ANNUALREPORT2011-12

National Council for the Training of Journalists 2 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Contents NCTJ strategic objectives 3 Vital statistics

4 Chairman’s report • Extend the NCTJ’s role and influence in order to deliver effective products and 5 Chief executive’s report services for all journalists across all 6 Qualifications media sectors and at all stages of their careers 8 Examinations 10 Gold standard students • Develop and broaden the progressive framework for ‘gold standard’ journalism 13 NCE results, 2011-12 qualifications that are the respected 14 Accreditation benchmark of excellence 17 Student Council • Support and enhance the high standard 19 Awards for Excellence and quality of education and training provided by accredited journalism 21 Journalism Skills Conference courses for employability 24 Journalism Diversity Fund • Take action to achieve greater diversity 27 Distance learning and publications of journalists in the media industry 29 Short courses • Take action to ensure high ethical 30 Business and finance review standards of journalists and greater 31 Who we are public confidence and trust in journalists

• Communicate effectively with all target audiences to increase awareness of the NCTJ’s brand values, its role, activities and status as a charity ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 3

Vital statistics

A total of 15,039 NCTJ exams were sat throughout 2011-12

These comprised:

9,578 preliminary exams (excluding shorthand) sat on course

726 national exam sittings, and 4,735 shorthand exam sittings

The total number of NCE exams sat was 1,011

1,598 students were enrolled on one of 68 accredited courses at

42 approved centres and sat the Certificate in Journalism and Diploma in Journalism exams

371 of these achieved gold standard, passing all exams while on the course

375 students were enrolled on non-accredited courses and sat NCTJ exams

429 candidates sat exams on the two national dates

315 trainees sat the National Certificate Examination –

309 reporters, 2 sports journalists and 4 sub-editors

146 trainees achieved the gold standard of passing their NCE –

143 reporters and 3 sub-editors

Registrations consisted of 168 reporters, 2 sub-editors,

2 sports journalists and 3 photographers

36 scheduled and in-house short training courses were run during the year 4 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Chairman’s report

There’s one topic that has dominated names copied off the internet in front the last year, eclipsing even those of a big audience on ITV? Do those other journalistic favourites, the celebrity sex stories demand an decline of print and the rise of social audience? Are we telling the truth media: media standards. This is when we stand on a doorstep and try to written shortly before Lord Justice persuade a grieving mother to let us in Leveson delivers a report that will and give us the picture of her dead destroy the freedom of the press and son? bring all newspapers under Personally, I’m ready to defend most of government control…or underpin the the things we do and want us to be free current system of regulation by giving to print what we like, within the some statutory authority to an existing law. But not without asking overseeing body…or ordain that the some questions first: are we right to do next version of the Press Complaints “It’s not enough this? Has this person done something Commission that has fewer industry that deserves this headline? Would I be insiders on it. happy to be treated in this way - or to spend a session Actually, of course, Brian Leveson can have a member of my family treated in do none of these things. He can this way? The Leveson inquiry has discussing the recommend things – and then it is up to made us think of rules, when we should the government to decide what it be thinking more about behaviour. wants to do. We’ve seen plenty of pre- Rules encourage us to work within PCC and Ofcom emptive defensive action by the them, going by the letter rather than newspaper industry, with more than the spirit of the regulation. If we want codes. Rather we enough criticism of the way the judge the public to trust us, the question is has interpreted his brief to make it as not “is this legal?” but “is this right?” need journalism wide-ranging as possible. The redtops To encourage these questions, the in the dock have said only a tiny NCTJ is getting more engaged in minority of journalists did bad things, students and ethics. It’s not enough to spend a the self-styled serious titles have put session discussing the PCC and Ofcom all the blame on the pops and the codes. Rather we need journalism trainees to consider regional papers have come on all students and trainees to consider outraged on the basis they have never every aspect of their work. It’s a done anything bad in their lives. every aspect of practice that should continue through The fact that this all started with illegal careers: as things stand, newspaper acts of phone tapping has blinded us to executives are unlikely to get any their work.” a bigger question, which is whether, as ethical guidance during the whole of a matter of routine, we do things in their careers. This is not to change the ways that don’t bear close scrutiny. character of the media, for we need it What was BBC Newsnight doing to be vigorous, cussed and rude. ditching its inquiry into Jimmy Savile Publish what you like - but only when and running its flawed story on Lord you have honestly engaged in the McAlpine? Why was Philip Schofield reason for doing so. waving around a piece of paper with ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 5

Chief Executive’s review

The media industry continues to operate In the year ahead we will see the results changes to the funding of higher and in challenging times with fewer journalism of some exciting projects. New further education have yet to be fully jobs and pressures on resources. We know apprenticeship and foundation certificate understood. that the jobs of journalists will continue to qualifications will give wider access to We are grateful to all those who support change alongside the restructuring and careers in journalism. The National the NCTJ and give their time so freely to further digitisation of our media Certificate Examination is being our charitable work. Your time is precious businesses. re-launched as the National Qualification and we value your dedication to the for Journalists. We are publishing This means our quality kitemark is more importance of good journalism. comprehensive new information about important than ever and we are committed working journalists – their views on to raising standards as well as moving with training, recruitment and conditions. the times. Expect to see a far greater emphasis on It is an on-going challenge for an industry training for seniors and managers. This is charity to ensure we have the expertise, part of our pledge to help ensure higher resources, support and products to help ethical standards and public confidence employers, trainers and individuals realise and trust in journalists. Training can't just their full potential. To enhance our be for trainees; we all have to keep operations we are continuing to invest in learning, adapting and changing at all new technology and communications and stages of our careers. to meet the needs of all journalists we are developing our range of services. We have many other challenges too. The need for exacting standards with enough Our plans to place more emphasis on ethics flexibility for innovation is a constant in our training and qualifications are well balancing act. We are determined to cater advanced and will be an interesting subject for different ways of getting into of debate at our annual conference in journalism. We are working hard to ensure Nottingham. our accredited training and our Whatever happens we will retain our focus examinations are up-to-date and delivered on the core skills. Editors stress time and by those who are in touch with how things “The need for exacting time again the importance of developing a have changed. news sense, building contacts, We remain very concerned about the over- interviewing, writing well to deadlines, standards with enough supply of journalism graduates who think accuracy and getting it right first time, they have the skills to get a job. Better knowing the essentials of media law, flexibility for innovation careers advice so that students are excellent English and a decent shorthand directed to the most appropriate career speed. is a constant balancing act. paths for them is one solution. Another During the year we signed up to our involves exposing these courses and We are determined to cater regulator Ofqual's new awarding body qualifications for what they are. recognition conditions – these demand Commercial realities and pressures cannot compliance with an array of criteria to for different ways of getting be ignored either. Not only is it a watershed demonstrate quality, rigour and time for the media; the consequences of professional standards. into journalism.” 6 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Qualifications

From this year all NCTJ-accredited “With the move towards multimedia course providers are delivering the newsrooms, it’s fitting that we now have Diploma in Journalism. a national standard and benchmark for entry-level broadcast journalism A new broadcast journalism specialist trainees.” option was piloted during 2011-12. Combined with the core journalism skills The process took almost two years to of the Diploma, it delivers an industry complete. “We set up a working group of standard for prospective trainee broadcast journalism employers, Catherine Houlihan, head of news, ITV Anglia journalists wanting to work in TV and educators and trainers in November radio newsrooms that broadcast 2010 to advise on content and we had employers can recognise. A total of 51 four centres who piloted the syllabus for “I was absolutely students across the four pilot centres us in the 2011-12 academic year. completed the module during the year “ITV London Television Centre hosted a and 55 per cent of them achieved the seminar on the new module in June thrilled to be part gold-standard A-C grade in the subject. 2012 with students, tutors and industry professionals to assess the module and of this ground- Designing the broadcast discuss any changes needed. As with all module new projects, a few adjustments were made, and it was very encouraging to breaking and Catherine Houlihan, head of news at hear such constructive and positive ITV Anglia and NCTJ chief examiner feedback.” exciting project.” for broadcast journalism. For Catherine, getting involved with the Catherine was appointed as the NCTJ’s new module was not just about setting first chief examiner for broadcast standards within the industry, but about journalism in September 2010. Working giving something back to those who with journalist, broadcaster and media prepared her for a successful career in consultant, Phil Harding, Catherine journalism: helped shape the broadcast journalism “The NCTJ gave me the solid grounding module, ensuring that the skills taught in journalism and set the high standards would equip students to hit the ground which have helped me throughout my running in a modern TV/radio career. To be given the opportunity to newsroom. help those who helped me is an honour.” “The NCTJ qualification means a safe pair of hands and a solid grounding in journalism. It is essential that the skills taught as part of the Diploma in Journalism reflect those that are needed in a modern newsroom. ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 7

