MIT . _ Continuous Cambridge _ews N Service . Massachusetts" I _ Since 1881
Tuesday, May 15, 1990 -_ A_ Volume 110, Number 27
I Protesters sa-y case is--nlaseu- By Andrea Lamnberti sixth-floor Faculty Club, where Ronald'W. Francis G-and Ste- Corporation members were eat- ven D. Penn G will appear before ing- lunch, eight --demonstrators the Committee-on Discipline fac- occupied the' only elevator that ing charges of assault and assault was programmed to go to the and battery on a police officer. sixth- floor. Penn and Francis assert that the Francis is also charged with as- cases are discriminatory and not sault and battery on a police offi- grdunded--in factual evidence, cer for allegedly kicking Officer and that the true motivation for Robert J. Molino while demon- the hearing is political harass- strators were trying to enter the ment. The exact date for the sixth floor from the stairwell of hearing has not been set, Penn E52. Francis has denied kicking said. Molino. "The disciplinary cases ... The police charge that the two exist solely for the purpose of demonstrators violated section harassing Francis and Penn for. 3.33.3 of MIT Policies and Pro- their long-standing willingness to eedures, which states that "all express their political view- members of the MIT community points," according to a pre-hear- are expected to conduct them- ing motion for dismissal, which selves with proper respect for one Penn and Francis submitted May another and for each other's 1. The two also submitted pre- property." hearing motions for discovery Campus. Police Chief Anne P. and for an open hearing to COD Glavin said she took the charges Chair Sheila E. Widnall '60, who to the COD, rather than through denied thiem.| the public judicial system, be- The charges stem from Cam- cause "no arrests were made' the pus Police statements on a March day of the demonstration. photo courtesy Steven LabadessalBoston Herald 2 demonstration organized by the This photograph indicates that Steven D. Penn G (left) and Ronald W. Francis G did not lead Coalition Against -Apartheid. (Please turn to page 2) students into the elevator during the March 2 demonstration. During the protest, demonstra- -tors' called for divestment in front of the home of President VP resigns fron reorganized AEPi Paul E. Gray '54 and in the lob- MIT chapter poorly and not by of -Building By Andrew L. Fish claimed to have about 15 interest- said poor relations with the na- gone E52, during an' through MIT Corporation meeting and One of the three students who ed students. tional were at the root of the "proper channels" when had headed the reorganization of The, national fraternity ex- expulsions. initiating the reorganization. I 1unc'he'ons, - The plccharge Penn and the Alpha Epsilon Pi fraternity pelled 45 of the 55 members from Baden, who had been elected Baden said he did not want to be associated with "an organization I Francis with assault, claiming, E.has -rezbeecause-9f the naa the. ,MIT chapter earlier this year. vice president of the chapter less whose behavior I found they "led a rush of den~ioingtrat-ors tional'9 process fat reorganizing -The-national said the reorganiza- than two weeks ago, said he reprehensible." into [the] elevator at E52,'" and the chapter. In a letter, Steven H. tion was prompted by violations reconsidered his membership in Baden '92 said that the reorga- of the Fraternity Insurance Pur- light of "other views" about the Borison claimed Baden's letter that this rush "caused an injury did not reflect Baden's current to Officer Rosie Sanders." But nized fraternity "was an insult to chasing Group rules, but mem- national's actions. He concluded Penn and Francis said they did the expelled brothers, the MIT bers of the new and old chapter that the national had treated the (Please turn to page 17) not lead the group into the eleva- Greek system, and the MIT tor, and they will submit as community at large." evidence photographs that show Baden said the reorganized Pledge will be unofficial again they were not the first demon- chapter only had "four or five" strators- into the elevator. members left and that by today By Prabbat Mehta and environmental consequences Johnson Athleeic Center. It will In an attempt to enter the "this whole episode will be little The Undergraduate Associa- of my professional activity." Its not be part of the official com- more than an unpleasant tion and Graduate Student Coun- goal is to get students to "think mencement materials, which cur- memory."' cil have tentatively agreed to about what we will be doing," rently only consists of the But the chapter's president, provide an optional pledge at Bapna said. commencement booklet. David S. Bbrison '91, said the Commencement for graduating "You could go here for four Students will keep the pledge. new AEPi chapter was moving students "to examine the conse- years without understanding the "We feel it would be much more forward. "We will be a good quences of their work," accord- consequences of a job you take effective for students to keep it fraternity." ing to UA President Manish later," he added. for their own sake," Bapna said. Borison would not reveal how Bapna '91. "Having [the pledge] would le- Eventually, Bapna hopes that if many members the chapter had, The pledge has students com- gitimize social awareness and cre- students continue to express in- but said, "We lost Steve, that's mit themselves to "investigate ate an atmosphere which encour- terest in the pledge, it will be- I about it." Earlier, the chapter thoroughly and weigh the social ages a discussion of ethics," said come part of the official materi- Ajay G. Advani '91, one of the als. "By this time next year, we II II · IIP s I _ C - r --- , - - · st - II original supporters of the pledge. will know whether students want The pledge will be offered to it as a part of the commencement students as they gather at the (Please turn to page 16) Student groups lobby for later party closings By Brian Rosenberg The proposal would require Ross M.