Vendor Evaluation Criteria Response Matrix

RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) Vendor Address 800 Douglas Entrance, North Tower, 2nd 808 E. Las Olas Blvd., Ste. 101Ft. 396 Alhambra Circle, South Tower, Suite 191 Peachtree Street NE, Suite 1023 SW 25th Avenue, , FL 33135 Floor, Coral Gables, FL 33134 Lauderdale, FL 33301 500Coral Gables, FL 33134 2400Atlanta, GA 30303 Evaluation Criteria Vendor Response

PNC2116748P1 Page 1 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) 1. Ability of Professional Personnel (Other Than See Supplemental Information Section 1, Please see supplemental attachment Please refer to the Supplemental Information Resumes for all key staff members from the DPZ Partners, LLC (DPZ) has assembled a Lead Architect/Planner): Max Number of Points 5 Ability of Professional Personnel regarding item 1 for team organizational section attached. lead architect/planner (Cooper Carry), and seasoned, best-in-class team with renowned Include resumes for the Project Manager, Lead chart and resumes. key staff members from each of Cooper prowess and excellence in planning, urban Architect/Planner and all key staff described. Include the qualifications and relevant experience Carry's subconsultant team member firms design, and coding (DPZ – Prime/Lead of all subconsultants’ key staff to be assigned to are included in the corresponding Planner); progressive this project. supplemental pdf documents uploaded to ( [ARQ]); sound POINTS VALUE 5 BidSync. economics/market feasibility (Colliers International [Colliers]); integrated infrastructure, transportation/parking, and stormwater management (Keith & Schnars [K&S] and GIT Consulting [GIT]); and sustainability, health, and wellness (The Spinnaker Group [Spinnaker]) – bolstered with recognized service to public agencies on urban master plans and a deep understanding of the local development context – to successfully assist the County in this initiative. In addition to our core team above, Uber also joins us as a special advisor on the impacts of and interface between autonomous vehicles and the proposed development.DPZ & ARQ each have a record of built, transformative, high value projects in a range of contexts, and together have a unique history of design collaboration in this region. The two firms collectively shaped the trajectory of urban and architectural practice in for over 40 years, resulting in two globally acknowledged brands. Together the two firms approach the design of the built environment from the scale of the building to that of the city and beyond. The synergies of DPZ’s innovative, form-based planning and coding with ARQ’s distinctive eye for well- sited iconic buildings provide a framework for an economically successful regional destination.Similarly, DPZ and K&S have formed a collaborative partnership on multiple planning and engineering projects throughout Florida. These efforts most recently include spearheading a holistic and

PNC2116748P1 Page 2 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) regional approach to the Sawgrass Mills periphery as part of a larger transportation network/TOD study for the City of Sunrise that will inform this new community envisioned at the BB&T Center property.The detailed firm profiles and resumes provided as Supplemental Information attachments herewith highlight a diverse team whose experience far exceeds the RFQ.

PNC2116748P1 Page 3 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) 2. Project Approach (Philosophy and Design See Supplemental Information Section 2, Brooks + Scarpa is a multi-disciplinary Please refer to the Supplemental Information Guided by our experience creating urban The BB&T property master plan is an Intent): Max Number of Points 20 Project Approach practice that includes architecture, urban section attached. environments, our approach will establish instrument for true placemaking, to be A. Describe the firm’s approach and its familiarity design, planning, environmental design, the right balance of mixed-use development imbued with civic purpose, social capital and with key issues, conditions and expected challenges. Such as: working around an existing materials research, graphic, and interior and public space in phase one; creatively diversity, economic feasibility, environmental building that may become obsolete within ten design services. Awarded the 2010 National and functionally integrate the BB&T Center; sustainability, and tactical flexibility. There years and be demolished; designing pedestrian American Institute of Architecture Firm implement innovative infrastructure are no “silver bullets” (e.g. a standalone circulation that is separated from vehicular Award for nineteen years of consistently strategies; and entice the right private megaproject or a random urban design circulation; complex service issues (trash exemplary work seamlessly blending investment.Establishing the right mix of uses gesture) that create an authentic sense of removal, delivery services for supplies, food, mail, taxi and ride share drop off and pick-up, hotel architecture, art and craft, urban design and and public space for phase one is critical. In place; this area of Broward already has access and service); and the future need for planning. Brooks + Scarpa has teamed up the development of RiverPlace in Greenville, several financially successful but parking may drastically change due to automated with Kimley-Horn and Coastal Systems SC, phase one established enough retail, physically/functionally disconnected cars. Describe experience and provide specific International due to their long association office, hospitality, and residential mixed with destination projects. Rather, as an examples of how you may have dealt with these with mixed-use master planning project well-designed park and plaza space to opportunity for a more holistic planning effort issues in a phased mixed-use project. POINTS VALUE 4 experience nationwide and locally in Florida. activate the site from day one. Most for this part of Broward, the plan must Our team’s varied project history illustrates importantly, a sense of place, or the “there” reintegrate the greater urban fabric to our ability to manage projects of different was established in phase one; catalyzing (re)connect and enhance existing sizes, types, and complexities, as well as stronger market momentum.In integrating retail/entertainment landmarks, whilst assist in guiding clients through increasingly the BB&T Center with future development, providing greater diversity of activities and complex master planning processes. Along our approach is informed by our experience uses, most especially employment, housing, with Broward County, we will help to shape and research of sports-anchored mixed-use and mobility options. We envision promoting the community’s vision for the BB&T Center development best practices. At Bull Street, balanced, innovative, and economically Master Plan into a reality.Our team’s proven we planned a mixed-use stadium, named the viable development; connecting experience at delivering design excellence Ballpark of the Year in 2016 by Ballpark thoroughfares and providing Complete that inspires and engages people, Digest, with retail and office lining the first Streets; defining public space and civic incorporating creativity, originality, base street edge. The ballpark is centerpiece amenities; and incorporating elements of functionality and technology in mixed-use of the development, embracing the street commercial/cultural incubation. Moreover, master planning and design, coupled with with active use.The master plan should build the plan is most effective when prepared expertise for the site and the surrounding on existing infrastructure to create a flexible within a highly collaborative design process area, will ensure effective implementation of network for the ebb and flow of arena and in the presence of project stakeholders. Our your vision. Success is measured by the daily events in the short term, transitions with team’s experience tackling issues relevant to designs responsiveness to the clients needs, the potential demolition of the arena, and the BB&T Master Plan includes the building’s users, and its specific site. We will adapts to new transportation options. It is examples below:West Sunrise TOD work with you to identify realistic goals, critical to create a hierarchy of streets for Masterplan• Producing a fine-grained develop a focused action plan, anticipate placement of retail in existing and new urbanism which completes the synergies of implications of decisions made early and late development, but also service and drop-off suburban Sunrise and is adaptable to in the process, and prepare a mechanism for locations. In creating this hierarchy, the plan shifting markets • Optimizing a well- addressing unexpected challenges and will create a safe pedestrian environment, positioned site with transit potential:- A opportunities. We understand that the role of vibrant street life, and allow for the “back of mixed use hub for businesses, entertainment the design team is sometimes marked by house” functions to occur with minimal venues, and an innovation incubator, among complexity and conflicting requirements as infringement on public space.Broward others - Complementary uses to attract the project evolves and responds to County wants to partner with private investment whilst sustaining existing assets stakeholders’ needs. Our integrated project developers to execute the vision. Our and limiting “cross-competition” with current

PNC2116748P1 Page 4 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) approach creates an environment where our experience tells us that successful public- stakeholders• Fostering public-private entire team and our clients collaborate to private partnerships prioritize long-term collaboration Downtown Doral• Transforming bring great projects to reality.The current success for the entire community rather than a suburban office park into a complete working relationships of Kimley-Horn in maximizing short-term returns. Cooper Carry community with a wide range of residential Broward County and the City of Sunrise will approach this project understanding both options, employment, shopping, educational, bring the latest in local market costs, new public and private interests to develop an and civic usesBrickell City Center • Creating technologies, design execution, and potential actionable plan that inspires. among the most complex urban infills with users to this project. the broadest mix of uses in South Florida (by ARQ; designed to DPZ’s Miami21 code)

PNC2116748P1 Page 5 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) B. Describe the firm’s experience with phased See Supplemental Information Section 2, The Brooks + Scarpa team has extensive Please refer to the Supplemental Information Cooper Carry has completed more than 100 DPZ’s urban mixed-use projects are urban mixed-use projects, specifically addressing Project Approach experience working through phased section attached. mixed-use projects including transit-oriented renowned for accruing value with every how is construction done on future phases so developments, from the master planning developments, town centers and village successive development phase. In contrast that the impact to present residents, tenants and guests are minimalized. level, but also considering the details that cores, within more than 35 urban districts to conventional phasing by use/product, our POINTS VALUE 5 are necessary to ensure that the master plan that represent over 30 million square feet of plans are implemented in increments of is feasible in detailed design and built space that fully engage the community, mixed market segments – usually structured construction. We review the staged catalyze urban core redevelopment, and along streets or around squares/plazas – development and alternatives for different leverage public and private expertise. Our with multiple product types per phase, and phasing sequences with our civil engineering experience has given us great insight into with each phase as a complete urban design. We ensure that the phased the realities of a multi-phased development environment. Moreover, while conventional development is sufficient for each phase to approach. Most great places have developed practice depicts phase boundaries running meet the regulatory requirements as well as as the market dictates with master plans that down streets/by streetblock, DPZ’s phasing the client’s goals so that there are not issues provide the flexibility to evolve with a plans depict mid-block demarcations. when each portion of the development is changing market while maintaining the Combined, these phasing strategies:-• designed and constructed. Working with our overall project vision, public realm Mitigate driving across the construction site subconsultants, we provide for stub outs for framework, and aesthetic quality. Some of that otherwise would be required when utilities, phased stormwater management the essential goals for success in multi- product types are planned/built as conceptual calculations, and vehicular and phased development include:• The project segregated pods• Consolidate infrastructure pedestrian connectivity as the phased appears complete at each phase• Phase not and reduce initial construction costs• Reduce development is implemented. We have also dependent on future phases for success; the impacts to early residents of subsequent worked closely with the client, “there” is energized and established in the construction (e.g. construction vehicles stay subconsultants and contractors to ensure first phase.• Infrastructure (utilities, fire out of occupied phases)• Create a better that as each phase is developed, the department access, etc.) is envisioned and public realm at the outset, i.e. vertical previously occupied/utilized phases are not documented for future phases• Managing development on both sides of a street, or all impacted from a utility, traffic, or construction expectations for residents, tenants and edges fronting a plaza or square, are noise perspective.When designing our methodology for future phase construction to completed per phase and early occupants do mixed-use projects it is of the highest priority minimize impact on earlier phaseso Consider not end up facing later construction• Raise to develop design and engineering future construction laydown areas, location values – via establishing at the outset a approaches that minimizes complex and and view sheds of residential units, service pleasant, desirable community character – of possibly expensive or time-consuming access, and a phased parking construction later phases, especially for those which structural elements, in favor of a simplified, strategy.Three examples of successful otherwise would have less value (e.g. farther direct approach which results in more phased urban mixed-use Cooper Carry from the main access)• Sustain the livability flexibility at the building stage, fewer projects include Riverplace, Emory Point, of completed phases in the event of market problems, and ultimately lower costs and and Capitol View. disruptions DPZ also integrates phasing with complications related to impact on present planning: as far as possible each phase residents while phased construction activities captures the value of key development occur. The quality of a project is not features and amenities (e.g. DPZ’s Seaside necessarily related to how much it costs, but was planned with phases-by-street; as the rather how wisely the resources of time and plan had all major streets leading towards money are spent, especially during the sea, each phase captured value from construction phases. We firmly believe that both coastal access and sea views. For design excellence and addressing project BB&T, the master plan and phasing might

PNC2116748P1 Page 6 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) challenges can be achieved on any scale or optimize orientation of phases towards the budget; that economy and aesthetics are not proposed light rail station, a main civic mutually exclusive. Our strategy is to seek space, or the BB&T Center itself). Finally, simplicity, which results in flexibility in use with these phasing strategies, developers and economy in cost. We are constantly may test the market “in real-time”, provide aware of our responsibility to our clients, who authentic variety with each phase, and adjust rely on us to honor our commitments to the product mix in subsequent phases budget, schedule, and quality of work. without severely altering the master plan. Please see supplemental info.

PNC2116748P1 Page 7 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) C. Describe the firm’s approach and its familiarity See Supplemental Information Section 2, Sustainability, resiliency, and climate change Please refer to the Supplemental Information Sherwood Design Engineers is a recognized The BB&T development provides the in designing for sustainability, resiliency and Project Approach are at the forefront of our design thoughts section attached. leader in sustainable water resource opportunity to introduce, incorporate, and climate change issues that Broward County must and processes for all projects. The rapid engineering at institutions, mixed use enhance sustainability/resiliency/climate deal with. POINTS VALUE 1 changes that our area is experiencing in sea developments and corporate headquarters, change-responsive strategies within a level rise, groundwater table rise, more from planning through documentation. comprehensive approach to traditional intense and frequent storms, and other Sherwood’s experience covers all aspects of community design. DPZ’s projects are climate related changes make designing a site’s water cycle including site storm water sustainable via the incorporation of New sustainable and resilient development more management, potable water systems, non- Urban planning principles, which align with important now than ever. Our team has potable water systems, storage, and many of USGBC’s LEED-ND standards, the significant experience in stormwater treatment. With an underlying focus on national standard for sustainable master management system design to sustainability, Sherwood’s work considers planning, the development of which DPZ accommodate more intense storms than system efficiency, return on investment, was a main agent. These strategies include required by regulatory agencies, designing public health, education, and overall increased development densities; underground electric and communication environmental impact.Our water integrated redevelopment and infill; transit oriented facilities to protect them from hurricanes, and design process begins with the evaluation of development and walkable communities; the providing for low impact design and an existing site and associated buildings to integration of development with regional green/sustainable practices to better serve set a baseline. Site based strategies are open space frameworks; etc. Meanwhile, our environment. B+S is, and has been, a developed for storm water management in team member TSG has extensive knowledge firm on the forefront of sustainable design for an effort to restore natural drainage patterns, and experience in the application of the decades. We have successfully completed improve water quality, reduce O&M LEED and WELL Rating Systems, in aspects multiple LEED certified projects, and many requirements, and improve the local ecology. such as Water Efficiency, Energy and more that were designed to LEED standards. Building and utility based strategies are Atmosphere, Materials and Resources, Our Colorado Court project was the first developed to reduce demand, improve Indoor Environmental Quality, and LEED Gold multifamily residential building in efficiency, and incorporate reuse where Community. TSG has over 130 LEED the . Our approach is to utilize prudent. Additionally, Sherwood has certified projects and is currently working on passive sustainable strategies first, before extensive experience working in areas that over 200 projects that are all pursuing LEED introducing active sustainable systems. We are highly susceptible to coastal and inland or WELL Certification. In addition, DPZ co­ believe every sustainable design application flood risks associated with climate change. led the Seven50 SE Florida Prosperity Plan leads to the integration of healthier and Our project work in New York, Connecticut, (which included Broward County), putting higher quality natural system. B+ S is New Orleans and San Francisco has forth proposals for mitigating issues of sea developing adaptation solutions to the accounted for future proofing for storm level rise. Similarly, Lizz Plater-Zyberk was challenges of sea level rise and climate events that incorporate resilient design Chair for the Miami-Dade Climate Change change. Our firm principal, Jeff Huber, is strategies which integrate natural protection Advisory Task Force, examining climate also a faculty member in the Florida Atlantic and performative infrastructure. Through the change and resiliency issues anticipated to University School of Architecture where his design process, Sherwood will analyze be pertinent to Broward as well. In this design research is focused on sustainable, climate variables, overall site context, and context, Plater-Zyberk has been considering resilient and climate ready built existing infrastructure in order to develop an this area of Broward for more than twenty environments. Working with the City of Fort overall sustainable infrastructure approach. years, and among the foremost resiliency Lauderdale, he is pioneering more holistic Infrastructure systems that address long­ and climate change issues she deems to be approaches to delivering award winning term integration, high efficiency, low energy, at the forefront of discussion and mitigation environmentally responsive urban designs. and are cost-effective will be prioritized. In include:• Rising sea levels and rising local This year the firm won a national AIA our experience, utility systems must often be water tables • “Right-designing” development

PNC2116748P1 Page 8 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) Institute Honor Award for Regional and replaced, up-sized or relocated as and buildings from the start, to ensure Urban Design for its project Salty Urbanism: developments expand and are equally as longevity in face of climate change• Sea Level Rise Adaptation Strategies for vulnerable to climate change. Sherwood will Development impact upon the Everglades: Urban Areas for this work. B+S is also work with the design team to locate utility the Everglades are not getting enough water, completing a design and construction systems in a coordinated way with the and while it presently is unclear what impact manual for the City of Fort Lauderdale that existing and proposed development to the BB&T development will have, the a places sustainability, resiliency and livability maximize flexible adaptation so that the holistic planning procees as proposed may as the tenants of structuring future system can be phased over time. help raise such issues for more detailed developments. review

PNC2116748P1 Page 9 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) D. How has the firm addressed pedestrian See Supplemental Information Section 2, Brooks + Scarpa is well aware of the climatic CRTKL’s work in temperate climates Our team has been working in South Florida The DPZ team acknowledges the influence circulation in sub-tropical climates? Project Approach issues surrounding south Florida’s sub­ addresses these issues in a manner integral for over 40 years. Some members, like of the local climate upon the configuration of POINTS VALUE 1 tropical region. Given our location in a sub­ to the organization of the plan and the Kittelson, have offices in the area and know the master plan and embedded strategies for tropical climate, our team recognizes the associated architecture. Our projects in the firsthand the pedestrian (and bicycling) walkability. People will walk and spend their challenges that our weather provides. We Middle East, Central, and South America, experience in sub-tropical climates. time outdoors, even in extreme climates, have worked closely with project inform our responses to the climate of South Challenges pedestrians and cyclists when three criteria are met:• When there is a subconsultants to design pedestrian Florida in a manner that gives form to the experience in this climate include extreme meaningful destination• When the trajectory circulation routes with aesthetically pleasing urban character of the place. Projects heat and heavy rains. Pedestrians and is interesting (i.e. the streetscape is human- methods to creatively shade pedestrian specifically located in South Florida feature a cyclists in South Florida face other non- scaled and interesting: walking past shops, pathways and create oasis points for wide array of active and passive strategies to weather related challenges such as poor restaurants, attractive architecture and open pedestrians. We actively use native shade enhance the year-round use of outdoor connectivity, lack of infrastructure, and spaces, versus walking along blank walls trees, trellises, and other landscape and space. The Solar orientation of the site is a vehicle-oriented design.Our team addresses and parking lots) • When the walking hardscape elements to reduce heat island significant consideration in the organization these challenges in sub-tropical climates, environment is safe and comfortable (i.e. effect and provide shading for the walking of the masterplan and supports the definition such as Sunrise, with a context-sensitive defined/connected trajectories, shelter from and biking public. Our master plan of uses in the plan. Understanding the approach. We follow the “8 to 80” harsh elements, an even pavement, "eyes recommendations would design for paseos overlap between public space and purpose philosophy; meaning anyone from the ages on the street", etc.)The BB&T development and “walk streets” or “shared street” allows the introduction of architectural of 8 to 80 should have access to a safe and may comprise smaller, intimately scaled configurations that treat the street as garden elements to provide an environmental comfortable walking or cycling experience blocks and streets that incorporate a finer- while also enhancing and promoting physical response which aligns with the contextual whether a visitor, resident or employee of the grained and permeable pedestrian and open activity, shade and comfort. The design of language of design for the location. CRTKL’s area. For sub-tropical climates, we advise a space system, providing a rich and “landscape as infrastructure” would also most successful projects recognizes shading well-connected pedestrian system that is beautifully detailed series of public plazas have the added benefit of providing devices, canopies, colonnades and shaded well shaded with opportunities to seek cover and walkways, and allowing more frequent ecological stormwater management or more passages as form givers that become from rain, provide shade either from opportunities and instances for refuge from commonly known as Low Impact integral with the architecture and character structure or plantings, and provide respite for the elements. A more walkable urban Development. Firm principal, Jeff Huber has of a place. people and pets to drink water. Pedestrian environment also reduces vehicular use, and co-authored a design manual for Low Impact focused systems and places should provide therefore reduces ambient heat from cars Development entitled, LID:a design manual clear priority for pedestrians to move safely and from motor exhaust. Reduced car use for urban areas that can be seen at the in the presence of vehicles. Tactics may reduces parking demand, and thus reduces following link: http://www.bwdh2o.org/wp­ include table top intersections, flush plazas the number of heat sinks that paved parking content/uploads/2012/03/Low_Impact_Devel with bollards, or mid-block safe pedestrian lots inadvertently become. The more opment_Manual-2010.pdf Huber is street crossings. All our sub-tropical projects pedestrian-oriented streets may be designed considered an expert on this subject matter also assess drainage needs as flooding to be relatively narrower to provide more and lectures across the county. Prevailing impacts pedestrian access. The team shade. Streets and public spaces also might breeze and radiation modeling could be studies circulation systems from multiple be asymmetrical in section with taller deployed within the schematic design phase user perspectives to optimize connections elements/massing on the solar-facing side in as a proof-of-concept that any proposed between origins and destinations (whether order to provide shade spanning the space. solution would consider pedestrian from a parking garage, a transit station, or a The more intimately scaled blocks also circulation. We are working on several nearby neighborhood). These direct engender an urbanism of a special building projects and design research regarding connections focus on the shortest path type: courtyard structures that create both policy change, where AASHTO’s Green options with an easy-to-understand, well- public and private spaces that temper the Book, a design manual that governs all integrated wayfinding system and user heat and sunlight. We also envision street design and planning, calls trees FHO, movement patterns. Examples of our team’s employing urban design and architectural

PNC2116748P1 Page 10 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) Fixed and Hazardous Objects and local experience include the City of Fort elements that mitigate climatic extremes: sidewalks, “auto recovery lanes” it is no Lauderdale, the City of North Miami, and the heat-insulating walls; shading overhangs, surprise that any community faces City of Miami Beach. We have design well- balconies and arcades; etc. Finally, public challenges in encouraging pedestrian loved subtropical pedestrian environments spaces may incorporate cooling water activity. like Mizner Park in Boca Raton, Los Olas features and/or sheltering vegetation Boulevard in Fort Lauderdale, and the One providing a utilitarian/recreational function Daytona project adjacent to Daytona (i.e. shelter) along with “placemaking” and International Speedway. pedestrian appeal.

