materials
Review Acoustic Properties of Innovative Concretes: A Review
Roman Fediuk 1 , Mugahed Amran 2,3,*, Nikolai Vatin 4 , Yuriy Vasilev 5, Valery Lesovik 6,7 and Togay Ozbakkaloglu 8
1 Polytechnic Institute, Far Eastern Federal University, 690922 Vladivostok, Russia; [email protected] 2 Department of Civil Engineering, College of Engineering, Prince Sattam Bin Abdulaziz University, Alkharj 11942, Saudi Arabia 3 Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering and IT, Amran University, Amran 9677, Yemen 4 Peter the Great St. Petersburg Polytechnic University, 195251 St. Petersburg, Russia; [email protected] 5 Department of Road-Building Materials, Moscow Automobile and Road Construction University, 125319 Moscow, Russia; [email protected] 6 Belgorod State Technological University named after V. G. Shoukhov, 308012 Belgorod, Russia; [email protected] 7 Research Institute of Building Physics, The Russian Academy of Architecture and Building Sciences, 127238 Moscow, Russia 8 Ingram School of Engineering, Texas State University, San Marcos, TX 78667, USA; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected]
Abstract: Concrete is the most common building material; therefore, when designing structures, it is obligatory to consider all structural parameters and design characteristics such as acoustic properties. In particular, this is to ensure comfortable living conditions for people in residential premises, including acoustic comfort. Different types of concrete behave differently as a sound conductor; especially dense mixtures are superior sound reflectors, and light ones are sound absorbers. It is found that the level of sound reflection in modified concrete is highly dependent on the type of aggregates, size and distribution of pores, and changes in concrete mix design constituents. The sound absorption of acoustic insulation concrete (AIC) can be improved by forming open pores in concrete matrices by either using a porous aggregate or foam agent. To this end, this article reviews the noise and sound transmission in buildings, types of acoustic insulating materials, and Citation: Fediuk, R.; Amran, M.; Vatin, N.; Vasilev, Y.; Lesovik, V.; the AIC properties. This literature study also provides a critical review on the type of concretes, Ozbakkaloglu, T. Acoustic Properties the acoustic insulation of buildings and their components, the assessment of sound insulation of of Innovative Concretes: A Review. structures, as well as synopsizes the research development trends to generate comprehensive insights Materials 2021, 14, 398. https:// into the potential applications of AIC as applicable material to mitigate noise pollution for increase doi.org/10.3390/ma14020398 productivity, health, and well-being.
Received: 30 November 2020 Keywords: concrete; noise; acoustic properties; sound-absorbing; sound-reflecting Accepted: 13 January 2021 Published: 14 January 2021
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neu- 1. Introduction tral with regard to jurisdictional clai- ms in published maps and institutio- Building regulations and planning authorities have not properly focused on resolving nal affiliations. the ongoing issue of noise pollution faced by the residents of urban areas [1]. Typically, concrete is used as an external cladding to inhibit the propagation of sound transmission, which reflects the sound waves away from the structure [2]. Although the sound waves get reflected away, its magnitude does not reduce and becomes an issue in enclosed Copyright: © 2021 by the authors. Li- spaces such as apartment complexes, factories, and narrow thoroughfares, respectively censee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. (see Figure1 )[3,4]. As a result, this leads to several problems such as masked warning This article is an open access article signals, higher chances of impaired hearing, and increased work-related stresses [5]. distributed under the terms and con- ditions of the Creative Commons At- tribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/).
Materials 2021, 14, 398. https://doi.org/10.3390/ma14020398 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/materials Materials 2021, 14, 398 2 of 28 Materials 2021, 14, x FOR PEER REVIEW 2 of 28
Figure 1. 1. SoundSound waves waves reflections reflections in ina surrounded a surrounded narrow narrow thoroughfare thoroughfare [3]. [Reprinted3]. Reprinted with withper- permis- mission from Elsevier [3]. sion from Elsevier [3].
