Journal of Human Kinetics volume 28/2011, 91-105 DOI: 10.2478/v10078-011-0026-9 91 Section II- Exercise Physiology & Sports Medicine
Altitude Training and its Influence on Physical Endurance in Swimmers
by Marek Strzała1, Andrzej Ostrowski2, Zbigniew Szyguła3
It is possible to plan an altitude training (AT) period in such a way that the enhanced physical endurance obtained as a result of adaptation to hypoxia will appear and can be used to improve performance in competition. Yet finding rationales for usage of AT in highly trained swimmers is problematic. In practice AT, in its various forms, is still controversial, and an objective review of research concentrating on the advantages and disadvantages of AT has been presented in several scientific publications, including in no small part the observations of swimmers. The aim of this article is to review the various methods and present both the advantageous and unfavourable physiological changes that occur in athletes as a result of AT. Moreover, AT results in the sport of swimming have been collected. They include an approach towards primary models of altitude/hypoxic training: live high + train high, live high + train low, live low + train high, as well as subsequent methods: Intermittent Hypoxic Exposure (IHE) and Intermittent Hypoxic Training (IHT). Apnoea training, which is descended from freediving, is also mentioned, and which can be used with, or as a substitute for, the well-known IHE or IHT methods. In conclusion, swimmers who train using hypoxia may be among the best-trained athletes, and that even a slight improvement in physical endurance might result in the shortening of a swimming time in a given competition, and the achievement of a personal best, which is hard to obtain by normal training methods, when the personal results of the swimmer have reached a plateau. Key words: altitude, hypoxia, training, swimming
Introduction Altitude training (AT) is used by athletes in determines the excretion of enzymes that are order to improve their physical endurance and to involved in muscle energy producing processes. increase their endurance and movement In this way, muscle angiogenesis is also controlled economics after they have returned to sea level. by increasing the level of vascular endothelial This practice has been used for decades. Different growth factor (VEGF) (Lundby et al., 2009). HIF-1 environmental conditions with a reduction in also regulates the expression of the gene ambient oxygen cause adaptive changes to responsible for erythropoietin (EPO); it also sportsmen’s organisms, which can be described as regulates the organism’s pH and glycolysis (Vogt “natural doping”. The process of metabolic et al. 2010). The cognizance of advantageous adaptation to a changed environment takes place physiological changes in an organism following in tissues at the cellular level without the hypoxia ensures that athletes readily use AT. In necessity of drug intake. Physical exercise sport, there is a belief that it is possible to plan an performed in hypoxia causes amplified synthesis AT period in such a way that the enhanced of the HIF-1 factor (hypoxia inducible factor 1) endurance obtained as a result of adaptation to influencing messenger RNA coding that hypoxia will appear after the athlete has returned
1 - Department of Theory and Methodology of Water Sports, University School of Physical Education, Cracow, Poland 2 - Department of Theory and Methodology of Water Sports, University School of Physical Education, Cracow, Poland 3 - Department of Sports Medicine, University School of Physical Education, Cracow, Poland
Authors submitted their contribution of the article to the editorial board. Accepted for printing in Journal of Human Kinetics vol. 28/2011 on June 2011. 92 Altitude Training and its Influence on Physical Endurance in Swimmers
from the mountains and can benefit competition. cells, synthesizing EPO influences the Many observations conducted during hypoxic erythropoietin gene transcription and increases its training, which were initiated in the 1960s during excretion, causing a rise in red blood cell preparation for the Olympic competition in production during hypoxic exposure. HIF-1, Mexico City in 1968, which is located 2300 m which is present in many cellular lines of the above sea level, encouraged coaches and athletes organism, streamlines the action of glycolytic to apply AT. enzymes (phosphofructokinase, hexokinase and Yet finding unequivocal rationales for lactate dehydrogenase) taking part in exercise undertaking altitude training, is problematic. In metabolism. It contributes to the regulation of practice, AT and its various forms are still transport and the utilization of glucose with the controversial, and an objective review of research participation of glucose-1-4 transporters and concentrating on AT advantages and lactate metabolism