-Okamura '91 and posters for events to state when Fritz N. Francis '92 recently the doors close, in order to avoid presented Campus Police Chief misunderstandings . Anne P. Glavin with a proposal Representatives of the Under- to allow student events held in graduate Association Executive the Julius A. Stratton Student Board, the Chinese Students' Center and Walker Memorial to Club, the Korean Students' remain open later than 12:30 am. (Please turn to page. 17) The proposal came as a result of dissatisfaction with the current _~~~~Q___ closing time by many student groups. The proposal, which would af- fect closing times for events at~ Awards recipients. Page Morss Hall, La Sala de Puerto 2. Rico, and Lobdell Court, would allow groups to choose between two systems. Either the doors would remain open until the MIT Symphony sizzles in 12:30 am closing, or the doors Rhapsody with Benny David H. Oliver/The Tech would close at 12:00 midnight, Weintraub '90. Raoul Alcala, the fourth rider in this photo, stays with the leaders. Alcala was the and the event would be allowed Page 1. eventual winner of the Tour de Trump. to continue until 1:30 am. IN 1IL_ IJ L I I -J Is_ I - I L 1
- ;-u1 W, ,,* .;h_1 ',I'll. --1 , -rv1-r -_ P I f 'CL_91 PAGE 2 TheTech TUESDAY, MAY 15, 1990 m Penn, Franc-is-press ofr dI missa l, open,herng (Continued from page 1) nied the motion for dismissal, Widnall "decided a hearing [was] and claimed that it "raises factu- f warranted" after reviewing the al issues which must be decided Campus Police complaint, Ar- on by the [COD] on the basis of nold R. Henderson Jr., the dean's evidence at the hearing." f office staff support to the COD, told Penn in a letter dated April 3. Their pre-hearing motion for dismissal also cites the collabora- a tive nature of the Campus Police L Protesters say police report, stating that the reports have other motives were not "the officers' original or I One thrust of Francis and individual viewpoints." Penn's defense is that other mo- Penn, Francis press tives exist for the charges against motion for discovery them. "I don't think we can deal on merely factual defense; we Penn and Francis also submit- also have to question why it is ted a pre-hearing motion for dis- these charges [are being] brought covery, which in a court of law r up in the first place," Penn said would give them access to all evi- I in an interview Sunday. dence possessed by the prosecu- a Also, "the fact that these cases tion "that may be useful in e P are solely motivated by reasons constructing their defense," of political harassment should be according to the motion. apparent from the sheer lack of The COD "will furnish [Penn] credible evidence" presented by with all photographs which the the Campus Police, Penn and MIT Campus Police intend to in- s Francis state in their motion for troduce as evidence during the dismissal. hearing," according to Widnall's "There should be some evi- letters as well as a list of witnesses I dence that distinguishes our ac- that will be called to testify. Wid- tions" from those of the rest of nall otherwise denied the motion the group, Penn said, because for discovery, though, because it they were the only two arrested. "requests information outside the He added that Glavin has to scope of the hearing." The stu- provide that evidence, and she dents will not be given access to "cannot do that." photographs the Campus Police The Campus Police report do not introduce. identifies several of the demon- The motion listed 10 items strators in the elevator. But Penn and Francis considered rele- Glavin would not "comment pub- vant to their case, such as records licly" on the fact that Penn and of their political activity on cam- Francis were the only. two pus, written and verbal discus- charged with causing Sanders' sions of them and the CAA, and injury. "all photographs and videos tak- Last-month, though, she said en since. January 1" by MIT . ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~, 11 they were the two charged be- employees, "specifically members cause they were "the ones [Offi- of the MhIT Campus Police, of photo courtesy-Steven Labadessa/Boston Herald cer Sanders] could identify." In [CAA] divestment demonstra- Campus Police Officer Rosie Sanders claims she was injured when students rushed the Sanders' own account of the tions, or participants." elevator. events, she identifies one demon- Widnall did not agree to accept I I II-- I -I---· I I- strator and describes two others. Penn's photographs as evidence, Penn and Francis also said he said, unless ,he provided her MIT brought the case to take with the complete roll of film, 4 1990t Awards, Convocation Reci pents time away from their school work taken at the scene of the demon- and, in particular, from their stration. They submitted