Your Serve

Save Our Scoring System The expanding use of tiebreakers and No-Ad scoring is destroying the game’s integrity. By Paul Fein

n 2001, the shattered tradition by adopting I 10-point tiebreakers in lieu of deciding sets for mixed doubles. Doubles star , then the ATP Players Council president, warned: “Eventually it’s going to go to men’s doubles and women’s doubles, and in the long term, singles as well. And then is no longer a true test of skill and will. What they’re doing to mixed doubles now is the beginning of the downfall of the whole game.” Woodbridge’s prediction proved prescient. Five years later, the ATP adopted the 10-point tiebreaker in lieu of deciding sets in doubles at all tour events—and installed No-Ad scoring to further distance itself from the sport’s classic scoring system. The WTA fol- lowed suit in mid-2007. Today, only Wimbledon abstains from using the 10-point tiebreaker in place of deciding skilled player, who needs just one point has noted. Television commentator sets in mixed doubles. to win a game from deuce. Fluke shots, and former pro player Mary Carillo If WTA CEO Steve Simon has his bad bounces, net cords and incorrect recently called a tiebreaker in lieu of a way, the last domino of Woodbridge’s line calls take on undue significance in third set “illegitimate.” doomsday scenario will fall. Simon, shortened scoring formats. Much like If attendances are decreasing in ten- who believes the ideal match length the 10-point tiebreaker damages the nis, “It is not because of long matches,” is 60 to 90 minutes, claims it’s neces- integrity of the set, No-Ad scoring dam- observes former singles sary to implement both the 10-point ages the integrity of the game. champion Virginia Ruzici, “but mainly tiebreaker and No-Ad scoring in singles “The third-set super tiebreaker is not because of a lack of big rivalries which by 2019 or 2020. a true test, and the best player or team create intense, dramatic matches.” ! “We need to begin embracing our doesn’t always win,” argues former future audience,” Simon told reporters Wimbledon champion Pat Cash. “It is Award-winning tennis this September at the Wuhan Open. usually the player or team with writer Paul Fein is “Now, if a video is more than 20 momentum at the time that wins.” a former Satellite seconds, it is too long and [people] Simon’s panicky, misguided propos- tournament director, won’t even look at it.” als would destroy one of tennis’ crown- USPTA Elite Pro and We need to remember, however, that ing glories: its brilliant scoring system. longtime tournament fairness and credibility matter. Tennis’ Longer, closer matches—including the player. traditional scoring system increases the fluctuating crises of ad-in and ad-out— odds that the more skilled player will are more entertaining. The scoring sys- win a given game, while No-Ad scoring tem provides us with classics that make We welcome your opinions. Please email

unfairly boosts the chances of the less a connection with fans, as comments to [email protected] FEIN AP/PAUL COURTESY

40 TennisIndustry January 2017 www.tennisindustrymag.com www.tennisindustrymag.com

YourServe.indd 40 11/18/16 12:47 PM