of how to deal with basic issues than several student-operated programs do so as well. But from the thinking of one individual. Still, I have we need to do more in this regard. We should been in legal education for two decades now, and a develop closer ties with State government, involve law school dean for 12 of those years, so it's natural ourselves more extensively in public education about for me to have some developed thoughts on what law and the legal system, and, more generally, reach any good law school, and in particular ours, can and out and touch more people in ways that will assist should do. them in understanding and dealing with the legal I would take a careful, thoughtful look at our basic system more effectively. J.D. curriculum. It's sound, I think, but it could still be improved upon. I would ensure that we Q: That's a rather weighty agenda, isn't it? adequately introduce our students to the legal system A: Not really. We can't, and won't, do everything and to lawyering in the first year, and in particular overnight, but we need to have a sense of direction, focus on professional responsibility during that and to proceed according to it. We need to think impressionable time in their careers. I would also long and hard about the future, and, while being return to a more structured curriculum, one with a somewhat skeptical about visionaries, have a vision larger number of required courses, especially in the of that future and the role we can and should play second year. I would further ensure that some in it, and in bringing it about. We should seek to exposure to skills training is provided for all shape as well as react to change—in legal education students before they graduate. And, finally, I would and more broadly. Educational institutions are intensify our growing efforts in the international and typically averse to risk-taking, as, for the most part, comparative law fields. Lawyer literacy in the 21st is the legal profession. We tend first to look century will require a better understanding of the backward, and then assume that the future will flow legal systems of other countries, greater familiarity more or less logically from the past. That's often the with multinational transactions, and an informed soundest and most sensible course, but not always. realization of how interdependent a world we live in. We also need to lead, and to be willing to take risks in doing so. Academic freedom, properly understood, Next, I would ask, what else can and should we protects not only the individual teacher and scholar, seek to do, in terms of our academic programs. I but also the institution and what it does, from would start by assuming that we can't, indeed improper external influences. We should, as shouldn't, attempt to do everything. Limited universities, be willing to seek to lead in certain resources and the need for depth and distinction in societal directions. And, as law schools, we should what we do choose to do argue against that. We actively address the deficiencies in the legal system— should develop several areas of concentration and through scholarship and service—and attempt to emphasis, I believe, that build on existing strengths provide constructive solutions for them. This may among our faculty and in our institutional history, result in some periodic tension between the 3

profession and the academy, but all of us would gain an advising body and serves as the focal point for in the end. private fundraising. But we need to diversify and Let me mention two stories, seemingly unrelated, expand our involvements with our graduates. Of the that make the essential point. Mother Teresa, when almost 7,000 living law alumni, over 2,000 live contacted by someone who sought to join her in her outside the State of Ohio. We need to reach out work, reportedly said (gently, I assume), "It would be more effectively to them, through regional alumni better for you to find your own Calcutta." We can groups we are forming—initially in New York City, learn from others, but not imitate simply to be like Chicago and Washington. And, in Ohio, we need to others. We should, in our own way, be building our do the same sort of thing in the major metropolitan own Calcutta. In a not dissimilar vein, President areas other than our home base in Columbus. That's Jennings, when asked a few years ago if Ohio State already underway in Cleveland and Toledo. was "keeping up with the Joneses" by constructing In addition, we need to enhance our placement the new athletic practice facility, said, "No, we are network; groups such as I've mentioned will help the Joneses." That same sort of maturity and self- greatly in this. And we need to revitalize our system assurance about our century-old law school, different of class representatives, so that the contact points from arrogance or conceit, are vital for our future. with each alum are several and include the actjve For generations Ohio State law graduates have involvement of fellow classmates. Finally, we need to distinguished themselves in public service to the communicate more effectively with our graduates and State and the nation, in private law practice and in friends. We're working on this, and improving, I business. Ohio State law faculty have for years been think, but it takes time and effort. We need to tell leaders in American legal education; three of them the law school's story more convincingly, so that have been presidents of the Association of American others will understand and repeat it. Law Schools, and many have authored casebooks and texts used throughout the country. We should be Q: What are the most frustrating — and the most proudly aware of this past, poised about the present satisfying — things about your job? and confident about our leadership role among law schools in the future. A; Well, it's easier to identify a number of things that aren't very satisfying. I sign my name Q: I understand that President Jennings has frequently, go to lots of meetings (some of which are announced his resignation, is that correct? necessary), say "no" too often, and seem constantly A: Yes, effective next summer. to be asking people for money. But these sorts of things come with the turf, such as it is, I guess. Maybe they're among the reasons why the average Q: What effect do you see this having on the tenure of a law school dean is currently between College of Law? three and four years. The demands on one's time are A: Ed Jennings has been a dynamic and effective considerable, and the various constituencies that must leader for the University for the past nine years. It's be addressed, in a number of ways, often pull one in a very demanding job, one that takes its toll. So his differing directions. Ohio State is a massive place. leaving the presidency shouldn't come as a great Getting things done here, efficiently and surprise, although the timing of the announcement expeditiously, isn't easy. It requires a good political was unexpected. Jennings has, on the whole, been sense and an understanding of how bureaucracies friendly toward and supportive of the law school. So operate. You need to know when to stay the course, we'll miss him, as will the entire institution. and when to respond to new ideas—and how to At the same time, our new Provost, Fred lead, not as a military person might, but as a Hutchinson, is an able person who'll provide stability symphony conductor seeks to do. during the transition between Jennings and his When all is said and done, I enjoy dealing with successor. A presidential search is always a time of people and with ideas. They're both combined in a uncertainty for a university. But the job should be an unique sort of way in an educational institution. One attractive one to lots of capable and experienced of the most important things a dean does is to people. There's no reason to assume that the search attempt to ensure that each person hired brings not committee won't do a good job. And no reason, so only quality, but something new and different with far as I can tell, for the new president to be him or her. And that those persons arq nurtured anything but interested in and supportive of a top- and, when necessary, prodded a bit. Students often quality law school. r tell me that law school is difficult. I say, in reply, that's what we want it to be, and if it were anything Q: Any thoughts about the role of our law else, we'd be cheating them. Law is complex and the alumni? world into which our graduates go is a difficult A: Of course. I'd start by saying that we have a place. They represent a new generation of leaders for dedicated, supportive alumni group that is one of the the legal system, just as our younger faculty will law school's most important assets. The Law Alumni provide leadership in legal education in another Association's National Council plays a useful role as decade or two. I enjoy seeing these people grow, D COLLEGE NEWS

and, along with my responsibility to seek and provide sufficient resources for the enterprise, I think that what I do to facilitate this process is both significant and satisfying. I do a lot of bar-related work, and am involved with legal education across the country in several ways. It's part of my job, I believe, but also something worthwhile doing. I also try to stay in touch with my own interests, especially constitutional law, and do some occasional scholarship. I wish there were more time for that, and for teaching, which I miss very much. I enjoy it, and the close contact with a cross-section of the student body that goes along with it. But I simply don't have the time to do it, and do it well. Finally, I value creativity very highly. There is unfortunately Thomas Cavendish '53, the 1988 College of Law Distinguished little opportunity, as an administrator, for doing Alunnus, with fellow National Council member Betsey Case '68. much that is creative—except indirectly and vicariously, through others. I wish that were not the and, if you're in tune with the institution and in case. touch with what's going on, and with yourself, that sort of thing usually takes care of itself. Whatever, I Q: How much longer do you expect to be dean want to be doing something worth doing, something here at Ohio State? I believe in, as long as I'm around. For now, at least, A: I haven't ducked a question yet, have I? But I the deanship continues to provide that sort of think I'll pass on that one, for I really don't know. situation. I'd certainly like to see the building addition completed and dedicated, we hope in 1992. And see Q: I appreciate your candor. some other programs and projects moving forward. A: And I your thoughtful questions. Let's work And then take a look, and see what else might make together for a good 1990, and for a decade of sense. There tends to be a time to go, for everyone, accomplishment for the College of Law in the 1990s.

ADMISSIONS TRENDS by John P. Hen von Associate Dean for Student Affairs

different undergraduate entering class earn their institutions and 48 different majors undergraduate degrees from Ohio represented, they bring strong State than any other college or academic credentials and diverse university, and the Class of 1992 backgrounds to the study of law. is no exception. Nonetheless, Once the admissions process was graduates of Miami (Ohio), the completed and the statistics were University of Michigan, compiled, the median LSAT score Northwestern, Notre Dame, was a 37 and the median Indiana University and Kent State undergraduate G.P.A. was a 3.44. are also well represented. Although most have ties to At this writing, it is a little too Ohio, the Class of 1992 hails from early to know about 1990; 23 different states, the District of however, applications to the Columbia, the Republic of China College are running ahead of the and the People's Republic of corresponding date in 1989. China. The average age is 24, Officials from the Law School The Entering Class of 1992 although the median age is still Admissions Council inform us that 22; the range is from 19 to 52. requests for Law School Data Forty-seven percent of this year's Assembly Service reports, which ne of the largest pools of class is composed of women; include an applicant's transcript applicants (1713) in the eighteen percent identify and LSAT score, are up 45 percent history of the College themselves as members of a nationwide from last year. Another sought admission to this year's minority group. banner year for Ohio State may be entering class of 211. With 98 Typically, more members of an in store. 5

THOMAS RECEIVES DISTINGUISHED ALUMNUS AWARD riday, September 15, 1989 is a '52, chair of the National Council day that will long live in the of the Law Alumni Association, Fm em ory of Judge William K. former Judge of the United States Thomas '35. On that date, Judge District Court for the Southern Thomas was given the very District of Ohio and partner of highest honor The Ohio State Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue. Other University College of Law can participants in the presentation bestow on one of its graduates— w ere The Honorable David A. that of Distinguished Alumnus. Nelson, Judge of the United States One of only thirteen such Court of Appeals for the Sixth honorees, Judge Thomas joined the Circuit, and Julia Anne Davis '85, venerable ranks of: Isadore Topper a former law clerk to Judge '29, Clarence D. Laylin '63, Thomas now an associate with Thomas F. Patton '26, C. William Judge Thomas, Dean Beytagh and Robert Schwartz, Kelm, Warren & O'Neill '42, Roger Smith '40, John M. Duncan '52 Rubenstein of Columbus. Sharing W. Bricker '39, Donald Clinton the award with Judge Thomas was Power '26, Charles Clifford his tireless efforts to serve the his wife Dorothy, three of their Callahan '34, William M. public good, and for his loyal four children, and other family McCulloch '25, J. Paul McNamara support of The Ohio State and friends. '32, J. Gilbert Reese '52 and University and its College of All of the speakers waxed Thomas E. Cavendish '53. Law." rhapsodic about their experiences A cum laude graduate of the with the newest Distinguished The history of the award dates College in 1935, Judge Thomas back to the 1960s, when alumni Alumnus. Of Thomas, Judge worked as a trial attorney with Nelson remarked, "In terms of leadership was mobilized to assist several Cleveland law firms from the College in its advancement temperament, scholarship, industry 1935 to 1950. In 1950, he was and evenhandedness, Judge efforts. It was acknowledged that appointed to the Geauga County alumni play an essential role in Thomas is the ideal judge. Had he Common Pleas bench by Governor lived in the 14th Century and providing valuable leadership for Lausche as the best person to the support of the College's pursued a slightly different line of clean up illegal gambling. The work, he could have been the academic mission and by closing of the notorious Pettibone enhancing the reputation of the very model for the knight in Club affirmed the confidence Chaucer's Canterbury Tales—for College through distinguished placed in Judge Thomas. In 1953, professional service and William Thomas truly is a 'very he moved to the Cuyahoga County perfect gentle (judge).'" The achievement. In recognition of Common Pleas bench, where he distinguished service and valued College of Law could not agree remained until President Johnson more. leadership to the profession and appointed him to the United the University, the College of Law States District Court in 1966. He Alumni Association established the was ranked by Cleveland lawyers "Distinguished Alumnus Award" the best common pleas trial judge to be given whenever considered and, in 1980, as the best federal appropriate to an alumnus whose district judge; in 1983, he was professional and public service chosen the best federal district contributions meet the criteria of judge in the Sixth Circuit by The this most prestigious award. American Lawyer, which quoted a There is no doubt that Judge former chair of the state judicial William K. Thomas represents the screening committee as saying, very essence of a "Distinguished "Thomas is one of the outstanding Alumnus." The award was made judges in the country....He's an "[i]n appreciation of his absolutely ideal judge in terms of extraordinary service to the Ohio temperament and scholarship. He's and federal judiciary for over scrupulously fair, very quick and thirty-nine years, for his very careful." exemplary personal commitment to Presenting the award to Judge "In terms of temperament, scholarship, in­ the highest standards of ethics in Thomas were Dean Francis X. dustry and evenhandedness, Judge Thomas the administration of justice, for Beytagh and Robert M. Duncan is the ideal judge," Judge Nelson remarks. 6 COLLEGE NEWS

Duncan continued with praise for his former colleague on the federal court bench. "Certainly, Judge Thomas is one of the most outstanding trial judges in the entire federal court system. However, with all of his honors and successes in public office, he has maintained a delightful sense of collegiality and commonality."

Judge Thomas makes acceptance remarks.

like he I never lose that "Law students petitioned, and got, a enthusiasm for the law." three dollar increase in tuition to help Judge Thomas graciously finance a Law Journal. Dean H.W. According to Robert Duncan, "Certainly, accepted the Distinguished Arant received this letter dated Judge Thomas is one of the most outstanding Alumnus citation and medallion. January 19, 1935, from the Chairman trial judges in the entire federal court system." The following is an excerpt of his of The Ohio State University Board of remarks: Trustees: "Since the time he worked as a "When I could not get a journalism My dear Dean Arant: law student to establish the Ohio job in the depression year of 1932, I I am delighted to receive Number 1 of State Law Journal, Judge Thomas went to law school. In the years 1933 Volume I of the Law Journal of Ohio State has continued his active support to 1935 we, the students, were University. The law school journals of the of the College of Law. Even with pioneering. I quote a headline and country have a very distinct place not only in the extraordinary pressures of his first paragraph from a Lantern article: the education of better lawyers, but in the position, he has always found time 'Law Students Plan Legal Aid for hands of the profession itself, and 1 have long City's Poor. The University Bar felt that our University Law School ought to do to participate in the affairs of the Association will give free legal aid to what you have now done. law school," acclaimed Duncan. indigent persons, William K. Thomas, With warm congratulations, believe me. As Judge Thomas's law clerk for L-2, president, has announced.' one year, "I learned that real law Cordially yours, is not found in books but is Newton D. Baker shaped in the courtroom. It is people and lawyers who make the "In my senior year my interest in law, and ultimately, a judge who organized labor prompted Professor allows it to be made....I have also Robert Mathews to select for me a learned that not all judges extend labor law curriculum. I pursued it. That led to my looking for courtesy as uniformly as does employment with a law firm that did Judge Thomas," observed Davis. some labor work. I was hired by Her praise may be best Harrison and Marshman, a Cleveland summarized in the following trial law firm. In June, 1946, Marvin statement: "It was perhaps the Harrison, myself, Craig Spangenberg greatest lesson of all that this and Allan Hull, formed the law firm Judge, who had sat on the bench of Harrison, Thomas, Spangenberg & for so many years, had never Hull. become blasé about what I think "I tried a jury case in Clark County he feels is the court's most Common Pleas Court in the late Judge Thomas's law clerk for one year, Julia significant function: facilitating the forties. I represented a woman who Davis found that, "Judge Thomas's excite­ suffered a spiral leg fracture in a fall jury's mission to find the facts. ment was always contagious, and I hope that Judge Thomas's excitement was from a step ladder in a cold storage like he I never lose that enthusiasm for the locker. From my client's recollection of always contagious, and I hope that law." the ladder, I drafted and filed her n

petition. Later, I bought a duplicate foresight, and a sure hand on the alumni supply both, but we can do ladder. I then realized the fall could tiller. Dean Beytagh is that kind of a more. not have occurred as described in the dean. If it is to survive, a law school "I am grateful to the Alumni petition. I filed an amended petition, must reach out to its alumni with Association, the National Council and adding that it was the collapse of a services and imaginative programming. the law school, for conferring this top platform that caused the plaintiff's Dean Murphy provides all of that. A award on me. It means a great deal to fall. law school depends on its alumni for me. This is our brother John's law "In my opening jury argument, I guidance and financial support. Our school, as well as my own." tried to make the point that my client's twisted leg was all due to the collapse of defendant's step ladder. I quoted from The Rubaiyat:

The Moving Finger writes; and having writ, Moves on: Nor all thy Piety nor Wit Shall lure it back to cancel half a line Nor all thy Tears wash out a Word of it. "In his closing, defense counsel Bitner Browne threw the words back at me. He read the original petition as to how the plaintiff said her fall occurred, and told the jury the plaintiff couldn't 'cancel half a line' nor could tears 'wash out a word of it.' As the jury retired to deliberate, I heard a farmer juror say 'I'd break my leg ever day for $35,000/ Defense verdict. "Looking back on one's life, one may wish some things were done differently. But, you can't 'cancel half a line' nor can your 'tears wash out a word of it.' "In May, 1950 I was trying an Three of the College of Law's Distinguished Alumni. Left to right: J. Paul McNamara '32, insurance license revocation matter in Judge Thomas and J. Gilbert Reese '52. the State House when I happened to meet Governor Frank Lausche. He said, 'Bill, I have to appoint a common pleas judge in Geauga County. I have Celebration Continued in Cleveland learned you live in the county.' That led to the Governor's offering me the The demands of law appointment. practice being what they are, "I wouldn't cancel half a line of my many alumni and friends decision to become a trial judge. In accepting this award, I see it as who wanted to share Judge recognition-that each trial judge Thomas's special award with upholds the rule of law when he or him were unable to attend she dedicates himself or herself to the Annual Return luncheon providing justice day in, day out. on September 15. As a result, "Doing that produces deep personal the College of Law, with the satisfactions. This is so, even if, at assistance of the Cleveland times, the judge thinks longingly of Regional Alumni Office, the money he or she believes he or John D. Drinko '44 addresses attendees planned a second celebration. she could make practicing law. It of Cleveland luncheon. comes to a trial judge who has fairly November 28 found many piloted a tough criminal trial to more of Judge Thomas's senior advisor to the policy verdict. It is felt when, free from the admirers at the City Club in committee of the Baker & adversary's yoke of self-interest, a trial Cleveland. Speaking on Hostetler law firm. judge has resolved alone, or with a behalf-of Judge Thomas as Colleagues from the federal jury, or by a reasonable compromise, a recipient of the Distinguished bench also joined Judge hotly contested civil suit. Alumnus Award were Dean "A law school professor needs that Thomas for this special same freedom from an adversary's self Francis X. Beytagh, Robert M. recognition. interest to be a dedicated teacher. Our Duncan and John D. Drinko Congratulations, Judge faculty is dedicated and strong. A '44, long-time friend and Thomas, from all of us. strong faculty needs a dean with 8 COLLEGE NEWS