Qualifications

Business and finance is much more straightforward and the • How to tell a news story journalism system allows students to download a • Recording information hard copy of their work once it has been • Legal considerations for journalists This year the NCTJ is introducing an moderated.” – Tom Hill, journalist and • Working as a journalist to ethical additional specialist option in Business media trainer, Up To Speed Journalism standards and Finance Journalism, which has been Training. developed with industry specialists They will then choose from a number of including Robert Peston from the BBC Foundation Certificate optional units covering subjects such as and Paul Addison of Bloomberg. It sports, feature writing or using video to Work has been underway to develop a ensures candidates can produce the complete the Certificate. new qualification aimed at those different types of story for all platforms involved in citizen/community required from each part of the business Apprenticeships journalism who would like to and finance news discipline including: ‘professionalise’ their skills. The NCTJ Throughout 2012-13 the NCTJ will be global financial issues; business and Level 3 Foundation Certificate in working with employers including Sky industry; banking; corporate finance; Journalism is designed as an News and the Evening Standard to economics; and consumer affairs. introduction to journalism with many introduce an Advanced Apprenticeship e-portfolio possible uses. Its flexibility means that it in Journalism. can be used as a stepping stone for A new digital portfolio has now replaced candidates wanting to go on to a career NCE review the previous hard copy file that is a core in journalism or by those wishing to A review of the NCTJ’s flagship subject in the Diploma in Journalism. improve their journalistic skills for a qualification, the National Certificate The secure online portfolio enables specific purpose. It will also be suitable Examination, has been conducted to students to upload their news stories for 16-18 year olds and could provide a ensure it continues to meet the needs of and features, produced on any platform. pathway to the Diploma in Journalism. news editors in today’s converged It is accessed via their personal student newsroom environments. login area on the NCTJ website. To gain the full qualification candidates will complete six mandatory units: The outcome reinforced the NCE’s high “The new e-portfolio allows students to standards and on-going values: upload and organise all their multimedia • How to research a story accuracy, unique content and good work in one place. The marking process • How to ask the right questions story-telling skills, but also highlighted the need to continue to develop to reflect what goes on in most newsrooms; particularly in the way reporters operate and deal with digital publishing.

The exams are being updated to reflect the multi-platform environment reporters work in and the logbook is being developed as a digital online version to compliment the introduction of the e-portfolio at pre-entry level. The qualification will also gain a new title, the National Qualification in Journalism (NQJ).

New e-portfolio 8 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Examinations

15,039 preliminary examinations were candidates to show evidence of listening sat through out 2011-12. The number of skills and the ability to be selective. NCE exam sittings increased from 805 to 1,011, reflecting the increase in Also, from September 2012, centres will registrations received in 2010-11. only offer one speed per sitting. “The way the exams are conducted has Registrations in 2011-12 decreased by 77 changed so that all exams are as fair Marie Cartwright from 252 to 175, however a trend has and accurate as possible,” said Marie. been noticed which suggests that editors are delaying registering trainees Often bemoaned by candidates as one which may explain the decrease in of the most challenging parts of the “If I had a pound numbers. course, her students are in good hands Changes to shorthand as Marie is proficient in not one, but for every journalism three types of shorthand: Pitman New exams Era, Pitman 2000 and Teeline. trainee who has Marie Cartwright has been involved with “My students often say they will never the NCTJ as a shorthand tutor for the ever make sense of it- they think it looks past 20 years. She is currently a like a page of hieroglyphics,” she said. moaned about lecturer at The Sheffield College, NCTJ “But after the very first lesson when the chief examiner and chair of the logic is explained and they see how the shorthand, I could shorthand board, as well as a member of Teeline alphabet is related to our the journalism qualifications board. alphabet, the fear is lost and they can However, she will be most recognisable start to enjoy it.” retire today. And to students as the author of Teeline “One of the first things I do is take my Gold for Journalists, the core textbook students to the book (Teeline Gold if I had a second for NCTJ candidates. Standard for Journalists) and the Throughout her career, Marie has seen forward by Kim Fletcher. He has pound for every the shorthand exams evolve, driven by considerable credibility as an editor and the requirements of editors and the he has given his three reasons why industry. In the mid-80s the test was a shorthand is essential.” editor who has solid four minutes – it gradually evolved to its most recent form of two minutes, told me just how one minute and a further one minute with a quote which candidates must pick out for themselves and write 100% important shorthand accurately. The addition of the quote two years ago is, I’d be retiring a was in response to a journalism skills survey in which editors wanted rich man. Kim Fletcher ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 9

Examinations

Those three reasons are, in short: afford to be choosy and they can insist 1. Shorthand is a practical skill on 100 wpm. They will often tell you it “I guess it’s possible that, and accurate record that can took them three or four times to get it. stand up in a court of law. It is a stepping stone to getting a job and somewhere, there’s a cub I think students are still willing to 2. It makes you concentrate and persevere until they achieve it.” reporter who loves learning listen carefully. And when it comes to achieving the 3. Shorthand signifies seriousness, coveted 100 wpm NCTJ gold standard, shorthand and looks forward commitment to the craft and there is no quick fix. “My top tips are accuracy. regular practice, little and often, and to every lesson. I doubt it. revisit the theory,” she said. Marie added that shorthand was still a I’ve seen more enthusiasm vital “tool of the trade” which would So despite the changes to the exam, it is always give candidates an advantage persistence and dedication, qualities all when looking for jobs and help to make good journalists should have, that from my children for extra them stand-out in an increasingly remain the key to cracking the competitive industry: “Editors can shorthand code. maths. But I’ve also seen the rising confidence of journalists who take the trouble to develop a good shorthand note”.

Kim Fletcher, NCTJ chairman 10 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 Gold standard students

Diploma in Journalism Ruth Hazard Andrew Gold Jessica Elizabeth Keating Philip Hayes Libby Powell Samantha Lewis Belfast Metropolitan College Catherine Roberts Sam Peoples Tanya Coulter Abigail Florance Rugg Philip Wroe Aileen Moynagh James Robert Stilgoe Matthew Symington Fraser Christopher Ward Liverpool Community College Romilly Scragg Brighton Journalism Works City of Wolverhampton College Olivia Stone Rebecca Choules Rebecca May Carr Rebecca Cooney Laura James News Associates - London James Cutler Charlotte Hannah Lilley Natasha Adkins Neil Hawkins Sophie Madden Emily Ansell John Herring Laura Jayne Maltby Nick Atkin Emily Hoquee Thomas Allnutt Natalie Laurence De Montfort University Peter Apps Ben Leo Jennifer Hannah Ayling Kieran Beckles Sarah Morgan Alice Hemmings Nadine Bernham-Marshalleck Christie Mudie Hayley Mortimer Nicholas Bonfield Emily Noszkay Sean Bourke Andrew Robinson Glasgow Caledonian University Erykah Brackenbury Katie Smith Harriet Brace Peter Bryant Jon Stapley Maria Yvette Smith Tristan Carlyle Kayleigh Tanner Elise Chamberlain Caroline Wilson Highbury College Emily Coen Henry Ascoli Helen Coffey Brunel University Francesca Cary Amaris Cole Kristina Jayne Beanland Rachel Cranshaw Liz Cooley Mamiyo Padi Jenny Dobson Michael Cox Matthew Graveling Christian Crowther-Smith Cardiff University Abe Hawken Ben Cusack Adam Care Jake Kendall-Ashton Dion Dassanayake James Chapple Jennifer Leigh McKean Lizzie Dearden Beth Cherryman Jonathan Sharman Thomas Duffell Elena Cresci Christopher John Shimwell Joel Durston Andrew Curry Josh Wilkie Robert Edwards Emily Davies Gemma Ellis Elizabeth Ann Day Kingston University Asif Faruque Philip Dewey James Charlton Alice Foster William Humphries Ben Jefferson Natalie De Freitas Amy Jones Annabel Langley Joseph Gammie Ellie Lawrie John May Helen Glover Tim Macfarlan Charlotte Meredith Abi Goodman Anne Moore Jennifer Norton Monique Hall Christopher Nokes Laura Proto Helena Hickey James Preston Lauren Stopps Michael Holder Benjamin Rogers Rachel Webster Katie Holland Tom Rouse Sarah Ingrams Huw Silk Lambeth College Laura Jackson Rhys Williams Azzam Alkadhi Tom James Michael Yong David Brenchley Philip James Elizabeth Buchan Robin Jellis City College Brighton & Hove Matthew Cannon Lucy Jordan Joshua Samuel Barrie Emily Churchill Hannah Kurzawski Mathew Beech Jack Davidson Jasmin Leitner Peter Browne Katy Docherty Andrew Magee ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 11 Gold standard students