four The Narl.Taylor Comptonq Pnzes *- Graduate Student Council Awards for Teaching - political activities. photographs, which show- events (For students who- have; made outstanding contributions in (Presented sepqmarely-in each depsinent) m promoting high standards of achievement and good The two will submit photo- happening on the sixth-floor Ole S. Madsen Edwin Melendez citizenship) 1: graphs as evidence against all the stairwell and the crowded scene Kimberly A. Pacheco '90 Civil Engineering Urban Studies and Planning charges. One photograph shows in front of the elevator. Kenneth L, Simons '90 William K. Durfee Randall M. Dole -- Penn and Francis outside of the Widnall is not required to fol- Cynthia R. McIntyre G Mechanice! Engineering Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Science elevator after several demonstra- low a specific procedure for evi- Ephraim P. Lin '90 The WDlliam L. Stewart Jr. Awards Michael F. Rubner Justin E. Kerwin tors are already inside. [See front dence. The "formal rules of evi- Matetaks Science (For outstanding contributionsto extracurricularlife) Ocean Engineering page photo.] dence that apply to civil judicial Michael J. Warwick G and Engineefing They have named Professor processes shall not be applicable" Sara F.- Bottfeld '91 Thomas R. Chastain Dankly Quah Frank S. Jones and Adjunct to COD hearings? according to Dan Butin '90 A rchitecture Economics Professor Melvin H. King, both the COD rules and regulations. Jason P. Vickers '90 Joanne Stubbe Stuart E. Madifick- William E. Robert '90 Chemistry Management from the Department of Urban Glavin said the Campus Police New Venture Associates' Studies and Planning, as advisors would turn over 7whatever [evi- Thomas F XKnight, Jr. John Dugundji Asian American Caucus ElectricalEngineering and Aeronautics and Astronautics for their case. In any COD case, dence] the COD chair asks for." ARMIT/AIDS Response at MIT C~oputer Scoce. the accused students are allowed African Students Association COD chair denies motion Frank Solomon Lucian NV. Pye '"the right to assistance in prepa- for open hearing The Laya W. Wiesner Award Biology PoliticalScience, ration of [their] defense." Penn (For an undergraduate woman who has enhanced MIT Mehran Kardar Lloyd N. Trefethen community life) Physics Mathemat ics and Francis asked King and Widnall also denied the pre- Luisa R. Contreiras '90 Jones to speak on their behalf hearing motion for an open hear- Christopher Atkeson David Pesetsky because 'these are respected ing, which Penn and Francis sub- The Laya'and Jerome B. Wiesner Awards Brain and Cognitive Scienc7es Linguistics and Philosophy (Forachievements in the creative arts) professors," Francis said. mitted April 30. Widnall denied Jefferson W. Tester 'Jee-Hoon Yap '90 Chemical Engineering Demonstrators submit motion the motion, because all COD Jonathan E, D. Richmond G to dismiss the case hearings "are closed to individ- The Albert G. Hill Prze The Aisociation of MIT Alumnae Awards uals who are not directly in- (For minority juniors or seniors who have maintained high (Forsenior women for academic excellence) The pre-hearing motions, volved" in the hearing, according academic standards or improved. the quality of life for Sima Setsyeshgar 390 Charissa Lim-'90. whichm Widnall denied, were an to COD rules and regulations. minorities) Elizabeth E. Quinn '90 effort by Penn and Francis to ap- Penn and Francis argued that The Goodwin Medal Virginia M. John '91 (Fora graduatestudent for conspicuously effective teaching) ply Massachusetts state laws to the hearings "Should be -made The Fredenrek Gardiner Fasset Jr. Award Franklyn A. Turbakc G their case. To stipulate that "the open to the community," accord- (For a member of the Interfraternity Council for spirit and The Louis Sudler Prize in the Arts COD must comply with the basic ing to the motion for an open dedication) (Fora graduatingsenior) procedures established by the hearing. Paul R. Cort '90 Jee-Lian Yap '90 Commonwealth's judicial sys- "To close this case to the pub- The James R. Killian Jr. Community Service Award The Gordon Y Bislard Award tem," their motion for dismissal lic would directly violate Com- (For a fraternity with an outstanding community service (For outstanding merit performed for the Institute) cites the Massachusetts Civil monwealth statutes and the prin- program) Mr. Paul F Barrett Rights Act, which "in part guar- ciples of the university. ... [We] Phi Delta Theta Professor H. Kent Bowen antees the basic civil rights to em- would welcome a public hear- The Kenneth R. Wadleigh Award The James N. Murphy Award ployees, students, and clients of (For an independent living group for promoting faculty/ (For a spirited employee who has won the hearts of students) ing," Penn and Francis state in Sheila Frankel private institutions." the motion. "Moreover we be- student interaction) Sigma Alpha Epsilon Tobie Weiner In a court of law, a motion for lieve that the hearing, if it is not The Class of 1948 Award- dismissal would be considered be- open to the public. will not The IFC Alumni Relations Award (Forthe male senior athlete of the year) fore the hearing. However, the receive adequate community Delta Tau Delta William E. Singhose '90 rules and regulations of the COD scrutiny." The Irwvin Sizer Award The Betsy Schumacher Awa do not account for the possibility In an interview last month, (For innovations in MIT education) (Foran undergraduate woman athlete) of pre-hearing motions. In a giv- Widnall would not discuss' the Film and Media Studies Program Yvonne M. Griergon 190 (third time) en case, the only statement ac- The Admiral Edward L. Cchrane Award case against Penn and Francis. The Edward L. H~orton Fellowship cepted from an accused student is 'It's a serious right of privacy for (Forfostering fellowship among graduate students} (For a male senior athlete for humility and Leadership) , Shane R. L. lousse '90 a written response to charges students," she said. Widnall was Brazilian Students Association against him or her. not available for comment t.