ALUMNI EARN KUDOS hile most schools would Morris & Arthur in Cincinnati. He be thrilled to have one of joined the firm after more than 30 Wtheir alumni receiving a years of legal service to Procter & prestigious award, five College of Gamble. Law graduates have been Watkins has been a member and recognized for their outstanding leader of the Ohio State Alumni achievements in the past few Club of Greater Cincinnati for months. The honorees include more than 30 years. He has been a Robert J. Watkins '53, James E. director for 25 years and served as Chapman '54, N oel F. George '32, president three times. In Stuart A. S u m m it '59, and Josiah recognition of his loyal service, H. Blackmore '62. Cincinnati Alumni Club friends established a scholarship in his name at the College of Law. The Robert J. Watkins presentation was made in James Chapman displays Everett D. Reese The Ralph Davenport Mershon Cincinnati at a September 7 Medal with President Edward Jennings. Alumni Award is given by The Presidents Club Dinner at the Ohio State University Alumni Peterloon Estate. On November 3, Chapman was Association to Ohio State alumni awarded the Everett D. Reese who have provided sustained James E. Chapman Medal, an award established in leadership of exceptional quality Since his summa cum laude 1984 by The Ohio State University and a generous contribution of graduation from the College of to honor individuals for time and talent to The Ohio State Law in 1954, James Chapman has exceptional service to the University. Having spent more university's fund raising programs. than half of his life in volunteer accumulated a distinguished record of volunteer service to the The Reese Medal is named for work of various types for Ohio University. Over the last three Everett D. Reese, retired chairman State, he certainly was qualified of the board of City National Bank on all counts to receive the decades, he has maintained a strong relationship with the (now Bank One of Columbus) and College, providing valuable Park National Bank of Newark. An counsel to Deans, faculty, and staff Ohio State alumnus, Reese was on the direction of the law school. one of the founders of The Presidents Club. In addition to fundraising activities, he has served on the Chapman received the award at executive committee of The the annual Presidents Council Presidents Club and is an active Dinner, held at the Wexner Center member of the Ohio State Alumni for the Visual Arts. A partner in Club of Cleveland. the Cleveland office of Baker and Hostetler, Chapman has served for three years as the volunteer chair of The Ohio State University Campaign's regional effort in Cleveland. He has been an important leader in the success of the record-breaking Ohio State University Campaign as a member Robert J. Watkins '53 of the National Campaign Steering Committee, and has taken the lead in enhancing the image of and Mershon Award in a ceremony on support for the University in the October 20. "She (Ohio State) is Cleveland area. like an old, dear friend to whom In further recognition of his more is owed than can ever be long and untiring service on repaid," he remarked. behalf of The Ohio State A 1951 graduate w ith a B.A. in University, Chapman was history, Watkins went on to earn presented the Distinguished his J.D. degree from the Service Award by the Board of University in 1953. He currently is James E. Chapman '54 Trustees at the Autumn a partner with Porter, Wright, Commencement held in December. 9

Noel F. George Stuart A. Summit Noel George was honored by To honor Stuart Summit's long­ The Ohio State University Board standing commitment to excellence of Trustees for his extraordinary and his dedication to Ohio State, loyalty and support with the The Ohio State University Board bestowal of the Distinguished of Trustees presented him with Service Award this fall. the Distinguished Service Award at Autumn 1989 Commencement. He was a past recipient of the Ralph Davenport Mershon Award from The Ohio State University Alumni Association in recognition of his special leadership as a member and chair of the Alumni Advisory Council. He currently serves on the National Campaign Steering Committee and the College of Law Centennial Campaign Committee. He has also been an active member of the executive committee of The Josiah H. Blackmore '62 Presidents Club and of the Development Fund Board. Josiah H. Blackmore II A member of the National A 1956 alumnus of Miami Council of the College of Law University, Blackmore returned to since 1969, he was elected his in August to president of the College's Alumni alma mater receive the honorary degree of Association in 1978. Summit is a Regretfully, ill health and his Doctor of Humane Letters. As ultimate death on December 14, reported in an earlier issue of the 1989, did not allow the Law Record, the 1962 College of opportunity for public recognition. Law graduate was named But those who knew Noel George president of Capital University in understand that public honors Columbus, Ohio in February 1988. were not the style of this quiet, Before that, he had served as steadfast Ohio State supporter. interim president of the university Over the last two decades, his and professor and dean of generosity has established two Capital's law school. endowed chairs in the College of The citation he was given that Medicine, from which two of his day captures many of Josiah sons were graduated, and Blackmore's qualities. "Throughout endowments at the College of Law your busy life you have been which will support the equally as concerned with seeking establishment of a chair and an knowledge as giving knowledge, endowed fund to benefit the in exploring the ways of Our addition to and renovation of the pioneers and drawing upon the Law Building. strengths of the past. This love of Noel George received both his history completes the definition of undergraduate and law degrees a Renaissance man, an individual from The Ohio State University. of rare productivity in his His early practice with the Public profession, devoted passionately to Utilities Commission began a the pursuit of learning." distinguished law career as a principal partner and head of Our warmest congratulations to lawyer specializing in the motor litigation with the New York City all! You have brought honor to freight industry. He organized the law firm of Summit, Rovins & yourself and to your law school. firm of George, Greek, King & Feldesman and contributes to McConnaughey, which today is many professional and public merged with Baker & Hostetler. service programs. A native of The University and the College Canton, Ohio, Summit received of Law have lost a friend both his undergraduate and extraordinaire. graduate degrees from Ohio State. 10 COLLEGE NEWS

NEW DIMENSIONS IN CLE PROGRAMMING: INTERDISCIPLINARY AND FLEXIBLE SCHEDULING n 1988, the Supreme Court of Ohio Supreme Court rules. Topics Ohio promulgated rules ranged from legal service Irequiring all attorneys licensed advertising to proper disbursement to practice law in Ohio to take 12 of clients' funds. 1 '■ ** hours of Continuing Legal d Education (CLE) program m ing Drug Testing Conference P . J each year. While the College of r w » m Law has historically offered The College of Law and the 1 educational seminars for the Council of Ohio Colleges of BRg W JH benefit of the bench and bar, we Pharmacy co-sponsored this have redoubled our efforts to continuing education conference assist lawyers in meeting these on "The Many Dimensions of requirements with interesting, Drug Testing in the Workplace." informative topics. Geared toward the legal and i V fWmSÊmÈÊmÈÊ l health professions and human Alumni Annual Return resource managers, the keynote address was given by Robert E. Robert E. Moffit, Ph.D., and Professor Hébert After the Alumni Annual Return Moffit, Ph.D., former Principal Luncheon during which Judge Deputy Assistant Secretary for Faculty Involved In Other William K. Thomas '35 received Legislation in the Department of Programs the Ohio State College of Law Health and Human Services, who Distinguished Alumnus Award discussed the genesis of the The involvement of our faculty (see story on page 5), a crowd of federal drug testing policy. in Continuing Legal Education well over 100 returned to the Other presenters included two goes well beyond the programs classroom for two segments of representatives from the College of mentioned above; In response to Continuing Legal Education Law. Faculty members L. Camille the increased demand for programming. H ebert and Louis A. Jacobs programming, the University The first seminar covered recent discussed two related topics. Office of Continuing Education United States Supreme Court cases Professor Hébert spoke about the and the College of Law have over a range of constitutional law legal implications involved in cooperated in developing sixteen topics, including affirmative action, protecting employees' privacy new courses for CLE credit. drug testing in the workplace, interests regarding private sector College of Law faculty and abortion, flag burning and the drug testing, while Professor instructors involved in teaching First Amendment, and the new Jacobs explained the constitutional the courses include: Michael Court majority. Moderated by protections afforded public sector Braunstein, Sheldon W. Halpern, Dean Francis X. Beytagh, the workers. Alan Holoch, Louis A. Jacobs, presenters were College of Law Carol J. King '79, Nancy Hardin faculty members Louis A. Jacobs, Rogers, Gregory M. Travalio, L. Camille Hebert, Stanley K. David Williams, II and Charles E. Laughlin, Jr. '60, and Barbara Wilson. Many of our alumni will Rook Snyder. be instructors as well. In an effort to accommodate The course offerings have been many requests from our alumni, devised to augment programming the second session was on “Legal available through other CLE Ethics and Substance Abuse." sources and seek to broaden Presented by Charles W. attorneys' available CLE choices. In K ettlew ell '71, nationally-respected addition, several have been specialist in the area of legal designed as "short courses," ethics and disciplinary proceedings meeting one evening a week for and Adjunct Professor of Legal several weeks. This format Ethics at the College of Law, the provides attorneys with an course was specifically designed to opportunity to receive in-depth meet the two hours of ethics Professor Jacobs speaks to alumni at Annual information on a given topic education required by the new Return Afternoon CLE Program. without missing time in the office. 11

COLLEGE HOSTS NIDR CONFERENCE lthough the students were on their fall break, the halls Aof the College of Law were bustling with activity on October 16. The National Institute for Dispute Resolution (NIDR), the Governor's Peace and Conflict Management Commission, the Supreme Court Committee on Dispute Resolution, and the Ohio State Bar Foundation jointly sponsored a conference on alternative methods of dispute resolution. Designed to focus on the new legislatively-created Ohio Dispute Resolution and Conflict Management Commission, the meeting attracted over 140 judges, mediation program administrators and other participants to its morning and afternoon sessions. Justice Thomas Moyer '64 moderates opening plenary session. Since Professor Nancy H. Rogers served as Co-Chair of the Moderated by the Honorable Kessler described the "multi-door Governor's Commission Thomas J. M oyer '64, Chief courthouse" project she directs in recommending the legislation, the Justice of the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia Superior College of Law served as host to Ohio, the panel included: William Court. the conference. R. Drake, Vice President of NIDR; "The strong support for conflict Dr. Deborah R. Hensler, Director resolution programs by the of Research for the RAND Governor and Chief Justice, and Corporation's Institute for Civil the substantial appropriation by Justice; John Richardson, the legislature, provide a unique Counselor of the United States opportunity for those serving on Institute of Peace and a former and working with the new Assistant U. S. Secretary of State; Commission," observed Professor and Edith Primm, Executive Rogers. Ohioans certainly look Director of the Justice Center of forward to the results. Atlanta. The purpose of the new Commission was discussed by its Bar Results Impressive primary drafter, William K. Weisenberg, Government Affairs The College of Law is Director for the Ohio State Bar pleased to notify its alumni Association. Speakers throughout that the graduates once again the day made suggestions for its excelled on the July 1989 Professor Rogers, Dr. Deborah R. Hensler, Ohio bar exam. Ohio State's Director of Research for RAND Corporation's tasks. The new agency is directed passing rate of 95.1 percent Institute for Civil Justice, and Judge Gladys to assist courts, schools and others Kessler, head oj Multi-door Courthouse Pro­ in the provision of dispute was the highest among the gram of District of Columbia Superior Court resolution services. nine law schools in Ohio. Dr. Hensler of RAND The overall pass rate was The introduction to the day's emphasized the importance of 88.3%; Cincinnati's pass rate events was given by David A. addressing program evaluation was second, at 93.7%, and Ward '58, Chair of the Supreme early in the planning process, so Case Western's was third, at Court Committee on Dispute that results before and after the 92.4%. Sincere congratulations Resolution. Following his remarks, innovation could be compared. to all who passed and to all the opening plenary session dealt David O'Connor, executive who helped prepare our with models for school, court, director of the Massachusetts graduates for their fine community and public policy Mediation Program, spoke on performance. dispute resolution programs. mediation skills training. Judge 12 COLLEGE NEWS

CAMPAIGN NEARS GOAL ith less than six months The Law Building, built by 1960 The building project will be remaining in the for 350 students and 15 faculty made possible by a partnership of Centennial Challenge, members, is now serving more private gifts and public and/or gifts and commitments to the Law than 600 students and 37 full-time University monies totalling at least Building Addition and Renovation faculty members. The number of $16 million. The University will project approximate $7 million. To activities and organizations has seek the matching money for this complete the private funding goal increased similarly, and the Law project from the General Assembly of $7.7 million for the building, Library has grown from 200,000 as part of the capital appropriation an additional $700,000 in gifts and volumes to nearly 550,000, making bill to be passed in either late pledges must be received by June it one of the largest collections of winter or early spring. 30, 1990. When the Centennial legal materials in the country. "Our work with the architects Challenge is met, the College of Two-thirds of the new space is has gone very well," said Dean Law will also qualify for the designated for the Law Library. Francis X. Beytagh. "They are $750,000 grant conditionally The addition will also provide ready to begin the final drawings promised last year by The Kresge improved facilities for the clinical which will allow us to seek bids Foundation of Troy, Michigan. programs, student organizations, for construction of the project this "Meeting the dollar goal is our the two law journals, faculty, spring or summer. If things go first priority, of course," said according to schedule, we should Thomas E. Cavendish '53, alumni relations, placement, and continuing legal education. Space be able to break ground in the campaign co-chair, "but we also early fall, hopefully on the seek to increase participation of will become available for two new programs—the Socio-Legal weekend of one of the early home alumni. We expect the challenge football games. I am hoping it gift to help us achieve our Research Center, in cooperation with Oxford University, and the will be September 29, when Ohio secondary goal of at least 50 State hosts Southern Cal." proposed Banking and Financial percent of our graduates giving to A limited number of naming the campaign." Institutions Center. opportunities, for rooms and other The Centennial Challenge gift is The Law Centennial Campaign, spaces, remains within the Law conditioned on the occurrence of launched in 1986, has a total goal Building. Individuals and law of $12.7 million to enrich many certain events, most importantly firms interested in receiving such aspects of legal education at Ohio the pledging of $1.5 million by recognition for gifts to the State. The cornerstone of this alumni and friends not later than campaign are encouraged to effort is the Law Building June 30, 1990. All new or contact the Development Office of Addition and Renovation project, increased commitments qualify for the College of Law, 106A Law which will add over 90,000 square the challenge funds. Payments on Building, 1659 North High Street, feet of critically needed library, new or increased gifts may be Columbus, Ohio 43210 or call office and activity space. made through December 31, 1992. (614)292-0601.

WEXNER CENTER OPENS DOORS

he much anticipated opening of the Wexner Center for Tthe Visual Arts brought an excitement to Ohio State unparalleled in recent years. The Center was named in honor of the father of its major benefactor, I" Leslie Wexner, a 1959 Ohio State 3—-si-rnK -— wWüBtn graduate and founder, president and chairman of the board of The Limited. The Center puts The Ohio State University in the forefront of the arts world, and is available to the faculty, students and the public. The Wexner Center for the Visual Arts 13 PLACEMENT POINTS by Darlene J. Brown, Director of Law Placement

all On-Campus Interviewing • In the Student News section of October. It proved to be so (OCI) began with its usual the Law Record, you will find the successful that 1989's break was Fwhirl of excitement. Our list of 1989 judicial clerks. They a full week. Not only does it students experienced are a fine group of young provide a much-needed academic approximately 3000 interviews alumni. We anticipate a bumper break, it has been tremendously between September 11 and crop of judicial clerks this year helpful for students conducting October 31. Over 160 different and believe we will surpass last job hunts outside of Ohio. legal employers (from more than year's total number. Additionally, students can use 170 various offices or branches) • A real treat for me this fall were the week for "call backs" conducted on-campus interviews. my visits with the Dean to the In addition, 132 firms requested following their fall on-campus New York City and Chicago interviews. resumes from our students, which alumni luncheons. It was great also resulted in offers and fun to finally place faces with • Anytime you or your employer acceptances. The list you find as voices and names. Our alumni needs to hire a law clerk for part of this column provides an are very enjoyable and continue summer or part-time during the overview of the different school year, remember to call the employers who scheduled campus to be extremely helpful to the Ohio State Law Placement visits. Placement program and our students. We look forward to Office. We post jobs weekly for Fall O verview continuing these contacts and our students. Also, if you are developing even more. seeking a lawyer with 0-5 years • "Second season" interviewing is becoming more and more • When I was on the road meeting of experience, be sure to notify popular in law placement and our alumni this past fall, the Placement Office so your OSU is no exception. A number frequently I heard during my listing can be included in the bi­ of legal employers have already discussions an echo, "...fall weekly newsletter which is booked dates during January and break?" During the fall of 1988, mailed to alumni who are February to interview third, the faculty initiated an actively seeking new or different second and first year law experimental three-day break in employment opportunities. students. If you are interested in filling your hiring needs between January and April, Mock Interview Program simply give us a call. • In addition to our on-campus This past September, 18 interview calendar, OSU students alumni from the Classes of participated in a number of off- 1987, 1988 and 1989 returned campus interviewing programs in to the law school to conduct Columbus, Washington, D.C. and mock job interviews for 56 Chicago. These off-campus students who requested to programs provided interviewing participate in the new opportunities w ith about 60 program. Each student additional legal employers. OSU received two mock interviews students were very successful in and a critique sheet from all of these trips and nearly a each interviewer. The dozen offers thus far have been interviews were followed by made, and many of those a light supper and accepted. A number of our refreshments where all of the minority students also alums renewed law school interviewed at the Midwest ties and relived many law BLSA-NALP interviewing conference in Cleveland. This is school memories. Barb Brown a very successful program that LIII, Chair of the Student Bar brings legal employers from Association Placement across the country together with Committee, and her midwestern law school students. volunteers helped make the Traditionally, the Cleveland program a great success and Third-year students Barb Brown and conference has produced one which we will continue Carolyn Matheson serve as student numerous second interviews and this fall. hosts for firm recruiters during OCI. offers. 14 COLLEGE NEWS

