Queensland South Native Title Services ANNUAL REPORT 2019 - 2020 QSNTS ANNUAL REPORT Prepared for the National Indigenous Australians Agency
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 i LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL The Hon Ken Wyatt AM MP Minister for Indigenous Australians Parliament House Canberra ACT 2600
25 November 2020
Dear Minister
We are pleased to present the 2019-20 Annual Report for Queensland South Native Title Services Limited (QSNTS).
This report is provided in accordance with the Australian Government’s National Indigenous Australians Agency (NIAA) terms and conditions relating to the native title funding agreement under s203FE(1) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (NTA). The report includes independently audited financial statements for the financial year ending 30 June 2020.
Thank you for your ongoing support of the work QSNTS is undertaking.
Yours sincerely
Bernie Yates Acting Chairperson On behalf of the QSNTS Board of Directors
ii Annual Report 2019 – 2020 WARNING TO ABORIGINAL AND TORRES STRAIT ISLANDER READERS: This annual report may contain culturally sensitive information and images of people who have passed away since publication. We sincerely regret any distress that may be caused.
Queensland South Native Title Services acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land on which we live and work, and pay our respect to Elders past and present.
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 iii CONTACT DETAILS Brisbane Office Level 10, 307 Queen Street Brisbane, Queensland, 4000
PO Box 10832, Adelaide Street Brisbane, Queensland, 4001
P (07) 3224 1200 | 1800 663 693 E [email protected] W www.qsnts.com.au
Mount Isa Office 31-33 Commercial Road Mount Isa, Queensland, 4825
PO Box 1948 Mount Isa, Queensland, 4825
P (07) 4743 1322 | 1800 663 693 E [email protected]
QSNTS Annual Report Contact Media and Communications Coordinator | Jasmin Michiels
Annual Report Photography Photography and artwork sourced from stock or generously submitted by QSNTS stakeholders and staff.
Cover Artwork Jasmin Michiels and Suckerpunch Design
Design and Layout Suckerpunch Design (Copyright QSNTS 2020)
iv Annual Report 2019 – 2020 TABLE OF CONTENTS 02 Glossary 06 Chairperson’s Report 08 CEO Report 12 Directors and Executives 18 QSNTS Overview 19 Who We Are 20 What We Do 21 Our Services 23 Requests for Assistance 26 Strategic Plan and Priorities 28 Performance Report 29 Responding to COVID-19 in Native Title 30 Strategic Plan Focus Areas 30 1. Securing Outcomes Through Recognition of Right People for Right Country 44 2. Supporting Traditional Owners to Manage Country 57 3. Becoming the Service Provider of Choice for Prescribed Bodies Corporate 63 4. Advocating Reform to Enhance Native Title for Traditional Owners 70 Corporate Report 71 Organisational Structure 74 Financial Performance Report 79 External Scrutiny 80 Consultants and Competitive Tendering and Contracting 82 Human Resources Report 83 Workforce Planning 84 Workforce Profile, Retention and Turnover 84 Enterprise Agreement 85 Training and Development 86 Workplace Health and Safety 87 PBC Assistance 87 Looking Ahead: Human Resources in 2020-21 88 Financial Report
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 01 GLOSSARY Applicant The person or persons authorised by the native title claim group to represent the group in matters arising under the NTA in relation to the native title determination application.
Authorisation The process (usually in the form of a meeting) that a native title claim group uses to give permission to deal with matters arising in relation to that application, including a determination application.
Claim An application for a determination of native title, a revised determination of native title or a compensation application under s 61 of the NTA. Also referred to as a native title determination application or a native title application.
Claimant A claimant application is made by a group of people, a native title claim group, who declare they hold rights and interests in an area of land and/or water according to their traditional laws and customs.
Commonwealth of Australia The Commonwealth of Australia as a respondent party in a native title determination application, being the Commonwealth Government. Also referred to as ‘the Commonwealth’.
Cultural Heritage The Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 (Qld) extends legal protection to any area or object that is significant or is evidence of historical or archaeological significance, to Aboriginal People throughout the state of Queensland. These areas and objects are known as ‘cultural heritage’. 02 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 Future Act A future act is a proposed activity that may affect native title, such as mining or exploration activities, compulsory acquisition, tourism and other developments. Under the NTA and the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2011 (Qld), a Traditional Owner or Traditional Owner group with a registered native title claim retains certain procedural rights, including the right for Applicants to be notified and consulted with in respect of future acts that may affect their native title rights and interests.
Indigenous Land Use Agreement An Indigenous Land Use Agreement (ILUA) is a negotiated agreement between native title groups and other parties (for example, government, pastoralists and utility providers) about the use and management of land and waters in a certain area.