PNC2116748P1 Page 11 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) E. Describe the firm’s approach to design that See Supplemental Information Section 2, Our team will approach a design that Please refer to the Supplemental Information Cooper Carry and its team members are DPZ’s approach to health-/wellness-oriented helps create better health and wellness for its Project Approach ensures the health and wellness of section attached. committed to a sustainable future in every design includes the following:• Integrating residents, tenants and guests. residents. We will look at the project through community in which we work. At the heart of wellness-oriented design at all scales, from POINTS VALUE 1 five lenses, place + identity, healthy & active sustainability is the positive impact on health the community level to the individual lifestyles, multi-modality, living infrastructure and wellness for people of all walks of life. In building. Among the LEED-ND standards and flood adaptation. Engaging public 2010 we issued our Sustainable Action Plan (which DPZ co-prepared) are many spaces that are attractive and inviting, and to the AIA’s 2030 Commitment. Cooper promoting health and wellness at a pedestrian friendly will anchor a sense of Carry utilizes a “Project Sustainability community scale. At the other end of the place and identity. Design for multi-modality, Integrator” on our staff with each project. spectrum, TSG is well-versed in the WELL integrating automobiles, transit-ready This subject matter expert is responsible for Rating System for assessing a building’s streets, bicycle and pedestrian will be promoting and monitoring the sustainable, impact on human health/well-being (i.e. air, essential. B+S will develop urban systems health and wellness aspects of the projects. water, nourishment, light, fitness, comfort, for flexibility and adaptability to future Cooper Carry’s master plans also integrate and mind)• Promoting community health via climate, context, economically changing the expertise of Pattern r+d, which uses a diversity - specifically in the case of people, futures—design futuring. Traffic calming and variety of validated industry-standard tools to planning a community that a the young, the other artistic streetscapes, like festival and support the decision-making process relative old, the well-off, and the meager to form a shared-street types will be explored.We to building massing and orientation to complete, healthy society able to withstand approach our designs as though we are optimize future daylighting and energy the shocks of economic cycles, and which going to be the resident, shopper, performance.Our planning process prioritizes fosters richer social connections• Planning restaurant-goer, or sports fan. We provide walkability and vibrant public spaces. This for multimodal community-wide accessibility, areas for people to utilize for walking and approach contributes to health and wellness beginning with walkability; communities biking, fitness areas, and other walkable in the key ways:1. It creates more should promote walking as an element of paths to provide for physical health benefits opportunities for physical activity. This focus social equity (for children, for the elderly, and to their users. We also create liveable and on walkability in our planning encourages for others for whom driving is not possible), pleasant spaces for people to enjoy on their more activity from people living, working, and as well as one of health and of own to gather their thoughts or to gather with playing on the site. The strategic placement environmental responsibility• Providing an others and improve their mental health. of public spaces create opportunities for array of spaces for positive interaction Mixed-use developments are unique in the informal and programmed outdoor activities. (social connectivity) and physical activity, fact that this is intended to be a lifestyle 2. Vibrant public spaces provide green including the proper detailing of streetscape center, where people can live, work, and respites in an urban environment, helping features (e.g. sidewalk width, street trees) as play. The design needs to reflect that and decrease the impacts of heat-island effect. well as green spaces, civic and cultural invite people to love their spaces, inside and Imagine the 140-acre site transformed from facilities. Research in the relationship out. This is why we will emphasize an urban the asphalt parking lots to a lush, urban between public spaces and public health design solution that first and foremost street and block network. 3. These vibrant points to benefits achieved via focused, considers pedestrian users and climate- public spaces and streets are designed to vision-driven investment in the public realm. ready infrastructure. allow for programming that focuses on health Also, healthcare facilities/services apparently and wellness – like farmer’s market and are underprovided in this area of Broward; activities like yoga in the park.Sherwood DPZ has experience working with healthcare Design Engineers strives to implement systems and integrating their facilities within nature based solutions, where practical, to sustainable urbanism• Ensuring access to help restore natural drainage patterns, fresh, healthy food at the neighborhood improve water quality, create layered level; insofar as possible, open space should

PNC2116748P1 Page 12 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) protection remedies, reduce O&M be set aside for community agricultureDPZ's requirements, and improve the local ecology. built projects show that, given the choice, The creation of a nature based flood solution people enjoy living in our healthy, framework also aims to create new sustainable communities, because it is greenspace within developments that help to environmentally responsible to do so, as well promote ecology, integrate community as because they promote fulfillment and space, and promote education and well-being. awareness.

PNC2116748P1 Page 13 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) F. Describe your experience and provide specific See Supplemental Information Section 2, Our team, B+S, Kimley-Horn and Coastal Please refer to the Supplemental Information RCLCO will perform an analysis of the local DPZ is a 38-year old planning practice with examples of a variety of professional planning Project Approach Systems has provided full design and section attached. market and identify key case studies to the largest number of New Urbanism services related to the implementation of projects engineering development services for mixed- inform the project direction. They will projects, and the record for the most projects identified within an urban mixed-use Master Plan including Economic/Feasibility Planning, Cost use developments and master planning and evaluate both the development feasibility built. Virtually all of our urban mixed-use Analysis, Facilities Infrastructure Analysis and Kimley-Horn has relationships with and public benefits (fiscal and economic master plans include Economic/Feasibility Evaluations, Parking Analysis (including the contractors, which will allow them to provide impact) of the proposed development Planning, Cost Analysis, Facilities future of parking garages with the coming of accurate order of magnitude opinions of programs. For the Tropicana Field Master Infrastructure Analysis and Evaluations, automated vehicles), and Traffic Analysis. probable construction cost to Broward Plan, RCLCO examined the redevelopment Parking Analysis, and Traffic Analysis. Some POINTS VALUE 8 County as we develop the phased master approaches and market impacts of several notable project examples for each task plan. Our team has experience on cost notable stadium districts to recommend the above include:Economic/Feasibility analysis of alternative bid items and resilient scale, mix of uses, phasing, and target Planning: Downtown Doral Master Plan, FL; design parameters as well as facility consumer groups likely for St. Pete.Cooper Gulfstream Park Village Master Plan, FL; infrastructure analysis+evaluation. We have Carry’s built project experience gives us the Bonita Beach Road Land Use Study, FL; expertise in pedestrian and vehicular traffic ability to provide real time cost analysis. We Miami21 (zoning code update), FLCost design. Parking utilization is going to be a recently completed 14 miles of streetscape Analysis: West Sunrise TOD Masterplan, FL; major consideration now and in the future. design with cost estimates and analysis for DownCity Providence Master Plan, RI; Plan With the success of ride-sharing like Uber all design components for the City of Baton Rouge (downtown master plan), LA; and Lyft and the advent of autonomous Augusta, .Sherwood Design Ave Maria Law School Campus Master Plan, vehicles, we must plan our parking surface Engineers will evaluate existing FL; Windward Pointe (brownfield lots and parking structures for the present, infrastructure, storm water modeling, flood redevelopment), MI; Downtown West Palm but with considerations for how the future mapping, topography, natural resources, Beach Master Plan, FLFacilities generations will utilize them. We implement future development in the vicinity and Infrastructure Analysis/Evaluations: shared parking analyses to reduce the existing and proposed greenspace links. Downtown Kendall Master Plan, FL; required parking below the maximum Utility infrastructure capacity, watershed Miami21, FL; Downtown West Palm Beach combined code requirement, and will work improvement opportunities, existing wetland Master Plan, FL; East Baton Rouge Mid-City with the County and City to provide an conditions, and habitat effects of the new Predevelopment Planning Project, LA; agreeable parking plan for the future. development are also analyzed.Several of , GAParking Analysis: Bonita Parking structures must also be designed to Sherwood's projects in New York, New Beach Road Land Use Study, FL (including accommodate future Orleans, and San Francisco integrate storm an examination of the impacts of Automated repurposing—potentially able to be water re-use and other water related goals Vehicles on parking); Downtown Doral converted into retail or other usable space. into their projects.Autonomous vehicles, Master Plan, FL; Gulfstream Park Village Kimley-Horn is the pre-eminent traffic combined ride-hailing services, and ride- Master Plan, FL; Coconut Grove Streetscape engineer in the Broward County, with sharing are expected to impact the parking and Parking Study, FL; Downtown Kirkwood expertise on traffic analyses for large scale landscape over a period of several decades. Master Plan, MO; Miami Design District mixed use developments, such as this one, Walker has developed a series of Master Plan, FL; Legacy Town Center and reviewing how they interact with the recommendations including right-sizing Master Plan, TX; Liberty Harbor North current and future buildout of the parking capacity, and planning for Master Plan, NJ(Note: As stated in our surrounding areas. B+S has developed a autonomous parking, passenger loading response to Item 1 above, Uber is a special range of planning studies for the Boston zones, connectivity capability and IT needs, advisor to our team on the impacts of and MCCA Convention Center that included adaptive reuse design, and phase-out of interface between Autonomous Vehicles and mixed-use parking structures that could be older facilities.Kittelson’s staff are national the proposed development, including parking implemented over time. The MCCA’s leaders in the advancement of “livable requirements)Traffic Analysis: Bonita Beach

PNC2116748P1 Page 14 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) requirements include being able to convert transportation.” Livable Transportation Road Land Use Study, FL; Downtown Doral the structures to office space, housing or addresses traffic performance balanced Master Plan, FL; Perdido Key Master Plan, other uses at a future date. B+S is working against other desired qualities of a FL; Miami21, FL; Ignite High Point with DESMAN as prime on the Design transportation system such as the existing (downtown master plan), NC; Legacy Town Criteria Package with the City of Miami and future social, economic, and Center Master Plan, TXMany of the above Beach for 13 parking structures currently environmental impacts.Specific project are among the representative projects being planned and constructed over the next examples include Sawgrass Area Intermodal described under Section 3. Past 10 years. Each of these structures has a Station, Sunrise Area-Wide Transportation Performance; further details on these “convertibility” to affordable housing within Needs Assessment Study, and Fort projects are provided in the Supplemental the lifespan of the structure. Lauderdale TOD Grant. Information attachments.

PNC2116748P1 Page 15 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) 3. Past Performance: Max Number of Points 40 See Supplemental Information Section 3, Brooks + Scarpa has worked on numerous True mixed-use urban developments Our Planning & Urban Design studio serves As stated prior, DPZ has 38 years of master A. Describe the firm’s qualifications and relevant Past Performance phased urban mixed-use master plans. planned from scratch are rare today, but our as a great facilitator, laying the foundation of planning experience in Florida and across experience and provide specific examples of These plans have included mid-rise and firm has been involved in several new build cities and communities, while aligning the the country. Moreover, our team at large phased urban mixed-use master planning projects that includes at least three of the following mid- high-rise components with inclusion of and repositioning projects that thoughtfully stars of private voices and public entities.We pos¬sesses unparalleled experience rise to high-rise components: Four star or greater structured parking. B+S has completed a stitch together the best of what a community are realists and humanists, but above all designing, coding, and implementing hotels; Class “A” to Class “B+” office buildings; series of master plans that retrofit sprawl and has to offer to transform the urban orchestrators and educators, coordinating economically and socially vital urban multifamily residential buildings; and some retail showcase a phasing strategy over time. B+S environment for the better. Planning and the functional, communal and human centers, amassing a vast portfolio of best to support the residential and office tenants. has worked with several cities and counties urban design is at the heart of our practice: a aspects of habitable spaces to better serve, practices and successful innovations. Our Provide a minimum of five projects with references. Preference in scoring will be given that control development for a particular site. discipline that courses through our history connect, and nurture the lives of the people team espouses ecologically sensitive, yet projects of similar nature and scope and to those B+S has shown a range of approaches that and informs every project we do. We’re who live, work and play within them. We commercially viable design, creating urban that have been successfully completed. can help shape public policy, incentives, and dedicated to creating people-oriented, have worked with many clients in the public, environments of memorable and unique Suburban mixed-use project where buildings are expectations for developing mixed-use urban economically viable places that are not only private, and non-profit sectors in the imagery that make a statement about the surrounded by surface parking will not be developments in a community otherwise well-designed, but also support the needs of southeast and across the country to help place, its culture, environment, and identity, considered. Provide written and graphic descriptions along with any photographs of these dominated by suburban residential products. resilient, high-performance communities and drive innovative and market-based mixed- and that bring worldwide attention and projects. Usually rated from easy to ambitious, each cities. We plan for both strategic and organic use planning solutions. Our passion is recognition.In undertaking these planning POINTS VALUE 20 of the two urban design and planning growth, understanding that success cannot informed by the latest trends and best efforts, we have worked extensively with frameworks for the BB&T site will integrate be measured from day one alone but from practices; as we strive for solutions that various agencies and municipalities, new public and semi-private open space, five, ten, twenty years down the line. Please connect people to place. *Detailed project including, where required, in venues with a parking structures, streetscapes, and multi­ refer to the Supplemental Information section pages for the following included in the great degree of public engagement. In family housing in tandem with renovations or attached for relevant experience. One of our supplemental section1. Bull Street Master carrying public sector projects forward, we demolition of the BB&T Center. B+S has most prolific project examples is LA LIVE!, Plan – Columbia, SCThis plan is a 20-year intensively coordinate all stakeholders, prepared aster planning for developer teams opened in 2007 as a new urban sports and vision for over 3 million SF of development agencies, and levels of municipal that will be selected to carry out one of the entertainment district in the South Park area including a new mixed-use minor league government from work order through the proposals. Please see Supplementary of downtown . It is adjacent and baseball stadium and regional park.Bob approval processes – this is critical with the Information-mixed-use for images and connected to the Staples Center and Los Hughes, PresidentHughes Development864­ interrelated planning, design, transportation, further information. Angeles Convention Center and, as such, 233­ economic, and sociocultural issues typically was envisioned as a walkable urban center [email protected]. associated with municipal development. This connecting the old sports district to the heart Riverplace –Greenville, SCA multi-phased experience has cross-pollinated with our of downtown. Using carefully planned uses catalytic development is a serves as a great work on urban retrofits, providing an that included new hotel, office, residential, example of a public private partnership Bob understanding of the way successful public restaurants and retail, the new district’s Hughes, PresidentHughes Development864­ projects function, of the economic success has been quick and unequivocal 233­ relationship between satellite centers and with full buildout of the original master plan [email protected]. their downtowns, the lessons of success and and continued growth around the district, Buzzard Point – Washington, DCThis plan failure that both offer, as well as an including CallisonRTKL-designed includes 1.5 million SF of residential awareness of shifting market realities and Oceanwide Plaza, which construction topped development and 75,000 SF of retail how to accommodate them through design off in May 2018. Please refer to the adjacent to the D.C. United soccer team and regulatory innovation. Per the RFP, our Supplemental Information section attached stadium.Adam Gooch, Development team’s projects provided as Supplemental for relevant experience. ManagerAkridge Development202-624­ Information attachments hereto comprise [email protected]. Capitol View – those which include at least three of the Nashville, TNThis 32 acre mixed-use master following mid-rise to high-rise components: plan has largely been realized. Cooper Carry four-star or greater hotels; Class “A” to Class

PNC2116748P1 Page 16 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) provided urban design, design guidelines, “B+” office buildings; multifamily residential entitlement, and full architecture design buildings; and supporting retail. Please refer services. Jeff Haynes, Managing to the attachments for detailed project [email protected]. information, including written and graphic Savannah River Landing (Eastern Wharf) – descriptions accompanied by photographs Savannah, GAThis 56 acre site focuses on as appropriate; references also are provided extending Savannah’s public realm to the in the attachments. water with a dynamic mix of uses in this new waterfront district.Trent GermanoMariner Group, [email protected] .0052

PNC2116748P1 Page 17 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) B. Describe the firm’s experience in designing See Supplemental Information Section 3, Brooks + Scarpa has various experience in Successful full-service hotels like the Hilton Cooper Carry’s Hospitality Studio is in the Team member ARQ designs hotels that Four Star and higher rated mid-rise and high-rise Past Performance design of hotels. We have completed , Mandarin Oriental and business of designing buildings for leisure redefine the guest experience and provide hotels in urban settings with structured parking. renovations and the firm is currently working Intercontinental Changsha create places for and escape, which is the business of real unique market identity. Their exterior designs Provide a minimum of five projects with references. Preference will be given in scoring to on a boutique hotel in Chengdu, China. The meeting, business, recreation and relaxation estate and brand, experience and efficiency, tell a story about the place and establish those hotels that have been successfully Y4 Boutique Hotel is a small 24 room luxury that complement, and interact with, the service and food, finance and well-designed identity in this competitive field, while their completed. Provide written and graphic hotel. It features a world class wine bar and existing urban fabric. They are designed to spectacle; all at once. We have done this for interior designs create comfortable yet descriptions along with any photographs of these tasting room, a 5 star restaurant and bar, connect to the city with offerings that face over 125 four and five star hotels across the memorable spaces. ARQ designs hotels and projects. private meeting rooms and event spaces outward, not inward. This strategy effectively country and in Florida. Hospitality is resorts for real estate developers, leading POINTS VALUE 5 with courtyards and plazas. The hotel rooms activates the urban experience with more complex, but we meet the challenge with hotel operators, and other clients on a global range from 135SF to 200SF suites with eyes on the street while giving the hotel a decades of destinations built, stories told and basis. The firm is well versed in designing private courtyards and balconies with genuine, local feel through its connectivity memories made. How? By having the these projects to the specific design panoramic views of the surrounding area. and accessibility to the city. Structured experience to get the basics right for the standards, operating procedures, and Please see Supplementary Information-hotel parking integrated into the hotel function is a business of the hospitality industry first, and requirements for the world’s leading hotel for images and further information. necessity for most urban hotels, since land is the creativity and innovative spirit to allow chains and franchises.The firm has worked too valuable and too scarce to allow for the beauty in it to bloom.*Detailed project on hospitality projects involving numerous surface parking. That said, orchestrating the pages for the following included in the industry-leading hotel operators including: (5 guest arrival experience such that the feeling supplemental section1. Hilton Cleveland, Star) Mandarin Oriental, Ritz-Carlton, JW of anticipation and excitement is maintained OH: The tower’s unique sculptural form Marriott, St. Regis, Four Seasons, Shangri upon entering the property is key. Please creates an iconic image for Cleveland’s La, Conrad, W Hotels, Melia, Regent, refer to the Supplemental Information section skyline.Ellis KatzDirector, Project Fairmont and Crown; (4 Star) Swire EAST attached for relevant experience. Management Consultants, LLC404-895­ Hotels, Westin, Sheraton, Hilton, Hyatt [email protected]. The Main Regency, Grand Hyatt, Marriott, – Norfolk, VA: The Main is a development Intercontinental, Le Meridien, Novotel, with three restaurants, a civic atrium space, Wyndham, Radisson Blu, and Virgin.Trip The Hilton Norfolk at The Main hotel and Advisor recently proclaimed that ARQ has “The Exchange at The Main” conference designed two of the World’s Top 15 Hotels: center in Norfolk, VA. Bruce Thompson, the Mandarin Oriental Pudong in CEOGold Key PHR Hotels & Resorts757­ and the Luxury Collection Tambo del Inka in [email protected]. Potomac Urubamba, Peru. As an aside, ARQ Yards Renaissance, Crystal City, VA: This designed the architecture and interiors of the 625-room conference center and hotel Accor Hotels World Headquarters in Paris complex is situated at the northern end of and is the design architect for the Ritz- Potomac Yards, a 1.5-mile-long rail yard Carlton Hotel and Residence in Ft. redevelopment site in Arlington, VA.Andrew Lauderdale.ARQ is a worldwide design McIntyreExecutive VP East Coast practice for leading hospitality brands, and DevelopmentCombined provides an understanding of luxury hotel [email protected]­ standards and the evolution of customer 28314. Marriott Marquis – Washington, DC: expectations. Having completed hundreds of The largest hotel in Downtown Wash. D.C., 4- and 5-Star hotels across the world, it this hotel is over 1 million sf with 1,175 would be impossible to name them all here; guestrooms and suites to area visitors and this being said, the Supplemental convention guests. Robert KnopfSenior Vice Information attachments provided herewith

PNC2116748P1 Page 18 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) PresidentQuadrangle Development depict those project that best illustrate the [email protected] firm’s experience with urban, mid- and high- 45. Tryon 300 – Charlotte, NC: The Kimpton rise hotels with structured parking. Tryon Park Hotel is an 18-story, 217-key luxury boutique hotel located at the corner of Third and Church Streets in the heart Charlotte’s uptown neighborhood. Stu TurnerManaging Director, [email protected]­ 7200