Katie Mansfield Hannah Hulme Milena Veselinovic Hardeep Matharu Linsey Humphries Freddy Mayhew Jonathan Humphries Press Association Training – Harry McAlister Mihaela Ivantcheva Newcastle Tom McMahon Andrew Little Esther Beadle Jacqueline McMillan Lauren Maughan Oliver Berrow Scott McWhinney Danny McCann James Burton Tom Meade Shanna McGoldrick David Cosgrove Jennifer Morris Alexander McIntyre Lauran Davis Lydia Morton James McLaughlin Sarah Fielden John Nassoori Kirsty Plowman Andrew Fowler Kevin Newton Rebecca Pocklington Philippa Goymer Katy Oglethorpe Najeeb Rehman Laura Heads Sabrina Parkar James Riches Claire Hennon George Pavlou Ian Silvera Francesca Infante Emma Phippen Carrie Smith Guy Kiddey Oliver Porritt Rebecca Thelwell William Lyon Hannah Raven Nicholas Watmough Bianca Murray Sophie Russell Gareth Westmorland Kate O’Neill Nate Saunders Sarah Whalley Michael Owens Rachel Stevenson Dean Wilkins Matthew Playford Yvonne Suen Jessica Wilson Philip Reade Tom Sweetman Lauren Riley Kimberley Swift Nottingham Trent University Daniel Robinson Michael Symons Hannah Mary Winifred Astill Joshua Shrimpton Dean Anna Tabrah Peter Michael Blackburn Jonathan Taylor Adam Tait Andrew Paul Butler Joseph Wilkes Will Turvill Darren George Donald Campbell Liam Twomey David Alan Cornish Robert Gordon University Samuel Wakefield Amie Glossop Fatima Husain Laura Walkinshaw Ben Alexander Griffiths Rachel Massie Ryan Walters Thomas Norton Jon Waring Eleanor Claudine Rhodes Sheffield College Natalie Whittle James Thomas Sharpe Toby Harrison Emily Wilson Kate Louise Wilson Chris Moore Hermione Wright Ashleigh Withall-Prince Alicia Shore Helen Wright Hannah Rose Mellor Worrall Jack Zorab Press Association Training – London Hilary Aked St Marys University College News Associates – Manchester Alix Culbertson Matt Stott Kieran Agnew Emma Davis Paul Berentzen Robin De Peyer Staffordshire University James Booker Anna Dubuis Natalie Clarkson Ben Burrows Lauren Fruen Naomi Herring Rebecca May Cohen Alexandra Gregg Kirsty-Ann Hewson James Coldwell Sarah May Hayes Lee Kettle Samantha Cordon Emma Lake Felicity Crease David Leslie University of Central Lancashire Jessica Cree Sasha Magill Maya Dibley James Dickenson Amanda Nunn Hugh Metcalf Charlotte Dobson Janine Rasiah Thomas Murphy Sean-Paul Doran Stephen Richardson Emma Rigby Karl Dyer Denise Roland Jessica Elliott James Rose University of Kent Joseph Fitzpatrick Jo-Anne Rowney Karolina Kaminska Melanie Hughes Patrick Surlis Katherine Purvis 12 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 Gold standard students

University of Salford Natalie Jane O’Hare University of Sheffield Kirsty Allen Harriet Elizabeth Rose-Gale David Parker Stephen Feekins Eleanor Simmons Todd Fitzgerald Joanna Stass University of Sunderland Liam Thorp Lauren White James Bailey James Hunt University of Sheffield Glasgow Caledonian University Ryan Kennedy Rebecca Jackson Nicola Hamilton Gavin Spensley Jeroen Kraan Mark McKay Nottingham Trent University Magazine Journalism Emma Robinson Hayley Amin Emma Boden University of Sunderland University of Sunderland Josie Crafts Lisa Johnson Thomas Carlisle Megan Faulkner Nicholas Robinson Marian Chan Kiran Ghuman Marianne Dick Lucy Gornall Christopher Hoy Lee Hammond Emma Hardwick University of Ulster Ryan Kelly Natasha Millar Rebecca Lax Nadejda Vidinova Hanna Ljunggren Rebecca Longshaw Up To Speed Journalism Training Elkie Maddison Francis Scott Sean McCausland Lee Williams Danny Mitchell Rebecca Perring Kelly Pike Certificate in Press Joshua Robbins Photography William Taylor Meghann Thorp Sheffield College Ross Timms Harry Atkinson Emma Village Timothy Goode Suzanne Wallace Joel Goodman Sophie Williams Steven Kingsman Robert James Streeter Teesside University Dougal Wallace Hannah Louise Bryan Alex Whitehead University of Brighton Up To Speed Journalism Training Chad Nugent Nadine Al Koudsi Rajan Upal Mark Chappell Jonathan Vale Elizabeth Wainwright University of Kent James Averill Certificate in Journalism Alex Dack Laura Hartmann Bournemouth University Sophie Jackson Mark Allaway Dean Kilpatrick Amber Ascroft Daniel Peter May Heloise Beaton Nicola Anne Sturmey Zoe Drewett Melanie Wimmer Amy Dyduch Sarah Hartland University of Portsmouth Rowena Heal Oliver Poole Samantha Herbert ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 13

NCE results, 2011-12

Reporters July 2011 Reporters March 2012

John Balson, Maidenhead Advertiser Rachel Butler, Derby Evening Telegraph Winnie Osayi Agbonlahor, Nottingham Evening Post Jessica Bell, Sale & Altringham Messenger Jill Castle, Kirkintilloch Herald Hannah Bargery, Warrington Guardian Owen Bennett, Braintree & Witham Times Paul Clifford, Shields Gazette Kirsty Beaton, Falkirk Herald Richard John David Blackledge, Star Stephanie Cureton, Wirral Globe Dan Bloom, Medway Messenger Newspaper – Sheffield Helen Davies, The Leader Tom Bristow, Eastern Daily Press Paul Broome, Hereford Times Simon Farr, Bucks Free Press Laura Anne Burge, The Comet Daniel Charles, The Citizen, Gloucester Tim Fletcher, Burton Daily Mail James Cox, Daily Gazette Katherine Clark, Daily Echo Sophie Flowers, Maidenhead Advertiser Matthew Dannatt, Grimsby Telegraph Jasmine Coleman, Hackney Gazette David Ford, Halifax Evening Courier Scott D’Arcy, Swindon Advertiser Vanessa Michelle Cornall, Lancashire Telegraph John Fuller, West Cumberland Times & Star Amy De-Keyzer, Kent & Sussex Courier Jordan Day, Cambridge News Hayley Gallimore, Worksop Guardian Timothy Dickens, Ilford Recorder Flora Drury, Worcester News Andrew Gray, Kent Messenger Emma Dunn, Swindon Advertiser Leanne Francesca Ehren, Cambridge News Andrew Groves, Harrogate Advertiser Benjamin Endley, Surrey Advertiser John Ellul, Surrey Advertiser Christopher Hewett, Watford Observer David Alexander Farbrother, Surrey Mirror Joshua Farrington, Courier Media Group Ltd David Edward Higgs, Hereford Times Jade Lynne Farrington, Cornish Guardian Christine Fleming, Richmond & Twickenham Times Amy Hirst, Ilkeston Advertiser Megan French, Braintree & Witham Times William Michael John Frampton, Wiltshire Times Alexander Homer, Express & Star Jayne Garfitt, Nottingham Evening Post Martin George, Surrey Comet Caroline Ivison, West Cumberland Times & Star Robert Golledge, Western Gazette Co. Ltd. Natalie Geraghty, Wigan Evening Post Scott Kirk, Westmorland Gazette Adam John Grinsell, MK News Stuart Gillespie, Fife Herald Laura Linham, Mid Somerset Newspapers Toby Higgins, Halifax Evening Courier David Graham, Cumbernauld News Jasmin Claire McDermott, Southend Evening Echo Matthew Hobbs, Warrington Guardian Emma Louise Harrison, Bracknell News Christopher Melvin, Wiltshire Times Rachel Hovenden, Kent Messenger, Gravesend Emily Victoria Heward, Halifax Evening Courier David Mercer, Press Association – London Nicola Jarvis Danielle Hoffman, Western Gazette Co Ltd. Will Metcalfe, CN Group Ltd, Furness William Lodge, Daily Gazette Hannah Hope, Express & Echo, Exeter Newspapers Ltd Michelle Sarah Macleod, Stornoway Gazette Cara Houchen, Sunderland Echo Helen Morton, Basingstoke Gazette Harriet Marsh, Daily Echo Lois Hough, The Flintshire Leader Simon Philip Moss, Basingstoke Gazette Tom Marshall, Islington Gazette Steven Hugill, Scarborough Evening News Omar Oakes, Wimbledon Guardian Jennifer Meierhans, Kidderminster Shuttle Christina Johnson, Luton & Dunstable Express Sara Odeen-Isbister, Barking & Dagenham Post Jennifer Moody, Uttoxeter Advertiser Nicholas Mayo, Maidenhead Advertiser James Palmer, News Shopper Hugh Morris, Archant (Anglia) Ruth Mosalski, Halifax Evening Courier Kenny Paterson, Berwickshire News Jennifer Newton, Arbroath Herald Kate Proctor, Westmorland Gazette Helen Mary Perkins, Westmorland Gazette Laura Niblett-Roberts, Herts Advertiser Tara Jayne Russell, Southern Daily Echo Suzanne Pike, Grantham Journal Kaye Nicolson, Press and Journal (Aberdeen) Nadia Mandana Sam-Daliri, East London Advertiser Paul Rogers, Hereford Times Joseph Michael Nimmo, The News, Portsmouth Benjamin Spencer, Star Newspaper - Sheffield James Scott, Kent Messenger - Kentish Express Laura Paterson, Press and Journal (Aberdeen) Emma Thomas, Southend Evening Echo Sophie Emily Scott, Luton on Sunday Bethan Phillips, Southern Daily Echo Lucy Thomson, Coventry Evening Telegraph Michael Jeffrey Sims, Folkestone Herald Emma Preston, North West Evening Mail David Trayner, Northants Evening Telegraph Sam Smith, Brentwood Gazette Samuel John Russell, Great Yarmouth Mercury Andrew Woodman, Kent Regional News and Media Jennifer Stanton, Surrey Advertiser Daniel John Sanderson, Edinburgh Evening News Colin Strachan, Wakefield Express Robert Setchell, Cambridgeshire Times Reporters November 2011 Elizabeth Sweetman, Worcester News Lowri Stafford, Courier Newspapers Jack William Tappin, Haverhill Echo Joshua Taylor, Burton Daily Mail Beth Allcock, Northwich Guardian Andrew Turton, Express & Star Christopher Ballinger, Courier Newspapers Nicholas Wakefield, Stroud News & Journal Sports July 2011 Daniel Bean, The Press, York Lindsay Watling, Press & Journal John Tompson, Grimsby Telegraph John Birch, Newark Advertiser Nicholas Webster, Western Gazette Co Ltd. Catherine Bolado, Dorset Echo Matthew White, Isle of Wight County Press James Michael Brindle, Burton Daily Mail Benjamin Wilkinson, Oxford Mail Sports November 2011 Laurey Buckland, Newark Advertiser Michael Wilkinson, Wiltshire Times Stephen Matthew Tervet, Kent on Sunday Richard Wood, Lowestoft Journal Matthew Young, Courier Newspapers 14 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 Accreditation