in muscles, with the disadvantages has been presented in several involvement of carbonic anhydrase (Lundby, scientific publications, including several 2009). Moreover, this factor in hypoxic training observations in swimmers. The main problem of influences the process of increasing the buffering those AT observations that have been conducted base capacity (Gore et al., 2001) and induces more is the lack of results that were replicated in similar efficient oxygen utilization in working muscles experiments. In the natural conditions of high (Gore et al., 2007). mountains, there is a multitude of changing When considering the possibility of physical conditions, such as humidity, insolation, endurance being enhanced as a result of AT and atmospheric pressure, that affect adaptation. In associated hypoxia, it should be noted that AT addition, in different procedures using promotes an increase in anaerobic glycolytic surrounding hypoxia, other poorly controllable metabolism. Such statistically significant factors play an important role in the athletes anaerobic work indices were noted in research on adaptive changes. These include: the diet used, competitive swimmers (Martino et al., 1995; which influences water-electrolyte equilibrium Nomura et al., 1999; and others). During intensive and iron intake, training intensity and appropriate physical exercises, the struggle is accompanied by recovery duration. One drawback of the large the production of large amounts of lactate, and number of observations noting advantageous the maintenance of an effective exercise adaptive changes is that there has been little metabolism depends on the efficient transport of variety when it comes to parallel comparative the produced lactate and H+ ions. Transport research conducted on a homogenous group of within skeletal muscle is controlled through cell athletes in normoxia and hypoxia. walls from muscle to blood using two The aim of this article is to review the various transporters – monocarboxylate MCT1 and MCT4. methods and present the advantageous and That is why an increase in the level of the proteins unfavourable physiological changes occurring in in muscular tissue as a result of endurance AT can the organisms of athletes as a result of AT. minimize exercise pH fluctuations (Gore et al., Moreover, AT results in the sport of swimming 2007). In the research of Zoll et al. (2006) a 44% have been collected and presented. increase in MCT1 concentration in the muscle of 9 Gene expression caused by hypoxia well-trained runners after a six-week training In recent years, scientists have been period in hypoxia in a simulated altitude of attempting to answer the question, in what way 3000m was noted in comparison to a control does hypoxia influence gene expression? In group. In this research, the post-experiment time Semenza’s research (2000), it has been noted that of a run to exhaustion at the intensity responding the main factor regulating aerobic homeostasis to 100% VO 2max was registered, as well as a and plays an important role in the cardio-vascular simultaneous increase of post-exercise blood LA and ventilatory response to hypoxia is the earlier concentration when compared to the same effort mentioned hypoxia inducible factor 1 (HIF-1), before hypoxia. It was stated that the MCT1 which is present in all the nucleated cells of our concentration increase enabled the improvement organism. The presence of this factor is regulated of anaerobic metabolism and the removal of by oxygen concentration in the cells. In kidney lactate from cells, which caused a slower decrease
Journal of Human Kinetics volume 28/2011, http://www.johk.pl by strzała M. et al. 93
of pH at the same race pace. A correlation determination of blood plasma transferine between MCT1 expression in mRNA and running receptors (sTfR). Blood plasma sTfR concentration results after hypoxic training at the level of r=0.60 correlates strongly with the number of cell was also noted. The possibility of adjusting the erythroblast receptors – TfR. In the human concentration of H+ ions in muscular tissue organism, iron delivery to numerous in bone strongly depends on buffering bases. Their marrow erythroblasts is enabled by the interaction increased concentration might belong to one of between transferine in blood plasma and surface the mechanisms responsible for enhanced TfR receptors (glycoprotein membrane regulating performance as a result of AT (Gore et al., 2001; cellular iron intake from blood circulation) Mizuno et al., 2008). positioned on erythroblasts (Mierzwa et al., 2006). Haematological and cardiovascular-respiratory Proliferating and maturing erythroblasts adaptation accumulate haemoglobin and synthesise haem AT and its variants are used in sports molecules using iron; these iron resources training mainly for the purpose of gaining better simultaneously start to be