PNC2116748P1 Page 19 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) C. Describe the firm’s experience in designing See Supplemental Information Section 3, Brooks +Scarpa has designed over Successful class “A” office is an essential Cooper Carry’s Office & Corporate studio are Many of team member ARQ’s projects over Class “A” and Class “B+” mid-rise and high-rise Past Performance 2,000,000SF of commercial office space. ingredient for all successful urban functionally focused, creatively driven the last 20 years have been predominantly office buildings in urban settings with structured B+S is currently working on a TOD project developments. Projects like 600 , 750 problem-solvers. The office is no longer just mixed-use projects that include hotels, parking. Provide a minimum of five projects with references. Preference will be given in scoring to located directly adjacent to the new Culver East Pratt Street, North Star Tower and the a building in which to park a desk—or an residential, or office mid- and high-rise those office buildings that have been successfully City Expo Robertson Station in Los Angeles. AEG office building at L.A. LIVE! are proof employee. It is a recruiting tool and an towers including those for corporate completed. Provide written and graphic This mixed-use development provides 144 that, with the right mix of street-level innovation device. Our long legacy which headquarters and office parks. ARQ designs descriptions along with any photographs of these residential units, 75,000 square feet of restaurant and retail, these developments includes over 50 Class A office buildings office environments that respond to the ever- projects. creative commercial space, 460 parking can become more than a daytime destination grounds us. Our focus on inquiry and changing needs of the workplace. Their POINTS VALUE 5 spaces and 40,000 square feet of retail while providing world-class amenities for analysis drives us. And our close exterior designs create imagery that convey space on the street level connecting directly office tenants. Designing a ceremonial ‘front collaboration with other Cooper Carry building purpose and market message while to the station. Please see Supplementary door’ for the building is effective in giving the studios helps us address the office’s place contributing to an improved public realm. Information-office for images and further project a distinct feel and sense of arrival on the cutting edge of convergence — where Their interior designs address contemporary information. and a fitting entry point into all that it has to hospitality, productivity, and everyday life issues of office systems, new technologies, offer. Case in point: 600 Brickell at Brickell come together.*Detailed project pages for adaptability, comfort, sustainability, and World Plaza opened in 2011 as the first the following included in the supplemental public perception.The firm’s bold modernism LEED Platinum office building in Florida. At section 1. Park Center Phase 1 – Dunwoody, and timeless designs have won numerous 560 feet tall, it offers more than 600,000 GAOne of State Farm’s three new design awards, and attract the most square feet of rentable space complemented employment hubs, this mixed-use campus prestigious office tenants, including: by restaurants, a 30,000-square-foot has direct transit access and a new public corporate headquarters like Paris’s 530,000 landscaped plaza, a private fitness center park.Larry WilsonKDC Real Estate SF European Headquarters and and structured parking integrated into a Development and 940,000 SF Bouygues Telecom single, 40-story tower. Please refer to the [email protected] Headquarters; Luxembourg’s 160,000 SF Supplemental Information section attached 1112. Duke Energy (formerly Progress Banque de Luxembourg Headquarters; for relevant experience. Energy) – St. Petersburg, FLThe 18-story, Lima’s 530,000 SF Banco de Credito mixed-use building includes several Headquarters; Shanghai’s 2,800,000 SF sustainable design features integrated into CITIC Pacifica Group Headquarters; Seoul’s the architecture, materials specification, 5,330,000 SF AIG International Finance MEP systems, and construction materials Center; Washington DC’s 150,000 SF and methods. Moses SalcidoPrincipal, Center for Innovative Technology (CIT); and Development and Investment, Foundry Sarasota’s 72,000 SF Herald-Tribune Commercialmoses.salcido@foundrycommer Headquarters for parent company The New cial.com407-540-77983. PNC Plaza – York Times, to multi-tenant office buildings RaleighThe 32 story tower mixed-use tower like Paris’ 860,000 SF Air Tour and 250,000 contains 15,000 SF of street level retail, SF Exaltis Tower; Columbus’ 260,000 SF 280,000 SF of office space on eleven floors, Miranova; Miami’s 230,000 SF Harbour 139 condominium units on eleven floors and Centre and 340,000 SF FORUM; Hong 8 levels of parking.Randy RobersonVice Kong’s 2,500,000 SF Cyberport Technology President of Development, Highwoods Campus and 1,200,000 SF Landmark East [email protected] Towers; ’s 170,000 SF Swire 19-872-49244. 725 Ponce – , GAThis TKH; Jakarta’s 560,000 SF Menara Karya; 12 story office tower sits over a new Kroger 645,000 SF Menara Satrio; Chengdu’s and is located on the Atlanta Beltline 5,220,000 SF International Finance Center;

PNC2116748P1 Page 20 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) adjacent to . James 2,060,000 SF Wharf Dong Dai Jie; IrwinPresident, New City Singapore’s 130,000 SF Hong Kong Bank; DevelopmentJim@newcity­ Prague’s 240,000 SF Luxembourg Plaza; properties.com404-835-82285. 900/800 and São Paulo’s 3,820,000 SF Torre São Glebe – Arlington, VAAdjacent to the new Paulo.The Supplemental Information mixed-use building at 950 N. Glebe Road, attachments provided herewith include Cooper Carry designed two prominent Class project examples that best illustrate the A office buildings and structured parking. firm’s experience with urban, mid- and high- James ReedVice President, rise office towers with structured parking. [email protected] 40-333-3600

PNC2116748P1 Page 21 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) D. Describe the firm’s experience in designing See Supplemental Information Section 3, Brooks + Scarpa has completed over 10,000 People are moving back to the city: not just From high-rise condominiums to mid-rise DPZ has extensive experience in designing mid-rise and high-rise multifamily residential Past Performance units of housing of every type that have recent grads and the oft-talked about apartment buildings, lofts and townhouses, urban mid-rise and high-rise multifamily buildings in urban settings with structured included structured parking. In particular we millennial generation, but all ages—even our mixed-use mindset and mastery creates residential buildings with structured parking parking. Provide a minimum of five projects with references. Preference will be given in scoring to have completed or have worked on dozens seniors who have come to appreciate the places that attract, retain, and make and workforce housing units. Indeed, one of those multifamily residential buildings that have of publicly funded affordable housing convenience and connectivity that comes business sense for our clients. We monitor our growing missions is the design of been successfully completed as well as those projects for such organizations as The Skid with being a city dweller. Please refer to the the evolution of consumer preferences to multifamily housing that, while being high multifamily residential buildings that have Row Housing Trust, Community Corporation, Supplemental Information section attached make sure our clients receive practical, density, is also dignified and engenders a included a work force housing component. Venice Community Housing, West for relevant experience. affordable, marketable designs to meet the human-oriented urbanism. Moreover, in all Provide written and graphic descriptions along with any photographs of these projects. Hollywood Community Housing, Coacella needs of today’s potential residents. With our high density housing master plans, POINTS VALUE 5 Valley Housing Coalition, Step Up, Forrest over 100 residential mid to high rise projects, community amenities (e.g. a pool, gym, City/Rattner, The Related Companies, and Cooper Carry understands how people live resident services, etc.) are provided at The Athens Group. We are currently working in vibrant mixed-use environments.*Detailed central locations within each plan, while with the South Florida Community Land project pages for the following included in green space is preserved and organized into Trust and Delray Beach Community the supplemental section1. AMLI Arts Center communal parks and recreation areas. The Redevelopment Agency on workforce and – Atlanta, GAAMLI Arts Center’s high-rise housing types themselves achieve a high affordable housing. We have learned how to apartments are ideally level of efficiency and are able to respond to deliver design excellence within restrictive situated walking distance to MARTA transit a variety of market conditions. Some budgets and are accustomed to working and are LEED® Gold Certified. Fred pertinent projects include our plans for within rigid time frames that allow very little SchreiberSenior Vice President, Downtown Doral FL, Liberty Harbor North room for error. We also understand how to DevelopmentAMLI NJ, and Legacy Town Center TX.Similarly, design for HUD financed projects, Federal [email protected]­ team member ARQ is a global leader in Fair Housing standards, TCAC projects and 33212. 60 Market Street – Asheville, NCThe high- and mid-rise multifamily residential how to meet all these standards on multi- residential building in this mixed-use design. Such ARQ projects become skyline funded affordable housing. Please see development is comprised of nine floors and landmarks and define the address of their Supplementary Information-multifamily seventy-five units with two separate residents, with units catering to housing for images and further information. penthouse wings, 9 ground level townhomes contemporary lifestyles and offering and retail. Jim PrivetteOwner, Halliday improved private living spaces as well as [email protected]­ shared public functions. ARQ designs with 03093. 905 Juniper – Atlanta, GA905 functional ingenuity, and creates Juniper is an eight-story, terraced mixed-use architectural personality contributing to each development with 117 luxury condominium city’s character and skyline. To date the firm units, including two-level townhouse units has designed and built more than 80 million and live/work spaces that offer street-level sqf of residential low-, mid-, and high-rise access adjacent to 2,200 square feet of residential buildings.In South Florida among prime corner retail space. Jason FrostVice ARQ’s projects are the Atlantis on Brickell, President, Development, Cousins Icon Brickell, SLS Lux, Hyde Midtown, the [email protected] Paraiso Bay towers, Brickell City Centre, 404-407-10004. Aramore and Astoria – Oceana Bal Harbour, Fendi Chateau, and Atlanta, GAThis multi-phased development the Ritz-Carlton Residences Sunny Isles. has 7 stories, 88 condominium units, 140 Moreover, ARQ has experience designing apartments, 50,000 square feet of retail, a office and residential projects with extensive 342-space parking deck, and an outdoor user amenities, micro units, co-working

PNC2116748P1 Page 22 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) plaza.Jack WilliamsBusiness Director, Kairos spaces, outdoor entertainment areas, bike- Development friendly facilities, ridesharing drop-offs, [email protected] reduced parking requirements, and m404-350-14855. AMLI at City PlaceLocated others.The Supplemental Information on 2.47 acres, consists of 240 residential attachments provided herewith include units and 459 parking spaces in a separate project examples that best illustrate the precast concrete structure.Fred team’s experience with urban, mid- and high- SchreiberSenior Vice President, rise residential towers with structured DevelopmentAMLI parking. [email protected]­ 3321

PNC2116748P1 Page 23 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) E. Describe the firm’s experience in designing See Supplemental Information Section 3, Brooks + Scarpa has worked on numerous The majority of CallisonRTKL-designed Cooper Carry knows retail architecture is DPZ espouses mixing and mingling uses in retail space in the ground floors of residential and Past Performance retail spaces in the ground floor of mixed-use residential, hospitality and office projects bigger than the box and must interplay with our master plans, bringing into close office buildings. Priority will be given in scoring projects. Over its 30 year history B+S has involve retail and restaurant uses at street surrounding uses. More than transactional, proximity the full range of elements that in to those retail spaces that have been successfully completed. Provide written and graphic completed over 200,000SF of retail space. level. From the firm’s beginnings in we see our work as cultural, community- concert make a town – residences, offices, descriptions along with any photographs of these Please see Supplementary Information-retail Annapolis, MD in 1945, we’ve maintained a minded, civic and deeply personal, as we public facilities, and retail – often in the same projects. space for images and further information. strong focus on master planning that has design places that more than ever have building. In our projects, the retail center is POINTS VALUE 5 allowed us to develop a prominent portfolio become an experiential thread in our conceived as a downtown, usually in the of commercial projects, the success of which everyday lives. From re-thinking and re- form the village/town center or a high street, is based on synergy between components energizing the monolithic malls and strips of with retail and commercial uses on the and a tailored, balanced mix of uses. the past, to designing the street-level ground floor and other uses above. This Projects like The Domain, Pinecrest and spectacle of new mixed use and main street arrangement creates community vibrancy, Liberty Center are proof that developments developments, we view retail architecture as an active and pedestrian-friendly public that interweave residential, hotel and office the glue that connects us as consumers and realm, and a strong sense of place. Among space with retail, restaurants, parks, plazas as individuals with experiences and energy, our various plans/projects which include and other amenities are more sustainable in movement and magic, in new, ever-changing retail space in the ground floors of residential terms of providing community benefit, as well ways.*Detailed project pages for the and office buildings are: Miami21, FL; Miami as economically viable in the long-term. following included in the supplemental Design District, FL; Naples 5th Ave South, Please refer to the Supplemental Information section1. Mercato – Naples, FLNational and FL; Downtown West Palm Beach, FL; section attached for relevant experience. local retailers line a pedestrian friendly Downtown Kendall, FL; Gulfstream Park shopping artery anchored by a national Village, FL; Bonita Beach Road Land Use bookseller and Whole Foods Market at one Study, FL; Mashpee Commons, MA; Atlantic end, and a second level luxury theater at the Station, GA; Liberty Harbor North, NJ; other end.Dougall McCorklePremier Seaside, FL; Rosemary Beach, FLSimilarly, Commercial, ARQ designs street level retail in many of its [email protected]. mixed-use office, hotel, and residential Emory Point – Atlanta, GAEmory Point’s first towers; moreover, the firm has experience in two phases encompass a total of 122,000 the full spectrum of retail, shopping, square feet of shops and restaurants and entertainment, and lifestyle environments. 750 residential units. Jason FrostVice ARQ creates retail architecture that defines President, Development, Cousins the destination and enhances the shopping [email protected] experience; its exteriors establish identity 404-407-10003. Bethesda Row - Bethesda, and deliver the message of shopping MDCooper Carry master planned the entire excellence, while its interiors provide development, then transitioned into memorable spaces, clarity of circulation, construction and built five buildings on six simplified orientation, visual stimulation, urban blocks. John TschidererVice President column-free unobstructed view-lines, and – DevelopmentFederal Realty Investment maximum exposure of the merchandise and Trust 301-998­ retail frontages. The firm seeks new retail [email protected]. E. 4th solutions that respond to the times – Street – Cleveland, OHA mix of national and stemming from a full understanding of local retailers comprise this catalytic project, historical retail design principles and global which include the new House of Blues, trends – resulting in the design of more than

PNC2116748P1 Page 24 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) development guidelines and pedestrian 65 million square feet of retail projects streetscape, all designed by Cooper around the world.The Supplemental Carry.Ari MaronPartner, MRN Information attachments provided herewith [email protected]. Hill include project examples that best illustrate Center Brentwood – Brentwood, TNThis the team’s experience with urban, ground- mixed use, multi-phase community includes floor retail in residential and office buildings. a village square, 150,000 SF of retail, 450,000 SF of office space, and two parking structures. Bo AdamsH.G. Hill Realty [email protected]­ 8100

PNC2116748P1 Page 25 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) 4. Lead Architect's/Planner’s Portfolio & Profile: See Supplemental Information Section 4, Please see supplemental attachment Please refer to the Supplemental Information The follow four issues for the BB&T Center DPZ shall be the Lead Planner for this effort. Max Number of Points 25 Lead Architect's/ Planner's Portfolio and regarding item 4a. section attached. Property master plan seem critical to the We are the recognized leader in Traditional If the Lead Architect/Planner is an individual, then Profile success of the project. We have assembled Neighborhood Development (TND) design the portfolio must include at least three urban mixed-use site planning projects done by the lead the right team for Broward County based on and our many built examples of authentic designer over the past ten years (each project the below understanding of this project.1. TNDs have been used as models throughout should identify his or her specific role) and at Identifying a dynamic market driven balance the industry to effect change in planning, least five completed urban mixed-use planning of mixed-use development and quality public regulatory, development, marketing, and projects done by his or her firm over the past ten space that functions efficiently and financing practices. Since its founding, years. Each example must include the images and text description. The portfolio must also establishes a “there” from the first phase 2. DPZ’s growing body of award-winning work include a designer profile noting such facts as Creative integration and/or replacement of has exerted a major influence on the making education, professional experience, design the BB&T Center facility within the overall of walkable urbanism, complete recognitions, and areas of responsibility and a community vision 3. Implementing forward neighborhoods, and resilient communities in statement of the lead designer’s philosophy and thinking strategies in transportation and the United States and around the world. DPZ design intent that incorporates an understanding of the design issues for the proposed project and parking; water management and resilience; is distinguished from other firms by its a philosophy for approaching the project. and both environmental and economic volume of built and implemented work and If the Lead Architect/Planner is a team, then the sustainability 4. Leverage public investment the lessons learned from these projects; portfolio must include at least two completed to entice the right private investmentThe lead ongoing pursuit of innovative solutions; projects per discipline done over the past ten designer from each of our team’s collective public process, including the DPZ Charrette years by each of the lead designers on the team and representing the firm, a selection of at least firms represent a dynamic amount of and rapid prototyping; business efficiency, as five additional completed projects done over the experience, perspective, and expertise. a small firm that collaborates with others; past ten years. Each example must include Included in our "Supplemental Information ­ and Partners' renown in the field. As a images and text description. The portfolio must Lead Architect's / Planner's Portfolio and progressive, cutting-edge think tank, DPZ also include a lead designer profile that Profile - Evaluation Criteria 4" uploaded file constantly cultivates the latest planning and summarizes the background of all team members and a design philosophy and design intent are brief profiles and specific project urban design initiatives for sustainable statement that represents the perspective of the portfolios for each lead individual from the urbanism; among those pertinent to the team as a whole. collection of firms on the Cooper Carry team BB&T development are: Smart Growth and A. Lead Architect’s/Planner's Portfolio - The and some direct relevant project experience form-based design and coding (for mixed portfolio should be thoughtfully arranged and they bring to the BB&T Center Property use development and placemaking); Sprawl composed of materials that demonstrate an understanding of the design issues to be Master Plan.Team Design Leads Repair (retrofitting suburbia); Lifelong addressed in this project. The exhibits should include:Lead Planner - Kyle Reis - Cooper Communities (multigenerational/multisectoral portray creative and appropriate response to Carry Lead Transportation - Jessica communities); Green By Design strategies County’s criteria and needs, demonstrate design Josselyn - Kittelson & AssociatesLead and Light Imprint development (tactics for leadership, and clearly exemplify design Market - Adam Ducker - RCLCOLead sustainable development rooted in a holistic excellence. POINTS VALUE 15 Infrastructure - Tom Jost - Sherwood Design body of vernacular practice); and many EngineersLead Parking - John Dorsett ­ others.Per the RFP, our portfolio – provided Walker ConsultantsFive additional projects as a Supplemental Information attachment – highlight our team's combined expertise in describes several successful DPZ projects projects which demonstrate our that offer creative planning and development understanding of the BB&T Center Property solutions pertinent to the County’s criteria Master Plan. and needs, that demonstrate DPZ’s leadership, and that clearly exemplify design excellence. The portfolio also includes team

PNC2116748P1 Page 26 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) member profiles, as well as describes our design philosophy and design intent statement in more detail.

PNC2116748P1 Page 27 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) B. Lead Architect's/Planner's Profile - The County See Supplemental Information Section 4, Please see supplemental attachment Please refer to the Supplemental Information Philosophy COOPER CARRY believes that As noted above, per the RFP, our attached will be looking for a breadth and depth of Lead Architect's/ Planner's Portfolio and regarding item 4b. section attached. well-designed places have the power to portfolio includes team member profiles education and work experience as well as Profile positively affect people’s lives. Through our describing each key team member’s increasing responsibility for delivering the complexity and magnitude of the project the work, we seek to create happier, more breadth/depth of education and work County has in mind. productive humans everywhere through experience pertinent to delivering the POINTS VALUE 10 design excellence. The Center for complexity and magnitude of the BB&T Connective Architecture® articulates our project. Specifically, the Lead Planner’s belief that connectivity is the centerpiece of (DPZ’s) Managing Partner Galina Tachieva our architectural, planning and urban design shall serve as Partner-in-Charge for this approach. Our process combines multiple effort. With nearly 25 years of expertise in disciplines in a rich composition of functional, sustainable planning, urban redevelopment, thoroughly connected spaces designed to sprawl repair, and form-based codes, Galina unite the experience of indoors and out.We directs the design and implementation work are a mixed-used firm with a firm-wide focus of the firm in the US and around the world. on the convergence of building types for the She is the author of the Sprawl Repair benefit of societies, communities, and Manual, an award-winning publication by individuals. Our studio leaders wear the Island Press, which focuses on the retrofit of mixed-use hat as advocates and expert auto-centric suburban places into complete, negotiators for their specialties – be it vibrant communities. Moreover, she is an hospitality, multi-family, retail, or beyond – inaugural Fellow of the Congress for the empowered by a legacy of deep industry New Urbanism, and leads its Sprawl Retrofit expertise to make decisions that prioritize Initiative. Galina also is a founding member place-making, civic space, and the greater of the Congress for European Urbanism, is a good of communities, tenants, residents and board member of the New Urban Guild visitors in places where buildings designed Foundation, and is certified by the American for specific uses must relate and react to Institute of Certified Planners (AICP) and by those around them to create a cohesive, the US Green Building Council as a LEED- sustainable, experience-filled whole.Design Accredited Professional. Successful projects StatementOur experience at the Center for completed under her leadership include Connective Architecture® brings together many downtown master plans, town and ideas from across the country, combined village centers, suburban retrofits, and urban with Cooper Carry’s 58-year background in infill efforts. Further details are provided in development design— our senses are the Supplemental Information attachments. attuned to the real world. We understand development’s fiscal demands of efficiency and “return on investment” while seeing the need for a vision that is inspiring, thoughtful and attainable. We envision an urban revitalization that balances the needs of public and private stakeholders so that vision can meet reality. The Center for Connective Architecture®, is unique in three important

PNC2116748P1 Page 28 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) ways:1. A proven consensus building process2. Creative visions with resourceful problem solving3. Expertise in implementationThe resumes of key leaders and key staff from our team are included in the Supplemental Information – Ability of Professional Personnel - Evaluation Criteria 1” pdf uploaded to Bidsync.