If a training centre is accredited by The NCTJ currently accredits 71 courses grades in each core exam. In the case of the NCTJ, then a prospective student at 42 centres across the UK. From July shorthand, the number and percentage knows that they will be taught the 2011 to June 2012, 25 centres were of students passing at a minimum speed essential skills needed to be a good visited for new accreditations, re- of 100 wpm - the industry standard - is journalist at that centre. If these accreditations, monitoring visits, and recorded. skills are to be meaningful, then it’s advisory visits for new centres wanting They also show the number and important that an NCTJ-accredited to apply for accreditation. percentage of students completing an course delivers vocational training to Six new journalism courses were accredited course gaining A to E grades the highest standard. The UK media awarded NCTJ accreditation for the first in each core exam. In the case of industry recognises the NCTJ’s time during the course of the 2011-12 shorthand, the number and percentage standard as the hallmark of academic year: of students passing at a minimum speed excellence. of 60 wpm. Coventry University College – The NCTJ believes that the overall • In 2020-11, the top six performing Diploma in Journalism programme structure and methods of courses were: Lambeth College – Diploma in teaching should be left to the experts at • Magazine Journalism HE postgraduate: Nottingham the universities, colleges and • Staffordshire University – BA Trent University, MA/ PGDip commercial training centres who deliver • Journalism (two-year fast-track) Newspaper Journalism the accredited courses. We are University of Central Lancashire HE undergraduate: University of confident that our training providers • • – MA Journalism Practice Kent, MA Journalism and the News believe that our accreditation process is University of Sunderland – BA Industry rigorous, fair, straightforward and • Fashion Journalism FE fast-track: Highbury College professional. • • University of Sussex – MA • Independent fast-track: Press We are grateful to the industry Multimedia Journalism Association, Newcastle professionals who donate their time to Academic year: City of Our protracted battle over standards • sit on accreditation panels and provide Wolverhampton College at Nosweat Journalism Training valuable feedback and support that culminated in the closure of this courses need in order to succeed. Best Performing Course journalism school in April and court 2011: Multi-media During the accreditation process, the action against the owner, Stephen Ward, Foundation Course, Press NCTJ aims to achieve the following: who pleaded guilty on four counts of false trading. The NCTJ deplores and Associates Newcastle Ensure the NCTJ syllabus is • regrets the way its reputation was delivered effectively so that The multi-media foundation course at misused by Mr Ward and particularly the students leave the course ready to Press Association Newcastle was effect of his actions on students. work as trainee journalists and the best performing NCTJ-accredited eventually achieve their We have investigated and scrutinised course in 2010-2011. All 24 students, professional qualification, the NCE, our own accreditation actions and a recruited over two intakes, which raises them to the level of a number of changes to our accreditation successfully completed the course senior journalist. scheme are being introduced as a result (NCTJ Certificate in Journalism), with of this review. These include new 100% getting A-C grades in media Support courses as they work to • contractual agreements with our law, court reporting, public affairs teach students the converged skills centres and terms and conditions of local government and public affairs that they need to work effectively accreditation. central government, while 96% in a 21st century newsroom. achieved 100 wpm shorthand. Work in partnership with course Results tables • Tony Johnston, head of training at providers and the accreditation For the fifth year running, the NCTJ will Press Association Newcastle, puts the board to maintain and inform an be publishing 2011-12 results tables on success of the course down to their accreditation process that ensures its website at the end of 2012. tutors and 44 years of experience in quality, “real world” journalism delivering journalism training. skills which is flexible enough to The tables show both the number and accommodate creative, value- percentage of students completing an “We have a strong legacy of delivering added initiatives. accredited course and gaining A to C high calibre training. I think the key ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 15

Accreditation

feature of the course is its high vocational Accreditation board members The NCTJ aims to accredit courses: nature. Our students are exposed to real That are promoted clearly and world journalism right from day one. Chairman • Chris Elliott, readers’ editor, The Guardian (NCTJ compellingly to students seeking a “We’re very conscious that the media world director and trustee) vocational qualification that is widely is changing and it’s important that the recognised and highly valued by journalism course stays ahead of that curve of change.” Members employers. Andy Cairns, executive editor, Sky Sports News With 14 of their 15 graduates in May 2012 • Where students are selected on the basis securing employment in a range of news Paul Connolly, managing editor, Belfast Telegraph of ability and the potential to succeed in a outlets, including traditional daily and Graham Dudman, editorial development director, career in journalism. weekly newspapers such as the Aberdeen News International • That are committed to fostering a safe, Journal and the Dundee Courier, the NCTJ Tom Hill, course director, Up to Speed Media supportive and inclusive learning gold standard remains a valuable asset on David Holmes, lecturer, University of Sheffield environment, regardless of class, gender, any budding journalist’s CV: ethnic origin, age, sexual orientation, Dave King, head of news, Sussex Newspapers disability, or particular needs. “Editors perceive the NCTJ accreditation as (NCTJ chief examiner – sports journalism) a good indicator of the basic level of skills Roz McKenzie, course leader, Lambeth College • Where the NCTJ syllabus is delivered required of trainee journalists and so it’s effectively and in full by knowledgeable Ian Reeves, director of learning and teaching, very important that we maintain that link.” and experienced teaching staff. University of Kent Centre for Journalism Where there is an integrated approach to Michelle Stanistreet, general secretary, • teaching with formal classroom tuition National Union of Journalists linked to practical journalism that reflects Chas Watkin, editor, You and Yours, BBC Radio 4 developments in media convergence. Joy Yates, editor, Hartlepool Mail • Whose providers are dedicated to a culture of continuous improvement based on a well-developed and coherent quality management process. • Where staff are able to carry out the required administrative and examination functions in a timely and professional manner.

Tony Johnson, head of training, Press Association 16 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Accreditation panel members 2011-2012

Mark Acheson, deputy editor, Portsmouth News Chris Harris, assistant editor, BBC Solent Nicola Priest, group editor, Warrington Guardian Sheenah Alcock, picture editor, MEN Stuart Hastings, chief photographer, Sheffield Star Sue Ryan, head of trainee reporters’ scheme, Lynn Ashwell, deputy editor, Bolton News Douglas Hill, editor, Deeside Piper Daily Mail Michael Beard, editor, The Argus Deric Henderson, Ireland editor, Press Association Marcus Ryder, editor, investigative news and current Bob Bounds, editor, KM Group Allan Hodge, editor, The Extra affairs, BBC Scotland Clare Bourke, editor, Hertfordshire Life Dave King, head of news, Sussex Newspapers Mike Sassi, editor-in-chief, Staffordshire Sentinel Richard Bowyer, deputy editor, The Sentinel Joël Lacey, editor, Dorset Life News Martin Buhagiar, group editor, North London Times Rob Lawson, former editor, Sunderland Echo Darren Thwaites, editor, Newcastle Evening and Independent Esther Leach, editor, Yorkshire Life Chronicle Andy Cairns, executive editor, Sky Sports News Martin Lindsay, former editor-in-chief, Mark Trevelyan, training editor, EMEA, Reuters Simon Caney, editor-in-chief, Sport Magazine Belfast Telegraph Laurie Tucker, day editor, Sky Sports News Colin Channon, chief editor, Sussex Newspapers Alan McCabe, editor, Evening Express Hannah Walker, editor-in-chief, South London Press Jane Clare, deputy head of production, Merseyside Fiona McGarry, assistant editor, The Irish News Paul Walker, editor, Newsquest (Midlands) Weeklies Martin McGinley, editor, Derry Journal Malcolm Warne, editor, Darlington & Stockton Times Drew Cochrane, editor, Largs & Millport Angus Moorat, news editor, BBC Surrey and Sussex Chas Watkin, editor, You and Yours, BBC Radio 4 Weekly News Keith Morris, editor, Northwich Guardian Fiona Webster, freelance writer and editor Paul Connolly, managing editor, Belfast Telegraph Ian Murray, editor-in-chief, Southern Daily Echo Damian Wilson, group editor, Johnston Press NI Graham Dudman, editorial development director, Paul Napier, editor, Yorkshire Evening Post Ian Wood, former assistant editor, Manchester News International Kevin O’Donnell, publisher/editor, Portfolio Publishing Evening News Paul Dutton, former night editor, The Sentinel Eamonn O’Neal, managing editor, Manchester Andy Worden, editor, Crawley News James Geary, editor, Ode Magazine Evening News Kay Wright, news editor, BBC Radio Leicester Alan Geere, former NCTJ board member and former Richard Ord, deputy editor, Sunderland Echo Joy Yates, editor, Hartlepool Mail editorial director, Northcliffe Media South East Malcolm Pheby, former regional editorial director, Keith Harrison, editor, The Shropshire Star Northcliffe Midlands and former editor, Nottingham Michael Devlin, senior reporter, Strabane Chronicle Evening Post Chris Elliott, readers’ editor, The Guardian Claire Pitcher, former editor, Hampshire Life ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 17

Harriet is is now a trainee journalist at the Carrik Gazette.