Firms Scheduled For On-Campus Interviews - Fall 1989

Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer & Feld*, Day, Ketterer, Raley, Wright & Johnson, Cusack & Bell, Ltd., Washington, DC Rybolt, Canton, OH Chicago, IL Arter & Hadden, Cleveland, OH Deloitte & Touche, Columbus, OH Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue, Arter & Hadden, Columbus, OH Dickinson, Wright, Moon, Van Dusen Columbus, OH Arthur Andersen & Co., Columbus, & Freeman, Lansing, MI Kahn, Kleinman, Yanowitz & Arnson OH Dinsmore & Shohl, Cincinnati, OH Co., L.P.A., Cleveland, OH Ashland Oil, Inc., Ashland, KY Dunlevey, Mahan & Furry, Dayton, Kay, Casto & Chaney, Charleston, WV Baker & Botts*, Austin, TX OH Keating, Muething & Klekamp, Baker & Botts*, Dallas, TX Duvin, Cahn & Barnard, Cleveland, Cincinnati, OH Baker & Botts*, Houston, TX OH Keck, Mahin & Cate*, Chicago, IL Baker & Botts*, Washington, DC Dykema Gossett, Detroit, MI King & Ballow, Nashville, TN Baker & Daniels, Indianapolis, IN Eastman & Smith, Toledo, OH King's County District Attorney's Baker & Hostetler, Cleveland, OH Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, Office, Brooklyn, NY Baker & Hostetler, Columbus, OH Pittsburgh, PA Kirkpatrick & Lockhart, Pittsburgh, Barnes & Thornburg, Indianapolis, IN Emens, Hurd, Kegler & Ritter, PA Barrett & McNagny, Fort Wayne, IN Columbus, OH Klett Lieber Rooney & Schorling, Barton, Klugman & Oetting, Los Ernst & Young, Columbus, OH Pittsburgh, PA Angeles, CA Federal Trade Commission, Cleveland, Kohrman Jackson & Krantz, Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan & OH Cleveland, OH Aronoif, Cleveland, OH Fisher & Phillips, Atlanta, GA Krugliak, Wilkins, Griffiths & Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan & Foley & Lardner, Milwaukee, WI Dougherty Co., L.P.A., Canton, OH Aronofi, Columbus, OH Freund, Freeze & Arnold Co., L.P.A., Lane, Alton & Horst, Columbus, OH Best, Best & Krieger, Riverside, CA Dayton, OH Bingham Summers Welsh & Spilman, Legal Aid Society Criminal Defense Frost & Jacobs, Cincinnati, OH Division, New York, NY Indianapolis, IN Fuller & Henry, Toledo, OH Black, McCuskey, Souers & Arbaugh, LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae*, Gallagher, Sharp, Fulton & Norman, New York, NY Canton, OH Cleveland, OH Borden, Inc., Columbus, OH Lincoln National Corporation, Fort Gendel, Raskoff, Shapiro & Quittner, Wayne, IN Bricker & Eckler, Columbus, OH Los Angeles, CA Brooks & Kushman, Southfield, MI Locke Reynolds Boyd & Weisell, Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, Los Indianapolis, IN Brouse & McDowell, Akron, OH Angeles, CA Buchanan Ingersoll Professional Long, Aldridge & Norman, Atlanta, Gray, Cary, Ames & Frye*, San Diego, GA Corporation, Pittsburgh, PA CA Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs, Manchester, Bennett, Powers & Graydon, Head & Ritchey, Cincinnati, Uliman Co., L.P.A., Youngstown, Akron, OH OH Burke, Haber & Berick Co., L.P.A., OH Cleveland, OH Greenebaum, Doll & McDonald, Marathon Oil Company, Findlay, OH Louisville, KY Burke, Wilson & Mcllvaine, Chicago, Marshall & Melhorn, Toledo, OH IL Hackman McClarnon Hulett & Martin, Browne, Hull & Harper, Cracraft, Indianapolis, IN Calfee, Halter & Griswold, Cleveland, Springfield, OH OH Hahn Loeser & Parks, Cleveland, OH McCullough, Campbell & Lane, Cargill, Incorporated, Minneapolis, Harris Beach & Wilcox, Rochester, NY Chicago, IL MN Hochman & Associates, Dayton, OH McDonald, Hopkins & Hardy Co., Cavitch, Familo & Durkin Co., L.P.A., Honigman Miller Schwartz and Cohn, L.P.A., Cleveland, OH Cleveland, OH Detroit, MI Michael, Best & Friedrich, Milwaukee, Clary, Nantz, Wood, Hoffius, Rankin Huddleston, Bolen, Beatty, Porter & WI & Cooper, Grand Rapids, MI Copen, H untington, WV Michigan Court of Appeals, Lansing, Cloppert, Portman, Sauter, Latanick & Hunt, Suedhoff, Borror & Eilbacher, MI Foley, Columbus, OH Fort Wayne, IN Millisor & Nobil, Columbus, OH Columbia Gas Distribution Ice Miller Donadio & Ryan, Mitchell, Silberberg & Knupp, Los Companies, Columbus, OH Indianapolis, IN Angeles, CA Columbia Natural Resources, Inc., Internal Revenue Service, Office of National Fuel Gas Distribution Charleston, WV Chief Counsel, Washington, DC Corporation, Buffalo, NY Connelly, Soutar & Jackson, Toledo, Isaac, Brant, Ledman & Becker, National On-Campus Interview OH Columbus, OH Consortium, Washington, DC Coolidge, Wall, Womsley & Lombard IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY Neal Gerber Eisenberg & Lurie, Co., L.P.A., Dayton, OH Jackson & Kelly, Charleston, WV Chicago, IL Coopers & Lybrand, CPA's, Columbus, Jacobson, Maynard, Tuschman & Ohio Attorney General's Office, OH Kalur Co., L.P.A., Cleveland, OH Columbus, OH Cors & Bassett, Cincinnati, OH Janik & McLaughlin, Cleveland, ÖH Ohio Public Utilities Commission, Cronquist, Smith, Marshall & Weaver, Jenkins, Fenstermaker, Krieger, Kayes Columbus, OH Cleveland, OH & Farrell, Huntington, WV Pattishall, McAuliffe, Newbury et al., Crowell & Moring*, Washington, DC Jenner & Block, Chicago, IL Chicago, IL Dade County State Attorney's Office, Johnson & Gibbs, A Professional Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker, Miami, FL Corporation, Dallas, TX Los Angeles, CA 15

Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp., Seyfarth, Shaw, Fairweather & Thrasher, Dinsmore & Dolan, Washington, DC Geraldson, Chicago, IL Chardon, OH Phelan, Pope & John, Ltd., Chicago, Shumaker, Loop & Kendrick, Toledo, Tressler Söderström Maloney & IL OH Priess, Chicago, IL Pickrel, Schaeffer & Ebeling, Dayton, Simpson & Moran, Birmingham, MI U.S. Dept, o f Health & Human OH Simpson Thacher & Bartlett, Services, Washington, DC Pillsbury, Madison & Sutro*, Los Columbus, OH Ulmer & Berne, Cleveland, OH Angeles, CA Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Vogelgesang, Howes, Lindamood & Pillsbury, Madison & Sutro*, San Flom*, Boston, MA Brunn, Canton, OH Francisco, CA Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Pillsbury, Madison & Sutro*, San Flom*, Chicago, IL Vorys, Sater, Seymour & Pease, Columbus, OH Jose, CA Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Pillsbury, Madison & Sutro*, Walnut Flom*, Los Angeles, CA Warrick, Weaver & Boyn, Elkhart, IN Creek, CA Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Weston, Hurd, Fallon, Paisley & Pillsbury, Madison & Sutro*, Flom*, New York, NY H owley, Cleveland, OH Washington, DC Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Whyte & Hirschboeck S.C., Porter, Wright, Morris & Arthur, Flom*, Washington, DC Milwaukee, WI Columbus, OH Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Winston & Strawn, Chicago, IL * Price Waterhouse, Cleveland, OH Flom*, Wilmington, DE Reed Smith Shaw & McClay, Winthrop, Stimson, Putnam & Sonnenschein Carlin Nath & Roberts, New York, NY Pittsburgh, PA Rosenthal, Chicago, IL Reinhart, Boerner, Van Dueren, Norris & Rieselbach, Milwaukee, WI Spengler, Nathanson, Heyman, Judges Scheduled For Robinson & McElwee, Charleston, WV McCarthy & Durfee, Toledo, OH Robison, Curphey & O'Connell, Squire, Sanders & Dempsey, On-Campus Interviews — Toledo, OH Cleveland, OH Fall 1989 Roetzel & Andress, Akron, OH Squire, Sanders & Dempsey, Rose, Schmidt, Hasley & DiSalle, Columbus, OH The Honorable Peggy L. Bryant '76, Pittsburgh, PA Stoll, Keenon & Park, Lexington, KY Ohio Court of Appeals, Tenth Rutan & Tucker, Costa Mesa, CA Strauss & Troy, Cincinnati, OH District, Columbus, OH Santen, Shaffer & Hughes, Cincinnati, Streich, Lang, Weeks & Cardon, The Honorable James H. Williams OH Phoenix, AZ '58, U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Akron, Schneider, Smeltz, Huston & Ranney, Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, OH Cleveland, OH Cincinnati, OH The Honorable John Evans, The Scholten, Fant & Marquis, Holland, Taft, Stettinius & Hollister, Honorable Thomas F. Bryant, Ohio MI Columbus, OH Court of Appeals, Third District, Schottenstein, Zox & Dunn, Theisen, Brock, Frye, Erb & Leeper Lima, OH Columbus, OH Co., L.P.A., Marietta, OH Schwartz, Kelm, Warren & Thompson, Hine and Flory, *Firms represented by the National Rubenstein, Columbus, OH Cleveland, OH On-Campus Interview Consortium. CLINIC TAKES CASE TO SUPREME COURT A ttorneys from The Ohio the conviction under the newly affirmed the conviction and State University College of construed statute without giving denied the petition for rehearing, X A . Law Clinical Programs, the defendant an opportunity for a Professors David A. Goldberger, together with an attorney from new trial under it. The appeal also Director of Clinical Programs, and the Ohio Public Defender challenged the statute as a John B. Q u ig le y joined the case Commission, recently appeared violation of the first amendment. and all three attorneys appealed before the United States Supreme The appeal was initially the case to the United States Court to argue Osborne v. State of undertaken by former Clinic staff Supreme Court. Ohio. The Osborne case challenged attorney Richard Curtner and by The case was argued before the the Ohio Supreme Court's then third-year student G erald A. Supreme Court in early December. affirmance of a criminal conviction M oore '86. When Curtner left the "We were pleased with our on grounds that the Ohio court's Clinical Programs for another presentation of the issues and we construction of a state statute in position, an appeal to the Supreme are anxiously anticipating the an attempt to save the statute Court of Ohio was taken by S. decision," said Professor Quigley. from constitutional attack deprived Adele Shank '80, of the Ohio It is the first case since 1966 in the defendant of a fair trial. This Public Defender Commission. which Clinical Programs attorneys is because the Ohio court affirmed When the Ohio Supreme Court have argued in the high court. 16 COLLEGE NEWS

Judge Addresses Faculty and sentences (over 90% are The College of Law was denied further review); 3) certified fortunate to host a visit on cases from the Judge Advocate General; and 4) "extra" writs October 13 from the H on orable which amount to some 2,500 Robinson O. Everett, Chief Judge requests for review each year. Oral of the United States Court of argument is presented in about Military Appeals. Judge Everett is a tenured professor at Duke half of the cases accepted for University Law School as well and review; many cases receive is the only law professor to sit on summary disposition. Until 1984, the Court. the Court was the court of last Judge Everett began his remarks resort. The United States Supreme by saying he is always pleased to Court may now grant certiorari in Professors Fink, Mandelker and Murphy en­ visit at law schools and with law cases from the military justice joy an interesting discussion. faculty, and to get away from system. Washington, D.C., "a place too Judge Everett said he is proud regulations faced a hard-to-rebut small to be a state and too large of the jurisprudence represented presumption of constitutionality. to be an insane asylum." Judge in the now 50 volumes of Recently, however, that Everett also enjoyed seeing several opinions of the Court and presumption has begun to shift. old friends who joined the welcomed faculty to visit "our The courts have not replaced the colloquium, including R o b e rt M . Courthouse." old presumption of constitu­ Duncan '52, former Chief Judge of In 1950 Judge Everett graduated tionality with some new the Court of Military Appeals, magna cum laude from the Harvard presumption of unconstitutionality. Columbus host Dennis A. Schulze Law School where he served two But at both the federal and state '68, and Associate Dean Gregory years on the Harvard Law Review. levels, the courts are examining M. Travalio, who was on special He received his LL.M. from Duke these local governmental actions assignment to the Court as part of Law School in 1959. He is a well- much more closely. Some judges his 1988 Reserve duty. known scholar of military law, have become cynical about the Judge Everett explained the criminal procedure, and evidence, expertise and rationality of local jurisdiction of the Court. and served as associate editor of government. Others are looking Established in 1951, members of Duke's Law and Contemporary closely at the takings clauses in the Court are all civilian judges, Problems. the federal and state constitutions. Others are reexamining the balancing tests between the social Mandelker Visits College welfare alleged and the degree of Daniel Mandelker, Stamper private burden imposed. The Professor of Law, Washington result, however, is a much more University in St. Louis, spoke open opportunity for lawyers several times at The Ohio State representing landowners. University under the joint Professor Mandelker also spoke sponsorship of the College of Law on "New Trends in Sign and the Departments of City & Regulation" at the School of Regional Planning and Landscape Architecture on November 16 and Architecture in the School of to a colloquium at the College of Architecture, College of Law on November 17 for the Robert Duncan joins Judge Everett for faculty Engineering. His lecture at the faculties of the College of Law colloquium. College of Law on November 15 and of the Department of City & considered recent shifts in the Regional Planning. His talk at the although appointees have some presumption of constitutionality College of Law dealt with recent military background. All parties for land use regulations. cases on the takings clause. He before the Court are represented Throughout most of the 20th began with the so-called trilogy of by military counsel. The Court has century, land use regulations 1987 United States Supreme Court review jurisdiction for offenses adopted by local governments decisions and then followed their prosecuted within the military arrived at the United States subsequent careers through the justice system for all armed Supreme Court and the supreme lower federal and state courts. His services. The judge reported that courts of the states with a final observation was that lawyers approximately one out of every presumption of constitutionality. should look most closely at the three cases appealed for review is Whether the regulations were decisions of intermediate state drug-related. Appeals come from attacked as being facially appellate courts because those the following sources: 1) unconstitutional or as were the courts, for good or ill, mandatory review of all death unconstitutional in their who were making the bulk of thé sentences; 2) review of convictions application, those challenging the land use decisions. 17

GENOA EXCHANGE CONTINUES he College of Law was a provision for plea bargaining, fortunate to have the which may be unconstitutional," Topportunity to host the stay explained Fanchiotti. of a second scholar from the University of Genoa this past fall. Following in the footsteps of Herman Travels to Genoa predecessor Enrico Zanelli, As part of our exchange Vittorio Fanchiotti, Professor of relationship with the University of Law at the University of Genoa, Genoa, in December P rofessor visited the College of Law for 11 Lawrence Herman traveled from days in September. Although the The Ohio State University to time was short, the second "Genoa Genoa for 16 days. He visited at Connection" was at once the University of Genoa Law educational and enjoyable. School, lectured to students and met with faculty and various lawyers, judges and government officials. He also observed criminal trials at all three levels of trial courts, which vary according to Professor Herman enjoys sightseeing with a the seriousness of the offense. host faculty member. "My wife and I were overwhelmed by the graciousness exclusionary rule which was and generosity of all of the people attended by magistrates, we met at the University of Genoa prosecutors, and defense attorneys Law School," exclaimed Herman. in addition to the law school "However, the most amazing thing community. The topic was of to me is how much they know particular interest because Italy about American law, and how enacted an exclusionary rule for interested they are in American unconstitutionally obtained legal developments. I was asked evidence in October 1989. about the flag burning case and the resultant Congressional Beytagh To enactment, and about a recent death penalty case out of Revisit Genoa Chicago." To strengthen the ongoing In explanation of their exchange relationship between heightened awareness, Herman Ohio State and the University of After graduation from law continued, "In the United States, Genoa, Dean Francis X. Beytagh school, Professor Fanchiotti we tend to litigate our social will revisit the Italian law school continued his education with a problems. Therefore, the majority, in late June. On his first visit, 'specialization' in criminology concurring and dissenting from November 27 to December from the Institute of Criminology. opinions really constitute a 10, 1987, Dean Beytagh held He is the author of several books published debate on very sensitive discussions with Italian law and articles regarding the social issues. Our litigation students, faculty, and judges about comparative aspects of Italian and provides them with arguments on comparative constitutional law, American criminal procedure. all sides of the social issues all and delivered six lectures on Professor Fanchiotti spent his societies must confront." constitutional law topics that were time here meeting with faculty, The topics of his lectures recently published in the students, judges and practicing included: the current status of the University's Annali di Genova. In attorneys to share common death penalty in America, plea addition to similar activities, his interests and ideas. One of the bargaining, the drug problem in plans for the trip in June include purposes of his visit was to the United States (because under firming up arrangements for a continue the plea bargaining Italian law the possession and use series of conferences to be held in research he began in Italy. "The of narcotics are not crimes), and 1991-1992 in Genoa and Columbus Italian criminal procedure code is the American Civil Liberties to celebrate the quincentenary of in a time of great change. Italy Union. Columbus's discovery of America, will soon have a more adversary Professor Herman gave one as well as the College of Law system, and the code now contains large public lecture on the Centennial anniversary. 18 COLLEGE NEWS