5. Location: Max Number of Points 5 See Supplemental Information Section 5, See form. Please refer to CallisonRTKL's Business Cooper Carry's principle place of business Prime Vendor DPZ's completed Business Refer to Vendor’s Business Location Attestation Location. The form was also submitted as Location Attestation Form. location is in Atlanta, Georgia. We are a Location Attestation Form is submitted with Form and submit as instructed. instructed in the RFP. short plane ride to Broward County and are this response as an attachment per the A Vendor with a principal place of business location (also known as the nerve center) within very familiar working in South Florida. Our instructions in the RFP. Broward County for the last six months, prior to team includes the Fort Lauderdale office of the solicitation submittal, will receive five points; Kittleson and the Tampa office of Walker a Vendor not meeting all of the local business Consultants. Jeff Weidner, from Fort requirements will receive zero points. The Lauderdale based Marlin Engineering will following applies for a Vendor responding as a Joint Venture (JV): if a member of the JV has 51% also act as a transportation advisor on our or more of the equity and meets all of the local team. business requirements, the JV will receive three points; if a member of the JV has 30 to 50% of the equity and meets all of the local business requirements, the JV will receive two points; and if a member of the JV has 10% to 29% of the equity and meets all of the local business requirements, the JV will receive one point. POINTS VALUE 5

PNC2116748P1 Page 29 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name AECOM Technical Services Brooks + Scarpa Architects, Inc. CallisonRTKL Inc. Cooper Carry, Inc. DPZ Partners, LLC (dba DPZ CoDESIGN, DPZ) 6. Willingness to Meet Time and Budget AECOM will meet the six month time YES Yes, CallisonRTKL Inc. is willing to meet the The Cooper Carry team is willing to meet the Yes, the DPZ team is willing to meet the Requirements: frame.AECOM will meet the $350,000 time and budget requirements for the project. six (6) month completion date requirement Project Time and Budgetary Requirements Completion Date Requirement: Six (6) Months budget requirement and is able to meet the $350,000 project as set in the RFQ by the County.In preparing YES = 1 Point NO = 0 Points Project Budget: $350,000 budget based on our understanding of the our fee proposal, we have assumed that the YES = 1 Point NO = 0 Points scope of work outlined in the RFP. County is able to provide and/or shoulder the Points Value: 2 costs of the following:· a suitable Charrette studio space, with the required Charrette furniture and equipment· a suitable presentation venue with the required A/V set-up (if different from the Charrette studio space)· all media and public relations outreach (i.e. flyers, newsletters/handouts, media spots, etc.)Additional deliverables that are one-time products, such as a physical scale model, or finite services, such as the production of a project video/brochure, are outwith our proposed scope. 7. Volume of Previous Work: See Supplemental Information Section 7, $0 Please refer to CallisonRTKL's Volume of Cooper Carry has been paid zero dollars Prime Vendor DPZ's completed Volume of Refer to Volume of Previous Work Attestation Volume of Previous work. The form was also Previous Work Attestation Form. ($0) over the past five years by Broward Previous Work Attestation Form and Volume Form and the Volume of Previous Work submitted as instructed in the RFP. County. of Previous Work Attestation Joint Venture Attestation Joint Venture Form and submit as instructed. Form are submitted with this response as The calculation for Volume of Previous Work is all attachments per the instructions in the RFP. amounts paid to the prime Vendor by Broward County Board of County Commissioners at the time of the solicitation opening date within a five- year timeframe. The calculation of Volume of Previous Work for a prime Vendor previously awarded a contract as a member of a Joint Venture firm is based on the actual equity ownership of the Joint Venture firm. Three points will be allocated to Vendors paid $0 - $3,000,000); 2 Points will be allocated to Vendors paid $3,000,001 - $7,500,000; 1 Point will be allocated to Vendors paid $7,500,001 - $10,000,000; 0 Points will be allocated to Vendors paid over $10,000,000). Payments for prime Vendor will be verified by the Purchasing Division. Points Value: 3

PNC2116748P1 Page 30 Vendor Evaluation Criteria Response Matrix

RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. Vendor Address 1512 E. Broward Boulevard, Suite 222 Broadway 19th Fl. New York, 2800 Ponce De Leon Blvd. Coral 2333 Ponce de Leon Blvd #1000, 3565 Piedmont Road, Building One, 1300 Spring Street, Suite 400Silver 110, Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 New York, 10038 Gables, FL 33134 Coral Gables, FL 33134 Suite 303Atlanta, Georgia 30305 Spring, MD 20910 Evaluation Criteria Vendor Response

PNC2116748P1 Page 1 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. 1. Ability of Professional Personnel (Other EDSA: Prime Consultant, Master Our team is specifically selected for See attachment: Supplemental SB Architects - A mid-sized firm by Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, The Torti Gallas + Partners Team Than Lead Architect/Planner): Max Planning and Landscape the BB&T Center Master Plan based Information_Professional design, we combine the world-wide Stewart & Associates, Inc. (SRSS) is brings the full spectrum of proven Number of Points 5 ArchitectureRobert Dugan | Projects: on key persons’ superb qualifications Personnel_Evaluation Criteria 1 knowledge, technical expertise and an established design firm providing expertise ranging from Conceptual Include resumes for the Project Manager, Lead Architect/Planner and all key staff Bahia Mar Beach Resort, BB&T and noteworthy relevant experience. resources of a large firm with the innovative professional services Thinking to Implementation, from described. Include the qualifications and Center, FAU Stadium, Pier 66 Resort, Other than the lead Architect/Planner, individual design approach and master planning, architecture, interior Mixed-use to Mixed-income, from relevant experience of all subconsultants’ Fort Lauderdale Riverwalk, W South key members of the team are Project hands-on attention of a smaller, design, landscape architecture and Placemaking to Flexible Frameworks, key staff to be assigned to this project. Beach Douglas Smith | Projects: Manager, Principal Urban Designer, boutique practice. Each project in the experiential graphic design. The firm’s and from thinking about today’s issues POINTS VALUE 5 Metropica, Bluewaters Island, Principal Architect, Transportation, office is directed by a principal-in­ professionals have designed 275 while anticipating tomorrow’s. The Campeche Waterfront, Deerfield Civil, Environmental Engineers, charge, who is responsible for the master planning projects.Mike proposed project team members have Beach Redevelopment, Village at Development and Implementation conceiving the overall vision, and Murphy, AIA LEED AP BD+C, the significant, and both national and MarbellaPerkins Eastman: Master Advisors, and Community directing the ongoing design efforts in Project Manager, is a Principal of the international, award-winning Planning Architecture Peter Cavaluzzi Communications Facilitator. Kate order to ensure that the project firm and has 37 years of experience in experience with all of the aspects of | Projects: CanalSide Buffalo, Dunham, who will serve as Project remains true to the original vision and the project management, master this effort. Firm Overviews for Torti CityCenter Las Vegas, Denver Civic Manager, has more than 18 years of intent. The project manager, a planning and design of similar Gallas + Partners and team member Center Square, Fordham Landing, experience in urban planning and seasoned professional with decades projects. He has been responsible for Kimley-Horn are included with this Penn Station District Hiliary Bertsch | design. She started her career as an of experience, oversees the technical mixed-use, hotels, multifamily, offices, submission in a PDF file with the Projects: Washington DC Wharf, urban designer at the aspects of the design drawings, and retail and parking deck projects. Mike name Supplemental Information_Firm Mayo Clinic Destination Medical Department of City Planning and ultimate delivery of those documents is registered in Florida. He will be your Overviews_Evaluation Criteria Center, Crystal City Redevelopment, spent 9 years working on important to the client, and local architect-of­ day-to-day contact.Charles (Chuck) 1.Resumes of key personnel are San Pedro WaterfrontShawn Basler | community planning projects such as record, if applicable. Project teams are Hull, AIA, the Lead Architect/Planner, included with this submission as PDFs Projects: Park Hyatt Saadiyat Beach, Long Island City re-zoning and carefully assembled so that each is a Principal of the firm and has 37 with the file name Supplemental Hoxton Hotel, Al Fateh New Cairo, Queens Plaza Master Plan. From individual adds value through his or years of experience in master Information_Key Personnel Anantara Hotel & Residences, St. 2006 to 2013, she was the a senior her directly applicable knowledge and planning, and design of similar Resumes_Evaluation Criteria 1. Regis Hotel & ResidencesKimley- urban designer at SOM Shanghai and experience with a particular project projects. His projects have included Horn: Civil and Traffic Engineering then principal urban designer for Arup type, site location or regional area. mixed-use, hotels, multifamily, offices, Christopher Heggen | Projects: BB&T Shanghai office leading major retail and parking components and Center, Sawgrass Mills Mall, planning projects that ranged from a several have received design awards. Metropica, Dania Pointe, PGA Place, few blocks to entire urban districts. Chuck is registered in Florida. He will Pompano Pier Redevelopment Mark Kate is a hands-on project manager lead the design phase and incorporate Santos | Projects: Sawgrass Mills that engages the whole team in the programmatic requirements into Mall, Fort Lauderdale Parking Study, collaborative and productive work to the master plan. Kimley-Horn, a civil Gables Station Mixed-Use, Orlando reach its greatest potential. Randy and traffic engineering firm which we Outlets, Galleria Mall Atelier Ten: Morton will serve as Principal Urban have worked on over 40 projects, will Environmental Design & Designer. Randy was a Principal with complete our team. Located in EngineeringBenjamin Shepherd | HKS until March of 2018 and led the Broward County, they have worked for Projects: Assembly Square, Cleveland Broward County Convention Center both pubic and private sectors clients Waterfront, Lexington Entertainment Expansion and Hotel Development in the county. These projects have District, MITIMCo Kendall Square, Master Plan. Randy and Jonie Fu, included mixed-use, commercial, Newark International Airport Michael Principal-in-Charge, have been residential, and institutional projects, Esposito | Projects: Reedy River collaborators for more than 25 years parks, signals, intersection Redevelopment, Comcast Innovation leading design and planning of improvements, school flashers, transit, and Technology Center, Franklin complex and challenging urban bridges, parking, structures, and

PNC2116748P1 Page 2 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. County Justice Center, MIT Net Zero mixed-use projects nationwide forensics services. Broward County StudyNelson Nygaard: Mobility including Hudson Yards in New York staff has expressed extreme Transit, AccessibilityChristopher City, Tampa Bay Devil Rays satisfaction with the quality of their Forinash | Projects: Institute for Redevelopment in St. Petersburg, and work, ability to meet accelerated Sustainable Communities – US Urban Museum Park in Miami, all schedules, ability to coordinate with Program, US Environmental transformative and economically local municipalities, FDOT, and utility Protection Agency – Sustainable beneficial in their respective cities. owners. Jason Webber, PE, the Civil CommunitiesMachete Group: Jason Webber of Kimley-Horn will Engineering Project Manager, has 12 Strategic OperationsDavid Carlock | lead transportation planning and years of experience with relevant Projects: Barclays Center, Carson Darren Badore of Thompson & projects and is registered in Florida. Stadium, Chargers Stadium, Wrigley Associates will lead civil and Christopher Heggen, PE, the Field, Orlando Magic Arena, Sam environmental engineering. Many Transportation Planning/Traffic Houston Race Park Lambert Advisory: members of the team have worked Engineer, has 20 years of experience Real Estate & Economic AdvisoryPaul together previously. We can jump- in similar projects and is a registered Lambert | Projects: Samsung Corp., start the planning process from day Civil Engineer in Florida. Queen Emma Foundation, University one. Key staff resumes, including of Pennsylvania, Harvard University, details of their qualifications and Ports of Miami, New York, New relevant experiences are presented in Orleans and Tampa See the Supplemental Qualifications supplemental information for detailed package. resumes.

PNC2116748P1 Page 3 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. 2. Project Approach (Philosophy and In respect of surrounding context, the Planning for BB&T Center will require See attachment: Supplemental Adjacent to potential future demolition: Successful live, work, play We seek to create sustainable Design Intent): Max Number of Points 20 BB&T development scheme must a thoughtfully designed process in Information_Project Foresight and flexibility are key to communities thrive on the synergy communities for our current and future A. Describe the firm’s approach and its recognize the current influence of and order to address the existing character Approach_Evaluation Criteria 2 designing around structures that may between business, retail and generations and recognize that city familiarity with key issues, conditions and expected challenges. Such as: working ultimate compatibility with adjacent of the place, economic reality, or may not remain. The design must residential opportunities. Easy, form, walkability, and place-making around an existing building that may land uses. Site access, future contractual timeline of the arena, work in concert with the existing gracious and visually compelling play an outsized role in creating become obsolete within ten years and be transit/mobility and connectivity, both parking availability and management, structure and be designed to a point to transitions between and within economically viable, equitable, and demolished; designing pedestrian vehicular and pedestrian must be physical needs of the build connect with potential future phases. buildings with different functions is health promoting communities. Torti circulation that is separated from vehicular woven into a development plan that environment, not to mention the Esplanade at Aventura replaces an critical to creating and enhancing that Gallas’ design approach is based on circulation; complex service issues (trash removal, delivery services for supplies, supports the Downtown West Broward opportunity to unlock the potential of existing Sears store adjacent to a synergy. Awkward or inconvenient the inextricable relationship between food, mail, taxi and ride share drop off and initiative.Within the site, design 140 acres of developable land. A good regional mall under separate connections between different parts of the planning, urban design, pick-up, hotel access and service); and the considerations include foundation has already started for this ownership. The existing interior mall the project will inevitably harm the architecture, and real estate of future need for parking may drastically responsiveness to market demand to planning exercise, including the 2016 connection is eliminated to re-focus overall concept and impact its communities. The hallmark of success change due to automated cars. Describe inform program, shared use ULI Advisory Panel Study and the the mall circulation on the exterior financial performance. Our master is not simply getting something built – experience and provide specific examples of how you may have dealt with these opportunities, separation of specific 2015 Broward County Climate Action edges of the mall in the event of planning designers integrate The hallmark of success is creating issues in a phased mixed-use project. uses, walkability, sense of place, Plan. Our approach to understand key potential future alteration or demolition distinctive architectural and landscape vibrant, walkable, mixed-income, POINTS VALUE 4 experiential aspects of both areas issues and challenges is through of the mall’s interior solutions to create environments that mixed-use, healthy, and economically users and non-arena users and rigorous analysis and assessment of concourse.Separating are visually engaging yet highly viable communities that residents love maintaining the operational flow of existing conditions. Site pedestrian/vehicular circulation: Our functional. In our design for and are proud to call home. We will traffic and services to/from the arena understanding, place quality, past design approach places high Atlanta we used a combination of strategically employ Placemaking during redevelopment. Block studies, current developments, importance on the viability and below grade parking garages with a design principles to create an organization that provides off-street resource evaluation, public realm and character of separated circulation. In dedicated internal service and parking amenity-rich community that provides service courts and potentially service- open space analysis, development resort design, we celebrate the Arrival access drives to maintain an unbroken the framework for enriching oriented roads are strategies.Perkins opportunities, connectivity and as the terminus of vehicular circulation texture of retail storefronts on the experiences, and that enlivens, Eastman’s experience with Target mobility analysis, land use, parking, and the gateway to the pedestrian main shopping streets and remove inspires, and entertains residents and Field station is relevant to this and environmental evaluation will experience. At Miami Design District, conflicts between public uses and guests. Our extensive experience with assignment. This project developed a become the foundation to generate this gateway concept is celebrated by circulation and back of house service complex phased urban mixed-use ‘Grand Central Station’ adjacent to the master planning principles and bringing guests from sub-grade functions. Gracious sidewalks, planning and architecture means that sports stadium, creating a new public guidelines that in turn will inform the through a sculptural geodesic dome canopies, lush plantings, curbs and we understand the key issues and realm and spurring development final solution. Our relevant experience, into a palm-canopied courtyard. This decorative landscape fencing make have diverse strategies to address around the stadium. Generating fan mentioned later in this submission, space is linked with a shop-lined mid- the sidewalk environment a distinctive any condition. Kimley-Horn’s long experiences around the existing arena dealt with vehicular and pedestrian block promenade leading to a series feature of that project, where association with mixed-use master in anticipation of an expanded circulation conflicts, area-wide of pedestrian spaces. In Aventura, the shoppers feel safe and separated planning projects gives us broad development was integral to the urban connectivity, land use, and phasing open-air Esplanade is surrounded by from adjacent vehicular experience nationwide and locally in plan.In the event the arena complications. We believe the sheltering retail structures, which traffic.Similarly, in our design for the Florida (including both Broward discontinues in 10 years, fan strength and the desirability of a place break into landscaped gateways to Bonnet Creek Resort property, we County and Sunrise). These illustrate experience areas can be considered rely on the quality of the public realm, connect valet and ride-share stations worked with the project owner to our ability to work with projects of for interim land uses that would neighborhood walkability, accessibility or vertical circulation to refashion their original master plan different sizes, types, and change at a later date. Target Field to recreational amenities and parking.Complex service issues: SB concept to provide clear separation of complexities, and in assisting clients Station is again relevant to how we conveniences, and easy connections Architects’ approach to complex service areas from the guest arrival through increasingly complex dealt with these challenges. to regional assets. All of these service issues is to carefully and resort function spaces. The result processes. Our integrated approach Convertible parking structures, zoned qualities are attainable here. Our skill choreograph disparate and myriad is a 1200’ long unbroken public resort creates an environment where our ride sharing pick-up and drop off and and expertise in urban design will programmatic needs as separate realm linking the two hotels, entire team and our clients collaborate

PNC2116748P1 Page 4 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. queuing/staging are important criteria. cohere the structure of the district, systems of a larger whole. This conference facilities, restaurants and and we believe the success of this In the short term, rideshare is expand the planning principles functional drama deliberately arranges pool amenities with views to the project hinges on a strong and lessening the need for residential and established by the ULI panel, and ideal adjacencies and overlaps to adjacent lake and golf course and no collaborative design team focused office parking, but increasing urban deliver an economically create a whole larger than the sum of impacts from vehicular or service around the creation of memorable traffic as it draws away from mass implementable and actionable its parts.Future parking needs: traffic.While we have not had an experiences. The Torti Gallas team transit. When garages are designed, framework by providing two alternative Emerging technology and enterprise opportunity to work on a project with crafts our approach to each plan thought will be given to floor-floor mater plans that work with or without such as self-driving cars, automated the exact circumstance you are facing, based on the unique characteristics of heights, future vertical circulation, the existing arena. Building a strong parking systems, and car-/ride-share we often work around buildings or site a project and, if selected, will work entry points and relationship to “place”, forgoing development in may greatly reduce future needs for features that need to be integrated with you to design the most remaining parking for residents/ isolation, and allowing for flexibility are physical parking space. SB sees this into the larger design concept. In our appropriate process. Please see the tenants. These strategies will be the best resilient practice for creating as opportunity to create flexible and work at the American Tobacco project attached for an additional discussion useful in the event the arena leaves an anchor for the west side of resilient structures. Carefully sited in Raleigh, NC, we refurbished and of key considerations including as event parking would be readily Broward County. above grade parking decks can be enhanced an existing water tower, Framework, Flexibility, and Alternative convertible to stand-alone designed with flat floorplates and linking it to new water features and Development Scenarios; Block Size developments. We must also factor in adequate floor to floor height for later park spaces creating a signature and Parking; Service; Mass Transit; the potential for autonomous vehicles conversion into commercial, organizing concept and iconic feature Open Space; and Guidelines. in the future. residential or other non-parking uses. element for the project.

PNC2116748P1 Page 5 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. B. Describe the firm’s experience with Development phasing strategies will Almost every large-scale development See attachment: Supplemental When designing our mixed-use SRSS has extensive master planning Phasing must be an integral phased urban mixed-use projects, ultimately influence the overall plan we have done has to be phased Information_Mixed Use projects it is of the highest priority to experience, having completed 275 consideration, rather than an specifically addressing how is organization of land uses, especially because of scale, market or financial Experience_Evaluation Criteria 2 develop design and engineering master planning projects. Master afterthought. The first phase must construction done on future phases so that the impact to present residents, in the scenario where the arena is constraints. At Hudson Yards in NYC approaches that minimizes complex planning in an urban context requires deliver a complete “place” that tenants and guests are minimalized. disbanded after 2028. In the case of a the first phases were over rail yards and possibly expensive or time- extensive investigation beyond the establishes an identity, adds value, POINTS VALUE 5 sustained 10-year buildout, early and are buffered from future consuming structural elements, in boundaries of the site to fully and attracts additional investment, occupants will be exposed to several construction phases by strategically favor of a simplified, direct approach understand the context of the project while later phases must logically build years of construction. Early phases of located parks and open spaces, much which results in more flexibility at the and develop a solution consistent with on infrastructure investments. At development should provide needed amenities in the area. In building stage, fewer problems, and the density, scale and character of the TG+P we consider the full spectrum of permanent access to facilities that Stamford, CT, a project that has been ultimately lower costs and neighborhood. It also requires careful considerations to develop plans that remain insulated from future under construction for over 8 years, complications related to impact on study of more practical issues such as don’t compromise existing uses or the construction phases. Dedicated the phasing was based on geographic present residents while phased pedestrian and vehicular connectivity, overall vision. An example is the construction access, buffers and locations, starting on the waterfront, construction activities occur. The security and separation of public and master planned Liberty Center in OH:• barriers, working hour control, site utilizing existing streets and quality of a project is not necessarily service functions.Providing Phase 1 is built - 925k retail, movie maintenance control (dedicated road progressing inland to make the first related to how much it costs, but appropriate accommodation for future theater, 150 key hotel, 100k office, cleaning and dust/mud control) are residents not feel the impact of long rather how wisely the resources of phase construction is a critical design 180 du, church, open spaces, imperatives to livability. Constructing term construction in the area. The time and money are spent, especially goal in any phased master plan structured parking (overbuilt to community amenities such as open phasing at Museum Park Miami began during construction phases. We firmly development. In our design for facilitate Phase 3), surface parking to space or retail early on, although an with the construction of American believe that design excellence and Alpharetta City Center, the first phase be developed in Phase 3, and land for up-front cost, will make the young Airlines arena (you already have an addressing project challenges can be of construction included the City Hall, construction staging/swing space. community immediately livable and arena in place) where future phases achieved on any scale or budget; that Library, public park spaces and public Multiple street connections minimize provide signature anchors that will had to accommodate the unusual and economy and aesthetics are not parking garage. These elements were interruptions during later phases.• attract interest in future projects. irregular frequencies of events as well mutually exclusive. Our strategy is to grouped on individual blocks on the Phase 2 is 1,000 du (220 senior), 120 Phasing of infrastructure will also be as the displacement of existing seek simplicity, which results in south and east sides of the site. key hotel, 100k wellness, & 30k retail. necessary, both physically and parking. Today’s auto-driven planning flexibility in use and economy in cost. Future development parcels were laid We have developed multiple detailed financially. Our team has worked approach may be the biggest We are constantly aware of our out within a new street grid on the scenarios for Phase 2.• Phase 3 is through such issues with Mayo Clinic challenge in transitioning into an responsibility to our clients, who rely north and west sides of the site, facing within the Phase 1 area, adds Destination Medical Center and with urbanized and pedestrian-oriented on us to honor our commitments to the existing commercial core. Working additional uses in the temporary the adjacent Metropica project.The environment. With the success of ride- budget, schedule, and quality of with the owner to define future surface lots, and includes 2­ largest challenge will be maintaining sharing like Uber and Lyft and the work.SB Architects’ successful development goals, SRSS was able to hotels/conference center, 900 du, and the operational flow of traffic and advent of autonomous vehicles, we practice almost always includes design appropriately scaled blocks 50k retail (currently developing services in and out of the arena during must plan our parking surface lots and phasing for urban mixed-use projects. allowing subsequent phase detailed plans for Phase 3).Another a phased redevelopment. However, it parking structures for the present, but Initial project phases need to tell the development to occur without example is Downtown Westminster in is an opportunity to begin to create fan with considerations for how the future story of the place, to create a “there” impacting the functionality or access CO (currently under construction and experiences around the arena in generations will utilize them. Shared there. At Santana row, buildings 7 & 8 to the Phase 1 facilities. The block one of many mall redevelopment anticipation of the expanded parking will reduce the required flank the terminus of the project high format defined discrete areas of plans we’ve created). These plans development. Actively announcing parking below the code requirement street, creating a linear plaza that impact for each out parcel, allowing retain one or more large tenants that ‘what’s next’ and displays of master and will require changes in the current establishes the neighborhood as a work to proceed on individual retain existing service points (as will plans can spark interest to override zoning. Parking structures must also “village within a city”. Both buildings outparcels as development partners need to be done at the BB&T site). discomfort. Target Field Station is be designed to accommodate future are designed with retail frontages on joined the project.In designing a These tenants are designed to be an again relevant to how we dealt with repurposing—potentially able to be the high street, and vehicular, service, phased master plan it is important to integral part of the plan and contribute these challenges of an existing sports converted into retail or other usable and residential access on multiple plan interim uses for future phase vitality to the overall place.Kimley­

PNC2116748P1 Page 6 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. venue and a major redevelopment. At space.For each plan we have done, side streets. This allowed for sites so they do not to detract from the Horn has extensive experience with the current Hard Rock Hollywood phasing has been a critical element to construction to be phased on each aesthetic impact of the early phases of phased developments including expansion where EDSA is the overall success, creating an early side of the high street, and retail and work. At the JW Marriott hotel in ensuring the plan is feasible in landscape architect, a series of buzz about what’s coming, and residential construction to be phased Nashville, our design envisions a detailed design and construction. We temporary routes for arriving guests allowing for flexibility and future within each building. second tower on a ¾ acre site evaluate the alternatives for different have been constructed and then construction to go on without adjacent to the Phase 1 hotel. SRSS phasing sequences with our civil repurposed when permanent routes impacting the value of early phase worked with the landscape designers engineering design, we ensure that were complete. The property is being real estate. to construct a park amenity that will each phase meets regulatory worked from the perimeter only, along serve as an outdoor performance and requirements avoiding issues with routes never exposed to guests. function space for the hotel until the each phase, we provide for stub outs Ample play is made of ‘Future Rock’ Owner works thru the logistics and for utilities, phased stormwater features to come via construction programming for their second phase management conceptual calculations, perimeters. of construction. Rock underlying and vehicular and pedestrian Phase 2 was blasted in Phase 1 to connectivity, and ensure that each facilitate connection of planned below phase is not impacted from a utility, grade levels with the existing Phase 1 traffic, or construction noise parking levels. perspective.