[be Everett Moore Balker Memorial Award -The Peite Bowl Awid ., (Fora female athlete-for inspiration and -leadership) In a letter to Penn, Widnall de- yesterday. lfor Excelleice in Undergraduate Teaching Paul A. LaGace . . Cecilia -H. Yarpinski '90 Thomas Simmons The Makeolm G.-Kspert AwHords Michael F. Rubner; (Forthe male and female senior scholar-athletes of the year) Amar IBos Teaching Award Anthony G. Lapes '90 (A new award in recognition of outstanding contributions to Maureen T. Fahey '90 undergraduate education by members of the electrical The Haiold J. Pettergrove Award engineering and computer science faculty) (Foroutstanding service to intramuralathletics) August Witt Michael D. Barrera G
L S,- V64 -.04,4e _A 6'4'4 ,A 46% 4J '_ I N , ,, , . .'L A',1&' I I I ' I r `I P' 1 141111 $ LI r -- I TUESDAY, MAY 15, 1990 The Tech PAGE 3 _
·-- · .··; ·; ·-
r YYIIY lr ll II Y4 ·.··· r
? · ·- - I ''
'o 1 l~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ML - l
Hezbollah urges halt Flag burning in Supreme Court again Arraignment soon in kidnapping case to freeing of hostages The latest dispute over desecrating the American flag Accused kidnapper Kenneth Cole of Holliston is ex- could'be settled in late June or early July with a Supreme pected to be arraigned today on charges of kidnapping The umbrella group for Moslem factions.holding hos- five-year-old Nicole Ravesi of Milford. The 24-year-old tages in Lebanon is urging-kidnappers not to release any Court ruling. The court yesterday heard civil rights attor- ney William Kunstler argue in favor of that form of polit- Cole was returned to Massachusetts yesterday from Flori- more captives. Hezbollah sponsored a women's sit-in at a da, where he was arrested last week. He is charged with Beirut house belonging to thie United Nations peacekeepe- ical protest, and Solicitor General Kenneth Starr speak against it. Hundreds of demonstrators on both sides taking the young girl April 3 and evading a national man- ing force in Lebanon.'About 50 women were there, saying out expressed their views outside the court. hunt for more than five weeks. The two were finally no- more Westerners should be freed until their loved ones located Thursday at a fishing village in the Florida are freed'from Israeli jails. panhandle town of Eastpoint. The youngster was report- EPA to run ecological adtcampaign edly unharmed. Nicole and her parents returned home The Environmental Protection Agency has come up Friday. Cole was flown to Boston yesterday under guard Mitterand joins desecration protest with an ad campaign that uses a touch of sarcasm to get by federal marshals. French President Frangois Mitterand was among the people to live more ecologically. The campaign is dubbed thousands of people who marched in Paris yesterday to "How to Destroy the Earth." One spot features a smirk- protest the desecrations of Jewish cemeteries. Mitterand ing announcer who says, '"Want to destroy the earth with Walden Pond declared was, cheered by the marchers. It was the first time since your car? No problem. Drive everywhere!" Others tell endangered historic place World War II that a French president has joined a public viewers to use' phosphate detergents, pour oil into the The National Trust for Historical Preservation has demonstration. . ground and leave on the lights. ruled that Walden Pond in Concord is on the list of endangered historic places. US Rep. Chester G. Atkins (D-MA) announced the action yesterday. Conservationists Soviets pass- anti-slander law High Court upholds clinic are trying to protect Walden Pond from proposed housing Soviet citizens may think twice before-thumbing their demonstration ban developments. The pond was once the site of Henry David noses at their leader in the future. The Soviet parliament The head of an Atlanta abortion'clinnic often targeted Thoreau's meditations on the world. Atkins said the ac- tion by the trust means that preservation of the Walden has passed a bill imposing stiff fines or up to three years by anti-abortion demonstrators is hailing a decision yes- Woods is clearly a national issue. in jail for insulting or slandering the Soviet president. terday by the Supreme Court. Justices refused to overturn The controversy over development in Walden Woods Passage comes' less. than two weeks after Mikhail. S. a Georgia judge's injunction saying protesters have to stay pits conservationists against advocates of low-income Gorbachev was jeered by thousands in an unofficial May 50 feet away from abortion clinics. Clinic operator Lynne housing, who have been pushing for new affordable Day protest. Randall said that women's rights to privacy have to be housing in the affluent community. balanced with the rights of others to protest.