Non-claimant A non-claimant application is made by a person who holds a non-native title interest in an area of land and/or water. This could be the Commonwealth or a State Government, or a person or organisation that holds a lease or licence.
National Indigenous Australians Agency The National Indigenous Australians Agency is the Commonwealth government department responsible for implementing federal policies and programs to support Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. The NIAA is the funding body for QSNTS.
National Native Title Council Established in 2005, the National Native Title Council (NNTC) operates at a national level as a unified coalition of Prescribed Bodies Corporate (PBCs), Native Title Representative Bodies (NTRBs) and Native Title Service Providers (NTSPs) from across Australia, serving to identify, explore and resolve challenges and obstacles faced by Traditional Owners in their pursuit of native title outcomes.
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 03 Native Title The communal, group or individual rights and interests of Aboriginal Peoples and Torres Strait Islanders in relation to land and waters, where the rights and interests are possessed under the traditional law acknowledged and the traditional customs observed by the group or individual. The NTA refers to the recognition of these rights and interests by the Federal Court of Australia.
Prescribed Body Corporate A Prescribed Body Corporate for the purposes of native title is a corporation required to be nominated by the claim group to hold and manage their native title rights and interests upon receiving a positive native title determination.
Queensland Representative Body Alliance The Queensland Representative Body Alliance (QRBA) is a strategic alliance of each of the NTRBs and NTSPs in Queensland. The QRBA was formed in 2013 and provides a forum for information sharing, issue identification, strategy development and advocacy at a state level.
Registered Native Title Body Corporate Following a positive determination, PBCs are entered onto the National Native Title Register. At this point, the corporation becomes a registered native title body corporate (RNTBC). While the terms PBC and RNTBC are often used interchangeably, the NTA deals with them separately. While RNTBC is technically the accurate name for these organisations, PBC is the most commonly used term.
State of Queensland The Queensland State Government and principal respondent party to a native title determination application. Also referred to as ‘the State’.
04 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 AIATSIS NTA Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) Torres Strait Islander Studies NTRB CEO Native Title Representative Body Chief Executive Officer NTSP CFO Native Title Service Provider Chief Financial Officer ORIC CHMP Office of the Registrar of Indigenous Cultural Heritage Management Plan Corporations
COO PBC Chief Operating Officer Prescribed Body Corporate
DPLO PLO Deputy Principal Legal Officer Principal Legal Officer
DPMC QRBA Department of the Prime Minister Queensland Representative and Cabinet Body Alliance
ILUA QSNTS Indigenous Land Use Agreement Queensland South Native Title Services MOU Memorandum of Understanding RNTBC Registered Native Title Body NIAA Corporate National Indigenous Australians Agency WTA Walking Together Agreement NNTT National Native Title Tribunal SDS Service Delivery Schedule NNTC National Native Title Council
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 05 CHAIRPERSON’S REPORT On behalf of the QSNTS Board, I am pleased to provide this report for 2019-20 as Acting Chairperson.
Just prior to the end of the year, our Chairperson, Colleen Wall, resigned after a decade with the Board, with much of that time as Chair. We express our deep appreciation for Col’s contribution, including her leadership, wise counsel and cultural expertise. Col developed strong relationships with clients and staff and led the organisation through a series of major changes to ensure it remained well-placed to support the aspirations of Traditional Owners in our region. We wish her well with her new endeavours, continuing her strong commitment to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.
During the year, the Board was pleased to welcome as new Directors, Wayne Denning, a proud Birri Gubba man, from July 2019; and Craig North, a proud descendant of the Bidjara people, from March 2020. They have brought extensive capabilities and experience, including in the areas of native title, communications and advancing economic development opportunities with Traditional Owners.
06 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 Bernie Yates, QSNTS Board of Directors The year saw significant progress made on 21 native title claims, including three that were positively determined; nine on the path to achieve consent determinations; and others progressed through our regional research program. Congratulations to the Gunggari, Quandamooka and Butchulla peoples for their native title outcomes this year.
QSNTS has also extended its work with PBCs in the region, supporting them in the management of their native title rights and interests. While QSNTS is constrained to apply its government-funded resources to meet its statutory responsibilities, it has found ways to help Traditional Owners and their PBCs to advance their aspirations beyond those limits through the use of cost recovery.
An important priority in 2019-20 was developing strategic responses to the High Court decision in the Timber Creek case, which opened the way to Traditional Owners to seek and pursue compensation claims. QSNTS has focused a lot of its advocacy efforts on this issue and has worked closely with the NNTC to help develop and progress a sector- wide strategy to guide how claims can best be progressed to maximise the prospects of successful outcomes.
Early in 2020, the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic impacted QSNTS as it did so many other organisations across Queensland and Australia generally. I commend the management team and all staff for the outstanding job done in responding and working with the restrictions introduced by government and the heath authorities to help contain the virus.