COLLEGE WELCOMES CLASS OF 1992 he College of Law has for small group discussions, the College of Law, and his plans for traditionally offered an Class of 1992 enjoyed a picnic the future of the institution. Torientation session before the lunch at Drake Union. Faculty, "The Dean's Coffees have start of classes to assist first-year staff and upperclass students took provided me a valuable students in learning what to this occasion to become better opportunity to get to know expect of a law school education. acquainted with the entering students in a relaxed, congenial This fall, the Class of 1992 students. Anxiety about starting atmosphere. Every Dean should assembled in the auditorium for law school cannot be eliminated, make a strong effort to establish a but the new Ohio State law good working relationship with students finished the day with a the student body—after all, thè better understanding of students are the reason the rest of expectations and the learning us are here," observed Dean environment. "We are all in this Beytagh. Certainly, the students together to help one another" was will find the Dean willing to the repeated theme of the day. listen and to help in solving any problems they might mention. Coffees with the Dean Placement Presentation The first year of law study can be at once exciting and traumatic. The guidelines of the National Knowing well the first-year Association for Law Placement experience and the difficulties encourage that no action be taken inherent in personalizing with first-year students by potential employers or school SBA President Patrick Dukes LIII and Judge relationships at a large institution Peggy Bryant '76. placement offices until November 1. In compliance with this their first law school experience agreement, first-year students were early on the morning of August introduced to the College's 19, 1989. The welcoming remarks Placement Services when they met of SBA President Patrick Dukes with Director Darlene J. Brown LIII, Associate Dean Gregory M. on November 1. T ravalio, and Dean Francis X. "First-year students actively seek B eytagh were filled with words of law-related summer employment. praise and encouragement, helping Fortunately, the current hiring to ease the anxiety of those first trends seem to be more open to few weeks. meeting these students' needs. It has become a tradition for a However, more positions for first- distinguished alumnus of the years are needed in all areas of College to participate in law, including public interest, law orientation and to share some firms of all sizes, government and broader perspectives about Dean Beytagh with first-year students at private sector," explained Brown. Dean’s Coffee. educational preparation for the legal profession. The H on orable like Ohio State, Dean Beytagh P eg g y L. B ryant, Tenth District initiated a program several years Court of Appeals of Ohio, was this ago to become better acquainted year's invited speaker. Judge with the students from their first Bryant is a 1976 graduate of the weeks at the College of Law. College of Law and currently Divided into groups of twenty serves on the National Council of or so, the students were invited to the College of Law Alumni a coffee with the Dean. Dean Association. Beytagh encouraged them to tell The opening session was the group about themselves and completed by the humorous yet their impressions of law school in insightful remarks of P rofessor general, and the College of Law Louis A. Jacobs and A ssista n t in particular. In return, Dean Professor David Williams, II. Beytagh offered insights into his Students study photos of first-years in Place­ After some break-out sessions background, the history of the ment Office window on Orientation Day. 19

LIBRARY NEWS his year, computer assisted legal research training was Tincorporated into the first year law students' legal research and writing course. WESTLAW training began just one month after the students started law school, and had received introductory lectures and assignments covering legal research skills. For one month a classroom was set up as a Law students practice their new research WESTLAW Temporary Learning skills on the WESTLAW terminals. Center with ten IBM work stations supplied by WESTLAW. The students were trained using personal computers because of the growing trend in law offices to use such equipment for WESTLAW and LEXIS searching rather than dedicated equipment. The classes were taught by a reference librarian and a WESTLAW representative. The first- WESTLAW representative teaches student. year students completed a 1-1/2 hour training session in which the Generally, the students have Helen Horton joined the library first hour was spent introducing been enthusiastic about the staff as a Catalog Librarian in the students to WESTLAW by expanded WESTLAW training charge of the retrospective working through an offline program and winter semester's conversion and reclassification tutorial program. The last part of LEXIS/NEXIS training which was projects. In this position, she will the session was completed online. offered for the month of January. coordinate and manage the The librarians referred to manual We look forward to having the lab transfer of all our card catalog research methods and showed the in the remodeled library which records into computerized data students the types of searches that will enable us to offer year round (retrospective conversion) and the are most efficiently performed by WESTLAW and LEXIS training change of our collection from the computers, and the searches that programs for the students. previous scheme of arrangement to are best completed manually. the Library of Congress system These concepts were further New Faces in the Library (reclassification). Horton recently emphasized in the advanced completed her Master's Degree in WESTLAW classes offered In the past few months, two Library Science from Indiana throughout the month. When new professional librarians have University-Bloomington. Her classes were not in session, the joined Director Alan Holoch's undergraduate degree is from students could practice their staff. Bowling Green State University WESTLAW skills in the Temporary Cory Skurdal assumed a with a major in Library Science Learning Center. The WESTLAW previously vacated position as and Education. Prior to library representative was available to Reference Librarian. He arrived school, she was associated for 15 assist the students and a number here from the Graduate School of years with the Bexley Public of research, assistants, Ohio State Library Science, University of Library, holding several positions Law Journal and Dispute Resolution Washington, where he recently as department head. Journal students took advantage of earned his Master's in Law The College of Law welcomes the opportunity to get individual Librarianship. Prior to his post­ both of you! help with their search strategies. graduate study, Skurdal earned his Law students with home J.D. and B.A. from the University computer equipment took of North Dakota, where he advantage of the WESTLAW offer majored in political science and of free WESTMATE software and criminal justice. He hopes to two hours of free WESTLAW develop his specialty in foreign searching. and international legal research. 20 FACULTY NEWS

VISITING PROFESSORS he fall semester brought Transfer Procedures. He is Jeffrey W. Morris three distinguished visiting teaching Gratuitous Transfers and Tprofessors to the College of a new Advanced Estate Planning Law. course this semester. Ira Mark Bloom Joseph W. Dellapenna Joseph W. Dellapenna, whose home is the Villanova University School of Law, served as a visiting professor for the autumn semester. A native of Michigan, Dellapenna remained in the "state up north" for much of his higher education. A 1965 graduate of the University of Michigan with a B.B.A., with distinction, he went directly to law school, finishing first in his Jeffrey W. Morris came to us as class at the Detroit College of a full professor from the Law. In addition, he holds two University of Dayton School of LL.M.'s, from George Washington University and Columbia Law. Also visiting the College for Ira Mark Bloom hails from the University, and has taught at the fall semester, his teaching faculty of the Albany Law School. George Washington, Willamette responsibilities were Secured He is serving as the Drinko-Baker University, and the University of Transactions and Debtor /Creditor and Hostetler Visiting Professor of Cincinnati. Law. Born and raised in Rhode Law and will be with us for the Island, he graduated cum laude full academic year. Professor with a B.A. in Political Science Bloom is a graduate of the City from Providence in 1974. The College of New York and the following fall found him in law Syracuse University College of school in Lexington, Virginia. "I Law. While in law school, he feel I received a first-rate served as research editor of the education at Washington & Lee," Syracuse Law Review, and stated Morris, who was the graduated magna cum laude. He executive editor of the Washington was elected to the Order of the & Lee Law Review and a member Coif. of the Jessup International Moot Before entering law teaching in Court Team while in law school. 1974, Professor Bloom served for After his graduation, cum laude, five years as a trial and appellate from law school, Morris practiced attorney in the Tax Division of Professor Dellapettna bankruptcy law with a large the U.S. Department of Justice Honors' Program. He is the author Atlanta law firm. Four years later, of numerous articles, and he is Professor Dellapenna has taught the call to teach became too coauthor of the following and written on many subjects, strong. "While I enjoyed the firm, ranging from contracts to casebooks: Estates and Trusts: Cases, I missed the opportunity to environmental law. His most Problems and Materials; Federal consider legal issues without recent book, Suing Foreign Taxation of Estates, Trusts and Gifts; regard to the economics of the Governments and Their Corporations practice of law," he admitted. and Estates, Trusts and Taxes - Cases (1988), related directly to one of and Materials on the Wealth his offerings, a course on Atlanta's loss, however, is Dayton's Transmission Process. He is currently Transnational Litigation. His other gain. working on a chapter for a book offering, Introduction to Chinese His scholarship endeavors have on estate planning and updating Law, arose from his longstanding included coauthorship of books on the material for his casebooks. interest in China. He has served Chapters 12 and 13 of the United During the autumn semester, he as a Fulbright lecturer in both the States Bankruptcy Code, as well as taught Taxation of Gifts, Trusts, People's Republic of China (1987- numerous articles regarding and Estates and a seminar on 88) and the Republic of China bankruptcy and secured Selected Problems in Wealth (1978-79). transactions. 21 FACULTY HIGHLIGHTS Francis X. Beytagh attended the New Teachers Workshop of the quarter century has passed since American Bar Association Annual Association of American Law the landmark New York Times v. Meeting in Honolulu in August. Schools to be held in Washington, Sullivan opinion. With that case, His service to the American Bar D.C. in July. He has been the Supreme Court began a Association continued in Novem­ reappointed to the Committee on process of constitutionalization ber when he acted as chair of the Professional Development of the that has produced a chaotic system ABA inspection team at St. Association of American Law that fails to meet the great Thomas University law school in Schools. He continues to serve as objective of accommodating the Miami. the chair of the College's Planning individual's interest in reputation In October 1989, he was a Committee which is planning the to the strictures of the first panelist and participant in a new law building addition and amendment. The article examines German-American conference on renovation. Sullivan and its progeny, placing a comparative constitutional law in realistic perspective on doctrine Washington, D.C. Arthur F. Greenbaum began his that has become accepted Throughout the summer and tenth year of teaching at The Ohio notwithstanding its formation fall, Dean Beytagh participated in State University College of Law through shaky Court majorities law alumni functions in New York this fall. His article, "Government and less than compelling logic and City, Chicago, Indianapolis, Participation in Private Litigation," suggests an approach toward Washington, D.C., Miami, and appeared in the December 1989 accommodation of the apparently Cleveland. He also continued his issue of the Arizona State Law irreconcilable interests predicated committee work with the Journal. This article presents the on concepts of professionalism. American Bar Association, the first comprehensive analysis ever The second, "Values and Value: Ohio State Bar Association, the prepared of the issues that arise An Essay on Libel Reform," will Columbus Bar Association, and the from the Federal Government's be published in February 1990 in Association of American Law participation in private litigation. the Washington and Lee Law Review. Schools. It addresses both the policy It was solicited by the Journal as considerations and procedural part of its symposium issue on Howard P. Fink has completed restrictions that govern this Communicative Torts; Professor work on the 1990 Supplement to important aspect of federal Halpern will also participate in Fink and Tushnet, Federal regulatory practice. the symposium at Washington and Jurisdiction: Policy and Practice, "Jacks or Better to Open: Lee at which the various articles which was published in December Procedural Limitations on Co-Party will be presented. In addition, 1989. He is currently hard at work and Third-Party Claims" will Professor Halpern, with coauthors on a treatise on the Ohio Rules of appear in the February 1990 issue Howard Abrams of the University Civil Procedure with Professors of the Minnesota Law Review. This of Detroit and David Shipley of Charles E. Wilson and Arthur F. work addresses the complex and South Carolina, has contracted to Greenbaum of the faculty. seemingly contradictory treatment write a casebook on Copyright Professor Fink has been the Federal Rules of Civil Law with West Publishing appointed co-chair of the newly Procedure give to claims raised in Company. reconstituted Editorial Board of the multi-claim litigation and presents Over the past year, Professor Michie Company, law book a framework for reform. It Halpern has served as chair of the publishers. This seven-person provides the only in-depth Association of American Law Board will advise the publisher on analysis of this subject ever Schools' provisional section on the acceptance of manuscripts for prepared and constitutes the first Defamation and Privacy. He was publication and on general significant treatment of these the moderator of the section's publication and corporate strategy. issues since Professor Friedenthal's program at the AALS conference In addition to Professor Fink, the Stanford article in 1970 on multi­ in January 1990 in San Francisco. Board will consist of Professors claim litigation in California. Professor Halpern has been Stephan Saltzburg of Virginia (co­ appointed to the University's chair), Charles Craver of George Sheldon W, Halpern has two Faculty Committee on Patents and Washington, Jane Ginsburg of forthcoming articles. The first, "Of Copyrights. In addition, he has Columbia, Edward Imwinkelreid of Libel, Language and Law: N ew been named to the American Law the University of California at York Times v. Sullivan at Twenty- Institute Members Consultative Davis, Daniel Mandelker of Five," was published in the North Group for the Restatement of the Washington University in St. Carolina Law Review in January Law, Third, Unfair Competition. Louis, and Mark Tushnet of 1990. The article is an extended Georgetown. exploration of the current state of L, C am ille H eb ert was recently Professor Fink will chair the the law of defamation now that a appointed by Columbus, Ohio 22 FACULTY NEWS

Mayor Dana Rinehart to the availability of the death penalty in chapter on the law of long term Mayor's Drug Legislation Ohio. care facilities for a book on health Commission. The Commission is to In September, Professor Herman care facility law. issue a report on proposed participated in a round-table on changes in the drug laws to Constitutional Law as part of a P. J. Kozyris gave a set of improve their enforcement. continuing legal education lectures in Greece to bar Professor Hébert has made program held in conjunction with associations and university'groups presentations to several different Annual Alumni Return. He gave on the subjects of constitutional groups in the past few months. In five lectures at the University of interpretation in the United States, July 1989, she spoke to the Genoa from December 3 to comparative corporate law, Columbus Area International December 15 as part of the conflict-of-laws doctrine, and Program on "Social Legislation College's ongoing exchange regulation of the mass media in Affecting Women." Her talk program with the University of America. Given in the spring of focused on legislation on sex Genoa. He will also be the 1989, these lectures led to articles discrimination in employment and resident director of the College's which are being published in education and legislation summer program for pre-law Greek legal periodicals. concerning abortion and child students in Oxford, England next In 1989, Professor Kozyris care. summer. published two major pieces on In September 1989, she spoke to corporate takeovers. One article, returning College of Law alumni Alan Holoch, Director of the entitled "Corporate Takeovers at on "The Constitutionality of law library, has been appointed to the Jurisdictional Crossroads: Employee Drug Testing." Professor a second term as a member of the Preserving State Authority Over Hébert was one of four faculty American Bar Association's Section Internal Affairs While Protecting presenters during the first portion on Legal Education and the Transferability of Interstate of the Annual Alumni Return Admissions to the Bar, Committee Stock Through Federal Law," was Continuing Legal Education on Law Libraries. In conjunction published in 36 U.C.L.A. Law Program on "The Supreme Court with the Section Council, the Review 1109 (1989). The article and Controversy: Analysis and Committee is reviewing the maintains that there is an Implications of Recent Decisions." process of inspecting and overriding federal interest to A third presentation was made evaluating law schools and law protect the free transferability of in November 1989 concerning school libraries. securities and of corporate control "The Many Dimensions of Drug in the interstate markets and that Testing in the Workplace: Timothy S. Jost spent the this interest may be fully Protecting Employees' Privacy spring and summer of 1989 at the implemented through rules of Interests." She led a discussion of Centre for Socio-Legal Studies at exclusion from the markets of privacy protections for private Oxford University on a Fulbright nonconforming securities without sector employees from the privacy grant. He studied health care otherwise interfering with the invasions inherent in drug testing quality regulation in England, authority of the states to regulate provided by legislation, tort Sweden, Belgium and West the management and internal theories, and contracts. Germany. A monograph on this affairs of their corporations as topic will be published by the they see fit. King's Fund of London in the The other article appeared under Lawrence Herman accompanied near future. the title, "Some Observations on Ohio State's team to the regional Professor Jost has begun work State Regulation of Multistate and final rounds of the American on a first-year Property casebook Takeovers: Controlling Choice of Bar Association's National which will be published by West Law Through the Commerce Appellate Advocacy Competition. Publishing Company. The book, Clause," in 14 Del. J. Corp. L. #2 The team, which consisted of which is coauthored by Sandra (1989). The main thesis is that, Carolyn Baker and Christopher Johnson and Peter Salsich of Saint under the Commerce Clause, the Parker, won the Ohio-Michigan Louis University and Thomas state of incorporation has wide regional round in Akron. In the Shaffer of the University of Notre powers to regulate takeover final round in Washington in Dame, will be designed to matters, within a broad definition August, the team finished second. facilitate the teaching of of internal affairs, of domestic but Congratulations to the adviser and professional ethics and alternative not of foreign corporations. The the team! dispute resolution in the first-year antitakeover statutes, however, run Professor Herman is a member curriculum. After finishing this, the risk of preemption if they of the Ohio Criminal Defense book, he will begin work on a discriminate in favor of Lawyers Association's special task second edition to his Health Law management-approved acquisitions force on the death penalty. The casebook, which was used in in violation of the neutrality task force is preparing testimony ninety law schools last year. policy of the federal tender offer against proposals to broaden the Finally, he is working on a laws. 23