Concrete is is a awidespread widespread and and cheap cheap structural structural material material for the for construction the construction of resi- of resi- dential buildings of any volume and number of storeys [6]. During the construction and dential buildings of any volume and number of storeys [6]. During the construction and operation of these buildings, it is necessary to ensure comfortable living conditions for operation of these buildings, it is necessary to ensure comfortable living conditions for people [7]. The most important step along this path is ensuring the acoustic well-being people [7]. The most important step along this path is ensuring the acoustic well-being of of residents through the optimal design of building envelopes [8–10]. Usually, when a residents through the optimal design of building envelopes [8–10]. Usually, when a sound sound wave strikes or hits the surface of a building, the sound energy gets absorbed, wavetransmitted, strikes or or reflectedhits thesurface away [11]. of a Hence, building, there the is sound a relationship energy gets between absorbed, the incident transmitted, orenergy reflected and the away absorbed, [11]. Hence,transmitted, there or is reflected a relationship energy between[12]. The theabsorption incident of energysound and thein a absorbed,porous material transmitted, is related or reflectedto the loss energy in energy [12]. wherein The absorption the incident of sound noise energyin a porous materialconverts isto relatedheat energy to the and loss some in energy other whereinenergies thedue incidentto vibration, noise friction, energy and converts air vis- to heat energycosity [13,14]. and some Sound other insulation energies is duethe tosound vibration, transmission friction, loss and of air the viscosity building [ 13partition,14]. Sound insulation[15,16]. Lightweight is the sound porous transmission materials absorb loss of sound the building well, while partition heavyweight [15,16]. and Lightweight hard porousmaterials materials reflect a absorbsignificant sound portion well, of while sound heavyweight energy [3]. Despite and hard the fact materials that there reflect are a sig- nificantsome studies portion on ofthe sound acoustic energy behavior [3]. Despite of different the concrete fact that material, there are it some is necessary studies to on the acousticsystematize behavior the current of different state of concrete sound-insulation material, it concrete is necessary composites to systematize and structures the current statemade ofof sound-insulationthem [17,18]. concrete composites and structures made of them [17,18]. To reduce reduce build build time, time, labor labor savings, savings, and thermal and thermal efficiency, efficiency, most architects most architects and de- and designerssigners prefer prefer the theuse use of insulated of insulated concrete concrete forms. forms. However, However, the acoustic the acoustic properties properties of of these insulated insulated concrete concrete forms forms are are often often overlooked overlooked or under or under looked. looked. To provide To provide better better acoustic properties, properties, the the use use of of acoustic acoustic insulation insulation concrete concrete (AIC) (AIC) is a isrecent a recent advancement advancement in the field field of of concrete concrete te technology.chnology. The The acoustic acoustic component component installed installed in an in AIC an AICreduces reduces the sound in in the the building building structure structure and and keeps keeps the the pollution pollution created created by noise by noise at bay at while bay while improving the the acoustical acoustical effects effects of of the the sound sound generated generated within. within. To achieve To achieve a desired a desired acoustic protection, the the installation installation of of an an AIC AIC wall wall can can provide provide excellent excellent exterior exterior insula- insulation astion well as well as a soundproofingas a soundproofing envelope. envelope. Due Due to a betterto a better soundproofing soundproofing envelope, envelope, AIC AIC becomes abecomes suitable a choice suitable for choice hotels, for airports, hotels, and airports, schools and where schools the requirement where the requirement of thick traditional of thick traditional walls can be eliminated. Meanwhile, the use of lightweight concretes walls can be eliminated. Meanwhile, the use of lightweight concretes such as foam or fabric such as foam or fabric are usually porous and do not allow sound to be reflected. As a are usually porous and do not allow sound to be reflected. As a result, the sound passes result, the sound passes through the porous medium, and the energy gets converted to through the porous medium, and the energy gets converted to heat while reducing its heat while reducing its magnitude [3]. Hence, the use of lightweight concrete is effective magnitude [3]. Hence, the use of lightweight concrete is effective when used in movie halls when used in movie halls or in recording studios. This reduces the resonance time in the orroom in recording [19,20]. Although studios. theThis use reduces of lightweight the resonance concrete time is in effective the room internally, [19,20]. Although it is not the usesuitable of lightweight in external conditions, concrete is and effective hence, internally, concrete is it still is not the suitablepreferred in material external for conditions, oth- and hence, concrete is still the preferred material for other commercial and residential building structures. Based on the past researchers, it was reported that various types of concrete behave differently as a sound conductor; especially dense mixtures are superior
Materials 2021, 14, x FOR PEER REVIEW 3 of 28
er commercial and residential building structures. Based on the past researchers, it was reported that various types of concrete behave differently as a sound conductor; espe- cially dense mixtures are superior sound reflectors, and light ones are sound absorbers. It is found that the level of sound reflection in modified concrete depends on the type of aggregates, size, and distribution of pores and changes in concrete mix design constitu- ents. The sound absorption of AIC is enhanced by forming open pores in concrete ma- trices by either using a porous aggregate or foam agent. To this end, this article reviews the noise and sound transmission in buildings, types of acoustic insulating materials, and the acoustic properties. This literature study also delivers a comprehensive review on the type of concretes, the acoustic insulation of buildings and their components, the assessment of sound insulation of structures, as well as to synopsize the research devel- Materials 2021, 14, 398 opment trends to generate comprehensive insights into the potential applications of AIC3 of 28 as applicable material to mitigate noise pollution for increase productivity, health, and well-being.