Student Council What the students said… “You knew that you were being listened to, rather than Student Council: putting annual meeting, now in its fifth year, is students at the heart of the main event at which students can just forgotten.” what we do get the opportunity to speak to key members of the organisation, including “Honestly, I was expecting it the chief executive and the head of Students may once have been content examinations. to be a bureaucratic to sit through a few lectures and take notes but not anymore. procedure. But, I found it very Student journalists are expected to be “The students are one of the most helpful. Mr Allen’s talk was active learners: working with recording valuable resources we have when it equipment, interviewing for articles informative and inspiring. comes to informing the content of our and probing sources for information. It Talking about the courses seems fair then, that they are given accredited courses,” says NCTJ chief the opportunity to inform their executive Joanne Butcher. “They are with other students was really learning as well. best placed to offer opinions on what great. I enjoyed the BBC tour The NCTJ have worked hard to develop they are taught and how they are as well.” and maintain a relationship with all taught it.” those who study an accredited course. With additional journalism courses “The most useful thing was This year’s student council meeting being awarded accreditation, bringing was based at MediaCity, Salford, where talking to other students going the total number of centres up to 42, it students were treated to a tour of the is more important than ever to make through the same experiences. BBC 5 Live studios and a talk from key sure that the student voice is heard. note speaker, and Co-Presenter of It helps to hear how other Student Council Drive on Radio 5 Live, Peter Allen, people cope with the same before getting the chance to meet the One of the ways in which the NCTJ aim NCTJ panel for a Q&A session. academic challenges that we to connect with their students is through the student council. The are faced with.” 18 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 Student Council

The event is highly valued by those the chance to ask the board if, as who attend. “The whole day was really employers, they would be put off by interesting and fun,” said Harriet someone who had taken some time out Brace, student rep for MA Multimedia to do that. They were all very positive Journalism at Glasgow Caledonian and encouraging about it.” University. “The Q&A session with the Hannah added: “We also got to sit down NCTJ was very helpful. It was so with some of the NCTJ staff and they accessible; I was able to speak directly were able to give great advice on to Joanne Butcher about exams.” applying for jobs in the industry, as well She added: “It’s a good opportunity for as how to write CVs and covering students from different parts of the UK, letters.” like us in Scotland and students in Northern Ireland, to meet the people who accredit the course and get the chance to put a name to a face.” Tom Edwards, who studied the fast- track newspaper journalism course at Lambeth College, also enjoyed the day: Tom is now working for The Sun Online as a “Peter Allen gave a really good talk, but freelance production journalist and sub-editor. one of the biggest benefits for me was meeting other students. It was nice to be able to compare experiences with What the students said… others on similar courses.” After travelling through south-east Asia, Hannah is now applying for junior reporter jobs. “I was worried that with such NCTJ Board a huge amount of travelling Following the student council meeting, Some of the topics discussed included members are invited to give their the timing of exams, access to different that the council meeting would feedback to the main NCTJ board at production software and developing the not seem worth it. I was their meeting in London in June. Harriet social media element of the course. Brace, Tom Edwards and Hannah Mark They thought the accreditation entirely wrong. The whole were all invited to share their feedback standard was good as it made courses with the board. challenging and liked the emphasis on NCTJ team were very Despite the prospect of being faced with practical skills as they can be welcoming and I felt that I transferred into real life. those at the top of the company, the took a huge amount out of the student reps were undaunted and glad They also appreciated the work the to have the support of their peers. NCTJ has put into student sessions.” “The three of us had all met previously communications and the student log-in at the student council so there was no area. There were requests for more “Listening to the key note feedback on exam results and more awkwardness and we were able to back speaker and panel of editors each other up,” says Harriet. content on using social media as a reporting tool in the newsroom. “We also got the chance to do some was really informative and networking after which was a really The Student Council and presentation to gave a lot of insight into the good opportunity.” the board provides a much needed line of communication between the NCTJ serious considerations we all Hannah Mark, who studied the Diploma and students, giving future journalists a in Journalism at Belfast Metropolitan voice, as well as a link to those already need to make about our College, said the meeting was useful for in the industry. The initiative has given futures.” the student reps to get some careers students a voice, and they are more advice. “I had been thinking about doing than happy to be heard. some traveling after my course so I had ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 19

Awards for Excellence

Joe Cooper The NCTJ Awards for Excellence Top Scoop have proved more popular than ever in their fifth year, attracting over Student: Adam Knight, 150 student and trainee entries. News Associates London On his award-winning article: “The day The awards celebrate the I did the story was one of those great achievements of individuals with days at the office, everything just promising journalism careers ahead of clicked, you were part of the buzz of a them. They also include performance busy newsroom and you realise why awards for those gaining the highest you wanted to become a journalist in David Churchill marks in the NCTJ Diploma and the the first place.” NCE. Trainee: Dominic Shaw, This year’s winners will receive their Hartlepool Mail awards at the NCTJ Journalism Skills On winning the award: “I was Conference in Nottingham in absolutely delighted. When I found out November 2012. I had been shortlisted I was over the Category Award moon but then to discover I had won the award is excellent!! It’s a Winners confidence boost to have your work recognised at this level, especially News Journalism Adam Knight when you see comments from the Student: Joe Cooper, judges about the standard of entry.” Leeds Trinity University College On his NCTJ training: “I couldn’t Features of the year imagine not doing an NCTJ course. It’s fundamental to the job and getting the Student: Jennifer Morris, right job. The course at Leeds Trinity News Associates London has been great.” On her award: “It’s really lovely to be recognised in this way, I’m absolutely Trainee: David Churchill, thrilled. I just wanted to help other Croydon Advertiser people feel comfortable talking about Dominic Shaw On winning the award: “It’s a great their feelings on it (the death of a feeling, as the judging panel was parent at a young age). I just started enough to humble any senior, let writing and it seemed to flow, I found alone trainee reporter. I have to say a it quite therapeutic. It just felt quite huge thank you to my editor… who natural.” has given our reporters a free reign to fully investigate a big story, and for that I am grateful, as without it, the great stories that come with success would be impossible.” Jennifer Morris 20 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Awards for Excellence

Trainee: Hardeep Matharu, Best Student Publication Epsom Guardian On her NCTJ training: “The diploma Royal Visit, De Montfort University gave me a good grounding in all of the Performance Award Winners basics… which stood me in great stead when I started work as a trainee NCTJ Student Journalist of the Year: reporter and encountered the steep Christopher Hoy, University of Sunderland learning curve of the practical, ‘on the NCTJ Reporter of the Year: job’, training. Importantly, I really Hannah Upton, Westmorland Gazette enjoyed the diploma – it had given me Hardeep Matharu that insight into journalism which I 2012 Judges didn't have before and confirmed my decision to pursue it as a career.” Jonathan Barry, picture editor, Worcester Evening News Images of the year Brien Beharrell, editorial director, Student: Joel Goodman, Newbury Weekly News The Sheffield College Orla Chennaoui, journalist, Sky Sports News “I’m flattered that the judges liked my David Collins, news reporter, Daily Mirror work and proud to be receiving the award. The training I have received Graham Dudman, editorial development director, Joel Goodman was terrific – an essential grounding News International for any photographer hoping to work Nicole Garnon, deputy editor at South Wales Argus; in press photography in the UK.” Will Gore, deputy managing editor, Evening Standard David Jones, chief foreign writer, Daily Mail Trainee: Alex Cantrill-Jones, Derby Telegraph Dave King, head of news, Sussex Newspapers On winning an award: “It’s brilliant Jayne Savva, features editor, Best magazine for my first full time job as a Stephen Moyes, senior reporter, The Sun photographer. It feels great to be able to uphold the standards of the Derby Steve Phillips, group picture editor, Telegraph and do them proud as well.” South Wales Evening Post Alex Cantrill-Jones David James Smith, journalist, Sports Journalism The Sunday Times Magazine Student: David Lyons, Laurie Tucker, day editor, Sky Sports News Glasgow Caledonian University Joy Yates, editor, Hartlepool Mail On winning the award: “It’s a privilege. All the judges are people I really respect and to receive praise from people you hold in such high regard is an honour.” David Lyons ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 21

Journalism Skills Conference

The NCTJ’s 60th anniversary ended the time famously, the most bombed on a high with the Journalism Skills hotel in Europe. The DUP junior minister “I’ve got my Conference in Belfast. welcomed delegates and added that it was a “milestone year” for professional Belfast Metropolitan College, University journalism training in Northern Ireland. (NCTJ) certificate of Ulster and leading media Making reference to the sometimes organisations in Northern Ireland uneasy relationship between politicians hanging proudly worked with the NCTJ to deliver a two- and journalists, Mr Bell said: “I think day event to cap the milestone year. there is a need for resourcefulness and in my office from The conference, bringing together enthusiasm, for the tenacity to pursue decision makers in journalism’s the story, no matter how uncomfortable many years ago education, training and industry sectors, that it can make anybody feel, or how took place on 30 November and the uncomfortable it can make politicians 1 December 2011 and has become a feel. when I trained. must-attend annual event for those who “Voltaire said it right: we may not like Michael Cairns, editor, are passionate about quality multimedia what you say, but we will defend your journalism. right to say it.” political programing, BBC NI:

The city was an apt venue for the Following the opening, delegates were conference as two new centres in involved in a Q&A session on politics and Northern Ireland were awarded NCTJ- the media. Speakers at the event accreditation in 2011: Belfast included Noel Doran, editor of the Irish Metropolitan College and North West News; Michael Cairns, editor of news Regional College. They join the award- gathering and political programmes, winning course at the University of BBC Northern Ireland; Ed Curran, editor- Ulster. in-chief Independent News and Media and; Maurice Neill, course co-ordinator Jonathan Bell MLA opened the at Belfast Metropolitan College. conference at the Europa Hotel, a familiar haunt for many journalists on For the afternoon session, delegates assignment during the troubles and, at moved to Belfast Metropolitan College’s 22 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Noel Doran, editor, Irish News: “Training in journalism has always been an essential part of the industry.” He added: “I think it’s very important to engage with people like the

Mark Simpson, Ireland correspondent, BBC News NCTJ, I completed an new campus in the Titanic Quarter for consultant; Mark Simpson, Ireland NCTJ course myself discussion panels on digital skills and correspondent, BBC News; and Dr Steve technology in journalism, and regulation Baker, a lecturer in film and television back in the 1970s and and ethics. studies at the University of Ulster. in those days there was Chaired by Alan Geere, editorial Simpson, who was a reporter during The director, Northcliffe Media South East, Troubles, offered an alternative title: a recession, in those delegates discussed the changing face Mayhem, Mocha and Mobiles. Mayhem, of journalism in the modern newsroom. because that’s what it was like reporting days there were very during a conflict. Mochas, because The gala dinner is always a highlight of modern day journalism is like a modern the conference and the reception at few jobs. day coffee shop: just as you can’t just Belfast City Hall did not disappoint. ask for a coffee anymore, journalists Delegates were treated to a three can’t just write a report without being course meal with an after dinner distracted by tweets, blogs and internet “We came out of it address from Ray Snoddy OBE. Awards breakers. And mobiles, because, were also presented to the top Simpson felt, new recruits were too luckily, hopefully we’ll performing NCTJ-accredited courses reliant on their phones and should get for 2010-11 and to Amanda Ball, the down to some old-fashioned come out of this one but recipient of the Chairman’s Award. networking. things will be different, Speaking at the event, NCTJ chief Following the session, delegates at the executive Joanne Butcher, said: “We’re conference attended specialist things will have thrilled to be in Belfast because it has workshops in different areas of such an interesting and illustrious journalism, including finance, health, changed, and we have background in journalism and international and lifestyle. to be in as good a journalism training. The trip was rounded off by an open-top “Belfast is a beautiful, historic city and bus tour, taking in the city’s main position as possible to it’s just made to have a party.” attractions including the Harland and Wolff shipyards, Stormont and the cope so this 60th Day two was spent at the University of murals on the Shankill and Falls Roads. Ulster York Street campus, where the And, if you look closely on one of the anniversary conference main session was entitled Architects of peace walls, the names of a variety of Peace: The media in Northern Ireland. editors, journalists and lecturers have for the NCTJ forms a Chairing the session was Professor been inscribed (on an official graffiti central part of that Martin McLoone, director of the Centre space of course), ensuring the NCTJ left for Media Research at the University of its mark on the city in more ways than process.” Ulster. He was joined by Fearghal one. McKinney, SDLP communications ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 23

Ed Curran, Michael Cairns and Noel Doran

Ed Curran, editor-in-chief of Independent News and Media Amanda Ball, senior lecturer, Northern Ireland and NCTJ board Nottingham Trent University, member, was a reporter during the NCTJ principal examiner Troubles. He recounts the role that journalists played in the conflict:

“Nowhere in these islands has provided Amanda Ball is no stranger to the work of the NCTJ and her dedication a bigger test of the journalist than was rewarded last year, as the latest recipient of the NCTJ’s annual Northern Ireland during the past four Chairman’s Award. decades. “The province is thankfully at peace The winner is nominated by their peers and the award is designed to today compared to the years of violence celebrate the individual’s outstanding contribution to high standards of when a generation of journalists faced journalism training. the challenge of reporting on a deeply divided society at war with itself, in much the same way as we see coverage “Standards in the media, and in the press in of other foreign trouble-spots today. particular, have never been as heavily scrutinised as “The same basic requirements – they are today, so the education of the next balanced, objective, impartial, investigative, accurate, fair reporting – generation of journalists is a key priority,” Amanda said. remain as essential in Syria, Iraq or Afghanistan as they did for a whole Amanda first became involved in the NCTJ’s work in 1993 when she joined generation of journalists covering the public affairs board. She was swiftly promoted to chair of the board in Northern Ireland. 1994, only recently stepping down after 16 years of service. “In conflict, the characteristics of good journalists stand out and many Amanda was also the first to be appointed as an NCTJ principal examiner who cut their teeth in the raw streets of and advises on quality assurance and standards issues. Most recently, she Belfast during the troubles went on to has been involved in writing the programme of study and assessments for become editors and distinguished broadcast journalism regulation. correspondents at home and abroad. “For journalists born and bred in In addition, Amanda is also a member of the NCTJ’s media law and Northern Ireland, there was the photography exam boards and a regular commentator on local radio on additional pressure of reporting on their media law and public affairs related issues. own society. What they were reporting upon impinged on their own lives and Amanda carries out her work for the NCTJ alongside her job as a senior families yet they carried out their duties lecturer in journalism at Nottingham Trent University, for which she for local newspapers, television and radio without fear or favour. recently won an award for outstanding teaching. She teaches media law, ethics and regulation and public administration on both the undergraduate “Times have changed very much for the and postgraduate programmes. better in Northern Ireland but the role played by the written and broadcast media should not be forgotten. The politicians built the peace process but journalism had its role as well.” 24 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Journalism Diversity Fund 2012-13 recipients at the 2012 Celebratory Lunch It has been a record Sky, one of the UK’s largest “If it wasn’t for the breaking year for the entertainment and communication Journalism Diversity Fund. providers, has agreed to provide financial support to the fund as well as Journalism Diversity in-kind backing through mentoring and The first round of bursaries for 2012 saw work placements for bursary recipients. a record number of applications Fund I would never submitted to the fund (in a bursary Andy Cairns, executive editor of Sky round) since its launch in 2005. Seventy Sports News, said: “Sky as a business have made it this far to one application forms were submitted - recognises the value of having a diverse a 54 percent increase on the same time range of voices on and off screen to my dream job. It gave last year. reflect the diversity of our customers.

To date, the Journalism Diversity Fund “I am a strong supporter of Journalism me the opportunity to has helped 130 people pursue a career in Diversity Fund recipients and that journalism. Thanks to an annual includes mentoring people who have a be on a par with other contribution from the Newspaper true passion and flair for journalism who Licensing Agency, and financial support may not have been able to make it in aspiring journalists from Associated Newspapers, The Scott this industry without the fund. Trust and Sky, the industry-driven “I’m proud that Sky is the first bursary scheme has been helping to and I am very grateful broadcaster to support the Journalism increase diversity in UK newsrooms by Diversity Fund and contributing to the funding socially and ethnically diverse to the bursary for that. bursary is just one of the many ways students on NCTJ-accredited courses. that we will continue to encourage the Applicants must demonstrate their best talent from all walks of life into a The bursary was a diversity, as well as their determination, great career”. commitment and potential to succeed in real lifeline for me the profession. They must not have the High profile support financial means to study NCTJ training The following journalists and editors so it is definitely courses at universities, colleges or have recently participated in the private training providers. selection process: Dave Betts, senior worthwhile.” So far, for the 2012-2013 academic year, home news editor, Sky News; Henry 106 people have applied for a bursary Bonsu, director and presenter, Colourful Lucy Roue, bursary recipient, 2011-12 from the Journalism Diversity Fund - 27 Radio; Marverine Cole, freelance TV were invited for interview and 12 have journalist and broadcaster; Graham been awarded a bursary. Dudman, editorial development director, News International; Paul Sky signs up as new sponsor Durrant, freelance journalist and trainer; Alan Geere, editor, Essex The Journalism Diversity Fund has Chronicle; Colleen Harris, broadcast expanded into broadcast media with journalist and presenter, BBC Essex; support from Sky. ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 25