Keeping our clients and staff safe was the first priority, while adjusting to new ways of working to meet our commitments to Traditional Owners and the Federal Court. This has been challenging, especially with not being able to hold in-person meetings impacting field research and how QSNTS has had to conduct authorisation meetings and other engagements with Traditional Owners. The move to electronic meetings has had to be carefully planned and implemented so as to maximise participation and manage risks appropriately.
QSNTS has demonstrated that it continues to deliver its services effectively, despite the challenges that come our way. The Board thanks the CEO, Kevin Smith, and his senior leadership team for the cooperation and support they have provided to the Board during 2019-20. Thank you to our staff for the dedication shown and readiness to find innovative ways to enable the organisation to continue its journey walking with Traditional Owners.
Bernie Yates Acting Chair
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 07 CEO REPORT Annual reports are a reflection upon an organisation’s annual performance in terms of planning, implementation, management and adaption within the context of a fluid multi- jurisdictional/multi-sectoral external environment. All of these intricate and moving parts make each organisation’s annual performance unique. Not in 2020.
There would be few organisations on the planet that were not in some way affected by a common nemesis: COVID-19. It has been (and is) the biggest threat to humanity since the last worldwide pandemic a hundred years ago. A virus that is indiscriminate in its selection of a host, be they rich or poor, and was capricious in the symptoms it inflicted. Tragically, a virus with a perverse predilection for the vulnerable - our venerated elderly.
However, through the lockdowns and restrictions, everyone has gained a renewed appreciation of the importance of relationships, be they with friends, family, work colleagues, neighbours or local community. We also gained a better understanding of the importance of place, be it the security of a home, reliable access to the necessary range of services and products, or the amenity of a particular locality. The COVID-enforced economic recession has heightened levels of uncertainty and stress, forcing people to dig deep into their reserves of resilience, yet necessity forced invention, and technology enabled people to stay connected and maintain some semblance of business continuity.
Kevin Smith, CEO 08 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 If COVID has forced a change in perspective, then these new perspectives may give some important insights into an Indigenous world view that are worthy of embracing and nurturing for the common good. Elders are knowledge holders and our links to the past, and must be protected. The rights of the individual must sometimes succumb to the rights of the community, but in that forbearance for the common good, an individual learns how to be human – and this crisis has given insights into our humanity. Being part of a community involves co-existence and respect for place; Country. Resilience is built, fortified and renewed when there is a strong connection between people and place, and a resolute will to forge a common future - a sense that we are in this together.
On the other hand, the challenge for Traditional Owners in the ‘COVID Normal’ is how to do community business (including native title) in a different way that protects Elders and vulnerable community members along with the broader Mob, but allows participation in important decisions. In other words, doing the same business but in a different way. These dual challenges can be enabled by technology, provided people are open to new ways of doing things.
These might sound like broad statements, but the points raised above are directly relevant to the evolution of QSNTS’ service delivery model. For instance, QSNTS is working with the Boonthamurra People on a prototype that applies a ‘People, Place and Partnership’ approach to managing the Indigenous estate; an approach that focuses on mapping human and social capital that is drawn from First Nations’ two most important assets: People and Country. This approach has a rights-based focus that draws upon the recognised native title, future act and cultural heritage rights, and translates them into a practical model that will strengthen governance, improve operational proficiency and enhance economic
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 09 opportunities via strategic stakeholder management. A mix of technology and tradition will be used to drive these changes. QSNTS looks forward to continuing the constructive work with the Boonthamurra People to finalise the project so the lessons can be shared and applied among other First Nations with the exciting prospect of scaling up the projects to cover whole regions.
Consolidation of the Indigenous estate is important to the People, Place and Partnership model, which means finalising outstanding claims attached to existing determinations. In this regard, it is great to see the Gunggari, Quandamooka and Butchulla peoples resolving additional claims during the reporting period. Significant work was also completed for many other native title claimants during 2019-20 that will pave the way for consent determinations in the 2021 and 2022 years. The aim is to roll out the ‘People, Place and Partnership’ model during the final claim phase to ensure a seamless transition from recognition to management of the Indigenous estate.
In the coming years, the role of PBCs will become more prominent beyond native title because such structures have an important role in broader aspirations involving Treaty, Voice and Closing the Gap coordination. QSNTS is working with the NNTC on public advocacy to ensure PBCs are front and centre in such initiatives.
QSNTS is also working with the NNTC and other NTRB/NTSPs to ensure a strategic approach is adopted toward the resolution of native title compensation. This strategy aims to broaden and increase the resources available to the Indigenous estate.