sound2. Transmission reflectors, andof Noise light and ones Sound are sound in Buildings absorbers. It is found that the level of sound reflection in modified concrete depends on the type of aggregates, size, and distribution of To produce a noise and sound-proof AIC, the walls and roofs of a building could be pores and changes in concrete mix design constituents. The sound absorption of AIC is engineered with modifications on the level at which the sound energy (Figure 2a) [21]: enhanced by forming open pores in concrete matrices by either using a porous aggregate or foam agent.Reflects To back this from end, the this building article reviewswall, the noise and sound transmission in buildings, types Absorbs of acoustic within insulating the wall, materials, and and the acoustic properties. This literature study also deliversTransmits a comprehensivethrough the building review wall. on the type of concretes, the acoustic insulation of buildingsStructural and their elements components, such as theglazing assessment and roof of lights sound, which insulation can reduce of structures, the perfor- as well asmance to synopsize, should thealso research be considered. development The transmission trends to generateof noise between comprehensive different insights zones of into thea building potential structure applications is shown of AICin Figure as applicable 2b. Two types material of noise to mitigatetransmission noise occur: pollution direct for increaseand flanking productivity, transmission health,, and and noise well-being. is transmitted when any two areas are separated from each other. The noise travels in two separate routes [22,23]: (i) through the separa- 2.tion Transmission structure, which of Noise is termed and Sound direct intransmission Buildings, and (ii) around the separation struc- ture through adjoining structural elements, which is termed flanking transmission To produce a noise and sound-proof AIC, the walls and roofs of a building could be [21,24]. Meanwhile, the insulation of sound for both types of transmission is controlled engineered with modifications on the level at which the sound energy (Figure2a) [21]: by its mass, isolation, and sealing characteristics [22,25]. The direct transmission of noise • canReflects be determined back from by laboratory the building tests wall,, since it directly depends on the properties of the • separationAbsorbs wall within and thefloor wall, [26]. and Meanwhile, the details of junctions between the structural • elementsTransmits make through it challenging the building to predict wall. the flanking transmission of noise [23,27,28].
(a) (b)
FigureFigure 2. Noise 2. Noise and and sound sound transmission transmission in in a a building. building. ((aa)) FactorsFactors of acoustic insulation insulation performance; performance; (b) ( bFlanking) Flanking and and direct transmissions of sound between different zones [21]. Reprinted with permission from DATA STEEL [21]. direct transmissions of sound between different zones [21]. Reprinted with permission from DATA STEEL [21].
StructuralIt should elementsbe noted suchthat at as various glazing conditions, and roof lights, the sepa whichration can wall reduce could the be performance, of high shouldstandard also AIC be considered., while the side The transmissionwall could be of of noise low betweenstandard, different which is zones continuous of a building be- structure is shown in Figure2b. Two types of noise transmission occur: direct and flanking transmission, and noise is transmitted when any two areas are separated from each other. The noise travels in two separate routes [22,23]: (i) through the separation structure, which is termed direct transmission, and (ii) around the separation structure through adjoining structural elements, which is termed flanking transmission [21,24]. Meanwhile, the insulation of sound for both types of transmission is controlled by its mass, isolation, and sealing characteristics [22,25]. The direct transmission of noise can be determined by laboratory tests, since it directly depends on the properties of the separation wall and floor [26]. Meanwhile, the details of junctions between the structural elements make it challenging to predict the flanking transmission of noise [23,27,28]. It should be noted that at various conditions, the separation wall could be of high standard AIC, while the side wall could be of low standard, which is continuous between the rooms. In such cases, flanking transmission can propagate more noise than direct transmission [21]. Hence, the joints between the separation elements should be properly detailed to minimize noise due to flanking transmission. Materials 2021, 14, x FOR PEER REVIEW 4 of 28
Materials 2021, 14, 398 tween the rooms. In such cases, flanking transmission can propagate more noise than4 of 28 direct transmission [21]. Hence, the joints between the separation elements should be properly detailed to minimize noise due to flanking transmission.