Barry Hunt, commercial editor, Archant material will be used on the Journalism Herts and Cambs; Janine La Rosa, Diversity Fund website, social media diversity manager, BskyB; Lisa Macleod, channels and careers websites. managing editor, Financial Times; Alice The diversity fund wants to strengthen Ryan, content editor, Cambridge the links with past recipients, ensuring Magazines; Sathnam Sanghera, that we maintain a connection with our journalist, The Times; Bob Satchwell, alumni and provide continued support. executive director, Society of Editors; To that end, an alumni survey has been Adrian Seal, deputy editor, Ealing developed and will be circulated to all Gazette; Vijay Sharma, former Head of past recipients. The results will be BBC Asian Network; Suzy Talbot, deputy analysed to determine any changes that editor, Harrow Observer; Laurie Tucker, need to be made. day news editor, Sky Sports News; Andy Veale, group editor, Archant. Celebratory lunch 2011-2012 recipients: where are they now? The celebratory lunch is always the Shabana Adam Kirsten Elder highlight of the Journalism Diversity Fund calendar. It is a chance for supporters of the fund to meet those receiving the bursaries while giving recipients a chance to network with journalism industry professionals. Over 60 people attended the annual celebratory reception and lunch this year, hosted by Associated Newspapers in London on Thursday 20 September. Having completed an MA in magazine Kirsten has completed work experience Robin Esser, executive managing editor journalism at the University of Central at the Belfast Waterfront Hall, the of the Daily Mail, welcomed guests and Lancashire, Shabana is now working as Belfast News Letter and the Coleraine Brien Beharrell, vice chairman of the parenting and travel editor for online Chronicle. lifestyle magazine, Female First. NCTJ accepted a cheque for £100,000 She now works as a freelance journalist from David Pugh, managing director of Course: MA Magazine Journalism for her local papers, while working the Newspaper Licensing Agency. Centre: University of Central part-time at Downtown Radio in Lancashire Northern Ireland. Course: Diploma in Journalism Rebecca Bastable Centre: Belfast Metropolitan College

Jake May

Attendees heard speeches from Andy Cairns, executive editor, Sky Sports News, who explained why Sky had While studying for her NCTJ chosen to support the fund; and past qualification, Rebecca completed work bursary recipients Robert Payling and experience at The Argus and the Since 2012, Jake has secured work Shabana Adam, who explained how the Chichester Observer. experience at various publications, fund helped them to begin their career She is now working as a junior reporter including The Bath Chronicle, The Herald, in journalism. at the Chichester Observer. Buzz and Swansea Life Magazine. He is currently freelancing for music Future plans Course: Fast-track Diploma in magazine, DIY. Journalism A promotional video is being produced Centre: Highbury College to explain the importance of the Course: MA Journalism diversity fund. Once complete, the Centre: Kingston University 26 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Natasha Millar Lucy Roue “I was only able to study a postgraduate journalism degree because of the help I received from the Having gained experience working at Lucy has previous experience as an Q Radio Network, NewBlue Media and editorial assistant at ncjMedia in Journalism Diversity Radio Media in Northern Ireland, Newcastle. She is now working as a Natasha is currently working as a trainee reporter for The Sentinel Fund. The course trainee cross-platform journalist at newspaper in Stoke-on-Trent while ITN’s regional news channel, UTV. working towards her National helped me develop my Certificate Examination (NCE). Course: MA Journalism Centre: University of Ulster Course: Multimedia Journalism news writing skills Foundation Jamie Nield-Siddall Centre: Press Association, Newcastle and equipped me with NCE success for Diversity Fund alumni knowledge of media Two journalists who started their law, which is vital careers with the help of the Journalism Diversity Fund have achieved senior for any journalist reporter status by passing the National Certificate Examination in July 2012. Hayley O’Keeffe, who studied a fast- working in a While studying for his NCTJ track course at noSWeat journalism qualification, Jamie completed a weekly training after receiving a bursary in professional newsroom. placement at The Daily Post and 2008, is now a reporter at the submitted stories to The TV Collective. Bedfordshire Times and Gazette. Former He is now working for NMN Media in The Journalism bursary recipient Amanda Hall now north Wales as a trainee reporter. works as a reporter for the Maidenhead Diversity fund gave Course: Multimedia Diploma in Advertiser, following her completion of Journalism an MA in journalism at the University of me my lucky break” Centre: News Associates, Manchester Sheffield. Robert Payling, University of Sheffield, 2010-11 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 27

Distance learning and publications Kate Palmer

Distance learning Kate also made sure she got plenty of Mike Dodd and Mark Hanna explain what work experience. She was editor of is involved in the writing process and More than 300 people have enrolled Trinity News, her university newspaper, offer their views on what the Leveson on the distance learning programme from May 2011 to May 2012 and Inquiry will mean for future editions. completed work placements at The since its launch in 2011. By Mike Dodd’s own admission, McNae’s Argus (Brighton), YouGov and the Mail Essential Law for Journalists is the first The five mandatory modules (reporting, Online. She has also worked for the Irish book he’s ever written. It is another portfolio, essential public affairs, Daily Star as a freelance sub since achievement to add to his list, including essential media law and shorthand) are September 2011. Chairman’s legal editor at Press Association and available for purchase as a ‘core skills package’. The work experience, putting the skills editor of Media Lawyer. He has worked she learned into practice, and shorthand as a journalist for 40 years and is also a Fourreport out of the seven specialist options proved to be the most rewarding parts qualified barrister. are currently available as distance of the course for Kate and she was not So when he was approached to co- learning modules: media law court short on support: reporting, sports journalism, production author the book, with senior lecturer in journalism and business of magazines. “Studying on my own was not too journalism at the University of Sheffield The new business and finance module difficult because everything was and award-winning crime and will be offered in the coming year and provided in the course materials. investigations reporter, Mark Hanna, he videojournalism for online is being I needed clarification on the portfolio PA said it was “an honour” to be asked. developed. assignment and found the tutor very Both are all too familiar with the book, helpful and she responded to me very having studied it from cover to cover to quickly.” complete their NCTJ Proficiency Distance learning case Certificate. Kate is currently concentrating on study completing her degree and, equipped Kate Palmer, from East Sussex, with an NCTJ Diploma, hopes to be completed the Diploma in Journalism ready for a job in journalism when she by distance learning in just one year graduates in 2013. and achieved the NCTJ gold standard: A-C grades in all diploma subjects and Publications 100wpm shorthand. The NCTJ continues to offer a wide The 22-year-old completed the diploma range of publications for trainee from September 2011 to September 2012 journalists and journalism students. while studying full-time for an MA in History and Political Science at Trinity The 21st edition of McNae’s Essential College, The University of Dublin. Law for Journalists was launched by Lord Hunt in March 2012 at the NCTJ “Because I study and work in Ireland, Media Law Seminar. It has been I wanted to do a course recognised authored by Mike Dodd and Mark Hanna. in the UK,” she said. “The distance learning course was more cost-effective; Described by Lord Hunt of the Press I could do the NCTJ qualification on top Complaints Commission as “an of my studies and wouldn’t have to take institution in its own right”, McNae’s on another year of full-time study after a Essential Media Law for Journalists is four year degree.” now in its 21st edition. New author team 28

Lord Hunt launches the 21st edition of McNae’s Essential Law for Journalists

“When I sat the exam many years ago, and Mark have a combined experience upcoming editions. It will fall to Mark I probably used the 3rd or 4th edition; of over 60 years in journalism to draw and Mike to use the book to guide their I just learned the book by heart. The on: “We like to aim things at the middle readers through this transitional period. plain fact is, you just couldn’t do that market: we’re not quite The Times and This is a responsibility they take now,” said Mike. not quite The Sun.” seriously and the changes made to the latest edition show their willingness to For the 21st edition, the pair were given “It’s a compromise and a challenge,” adapt to change and listen to their the unenviable task of packing the says Mark. “It needs to be accessible to Chairman’s readers. At this critical juncture, it is largest amount of legal regulation the students and trainees, for those coming clear the book dubbed the ‘media law industry has seen into a slimmed down to law for the first time, but it needs to Bible’ is in good hands. versionreport of the book. In response to be detailed and useful to experienced feedback from readers, the book has professionals who may need to stand up undergone a number of changes, in court and refer to it.” A new edition of Public Affairs for including a new visual design, easier “In the end, the aim is to avoid becoming Journalists, by James Morrison, PA cross referencing and more real-life too legalistic, as it turns people off and tutor at Kingston University and case studies. it’s also very dull,” added Mike. “If you NCTJ chief examiner for PA is to be But as media law continues to evolve, so listen to a good barrister in court they released in 2013. the process of updating the book is will put things in a way that will interest becoming a more demanding job, taking those they’re talking to.” almost two years to complete. Add to With the next edition due out at the end this the job of updating the of 2013, it’s no secret that it will be accompanying online resource website influenced by the findings of the and the authors can’t have much spare Leveson Inquiry. Mark points out that time on their hands. the 21st edition has already been “The Oxford University Press start affected by the changing regulatory reviewing when the edition comes out world, with more emphasis on and within the six or seven months after regulation and compliance. These it’s published, they email me with a chapters can now be found at the start timetable for the next edition,” said of the book in recognition of the rapidly Mark, who is also a member of the NCTJ changing media landscape. media law board. “We will probably start While Mike has reservations about the writing seriously sometime in the spring effect that a statutory regulatory body for an edition which will be published in would have on the press, he stressed October 2013. It’s a continuous process there is a difference between the really- not much time off.” Leveson report and the actions Mike added that, as the authors, the resulting from it: “The real question is: buck stops with them: “We are fortunate what happens after he (Lord Justice to have barristers willing to read for us Leveson) makes his recommendations? and solicitors who could contribute but, One wonders if there is enough political ultimately, you have to take will to make statutory changes that may responsibility for what you write.” be recommended.” And it is a heavy responsibility, as the Although it is not clear how far reaching book is used by journalism students, the repercussions of the Leveson tutors, seasoned reporters and editors. Inquiry will be, ethics, regulation and NCTJ chief executive Joanne Butcher Mike said, when it comes to writing for media standards will undoubtedly be at speaking at Media Law Seminar such a diverse audience, it helps that he the forefront of media law issues in ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 29