Despite the success in 2020, the challenges have been immense. A quote often repeated by world leaders in hard times is that “you never want a serious crisis to go to waste”. Native title claimants, holders, PBCs and representative bodies need to heed those words and make sure there is no ‘return to business as usual’, because in a deep recession, it might mean an actual regression as the jostling for priorities peg back hard-fought advances. We cannot let that happen. We cannot afford to waste this crisis but success will depend on our ability to embrace the challenge of doing business differently. The world has witnessed good and bad leadership during this crisis, with the hallmark of good leadership being the good of the people. First Nations have an opportunity to show leadership in the benefits of a communitarian approach particularly amidst, and arising from, a crisis - we are truly the experts when it comes to harnessing the power of community. It is our time, so let’s not waste the crisis.
10 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 Talking about remarkable leadership, QSNTS has been favoured with the strong leadership of Aunty Colleen Wall as Chair of the QSNTS Board for many years. Aunty Col decided to retire from the Board in early 2020 to focus on her deep passion for the arts and the importance of its preservation, protection and practise as a manifestation of culture itself. Thank you for the selfless commitment, impenetrable integrity, sage wisdom and wry humour – you will be missed.
Thank you also to Acting Chair Bernie Yates and the very committed Directors for your leadership over this “interesting” year. Thank you to the Executive team for the hard work during the year, but in particular, for your remarkable agility in leading adjustment with the advent of the pandemic. As always, thank you to the amazing QSNTS staff whose commitment to our clients and our work came to the fore when they all commenced working from home in the interest of protecting our clients and one another.
Finally, to the clients and constituents, thank you for your patience during the COVID adjustment. It was another challenging year, but there were many good outcomes, and QSNTS looks forward to continuing the walk with you on your native title journey.
Kevin Smith CEO Queensland South Native Title Services
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 11 DIRECTORS AND EXECUTIVES Directors Colleen Wall (Chairperson) Appointed 9 November 2010 to 28 May 2020
Daughter of Herb and Alfa Geiszler (nee Beezley), granddaughter of Bert and Mary Beezley (nee Minniecon), Colleen is a Senior Dauwa Kabi Woman from the Wide Bay and Munna Creek tributaries of the Mary River. Colleen works from an Aboriginal Land Law framework and through Grandmother’s Law and strives to achieve a cultural balance for healing. Her aim is to have grandmothers recognised by governments and the legal system as key drivers in the traditional practice of child rearing. Colleen is developing a Cultural Care program for children in long term care informing them and their carers on the basics around Aboriginal Grandmother’s Law and the growing up of resilient, respectful and responsible children. She teaches respect for Mother Earth and Murung (Totems) as significant beings in maintaining balance in spiritual, physical and mental health and through children’s Lore Stories shows their importance in the healthy cultural growth of our young ones. Colleen is a former Member of Family Law Council Australia and her paper on Grandmother’s Aboriginal Child Rearing Practice is on their website. She is currently cultural advisor to Queensland Performing Arts Center and Brisbane Power House (Australian Performing Arts Market). Colleen has recently worked for Save the Children, Anglicare and Relationships Australia Queensland and is now working with the global research group IPSOS on the Women’s Safety Package.
Bernie Yates (Acting Chairperson) Appointed 14 March 2011
Until 2010, Bernie had a long career in the Australian Public Service (APS) working in policy and service delivery areas for various agencies, including Treasury and Employment and Industrial Relations. He moved into Indigenous affairs in the early 2000s, with ATSIC and the then Department of Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs (FaHCSIA). Bernie was involved in developing the Council of Australian Governments’ Closing the Gap Strategy and represented the Australian Government at the United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Affairs. Since leaving the APS, he has been a part-time consultant and volunteer, primarily working in the Indigenous affairs area. He is also an independent director of Miwatj Health Aboriginal Corporation, an Aboriginal Medical Service in the Top End.
12 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 Directors Pele Bennet (Director) Appointed 10 August 2015
Pele is a descendant of St Paul’s Village on Moa Island in the Torres Straits. A mother of four, Pele was born and raised in Brisbane and is a proud member of the region’s Indigenous community. Currently employed as a Manager in the Department of Youth Justice with an extensive career in the health sector, Pele commenced her career as a trainee health worker and has worked in government and non- government sectors for over 20 years. Previously employed at Queensland Aboriginal and Islander Health Council as Manager of Health Programs, and former Director of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Community Health Service, Pele holds several qualifications, including a Bachelor of Health Science and certificates in leadership, training/education and coaching/mentoring. Pele has a demonstrated history of working in the non-profit organisation management industry and is skilled in Coaching, Epidemiology, Prevention, Facilitation, and Health Promotion.