PNC2116748P1 Page 7 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. C. Describe the firm’s approach and its As long-time residents of Broward The Broward Climate Change Action See attachment: Supplemental SB Architects is very familiar with SRSS is familiar with the Broward TG+P has a commitment to designs familiarity in designing for sustainability, County, our senior leadership has Plan (CCAP) 2015 will be used as the Information_Sustainability_Evaluation opportunities and challenges of County Climate Action Plan and is that yield environmentally and resiliency and climate change issues that witnessed first-hand real impact of roadmap for our firm’s approach to Criteria 2C sustainability, resiliency and climate impressed by the efforts of the economically viable communities. We Broward County must deal with. POINTS VALUE 1 climate change. For this reason, we address sustainability, resiliency and change in the South Florida region. Broward County Climate Change Task integrate a Sustainable Development have included Atelier Ten on the climate change. There are many The completed Miami Design District Force to address policy, natural Workshop to identify feasible team. They have extensive objectives outlined in the CCAP that project achieves LEED gold, platinum systems, the water supply, energy sustainable horizontal and vertical experience delivering sustainable, our firm and team collectively are very and LEED ND certifications, takes resources, the built environment and construction strategies. We have 40 resilient projects and masterplans in a familiar with including but not limited advantage of transit and walkability community outreach. Our firm is LEED Accredited Professionals range of scales and sectors. We to transportation planning, multimodal with its central urban location, has committed to the concept of supported by the Firm’s resources in intend to take a comprehensive transportation options, native habitat extensive use of native planting; and a sustainable design and believes all researching, designing, monitoring approach that exceeds the stated vegetation, habitat buffer zones, 2 for 1 solution of green roofs buildings should be designed to and implementing sustainable sustainability mandates towards centralized stormwater systems, water throughout – serving to slow the reduce their negative impact on the strategies that enhance the natural reducing the project’s overall quality, reclaimed water, LED lighting, shedding of rainwater into storm environment. Limiting the carbon setting and buildings that maximize environmental impact, while providing LEED principals, solar, education and drains, while serving as an identifier footprint and other negative energy efficiency and indoor air long-term resiliency planning. We will public outreach. Our approach will for the district as it is visible on the environmental and cultural impacts of quality. Some examples follow:a. work collaboratively during the early include a detailed evaluation of the main flight path to Miami International building construction and operation Master planners for Arlington County, stages to develop a sustainable vision potential opportunities to incorporate Airport. KEITH is devoted to improving are important design goals for our VA for the 260-acre Crystal City and establish specific environmental the actions outlined in the CCAP as the built and natural environments we projects and vital to protecting our Master Plan that achieved LEED-ND and building performance goals. We well as recommendations related to are fortunate to be a part of and for quality of life into the future. As a certification.b. Our 190-acre Salishan will explore a range of sustainable ensuring that the opportunities are our team that starts at our home member of the U.S. Green Building project is a zero run-off community design strategies to achieve these capitalized upon. These offices. Sustainability requires a more Council, SRSS has been a leader in and has 91 LEED Platinum homesc. goals; analyze opportunities for recommendations could include holistic approach than before; one that bringing sustainability into the In 2006, TG+P was selected by HUD impact, viability and cost policies, the creation of a special looks at a triple bottom line from commercial real estate. The firm has and the NAHB to design the PATH effectiveness; and make district or even requirements tied to economics, social and ecological projects certified by the Florida Green Concept Home (Partnership in recommendations for strategies which the future development of the aspects. KEITH is currently engaged Building Coalition, LEED®, Energy Advancing Technology in Housing) as are sensitive to capital costs, property. with the City of Fort Lauderdale Star, National Association of a LEED-H Certified home (occupied in operational budgets, schedule and developing a comprehensive Design Homebuilders, and National Green June 2007).d. We have designed 2­ overall program priorities. Design and and Construction Manual that is aimed Building Standard.SRSS has 10 LEED LEED Platinum, , 5-LEED Gold, 15­ construction methods will be based on at developing a resilient public realm. Accredited Professionals including the LEED Silver, and 7-LEED Certified in-depth studies of and water The manual takes into account Project Manager Mike Murphy, AIA, buildings, 91-LEED Platinum Homes, impacts, providing storage, natural several different aspects of the public LEED AP BD+C.SRSS has received and 4-LEED ND filtration and treatment of storm runoff. realm from drainage, landscape, many accolades and awards in green communities.Following Hurricane High-performance architecture walkways, roadways, sea level rise, building and sustainable Katrina, we developed design optimizing use of daylight and passive lighting, site furniture and more to developments. SRSS’ design for 171 strategies for Gautier, MS that systems will be recommended. create a directive that will assist both 17th Street, at Atlantic Station in provides unique river and bayou Evidence-based landscape based on the public and private realm Atlanta, was the first LEED Silver® shorelines consistent with the species selection and planting development in the city. The goal is Core and Shell high-rise building in community’s ecotourism goals (homes techniques will withstand and that this manual may become the world and the first LEED on “stilts”) and creates a viable town regenerate from wind and water adaptable at the county level in the Certified® high-rise building in center. Strategies in other events. Heat island reduction through future. The work developed as apart Georgia. The Ritz-Carlton, Charlotte communities include raising the land site and building orientation will of this FLL Design and Construction designed by SRSS, was the first elevation and building open maximize shading and air movement. Manual can be utilized within this LEED Gold® hotel for The Ritz­ foundations with breakaway panels. At

PNC2116748P1 Page 8 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. The team will ultimately produce a master plan process for the BB&T Carlton Hotel Company. The Kimley-Horn, sustainability, resiliency, sustainability framework document Center. Brooks + Scarpa is, and has Brookwood, also designed by SRSS, and climate change are at the and implementation plan for the BB&T been, a firm on the forefront of was the first LEED Certified® high-rise forefront of our design thoughts and site study area. Atelier Ten has sustainable design for decades. Our residential building in Georgia. processes. The rapid changes that our extensive experience developing Colorado Court project was the first area is experiencing in sea level rise, sustainable masterplans for a variety LEED Gold multifamily residential groundwater table rise, more intense of projects including: Cleveland building in the United States. Our and frequent storms, and other Waterfront Redevelopment, City of approach is to utilize passive climate related changes make Buffalo’s Canal Side and Port sustainable strategies first, before designing sustainable and resilient Authority of San Francisco’s Mission introducing active sustainable development more important now than Rock, as well as working with EDSA systems. We believe every ever. We have significant experience to develop a preliminary masterplan to sustainable design application leads in designing stormwater management evaluate sustainable design and to the integration of healthier and systems to accommodate more energy efficiency options for higher quality natural system. B+ S is intense storms, designing Panama’s Global City development. developing adaptation solutions to the underground electric and challenges of sea level rise and communication facilities to protect climate change. them from hurricanes, and providing for low impact design and green/sustainable practices.

PNC2116748P1 Page 9 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. D. How has the firm addressed pedestrian Encouraging pedestrian movement is Walkability is key to the success of See attachment: Supplemental SB Architects’ site specific and user- Having worked on many projects in At TG+P we believe in creating circulation in sub-tropical climates? a challenge in hot, humid and rainy urban environments; however, sub­ Information_Pedestrian centric design approach considers all sub-tropical climates, SRSS is well culturally authentic and architecturally POINTS VALUE 1 weather. Walkability is critical within tropical climates offer both Circulation_Evaluation Criteria 2D climates as assets to be appreciated versed in addressing pedestrian indigenous communities. Our work the rule that pedestrians on foot will opportunities and constraints for and elevated. At Esplanade at circulation so that it is a pleasurable across the US and internationally walk up to 400 meters, which is a 5­ pedestrian circulation. While winter Aventura, the main public circulation is experience and one to be celebrated. provides us with a diverse perspective minute stroll. People must also be conditions may be pleasant for outdoors with lush, resort-like For our office project at 2525 Ponce and large toolkit, however, we believe engaged by street level activity during pedestrians, urban design measures landscaping. Wide covered elevated de Leon Boulevard in Coral Gables, that each region and each site are that journey. Furthermore, it is proven need to address heat, humidity, glare open-air concourses celebrate the Florida, we developed transitional unique and require a custom solution. that providing a progression of and torrential rain in the summer. In favorable climate while providing spaces of enclosed, semi-enclosed, One of the defining factors of regions indoor/outdoor sheltered spaces with our Master Plan for Palm Beach Mall, shade and harnessing cooling and open spaces which circulated are the varying climates from arid to architectural shade and tree canopies, we used a combination of street trees breezes. Water features along the cool breezes. Internal courtyard humid, from cold to hot, from wet to is an effective model to address and awnings to provide shade and way release cooling mists and gardens were used to create a dry, and from cloudy to sunny. We climatic comfort. Urban tree planting is shelter for pedestrian comfort. Mild psychologically cool with sound and landscape of private outdoor spaces create places that respond to their especially important and is sometimes tone and low-glare paving are used to sight of running water. At Miami where plants and breezes create a environment:• Through urban design lost in the quest for an urban prevent glare. Furthermore, buildings Design District, the main pedestrian constantly refreshing air quality for at the neighborhood scale such as character. On the contrary, creating are designed to support mall is open to the sky yet limited to pedestrians. People move through the narrower building face-to-building face heavily shaded streets, developing indoor/outdoor activities such as thirty feet wide. Along with covered project under arcades and loggias dimensions to create more shade dedicated pedestrian zones with a outdoor dining and marketplace. If we arcades, tree canopy, covered shop which protect them from the sun and such as at Al Wasl in Saudi Arabia• continuous green ribbon of parks, were chosen for the BB&T Master entries, and narrower side paths, the inclement weather and provides Building design such as continuous urban trails, water elements and a Plan, we would apply walkability passage width ensures shade for user thermal comfort. These micro level colonnades for townhouses at San central park should be highly principles for sub-tropical climate to comfort. he KEITH team understands strategies can also be applied at a Diego Naval Training CenterWe have prioritized. Fort Lauderdale’s make walking as appealing as efficient design and engineering macro level when planning larger sites experience designing in sub-tropical Riverwalk, where EDSA served as possible. principles that lead to truly sustainable like we did for Grande Lakes Resort in climates and have included pedestrian master planner and landscape Complete Streets that move beyond Orlando, Florida. Pedestrian pathways strategies such as the following:• A architect for its cornerstone projects, the road as the sole means of were lined with shade trees and principal street with a continuous is heavily shaded and serves as a foil transportation. Shade is the first key permeable spaces were shaped to covered arcade providing shade for to adjacent intense element to integrate into any accommodate circulating cool breezes pedestrians such as at the Miramar development. We were able to pedestrian area. This can be coming from natural large bodies of Town Center• Narrow streets with coordinate with adjacent development accomplished through natural planting water. Like many of our projects, the smaller building face-to-building face projects at the time to relocate several where space allows for Trees/Palms pedestrian experience at Grande dimensions to provide increased large trees to bare corridors, most of and in other areas Arcades, trellis, Lakes took higher priority over shade at Camana Bay• Orienting the which stand 30 years later and lend a awnings or building facades. Also the vehicular circulation. Circulation was principal pedestrian route at Camana sense of permanence and respite to integration of seating and site furniture meandering with surprising Bay west to east to capture the the linear park. On the City Center Las elements to allow for pedestrian experiences around each corner. By prevailing winds in the hottest months Vegas project, Perkins Eastman paid respites throughout.Brooks + Scarpa providing a network of pedestrian from May through October.• Proposed particularly close attention to the is well aware of the climatic issues circulation that is both pleasurable and streetscapes planned with canopy pedestrian climate comfort by surrounding south Florida’s sub­ comfortable, people will get out of trees and not palm trees to provide incorporating a series of strategies tropical region. Embedded in our way their cars and experience projects on shade at projects such as Belmont including reduction of heat island of working is a respect for our natural their feet which is good for the project Heights in Tampa Florida, but closely through paving material selection, environment and fragile ecosystems and good for the environment. spaced palms at Camana Bay where building orientation for shade and of south Florida. By integrating state- canopy trees are very small.Given our breeze capture and placement of of-the-art eco-friendly design and location in a sub-tropical climate,

PNC2116748P1 Page 10 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. trees and shading devices along science, our work is at the leading Kimley-Horn recognizes the promenades and near mixed use edge of sustainability best practices challenges that our weather provides. zones. and innovation. We would design We have worked closely with project paseos and “walk streets” or “shared architects and landscape architects to street” configurations that treat the design pedestrian circulation routes street as garden while also enhancing with aesthetically pleasing methods to and promoting physical activity, shade creatively shade pedestrian pathways and comfort. The design of “landscape and create oasis points for as infrastructure” would also have the pedestrians. We actively use native added benefit of providing ecological shade trees, trellises, and other stormwater management or commonly landscape and hardscape elements to known now as Low Impact reduce heat island effect and provide Development. shading for the walking and biking public.

PNC2116748P1 Page 11 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. E. Describe the firm’s approach to design Essential to the health and well-being In our minds, the creation of great See attachment: Supplemental We integrate sustainable design with Our approach to incorporating health Chronic diseases are the leading that helps create better health and of residents, employees and guests places is primarily for and about Information_Health and wellness amenities for the overall and wellness into our designs causes of death and disability in the wellness for its residents, tenants and will be opportunities for social people. Healthy neighborhoods Wellness_Evaluation Criteria 2E health of the user, project, and supports our general philosophy of United States and makes up 86% of guests. POINTS VALUE 1 interaction and accessibility to parks, support the health and wellness for its environment. We think about these providing access to nature and our annual healthcare expenditures – gathering plazas and recreation residents and visitors. Our design design principals at the beginning of facilitating social engagement. We Yet they are the most preventable. zones. Within the site, the spaces that approach promotes urban realm with our projects to ensure they are create high-quality spaces that While genetics play a role, our own host these activities must be carefully character and authenticity, land uses integrated and harmonious. Brooks + promote everything from community individual behavior and our crafted, articulated and defined by the that are ingrained with arts and Scarpa will approach a design that interaction to multi-generational play environment determine 45% of our architecture of the project. culture, and complete streets that are ensures the health and wellness of and we strive to place this connectivity health. A significant amount of Pedestrians must be given priority on integrated with green infrastructure residents. We will look at the project in a natural setting. Projects like our research has been undertaken and properly scaled streets and mid-block reducing flooding and air pollution. through five lenses, place + identity, Alpharetta City Center, 5th Street shows that the physical form of a paseos to encourage foot traffic. Considerations are given to healthy & active lifestyles, multi- Bridge, and Buckhead Atlanta are all community can influence both daily Furthermore, pedestrian connections multimodal transit opportunities, modality, living infrastructure and flood about connecting people to one behaviors (such as increases in to Sawgrass Mills and other adjacent vehicle sharing, better way-finding, adaptation. Engaging public spaces another and to their environment. walking) and the environment in a residential projects must be and greater efficiency and that are attractive and inviting, and Pedestrian oriented streetscapes and manner that can significantly impact addressed. Given the site’s adjacency conveniences in public services. As a pedestrian friendly will anchor a sense bike infrastructure are common health outcomes. TG+P’s Healthy to the Everglades, the concept of a result, we create walkable and of place and identity. Design for multi- components in many of our projects. Communities initiative places us at the physical connection recommended by connected communities with equal modality, integrating automobiles, Providing end-users the opportunity to forefront and organizes our approach the ULI Case Study will provide a new access to basic services and transit-ready streets, bicycle and walk, rather than drive, is a common and design strategies into 5­ gateway for an Everglades experience amenities that in turn will advance pedestrian will be essential. B+S will strategy that we promote across all categories: Active Living, that can be embedded in the storyline health and wellness for all. develop urban systems for flexibility project types. Integrating buildings into Environment, Food and Nutrition, of all elements of the master and adaptability to future climate, the surrounding landscape provides Social Cohesion and Mental Health, plan.Programming of the public realm context, economically changing opportunities to take advantage of and Health Services. Not only do we is needed for events at a variety of futures—design futuring. Traffic natural assets, such as wetlands, understand the design strategies that scales with emphasis on frequency calming and other artistic lakes, mature forests, and unique and promote health within each of these and consistency. The BB&T streetscapes, like festival and shared fragile ecosystems. Being able to categories, but we have developed a development plan must also street types will be explored. experience these natural assets from proprietary tool called the “Community implement ‘Smart Cities’ initiatives in the interior or exterior of buildings has Health Report Card” that allows us to technology applications for data proven to be beneficial to both mental take the vast amount of medical capture, communications and and physical well-being. research and compare any two information tracking. This data will communities to project the differences assist in guiding community managers in the chronic disease rates to plan and communicate events and (hypertension, type 2 diabetes, activity programming as well as obesity, anxiety/mood disorder), contributing real time information to an hospital attendance and expenses, application that can be use regularly traffic related accidents, by residents and guests through a cardiopulmonary mortality, lung smart phone to make appointments cancer, and medical expenses due to and reservations, to place orders and the different designs of the to make community inquires. With the communities. A case study efficient operations and functioning of (comparative analysis) of projected buildings, businesses, streets and differences in chronic diseases

PNC2116748P1 Page 12 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. common areas, people will be between King Farm (a 350 acre built encouraged to walk rather than ride TG+P master ) and the public realm becomes a and a nearby community using this venue for social interaction, thus tool is attached.Kimley-Horn provides raising the wellness quotient of the areas for people to utilize for walking place. and biking, fitness areas, and other walkable paths to provide for health benefits to users. We also create livable and pleasant spaces for people to enjoy on their own, to gather their thoughts, or to gather with others and improve mental health. Mixed-use developments are unique in the fact that people can live, work, and play ­ The design needs to reflect that and invite people to love their spaces, inside and out.