3.3. AIC Properties Properties The ability to reduce sound transmission through through a a structural structural element element is is what what de- defines thefines properties the properties of AIC. of AIC. Usually, Usually, concrete concrete is a is good a good insulator insulator of sound,of sound which, which can can reflect re- up toflect 99% up ofto its99% total of its energy. total energy. However, However, it is also it is a also relatively a relatively poor poor absorber absorber of sound of sound and can propagateand can propagate within enclosedwithin enclosed spaces, spaces causing, causing echoes echoes [29–32 [29].– Sound,32]. Sound, a form a form of energy, of en- can travelergy, can through travel mediumsthrough mediums of solid, of liquid, solid, andliquid, gas and in longitudinal gas in longitudinal wave bywave the by oscillation the ofoscillation vibrating of particlesvibrating [particle1,33]. Ass [1,33]. the soundAs the wavessound waves dissipate, dissipate, it gets it expandedgets expanded outward outward while distributing the intensity over a larger area. The larger the vibrating par- while distributing the intensity over a larger area. The larger the vibrating particles in the ticles in the medium, the more the energy that passes through the medium [34]. Mean- medium, the more the energy that passes through the medium [34]. Meanwhile, audible while, audible sounds are classified into two types: airborne and impact sounds. Air- sounds are classified into two types: airborne and impact sounds. Airborne sounds can be borne sounds can be recognized as speech, loudspeakers, and musical instruments, re- recognized as speech, loudspeakers, and musical instruments, respectively. These sounds spectively. These sounds waves travels through the air only and cannot travel through wavessolids [3]. travels The throughairborne the sound air only produces and cannot vibration travel in throughthe concrete solids, which [3]. The causes airborne the vi- sound producesbration of vibrationsuspended inparticles the concrete, on the other which side causes of the the wall, vibration thus, causing of suspended it to be heard. particles onOn thethe otherother hand, side of footsteps, the wall, clos thus,ing causingdoors, and it tofalling be heard. objectsOn are thecategorized other hand, as impact footsteps, closingsounds, doors,which can and vibrate falling between objects walls are categorized and floors, leading as impact to airborne sounds, noise which in adjoin- can vibrate betweening room wallss [2]. Typically, and floors, noise leading and tosound airborne differ noise from in each adjoining other, with rooms the [2 former]. Typically, being noise andsubjective sound and differ dependent from each on other,the receptor. with the Due former to it being subjectivesubjective, andarchitects dependent and de- on the receptor.signers should Due to consider it being reducing subjective, noise architects in the building, and designers in urban should areas consider in particular reducing [35]. noise inHowever, the building, since it in is urban challenging areas into particularlower the volume [35]. However, or the propagation since it is challenging of sound, noise to lower themitigation volume mea or thesures propagation should be of implemented sound, noise mitigation to bring down measures the level should of be annoyance implemented to[36,37]. bring In down this theregard, level remedial of annoyance measures [36 ,such37]. In as thisinsulation, regard, reflection, remedial measures and isolation such as insulation,provide the reflection,best ways to and reflect isolation sound provide energy the[3,26]. best ways to reflect sound energy [3,26].
4.4. Types of Acoustic Acoustic Insulating Insulating Materials Materials The commoncommon aspects concerning concerning the the conservation conservation of of acoustic acoustic energy energy according according to to the classicthe classic ratio ratio (1) (1) are are shown shown in in Figure Figure3. 3.
EEi i== EEr r++ EEee (1) (1)
where Ei—energy of sound falling on the building envelope; Er—reflected sound energy; where Ei—energy of sound falling on the building envelope; Er—reflected sound energy; e andand Ee——comprisescomprises the the absorption absorption and and transmission transmission of sound of sound energy. energy.
FigureFigure 3. SoundSound energy energy conservation conservation [14]. [14 Reprinted]. Reprinted with with permission permission from from Elsevier Elsevier [14]. [14].
For the design of enclosing structures, it is important to use extremely sound-absorbing or extremely sound-reflecting materials.
4.1. Sound-Absorbing The acoustic absorption coefficient α is computed using Equation (1) is expressed as (2).
E α = 1 − r (2) Ei Materials 2021, 14, x FOR PEER REVIEW 5 of 28
For the design of enclosing structures, it is important to use extremely sound-absorbing or extremely sound-reflecting materials.
4.1. Sound-Absorbing The acoustic absorption coefficient is computed using Equation (1) is expressed as Materials 2021, 14, 398 (2). 5 of 28