Professor Kozyris has been for Academic Excellence for following in the footsteps of selected by the International Women. The Council meets distinguished former Ohio State Academy of Comparative Law to monthly to plan activities and law professors Robert Mathews be the national United States discuss issues affecting women and Ivan Rutledge. For those reporter on "Crossborder faculty and staff. In addition to concerned about Professor Bankruptcy in the Conflict-of- attending a fall reception for new Modjeska's health and vigor, Laws," a topic to be presented at women faculty, a promotion and suffice to note that he just became the Academy's XHIth Congress to tenure workshop, a child care a brown belt in taekwondo. be held in Montreal in August forum, and meetings with both 1990. the Provost for Academic Affairs At the annual meeting of the and the President, she hosted Earl Finbar Murphy remains Association of American Law three luncheons for women active as a member of the Board Schools held in San Francisco in faculty. She continues her work as of Visitors, Indiana University January 1990, Professor Kozyris a member of the College of Law School of Law—Indianapolis at the spoke to the Conflicts Section on Appointments Committee as well. Indiana University/Purdue "Methods and Values in Choice-of- Professor Krauskopf also spoke University Campus at Indianapolis. Law: Comments on Recent about family law issues on the As Courtesy Professor of Natural Legislative Texts Relating to Central Ohio Radio Reading Resources in the College of Products Liability Conflicts." He is Service for persons with visual Agriculture, Professor Murphy has also currently completing "Choice impairments. participated in working on the of Law in the American Courts- curriculum of the Natural 1989" to be published in the Resources Development Project Stanley K. Laughlin traveled American Journal of Comparative Law. and on the committee for the this past summer to St. Croix in Wayne Nichols Lecture. He has the United States Virgin Islands to Joan M. Krauskopf continues continued his work with the address the Virgin Islands Bar her work on issues relating to World Society for Ekistics, family law. She authored an Association and to appear on local headquartered in Athens, Greece. television shows. His general topic article, "Theories of Property Professor Murphy published a was the political status of the Division/Spousal Support: chapter, "Euclid and the Virgin Islands. Later in the Searching for Solutions to the Environment," in Zoning and the summer he went to Oxford, Mystery," which was published in American Dream: Promises Still to England to participate in the 23 Family Law Quarterly 253 (1989). Keep, Charles Haar and Jerold College of Law's summer programs The article explores the differences Kayden, eds., published by the there and to visit the Oxford and similarities between property American Planning Association in division and spousal support at Socio-Legal Centre. He is a association with the Lincoln member of the board of overseers marriage dissolution. The thesis is Institute of Land Policy. The book of the Ohio State. counterpart of that property division divides the explores the ramifications of the the Oxford Centre. gains in traditional assets that are 1926 case of Ambler Realty Company Professor Laughlin continues to a product of the marriage while v. Village of Euclid. He also be involved in a number of spousal support shares the gains published an article, "Implements projects with the Mershon Center, and losses in earning capacity of for the World Garden," in Ekistics, including co-chairing the World each spouse which are due to Nos. 325/326/327, which deals Affairs Seminar, which is an marital roles. Further, she has with the international law of begun work with two new interdisciplinary group of scholars. environmental protection and land coauthors to write a second use allocation. He is continuing edition of Advocacy for the Aging, Lee Modjeska recently his work on groundwater law and first published by West Publishing published "Federalism in Labor the theory of property law. Company in 1983. Relations - The Last Decade" in Professor Krauskopf has also the Ohio State Law Journal, and Joanne Wharton Murphy been engaged in researching and another article, "Employment coordinated an active program of analyzing Ohio property division Discrimination and the alumni events over the fall in and alimony law in the context of Reconsideration of Runyon," will addition to teaching her seminar a major legislative revision of be published shortly in the dealing with "Problems in Ohio law. She has advised various Kentucky Law Journal. He is International Finance and lobbying groups and testified in currently writing casebooks and Banking." An article, "Financing the Ohio Legislature on the treatises on labor and employment Physical Infrastructure for Future proposal. law. Urban Settlements," recently On the University front, Professor Modjeska was recently appeared in Ekistics magazine. The Professor Krauskopf's activities admitted to membership in the piece was based upon a include service as chair-elect of prestigious Labor Law Group, a presentation at a symposium in The Ohio State University Council select group of scholars, thereby Athens, Greece for the World 24 FACULTY NEWS

Society of Ekistics. She is a legal systems of socialist countries addition, he received an award member and director of the form a family of law separate from the Palestinian Community Society which is a from the civil law from which it of Central Ohio at a ceremony and multidisciplinary organization takes its origin. In "Socialist Law reception at the Parke Hotel. dealing with urban planning on a and the Civil Law Tradition," 37 Congratulations! world scale. American Journal of Comparative Law Professor Quigley conducted a 301 (1989), Quigley argues to the two-week continuing legal John B. Q u ig le y continues his contrary that socialist law remains education program for fifteen prolific scholarship with the part of the civil law tradition lawyers in Kenya from September publication of several additional despite the addition of socialist 22 to October 8. In addition to articles. "Palestine's Declaration of elements. giving lectures on Kenyan law, he Independence and the Right of Professor Quigley has spoken to also arranged visits to Kenyan, the Palestinians to Statehood," 7 a variety of community groups in courts and meetings with Kenyan Boston University International Law Columbus on the topic of lawyers. Journal 1 (1989), analyzes from the international drug trafficking. He standpoint of international law lectured at Cleveland State College Rhonda R. Rivera wrote an (territorial rights, self- of Law and Case Western Reserve article on HIV infection and determination) the Palestinian Law School on the topic of "Legal handicap law in the black declaration of independence of Aspects of Palestinian Autonomy" community for the Columbus Call & 1988 and concludes that there is a on April 11. On April 18, he Post newspaper which appeared in sound legal basis for the spoke over the Ohio Radio a recent issiie. Additionally, she declaration. "Human Rights Study Reading Service on current was quoted in articles appearing in Soviet Academia," 11 Human developments in Saudi Arabia. in The Columbus Dispatch, Columbus Rights Quarterly 452 (1989), April 23 found him at the Islamic comments on the attention being Alive!, and the San Francisco Center lecturing on current given to the study of human Examiner. In September 1989, she Middle East negotiations. rights today in the U.S.S.R. and presented the Rhonda R. Rivera Among the lectures he gave in the greater receptivity of the Humanitarian Award to Cynthia October were: "Legal Reform in U.S.S.R. to international Cecil Lazarus, Columbus City monitoring of human rights there. the U.S.S.R." at the OSU Center Councilwoman, at the Stonewall Following the end of the 1980- for Slavic & East European Studies; Union Annual Dinner. 1988 war between Iran and Iraq, "Apartheid in Columbus, Ohio On December 9, 1989, Professor the two countries held about and Southern Africa" at the OSU Rivera received the Annual Civil 100,000 prisoners. In "Iran and Black Studies Department; and Rights Award from the American Iraq and the Obligation to Release "Israel and the Palestinians" to the Civil Liberties Union of Ohio for and Repatriate Prisoners of War Peacemaking Committee of her tireless efforts for gay and After the Close of Hostilities," Covenant Presbyterian Church in lesbian civil rights and for persons found in Volume Five of the Columbus. with AIDS. She was further American University Journal of He attended a meeting of legal honored with a distinguished International Law (1989), Professor experts in humanitarian law in teaching and service award from Quigley argues that the two Geneva, Switzerland from May 28- the Society of American Law countries have an obligation to 31 aimed at finding ways to Teachers for her pioneering work release them, even if they are not encourage Iran and Iraq to release in bringing the concerns and yet able to come to terms on a the prisoners they hold from the perspectives of gay and lesbian peace treaty. Iran-Iraq war. Together with an teachers and students to the In 1989 the U.S.S.R. gave all Austrian sociologist and a retired attention of the law school privately-operated cooperatives and Italian deputy commander of community and for her invaluable all state-owned factories the right NATO, he conducted a fact­ contributions to the Society as one to export and import. Previously, a finding mission in and around of its former presidents. single ministry had done all Jerusalem from June 26-30 to Congratulations to Professor Rivera exporting and importing. 7 investigate measures taken by the for her hard work and dedication. International Tax and Business Lawyer government of Israel affecting the Professor Rivera also continues 275 (1989) contains an article, rights of Palestinian children in to speak to various groups on the "Legal Implications of the the Gaza Strip and West Bank in legal issues surrounding AIDS. In Dismantling of the Soviet Foreign the context of the Palestinian June 1989 she was a speaker on Trade Monopoly," in which uprising. the steps of Columbus City Hall to Professor Quigley discusses the In early November, he served as commemorate the Bowers v. meaning of this reform for the a judge in Bogota, Colombia on H ardwick decision, which denied United States corporations doing the Permanent People's Tribunal, a privacy rights to gay and lesbian business with the U.S.S.R. citizen inquiry into human rights persons. July found her behind Most analysts have said that the violations in Colombia. In the podium at a "Meeting with 25

Success" luncheon sponsored by dispute resolution and served as a David Williams, II was a the YWCA. At the University of panelist on "An Analysis of member of the American Bar Oklahoma College of Law Alternative Dispute Resolution Association's Special Delegation to Enrichment Program, Professor Legislation." the European Economic Rivera spoke on "The Challenge An excerpt from the book she Community for eight days during of AIDS to the Law." She has coauthored with Craig A. McEwen the month of October. He traveled lectured on AIDS legal issues to was published as an article, to Luxembourg, Belgium and the AIDS Educator Forum of "Mediation and the Unauthorized London to meet with senior Colleges and Universities of Ohio, Practice of Law," by M ediation officers of the European Economic on counseling AIDS clients on a Q uarterly in the spring issue. Community to discuss economic myriad of legal issues at a and legal policies. Cleveland Bar Education Center Michael D. Rose has several Professor Williams recently Continuing Legal Education recent publications to his credit, completed an article entitled, "Is it seminar titled, "Representing including the 1989 pocket part to Soup Yet? The Enterprise Zone People with AIDS," on "Legal the third edition of his hornbook Concept at the Federal Level. Are Issues for HIV Positive People" for (with the late John C. Chommie) Proposed Tax Incentives the the "Our Church Has AIDS" on Federal Income Taxation, the Needed Ingredient?," which has National Episcopal AIDS Coalition 1990 edition of Selected Federal been submitted for publication. in Cincinnati, on "HIV and AIDS: Taxation Statutes and Regulations, Professor Williams served on the Legal and Ethical Issues: A Live and the 1989 supplement to the University's Search Committee to Teleconference" sponsored by East Ohio Will Manual. select a new Vice Provost for Central AIDS Education and Professor Rose served last Minority Affairs. Additionally, he Training Center, on "Legal Issues summer as the Director of the was a member of the Advisory of AIDS" for a live teleconference Oxford Summer Law Program. He Board for the Black Studies' on "AIDS in the College organized the seventh annual OSU Extension Centers Spring Community" sponsored by the College of Law Estate Planning Conference on "Black Economic American College Health Conference held in May 1989 at Development." This University Association, and on the ethical Stouffer's Dublin Hotel, Dublin, group is planning the conference and legal issues of AIDS for a Ohio. His public speaking for early May 1990. Continuing Medical Education engagements have included a conference sponsored by Ohio speech to the Torch Club of Charles E. Wilson was a visiting Osteopathic Medicine. Columbus, Ohio, on "Tax Reform professor of law at the Brooklyn in the '80s: Rhetoric or Reality?" Law School fall semester. On Nancy H. Rogers has been November 8, 1989, he conducted a appointed by American Bar Thomas G. Spaith, Associate Association President L. Stanley Director of the law library, has faculty seminar for the Brooklyn Chauvin as Chair of the eleven- been elected treasurer of the Ohio Law School faculty on Negotiation member ABA Standing Committee Regional Association of Law Theory and Practice. He will be on Dispute Resolution. The Libraries (ORALL). His term of on sabbatical during the winter Committee's objectives are: to office will run from 1989 to 1991. semester 1990 completing a book provide comprehensive on the Ohio Rules of Civil clearinghouse services and D ouglas J. W h aley continues his Procedure that he is coauthoring technical assistance to all extensive textbook publications with Professors Howard P. Fink interested persons; to develop and with several new works. He and Arthur F. Greenbaum. carry out a plan for increasing recently completed the second He served as a faculty member state and local bar involvement; to edition of Problems and Materials on at the National Institute of Trial conduct legal, judicial, and public Commercial Law, to be published by Advocacy's Negotiation Workshop education programs; to develop Little, Brown later this year. The at the University of North law school curricula; and to second edition of Problems and Carolina School of Law from conduct research and Materials on the Sale and Lease of October 22-24, 1989. In September experimentation. The Governor's Goods will also be published in 1989 he made a presentation at Peace and Conflict Management 1990. In addition, he is working the West Liberty, Ohio Mennonite Church on the role of unions and Commission, for which she served on a newr casebook on Consumer as co-chair, recently approved its Law which Little, Brown has collective bargaining in a Final Report to Governor Celeste. contracted to publish in 1991. democratic society. At the annual meeting of the On the lighter side, Professor Later this winter, he will Society of Professionals in Dispute Whaley has signed a contract with conduct a Negotiations course for Resolution in Washington, D.C. in a literary agent in New York and The Ohio State University October, she moderated an Open expects to publish his novel, Continuing Legal Education Forum on the use of mandatory Frightening the Horses, in 1991. Program. 26 FACULTY NEWS

THE TAX REFORM ACT OF 1986: RHETORIC OR REALITY? . by Michael D, Rose, Professpr of Law

and they were brought about—or prevented President Reagan's at least made possible—through victory from being seen by the use of another rhetorical Congress as a mandate for reform. device, reference to the Angry Nonetheless, the image of the American Taxpayer, a somewhat Angry American Taxpayer mythical person who was a remained in the anxious minds of composite creation of Howard Congress and special interest Jarvis, Jimmy Carter, and Ronald groups. While the rhetoric of tax Reagan. reform was not a significant factor This person, the Angry in garnering support for American Taxpayer, was born to legislation, it caused a certain the middle class somewhere in hesitation among the opponents of California during the time of reform. Although tax reform never Proposition 13 and tax revolt. quite ignited the American people, Howard Jarvis said that this its supposed potential to do so taxpayer was "furious, taxed to the effectively kept opponents of the Michael D. Rose, Lawrence D. Stanley limit, politically volatile, mindful legislation at bay and, in this way, Professor of Law, spoke last year to the of his own power, and a real allowed its supporters to make the Torch Club of Columbus, Ohio. The danger to any politician who Tax Reform Act of 1986 the law of following are excerpts of his remarks. refused to act in his interest." the land. Professor Rose teaches the basic income Jimmy Carter said that this tax course, Corporate Taxation, and Has there been a change for the courses dealing with estate and business taxpayer was not only angry, but better? Before I deal with that planning. He has published three books on "ashamed" of the "disgraceful" question, consider some of the federal income taxation and each year federal income tax system because difficulties in evaluating tax edits a widely-used volume of selected it was so "complicated, arbitrary, reform. federal taxation statutes and regulations. and unfair." Ronald Reagan said The first difficulty is being able Professor Rose wishes to acknowledge the that the Angry American Taxpayer to get beyond a sort of pervasive significant contribution of Kay Ballard, a felt not only a "bitterness and suspicion and negativism that, second-year student at the College of Law frustration that was about to boil collectively, many people may feel during the 1988-1989 academic year, who over" but also "like the country's about any activity of Congress. transferred to the University of Iowa to be biggest chump." President Reagan near her family in Illinois. Even though the public might added that the system "corrupted profess to have an underlying honest people and encouraged esteem for its elected them to cheat...and to brag about representatives, the public is quite oes the Tax Reform Act of their cheating at social get- familiar and comfortable with a togethers." 1986 represent real reform characterization of members of or mere rhetoric? The While these descriptions may Congress either as well-meaning, D have resembled real American but inept, or as puppets of special phrase "tax reform" is itself a rhetorical device. Tax revision taxpayers, polling by the Reagan interests. Also, the public cannot means a change in the tax laws. campaign organization in 1984 help remembering that the laws Tax reform implies a change for revealed that voters were not being reformed were laws that the better, and it connotes eager for tax reform. While many Congress had passed in the first expressed a dissatisfaction with the place. impartiality, reasonability, and federal income tax system, most Syndicated columnist, David justice. Throughout the nation's were quite suspicious of the history nearly every change in the Broder, has suggested that with phrase "tax reform" and saw it as tax reform the public's suspicion tax laws has been promoted as a an euphemism for "tax increase." reform of the then current system. might be further fueled by the The Reagan campaign organization fact that the subject is not The Tax Reform Act of 1986 is decided that tax reform was not telegenic. We are, after all, a one of four revenue measures to an issue that would excite voters nation that receives much of the use the word "reform" in its and chose instead to use such news from television and since it name. We have also had the Tax themes as "Go for the gold!" and is nearly impossible to "see" tax Reform Acts of 1969, 1976, and "You ain't seen nothing yet." This reform, this may have caused the 1984. But the changes in the tax unwillingness to bring the issue of public to question whether it was laws in 1986 were extraordinary, tax reform into the 1984 campaign occurring. 27