Margaret Stephenson (Director) Appointed 16 March 2018
Margaret Stephenson held the position of Associate Professor at Law at the TC Beirne School of Law, University of Queensland (UQ) being a member of Faculty 1983-2017. Currently, Margaret is Visiting Associate- Professor, Sustainable Minerals Institute, Centre for Social Responsibility in Mining, UQ. Prior to commencing an academic career Margaret practised as a solicitor in Property Law in Brisbane. During her academic career, Margaret championed the development of courses in Property Law, Native Title Law and International and Comparative Indigenous Rights. In 2010, she received a national Citation for Outstanding Contributions to Student Learning in the Australian Awards for University Teaching, and in 2009 she was awarded the Vice-Chancellor’s Internationalisation Award for leadership in internationalising the curriculum. Margaret has published extensively in Property Law, Native Title Law and Comparative Indigenous Rights and speaks frequently at international and national conferences on these topics. Her first book, Mabo: A Judicial Revolution remains a seminal work on the Mabo decision. She has also compiled and edited Mabo: The Native Title Legislation and Australia: Republic or Monarchy, and is co-author of Land Law. In addition to serving on numerous University Committees, Margaret was the UQ co-ordinator of the Aurora Project (Native Title Representative Bodies Australian Student Internships).
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 13 Directors
Julie Finlayson (Director) Appointed 13 March 2018
Dr Julie Finlayson is a social anthropologist by training with a varied career history in anthropology. She is currently Research Fellow managing the Centre for Native Title Anthropology (CNTA) at the Australian National University (ANU). She is a member of the National Centre for Indigenous Studies’ Panel of Research Experts at the ANU. Her original doctoral research concerned welfare-dependent Aboriginal households near Kuranda in north Queensland, which has informed much of her research and interest in rural and remote Indigenous communities. She was a lecturer at La Trobe University, and then a researcher at the Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research at the ANU. She was also an independent consultant, including in native title, before working in various Federal bureaucracies on matters relating to Indigenous affairs. More recently, before taking up her position at CNTA, Julie worked for an Aboriginal-owned organisation in central-western NSW on an innovative housing project in Bourke, and managed an Aboriginal-controlled radio station in Wilcannia for a year, bringing to it a focus on community development and inclusiveness.
Glenn Ferguson Appointed 12 June 2019
A Solicitor of the High Court of Australia and the Supreme Court of Queensland, Glenn is the Managing Director for FC Lawyers and an Adjunct Professor of Law at the University of the Sunshine Coast. Glenn has served as President of LAWASIA, the Law Council of Australia and the Queensland Law Society, and is an advisor in governance, risk and compliance with a particular interest in cyber security and risk. He is a Founding Fellow of the Australian Academy of Law, a Fellow of the Australian Institute of Company Directors, Fellow of the College of Law and a Fellow of the Australia and New Zealand College of Notaries. Glenn has also held a number of board positions in both the public and private sector in aviation, charity, education, information technology, insurance, security, superannuation and workers compensation. He has been appointed by both Federal and State Governments to various advisory boards and task forces in the business, legal and migration sectors. In 2004, the Queensland Premier selected Glenn to Chair Smart Exports Queensland, and in 2010, he was appointed by the Prime Minister to the Expert Panel considering the recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders in the Constitution. Glenn has for over ten years chaired the Law Council of Australia’s indigenous legal issues committee, and in the 2015 Australia Day Honours, Glenn was made a
14 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 Directors
Member of the Order of Australia ‘for significant service to the law and to the legal profession, both nationally and in the Asia-Pacific region, and to the community’.
Wayne Denning (Director) Appointed 18 July 2019
Wayne holds a Bachelor of Arts (Sociology, Psychology, Political Geography) from Central Queensland University and a Master of Business Administration (Corporate Governance, Strategy, Entrepreneurship) from the Queensland University of Technology. In 2006, Wayne, a proud Birri Gubba man, left a successful career working on landmark government policies in native title and land rights with the Federal Government to form creative agency Carbon Creative. Through Carbon Creative, Wayne aimed to give Indigenous Australians a positive voice, and has done so for over a decade, providing creative communication services in both children’s television and in the corporate arena. From his position as Managing Director, Wayne made a commitment to ensure Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children and young people, like their forbearers, are inspired and motivated to be part of and explore continued learning and innovation. Wayne embraces his role as the Deputy Chair of the National Film and Sound Archive of Australia, and as a board member of the Australian Indigenous Mentoring Experience. He has also recently been a member of the Queensland Theatre Board, a Digital Ambassador for the Queensland Government, and a member of the Queensland Government’s Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Business and Innovation Reference Group.