Short courses

The NCTJ has been delivering gold Newport Business Association (NBA) on our hard work at Newport Station, as standard training to journalists for has steadily grown its media coverage well as Essex Bee Keepers’ Association the last 60 years, and we apply the with expert help and guidance from the commenting on how NBA is making a same standard to our short courses. NCTJ. Regular reporting and media bee and butterfly friendly habitat at In addition to training journalists, we stories in the local press, regional radio Newport station. We were then reported also train anyone who needs and national papers has enabled NBA to in the local press for this coverage. journalistic skills. have a voice in the community. Jeremy Overall we raised further funds and Rose, founder of Newport Business developed local community support to SubjectsChairman’s that we cover include writing Association, has attended two training develop the initiative further. We want and sub editing, media law, grammar courses with the NCTJ. our green corridor to radiate out to and proofreading and video reporting. other areas and create a bee-line to Jeremy notes: “We’re very proud of our Wereport also run NCE and diploma refreshers Newport.” association with NCTJ. A national and in advance of national exam dates. internationally renowned organisation The NCTJ can also organise in-house located locally for our members. Our bespoke training for businesses in both members can receive expert media the UK and abroad. The courses are training from international experts on a designed to deliver transferrable number of courses: how to write journalistic skills in order to boost effective press releases, construct web business communications. Course sites for maximum impact, creating the mediums include print, video, audio and right image and developing media skills the web. Each trainer is an experienced to capture the interest of editors, journalist who is handpicked for each reporters and the public alike. course’s particular requirements and “NCTJ offers us qualified training that teachs the relevant skills delegates has enabled us to promote our ethos, need. In the past year, we have community projects and business developed in-house courses for standards. We understand the structure companies in a variety of sectors, of getting a press release into the media including media, transport, energy and environment, and in such a competitive public sector. market for news stories, how important it is to develop the right image, right format, to make it easier for media Some of the courses available people to use our material. We feel include: confident we can communicate and promote Newport’s thriving business • Grammar and proofreading skills community to the most important • Interviewing skills people in the business: our customers. • Journalism skills for PR • News and feature writing “One major success was the promotion • The essentials of media law of our Newport Railway Station • The essentials of sub editing initiative – The Lavender Line. We • The new editor created press releases for the local Jeremy Rose, Newport Business Association • Video and audio reporting media, and were delighted when BBC Founder, celebrates media success thanks to for the web Radio Essex picked up the story and ran NCTJ media training courses • Writing for the web a Saturday prime-time slot highlighting our initiative. We had Greater Anglia, a national railway company commenting 30 ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12

Business and finance review

The net incoming resources of the developing products and services to wealth and Investment and the directors group amounted to £55,791 (2011: net meet the needs of a wider more diverse are satisfied with its performance. outgoing resources £189,996). After media industry, is now seeing results Reserves the deduction of net realised and with increased growth providing finance unrealised losses on investments of to further improve and expand our It is the aim of the directors to generate £26,619, (2011: net gain £34,371) there services. The directors consider the surpluses sufficient to maintain was a total increase of funds state of affairs of the charity to be adequate resources, in line with the amounting to £29,172 (2011: £155,265 satisfactory. Board’s policy, to meet risks associated deficit). There was, exclusive of the with the various income streams, The industry charitable fund, the Journalism Diversity Fund a trading expenditure plans and balance sheet Journalism Diversity Fund, is managed surplus of £37,753 partially reduced items. and administered by the NCTJ as a by revaluations on investments to ‘restricted fund’. Donations of The principal income sources are: £11,134 (2011: £26,567 deficit). £100,000, £25,000, £15,000 and donations from per capita members; The NCTJ has continued to invest in £5,000 were received from the income from registration and new technology, communications, Newspaper Licensing Agency (NLA), examination fees; sales of publications, distance learning courses and Scott Trust, BSkyB and Daily Mail and distance learning packages and training qualifications. A new broadcast option General Trust respectively (2011: materials; accreditation fees; donations was delivered at four pilot centres and is £130,000). The NLA is committed to a to the Journalism Diversity Fund; and now available to all providers running further donation of £100,000 in the investment income. NCTJ courses. A further specialist next year. option in business and finance Structure and governance journalism was developed during the Investment powers, policy year, strengthening the diploma and performance The National Council for the Training of qualification. Evolutionary changes to Journalist is a registered charity. The the National Certificate Examination are Under the Memorandum and Articles of training activities of the group are also being implemented. The short Association, the NCTJ has the power to carried out by NCTJ Training Ltd, a course programme was reviewed and make investments in such securities, wholly owned subsidiary. property and other investments as the revamped with a resulting increase in New directors are recommended and sales. The strategy for the charity, directors see fit. The Charity’s portfolio appointed by the directors. The number incorporating in investment in is invested with the advice of Investec of directors is not subject to any maximum but is not less than three. Statement of accounts 2011-12 2010-11 A director’s term of office is three years, Incoming resources £1,062,442 £901,047 renewable for a further three years, Expenditure £1,006,651 £1,091,043 and, in exceptional circumstances; Operating surplus/(deficit) for the year £55,791 (£189,996) another three years. Consisting of: Restricted fund surplus/deficit £18,038 (£128,698) Charitable contribution Trading deficit/surplus £37,753 (£61,298) During the year NCTJ Training Limited Balance Sheet as at 30 June 2012 made a charitable donation under deed Tangible fixed assets £480,124 £492,984 of covenant of £81,813 (2011: £4,042) to Investments £351,762 £378,380 its holding company, The National Current assets £603,501 £524,886 Council for the Training of Journalists, a Current liabilities £153,954 £143,989 registered charity (No: 1026685). Net current assets £449,547 £380,897 Net assets £1,281,433 £1,252,261 Notes 1. This financial information does not constitute statutory accounts within the meaning of Section 394 of the Companies Act 2006. 2. Copies of the full statutory accounts are available on request

ANNUAL REPORT 2011-12 31

Who we are

NCTJ board of directors JOURNALISM QUALIFICATIONS Chas Watkin, editor, You and Yours, BOARD BBC Radio 4 CHAIRMAN: Kim Fletcher, managing director, Joy Yates, editor, Hartlepool Mail Brunswick PR CHAIRMAN: Stephen Mitchell, deputy director, VICE-CHAIRMAN: Brien Beharrell, editorial BBC News Joanne Butcher, chief executive director, Newbury News Group Amanda Ball, NCTJ principal examiner Sue Campbell, managing director, Media Marie Cartwright, chief examiner, shorthand Messages and further education representative QUALITY ASSURANCE AND Edmund Curran, editor-in-chief, Independent Cathy Duncan, chief examiner, production STANDARDS COMMITTEE News and Media Northern Ireland journalism Chris Elliott, readers’ editor, The Guardian Mark Hanna, chief examiner, media law CHAIRMAN: Sean Dooley Jan Lever, managing director, Newsquest Catherine Houlihan, chief examiner, broadcast Amanda Ball, NCTJ principal examiner Blackburn, Bolton and Kendal journalism Tom Hill, Up to Speed Media Donald Martin, editor, Sunday Post Helen Hutchinson, chief examiner, Barry Hunt, Archant Stephen Mitchell, deputy director, BBC News videojournalism for online Peter Moutray, Highbury College Alison Moore, director of finance and company Janet Jones, chief examiner, public affairs Sarah Niblock, Brunel University secretary, Newspaper Licensing Agency Dave King, chief examiner, sports journalism Steve Panter, journalist and senior lecturer, Steve Nelson, chief examiner, reporting Joanne Butcher, chief executive University of Salford Steve Phillips, chief examiner, press Lyn Jones, head of qualifications John Ryley, head of Sky News photography and photojournalism Helen Tindle, head of examinations Bob Satchwell, executive director, Society of David Rowell, industry representative Editors Sarah Rowlands, education representative Malcolm Vickers, group director of human resources, Johnston Press Joanne Butcher, chief executive Neil White, editor, Derby Telegraph Lyn Jones, head of qualifications Russell Whitehair, chairman, NWN Media

Joanne Butcher, chief executive ACCREDITATION BOARD Chris Dunham, company secretary CHAIRMAN: Chris Elliott, readers’ editor, The Guardian NCTJ STAFF Andy Cairns, executive editor, Sky Sports News Paul Connolly, managing editor, Belfast Jan Alder, PA to chief executive Telegraph Katie Burgess, examinations administrator Graham Dudman, editorial development Joanne Butcher, chief executive director, News International Emma Clark, marketing and communications Tom Hill, course director, Up to Speed Media manager David Holmes, lecturer, University of Sheffield Chris Dunham, head of finance and IT Dave King, head of news, Sussex Newspapers Lisa Edmonds, examinations controller Roz McKenzie, course leader, Lambeth College Shevon Houston, events and website manager Ian Reeves, director of learning and teaching, Lyn Jones, head of qualifications University of Kent Centre for Journalism Lisa Nelson, Journalism Diversity Fund intern Michelle Stanistreet, general secretary, Hayley Poulter, examinations controller National Union of Journalists Helen Tindle, head of examinations

NCTJ The New Granary, Station Road Newport, Saffron Walden Essex CB11 3PL

Tel: 01799 544014 Fax: 01799 544015 Email: [email protected] www.nctj.com