Another problem in evaluating analysis of fairness in tax policy returns. For subjective measures, tax reform is that most individuals usually involves considerations of one might ask accountants or are taxpayers. It is difficult to be how the tax burdens should be lawyers whether the law is objective when one's own money shared by persons in different simpler or members of Congress is at stake. Senator Russell Long economic circumstances. whether constituents are said that tax reform means: "Don't Progressivity has had wide complaining less about the tax you. Don't tax me. Tax the acceptance in this country. Two complexity of the tax laws. fellow behind the tree." It is hard justifications for progressive Defining economic growth also to be favorably impressed by the taxation are that it is based on the poses problems. Some people elimination of a "loophole," if it ability to pay and that it reduces believe that this is best measured is one that we ourselves use. For economic disparities. by increases in the Gross National most people the answer to the Fairness should also consider the Product or decreases in the question: "Has there been tax treatment of persons in essentially unemployment rate. Others believe reform?" hinges on whether they the same economic circumstances. that economic growth should be are paying more or less in taxes This usually involves exploring measured by increased than before. Maybe this whether income should be treated expenditures for plants and shortsightedness is simply a differently based on its source or equipment. Some believe that this function of human nature. Perhaps what it represents and whether objective should be measured by it is an indictment of societal taxpayers should be treated determining whether investment greed. But it is not an unusual differently based on their decisions are more likely to be attitude when political candidates particular circumstances. based on economic factors and have encouraged people to cast There is no widely accepted test business considerations rather than their votes based on their own for evaluating improved simplicity on tax consequences. individual economic circumstances in the tax system. For seemingly In sum, an unbiased, by asking: "Are you better off objective measures, one might look comprehensive evaluation by today than you were four years to the number of words in the applying these three seemingly ago or eight years ago?" Internal Revenue Code or to the straightforward criteria is not A fourth problem in evaluating time required to prepare tax possible. tax reform is that even if a person is able to ignore the personal financial consequences of the legislation, that person is still making an evaluation from his or her own viewpoint. Concepts of GOLDBERGER HONORED social policy and order are either rofessor David A. Goldberger promoted or offended by the tax was honored on December 10 laws, and this naturally affects P for his courageous defense of one's judgment no matter how the first amendment in the Skokie hard he or she may strive for case during the late 1970s by the objectivity. American Civil Liberties Union of While these problems exist, it is Illinois. necessary to move beyond a Goldberger, who served as for­ negative, politicized, and self- mer staff counsel and then as Legal centered perspective and to apply Director of the ACLU of Illinois reasonable objective criteria for from 1967 to 1980, received the evaluating the Tax Reform Act of organization's Harry Kalven Award 1986. An obvious approach is to which honors those who have evaluate the Act based on the demonstrated. devotion . . . and , , dedi- , Professor____ Goldberger- receives Kalven , goals of fairness, simplicity, and cation to the principles of freedom Award from ACUf gf Illinois. economic growth, to which of expression. President Reagan referred in The ACLU's Freedom of Expression award is named for the late proposing an overhaul of the tax Harry Kalven, a University of Chicago law professor widely recognized laws. in thjs legal field as one of the giants of first amendment issues. Most people would probably say Following his death in 1974, the ACLU created the award to honor that making the tax system fairer those who have demonstrated Kalven's devotion to the principles of should be the major objective of freedom of expression. Goldberger, who graduated from the University improving the tax laws. This is of Chicago .Law School in 1967, was one of Kalven's students. extremely difficult to do, however, Congratulations, Professor Goldberger! because there is no general standard of fairness. A reasoned 28 STUDENT NEWS STUDENT LEADERS 1989-1990 tudents at the College of Law Patrick M. Dukes are a well-qualified, articulate and dynamic group of Law school was a natural choice S for Youngstown, Ohio native aspiring professionals. Many have advanced degrees and substantial Patrick M. Dukes, LIII. The work experience to bring to the Student Bar Association President study of law. All have a strong considers Ohio his home and he wanted to go to a large law school desire to understand the complex upon graduation from Youngstown environment in which lawyers State University in 1987, so Ohio attempt to use the tools they were State College of Law was the given in law school. In an effort perfect choice. "My three years to acquaint our readers with here at Ohio State have been the today's law students, we are most rewarding educationally, introducing some of the student especially in terms of the quality John W. Hopper leaders for the 1989-1990 academic of the faculty, staff and students," year. We hope to introduce you to Dukes stated. John W. Hopper had several other students who provide The summer after his first year years of work experience under helpful leadership throughout the found him clerking for the his belt before he came to law year in the next issue of the Law Columbus firm of Crabbe, Brown, school. Raised in East Liverpool, Record. Jones, Potts & Schmidt, a position Ohio, Hopper graduated in 1980 he obtained through the Minority from Mt. Union College, in Drew H. Campbell Clerkship Program. He enjoyed Alliance, Ohio, with a double the firm, and liked the challenge major in economics and finance. As editor-in-chief of the Ohio of insurance defense work. He went directly to the University State Law Journal, third-year Since the Minority Clerkship of Pittsburgh, where he earned an student Drew H. Campbell brings Program does not permit a student M.B.A. in 1981. a diverse background to the to return to a firm for a second After working in several College. After graduating in 1981 summer clerkship, Dukes elected different positions in both from Boston University School for to spend the next summer as a Pittsburgh and Columbus, he the Arts with a major in music, he law clerk for the Cleveland firm decided to go back to law school. played string bass for the Veracruz of Weston, Hurd, Fallon, Paisley & He has never regretted the Symphony in Southern Mexico for Howley, where he plans to work decision. Last year Hopper was a year. after graduation. "I found I really elected editor-in-chief of the He returned to the United States liked litigation, especially the Journal on Dispute Resolution, defense of medical malpractice commonly referred to as J.D.R. in 1982, and obtained a position claims." with the Columbus Symphony, for "J.D.R. provides a unique which his brother plays trumpet. Campbell served on the Orchestra Committee and assisted in negotiating a new contract for the players which ended a five and one-half month strike. He resigned from the symphony in 1987 to take up the study of law. "Having been out of school and coming back again, you have a different point of view. It helps to keep the whole academic experience in perspective," he observed. Upon graduation in May, he plans to clerk for the Honorable Joseph P. Kinneary, Senior Judge for the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio, Eastern Division. Drew Campbell, Monte Smith and John Hopper 29

opportunity for many students, and benefits the law school as DECEMBER HOODING well. We are all working very hard to assure the ongoing operation of the Journal." Hopper intends to head back to Pittsburgh after hooding to practice in the corporate finance section of the Buchanan Ingersoll law firm. "As rewarding as law school has been, the opportunity to go out and actually practice what I have learned is very exciting." Monte G. Smith Monte G. Smith, LIII, is the Chief Justice of the Moot Court Governing Board. A native of Granville, Ohio, Smith grew up in Graduates Gloria Bowman Washington, Marianne Mitchell, John Sheppard, Heidi Johnson- the shadow of Denison University Wright, Matthew Seyfang and Shila Fletcher Stoner but chose to attend Ohio State. He received a B.A. in English oinsettias added a touch of responsibilities will not be easy to Literature in 1986, and worked for holiday cheer to the Hooding discharge, but he cautioned young one year in the Communications Pceremony conducted on lawyers that the demands of the Department of Licking Memorial December 16 in the Moot profession should be balanced Hospital in Newark, Ohio. Courtroom. The ten candidates for with support for your family and "In my experience as Chief the Juris Doctor degree were: community. He also encouraged Justice of the Moot Court Gardner Jerry Combs the graduates to join increasing Governing Board, I have been numbers of alumni who give back consistently impressed by the Heidi Johnson-Wright Robin Edwina Lampkin to the College to enrich overall academic and writing skills opportunities for students that of the first-year students. It is Gregory Charles Luke follow. clear to me that Ohio State's Marianne K. Mitchell Professor Louis A. Jacobs efforts to recruit top students have Gregory Allen Price Matthew George Seyfang presented remarks on behalf of been successful/' remarked Smith. the faculty. He described the pride Central Ohio will remain John Bolling Sheppard each faculty member feels on Smith's home after graduation. He Shila Ann Fletcher Stoner Gloria Bowman Washington commencement day, having plans to work with the Columbus watched the students grow from office of Jones, Day, Reavis & Patrick M. Dukes, LIII, awestruck first-year students to Pogue after preparation for the bar welcomed the graduates, faculty, confident, competent legal exam. He looks forward to the and guests as President of the professionals. He then assisted firm's rotation program, and the Student Bar Association. He spoke Dean Beytagh and Assistant Dean opportunity to gain exposure to of the importance of considering Joanne Wharton Murphy '58 in many different areas of law. the "road not taken" and investing the purple hood of the challenged the graduates to take Juris Doctor on each participant. the personal and professional risks which will best serve the legal community. Dean Francis X. Beytagh added his welcome and introduced the hooding speaker, Robert M. Duncan/52, a former United States District Court Judge and partner with Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue. He spoke about the challenges each new lawyer will face as a member of the legal profession and as a responsible Hooding speaker Robert Duncan '52 poses member of society. Choices and with graduates. 30 STUDENT NEWS

1989 Graduates Accept John R. Paliga AndreUr G. Sykes Judicial Clerkships U.S. District Court for the U.S. District Court for the Western Northern District of Ohio/Toledo, In the past several years, the District of Pennsylvania/ Ohio Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania College of Law has encouraged its The Hon. John W. Potter graduates to seek judicial The Hon. Maurice B. Cohill (Chief clerkships upon graduation, and Roxanne O. Peach Judge) Franklin County Common Pleas has actively assisted them in Teresa A. Villareal obtaining these positions. The Court/Columbus, Ohio The Hon. Michael L. Close, Third District Court of Appeals of following is a list of the members The Hon. Dale A. Crawford Ohio/Lima, Ohio of the Class of 1989 who have obtained judicial clerkships: Lawrence D. Pollock The Hon. John R. Evans U.S. District Court for the Jack W. Whitesell Rachelle Cohen Southern District of Ohio/ U.S. Court of Appeals for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Cincinnati, Ohio Sixth Circuit/Cleveland, Ohio Ninth Circuit/Reno, Nevada The Hon. Carl B. Rubin (Chief The Hon. Proctor Hug, Jr. Judge) The Hon. Robert Krupansky Debra Colacci Kimberly R. Strong Susan E. Wuornien U.S. Bankruptcy Court/Columbus, Third District Court of Appeals of U.S. District Court for Alaska/ Ohio Ohio/Lima, Ohio Anchorage, Alaska The Hon. R. Guy Cole The Hon. Thomas F. Bryant The Hon. Andrew J. Kleinfeld Peggy W. Corn Supreme Court of Ohio/Columbus, Ohio Justice Craig Wright Wantuck Wins ASCAP Prize Philomena M. Dane U.S. District Court for the Eastern Congratulations are in order Absence of an American Moral District of Pennsylvania/ for Michael Sissine Wantuck, Right." Philadelphia, Pennsylvania LIII, who was recently awarded The Nathan Burkan Memorial The Hon. Louis H. Poliak the $500.00 First Prize in the Competition is sponsored Nathan Burkan Memorial Debra Ann Dixon annually by ASCAP in memory Office of Immigration Judge, Competition at The Ohio State of ASCAP's first General Executive Office of Immigration University College of Law. The Counsel, who died in 1936. The Review/Chicago, Illinois award was announced in awards, designed to stimulate August 1989 by Morton Gould, interest in the field of copyright James W. Harshaw, III President of the American U.S. Court of Appeals for the law, have been traditional at Society of Composers, Authors ASCAP since 1938. Third Circuit/Wilkes-Barre, and Publishers (ASCAP). The Pennsylvania Wantuck will also be The Hon. Max Rosenn winning essay is entitled, considered for one of five "Colorization and Copyright: National Prizes, ranging from Douglas Jennings Judicial Discomfort with the Tenth District Court of Appeals of $500.00 to $3,000.00. Ohio/Columbus, Ohio The Hon. Archer E. Reilly John W. Kennedy U.S. Bankruptcy Court/ Youngstown, Ohio The Hon. William T. Bodoh Marion H. Little, Jr. U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio/ Columbus, Ohio The Hon. Joseph P. Kinneary Todd McKenney U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio/Akron, Ohio The Hon. David D. Dowd, Jr. Jeffrey A. Moyer U.S. Bankruptcy Court/Grand Rapids, Michigan Professor Halpern, copyright law scholar, Michael Wantuck and Dean Beytagh. The Hon. James D. Gregg 31

carriers' thwarted attempts at entry into the center of Beijing, or IN THE SPOTLIGHT people power blockades aimed at stopping all troop (as well as their AK 47's) movements into town. I his installment of alumni "In Lsaw a kind of bravery and love the Spotlight" features two for freedom I am sure would have Tgraduates who have accepted brought tears to the eyes of the challenges of the world of Washington or any of America's international politics. Each has gives people the democracy and founding fathers. written a personal account of their freedom already delineated in the As I sat atop the Hero's adventures for publication in the Chinese Constitution. "You see, Monument in the center of Law Record, and the editor thanks Mitch, we are not so much Tiananmen Square on the first them for their efforts. interested in replacing our night of martial law and looked leadership as we are in simply out at the 500,000 or so Chinese Illusory Freedom forcing the government to follow quietly, almost eerily, waiting for the system that they have already troops to enter the square, I was created," he said to me in Chinese taken by their willingness to from the Beijing hotel where he sacrifice everything, including and other student leaders were in their own lives, in order to bring hiding. "If we replace the dictator, Mitchell Dudek '89 freedom and democracy to their we will still have a dictator, albeit country. I remember asking one a new one. No, what we need is Chinese naval academy student, freedom of the press and freedom who had become a good friend of for the masses." Liu Xiao Bo is mine over the duration of the now in a Chinese prison and has been labeled the "Black Hand" movement, what would happen if Mitchell Dudek is a 1989 the troops actually moved on graduate of the College of Law. He over the movement by the. authorities for his public speaking. Tiananmen Square that night. He has a B.S. and an M.B.A. from Texas replied with a tear in his eye, A&M University. This past spring he I can only pray that he will live long enough to see his ideas "We will die here." As I looked at was a student at Beijing University my friend, his mouth and nose and an eyewitness observer of the realized in China. In mid-May, after the protests covered with a gas mask and his short-lived pro-democracy movement. hands covered with rubber gloves He has taken classes at six different had gone on for nearly a month, I spoke with one of my old law in order to avoid burns from the Chinese universities over the past five expected initial attack of gas, I years and speaks Mandarin Chinese. professors from Beijing University about the slogans and chants of could not help but think that he These skills led to his employment as was one of the bravest persons, if an interpreter for CBS Evening News the people as well as the thoughts not the bravest person, I had ever covering the unfolding events in of the student leaders. He had been too afraid to go to met. Tiananmen Square. He shares some of Did my friend die in the his observations and experiences. Tiananmen Square for fear of losing his job, but was very massacre? I doubt if I will ever excited that the Chinese people know. But I do know the Chinese "Citizens of the People's were beginning to take hold of people have genuinely grasped Republic of China enjoy freedom the idea of a country governed by hold of the idea of freedom and of speech, of the press, of law rather than the thoughts of democracy and no government can assembly, of association, of the current leader. He believed contain those ideas forever. procession and of demonstration." even if the movement was not - Constitution of the People's successful at this time, the Mitchell Dudek has not been Republic of China, Article 35. people's minds have been opened deterred from his goal of mastering As an interpreter for CBS News to the idea of freedoms protected the Chinese language, culture and in Beijing during the recent pro­ by the government and ultimately laws. He is currently studying law in democracy movement in China, I those freedoms would be realized. Taiwan and looks ahead to a legal spent long hours on Tiananmen During the several months of career representing U.S. and other Square speaking with student the pro-democracy movement I foreign clients interested in trade and leaders. I remember Liu Xiao Bo, a virtually lived with camera crews business contacts on the mainland. young Beijing professor and at Tiananmen Square—except Despite the present curtailment of primary adviser to the protesting when we would make daily visits foreign business enterprise, Dudek students, explaining that what to such interesting events as tank believes the future is promising for a China needs is not so much a new processions in Beijing's western person with his education and government as a government that suburbs, armored personnel experience. 32 ALUMNI NEWS