Craig North (Director) Appointed 11 March 2020
A proud descendent of the Bidjara People, Craig has enjoyed an extensive senior executive career in both government and commercial sectors for the past 15 years, primarily in Indigenous Economic Development. Craig was the first Indigenous CEO of the Indigenous Land and Sea Corporation’s (ILSC) commercial agribusiness. In this role, Craig led a significant restructure of the ILSC’s commercial agribusiness portfolio and the execution of a new agribusiness diversification strategy. Whilst at the ILSC, Craig also held other senior executive positions, including Executive Director of Program Delivery where he was responsible for a national portfolio of investments to purchase and return Country to Indigenous groups across Australia. Responsibilities
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 15 Directors
also included oversight for new investments and projects focussed on improving, developing and caring for Country to provide sustainable cultural, environmental, social and economic benefits for Indigenous Australians. A key highlight in Craig’s career is the full development of the Indigenous award-winning tourism business, the Mossman Gorge Centre, in North Queensland. Craig is also the founder of Indigenous Impact Pty Ltd, a company established in 2020 to continue the work of creating and executing impact investment opportunities for Indigenous Australians, and he also holds a Bachelor of Environmental Science (Environmental Management) at Deakin University. Craig is also undertaking a Graduate Certificate in Business at the University of New England, and is also member of Australian Institute of Company Directors.
Executives
Kevin Smith Chief Executive Officer
Kevin holds traditional connections to Ugar (Stephen Island) and Erub (Darnley Island) in the Torres Strait and has nearly 30 years of professional experience in Indigenous affairs. He has held senior positions with the National Secretariat of Torres Strait Islander Organisations, the Brisbane Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Service, the National Native Title Tribunal, Aboriginal Hostels Limited and the NNTC. Kevin has filled the role of CEO of QSNTS since 2008. He holds qualifications in both law and business management from UQ, and was admitted as a solicitor in 1994.
Tim Wishart Principal Legal Officer
Tim joined QSNTS in August 2010 as a senior legal officer and has filled the role of PLO of QSNTS since 1 September 2011. He was admitted to practice in 1991. While his pre-QSNTS work was primarily in litigation and commercial law, Tim has been recognised as a leading native title practitioner by Doyle’s Guide, and is a nationally accredited mediator. Tim regularly presents papers on native title topics at specialist forums.
16 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 Executives
Paul Davies Chief Financial Officer
Paul was admitted as a Certified Practicing Accountant in 2003 after completing his studies at Queensland University of Technology. Paul has acquired a range of experience in the public and not-for-profit sectors, both in Australia and overseas. With over 14 years’ experience in native title, working for both representative bodies and service providers in Queensland, Paul has the skills required to assist PBCs to develop their corporate structures.
Felicity Thiessen Chief Operating Officer
Felicity commenced working with QSNTS as a legal officer in June 2017 and was appointed as COO on 1 July 2019. Felicity holds qualifications in law from the University of Southern Queensland, and anthropology from the University of Queensland. Prior to commencing with QSNTS, Felicity worked for the Federal Court of Australia and held positions with a number of agencies, including the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Services, the Department of Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs, and the National Native Title Tribunal.
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 17 QSNTS OVERVIEW
QSNTS Overview
18 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 QSNTS OVERVIEW
WHO WE ARE Queensland South Native Title Services Ltd
QSNTS is among the largest NTSPs in Australia. Recognised under section 203FE of the NTA, our region of responsibility covers nearly two-thirds of Queensland, spanning Mount Isa in the west, to Rockhampton in the east, and down to the state’s southern border.
Established in 2005 to operate in a region without any native title determinations since the NTA came into operation, QSNTS has since assisted 20 Traditional Owner groups to attain positive determinations, with a further 17 claims under way.
Collectively, the outcomes achieved for Traditional Owners have underpinned a substantial transformation of Queensland’s native title sector, with many areas now determined, or nearing determination. A growing number of Traditional Owners are now moving beyond the claim process and into the era of governance that must follow every positive determination, and as an NTSP committed to sustainable self-determination for Traditional Owners, QSNTS is evolving to ensure Native Title Holders receive the professional support they need to establish, understand and leverage native title rights and interests for the long-term benefit of their communities.
QSNTS is governed by a Constitution that confirms the company’s objective to provide native title services to the Traditional Owners of the land and waters in its statutory region. QSNTS is funded by the Commonwealth Government represented by the NIAA, and is therefore accountable to the NIAA for its conduct and expenditure.