PNC2116748P1 Page 13 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. F. Describe your experience and provide Lambert Advisory uses a research- Our Development and Implementation See attachment: Supplemental KEITH provides the ideal combination SRSS offers services in master Creating an economically viable specific examples of a variety of driven method to objectively Advisors from Pinstripe have provided Information_Professional Planning of creativity, technical expertise, local planning, architecture, interior design, master plan requires significant professional planning services related to recommend land use mixes, densities, development, implementation and Services Projects_Evaluation Criteria and regional development experience, landscape architecture and experience in the development world. the implementation of projects identified within an urban mixed-use Master Plan land acquisition, leasing and financial consulting services for a 2F and familiarity with Broward County experiential graphic design. Our Since many of our clients are including Economic/Feasibility Planning, public/private partnerships. Lambert variety of master plans in urban and the City of Sunrise as a master planning services include site developers, we not only think like Cost Analysis, Facilities Infrastructure developed the investor package for settings. Their work is built upon the whole.KEITH is well-versed in analysis, land use analysis, and designers, we also think like Analysis and Evaluations, Parking MANA who is master planning several initial visioning efforts and included managing the planning process for feasibility studies. We tailor our developers (and some of our partners Analysis (including the future of parking sites in downtown Miami, Wynwood studies of project feasibility, private development. This provides services to the needs of the client. Our even have their own development garages with the coming of automated vehicles), and Traffic Analysis. and Jersey City. At Miami Airport City, identification of strategic partners and our team with a unique perspective, in mixed-use projects incorporate companies), so create economically POINTS VALUE 8 Lambert assisted in negotiation of funding sources, analyses of market that we appreciate the need to various combinations of multifamily, viable solutions – This is the reason terms and conditions defining conditions, programming alternatives streamline processes to gain retail, office, hotel and parking many cities hire us. The TG+P master development timing, developer and ancillary development efficiencies and to provide timely components. Many are in urban planned 260-acre Crystal City contribution and terms of development opportunities, as well as collaboration service to clients who invest in environments and sometimes are included determining the additional agreements. This work is a natural with a variety of architects and development projects, that ultimately high-rise, vertical stacked density required to make bridge between the 2016 ULI Case engineers on issues including energy, serve to increase a city’s tax base. developments. Below is an example of redevelopment feasible and “finding” Study, the proposed Master Plan and communications, and other KEITH has likewise garnered success how we are working to incorporate additional development sites the ensuing Developer RFP. EDSA’s infrastructure needs. Parking analysis, within the private sector, particularly flexibility for the future in our designs (including transforming excess road and Perkins Eastman’s master public infrastructure improvements with major redevelopment projects of parking decks for a repeat client. right-of-way along Route 1 into planning experience will be called into and costs are holistically evaluated by that have yielded expended economic SRSS has a 30+ year relationship with developable parcels). At Camana Bay play to support the balance of our the design team. Representative opportunities for varied stakeholders. Chick-fil-A, Inc., for whom we we used projected absorption rates to team in offering their expertise in examples include Rose Rock Mixed-Use, multi-family, retail and continuously renew their master plan arrive at a development program to assessing the economic, physical, International Financial Center in affordable housing projects are and facilities. This effort includes shorten the build-out timeframe while transportation, connectivity, open Tianjin, China, Chula Vista Bayfront product types that can influence the regular analysis of budgeting future maximizing the use of shared space, environmental and community Master Plan in San Diego, California, character of a neighborhood. From costs with escalation as well as parking.Kimley-Horn has provided full aspects of the plan. Kimley-Horn has El Paso Sports & Entertainment economic and environmental infrastructure analysis. We are engineering development services for intimate knowledge of the BB&T District in El Paso, Texas and sustainability to the impact of art in currently planning a parking structure mixed-use developments and master Center infrastructure and traffic currently in St. Petersburg, FL with the public spaces, KEITH’s staff has had for them with the expectation of a planning. We have relationships with conditions based on their traffic DRI City on Tropicana Redevelopment. In extensive experience. This includes reduction in parking requirements in contractors, which allows us to work that was key to the project’s each of these examples focus was long range planning services the future due to the advancement of provide accurate order of magnitude approval. Professional services with given to the creation of a new urban comprised of comprehensive driverless car technology, opinions of probable construction the City of Sunrise has informed their district, enhanced urban environment, planning, evaluation and appraisal teleworking/carpooling, and increased costs as we develop phased master knowledge of utilities and road and commercial appeal to mixed-use reports, preparation of land use of transit. Our design plans. We have expertise in capacities. Kimley-Horn will be a key development in connection to a development applications including accommodates the eventual pedestrian and vehicular traffic asset in assessing infrastructure broader regional real estate rezoning, platting, delegation requests conversion of the top two floors into design. Parking utilization is a needs for the pending master plan opportunities and developing sound and site planning. We can also office space by increasing the floor-to­ consideration now and in the future. development. Their work at Miami and effective strategies for deploying provide numerous planning studies floor heights, increasing structural With the success of ride-sharing like World Center was an exercise in public-private partnerships as well as including but not limited to parking load factors for office use, revising the Uber and Lyft and the advent of utilities master planning and staging assisting cities and municipalities with studies, corridor studies, state ramping and floor slopes to maximize autonomous vehicles, we must plan and will be invaluable. developer RFPs and selection mandated planning reports, urban flat floor area, and adding elevator our parking for the present, but with Nelson/Nygaard’s experience with process. design analysis, transfer of capacity. We are also incorporating considerations for how future ’s Lincoln Yards Master Plan development rights, community liaison sprinklering in the initial buildout as generations will utilize them. We involves developing a comprehensive and numerous types of feasibility required by codes for the future mixed implement shared parking analyses to

PNC2116748P1 Page 14 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. parking and transportation demand studies.Brooks + Scarpa has occupancy.Our consultant Kimley- reduce required parking, and will work management program in addition to developed numerous phased mixed- Horn has provided full engineering with the County & City to develop an supporting an overall use “Master Plans” for a variety of development services for mixed-use agreeable parking plan for the future. pedestrian/bicycle/road network study location types. Brooks + Scarpa developments and master planning. Parking structures must also be including innovative programs for developed a range of planning studies Their relationships with local designed to accommodate future future residents, employees and for the Boston MCCA Convention contractors allows them to provide repurposing—potentially able to be visitors. Nelson/Nygaard will assist in Center that included mixed-use accurate order of magnitude opinions converted into retail or other usable assessing mobility conditions and parking structures that could be of probable construction cost during space. Kimley-Horn is the pre-eminent fulfilling the connectivity desire for the implemented over time. The MCCA’s the development of phased master traffic engineer in the Broward County, BB&T Center.Machete Group’s role at requirements include being able to plans. Our combined expertise in with expertise on traffic analyses for the Chase Center in San Francisco convert the structures to office space, pedestrian and vehicular traffic design large scale mixed use developments, focused on the venue program, cost housing or other uses at a future date. is extensive. Our team will implement such as this one, and reviewing how estimation, entitlement and schedule. Each of these structures has a shared parking analyses to reduce the they interact with the current and At the Barclays Center in Brooklyn, “convertibility” to affordable housing required parking below the maximum future buildout of the surrounding they performed a comprehensive within the lifespan of the structure. combined code requirement and will areas. design and engineering audit. Such B+S has worked with team members work with the County and City to analytics will guide the practical and clients on cost analysis of provide an agreeable parking plan for aspects of the master plan. alternative bid items and resilient the future. design parameters.

PNC2116748P1 Page 15 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. 3. Past Performance: Max Number of The Wharf (Washington, DC): The Our urban design practice See attachment: Supplemental SB Architects strategic approach to SRSS has designed 275 phased TG+P’s award-winning Urban Mixed- Points 40 design restores connections between encompasses large-scale master Information_Past master planning and conceptual master plans, including 83 with 3 of Use Master Planning experience A. Describe the firm’s qualifications and the city and waterfront by integrating plans, small area plans, and block-by­ Performance_Evaluation Criteria 3 design — taking into account shifts in the following components – 4+star ranges from 350 acres to 50 acres relevant experience and provide specific examples of phased urban mixed-use land and water functions. The $2 block development plan. We are socio-economic landscapes —will hotels, Class “A & B” office buildings, with both public entity and developer master planning projects that includes at billion waterfront development accustomed to working closely with contribute to the success of this Residential and Retail. Below is a list clients and range from greenfield to least three of the following mid-rise to includes 1.5 million sf of office, retail, client and stakeholder groups and project. As with our other mixed-use of projects of similar scope and pdfs infill to redevelopment. Several (with high-rise components: Four star or greater residential, hotel and cultural land teams of economic consultants, projects, we explored what was with more information are attached. 1. accompanying guidelines or codes) hotels; Class “A” to Class “B+” office uses. Assembly Doraville USA engineers, community facilitators, and available in the immediate Downtown City Center Master Plan, are built or currently under buildings; multifamily residential buildings; and some retail to support the (Doraville, Georgia): The “city within a specialist consultants. We design with neighborhoods, what was of interest Mixed-Use Development and construction. We have subsequently residential and office tenants. Provide a city “has districts of its own and the whole community in mind, not one to target markets, and how could Outparcels, Alpharetta, GA - This 22­ been hired by developers to design minimum of five projects with references. provides a variety of urban building and not one use. We solve BB&T project foster a more acre public/private project created a individual buildings and by Preference in scoring will be given experiences. The project incorporates complex urban issues and aim for meaningful sense of community and downtown area. We provided master jurisdictions to oversee and review the projects of similar nature and scope and to walkable streets, integrates with long-term potential with an eye toward encourage guests to stay and invest. planning and architectural services for implementation by others. This those that have been successfully completed. Suburban mixed-use project nature, has high-density mixed-use short-term implementation The master plan can say more about a 455-space parking deck, a town breadth of experience from where buildings are surrounded by surface close to transit and convenient bicycle strategies.Museum Park Miami – A a particular era than a single building, green, public park, and an office conceptualization to implementation parking will not be considered. Provide connectivity. Transit is the preferred cultural district master plan that park or interior can ever aspire to. building. The project also includes a provides our clients with superior written and graphic descriptions along mode of travel to and within the site, focused on creating a waterfront park Today’s mixed-use urban designs City Hall (interior design) and Library. insight and unparalleled with any photographs of these projects. minimizing auto use and maximizing to generate downtown renewal. The provide an exceptionally high level of 2. Tower Place Master Plan and expertise.Kimley-Horn brings POINTS VALUE 20 pedestrian-oriented streets. Village of park hosted Perez Art Museum, prescription compared to planning Mixed-Use Development, Atlanta, GA significant experience with mixed-use Marbella (Coconut Creek, FL): The Museum of Science, and was efforts of the previous century. As – This 20-acre MXD includes several projects for both private and public goal of the project is to develop a integrated with the neighboring seen with Santana Row, the secret to SRSS projects including Tower Place sectors and knows how to coordinate place-based urban core that serves as American Airlines Arena. Our intention successful and enduring mixed-use 100 Refresh (Public Space), Tower the diverse elements to ensure a focal live/play space. With a vibrant was to connect to the upland communities lies in the connectivity Place 200 (Office Tower), the Park at successful implementation and also mix of uses the development includes neighborhood with improved and interrelationships between the Tower Place, Buckhead Grand brings local Broward County and residential, hospitality, commercial streetscape, retain its historic ground floor retail and shoppers, the (Condominiums), Retail, Restaurants, Sunrise experience and and retail offerings. EDSA addressed character with low height and density residents who call it home, the office Buckhead Church and relationships.The projects included in all aspects of LEED certification and propose high-rise multi-family workers who frequent it each day and 3344/Sovereign (Vertically Stacked the attached PDF titled Supplemental incorporating transit stops, bike buildings along Biscayne Boulevard. the visiting hotel guests whose MXD). 3. Riverside on the James Information_Phased Urban Mixed-Use facilities, street connectivity, Today, this area is one of the most experience is enhanced. This Master Plan and Mixed-Use Master Planning Projects_Evaluation pedestrian orientation, active street popular neighborhoods in choreographed experience between Development, Richmond, VA ­ Criteria 3A are listed below:Master level uses and green infrastructure Miami.Harbor Point, Stamford – a districts delivers authentic, collective, Located on Johns Island, the project Planningi. Crystal City, Arlington solutions. Bahia Mar Resort & master pan that transformed 80 acres real-time experiences for families, includes an 8-story office building, a County, VA – TG+P, public sector, Yachting Center (Fort Lauderdale FL): of brownfield into five mixed-use couples, and individuals to share and 10-story residential tower, 70,000 SF adopted, some completed buildings The $400 million redevelopment is neighborhoods based on a network of remember.Brooks + Scarpa has of retail and 800-space parking and current construction, is finalist for envisioned as a mixed use, resort open spaces that also marked the worked on numerous phased urban deck.4. Buckhead Atlanta Master plan Amazon HQ2ii. Liberty Center, community that includes a new hotel, division of phases. Within walking mixed-use master plans. These plans and Mixed-Use Development, Atlanta, Liberty, OH – TG+P, private sector, commercial/retail space, restaurants, distance to the multi-modal have included mid-rise and high-rise GA - This phased mixed-use Phase 1 built, 2 and 3 detailed fishing village, marina and a 4-acre transportation center, the components with inclusion of development reinvigorated an planning underwayiii. Camana Bay, elevated park that anchors the development includes 2,500 dwelling structured parking. B+S has entertainment/retail district. SRSS was Grand Cayman – TG+P, private development to the beach. Creating a units in a variety of housing types, completed a series of master plans Architect-of-Record for the project sector, infrastructure under pedestrian-friendly experience, a 350,000 sf of commercial office, that retrofit sprawl and showcase a which includes residences, retail, construction, 1st buildings in design series of parks, plazas and 60,000 sf of retail and a 250-room phasing strategy over time. B+S has offices, restaurants and parking phaseiv. Prince Georges Plaza –

PNC2116748P1 Page 16 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. promenades compliment on-site boutique hotel. Phase I and II of this worked with several cities and decks. 5. Uptown Charlotte, Master TG+P, public sector, adopted, two parking. 90Ninety Way (Jamaica, New development have been completed in counties that control development for Planning and Design Projects, buildings under constructionv. York): Design of the 624,000-sf 2013 and have been awarded a particular site. B+S has shown a Charlotte, NC – Uptown Charlotte Westminster New Downtown, CO – mixed-use development includes 525 LEED_ND Gold. National Ballpark – a range of approaches that can help encompasses several SRSS projects TG+P, Phase 1 under constructionvi. units of sustainable housing with master plan on the Anacostia River shape public policy, incentives, and including The Ritz Carlton Charlotte Loudoun Metro, Loudon County, VA – varied affordability centered around a with retail, residential, hotel, office expectations for developing mixed-use (5-stars), Hearst Tower, Fifth Third TG+P, private sector, comprehensive recreation of the de-mapped portion of centered around the Washington urban developments in a community Center, Ally Center (Offices), Catalyst plan being updated by jurisdictionvii. 91st, 90NINETY is designed to National’s Stadium. The plan provides otherwise dominated by suburban and 2 SkyHouses (Apartments), Twinbrook Metro Place, White Flint, activate 75,000 sf of retail through one million sf of retail, two million sf residential products. Usually rated Avenue (Condominiums) and MD – TG+P, County Project Plan increased street frontage, pedestrian each of office and residential uses from easy to ambitious, each of the Charlotte Ballet. 6. Metropica, Master approval expected Dec. 2018viii. realms and flexible spaces for with structured parking. Chester two urban design and planning Plan Design Competition, Sunrise, FL Westchester Bio-Science and community amenities. See Waterfront with Talen Energy Stadium frameworks for the BB&T site will - A Design Competition for a MXD Technology Center, Westchester, NY supplemental information for – a master plan for 147 acre of integrate new public and semi-private adjacent to Sawgrass Mills Mall, the – TG+P, Environmental Impact Study additional project details. brownfield on the Delaware River. The open space, parking structures, master plan included 71,500 SF of and zoning approval phaseix. proposed mixed-use development streetscapes, and multi-family housing retail space, 2,400 apartments, a Bahcesehir, Istanbul, Turkey – TG+P, was organized around a public realm in tandem with renovations or 35,000 SF clubhouse and parking private sector, builtx. Dania Pointe, plan. The development program demolition of the BB&T Center. decks with 4,080 spaces. Dania Beach, FL – Kimley-Horn, included a 20,000-seat soccer private sector, Phase 1 constructionxi. stadium for the Philadelphia Union, Suntrust Class A and B offices, mi

PNC2116748P1 Page 17 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. B. Describe the firm’s experience in 1 Hotel & Homes South Beach (Miami Our hotel experience ranges from 60­ See attachment: Supplemental Our hospitality practice is dedicated to Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Hotels play an important role in designing Four Star and higher rated mid- Beach, FL): Focusing on the arrival room boutique hotels to 4,800-room Information_Hotel producing designs where site Stewart & Associates (SRSS) has creating regional destinations and rise and high-rise hotels in urban settings sequence, amenities and public casino/convention center hotels in Experience_Evaluation Criteria 3B sensitivity, structure and nuance are designed 248 4+ star and higher rated allow visitors to experience and with structured parking. Provide a minimum of five projects with references. access points, the design articulates large cities like New York and Las favored above all else. In order to best mid-rise and high-rise hotels in urban contribute to the vitality of a place Preference will be given in scoring to the crux of the destination’s character Vegas to smaller towns such as convey the individuality of each site, settings with structured parking. Below throughout the day and evening. those hotels that have been successfully through space, substance, form and Stamford, CT and resort destinations we try to be modern in our thinking is a list of completed projects. 1. While some hotels can be bland and completed. Provide written and graphic functionality. The site features 417 such as Disneyland Park in California. and classic in our approach. With an Renaissance Tampa International inward facing, our hotel designs descriptions along with any photographs hotel rooms, 163 residences, 4 Our master plan for City Center in Las extensive background in hospitality Plaza Hotel, Tampa, FL - This 8-story, contribute to the architectural vitality of of these projects. POINTS VALUE 5 swimming pools, a spa and fitness Vegas included 2,400 condo units and design and resort master planning, we 294-key, 206,000 SF hotel contains a neighborhood with ample windows, center, private beach and 4,800 hotel rooms in five high-rise consider ourselves less as traditional 10,000 SF of meeting space, a 750­ pedestrian scaled facades, and active entertainment/dining experiences. 1 towers and more than 12,000 architects and more as designers of seat ballroom, bar and a restaurant. ground floors. Recent hotels that we Hotel Brooklyn Bridge Park (Brooklyn, structured parking spaces. City Center an experience, whether that The project is located 1.7 miles from have designed include the urban NY): Design services for the 193-key opened its first hotel in 2009 and experience is a golf clubhouse, a 100­ Raymond James Stadium (Tampa mixed-use 118K SF Kimpton Hotel in property includes multi-family completed the 76-acre development in acre beachfront resort, or branded Bay Buccaneers) and 1.9 miles from Nashville, TN (built), a 10-story residential. The new hotel includes an 2015 by numerous architects following residences. Branded Residences; this Steinbrenner Field (Baseball). 2. Homewood Suites in Arlington, VA, a all-day dining venue, specialty the master plan. In another project for unique residential product provides Nashville Marriott at Vanderbilt luxury 50-room hotel in Bodrum, restaurant, rooftop bar and pool, MGM Resorts, we planned for a multi- whole or fractional-ownership, luxury University, Nashville, TN – The hotel Turkey with water views, separate spa spa/fitness center, ballroom, and phased re-imagination of the living in many of the world’s most overlooks the Vanderbilt Football building, and extensive outdoor various meeting spaces. The new Excalibur, Luxor, and Mandalay Bay sought-after cities and destinations. Stadium and is .3 miles from amenities (under construction), the destination helps to revitalize the Hotels into a mega-resort with shared Imagine a home not only defined by Centennial Park (The Parthenon), and urban mixed-use Cambria Hotel and waterfront and create activity. W parking, convention center, retail, and sophisticated style and luxurious .3 miles from Charles Hawkins Suites in Rockville, MD (built), and a South Beach (Miami Beach, FL): The resort amenities. In New York City, finishes, but equipped to deliver Baseball Stadium. The 30-key, 11­ development concept for an urban 10­ ambitious expansion created a along the High Line, we designed a legendary hospitality service. From story, 207,000 SF facility features a story 5-star hotel in Grand Cayman dynamic urban oasis that echoes the five-star 180-room hotel featuring a concierge services and in-residence 12,000 SF conference facility and that will anchor one end of the Town characteristics of South Beach living. woonerf, a street specifically designed dining to a dedicated management ballroom. 3. JW Marriott Nashville, Center. Please see the project sheets The project includes a 19-story hotel for people but shared by automobile team, a lifestyle of privacy and comfort Nashville, TN – Architect-of-Record in the attached PDF with the file name tower, retail, spa, ballrooms and traffic, lined with the hotel lobby and awaits.Brooks + Scarpa has various for the 33-story, 533-key hotel with Supplemental Information beachfront pool amenity area with ground floor retail and gallery. As part experience in design of hotels. We 50,000 SF of event space, a spa, and Hotels_Evaluation Criteria 3B. amphitheater, raised decks and sun of the master plan for Harbor Point in have completed renovations and the restaurants. The hotel is .9 miles from lawns. A seagrape and gumbo limbo Stamford, Ct, a 210 room four-start firm is currently working on a boutique Bridgestone Arena (Nashville hammock garden serves as a liaison hotel anchored Harbor Point Square hotel in Chengdu, China. The Y4 Predators), 1.4 miles from Nissan between the pool area, hotel and and was one of the first buildings to be Boutique Hotel is a small 24 room Stadium (Tennessee Titans and CMA public restaurants. City Center (Las completed in a multi-phased long-term luxury hotel. It features a world class Music Festival) and 2 miles from The Vegas, Nevada): The 66-acre site was plan along with parking and a wine bar and tasting room, a 5 star Ryman Auditorium.4. Hilton Hotel and developed into a urban complex waterfront park. restaurant and bar, private meeting Waldorf Astoria Hotel, Bonnet Creek defined by avenues, places and rooms and event spaces with Orlando, FL – These two hotels are experiences. The project includes the courtyards and plazas. The hotel located inside the gates of Disney development of 18 million sf of space rooms range from 135SF to 200SF World – a 1,000-key Hilton Hotel and consisting of a 4,000-room suites with private courtyards and a 500-key Waldorf Astoria. Shared hotel/casino, three 400-room boutique balconies with panoramic views of the amenities include 110,000 SF of hotels, approximately 550,000 sf of surrounding area. ballroom/meeting space and 12 retail shops, dining/entertainment restaurants. 5. The Ritz-Carlton

PNC2116748P1 Page 18 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. venues and 1,650 units of Charlotte, Charlotte, NC – The hotel is condominiums and private residence located next to the Bank of America clubs.Ritz-Carlton Resort and Spa offices which utilize 50% of the guest (Fort Lauderdale, FL): Guests of the rooms. The 5-star hotel has 140 keys, 120-room, 25-story hotel 38 36 suites, and 13,000 SF of condominiums experience the conference space including a 9,000 refinement of another era with SF ballroom. Amenities include a dramatic oceanfront terraces, a restaurant, bar, rooftop spa and heated infinity pool on a 29,000 fitness center.6. Renaissance Atlanta square foot tropical deck, private VIP Midtown Hotel, Atlanta, GA – This oceanfront cabanas seemingly 207,500 SF, 20-story, 304-key suspended over Ocean, boutique hotel features a 150-seat an elegant spa, expansive fitness restaurant, 100-seat rooftop bar, center, signature ocean view 1,100 SF fitness center, 10,000 SF restaurant, and more than 24,000 ballroom/meeting space, lounge and square feet of meeting space.See parking garage with 119 spaces. supplemental information for additional project details.