reduced, and if the haematological indices that influence endurance organism lacks iron it increases the sTfR level capabilities during prolonged effort. Because (Beguin, 1992). That is why in research that has lower oxygen partial pressure (PIO2) in breathing monitored the hematopoetic mechanisms in air causes increased EPO production, kidney athletes, (e.g. Koistinen et al. (2000) and Robach et artery blood oxygenation decreases. al. (2004)) a mutual dependence between sTfR Endogenously produced EPO influences bone receptors level and erythropoiesis was noted. An marrow stem cells, increasing red blood cell-line effect of the processes described above is an cells precursors, which consequently cause an increasing number of red blood cells and increase in erythrocyte production (Jelkmann, erythrocytic mass (polycytaemia), and further 1992). Research conducted on well-trained growth in the amount of haemoglobin, which swimmers, runners and triathlonists in different leads to the improvement of aerobic metabolism hypoxic conditions did not always show this kind (Schmitt et al., 2006). of relationship (Nomura et al., 1999; Friedmann et Hypoxic-hypobaric surrounding conditions al., 2005; Robach et al., 2006; Gore et al., 2006). promote respiratory adaptation, which manifests Some research indicates that subjects who reside itself in the improvement of maximal minute in mountainous areas and descend to sea level, ventilation ( VE max). Such a statistically have intensified HIF-1 decomposition (Jelkmann, significant increase in V max was noted in 2004) and consequently there is a decrease in EPO E research on swimmers (Truijens et al., 2003; synthesis. This can influence the reduction of Rodríguez et al., 2007). These changes, together erythrocytes precursors and decrease the vitality with the improvement of oxygen transport, of red blood cells. This phenomenon is called enhance cardiovascular-respiratory endurance, neocytolysis (Rice et al., 2005; Risso et al., 2007). In other research it has been observed that after 1-2 assessed by VO 2max . Greater oxygen utilization days at altitude, blood EPO level reaches its peak enables a more efficient aerobic muscular energy value and then it progressively decreases to base production in prolonged physical efforts. level (Eckardt et al., 1990). In their observations Exercise metabolism enhancement Robach et al. (2004) noted an increase in sTfR level For well trained athletes, a favourable and a simultaneous decrease in the EPO level phenomenon is the enhancement of movement during a one-week stay at an altitude of 4300 m economics combined with a reduction in oxygen above sea level, then EPO concentration uptake while maintaining the same effort decreased to basic values in 24h after the return to intensity after altitude acclimatization (Green et sea level. al., 2000b; Saunders et al., 2009). Oxygen uptake Inter alia that is why in the examination of reduction at a given intensity of exercise was athletes, in which erythropoiesis effects, such as associated in those observations with the change an increase in the erythrocytes mass (RCV) or the of substrate use towards accelerated uptake of percentage of blood haemoglobin, iron status was carbohydrates in comparison to free fatty acids, additionally controlled with the simultaneous which was supported by the level of respiratory
© Editorial Committee of Journal of Human Kinetics 94 Altitude Training and its Influence on Physical Endurance in Swimmers
indices: an increase in the RER index without concerns the best trained athletes, who are
-1 -1 changing VCO 2 and lowering VO2 . In this characterized by VO 2max above 65 ml·min ·kg . situation, an increase in energy production – ATP Such conditions result in higher vascular per mole of oxygen used in full oxidation of hipoxemia and proportionally more reduced glycogen (Green et al., 2000b) – was obtained. work capacity. It is bound to venoarterial Unfavourable symptoms of AT in athletes shunting, irregular perfusion ventilation and Altitude training in athletes is connected not limited alveolar-capillary diffusion. only with the enhancement of effort efficiency or In the initial phase of staying in the enhanced physical endurance after a return to sea mountains, blood pH changes proceed towards level. Hypoxic conditions cause additional more alkalization together with increased physiological strain on the organism. Therefore, in hyperventilation and increased CO2 excretion. It order to avoid the build-up of fatigue or acute induces a lower level of hydrogen ions mountain sickness (AMS), effort intensity is lower concentration in body fluids. Active hydrogen in comparison to training at sea level. Wilber ions transportation form blood to cerebrospinal (2007a) claims that many runners and swimmers fluid directly without neuron-contacting central have noticed a loss of race pace