Mini Guide Fédération Internationale de Association

Boston Invitational Model United Nations XVI February 10-12, 2017 // bosmun.org MINIGUIDE Federation Internationale de (FIFA) + Fédération Internationale de

Football Association (FIFA)

FIFA was founded in May 1904 in by delegates from , Denmark, , the

Netherlands, Spain, Sweden and . The founders created the first FIFA statutes, unifying the

laws of the game to make it fair and clear to all players setting the foundation for all future football

development. FIFA’s primary objective is “to improve the game of football constantly and promote it

globally in the light of its unifying, educational, cultural and humanitarian values, particularly through

youth and development programmes.” 1 The second objective is to organize international football

competitions, from men’s, women’s and youth football to . The third objective is to build

a better future for all through football. They want to improve the lives of young people and their

surrounding communities.

Everybody has a right to play football free from discrimination or prejudice.

FIFA's supreme body is the FIFA Congress, an assembly made up of representatives from each

of the 209 affiliated countries. The member nations are split up into six confederations; CONCACAF,

CONMEBOL, UEFA, CAF, AFC AND OFC. Each national football association has one vote, regardless

of its size or footballing strength. The congress makes decisions relating to FIFA's governing statutes

and their method of implementation and application. Only the Congress can pass changes to FIFA's

statutes. For the Game. For the World.

1 “Who We Are: FIFA.” FIFA.com. http://www.fifa.com/about-fifa/who-we-are/index.html 2 Marcus Christenson and Paul Kelso, “Soccer chief’s plan to boost women’s game? Hotpants,”

PAGE 2 MINIGUIDE Federation Internationale de football association (FIFA) + Topic 1 Gender Equality in

Former FIFA President , infamously stated in 2004 that female soccer

players should, “play in more feminine clothes” to increase their ’s popularity. His comment was

widely viewed as insensitive and inappropriate for the occasion and insulted the entire community of

female soccer players. Women athletes in every sport experience this kind of sexism along with

unequal pay.2

The 2012 London Olympics Women’s Gold Medal soccer match was the most sporting event

during the Olympics.3 The 2015 women’s World Cup final between the United States and Japan

brought in 25.4 million viewers in the United States. This was higher than the men’s World Cup final

match from 2014 (17.3 million), the NBA finales and the Stanley Cup final (7.6 million). This signaled a

new inspiration for future soccer players, especially young girls. The game was also able to shine a

spotlight on the continued inequalities between the men and women.

The United States Men’s National Soccer team earned $8 million in their world cup

even though they didn’t make it into the elimination rounds. Yet, the United States Women’s National

Soccer team only earned $2 million for winning the tournament. The winner of the men’s tournament,

2 Marcus Christenson and Paul Kelso, “Soccer chief’s plan to boost women’s game? Hotpants,” The Guardian https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2004/jan/16/football.gender 3 “Team USA Soccer Gold Medal Match Most-Watched Event in History of NBC Sports Network” http://nbcsportsgrouppressbox.com/2012/08/10/team-usa-soccer-gold-medal-match-most-watched-event-in- history-of-nbc-sports-network/

PAGE 3 MINIGUIDE Federation Internationale de football association (FIFA)

Germany, was awarded $35 million. When asked about the conflict, FIFA Secretary General Jerome

Valcke said, “That's not even a question I will answer because it is nonsense…We played [the] 30th

World Cup in 2014 and we are playing the seventh Women's World Cup...We are still another 23

World Cups before potentially women should receive the same amount as men.”4 (Blatter was banned

in 2016 for 12 years) FIFA is well behind another popular women’s sport, tennis, in addressing

inequality. In 2007 Wimbledon equalized prize money. Champions of both sexes will receive 26.7

million pounds for the 2015 final.5

The women were also subjected to playing on in the 2015 women’s World Cup. Artificial

turf has been blamed for increased injuries on sporting fields, including more sprained ankles,

concussions, turf burns, and an injury known as "turf toe." Overheating is also a health concern for

athletes since temperatures can be hotter on artificial surfaces than on natural grass. Finally, turf is

widely known to alter the speed and quality of play on the field. was noted as saying,

“The men would strike playing on artificial turf.” FIFA has stated that the women will no longer have to

play on turf for future games

4 Steve Keating, “Equal pay for women many World Cups away, says FIFA” http://in.reuters.com/article/soccer-world-women-money-idINKCN0JK02120141206 5 John Walters, “Taking a Closer Look at the Gender Pay Gap in Sports,” Newsweek http://www.newsweek.com/womens-soccer-suit-underscores-sports-gender-pay-gap-443137