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 19 QSNTS OVERVIEW
WHAT WE DO Our Role and Functions
As an NTSP, QSNTS performs the full range of statutory services prescribed by the NTA at the request, and for the benefit, of Traditional Owners with native title determinations, claims or potential claims within the organisation’s region of responsibility. The statutory services provided by QSNTS in accordance with the NTA are as follows: Section 203BB - Facilitation and Assistance QSNTS conducts the research and preparation of native title applications, and both represents and facilitates native title-related proceedings. These include consultations, mediation, negotiations and proceedings relating to native title applications, future acts, ILUAs and any other matter related to native title. Section 203BE - Certification Previously, QSNTS certified native title applications and applications for the registration of ILUAs, however this function is currently being considered in a matter before the High Court of Australia. Until a decision is handed down, QSNTS is not undertaking certification functions and is instead relying on an alternate procedure set out under s 24CG(3)(b) of the NTA. Section 203BF - Dispute Resolution QSNTS provides assistance in promoting agreement between clients regarding native title applications by conducting consultations, negotiations, mediation and other native title related proceedings. QSNTS provides mediation services between client groups regarding native title claim issues such as claim boundary overlaps and shared Apical Ancestors. Section 203BG - Notification QSNTS ensures that notification of proposed activities which relate to the land and waters wholly or partly within the region are brought to the attention of Native Title Holders and claimants, and relevant information is given to these persons. Section 203BH - Agreement Making QSNTS will participate as a party to ILUAs where appropriate, consulting with and having regard to the interests of native title claimants. Section 203BI - Internal Review At the request of clients, QSNTS undertakes internal reviews of decisions and actions carried out in the execution of statutory services, in accordance with policies and procedures which govern the internal review process. Section 203BJ - Other Functions QSNTS conducts other functions related to native title that aim to improve the native title system and to deliver better results for Traditional Owners. Examples of these functions include advocacy for reform, capacity development, regional research projects, and negotiating agreements with other organisations such as MOUs. In particular, QSNTS undertakes regional research projects pursuant to s 203BJ(b). 20 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 QSNTS OVERVIEW
OUR SERVICES In addition to providing the above-mentioned statutory services, QSNTS aims to be the native title service provider of choice for Traditional Owners on the path to self-determination, offering a comprehensive range of services under five key categories as follows: Native Title Claims QSNTS provides legal representation and facilitation assistance to native title claimants by providing consultation, mediation, negotiation, agreement-making and court appearances relating to their native title claims.
QSNTS also assists and facilitates research for, and preparation of, native title claims. This includes seeking evidence to determine ‘right people for right Country’, resolving disputes that may arise in identifying the claim group, and certifying claim lodgement with the Federal Court of Australia.
QSNTS has also recently commenced research and planning around potential native title compensation claims within our region of responsibility, guided by a compensation strategy developed in conjunction with the broader native title sector.
Future Acts Most future acts are notified under s 24 of the NTA. As the NTSP for the southern region of Queensland, QSNTS receives future act notices and forwards them to the relevant native title claim Applicants. QSNTS provides registered Applicants with assistance to understand the complex process, allowing them to comment on or object to the proposed activities.
Activities such as mining, petroleum, exploration and compulsory acquisition of land for non-government parties are notified under s 29 of the NTA. Where a right to negotiate applies, QSNTS provides a service representing the registered native title claim group in negotiation and arbitration of future acts as necessary.
In addition to legal representation, advice and negotiation services in respect of future acts, QSNTS assists Traditional Owners with understanding the location and impact of a proposed future act, organising meetings with future act proponents, and resolving issues with internal or external stakeholders.
Cultural Heritage Cultural heritage matters are managed by the registered cultural heritage body for the relevant area, often the Native Title Holder or registered native title claim group.
QSNTS supports Traditional Owners with managing cultural heritage by providing legal, negotiation and compliance services, as well as administrative support in organising meetings with relevant proponents.
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 21 QSNTS OVERVIEW
PBC Support As part of its commitment to assisting Traditional Owners with attaining self-determination through native title, QSNTS provides a range of support services for PBCs to help build capacity and maximise the opportunities provided through native title. These services include governance training, strategic planning, research products and assistance with grant applications, compliance, and agreement implementation, as well as corporate and administrative support in finance, human resources and communications. QSNTS also provides facilitation assistance and representation in negotiating, resolving and implementing native title agreements, including ILUAs, and planning has commenced toward compensation applications on behalf of several PBCs.
More information about QSNTS’ work with PBCs can be viewed in the Performance Report section of this Annual Report.
Advocacy QSNTS is committed to the development of a fair and balanced native title system, making advocacy for reform and improvement of native title processes and outcomes a necessary function of the organisation. To this end, QSNTS takes every opportunity to engage with reviews of administrative frameworks and of both state and federal legislation.
Further, QSNTS participates extensively in advocacy programs through its membership of the QRBA and the NNTC. More information about QSNTS’ advocacy activities in the reporting period can be viewed in the Performance Report section of this Annual Report.
22 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 QSNTS OVERVIEW
REQUESTS FOR ASSISTANCE QSNTS aims to provide Traditional Owners with the right support at the right time, through every step of the native title journey. However, as an NTSP, QSNTS may provide assistance to Traditional Owners only if a written request is both received and approved, in accordance with s 203BB of the NTA.