PNC2116748P1 Page 19 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. C. Describe the firm’s experience in 800 Main Avenue at the Wharf For our work at Hudson Yards on the See attachment: Supplemental Brooks +Scarpa has designed over Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, In the highly competitive and generally designing Class “A” and Class “B+” mid- (Washington, DC): The 11-story west side of Manhattan, we designed Information_Office 2,000,000SF of commercial office Stewart & Associates (SRSS) has overbuilt office market, urban rise and high-rise office buildings in urban Class-A office building serves as The a master plan for 15 million square Experience_Evaluation Criteria 3C space. B+S is currently working on a designed 113 Class “A” and Class “B” destinations (and the accompanying settings with structured parking. Provide a minimum of five projects with Wharf’s main gateway. The building’s feet of Class A office space, the bulk TOD project located directly adjacent mid-rise and high-rise office buildings amenities) are the most desirable references. Preference will be given in pedestrian scaled street wall provides of that is near completion today. Our to the new Culver City Expo in urban settings with structured locations. However, these destinations scoring to those office buildings that have a civic presence that complements plan for Harbor Point in Stamford, CT Robertson Station in Los Angeles. parking. Below is a list of completed, require office buildings to play a larger been successfully completed. Provide grand boulevards and recognizable has been the only continuously This mixed-use development provides urban projects of similar nature and role in placemaking - Street entry, written and graphic descriptions along architecture. Retail space has been running construction project in the 144 residential units, 75,000 square scope. 1. 2525 Ponce de Leon ground floor retail, appropriate urban with any photographs of these projects. POINTS VALUE 5 allotted for all sides, while the flow in state since 2008 and features feet of creative commercial space, Boulevard, Coral Gables, FloridaThis facades that define streets and open and around the building introduces an waterfront Class B offices. In St. 460 parking spaces and 40,000 12-story, 250,000 SF Class “A“ office spaces, and special architectural active community. Mayo Clinic Petersburg, FL our work at Tropicana square feet of retail space on the building responds to its Mediterranean elements to reinforce the urban design Destination Medical Center Field is a vision for a Sports and street level connecting directly to the Revival style neighborhood. The office are important elements to consider. (Rochester, Minnesota): Reshaping Entertainment District where the station. Please see Supplementary building includes a 906-space parking Two recent urban office buildings the character and long term economic parking for a ballpark is shared with Information-office for images and deck and an existing bank office designed by TG+P include Clarendon health of Rochester, the master plan Class A and Class B offices to cut further information.Close to building.2. Centergy Mixed-Use Center across the street from the transformed the downtown skyline and costs. In Houston, we designed a mid- everywhere you want to be, the offices Development, Atlanta, GeorgiaThis Clarendon light rail station and streetscape into a destination city. rise Class A office building for Interfin, within this master plan could offer a mixed-use complex has over 2 million Clarendon Central Park that has With a 20-year multi-phase plan that is set to become offices for energy culture to recruit, engage and retain SF of Class “A” office and retail space ground floor restaurants and the market-driven and flexible, the design investors. At the American Tobacco the best. The sidewalks bustle with on a 12.5 acre site. This first phase Mourant Office Building at Camana positioned DMC to embrace and Campus in Durham, NC we have activity from the street-level retail with includes two office buildings at Bay that anchors the main plaza with leverage the evolving characteristics, designed, with Hines Development, a modern upscale dining, a comfortable 730,000 SF, 55,000 SF of street level ground floor retail. Other urban office demographics and development Class B office building atop structured pub, classic coffee shops and more. retail and a 1,500 space parking buildings include the 530,000 SF opportunities of its hometown. Harbor parking that will share parking with The offices are adjacent from a world- garage. 3. Mixed-Use Arlington Courthouse Plaza (pair of Point Square (Stamford, Connecticut): their minor league ballpark, home to class combination of amenities for Development, Atlanta, GeorgiaThis buildings) with theater and retail at the Incorporating smart growth and the Durham Bulls. health and wellness, entertainment, vertically-stacked mixed use tower Courthouse light rail station, the 12­ transit-oriented development dining, and business—all in one consists of 509,000 SF of Class “A” story 277,000 SF Artery Plaza in concepts, Harbor Point is one of the remarkable setting. The office floor Office space, with 82 luxury high-rise downtown Bethesda that creates an first projects to qualify for the plans accommodate the work needs residences located above the office urban plaza along Wisconsin Avenue, USGBC’s LEED for Neighborhood of every type of business from a floors. The project includes 23,000 SF and 1515 Courthouse with ground Development pilot program. The Fortune 500 financial services firm to of street level retail and a 1,600-space floor retail and pocket park. Please mixed use development has 4,000 a 5-person creative services group. parking deck.4. One , see the project sheets in the attached residences, 400,000 sf of retail space, Tenants and residents will be Atlanta, GeorgiaThis 20-story tower PDF with the file name Supplemental nearly 350,000 sf of office space, a empowered to work where they live offers 580,000 SF of prime Class “A” Information_Office hotel and spa, 16 acres of parks, and and live where they work to whatever office. Designed as the initial phase of Buildings_Evaluation Criteria 3C. more than a mile of shoreline and degree they choose. And for those the 1.8 million SF mixed use Alliance harbor access. Paseo Colorado who still need to come into the office, Center master plan, the project (Pasadena, CA): The team’s plan it’s important that they be greeted by features a 1,586-space parking turned the mixed-use district inside more than a water cooler and a deck.5. Hearst Tower, Charlotte, out, knitting the new development standard fitness center in the North CarolinaThis striking 47-story back into the downtown street grid basement. It’s no secret that the office tower links to an existing sky- and re-establishing the central axis. traditional office park is losing out as bridge network connecting it to the By introducing a mix of offices, corporate tenants looking to recruit adjacent 60-story Bank America

PNC2116748P1 Page 20 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. hospitality, retail, and residential fresh new talent gravitate toward Corporate Center building and the above the existing retail, the design dynamic, amenity-rich urban cores. If companion 30-story IJL Corporate reused much of the mall’s existing they can find what they’re looking for Headquarters building, also designed structure. WeWork WeLive Crystal in the suburbs where the costs are by SRSS. In addition, the project City (Arlington, VA): Blending co- less, the chance for success is high. includes a 1,500-space parking working and co-living concepts into a Residents live above shops and deck.6. Ally Center, Charlotte, North single setting, the project embodies restaurants with access to a central CarolinaAlly Center is a 15-story office the client’s mission by offering an plaza and quality transit connections. building with ground level retail and environment for residents to share shares a 1,201-space parking deck space and collaborate. To support this with the Catalyst residential project, approach, traditional apartment living also designed by SRSS. is supported by office space, a chef’s kitchen, dining areas, laundry arcade and media lounge to create a sense of community and connect the residents. See supplemental information for additional project details.

PNC2116748P1 Page 21 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. D. Describe the firm’s experience in 1000 Ocean (Boca Raton, Florida): Our master plan for Museum Park See attachment: Supplemental Our Multi-Family practice utilities a Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, TG+P has extensive multi-family designing mid-rise and high-rise Design of the residences showcases a Miami included five high-rise multi­ Information_Residential broad range of housing types, ranging Stewart & Associates (SRSS) has experience having designed and built multifamily residential buildings in urban unique nautilus shaped 7-story family residential buildings which front Experience_Evaluation Criteria 3D from attached on-grade townhouses designed 130 mid-rise and high-rise over 485,000 multi-family dwelling settings with structured parking. Provide a minimum of five projects with building. The residential development on Biscayne Boulevard and along the to 20-story high-rise apartment multifamily residential buildings in units ranging from low-rise to mid-rise references. Preference will be given in includes 52 luxury units with private new waterfront park that is home to buildings. The goal is to respond to urban settings with structured parking, to high-rise buildings. Almost all of our scoring to those multifamily residential terraces, an amenity sundeck two museums and the arena for the the growing need for urban in-fill including projects with affordable multi-family buildings in the last two buildings that have been successfully featuring a resort style pool, private Miami Heat. At the American Tobacco apartments and condo units. Resident housing. Below is a list of completed decades have been urban buildings completed as well as those multifamily cabanas and lounging terraces, an Campus in Durham, NC our mixed profiles were created to determine the and occupied projects. Please see the with structured parking. This includes residential buildings that have included a work force housing component. Provide underground parking system and use plan features two mid-rise demographic most likely served in this attached pdfs for additional all methods of construction, so we written and graphic descriptions along rooftop gardens. The Bristol Palm residential apartment buildings to be area, and to inspire indoor and information. 1. Icon Harbour Island, understand the construction and with any photographs of these projects. Beach (West Palm Beach, Florida): built as stick construction over a outdoor amenities and experiences Tampa Bay, FL - A 21-story high-rise development economics, as wells as POINTS VALUE 5 Redefining luxury urban living, design concrete parking deck. In Stamford, that will appeal to this user group. with 340 residential units. An elevated the nuances of each of the various of the twenty-five story waterfront CT our plan for Harbor Point included Community as Amenity: We view end pedestrian walkway provides an types. Not only do we understand the condominium and surrounding spaces 12 mid- to high-rise multi family users as ‘guests.’ As such we view the enclosed, conditioned connection to typical multi-family buildings types, but integrates high-finish hardscape buildings that defined new public community as an amenity. The new structured parking. Includes a 1,650 we have invented new multi-family materials, tailored landscapes and parks and a new waterfront model is about weaving the buildings SF fitness center, private dining facility building types for our developer clients streamlined water features for visual destination for the town. In our into the fabric of the local with kitchen, club lounge, and media to solve various design problems such interest and a comfortable scale redevelopment plan for Tropicana surroundings, encouraging guests to lounge.2. Sovereign, Atlanta, GA – A as a Charleston Multi-Family building throughout the entry drive, landscape Field in St Petersburg, FL we have explore their neighborhood and high-rise featuring 82 residences in a type to both meet a more diverse terraces, outdoor gardens, and the incorporated low, mid- and high-rise providing access to a broader mixed-use tower in Buckhead along market segment and work as a scale public waterfront promenade. With the residential that spans from affordable spectrum of services and offerings. with retail, office and structured transition, a Liner Townhouse to goal of creating an energy efficient, to luxury housing markets in a plan This is where a strategically balanced parking. Amenities include a pool, club screen above grade garages, a healthy community that positively that knits together many diverse mixed-use development can be key to room, conference room, guest suite, “wedding cake” multi-family building impacts the environment, the neighborhoods. In Washington, DC leasing strategies. Developers are no art gallery and wine storage room. 3. type that creates liners for an above development will be LEED Silver our master plan for development in longer renting square footage, they Icon Midtown, Atlanta, GA – A 39­ grade garage on the lower floors and certified. WeWork WeLive Crystal City support of the Nationals Ballpark led are leasing experiences — whether it story tower with 389 units above a tower on top of the garage (such as (Arlington, VA): Blending the concepts to 12 city blocks of mid-rise residential be the hip restaurant a few blocks structured parking. Amenities include Rockville Town Center in MD and the of co-working and co-living in a single buildings that respond to the height away, concerts in the park, farmer’s a fitness center, pool/garden terrace Aertson in Nashville, TN) as well as setting, the project embodies the restrictions Washington DC. markets, or a mix of retail that takes and club venue. The ground floor many others. Please see the attached client’s central concepts and mission care of all your shopping includes retail shops. 4. SkyHouse PDF for examples including Arlington by offering an environment for needs.Parking that Creates Visitor Program, Various Locations, United East, Park Van Ness, Notch8, The residents to share space and Memories: At Santana Row, we States –18 projects, each in a Bartlett, Met Park, City Vista, The collaborate. To support this approach, designed an elegant public parking metropolitan area and featuring a Swift, and Pacific Beacon. Please see traditional apartment living is solution that provides an easy-to-use, high-rise residential tower with ground the project sheets in the attached PDF supported by dynamic common areas well-lit, safe environment, which level retail and adjacent parking deck. with the file name Supplemental — a chef’s kitchen, dining areas, moves the visitor through a broad Project amenities include a swimming Information_High Rise laundry arcade, media lounge — to aperture marked by grand stairways, pool, fitness center, yoga studio and Multifamily_Evaluation Criteria 3D. create a sense of community and public artwork, and internally-facing club room.5. Catalyst (Part of Ally), connect the residents. 90Ninety Way retail and restaurants. This approach Charlotte, NC –A 27-story tower with (Jamaica, New York): Perkins expands the retail street-frontage, and 462 apartments, ground level retail Eastman develop the design for a creates additional highly valuable and a Structured Parking. Amenities 624,000-sf mixed-use development to corner tenant conditions in what would include a media room, fitness center,

PNC2116748P1 Page 22 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. include sustainable housing that offers otherwise be a typical mid-block clubroom, outdoor swimming pool and a range of affordability in 525 units, condition. Brooks + Scarpa has grilling area. 6. Twelve Centennial including 105 affordable units for completed over 10,000 units of Park, Atlanta, GA – Mixed-use project artists of the Greater Jamaica housing of every type that have with 2 phased, 33-story, 517-unit Development Corporation. Centered included structured parking. In condominium towers over structured around a recreation of the de-mapped particular we have completed or have parking with a 100-key hotel. 20% of portion of 91st, 90NINETY is designed worked on dozens of publicly funded the residences at TWELVE Centennial to activate 75,000 sf of retail through affordable housing projects for such Park were designed to be affordable increased street frontage, pedestrian organizations as The Skid Row units to those who qualify through a realms and flexible spaces for Housing Trust, Community special program. 7. Viridian, Nashville, community amenities. Corporation, Venice Community TN - A 31-story, 552,000-SF, 305-unit Housing, West Hollywood Community condominium tower over structured Housing, Coacella Valley Housing parking. Project includes 45 units set Coalition, Step Up, Forrest aside as affordable housing. City/Rattner, The Related Companies, Amenities include a clubroom bar and and The Athens Group. roof-top pool.

PNC2116748P1 Page 23 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. E. Describe the firm’s experience in Flushing Commons (Flushing, NY): As We have designed many mixed-use See attachment: Supplemental Our Mixed-Use practice focuses on SRSS has designed 46 residential Retail enhances the overall desirability designing retail space in the ground floors part of a developer-led joint venture, master plans with retail ground floors Information_Retail transforming neighborhoods to include projects with ground-floor retail and 49 of a community, but it is also the most of residential and office buildings. Priority Perkins Eastman designed a mixed- with both residential and commercial Experience_Evaluation Criteria 3E the convenience of localized offices with ground-floor retail. Below competitive and most sensitive to will be given in scoring to those retail spaces that have been successfully use development that includes uses above, most recently at the amenities, community gathering is a list of completed, urban projects of location and configuration. Despite the completed. Provide written and graphic 460,000 sf of commercial retail and American Tobacco Campus in spaces, retail, fine and dining facilities. similar nature and scope. Pdfs are rise in on-line retail sales, significant descriptions along with any photographs office space, 700,000 sf of market-rate Durham, NC where the retail weaves A vibrant community adapted to attached to provide descriptions and opportunities remain, especially for of these projects. residential space consisting of together different uses and open today’s active lifestyles. A pedestrian photographs. 1. Buckhead Atlanta, well-designed experiential POINTS VALUE 5 approximately 700 condominiums, spaces throughout the project. At promenade navigates through the Atlanta, GeorgiaThis phased mixed- destinations that serve as gathering 90,000 sf of community facility space, Hudson Yards in NYC, ground floor resort capturing a diverse range of use development has re-invigorated a places for a community. This requires open public space, and parking for retail is prominently laid out to activate outdoor experiences and connecting premier entertainment and retail a detailed understanding of the role of 1,600 vehicles. The vision for the streets and parks in both commercial the resort’s most dramatic points district. SRSS served as Architect-of- programming, tenant mix, open space development consists of four buildings and residential district; the project is within a distinct hospitality and Record for the project. Parcel A design, the interface of buildings, and placed around a central green near completion. Our plan in Chula residential infrastructure. The design includes class “A” office space the branding of a place. TG+P has supported by plazas, gardens and Vista, CA for the Port of San Diego is represents a careful balance between housing Spanx Corporation, retail significant experience in creating water features.La Plaza Del Barrio predominantly residential with ground existing natural and man-made suites, restaurants and outdoor dining these types of places and brings to (New York, NY): Perkins Eastman floor retail throughout, leading to the surroundings; brings together terraces in 5 separate structures bear our Placemaking Studio. Our developed a design concept for a Bayfront and sharing structured residential and street-level retail to constructed over a base containing 4 experience ranges from large Lifestyle 700+ unit affordable housing project parking with surrounding uses. The create a focal point within this bustling below-grade parking levels. Parcel C Retail Centers to Main Streets to for the NYC Department of Housing redevelopment plan for Tropicana area of a city. Activate Main Street: includes street level retail suites and 2 Urban Retail Districts to Neighborhood Preservation and Development that Field in St Petersburg, FL creates a We advocate lining the project’s main high rise residential towers over a Centers to mixed-use buildings with included school, commercial and destination retail experience street with regionally-driven base containing below-grade and grocery stores and in-line retail. Some community facilities. The holistically connecting the ballpark to surrounding storefronts, cafes and restaurants. We above-grade parking.2. Ally Center, examples include Arlington East at planned community focused on neighborhoods on typical city blocks look forward to investigating the Charlotte, North CarolinaAlly Center Bethesda Row in MD, City Vista in community facilities, and an with both housing and commercial possibility of generating outstanding with its 15 stories of 393,000 SF of Washington, DC, Shirlington Arlington, abundance of accessible open space development above sharing structured exposure and non-traditional tenancy stunning glass and steel, stands out VA, Clarendon Center in Arlington, both at grade and on various roof parking. Our plan for the Nationals depths, hip brands and locally among the buildings in the Uptown VA, The Swift in Washington, DC and, setbacks. See supplemental Ballpark in Washington DC creates a significant food and beverage outlets, skyline. Onsite retail includes a currently in the construction document information for additional project retail corridor between transit and the grounding the main street in the sundries shop, dry cleaning services phase, The Parks at Historic Walter details. ballpark, on mixed-use development agriculture, artistry and food culture of and 3 restaurants.3. Centergy at Reed in Washington, DC. At a more blocks having commercial and the island.Livened Up Public Spaces: Technology Square, Atlanta, practical level, since we create retail residential development above. Our Dead spaces are a thing of the past GeorgiaCentergy at Technology architecture, we also understand the retail plan for Harbor Point was and we have turned attention to alleys Square, the first phase of the specific needs of retail ranging from specifically sized and tailored to the and other public spaces. In a Centergy Global Innovation Center, is typical building depth, loading local residential market and not to beneficial blending of design a mixed-use complex planned with requirements by type of retail, trash compete with Downtown Stamford. disciplines, residential and urban over 2 million SF of class A office and requirements by type of retail (for design are taking a clue from retail. An 8-story parking garage example the need for refrigerated hospitality and integrating food and connects to the 2 office buildings and trash for some food related beverage, varied seating 55,000 SF of street-level retail space businesses, and venting requirements arrangements with views to the rounds out the first phase.4. 3344 for restaurants in mixed-use outside and a general blurring of the Peachtree, Atlanta, GeorgiaThis buildings). The majority of our lines between public and private to vertically stacked mixed-use tower residential and office buildings promote chance encounters and consists of 309,000 SF of luxury high- designed over the past two decades

PNC2116748P1 Page 24 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. socialization.Be Famous for rise residences (82) located above have retail on the ground floor. Please Something: In our retail, mixed-use 509,000 SF of Class “A” Office space. see the project sheets in the attached and hospitality design and planning In addition, the project includes PDF with the file name Supplemental work, SB Architects promotes the idea 23,000 SF of street level retail and a Information_Retail_Evaluation Criteria of scripting the ways the client 1,600-space parking deck. 5. The 3E. envisions the property being used. We Brookwood, Atlanta, GeorgiaLocated call this process, and its end result, in midtown Atlanta, this 19-story, “being known” or “being famous” for 430,000 SF condominium tower offers something. This is generally seen as a scenic views, 20,000 SF of street-level marketing or branding exercise, and it retail and an abundance of amenities. is. However, this thought process is The 275-unit Brookwood creates a equally valid as an important tool live-work-play environment that helps during the conceptual planning and to further enhance the new trend of in- design process. town living.

PNC2116748P1 Page 25 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. 4. Lead Architect's/Planner’s Portfolio & Our previous team collaborations and Principal-in-Charge, Jonie Fu, and See attachment: Supplemental SB Architects is widely known for its Charles (Chuck) Hull, AIA has 37 Please see the portfolio for our Lead Profile: Max Number of Points 25 synergies allow us to focus on Urban Design Principal, Randy Information_Lead Planner architecturalwork in the hospitality, years of experience in the Master Architect/Planner included in this If the Lead Architect/Planner is an creativity. EDSA - Master Morton, have a combined 60 years of Portfolio_Evaluation Criteria 4 mixed-use, urban design Planning, Design, and Project submission with the file name individual, then the portfolio must include at least three urban mixed-use site Planning/Landscape experience in design and planning. andresidential space. Since 1960, the Management of multifamily, Supplemental Information_Lead planning projects done by the lead ArchitectureBluewaters Island, : Together they have led many firm has promotedsustainable hospitality, office, and mixed use Architect_Planner Portfolio_Evaluation designer over the past ten years (each $1.6 billion destination has retail, challenging and transformational communities and iconic brands, both developments. The primary focus of Criteria 4A. project should identify his or her specific residential, hospitality and projects. While Partners at Cooper locallyand globally. With offices in San his career has been design. He has a role) and at least five completed urban entertainment.BB&T Center, Sunrise: Robertson and co-heads for the Urban Francisco, Miamiand Hong Kong, we great interest in architectural history mixed-use planning projects done by his or her firm over the past ten years. Each The design organizes traffic for 7,000 Design Studio, they led the master provide responsive, creative and has worked in a broad range of example must include the images and text cars and creates a landscaped planning for Hudson Yards in New andtailored experiences and the design styles, drawing on the lessons description. The portfolio must also pedestrian enclave.Perkins Eastman – York City, National Ballpark District in technical capabilities tosuccessfully of the great architecture of the past to include a designer profile noting such Master Planning/Architecture Target Washington DC, Harbor Point in deliver projects of all scales from create contextually appropriate facts as education, professional Field Station, Minneapolis: TOD with Stamford, CT, Museum Park in Miami, initialconcept through construction. contemporary buildings rich in detail experience, design recognitions, and areas of responsibility and a statement of the year-round public space connects 500 and Alexandria Small Area Plan in Everything we do isinformed by and spatial experiences. Chuck lead designer’s philosophy and design trains and 1,900 daily bus trips.Circle Alexandria, VA. They worked side by principles which are inspired by believes that every building project intent that incorporates an understanding Centre Mall, Indianapolis: side to achieve design excellence and timelessvalues and a commitment to should develop from its unique of the design issues for the proposed Incorporates a pedestrian street, built lasting relationships with our craft.Our approach is founded on situation, the possibilities inherent in project and a philosophy for approaching retail, cinemas, hotel and colleagues and clients. Jonie’s a commitment to designexcellence the program, and the goals of the the project. If the Lead Architect/Planner is a team, Artsgarden.Kimley-Horn – Civil/Traffic portfolio includes many arena master and is characterized by a client.Chuck earned his Master of then the portfolio must include at least two Engineering Brickell City Centre, plans in cities such as Cleveland, collaborativedialogue between the Architecture and his Bachelor in completed projects per discipline done Miami: $1.05 billion project has retail, Sacramento, Vancouver, Winnipeg, client and design partners. Inthe Architecture from the Georgia Institute over the past ten years by each of the lead office, residential and and Recife. Since starting her own design process, the site, the regional of Technology. He is a Registered designers on the team and representing entertainment.Miami World Center, studio in 2014, Jonie completed architecturalhistory, culture, and Architect in the State of Florida. Chuck the firm, a selection of at least five additional completed projects done over Miami: The 20+ acres development Mellon’s Orchard Strategic Plan and traditions are equally is active in the industry and speaks at the past ten years. Each example must includes retail, residential, office and Enright Park Master Plan both in important.Whether the eventual conferences and is a member of the include images and text description. The institutional uses.Atelier Ten – Pittsburgh, PA. Mellon’s Orchard was design solution is traditional American Institute of Architects. portfolio must also include a lead designer Environmental a city-owned site that needed re- orcontemporary, it should be culturally profile that summarizes the background of Design/EngineeringAssembly Square, imagining due to the pressure of and contextuallyrelevant.At the all team members and a design philosophy and design intent statement that Somerville: The 65-acre TOD consists adjacent developments, transit cornerstone of our design philosophy represents the perspective of the team as of office, residential, retail and subway improvements, and its isolated and is a focuson collaboration with an a whole. stop.Buffalo Canal Side Development, underutilized nature. The design intent openness to new ideas andcreative A. Lead Architect’s/Planner's Portfolio ­ Buffalo: Commercial, cultural and was to weave the site into the existing interpretation. Our mission is to not The portfolio should be thoughtfully residential spaces with interpretive city fabric, increase the density and only createalluring and successful arranged and composed of materials that demonstrate an understanding of the features, towpaths and public mix of uses, and enhance the open projects but also nurture theshared design issues to be addressed in this areas.Nelson Nygaard - Mobility space connections. Working with the passion and vision that allow for a project. The exhibits should portray Transit, AccessibilityLincoln Yards, community, the design team brought rewardingjourney for the entire team. creative and appropriate response to Chicago: The project addressed open back the celebrated East Liberty We believe that hospitalityis founded County’s criteria and needs, demonstrate space, river access, street network Farmers’ Market and implemented the on the cultivation of strong design leadership, and clearly exemplify design excellence. and mixed-use offerings. Destination first Live/Work zoning text in the area. relationshipswith each other, our POINTS VALUE 15 Medical Center, Rochester: The 20­ Getting it right for Mellon’s Orchard clients, our partners, and year, $1.2 billion transportation required skills in working with policy­ ourcommunities. Architecture is not investment strategy catalyzes $5 makers and city agencies, building only about buildings,design, products,