fitness form and control and respiratory system, which lowers turnover after specific AT with reduced intensity. blood alkalinity as a result of removing part of the Hypoxia lowers muscle energy production with bases by the kidneys (Kozłowski, 1986). Cases of the involvement of free fatty acids in prolonged maintenance of high muscle and blood mitochondria in the Krebs cycle, especially at lactate concentration are caused by an intensified higher effort intensity. The restitution time after anaerobic metabolism engagement. High lactate training is prolonged; sleeping problems, and hydrogen ion concentrations might slow the headaches, nutritional disorders associated with predicted synthesis and excretion of EPO by the significant atmospheric pressure reduction occur kidneys (Gunga et al., 2007) and cause red blood in the first days of altitude acclimatization. More cells haemolysis (Szyguła, 1990), delaying an or less intense negative hypoxia effects appear improvement in haematological parameters. Gore even during the exposition and training at et al. (1998) have noted an overall lowering of medium heights (Gore et al., 2007); furthermore, creatine concentration in red blood cells in 8 track swimmers (Miyashita et al., 1998) may suffer from cyclists after a 31-day stay in the mountains a worse physical condition, including problems (Toluca, Mexico 2690 m above sea level), and such as diarrhea, the common cold, a sore throat training at different altitudes from 1850 to 4578 m or low back pain. It has been noted that at an above sea level. The occurrence of these altitude greater than 2000 m above sea level, AMS symptoms was explained by an intensification of symptoms, such as lung and brain swelling, heart- red blood cell decomposition. In the same cyclists, beat distortion and organism immune function an initial increase in mean corpuscular volume weakness, may appear (Bailey et al. 1997). Our (MCV) without a corresponding change in Hb knowledge of the trained human organism’s mass and blood volume were also found. In physiological reaction to hypoxic surrounding research conducted by Wilber et al. (2000), at a conditions tends to suggest that what is needed is high altitude (1860 m above sea level) a reduction of physical exercise intensity, triathlonists’ conditioning camp, an increase in increased recovery after all training units, in order blood plasma creatine kinase (CK) and cortizol to allow regeneration and progressive level were noted during and after a 5-week period acclimatization. It is well known that attempts of intensive training. This is connected with have been made to maintain the effort intensity skeletal muscle catabolism (Hakkinen et al., 1989). close to that of sea level from the very beginning An increased CK level accompanies muscular of altitude camps. The will to maintain high tissue microinjuries and the beginning of a training quality without using the base level of delayed onset of muscle soreness. Skeletal muscle training is the main reason as to why Koistinen et microinjuries cause an increase in free al. (1995) have noted an altitude reduction of intercellular calcium (Ca2+) and A2 phospholipase. effort capabilities which is connected to maximal They occur as a result of sarcomer breaks during minute oxygen uptake reduction, what especially eccentric contractions (Nosaka et al., 1995). It is
Journal of Human Kinetics volume 28/2011, http://www.johk.pl by strzała M. et al. 95
also accompanied by post exercise chambers (hypobaric hypoxia). This method was immunosuppression (neutrophillia, eosinophilia, introduced by Finnish scientists for their athletes, lymphocytopenia) (Nieman et al., 1997) and who wanted to utilise the favourable hypoxia increased susceptibility to infections. organism adaptation without inconvenient and Altitude training forms expensive travelling (Rusko et al., 1995). Athletes LH+TH – live high and train high – the original are exposed to hypoxia in rooms; training is the AT method was to continually stay at a medium only break from the hypoxia. In a hypoxic room, height between 1500 and 4000 m above sea level; they breath with air depleted in oxygen by N2 it was assumed that during this period, enrichment (Koistinen et al., 2000; Gore et al., moderately intense training would result in an 2001) or some oxygen is filtered out (Robach et al., increase in blood erythrocyte mass, which means 2006; Schmitt et al., 2006). These researchers recommend staying at a simulated height of ≥ VO 2max improvement in normoxia conditions, 3000 m for at least 3h·d-1 for 1-3 weeks. Those while simultaneously improving endurance conditions, in which athletes who train using the (Wilber, 2007a). Live high and train high – LH+TH IHE method, e.g. swimmers (Rodríguez et al., – for athletes living at sea level takes place during 2007), closer to a high-mountain climate are those camps in