Deficit negotiations to begin today All-sides going into deficit-cutting negotiations today seem to be saying, "you first." Congressional participants insist they will not be the first to, propose higher taxes- I = 'i-hi* Hloise'96eghifetin 'MathnikL. fi~tzWater, s~ays' Prdl-- dent Bush will not make specific proposals, butt will-'st- -Humid weather on. the way ply state his godi§s. The'summit is designed to find $50- The warm weather of the past four days will billion or more in deficit savings - through spending cuts continue at'least for the next four days.' A fe'w more After defeating the New York Knicks Sunday n ight 102- or taxes. clouds and increasing afternoon relative humidities 90, the Detroit Pistons are leading their Eastern Confer- will accompany this period of late spring weather. ence semifinal series three games to one. Led byr Michael -Jordan's 45 points, the Chicago Bulls took a commanding N. Korea to return soldiers' remains Tuesday afternoon: Partly cloudy and mild with an 3-1 lead in their best-of-seven series with the Philadelphia The State Department said it welcomes an announce- afternoon sea breeze keeping coastal areas cool. 76ers with a 111-101 victory Sunday afternoon.' San Anto- ment yesterday from North Korea. The communist coun- Highs 55°F (13'C) along the coast to the 70's nio and Portland are even in their Western Conference try said it will release the remains of some American sol- inland (21 C). semifinal at 2-2. Phoenix took a 3-1 lead in their series diers killed in the Korean conflict. The arrangement Tuesday night: Partly cloudy and mild. Lows 48- with the LA Lakers with a 114-101 victory over the Lak- involves only five of the more than 8000 soldiers still un- 53°F (9-12'C) overnight. ers Sunday night. accounted for. But the State Department said the move is Wednesday: Partly sunny and "stickier" with late significant because it is the first such return since 1954. afternoon showers possible especially in the western part of the state. Highs 7075°F (22- Mexican wins Tour de Trump 25 C), lows 55-60°F (13-16 C). .Raul Alcala of Mexico won the Tour de Trump Sunday Drivers' victory in Greyhound dispute Thursday: Partly cloudy, warm, and humid. Showers likely during the afternoon. Highs 75- in Boston, defeating his nearest rival by a cumulative time In a victory yesterday for the drivers' 'union striking of 43 seconds. Alcala collected $50,000 of the $300,000 Greyhound, a federal investigator said the company en- 85'F (24-29°C), lows 59-64°F (15-18'C). Forecast by Michael C. Morgan total in prize money for his efforts. Greg Le Mond, the gaged in unfair labor practices during the walkout. If the American winner of last year's Tour de Prance, finished National Labor Relations Board agrees, Greyhound could back in the pack after making a late charge for the lead. be forced to give the striking drivers their jobs back. Compiled by Dave Watt
Io _ _ . 1" I I I I I A ,NY PURCHASE OF $10.00 or MORE! I cI.O MPACT DISCS, POSTERS, T-SHIRTS!
(No Double. Discounts. Sale Items Excluded. Expires 5122190.) rI
I - 8.l.T8.: Student Center 225m28721 r i BOSTON: 332 Newbury St. 236-49301 tI m HARVARD SO.: 36 J.F.K. ST. The Garage 491 0337 ______8 lr 1 _ 8 __ _~,8~l _ __ _ g BP_ 1 m _,me1 _a _ ~PAGE 4 The Tech TUESDAY, MAY 15, 1990 M - .
- 0 0 ,
e
-
EDITORIAL Suet ohv-rgt - Penn, Fr~anci sh4ould Column by Jonathan Richmond To the Wiesner Awards Committee: This award is surely theirs as much as it is mine. Me I was delighted to receive a Laya and Jerome B. I also acknowledge the contribution, of my editors no be sige out Wiesner Award at yesterday's Awards Convocation at Technology Review and the Christian Science in connection with my founding and administration Monitor, and of the MIT Office of the Arts, which Steven D. Penn G and Ronald W. Francis G should not face .of MIT's discount ticket service, The Tech Perform- helped out by selling hundreds of tickets to charges before the Committee on Discipline for their actions in the ing Arts Series, and my arts writing -mainly for Madama Butterfly to a horde of students sprawling March 2 protest. The two were brought before the COD for alleg- The Tech, but also for Technology' Review and the across the lobby of the building which honors D~r. edly assaulting police officers by leading protesters into an eleva- Christian Science Monitor. Wiesner's name; and I also thank the artistic orga- tor. But the surrounding circumstances make it clear that MIT is I feel. deeply honored and grateful to the awards nizations which have participated' in The Tech not interested in punishing violence, but rather in intimidating stu- committee for selecting me. I cannot say, further- Performing Arts Series for their involvement. e dents who organize anti-administration protests. For this reason, more, how much I appreciated Dr. Wiesner's pres- This award also provides a unique opportunity to the COD should refuse to punish Penn and Francis for their ence at the ceremony. He has been quite unwell late- respond not only to an event which happened last - actions. ly, and in considerable pain. I know he wvished to year, but to send a message to. the community as a ee Eight students charged into the elevator in the Sloan Building, present the award himself, but was unable to due to whole about out obligations to each other. Last and all are known to the Campus Police. Yet, MIT singled out ill-health. I was sorry to hear, also, that Mrs. Wies- year I was involved in a controversy with a particu-. ner has been unwell. I wish both these beloved lar unit of MIT over a-financial 'matter. I argued _ Francis and Penn for punishment. The two are perceived by the - administration as protest leaders -this is likely the only reason members of our community the very best in. quickly that I was entitled to a certain payment according recovering. to MIT's own regulations and, following a bitter why they were charged with violations of MIT policy. e When I first heard that I had been nominated for dispute, received the payment I had requested. Dur- In addition, the Campus Police charge that Penn and Francis led this award, I started thinking of the opportunity it ing the course of the dispute and discussions with the protesters into the elevator is clearly refuted by photographic might present to make a statement, to say a few of numerous MIT faculty and officials, I found some l evidence and witnesses. Indeed, Penn never even entered the eleva- the things I have learned during my lengthy love/ who-were extremely sympathetic and helpful, and tor, and a photo shows that several students preceded Francis in hate relationship with MIT and, above all, to do others who told me things such as that "students e the occupation. The distortions in the Campus Police complaint something positive before I leave. have no rights," and that I would suffer recrimi'na- provide further evidence that Penn and Francis are not being tions if I pursued MIT's own grievance procedure. C charged for their actions on March 2 but for their status as protest First of all, I could not have this