PNC2116748P1 Page 26 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. billion in economic consensus with the community, and standards, and efficiencies – it is development.Machete Group – collaborating with transpiration and aboutpeople. It is the very heart of Strategic OperationsWestfield parking planners (who had proposed a hospitality, as people arethe very Promenade, Woodland Hills: Lifestyle different plan) in addition to center of our business. community with office, entertainment, inventiveness, creativity and housing, dining and shopping.Chase innovation. Randy Morton has served Center, San Francisco: Destination public and private sector clients for with championship sports team, more than 30 years seamlessly culinary scene, retail and office space integrating urban form, architecture, for innovative companies.Lambert landscape, and infrastructure to create Advisory – Real Estate and Economic environmentally sensitive and AdvisoryMLS Stadium, Miami: memorable places. From 2011 to Proposed development of a 25,000­ spring of 2018, Randy oversaw the seat stadium, office, retail, hotel and HKS Urban Design Studio. During that entertainment with $1 billion time, he completed the Broward budget.Airport City, Miami: Proposed County Convention Center Expansion 1,000+ parking spaces for retail, office and Hotel Development Plan. Other and hotel complex on 32 acres.See relevant experiences include Atlanta supplemental information. Brav

PNC2116748P1 Page 27 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. B. Lead Architect's/Planner's Profile - The EDSA: Landscape architects and Jonie Fu has provided design and Full Lead Lead Planner portfolio Mark S. Sopp/SB Architects - With Charles (Chuck) Hull, AIA has over Unique to most of the profession, the County will be looking for a breadth and urban designers providing land planning leadership for award-winning including education and responsibility more than 25 years of international thirty years of experience in the partners of the firm share a common depth of education and work experience as planning and programming, landscape projects for 25 years before founding is listed under Supplemental and domestic mixed-use and Master Planning, Design, and Project design philosophy that is integral to all well as increasing responsibility for delivering the complexity and magnitude architectural design, production and her own studio. Previously, she was a Information_Lead Planner hospitalitymaster planning, conceptual Management of multifamily, of the work that we do. This is codified of the project the County has in mind. field supervision. We produce livable, Partner and co-head of the Urban Portfolio_Evaluation Criteria 4 design and project management hospitality, office, and mixed use in the firm’s Design Charter, which is a POINTS VALUE 10 memorable environments and Design Studio at Cooper Robertson experience, Mark Sopp has an acute developments. The primary focus of written set of principles on consistently elicit best practice from from 1996 to 2011 and Director of understanding of business operations his career has been design. He has a Architecture, Urbanism, Social multidisciplinary project teams. Urban Design at AECOM from 2011 to and innovative design principles. He great interest in architectural history Justice, and Sustainability – This is Perkins Eastman: . The firm is 2104. Believing that every city is works with developers and design and has worked in a broad range of something that all of the partners have composed of architects, interior unique and every place distinctive, teams to lead projects through a design styles, drawing on the lessons developed together and have signed ­ designers, construction experts, Jonie is interested in understanding coordinated process to ensure the end of the great architecture of the past to a copy is attached with file name environmental analysts, resiliency and the physical design challenge of a product reflects the client’s goals and create contextually appropriate Supplemental Information_TGP other key experts. We design for a place and its context and above all the vision. As the former Director of the contemporary buildings rich in detail Design Charter_Evaluation Criteria sustainable and resilient future, and to lasting relationship between people Retail and Mixed-Use Studio at and spatial experiences. Chuck 4B. The following beliefs are central to enhance the human experience and places. She is accustomed to Callison, he was the lead designer for believes that every building project our practice and inform all projects, through the built environment Kimley- leading teams of engineers, real the Ala Moana Center expansion and should develop from its unique regardless of their scale or density:1. Horn: Our multidisciplinary consulting estate consultants, landscape the revitalization of the Royal situation, the possibilities inherent in The belief in a broad starting point, firm offers a broad range of architects to work collaboratively on Hawaiian Center, which won the 2008 the program, and the goals of the called the “Spectrum”—a 360-degree engineering and environmental complex issues and creative solutions. Honolulu AIA Merit Award. Shanghai’s client.Chuck earned his Master of approach to the design task that services. We understand zoning, Jonie works with public and private mixed-use Grand Gateway Architecture and his Bachelor in simultaneously considers nature, the mixed-use development, sector clients to re-imagine development and the Ayala Center Architecture from the Georgia Institute built environment, and people (please transportation plans, shared parking neighborhoods refine new Greenbelt in - winner of the of Technology. He is a Registered see attached).2. The understanding and design standards for mixed-use environments, and in particular, 2003 ULI Award of Excellence design Architect in the State of Florida. Chuck that urban design informs urban environments.Atelier Ten: We revitalization of secondary American direction. is active in the industry and speaks at architecture.3. The conviction that deliver sustainable, resilient projects cities. Practicing with big firm conferences and is a member of the cities must have a great public realm, in a range of scales and sectors. We experience but in a small firm culture American Institute of Architects. He is a vital mix of uses, diverse explore sustainable strategies and by choice, Jonie’s most recently a Principal of SRSS and has many populations, and strong connections, analyze opportunities that are completed urban design projects are responsibilities on his projects. locally and regionally.4. The belief that sensitive to capital, operational costs for the City of Pittsburgh Department Depending on the particular role he is architecture must connect and be and schedule. We produce climate- of Planning and for the Urban serving on each project, his duties appropriate to the character of the responsive design and high- Redevelopment Authority also in may include the following: developing place and not be self-conscious.5. performance architecture.Nelson Pittsburgh. Jonie has a degree in an overall project design budget, The recognition that design is a Nygaard: We develop transportation Master of Architecture and Urban schedule and staffing guidelines, continuum and that the design must systems that promote vibrant, Design from Columbia University and reviewing design recommendations find a place to connect to when sustainable and accessible a Bachelor of Architecture degree and construction documents, coming to a place and leave a place of communities. Our consensus-based from the University of Southern evaluating work progress, supervision connection for the next designer.6. plans are renowned as practical and California. She speaks regularly on of financial management, The commitment to design with implementable serving as platforms city-making and place-making, mostly incorporating all required consultants, multiple stakeholders in mind: the for achieving mobility, equity, recently at the New American City specialists and services into a client, the community, and the city.7. economic development and healthy Conference hosted by New York cohesive project team and managing The knowledge that people complete living. Machete Group: We provide University. the design portion of the project. the places they inhabit, as the places strategic and advisory operational shape their inhabitants’ lives.The Lead

PNC2116748P1 Page 28 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. services to clients in sports, Designers for the BB&T project would entertainment, retail and real estate be:John Francis Torti, FAIA, Principal­ development. The team has extensive in-ChargeErik J. Aulestia, AICP, knowledge of complex customer- Project Manager/Principal facing operations and venue PlannerJohn has extensive development, due diligence and experience developing complex urban organizational strategy. Lambert mixed-use master plans and mixed- Advisory: We are an internationally use buildings and Erik has extensive recognized real estate and economic experience in developing complex advisory firm. Established on a mixed-use master plans and foundation of knowledge, data, and implementation tools, such as form- experience, Lambert works based codes and guidelines. Please collaboratively with clients and see the resumes for our Lead partners to transform places and build Architect/Planner included in this stronger communities. See submission with the file name supplemental information for detailed Supplemental Information_Lead team profiles. Architect_Planner Resumes_Evaluation Criteria 4B. 5. Location: Max Number of Points 5 EDSA is based in Fort Lauderdale, The lead architect/planner, Fu Perkins+Will is located at 2800 Ponce N/A Vendor does not meet local Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Included in this submission is the Refer to Vendor’s Business Location Florida located in Broward County as Wilmers Design | Architecture + De Leon Blvd. in Coral Gables, Florida business requirements Stewart & Associates, Inc. is located completed Vendor's Business Attestation Form and submit as instructed. noted on the Location Attestation Urbanism, is located in New York City, as noted in the Vendor's Business in Atlanta, Georgia. Location Attestation Form. A Vendor with a principal place of business location (also known as the Form. as is Pinstripe, our development Location Attestation Form. nerve center) within Broward County for advisor. Other team members Kimley- the last six months, prior to the solicitation Horn, Thompson Associates, and submittal, will receive five points; a Vendor Garth Solutions are located in not meeting all of the local business Broward County, bringing on-board requirements will receive zero points. The following applies for a Vendor responding the best combination of national as a Joint Venture (JV): if a member of the expertise and local knowledge. JV has 51% or more of the equity and meets all of the local business requirements, the JV will receive three points; if a member of the JV has 30 to 50% of the equity and meets all of the local business requirements, the JV will receive two points; and if a member of the JV has 10% to 29% of the equity and meets all of the local business requirements, the JV will receive one point. POINTS VALUE 5

PNC2116748P1 Page 29 RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning

Vendor Name EDSA, Inc. Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + Perkins+Will SB Architects Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc. Urbanism Stewart & Associates, Inc. 6. Willingness to Meet Time and Budget The EDSA team is willing to meet time Fu Wilmers Design | Architecture + YES Yes to time and budget requirements Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Torti Gallas is willing to meet the time Requirements: and budget requirements as detailed Urbanism is proud of our project Stewart & Associates, Inc. is willing to and budget requirements of this Completion Date Requirement: Six (6) in Solicitation PNC2116748P1. management capabilities. Project meet the time and budget contract. Months YES = 1 Point NO = 0 Points schedule and budget is established requirements. Project Budget: $350,000 with client input at the beginning of YES = 1 Point NO = 0 Points every assignment in our office. We Points Value: 2 conduct monthly project management report to track project progress against schedule and budget. We take schedule and budget seriously and are able and willing to meet the six months time frame and the $350,000 budget requirement. 7. Volume of Previous Work: Neither EDSA or any of the team's Fu Wilmers Design |Architecture + Perkins+Will has been paid $0 as N/A Vendor has not completed any Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Included as part of this submission is Refer to Volume of Previous Work sub-consultants have worked for Urbanism has not contracted with noted in the Previous Work Attestation previous work or work as a Joint Stewart & Associates, Inc. has not the completed Volume of Previous Attestation Form and the Volume of Broward County within the past five Broward County previously and Form. venture for or in Broward County worked with Broward County. Work Attestation Form. Previous Work Attestation Joint Venture Form and submit as instructed. years as verified on the Volume of therefore the volume of previous work The calculation for Volume of Previous Previous Work Attestation Form. paid by Broward County is $0. Work is all amounts paid to the prime Vendor by Broward County Board of County Commissioners at the time of the solicitation opening date within a five-year timeframe. The calculation of Volume of Previous Work for a prime Vendor previously awarded a contract as a member of a Joint Venture firm is based on the actual equity ownership of the Joint Venture firm. Three points will be allocated to Vendors paid $0 - $3,000,000); 2 Points will be allocated to Vendors paid $3,000,001 - $7,500,000; 1 Point will be allocated to Vendors paid $7,500,001 ­ $10,000,000; 0 Points will be allocated to Vendors paid over $10,000,000). Payments for prime Vendor will be verified by the Purchasing Division. Points Value: 3

PNC2116748P1 Page 30 Broward County Board of PNC2116748P1 County Commissioners

Evaluation Criteria Response Form

The completed Evaluation Criteria Response Form should be returned with Vendor’s submittal. If not provided with submittal, the Vendor must submit within three business days of County’s request. Failure to timely submit may affect Vendor’s evaluation or deem vendor non-responsible.

Evaluation Criteria Response Form: The responding vendor must complete the Evaluation Criteria Response Form (pdf fillable file) with responses corresponding to each numbered item in text format only. Each Evaluation Criteria response should be succinct and include only relevant information which best answers the item. Do not include graphs, charts, resumes, tables, pictures, etc., in the Evaluation Criteria Response Form. Each Evaluation Criteria response allows for a maximum of 2100 characters of text only.

Instructions for uploading: Download document, save as the pdf fillable document (do not save as any other type of document), complete form and upload form as the fillable pdf file. DO NOT APPLY ANY TYPE OF SECURITY, ALTER OR OTHERWISE MANIPULATE THE DOCUMENT. DO NOT PRINT TO PDF OR SCAN DOCUMENT BEFORE UPLOADING TO BIDSYNC.

Evaluation Criteria Response Form (Supplemental Information): If the Vendor’s evaluation criteria response needs to reference additional Information to supplement their response to an item such as graphs, resumes, tables, org charts, etc., include only the supplemental information as an attachment appropriately labeled as follows: Supplemental Information - Title - Evaluation Criteria Item Number (ex. Supplemental Information - Resume John Doe – Evaluation Criteria 1b.) The Supplemental Information should be uploaded to BidSync as separate pdf files (attachments) and not combined with the vendor’s completed Evaluation Criteria Response Form.

✔ Check here to indicate that Vendor agrees it has read and will comply with the submission instructions above.

8/9/2018 BidSync p. 41 Broward County Board of PNC2116748P1 County Commissioners

Evaluation Criteria Response Form

RFP/RLI/RFQ Number and Title PNC2116748P1 - BB&T Center Property Master Planning Vendor Name STRANG DESIGN, LLC

2900 SW 28th Terrace STE 301 Vendor Address Miami, FL 33133

Evaluation Criteria Vendor Response

1. Ability of Professional Personnel (Other Than Lead Architect/Planner): Max Number of Points 5 Include resumes for the Project Manager, Lead Architect/Planner and all key staff described. Include the qualifications and relevant experience of all subconsultants’ key staff to be assigned to this project. POINTS VALUE 5

2. Project Approach (Philosophy and Design Intent): Max Number of Points 20 A. Describe the firm’s approach and its familiarity with key issues, conditions and expected challenges. Such as: working around an existing building that may become obsolete within ten years and be demolished; designing pedestrian circulation that is separated from vehicular circulation; complex service issues (trash removal, delivery services for supplies, food, mail, taxi and ride share drop off and pick-up, hotel access and service); and the future need for parking may drastically change due to automated cars. Describe experience and provide specific examples of how you may have dealt with these issues in a phased mixed-use project. POINTS VALUE 4

B. Describe the firm’s experience with phased urban mixed-use projects, specifically addressing how is construction done on future phases so that the impact to present residents, tenants and guests are minimalized. POINTS VALUE 5

C. Describe the firm’s approach and its familiarity in designing for sustainability, resiliency and climate change issues that Broward County must deal with. POINTS VALUE 1

D. How has the firm addressed pedestrian circulation in sub-tropical climates? POINTS VALUE 1

E. Describe the firm’s approach to design that helps create better health and wellness for its residents, tenants and guests. POINTS VALUE 1

8/9/2018 BidSync p. 42 Broward County Board of PNC2116748P1 County Commissioners

F. Describe your experience and provide specific examples of a variety of professional planning services related to the implementation of projects identified within an urban mixed-use Master Plan including Economic/Feasibility Planning, Cost Analysis, Facilities Infrastructure Analysis and Evaluations, Parking Analysis (including the future of parking garages with the coming of automated vehicles), and Traffic Analysis. POINTS VALUE 8

3. Past Performance: Max Number of Points 40 A. Describe the firm’s qualifications and relevant experience and provide specific examples of phased urban mixed-use master planning projects that includes at least three of the following mid-rise to high-rise components: Four star or greater hotels; Class “A” to Class “B+” office buildings; multifamily residential buildings; and some retail to support the residential and office tenants. Provide a minimum of five projects with references. Preference in scoring will be given projects of similar nature and scope and to those that have been successfully completed. Suburban mixed-use project where buildings are surrounded by surface parking will not be considered. Provide written and graphic descriptions along with any photographs of these projects. POINTS VALUE 20

B. Describe the firm’s experience in designing Four Star and higher rated mid- rise and high-rise hotels in urban settings with structured parking. Provide a minimum of five projects with references. Preference will be given in scoring to those hotels that have been successfully completed. Provide written and graphic descriptions along with any photographs of these projects. POINTS VALUE 5

C. Describe the firm’s experience in designing Class “A” and Class “B+” mid-rise and high-rise office buildings in urban settings with structured parking. Provide a minimum of five projects with references. Preference will be given in scoring to those office buildings that have been successfully completed. Provide written and graphic descriptions along with any photographs of these projects. POINTS VALUE 5

D. Describe the firm’s experience in designing mid-rise and high-rise multifamily residential buildings in urban settings with structured parking. Provide a minimum of five projects with references. Preference will be given in scoring to those multifamily residential buildings that have been successfully completed as well as those multifamily residential buildings that have included a work force housing component. Provide written and graphic descriptions along with any photographs of these projects. POINTS VALUE 5

E. Describe the firm’s experience in designing retail space in the ground floors of residential and office buildings. Priority will be given in scoring to those retail spaces that have been successfully completed. Provide written and graphic descriptions along with any photographs of these projects. POINTS VALUE 5

8/9/2018 BidSync p. 43 Broward County Board of PNC2116748P1 County Commissioners

4. Lead Architect's/Planner’s Portfolio & Profile: Max Number of Points 25 If the Lead Architect/Planner is an individual, then the portfolio must include at least three urban mixed-use site planning projects done by the lead designer over the past ten years (each project should identify his or her specific role) and at least five completed urban mixed-use planning projects done by his or her firm over the past ten years. Each example must include the images and text description. The portfolio must also include a designer profile noting such facts as education, professional experience, design recognitions, and areas of responsibility and a statement of the lead designer’s philosophy and design intent that incorporates an understanding of the design issues for the proposed project and a philosophy for approaching the project. If the Lead Architect/Planner is a team, then the portfolio must include at least two completed projects per discipline done over the past ten years by each of the lead designers on the team and representing the firm, a selection of at least five additional completed projects done over the past ten years. Each example must include images and text description. The portfolio must also include a lead designer profile that summarizes the background of all team members and a design philosophy and design intent statement that represents the perspective of the team as a whole. A. Lead Architect’s/Planner's Portfolio - The portfolio should be thoughtfully arranged and composed of materials that demonstrate an understanding of the design issues to be addressed in this project. The exhibits should portray creative and appropriate response to County’s criteria and needs, demonstrate design leadership, and clearly exemplify design excellence. POINTS VALUE 15

B. Lead Architect's/Planner's Profile - The County will be looking for a breadth and depth of education and work experience as well as increasing responsibility for delivering the complexity and magnitude of the project the County has in mind. POINTS VALUE 10

5. Location: Max Number of Points 5 STRANG DESIGN, LLC Refer to Vendor’s Business Location Attestation Form and submit as instructed. FORT LAUDERDALE OFFICE A Vendor with a principal place of business location (also known as the nerve 330 N. ANDREWS AVE. STE 102 center) within Broward County for the last six months, prior to the solicitation FORT LAUDERDALE, FL 33301 submittal, will receive five points; a Vendor not meeting all of the local business requirements will receive zero points. The following applies for a Vendor responding as a Joint Venture (JV): if a member of the JV has 51% or more of the equity and meets all of the local business requirements, the JV will receive three points; if a member of the JV has 30 to 50% of the equity and meets all of the local business requirements, the JV will receive two points; and if a member of the JV has 10% to 29% of the equity and meets all of the local business requirements, the JV will receive one point. POINTS VALUE 5

8/9/2018 BidSync p. 44 Broward County Board of PNC2116748P1 County Commissioners

6. Willingness to Meet Time and Budget Requirements: Completion Date Requirement: Six (6) Months YES = 1 Point NO = 0 Points Project Budget: $350,000 YES = 1 Point NO = 0 Points Points Value: 2

7. Volume of Previous Work: Refer to Volume of Previous Work Attestation Form and the Volume of Previous Work Attestation Joint Venture Form and submit as instructed. The calculation for Volume of Previous Work is all amounts paid to the prime Vendor by Broward County Board of County Commissioners at the time of the solicitation opening date within a five-year timeframe. The calculation of Volume of Previous Work for a prime Vendor previously awarded a contract as a member of a Joint Venture firm is based on the actual equity ownership of the Joint Venture firm. Three points will be allocated to Vendors paid $0 ­ $3,000,000); 2 Points will be allocated to Vendors paid $3,000,001 ­ $7,500,000; 1 Point will be allocated to Vendors paid $7,500,001 - $10,000,000; 0 Points will be allocated to Vendors paid over $10,000,000). Payments for prime Vendor will be verified by the Purchasing Division. Points Value: 3

8/9/2018 BidSync p. 45