defined periods throughout an annual used in hypobaric chambers where a lower training cycle. Studies show (Nies et al., 2003) that atmospheric pressure is present. Rodríguez et al. a good compromise between mountain condition (2000) suggest that IHE application prevents sport stress and moderate training intensity is the shape decrease after a sudden elevation at choice of a height of around 2500 m above sea significant altitude, and support erythropoiesis level. Other researchers, considering mainly the with a simultaneous improvement of effort haematological indices, which have the strongest capabilities. influence on endurance capabilities in sports such LL+TH – live low and train high by IHT – as running, speed skating, cycling and swimming, Intermittent Hypoxic Training – Classified as – the recommended choice of altitude is between LL+TH (live low and train high) – living at sea level 1500 and 3000m (Friedmann et al., 1997). The with altitude training (Wilber, 2007a). This AT duration of time spent at AT camps averages 3 model, in which athletes exercise in hypoxic weeks (Miyashita et al., 1988; Bailey, 1997; conditions from seconds to hours for periods Heinicke at al., 2005), and endurance lasting from days to weeks (Millet et al., 2010). improvement at sea level might be noted after re- Hypoxia is produced artificially in rooms or acclimatization to sea level conditions, with blood hypobaric chambers as well as using plasma volume alignment, which decreases its hypoxicators, which enable the breathing of a gas volume in high-mountain conditions as a result of mixture (Katayama et al., 2004). This solution was increased water excretion (Bailey, 1997). also used in swimmers (Truijens et al., 2003). Such LH+TL – live high and train low (via methods simulate the atmospheric conditions natural/terrestrial altitude) – A technique that is present at an altitude of 2500 – 3500 m above sea well-known and often used by athletes (Wehrlin level. The interval effort in such conditions occurs et al., 2006), the hypoxic training method involves in periods from 5 to 180 minutes (Wilber, 2007a). living in natural mountain conditions (high) and Millet et al. (2010) show that intermittent hypoxic training at low altitudes (at sea level). This interval training interspersed (IHIT) is defined as solution, when compared to the classical LH+TH a method where, during a single training session, method, enables the maintenance of normal there is an alternation between hypoxia and training intensity. It prevents the loss of training normoxia. power during the initial altitude acclimatization The researchers claim that, in a manner period and enables the activation of favourable similar to IHE, time spent outside the chamber, in altitude effects (cardiovascular, respiratory and which the IHT method is applied, might also be metabolic adaptations) (Millet et al., 2010). used for additional normal training activity, as in LH+TL – live high and train low by IHE – the case of swimmers in Truijens et al. (2003) and Intermittent Hypoxic Exposure – another solution other athletes (Meeuwsen et al., 2001; Hendriksen for hypoxia application is its simulation in et al., 2003). Another advantage of the IHT normoxia conditions, such as in rooms, tents or
© Editorial Committee of Journal of Human Kinetics 96 Altitude Training and its Influence on Physical Endurance in Swimmers
method is recovery after altitude training in sea propulsive continuity between the two arms level conditions, which prevents the occurrence of action. the negative symptoms of prolonged high- Swimmers altitude training mountain exposure. These circumstances do not AT with the use of a chosen hypoxic method force a reduction in the amount of physical is particularly appropriate for the sport of training, and they prevent sleep perturbations swimming. Former use of the classical method and dehydration; they also enable normal LH+TH therefore entailed travelling to a location alimentation. The behaviour of athletes using IHT with a swimming pool situated at the desired methods results in the improvement of non- height. In swimming AT is designed to enhance haematological physical endurance indices, such the overall physical endurance level in the as an increase in mitochondria density, the preparatory phase and obtaining the highest muscular fiber of capillary ratio and the cross- possible sport efficiency shaped in the details for a section of muscular fibers (Vogt et al., 2001; Czuba given competition in the tapering phase. The et al., 2011). It also enables changes in the blood planned effect to achieve the highest standard of oxygen transport properties. These effects, fitness through altitude adaptation is most however, are not always significant (Truijens et frequently obtained from 5 to 12 days after al., 2003; Roels et al., 2007). returning to sea level at the start