award without - leaders. This type of intimidation should not be allowed ons an all the wonderful musicians, actors and other artists I said that I was taking action out of principle as who so plentifully populate this campus. It takes open university campus. much as for the money, the principle being that far more talent and effort to put on an artistic per- Additionally, the Committee on Discipline's lack of procedural MIT students do have rights, and should be treated - formance than it does to scratch out a review. Their at least as well as is stipulated by MIT regulations. I safeguards makes it ill-equipped to handle this kind of case. The creative contribution is immense and of far greater rules of evidence seem to be determined ad hoc by the committee was laughed at and told I was only in it for the significance than mine: I'd like to let them know money. Nowv, I think I can show that I was in it for - chairman, Sheila E. Widnall '60; Penn claims she may not let him that even if I have sometimes given them a less than introduce the evidence which clearly exonerates him. At the same the principle, with cash which is mine tos use freely positive review -part of a critic's job whether one as I wish. If that minority of faculty and staff who time, the two students are not permitted to examine any evidence likes it or not -they have enriched my stay at MIT e collected by MIT, including photographs which might clear them might under duress-not accord their students all of and are very much appreciated. their rights appreciate what I am now doing, call I of wrongdoing. Because the COD has no common sense rules of Secondly, I could not have this award without the ask them in' future to think twice before treating pi evidence or formal rules of procedure, any hearing on these efforts of a large number of devoted people at both their students unfairly. Students are MIT's most charges will lack fundamental fairness. For this reason, the COD The Tech and the Technology Communlity Associa- e precious charge, anld are entitled to respect, wheth- - cannot give a fair hearing to this case and should not punish Penn tion. Any time I write an article, it has to be edited, er in their relations with MIT on academic, finan- and Francis. proofed, typeset and pasted down. Peter Dunn and cial, or employment matter's or in exercise of their it Debby Levinson have been two particularly hard- legal rights to freely express their opinions or seek working and supportive members of the arts edito- redress on whatever topic concerns them, ranging rial staff. I have also worked with several editors in from the conduct of their education to whether chief - 1iraj Desai and Prabhat Mehta being the their university should have investments in most recent -who are willing to labor night and apartheid. E day, somehow getting their problem sets done at the edges between day, and night - to produce the For all these reasons, I would like to share my newspaper to the best of their abilities. Not least, award with all those cited above. I therefore asked recognition should go to those invisible, but crucial not to receive a check at the awards ceremony yes- - members of Tech staff the production workers, terday, but requested that two other checks be writ- Volume 1 10, Number 27 Tuesday, May 15, 1990 who make sure the paper actually appears. ten as follows. SinlfoNova, one of the most enthusi- - With respect to The Tech Performinlg Arts Series astic participants in The Tech Performiing Arts Chairman ...... Deborah A. Levinson '91 Series, is currently in-deep financial trouble and at credit must go to the entire Tech board, which ap- e Editor in Chief ...... Prabhat Mehta '91 risk of going out of existence. SinfoNova Music Di- proved the provision of free publicity for promoters - Business Mlanager ...... Russell Wilcox ' 91 rector Aram Gharabekian has told me how thrilled willing to provide affordable tickets for MIT stu- - Managing Editor ...... M/arie E. V. Coppola '90 dents. Thpe Tech depends for its existence on adver- he was to get 140 subscribers from MIT, the single Executive Editor ...... Linda D'Angelo '90 tisinig revenue, and, has lost income from several largest group of subscribers the orchestra has. He promoters who previously paid for their advertis- likes to have younger people in the audience; he's - News Editors ...... Annabelle Boyd '90 told me that in an ideal world he'd like to let them Andrea Lamberti '91 ing, and now get it for free. The commitment of everyone at The Tech to make this sacrifice for the in for free. I would like MIT students to be able to Reuven M. Lerner '92 continue to enjoy the orchestra's work at the dis- Night Editor ...... Daniel A. Sidney G benefit of their fellow students should be Opinuion Editor ...... Michael J . Franklinl'88 acknowledged. count prices SinfoNova kindly offers. SinfoNova Sports Editor ...... Shawn Mastrian ' 91 The tickets for our discount program could not has launched an appeal, "A farewell or a new begin- Arts Editor ...... Peter E. Dunn G have been sold without the massive help of the ning." I have requested that $250 be sent to the Photography Editor ...... Kristine AuYeung '91 Technology Community Association. Their unpaid appeal. Contribulting Editors ...... Jonathan Richmond G members staff the desk from which tickets are sold, I've asked for the remaining $750 to be remitted Niraj S. Desai '90 rff and carry out logging, payment and other adminis- to the National Scholarship Fund of the MIT Alum- Irene C. Kuo '90 R.- trative tasks to boot. Here, as well', a strong service ni Association, an account which is not part of the Lisette W. M. Lambregts '90 m ethic is visible; here as well we see the human side endowment, but which directly provides student w Lois Eaton '92 financial aid. Advertisineg Manager ...... Mark E. Haseltine '92 of MXIT students: not technocratic nerds, but gener- w Production Manoager ...... Ezra Peisach '89 ous-minded people who want to make a contribu- Senior Editor ...... Genevieve C. Sparagna '90 tion to the community. My appreciation goes to all Jonathan Richmond is a graduate student in the I. the students at The Tech, the Technology Commu- Department ofr Civil Engineering and a Contributf- NEWS STAFF nity Association and in the arts community at large. ing Editor at The Tech.- Associate News Editors: Neil J. Ross G. Dave Watt G. Joanna Stone '92, Brian Rosenberg '93, Katherine Shim '93; Staff: Joan Abbott '90, Anita Hdsiung '90, Miguel Cahtillo '91, Adnan Lawai '91, Chitra K. Raman '91, Gaurav Rewari '91, Eun S. Shin '91, Aileen Lee '92, Adam Chen '93, Karen Kaplan '93, Shannon Mohr '93, Michael Schlarnp '93, Cliff Schmidt '93; Meteorolo- gists: Robert X. Black G. Robert J. Conzemius G. Michael C. Morgan G. Greg Bettinger '91, Yeh-Kai Tung '93. PRODUCTION STAFF Associate Night Editors: Kristine J. Cordella '91, David Maltz '93; Staff: Sunitha Gutta '93, Jonathon Weiss '93, Aaron M. t Woolsey '93. BUSINESS STAFF Delinquent Accounts Manager: Jadene Burgess '93; Advertising Accounts Manager: Shanwei Chen '92; Staff: Ben Tao '93.