QSNTS assigns resources to requests for assistance in the descending order of priority provided below (noting that some lower order activities may require action before a higher order activity can be addressed):
1. Native Title Claims. All claims filed with the Federal Court must accord with credible evidence, and are handled either in-house or otherwise briefed out to competent, ethical practitioners. The amount of resources allocated, as well as other factors such as logistics, are associated with the size and location of the native title claim group. 2. PBC Support. PBC support includes legal assistance with native title and other related agreements, administrative support for key PBC functions, including governance, meetings, financial administration and other matters. 3. Regional Research. The strategic value of regional or specific research projects pursuant to s 203BJ are prioritised in circumstances where they may resolve native title across a wider region. This research serves to clarify complex regions that have multiple competing assertions of native title, as well as regions that have one or more adjoining native title determinations that can be used as ‘neighbour’ evidence to support new or current claims.
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 23 QSNTS OVERVIEW
4. Claim-Specific Research. This includes claim-specific research and investigation that arises from, and is consistent with, the s 203BJ research projects referred to above. 5. Dispute Resolution. This extends to both inter- and intra-Indigenous dispute resolution pursuant to s 203BJ, with particular priority being given to those claims that are subject to trials, or those claims capable of consent determination where connection has been accepted but outstanding Indigenous respondent issues remain. 6. Interlocutory Applications. Funding can be granted for interlocutory applications to dispose of unmeritorious Indigenous responses where dispute resolution (referred to above) has been unsuccessful. 7. Future Acts. This includes the provision of limited future act legal advice, representation and assistance.
While the order of priority for resource allocation remains the same, the balance in volume of services delivered by QSNTS has shifted in recent years due to the growing number of native title determinations made within its service boundaries. Since the 2008 amalgamation which extended QSNTS’ regional coverage, native title has been determined for 49 claims wholly or partially in the southern and western regions of Queensland, 25 of which were assisted by QSNTS. Accordingly, QSNTS has adapted its operations to better meet the changing needs of Traditional Owners in our region of responsibility by providing services not just to Native Title Claimants, but also to Native Title Holders following a determination. This is what we refer to as our ‘whole-of-client, whole-of- organisation approach’ to service delivery.
With this approach, we work together with Traditional Owners to develop long-term plans that capitalise on the long-term relationship built with QSNTS throughout the native title journey, from initial research all the way through to determination and thereafter. These plans are comprised of a Walking Together Agreement (WTA) and Service Delivery Schedule (SDS) which encompasses the views, needs and aspirations of our clients, and sets the foundations for a streamlined transition from Native Title Claimant to Native Title Holder.
24 Annual Report 2019 – 2020 QSNTS OVERVIEW
The SDS provides a clear view of what services we will be providing, who will be responsible for providing them, and when they will be provided by. Once the client has approved the SDS, it becomes attached to the WTA for the duration of the financial year.
The WTA is an agreement between QSNTS and the client that recognises the intention to walk and work together towards achieving the client’s native title aspirations and promotes a positive, cooperative and collaborative relationship that supports the efficient and effective delivery of QSNTS services to the client. The WTA is based on shared values of respect, trust, honesty, fairness and accountability, and is to be implemented with a spirit of goodwill.
The WTA and SDS are developed and finalised with each client as follows:
1. Initial meeting with QSNTS representative and the Applicant or Board to discuss QSNTS services and claim group or PBC goals and aspirations 2. QSNTS internal whole-of-client team meeting to identify the services that assist the client to achieve the goals. Allocating the tasks to team members and developing draft SDS that includes the estimated service delivery timeframes as well as the funding source 3. Draft SDS offer with deliverables is sent to the Applicant or Board for review and consideration 4. Amendments are made into the SDS, if necessary 5. WTA with the attached SDS is finalised and signed by both parties.
The WTA and SDS set out the tasks for the whole-of-client team for the financial year. A new WTA and SDS will be created with clients for the following financial year.
Annual Report 2019 – 2020 25 QSNTS OVERVIEW
STRATEGIC PLAN AND PRIORITIES During the 2019-20 year, QSNTS continued to focus on delivery against the strategic priorities of its Strategic Plan 2018-22.
Our strategic priorities are:
1. Securing outcomes through recognition of right people for right Country 2. Supporting Traditional Owners to manage Country 3. Becoming the service provider of choice for Prescribed Bodies Corporate 4. Advocating reform to enhance native title for Traditional Owners.
QSNTS’ Strategic Vision, Purpose and Values is provided below and Strategic Plan can be found on our website at: www.qsnts.com.au/strategic-plan
Our Vision Right People, Right Country, Right Path Our Values Respect Honesty Trust Fairness Accountability V ES VISION