of the most Apnoea – French researchers (Lemaître et al. 2010) important competition phase (Miyashita et al., claim that apnoea training may well be a training 1998; Robertson et al., 2010). For example method used in the future. In sea-mammals, as Friedmann et al. (2005) report that the optimum well as in humans, spleen contraction occurs period is 10 days after a return to sea level. during apnoea, provoking extrusion of According to experienced German coaches this accumulated erythrocytes. In literature studies on time interval is required for swimmers to achieve this particular field, Lemaître et al. (2010) have maximum sea level performance after altitude observed that in subjects after 5 repeated apnoeas, training. In this time the results may be influenced there is an increase in Hct and Hb (both in the by even small changes in haematological and range from 2% to 5%), which reduces arterial muscle biochemical variables. oxygen desaturation and enhances exercise Observations conducted on swimmers using metabolism. Lemaître et al. (2010) believe that various AT methods, beginning with camps using such effects obtained mainly by freedivers can the natural LH+TH method, through to artificial also be achieved in regular training by swimmers, approaches using hypoxic chambers or rooms and it might be an easy method to boost (LH+TL or LL+TH), or a combined approach that is immediate performance. Apnoea should be used also used more frequently with swimmers (Table directly before a race because its effects (i.e. 1a. and 1b.) are described in the literature. From increased Hct) disappear in 10 minutes after the the point of view of subjects who want to apply last apnoea (Espersen et al., 2002; Schagatay et al., AT information, how it has been implemented 2005). After apnoea training in swimmers, the and the effects obtained by other researchers and research conducted by Lemaître et al. (2009) practitioners of swimming are important. indicated that 30-second apnoea epochs separated LH+TH – for example, during two independent by 30 seconds of breathing room air during 1 hour three-week camps held in Mexico City (2300 m of steady state cycling exercise at 30% of their above sea level) two groups of Japanese maximum oxygen uptake presented a significant swimmers undertook swim training (about 5000 m per two hours) twice a day for successive days increase in peak VO 2 , minimal arterial oxygen and then had a non-training resting day saturation (SaO2min) and power at the Respiratory Compensation Point in a maximum (Miyashita et al., 1988). Researchers qualify that incremental test on a cycle ergometer. Swimmers the extent of the swimming distance was in the did not improve their performance (clean velocity usual way tapered towards the swim meets three and time on 50 m); however, they improved their days after altitude training (Table 1a.). The Swim technique by decreasing their stroke rate and Meet held in Indianapolis 1982 or the Pre- increasing their stroke length and index Olympic Games in Los Angeles 1993. The 8 coordination of arm, demonstrating greater swimmers in 1982 improved their results to a
Journal of Human Kinetics volume 28/2011, http://www.johk.pl by strzała M. et al. 97
degree that was statistically significant at the of 12-athletes reached very high results at distance of 200 m, but no improvement was different distances. noticed for the distance of 100 m. In 1993, only 5
Table 1a. A summary of studies on altitude and hypoxic training with swimmers. Post-altitude and altitude of Hypoxic Group swimming, hematological, Type of Authors Research schedule biochemical, endurance results training ( ) improvement, ( ) no change, Control Group ( ) deterioration 8♂, (13-19y) V competition 100m, V competition 200m, RBC, Hb, Miyashita et no 21 day swimming training at altitude Htc al. (1988) 2300m (Mexico City, Mexico) 4♀, 8♂ (13-18y) RBC, Hb, Htc, V (not measured) no 12♀, 8♂ V 100m; peak power [W] and mean power [W] of upper Martino et al. 21 day sprint swimming training extremities in Wingate test. (1995) 7♀, 6♂ at altitude 2800m No significant improvement in the control group 8♀, 14♂ V max in 5x200m test, La/V 24 day swimming training camp at Pyne (1998) (lactate-velocity curve in 5x200m no altitude 2100m (Flagstaff , USA) LH+TH test) Two separate altitude swimming 3♀, 3♂, (ns) shift to the right La/V camps with 1,5 month gap, at 2100m Tachi et al. (18.0±1.3y) of lactate-velocity curve (Flagstaff, USA)First held 21 day, (2002) in incremental swimming tests second 19, 21 no through and after both camps or 30 day for each pair of swimmers Camp I: 1200m: sTfR, MCV, 8♂ (16.3±0.9y) Two 13 days camps separated by Reticulocytes [%], RBC, VEmax, 6 weeks of sea level training. Roels et al.. VO2max, V 2000m. First camp held on ≈1200m, (2006) Camp II: 1850m: sTfR, MCV, no second camp held on ≈1850m Reticulocytes [%], RBC,