PRODUCTION STAFF FOR THIS ISSUE Night Editors: ...... Daniel A. Sidney G Marie E. V. Coppola '90 David Maltz '93 Staff: Peter E. Dunn G, Ezra Peisach '89, Linda L. Cordella '90, . *, Deborah A. Levinson '91, Kevin Frisch '93, Jonathon Weiss !i I '93. l I
The Tech (ISSN 01 48-9607) is poublished on Tuesdays and Fridays during the academic year (except during MIT vacations) Wednesdays during January, and monthly during the summer for $17.00 per year Third Class by The Tec:h, Room W20-483, 84 iS Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, MA 02139-0901. Third Class postage paid at I Boston, MA. Non-Profit Org. Permit No. 59720. POSTMASTER: Please send all address changes to our mailing address: The Tech, PO Box 29, MIT Branch, Cambridge, MA 02139-0901. Telephone: (617) 253-1541. FAX: (617) 258-8226. Advertisi~ng, subscription, and typesetting rates available. Entire contents A) 1990 The Tech. The Tech is a member of the Associated Press. Printed by Charles River PublshnIc I" 0 _LC--d I, r r, r- I _II-- TUESDAY, MAY 15, 1990 The Tech PAGE 5 _ --- _I-_1 -- -
L I ------_ - -- -- opinion
------I- -- I e , | I 1 ------i I Baden, AEPi's vice president, resigns Over the past few weeks,, the other views on the reorganiza- pelled brothers, the MIT Greek reorganization of the Alpha. Epsi- tion. Increasingly, we have been system, and the MIT community Ion Pi chapter on our campus has flooded with information from at large. In this spirit, I announce been a source of concern and dis- many sides, learning "facts" my resignation from the office of tress for many members' of the from each that seem to contra- vice president of the Mu Tau iI MIT community. As -a principal dict the others. That is why, chapter of AEPi, and dissociate actor in the construction of the at the Undergraduate Association myself from any further actions new chapter, I would like to con- meeting, I was unwilling to de- of AEPi. vey to the community some of fend the national, and felt that I In the last few days, I have my thoughts about what has might change my mind at any spoken with almost all of the transpired. moment. On the one hand, I did members of the new chapter. At When I first heard that AEPi not want to miss a great opportu- the time of this letter, all but was reorganizing, I thought it nity; on the other hand, I did not four or five have expressed their would be a good idea to have a want to ally myself with an orga- agreement with my position, and secular Jewish social group on nization whose behavior I found have abandoned the fraternity. I campus. With this goal in mind reprehensible. expect that by the time this issue and the support of several of my Having given the matter much of The Tech is printed, this whole friends, I contacted the AEPi thought, I have finally come to a episode will be little more than director of expansion, Andrew S. conclusion, and I feel secure that an unpleasant memory. Borans. In our initial meeting, it is the right one. I have come to As the person who initiated Borans made the idea of joining agree that the reorganization of this objectionable endeavor, I a national fraternity very appeal- the Mu Tau chapter of AEPi was want to apologize for my insensi- ing. Sold on the idea, we began handled poorly, without proper tivity to my fellow students, to working to form a new chapter. consideration for the students in- the Interfraternity Council, and We believed that AEPi could volved, or for using the appropri- especially to the expelled brothers have a very positive influence on ate channels of action. I further of AEPi. this community. think that at this time the exis- After we had already become tence of an AEPi chapter on this Steven H. Baden '92 involved, we began to hear the campus is an insult to the ex- I ,_ I pIIL - -
If
le
_i A Anti-divestmentI -1 sentiments . gr do not supp rltapartheid
,4'KI-. ';;...... > . In response to William T. Jack- are the ones who would be hurt. son '93's column on divestment Does this mean that he and all ["No more Twinkies: Gray in of his black South Africans are
black South Africa," May 11], I immoral? Thousands of blacks .- from neighboring countries travel , feel that several points need to be ., made. to South Africa to work. Are The results of the referendum they immoral also? Obviously show that less than half the stu- not. In the future, Jackson dents who voted supported di- should try to base his arguments vestment. The margin of differ- on facts, not some alleged ence between support and ''morality.' disagreement was 9.5 percent. Another classification is neces- The no opinion vote (18.3 per- sary. Opposition to divestment cent) was almost twice that does not equal support for apart- amount. These factors support heid. This is a cheap political