The Rome Project Soviet Jews who had finally been impression on INS officials. By the granted permission to leave the time I left for Rome, I had seven Soviet Union as a result of new other cases that had come to me policies instituted by Mikhail through the pipeline of concerned Gorbachev concerning freer human rights activists in the Adrienne Lalak '78 emigration of Jews to the West. United States. My February visit to However, just as the "doors" Rome was a success—due to started opening in Russia, they several meetings at INS and began to close in this country. further correspondence with INS Last summer, then-Attorney officials upon my return, all eight General Edwin Meese had cases were ultimately approved for Adrienne C. Lalak graduated instructed the Immigration and refugee visas. from the College of Law in 1978. She Naturalization Service (INS) to I thought this adventure was is a partner with the Cleveland, Ohio begin requiring Soviet Jews to over, but I was wrong. Upon my firm of Kahn, Kleinman, Yanowitz & prove—by American evidentiary return to the United States, I was Arnson, maintaining an active standards—they had either litigation practice. besieged with telephone calls from suffered actual persecution as a other families and friends of result of their religion or had a hopeful Soviet emigres who were "POSITION AVAILABLE: An "well-founded fear thereof." By also refused refugee visas. international refugee relief late 1988, the INS office in Rome, In March, I was invited to organization is looking for an which receives the overwhelming experienced litigator to spend two Washington, D.C. to meet with months working in a desperately number of refugee applications leaders of national Jewish overcrowded office in a major from Soviet Jews because it is a organizations to explain how I had European capital handling applications regional refugee processing center succeeded where HIAS was failing, for refugee status and motions to in Europe, had begun rejecting and to participate in Congressional reconsider the denial of such numerous applications. The briefings sponsored by the applications. Russian-speaking client Hebrew Immigration Aid Society Committee on Security and base numbers approximately 10,000. (HIAS), a volunteer agency Cooperation in Europe (also Successful candidate will handle 100+ historically responsible for pending motions and backlog of known as the Helsinki Accords approximately 1000 cases and also shepherding Soviet Jews through Committee), chaired by Senator have training responsibility for the administrative labyrinth at DeConcini. existing staff, which have no legal INS, had protested the change in Most importantly, I was asked to training and primarily speak Italian. the Administration's policy but prepare a proposal for an No word processing, computer had done nothing at their Rome emergency legal advocacy project capabilities or library. Some secretarial headquarters to gear up to handle to be launched in Rome to tackle assistance available; prefer candidate cases in what had become an the ever-mounting numbers of with typing skills. SALARY: Small adversarial environment. My cases for which Motions to Reopen subsidy. Modest housing and round friend Misha, caught in the trip air will be provided to the were needed. (Since my return successful candidate. Reply in nightmare, called me from Rome from Italy in early February, the confidence to..." hysterical. so-called "refusal" rate had I did what any good lawyer climbed steadily, and by April As far as I know, this would have done: I looked at the 1989, a staggering 40% of all advertisement has never appeared INS regulations and determined refugee visa applications made by in any newspaper in the United that Motions to Reconsider and/or Soviet Jews were being rejected.) States. But the job did exist, and Reopen could be submitted to INS I sat in my hotel room and on April 14th I arrived in Rome, on the basis of affidavits drafted a proposal. Once refined, Italy to fill it. corroborating the claimed the proposal was circulated. By All lawyers have their own persecution. Within two weeks, I mid-March, the handwriting was amusing stories about being in had 22 affidavits; Misha had been on the wall: both the Union of either the wrong place at the a well-known Hebrew teacher in Councils for Soviet Jews, one of wrong time or the converse. This Leningrad, had actively solicited the leading advocacy organizations is mine. visits from American Jewish in the United States, and HIAS Last February, I went to Rome activists traveling in the Soviet itself wanted me to move to Rome. to help a Russian Jew, with whom Union and was, in fact, well I demurred. I waffled. I protested. I had become friends during two known to the United States-State I looked at my desk, my trial previous trips to the Soviet Union, Department as a Jewish dissident. calendar, my plants, my bank obtain a refugee visa for I sent the affidavits to INS in account. I looked at my fellow emigration to the United States. Rome and planned my trip, partners. My partners looked back. Misha had found himself in the thinking that a visit by an They nodded. They took over my same predicament as many other American lawyer would make an cases. They promised to send me 33 the minutes of partners' meetings the time of day when INS called) "Your motion in the Kaplan case by Federal Express and wished me from the bar downstairs. We was just granted. Family well. agonized over the cases I knew, as proceeding to NY before end of HIAS's Rome office was exactly a lawyer, could not be won month. Ciao..." Or a family as advertised, as was the case load. because of the absence of member in this country will With the invaluable assistance of a corroborative evidence or the telephone me to share the news. young woman from San Francisco direct submission to INS by And as soon as I recover from the whom the Union of Councils for anxious stateside relatives of excitement of knowing that, as a Soviet Jews had sent to Rome to inconsistent or flatly incorrect lawyer and a human rights be my executive assistant, we affidavits. We scoured our brains activist, I have made a difference tackled the case load. In early and experiences for ways of in the lives of people who had no May, the first of several volunteer solving complex evidentiary problems. advocacy until the "Rome Project," lawyers from the United States I do the only logical thing: have arrived; they came from Cleveland, When I left HIAS on June 14th, where the local Jewish Community many questions remained another cup of cappuccino. Federation was an active unanswered, including what (Post Script: The United States proponent of the “Rome Project," would happen to the 10,000 or so government has revised emigration and from New York. (Since my other Russian Jews—m y clients— procedures with the result that all return to Cleveland in late June, whom I had to leave behind when new applications are accepted and numerous other lawyers from the I returned to the almost decadent processed in Moscow. They already Cleveland area, as well as from luxury and order of a normal trial have applications now which, if New York, Minneapolis, San practice in the United States. But granted, would use up all of fiscal Francisco and Boston, have all every so often I receive a fax from year 1990's allocation of refugee slots volunteered to spend their HIAS Rome saying something like: (50,000).) vacations working at HIAS.) We worked 12 or 14 hours a day reviewing files; making requests of Alumni Enjoy Fourth Golf Outing volunteer lawyers and agencies in the United States to obtain lumni and friends of the College of Law defied the omens to tee off for the Fourth Annual College of Law Golf Outing on Friday, October corroborative affidavits from 13. 75 degrees and breezy, the weather seemed more like October in applicants' stateside friends and A Florida than Ohio. family members; meeting with and After a beautiful afternoon, the scores were tallied and the following lucky comforting applicants during alumni were in the prize pool: interviews and otherwise. I met Low N et...... Bill Grim '74 regularly with Robert Eddy, the Low Net Runner U p...... Bob W inningham '54 Officer-in-Charge at INS, to Low Gross (Tie)...... Bob W atkins '53 and M ike M ahoney '72 discuss cases and present Best Female Player...... Mary Ellen Fairfield '73 humanitarian pleas in situations Closest to Pin on # 4 ...... Ray Cunningham '50 Longest Drive on ttlO ...... Carl Sm allwood '80 where serious health problems Longest Putt on ft 15...... Frank Bazler '53 required special consideration. The ever-growing community in Next year's Outing is planned for Columbus Day, October 8, 1990. We hope Ladispoli, the Roman suburb all this will enable still more of our alumni to get in one last game before hanging but taken over by Russian Jews, up the clubs for the winter. Please feel free to contact Dean Joanne W. Murphy sent a delegation of leaders to or Jenifer Bernard Rasor with questions, comments or ideas. meet with me on a biweekly basis. In our "spare time," we installed a computer-based case tracking system and trained dozens of case M* m l workers in the fine arts of witness preparation and client interviewing. Slowly but surely we chipped away at the case load, celebrating victories (such as obtaining a refugee visa for the man who had been forcibly tattooed with crosses on his legs as retaliation for being circumcised) with wonderful cups Golfers in the prize pool, left to right: Watkins, Fairfield, Bazler, Grim, Winningham, of cappuccino or bottles of Mahoney and Cunningham. (Not pictured is Smallwood.) excellent red wine (depending on 34 ALUMNI NEWS

CLASS REUNIONS REUNITE FRIENDS all is an exciting time on the OSU Columbus campus with Class of 1939 Freturning students, tailgate parties, football games and alumni activities. With the support of class coordinators the Office of Alumni Relations organizes some nine to ten reunions annually, primarily during the fall. Over 1,000 alumni in nine graduating classes were contacted over the spring and summer and encouraged to share some OSU activities and memories at fall reunions. The College is grateful to those who expressed their continuing interest in associations with former classmates, friends and faculty. September 16 Class of 1949 The weekend of the Annual Alumni Return, four classes organized reunion activities. Special celebrations and recognitions were in store for the Class of 1939, who gathered at the Great Southern Hotel for their reunion dinner on Saturday, September 16. Coordinators were Ruth Kessler, John S. Mitchell, Paul F. Ward and G eorge D. Young. Ohio classmates welcomed Wilford H. Heaton from San Antonio, TX and B ernard S. Schrager from South Bend, IN. Dean Beytagh honored each of the 17 reunioners with a Fifty-Year Certificate and gave a toast for many more returns. Class of 1954 The Class of 1949 joined the 50 year celebrants at the Great Southern Hotel the same evening. Eighteen class members and spouses from around Ohio enjoyed an evening of recollections and good conversation. On the north side of Columbus, two class reunion groups gathered at the University Parke Hotel. John M. Adams and Stan B. Schneiderman helped organize and plan a successful Class o f 1954 reunion for 28 classmates plus their spouses. The events of the evening were recorded by videotape and subsequently made 35 available to all classmates. Two classmates, R o b e rt E. M cG in n is and his wife Jane and M aurice L e w itt and his wife Kim, returned from California to see friends and revisit Columbus. The excited greetings of friern of the Class of 1984, celebrating their first class reunion at the University Parke Hotel as well, were heard throughout the evening. Reunion organizer K aren Riestenberg Brinkman was successful in turning out 80 classmates, spouses and friends for the event. Classmates returning from out of state included Brent D. Benjamin, Charleston, WV, David H. Braff, New York, NY, Judy Monastra Davis, Fort Wayne, IN, Robert W. Dibert, Louisville, KY, Anne M. Donnelly, Brooklyn, Class of 1964 NY, P aul T. H o yin g , Charlotte, NC, Eric F. Kleinfeld, Washington, D.C., Olinda Moyd, Washington, D.C., P ierre W. P riestley, Chicago, IL, N e il P. S tern , Chicago, IL, K aren S. T im ko, Pittsburgh, PA and B rent A . T itus, Lansing, MI. October 14 Three classes decided to hold their reunion on the evening of the OSU v. Indiana football game. The classes spread out in various locations. The Class of 1964, coordinated by Duke W. Thomas, met for dinner at the Columbus Athletic Club. 24 classmates plus spouses enjoyed an evening of Class of 1969 stories, catch-up and a good party. The traveling contingent included Peter G. Eikenberry, New York, NY, Albert S. Tabor from Houston, TX, Donald R. Wheeler, Towaco, NJ and Janice E. W olfe, Alexandria, VA. The Class of 1969 produced another, successful reunion through the efforts of D a v id S. Bloomfield, Michael G. Long, Jack R. Pigman and W alter W. R eckless. The group held a brunch at the Faculty Club prior to the football game and then the old gang gathered at Schmidt's Sausage Haus for an informal buffet. The Class of 1969 "In Retrospect" was presented by 36 ALUMNI NEWS

David Bloomfield, as an humorous reminder of the movies, music, Class of 1974 people and events of the late 1960s. Over 40 classmates, many with their spouses, came from around Ohio to enjoy the reunion. Lee I. Turner and his wife, Sue, drove south from Southfield, MI for the occasion. The Class of 1974, with the special efforts and attention of Susan Garner Eisenman and William A. Grim, threw a special party at the Great Southern Hotel with hors d'oeuvres, a dinner buffet and their own 1970's D.J. music. Over 50 classmates and their spouses enjoyed the evening. Professor Larry Herman was their special guest. The reunion travelers were Shelley J. Venick, Class of 1959 Evanston, IL, Stephen R. Schmidt, Louisville, KY, Lois G. Williams, Washington, D.C. and Laurie A. Young, Indianapolis, IN. October 21 and November 4 The final two reunions of the season were the Class of 1959, coordinated by A lb e r t L. Bell, and the Class of 1979, coordinated by Bruce A. Niswander. The Class of 1959 met for dinner at the University Parke Hotel on Saturday, October 21. Twenty- seven classmates with their spouses shared the evening. They were joined by Joseph J. Baronzzi, Marco Island, FL, Albert W. Eoff, Class of 1979 II, Alexandria, VA, W illiam P. M eehan, Fort Myers, FL, P eter P. R osato, Yonkers, NY and D on ald H. W augh, Columbia, MD. The Class of 1979 stepped back in time on Saturday, November 4 with a party on the Street of Yesteryear at the Center of Science and Industry. A rock and roll band added a modern touch, and over sixty-eight classmates and guests enjoyed the refreshments and hors d'oeuvres while renewing old ties. Many thanks to the coordinators and all returning alumni who made this reunion season a resounding success. 37

CLASS OF 1939 REUNION The freshman law students of circumstances, we did manage to ______by Ruth M. Kessler '39 1989 will envy the 1937 fees, but have three good years in law not much else. In 1937 to make a school. In June 1939, 67 of us n September 1937, 123 copy of a decision meant to sit graduated ifrom The Ohio State freshman law students came down and write it long hand. University College of Law. Now Ifrom 56 different cities in Ohio There were no copy machines. To in 1989, 50 law classes later, the and 9 cities from out of Ohio to find a citation meant searching Law School has outgrown the their first day of class in Page digests, casebooks or texts. There "new law building." Each class Hall. Page Hall became their home were no computerized legal and each student has contributed for the next three years, and their retrieval systems. In 1937 the law in their own way to the quality mentors were Dean Herschel library consisted of 40,000 volumes and current rating of the College Arant, Robert Mathews, Silas with little access to other legal of Law. There are now 600 law Harris, Harry Vanneman, John resources. In 1989 on-line catalogs students enrolled and 37 full-time Hallen, Norman Lattin, Robert make available the material in faculty. There are two law Hunter, William Rose, Arthur nearly every other law library in journals, moot court programs, Martin, and Frank Strong. the United States. clinical programs, joint degree In 1937, fees were $35 per In 1937 there was no television, programs, plus many student' quarter for a resident of Ohio and no VCR, no CD players, but for activity groups. Consequently the $85 for a non-resident. In 1989, relaxation and entertainment there College has outgrown the current fees are $1,776 a semester for Ohio was "downtown" Columbus. There building and is planning a new residents and $4,274 for non­ were the Ohio and Palace movie addition to be completed by 1992, residents. In 1937 the estimated theatres. There was music and the Centennial of the College of expenses for a law student for one dancing at the Neil House and the Law. However, the association of year, including tuition, were $448 Deshler. In 1937 drugs were law school for the Class of 1939 for men and $475 for women. The aspirin or other headache remedies will always be Page Hall and the difference was in the cost of you took before going to class. reminiscences each of us has of dormitory rooms. In 1989 the Fast food was opening a can of those days. We enjoyed sharing estimated living expenses for a soup and eating it without waiting our memories and celebrating our law student for one year is $5,484, to heat it. continuing good fortunes on the plus tuition. But in spite of our deprived evening of September 16.

DEAN STRENGTHENS TIES insights into the progress of legal College of Law are fundamental to education." the future of this institution," Often accompanied by D arlene Beytagh remarked. J. Brown, Director of Placement, or John R. Meyer, Director of Alumni Requests ne of the priorities of D ean Development, the Dean attended Francis X. Beytagh's College-organized luncheons and/ The Alumni Office will continue administration has .been, or receptions this fall in New to coordinate alumni activities O around the travel plans of the and continues to be, the further York City, Chicago, Cleveland, improvement of alumni relations. Indianapolis, Washington, D.C., Dean and faculty. Alumni are also To this end, the Dean instituted a Miami, and San Francisco. encouraged to initiate contacts program of alumni meetings in The gatherings have provided with Dean Beytagh or Assistant conjunction with his travels to get alumni with the opportunity to Dean Joanne W. Murphy to to know our alumni on a more meet other attorneys in the same request special visitations and personal basis. "This type of city as well. Some have discovered programs for College alumni in informal interaction is very they were living a few blocks their local communities. Such important to me and to the law away from a former classmate and combined efforts will help achieve school," stated Beytagh. "Our never knew it! "We would like to our goal of more extensive alumni are a vital group of extend our thanks to those alumni personal communication with professional and community who attended the receptions. Their alumni throughout Ohio and the leaders who provide unique interest in, and support of, the country. 38 ALUMNI NEWS

ALUMNOTES ’ ^ ^ 7 Carter C. Kissel I is still enjoying one f C fZ Robert L. Hill, assistant vice presi- ticle for his pioneering work in citizenship Jim / of his favorite pastimes, fly fishing, C / w /dent of law and public affairs fot the education. He and his wife, Norma, created around his northeast Ohio home. Aetna Life & Casualty Company of Hartford, the "Citizenship Education Instructional Connecticut, has been appointed chairperson Guide" to encourage young schoolchildren to f ^ / \ Carl C. Tucker continues his contacts of the Law in the Public Service Committee understand the rules of American society. vJTlw ith the College as an honorary of the Tort and Insurance Practices Section Their work has been commended by the Ohio member of the College of Law National of the American Bar Association. Addition­ State and American Bar Associations. Council. ally, he will serve as senior vice chairperson Benjamin L. Zox is currently serving as of the Alternative Dispute Resolution president of the Columbus Bar Foundation. ' * 5 C William K. Thomas received the Ohio committee. J E state Bar Foundation Award for Out­ ^ £Z 9 Jacob E. Davis, II, has been inducted standing Research in Law or Government on t C * 7 Richard L. Loveland has been elected v v Jin to the Columbus Bar Foundation. N ovem ber 10, 1989. Congratulations! c / / to the C olum bus Bar Foundation board Michael B. Hendler, of Blakemore, Rosen, of trustees for a one-year term. Meeker and Varian, took office July 1, 1989 ^ O Ed ward J. Cox, Sr. remains in private as president of the Akron Bar Association. ^ practice doing appellate work with ' C Ci John T. Brown was recently awarded the Columbus firm of Cox and Cox, a firm w sO an Honorary Life Fellowship from f CZ A Thomas J. Moyer, Chief Justice of he has shared with his son, Edward, Jr., since the Ohio State Bar Foundation for dedication U T tth e Supreme Court of Ohio, was ap­ his son graduated from the University of and service to the community and the legal pointed by American Bar Association Presi­ Michigan's law school in 1972. profession. As a principal in the Mansfield dent L. Stanley Chauvin to the ABA Standing Paul F. Ward has been inducted into the firm of Brown, Bemiller, Murray & McIntyre, Committee on Dispute Resolution. Columbus Bar Foundation. he has developed expertise in areas including Warren L. JJdisky published, "The Business negligence law, insurance, and litigation. Judgement Rule in Ohio in Connection with ' Charles £ Connor has kept busy, even Congratulations! Change in Corporate Control," in the No­ Tfcvlin retirement. While in Florida for David A. Ward, formerly senior vice pres­ vember 1989 issue of the Ohio State Bar As­ the winter, he is active in an advisory group ident, general counsel and secretary of Ow­ sociation Corporate Counsel Section Newsletter. representing migrant workers. ens-Illinois, Inc., has joined the Toledo firm He remains in active practice with Benesch, of Robison, Curphey & O'Connell. As counsel, Friedlander, Coplan & Aronoff in Cleveland, ^ J\ Russell Leach currently serves as a he will practice general corporate law, spe­ Ohio. jf c 7 ju d g e for the C ourt of Claims of Ohio. cializing in mediation. He also serves as chair of the Ohio Supreme Court Committee on f £Z fC.£ Lawrence spoke on "The f\Philip R. Bradley continues his civil Dispute Resolution and as a member of the UxJEm ployment Relationship - Compen­ w /V litigation practice as a partner with Ohio Commission on Dispute Resolution and sation and Benefits" at a Cincinnati CLE pro­ the Columbus firm of Bradley and Farris. Conflict Management. gram on Employment Law for the General Raymond P. Cunningham recently re­ Practitioner. ceived the Columbus Bar Association Bar ï C Û Clark "Moose" Miller is vice presi- David P. Rupp, Jr. is the District 3 Rep­ Services Award in recognition of his long w /^dent/security director of Great Amer­ resentative to the Ohio State Bar Association history of service to the bar, including the ican Bank in San Diego, California. He is also Executive Committee. He is a principal with offices of CBA and Columbus Bar Foundation a legal instructor at the Institute of Finance the Archbold firm of Plassman, Rupp, Hensal president. He currently serves on the Colum­ Education in San Diego. an d Short. bus Bar Foundation board of trustees. Warren J. Smith is chairman of the In­ dustrial Commission of Ohio in Columbus. ' CZCZjames H. Bradner, Jr. is assistant gen- ^ C 1 Richard H. Oman is the head of the U U e ra l counsel for the Alliance of Amer­ J J . probate and trust department at Por­ ’ £ \ \ Michael E. Moritz, partner with the ican Insurers in Schaumburg, Illinois. ter, Wright, Morris & Arthur in Columbus, U JL Columbus office of Baker & Hostetler, and legal counsel to the Columbus Founda­ has been named the firmwide business area Gerald Office, Jr., former chairman tion, a nonprofit organization. chair. / of Ponderosa, has begun a new family restaurant chain, Traditions, based in Mo­ ' C ^ Charles £ Brown remains a trial law- raine, Ohio. His newest endeavor was fea­ U Amyer with the Columbus firm of Crabbe, tured in a N ovem ber 18, 1989 New York Times Brown, Jones, Potts & Schmidt. One of his article. sons, Jeffrey M. Brown '79, practices with Myron Shwartz has become of counsel to the firm as well. Evans, St. Clair & Kelsey, Columbus. William A. Levelle, of Athens, Ohio, has been named the District 17 Representative for t fZ Q Betsey Brewster Case is now with the Executive Committee of the Ohio State ^J^Jthe Cleveland office of Thompson, Bar Association. Hine & Flory. Jay £ Eckhaus has joined Alfa-Laval, Inc., f C *5 Thomas £ Cavendish was recently in Fort Lee, New Jersey, as its general counsel. elected chair of The Ohio State Uni­ Michael P. Graney, of Simpson, Thacher versity Presidents Club Executive Committee. & Bartlett, was named a fellow of the Co­ He serves as vice president of the Columbus lumbus Bar Foundation. Bar Foundation as well. Michael J. Hickey has been admitted to Michael E. Moritz 61 Robert J. Watkins passed the ceremonial partnership in the Columbus office of Squire, gavel to classmate Cavendish after serving Sanders & Dempsey. He is in the firm's labor the maximum amount of time allowed on the ' £Z O Donald A. Davis, a partner w ith Arter practice area, specializing in workers' com­ Executive Committee of the Presidents Club— Hadden, has been named a Colum­ pensation law. two consecutive terms. After 33 years with bus Bar Foundation fellow. Charles J. Kegler is the new secretary/ Procter & Gamble, Watkins retired in June Michael R. McKinley, Ashland County treasurer of the Columbus Bar Foundation. and joined the Cincinnati office of Porter, Probate and Juvenile Court Judge, was rec­ He is a principal with the Columbus firm of Wright, Morris & Arthur on August 1. ognized in a recent Cleveland Plain Dealer ar­ Emens, Hurd, Kegler & Ritter. 39