PAGE 4 MINIGUIDE Federation Internationale de football association (FIFA)

+ Research Questions

1. Is FIFA responsible for fixing the inequalities in women’s soccer?

2. How many women are on FIFA’s governing boards?

3. What do other leagues/organizations do to combat inequalities?

4. What can FIFA do to further promote the women’s game?

5. What can FIFA do to address these inequalities for the 2019 Women’s World Cup?

+ Useful Resources

http://www.newsweek.com/womens-soccer-suit-underscores-sports-gender-pay-gap-443137

https://www.womenssportsfoundation.org/home/research/articles-and-reports/equity-issues/pay-

inequity

http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2016/03/22/sexism_in_pro_tennis_still_pales_in_comparison_to

_soccer.html

https://www.womeninsport.org/how-were-doing-it/sexism-in-sport/

http://money.cnn.com/2015/07/07/news/companies/womens-world-cup-prize-money/

.

PAGE 5 MINIGUIDE Federation Internationale de football association (FIFA) + Topic 2 FIFA Reform

Following an investigation by the FBI, in May 2015 the United States Department of Justice

raided a luxury hotel in Zurich, headquarters. Fourteen FIFA executives and officials were indicted

and arrested at the request of the US government. The Justice Department primarily states that the

deals between FIFA, groups and broadcast networks for the television rights

to air the World Cup dating back to 1991. It is found that the cumulative sum of these bribes is close to

$150 million.6 At a press briefing following the arrests, US attorney general Loretta Lynch said, “The

indictment alleges that is rampant, systemic and deep-rooted. It spans at least two

generations of soccer officials who, as alleged, have abused their positions of trust to acquire millions

of dollars in bribes and kickbacks.”7

The DOJ indictment is specifically a federal case so it’s only concerns are with the alleged fraud

in North and South America, but FIFA’s corruption problems started before arrest were made in May

2015. In 2002 a whistleblower contacted a British journalist relating to corruption within FIFA. In 2010

when FIFA awarded the 2010 World Cup to and the 2022 World Cup to many people

were suspicious about the choices. Russia has been accused of high levels of racism in football,

6 K.M. McFarland “Everything You Need to Know About FIFAs Corruption Scandal,” Wired http://www.wired.com/2015/05/fifa-scandal-explained/ 7 ibid.

PAGE 6 MINIGUIDE Federation Internationale de football association (FIFA)

especially with its involvement in the Ukrainian crisis. Qatar has a limited soccer history, their human

rights record and their high temperatures in the summer. The Qatar World Cup specifically was

question about voter buying. In the past FIFA has never admitted to any corruption and has instead

fired/suspended scapegoats. However, in 2012 FIFA commissioned an investigation into these

allegations. Although FIFA announced that it could not release the because of legal

reasons, people remained suspicions.8 FIFA is run by one country one vote. That means that smaller

countries like Trinidad & Tobago or have the same say as Russia or Germany. The smaller

countries also receive a cut of FIFA revenue so there is no initiative for them to change the voting

procedures.

The end of the corruption saga seemed to end when Sepp Blatter stepped down as president

in February 2016. On September 25, Swiss investigators announced that they were investigating

Blatter in relation to payments made to UEFA president . While Blatter and Platini denied

any impropriety around the payments, major FIFA issued public statements requesting that he resign

for the good of FIFA. In October 2015 he was suspended from FIFA for 90 days while investigations

into payments made to Michel Platini were conducted. In December, FIFA's ethics committee banned

both Blatter and Platini from football for eight years. In February 2016, a FIFA appeals committee

upheld the suspension but reduced it from eight years to six.9

8 Owen Gibson, “Michael Garcia’s report into Russia and Qatar World Cups suffers new delay,” The Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/football/2015/jun/17/michael-garcia-report-russia-qatar-world-cups

9 “Sepp Blatter, Michael Platini bans reduced to 6 years by FIFA” ESPNFC http://www.espnfc.us/blog/fifa/243/post/2814374/fifa-cuts-sepp-blatter-and-michel-platini-bans-to-6-years

PAGE 7 MINIGUIDE Federation Internationale de football association (FIFA) + Research Questions

1. What could FIFA have done to prevent the corruption?

2. How have other leagues dealt with corruption?

3. What are the next steps FIFA can take?

4. Should there be an overhaul of the FIFA system?

+ Recommended Readings

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/football/2016/03/22/fifa-a-timeline-of-corruption---in-90-seconds/

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-32897066

http://www.wired.com/2015/05/fifa-scandal-explained/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_FIFA_corruption_case

PAGE 8