II i Is -- · -- · - I I------= mrrsal84lp -- I·r ra I -a r I the contention that no consensus ploy aimed at slandering those or mandate on which MIT against divestment. After all, should act has been established. do those aforementioned South Fund raising for clock tower not appropriate Despite considerable activism African blacks who are opposed in support of divestment (includ- to divestment really support I was very disappointed with a around our campus buildings, responsibilities which we have to- ing protests and the passing apartheid? Of course not. Those note which I received earlier in but is achieved almost exclusively wards the advancement and the out of pro-divestment papers) of us opposed to divestment see the week from the president of through the contributions of its enrichment of society. and the lack of activism on the other ways of helping to end the Class of 1990. The note from' alumni/ae to society. The remainder of the funds other side of the issue, thiss small apartheid. Joseph R. Babiec Jr. '90 was a Personally, I would be very em- which have been raised can in- margin of victory is all that could The South African government pledge to all graduating members barrassed to announce at gradua- stead be used to establish the be obtained. Arguing that Paul. has removed some restrictions of the Class of 1990 to contribute tion that our class had achieved a Class of 1990 gifts and prizes to Gray should act on1 this small dif- and has talked with black lead- to the Senior Gift fund, for the record-breaking participation in these outstanding individuals of ference in the strengths of the ers. Remember, they did release construction of a $30,000 clock raising $30,000 for the construc- our community. For instance, if two sides is ridiculous and self- Nelson Mandela. They are mak- tower. Although this letter was tion of the clock tower, the Se- we used around $5000 for the serving. Based on the mixed ing progress. The US government not written on behalf-of members nior Gift from the Class of 1990. plaque, we would have a remain- results, there is no basis to and American companies should of the Class of 1990, I believe Instead, I would be more hon- der of $25,000 in funds. This any claim that the undergrad- act to encourage this behavior. that there are at least a few of my ored to inform the Institute that amount of money can be used in- uate population is advocating Divestment would simply take colleagues who share my opinion we had raised the same amount stead to present awards to indi- divestment. away all this potential influence. Ii - that the proposal for this Senior of money to establish a fund viduals of the MIT community. If I would also appreciate it if Don't distort this argument. Gift is not at all appropriate. which would award recognitions we allocate $5000 each year for Jackson and his allies stop trying Don't shove your "morality" at While the attempt to reach a to members of the MIT commu- such awards, the funds can be to shove their "morality" on the us. Don't make false accusations record-breaking goal of $30,000 nity whose contributions have en- used for a period of five years. rest of us. What they see as mor- that those of us opposed to di- is somewhat fair, I disagree with riched the environment of the In- By our fifth class reunion, we al, others do not. It just so hap- vestment are big fans of apart- the idea of the clock tower as be- stitute, and society as well. A should be able to establish anoth- pens that Mangosuthu Buthelezi, heid. Most importantly, don't tell ing the appropriate gift to MIT. simple plaque with the following er fund which would continue chief of South Africa's several us that MIT should be acting in Our "gift" to the Institute is indi- words could stand at one of the this class tradition. million-member Zulu tribe, is op- response to inconclusive referen- rectly related to our future con- main corridors of MIT. Our decision will reflect that posed to sanctions and divest- dum results. tributions to society. MIT gradu- This plaque was presented by we have the foresight to recog- ment because the black people Steven Lustig '93 ates have always made significant the graduating members of the nize the importance of contribu- contributions to society.. Class of 1990 as its Senior Gift to tions by such individuals/parties Editorials, marked as such and printed in a distinctive By accomplishing such tasks MIT in recognition of the indi- to society. Such a move will also which benefits society, we have viduals who have made signif- remind us of such similar roles format, are the official opinion of The Tech. They are fulfilled the ambitions of the In- cant and important contributions that we are going to take in soci- written by.the editorial board, which consists of the stitute, that-is to provide an envi- which have benefited society. rI is ety, roles of great responsibilities, chairman, editor in chief, managing editor, executive ronment of education and learn- our hope that similar contribu- roles of future leaders in society. editor, news editors and opinion editor. ing which cultivates excellence tions in. the future which benefit So please, do not bring the clock Dissents, marked as such and printed in a distinctive and leadership of individuals at society will be recognized and tower to- campus. Show someone all levels of society. The world- appreciated. To all present, and else instead that their contribu- .foimnat,, we the opinions of the undersigned members of wide recognition of MIT is not future members of the MIT com- tions to society have been greatly e the editorial board choosing to publish their disagreement gained through expensive and munity, we hope that this plaque appreciated. with th Aitodridi. <
somewhat artistic structures h . ., .. . A_ will serve as a reminder of the Choong Huei Seow '90 . ,. IJ r·· ·' L .r ':· PAGE 6 The Tech TUESDAY, MAY 15, 1990 I _·_I IL~= I -1 · - -- I I r-I
Work~ With The -Bes-t d e nTh Business At nd Save-!