f /Z f \S a llv W. Bloomfield was recently * 5 Stephen C. Fitch has been named a baum, Boone, Treitz, Maggiolo, Reisz & Brown. voted to the board of trustees of the / J fellow of the Columbus Bar Foun­ Michael J. Fusco is a principal with the Columbus Bar Foundation. She will receive dation. He is a partner with the Columbus Westerville, Ohio firm of Fusco & Ison. the 1990 YWCA Women of Achievement firm of Szolosi & Fitch. Ronald S, Kopp was elected to a three-year Award in March. Mary Jane Goldthwaite has become of term on the Akron Bar Association Executive Jeffrey E. Fromson, former general counsel counsel to Schottenstein, Zox & Dunn, Co­ Committee. He is a Roetzel & Andress partner. and corporate secretary for Converse, Inc. of lumbus. Goldthwaite is a former vice presi­ Melodee S. Kornacker is of counsel to the Boston, has returned, to his hometown of Co­ dent, chief administrative officer, general law firm of Casey, McFadden & Winner in lumbus, Ohio to become a partner in the law counsel and secretary of Chemlawn Columbus. firm of Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan & Corporation. Aronoff. f Çyf\Pamela I. Hanover has been admitted Michael G. Long has been inducted into 4 Janice M. Bernard has been named O x /to partnership with Squire, Sanders the Columbus Bar Foundation. He maintains / Jta partner with Squire, Sanders & & Dempsey. A member of the National As­ an active practice with Vorys, Sater, Seymour Dempsey. She joined the firm in 1981 and is sociation of Bond Lawyers, Hanover practices & Pease. a member of the Columbus office's litigation public law in Cleveland. Thomas J. Riley, a partner of Riley & Lav- practice group. Craig R. Mayton has resigned as Upper insky, has consolidated his practice with the Arlington City Attorney, and has begun pri­ Cleveland and Columbus firm of Hahn Loeser f ^ 7 C Frederick M. Gittes continues his vate practice with the Columbus office of & Parks under the name Hahn Loeser & Parks, / Jw o rk in public interest law with the Reminger & Reminger. A trial lawyer, Mayton Columbus, Ohio. Columbus firm of Spater, Gittes & Terzian. will concentrate his practice on the defense Recently he was elected to the Columbus Bar of personal injury, medical malpractice, and f r j Charles F. Freiburger, IV was elected Foundation. product liability cases. / v ia fellow of the Columbus Bar Foun­ Patricia G. Roberts has received the Jurist Carolyn S. M elvin was recently named a dation, much to the pleasure of his associates Teacher of the Year Award at Wake Forest, fellow of the Columbus Bar Foundation. She at Bricker & Eckler. where she is an associate professor teaching continues her employment with BancOhio /. Frederick Gatzke accepted a labor coun­ Estates, Torts, and Legal Research and Writ­ National Bank. sel position with Motorola, Inc., in September ing. Congratulations! 1988. He currently resides in Scottsdale, ' Q "f Richard D. Brown has become a part- Arizona. Mark S. Coco has joined the Colum- O A ner in the Columbus firm of Den- Ronald L. Solove, a judge of Franklin / / bus firm of Jones & Troyan. mead, Blackburn & Willard. Litigation and oil County Municipal Court, joined classmate and gas law are the primary areas of his Freiburger as a Columbus Bar Foundation * ^ 7 Q John W. Cook serves as Bricker & practice. fellow. / OEckler's administrative partner, the liaison between staff and the managing part­ f T J ' f Susan E. Brown coauthored an article ner, as well as chair of the firm's Opinion / JL w ith A m y H. Geis '88 entitled, “SEC Letter Committee and coordinator of new as­ Alumni Directory Examines Management's Discussion and sociate orientation. Analysis — Traditional Disclosures Do Not Michael S. Crane has become of counsel In Progress Measure Up," in the November 1989 issue of to Schottenstein, Zox & Dunn, Columbus. the Ohio State Bar Association Corporate Counsel Nora E. Jones joins classmate Crane as of Progress continues on The Section Newsletter. In addition to her respon­ counsel to Schottenstein, Zox & Dunn, Ohio State University College of sibilities as a partner in the Columbus office Columbus. Law Alumni Directory, which of Vorys, Sater, Seymour & Pease, Brown con­ Kristine A. Roth has been given a year's we expect to be completed by ducted a Course on Regulation of Securities leave from the Internal Revenue Service to Distribution as an adjunct professor at the participate in a special agent-in-residence pro­ late spring. Harris Publishing College of Law during the fall semester. gram coordinated with Cornell University Law Company, our publisher for this School. As a visiting professor at Cornell, she project, has nearly concluded is teaching Taxation of Partnership Income, the process of collecting and International Taxation, and Tax Practice and Procedure. Roth has worked with the IRS verifying the information about since 1978, and is currently senior trial at­ each graduate that will appear torney with the Washington branch office in the Directory. Most of our where she directs all phases of litigation be­ alumnae/i have already been fore the United States Tax Court. She has contacted by telephone, and this received special achievement awards from the IRS in 1986, 1987, and 1988, and is one of stage of production should be three IRS attorneys selected to participate in finished in a few weeks. this special loan program. Since graduation The new Directory will from Ohio State, Roth has found time to earn include information about our an LL.M. in taxation from Georgetown as Susan E. Brown '71 well. graduates, now numbering over 6,500, and will commemorate ^ 7 O William L. Kovacs has moved from Q Tames H. Becht has remained with the College's forthcoming / Jm¡the east coast to the west to assume / Deere & Company since law school Centennial. his new position with the Portland, Oregon graduation. His current position is chief coun­ To those of you who have firm of Dunn, Carney, Allen, Higgins & sel to John Deere Credit Company in Moline, Tongue. Illinois. participated, thanks for your John H. Lahey has moved even further! Thomas C. Fenton has joined First Ken­ support. If you have not He is now with the Hong Kong office of tucky National Corporation in Louisville, received any information, Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue. Kentucky as vice president and counsel, with please contact the College of Alan T. Radnor, a partner with Vorys, Sa­ responsibilities including employment rela­ Law as soon as possible as the ter, Seymour & Pease and adjunct professor tions and discrimination law, litigation, and of law at the College of Law, has been elected commercial loan transactions. He was for­ deadline is fast approaching. to the Columbus Bar Foundation. merly a partner with the law firm of Greene 40 ALUMNI NEWS

Guy L. Reece, II was elected this past No­ J\ Judith Monastra Davis has been ap- f 43 CD Peter J. Albert has accepted a position vember to the Franklin County Municipal pointed assistant general counsel in Court bench. Congratulations! O O a s a corporate attorney with Progres­ the law division of Lincoln National Cor­ sive Casualty Insurance Company in poration, the nation's seventh largest holding Cleveland. ! Q ^ Jeffrey Fort has left Marathon Oil company whose subsidiaries are engaged pri­ Jeifrey J. Helmick is in sole practice with ^¡»Company to practice environmental marily in insurance and investment services. an association of independent attorneys, Ka­ law with the Toledo, Ohio firm of Shumaker, She specializes in the areas of computer and plan, Richardson, Rost & Helmick, in Toledo, Loop & Kendrick. employment law. Ohio. He is working primarily in criminal Randolph H. Freking was named a partner Richard G. Hornig is employed by the law defense and plaintiff's personal injury in Frost & Jacobs, Cincinnati, effective No­ firm of Madigan & Scott in Springfield, litigation. vem ber 1, 1989. Virginia. Thomas A. Hampton has become a partner Bruce C. Lazear has been appointed to a ' Q Q Yvonne L. Blauvelt is em ployed w ith with Yoss, Starr & Hampton in Barnesville, one year term as legal counsel to the Colum­ U Zr the Columbus firm of Schrim, Henry O hio. bus Jaycees. He is an associate with the Co­ & G reenw ald. William J. Leibold has become a partner lumbus firm of Luper, Wolinetz, Sheriff & Marc Matlock is serving a judicial derkship in the newly-formed law firm of Chernesky, Neidenthal where he specializes in corporate with the Michigan Court of Appeals in Heyman & Kress located in Dayton, Ohio. law, including mergers and acquisitions. Lansing. was recently elected a David K. Liberati Pamela Parsons Fowler m arried Scott Fow­ Kenneth H. Wine received an honorable partner in Sommer, Solovan, Piergallini & ler '84. They live with their daughter, Lor­ mention from the Inter-American Bar Asso­ Liberati, a law firm in Martins Ferry, Ohio. raine Elise, in Canfield, Ohio. ciation for his paper entitled, "Self-Deter­ a newly-named member David H, Meade, mination and Latin America: A Proposal of the Columbus firm of Isaac, Brant, Ledman r Q C Beverly J. Farlow, former legal coun- Seeking Inter-American Peace." & Becker, has served as state legal advisor O ^ Jse l and associate executive director of for all Ohio MADD chapters since 1988. the Ohio Association of Secondary School Michael M. Schmidt was named a member Administrators, has joined the Columbus firm Order of the Coif of the law firm of Schottenstein, Zox & Dunn of Artz, Dewhirst & Farlow as a partner. The following graduates from the in July 1989. Elizabeth A. Whiteside is deputy general Carol I. Tenyak has been named vice pres­ counsel to the environmental consulting firm Class of 1989 have been elected to ident and counsel of LaSalle National Cor­ of Geraghty & Miller in Dublin, Ohio. She the Order of the Coif: poration, a six-bank holding company. She most recently was an associate with the New has also found time to complete the M.B.A. York City law firm of Shearman and Sterling. Judith A. Clausing James M. Mattimoe program at Northwestern University's J.L. Rachelle Cohen Lawrence W. Kellogg Graduate School of Management. f O fZ Perry M. Chappano has returned to Kevin T. Connor Mitchell O vC olum bus to practice international Philomena M. Dane Patrick J. Mulligan t o * ) Linda J. Fisher has been confirmed corporate and tax law with the law firm of Michael Dubetz Jack R. Rosati, Jr. O v^by the United States Senate as the Carlile, Patchen, Murphy & Allison. Sylvia L Gillis Jeffrey S. Schira assistant adm inistrator for pesticides a n d toxic Barbara A. Farnbacher has moved to the Dodd J. Gray Donna B. Owens substances of the U.S. Environmental Protec­ Ohio Public Defender Commission from the James W. Stokes tion Agency. She had been assistant admin­ Franklin County Public Defenders' Office. Her Harsh aw, III Mark S. Tibberts istrator for policy, planning and evaluation work is primarily appellate and post-convic- Jonathan D. Henry Robert A. Wade at the EPA since January 1988. tion criminal defense litigation. Elisabeth A. Keller Susan E. Wuorinen D. Wesley Newhouse has been named a Marion H. Little, Jr. Deborah M. Yoon partner in the law firm of Lane, Alton & f Thomas E. Berry, Jr., returned home Horst, Columbus. O / to St. Louis to practice labor law with Mitchell A. Weisman, of the Cleveland McMahon, Berger, Hanna, Linihan, Cody & firm of Weisman, Goldberg, Weisman & Kauf­ M cCarthy. man, was recently involved in a medical mal­ Barry L. Breslow finished his clerkship with IN MEMORIAM practice case with an $8 million verdict. United States District Court Judge Howard The College of Law regrets to report the Apparently, this is the second largest verdict D. McKibben in Reno, Nevada, and is now following deaths among its alumni: ever obtained in the State of Ohio in a med­ associated with the Reno litigation firm of ical malpractice case. Robison, Belaustegui, Robb and Sharp. In June Michael H. Austin '23; Peter M. Mizenko 1989 he married Susanne Hauer of Linz, Aus­ '27; Americus G. Lancione '29; William E. tria, a fashion designer and model. He has Bailey '31; N oel F. George '32; John M. McElroy become an avid skier, and would welcome '32; Richard Backus '34; Edward D. Harbert Bosch Foundation Fellowship the chance to teach any of his former class­ '36; Jack M. Parrish '36; John E. Harmon '39; To strengthen the ties of friendship and mates who would happen to be in the Lake Richard L. O ldham '39; Edw in R. Jonas, Jr. understanding between the United States Tahoe area. '40; M. William Tyrrell '42; Thomas A. White and the Federal Republic of Germany, the Monica Gfoeller is a labor counsellor for '48; Charles B. Ballou '49; John G. Beyoglides Robert Bosch Foundation annually sponsors XVIII Airborne Corps and Fort Bragg. Re­ '49; Joseph S. Deutchle, Jr. '50; Andrew R. an intensive work/study Fellowship cently married, she resides with her husband Sarisky '52; Donald A. Gibeaut '59; James J. Program in West Germany. The program in Durham, North Carolina. Kozelek '62; James R. Scott '62; J. D ennis aims to provide young American Jay E. Jadwin has moved to American Elec­ Burns '64; Robert B. Watson '76; Theodore T. professionals and executives with a tric Power, Columbus, as a member of the Schuld '82; Sylvia S. N eff '84 comprehensive overview of the political, in-house legal staff. He will be working pri­ economic, and cultural environment of marily in the real estate area. The College of Law regrets to report the Europe, and especially West Germany. Anastasia N. Markakis is an associate with following deaths among its associates: Alumni of The Ohio State University the firm of Katten Muchin & Zavis in Chi­ James C. Kirby, Jr., Dean from 1970-1974; College of Law are encouraged to contact cago, Illinois. N ancy R hoden, A ssistant Professor from 1982- Associate Dean Gregory M. Travalio for 1987; and Olive Busick, Assistant to the Dean more information. w ho retired in 1966. U.S. SUPREME COURT ADMISSION

As announced in the last issue of the Law Record, the College of Law has scheduled a group admission to the United States Supreme Court for Monday, May 21, 1990. To be eligible for admission, an applicant must have been admitted to practice in the highest court of a state, territory, district, commonwealth, or possession for the three years immediately preceding the date of application, and it must appear to the Court that the applicant is of good moral and professional character. Each applicant also mult currently be Jn good standing in the state or lower court bar from which he or sh^sggfes^m ^ien. Dean Beytagh ^will move the group's admission. Participant^^rfbe^^m^dntT^omplete applications for admission. ^ 11 fit tF IffS! The adniif£i^§ fee is $100.00, ap^He&sfkl^md|be made paya^e U.S. Supreme\cyu^p Pl^s^sopd compfëfe We have a ^hisxeremonyfe-^Éherefore. while your check isS|p9f“reserved«; theUdilegeofLfw-'wiihtimdud^^ of all reservations received by the deadline if we are unable to accommodate all interested alumni. We will return the check of anyone we cannot accommodate. To keep the weekend as flexible as possible for our alumni, the participants are free to make their own travel and lodging arrangements. We are in the planning stages for a reception on Sunday, May 20, and/or a luncheon after the ceremoney on May 21. Please indicate your interest in these events on the registration form below. We hope you can join us in Washington, D.C.!

(Detach and Return)

U.S. SUPREME COURT REGISTRATION FORM Name: ; ------Year:______Address:______-

------Day T elephone; ______Guest's Name:.

Date of admission to state's highest court:. State through which you seek admission:—

I am interested in a Sunday evening reception. I am interested in a Monday luncheon.

SPACE IS LIMITED. YOU MUST RESPOND BY MARCH 23, 1990. T • H • E Non Profit Org. U.S. Postage OHD PAID Columbus, Ohio Permit No. 711 SIATF, College of Law UNIVERSITY 1659 North High Street Columbus, Ohio 43210