SG/Inf(2003)15 2 April 2003

Information Documents SG/Inf(2003)15 2 April 2003

————————————————

Alleged political prisoners in Azerbaijan Information on the work of the Secretary General’s Independent Experts in the framework of their second mandate (as from April 2002)

————————————————

Contents

page

Information on the work of the Secretary General’s Independent Experts on cases of alleged political prisoners in Azerbaijan ………………………………….2

A. 1st mandate (2001)………………………………………………………………….2

B. 2nd mandate (as from 2002)………………………………………………………..2

Appendix I: List of 212 cases to be examined by the Independent Experts in the framework of their 2nd mandate…………………………….6

Appendix II: List of 504 cases not to be examined by the Independent Experts in the framework of their 2nd mandate…………………………... 34

Internet : www.coe.int/sg/e/

A. 1st mandate (2001)

1. After Armenia and Azerbaijan became member States of the Council of Europe on 25th January 2001, the Ministers’ Deputies decided to look into cases of alleged political prisoners in both countries. In this context, they approved the Secretary General’s proposal to instruct (at that time) three Independent Experts1 to inquire into cases referred to them. On 18 July 2001, the Secretary General informed the Committee of Ministers that he had received the experts’ report and, in the light of developments in Azerbaijan, decided to make the Experts' report public on 24 October 20012 . Political follow-up to the Independent Experts' report is now being undertaken by the Committee of Ministers and the Parliamentary Assembly.

B. 2nd mandate (as from 2002)

2. In April 2002, two of the three experts, Professor Stefan Trechsel and Professor Evert Alkema, accepted the Secretary General's proposal to resume their task as Independent Experts and to provide opinions on whether or not the remaining group of prisoners in Azerbaijan, out of the list of 716 initially submitted to them in 2001, may be regarded as political prisoners, on the basis of the objective criteria adopted in their first report. This new task is presently being carried out.

3. As the Independent Experts noted discrepancies between information provided by the Azerbaijan authorities and Azerbaijan NGOs as to the number of persons in prison, out of the list of 716, they liaised both with the country’s authorities and the Azeri NGOs concerned, in order to ensure exactly how many cases they must still deal with.

4. In so doing, the Independent Experts decided to examine the Azeri language transcripts of all cases, out of the list of 716, except the following: - cases of persons not detained (released, deceased, repetition of another name); - cases they have already examined3; and - cases with respect to which NGOs were not able to provide additional information indicating that the persons on the list were actually detained (in a situation in which the authorities indicated that the persons on the list were not detained).

1 Mr Stefan Trechsel, Professor of Criminal Law and Procedure at the University of Zurich, Switzerland, and a former member and President of the European Commission of Human Rights; Professor Evert Alkema, member of the Dutch Council of State, and Alexander Arabadjiev, at the time member of the Bulgarian Constitutional Court, both also former members of the European Commission of Human Rights.

2 See documents SG/Inf (2001) 34, SG/Inf (2001) 34 Addendum I and SG/Inf (2001) 34 Addendum II, dated 24 October 2001, also available on the Council of Europe’s Internet Site: www.coe.int/sg .

3 idem.

Internet : www.coe.int/sg/e/

5. In March 2003, the Independent Experts established a list of 212 cases they will examine (see Appendix I)4, as well as a list of 504 cases they will not examine (see Appendix II). The lists were then transmitted to the Secretary General on 2 April 2003.

* * *

6. The Independent Experts have established the following procedure with respect to the cases they are now examining:

Informal confidential Formal confidential procedure procedure (possible "friendly settlements")

Independent Experts’ ÎIndependent Experts’ ÎIndependent Experts’ Provisional opinion Draft opinion Opinion

informal transmission, to formal transmission of Provision of definitive the Azerbaijan authorities, draft opinions to the opinions to the Secretary of summary of provisional Azerbaijan authorities General opinions, for observations for observations and possible “friendly settlement” / release

7. The first set of Opinions, with respect to this second mandate, is likely to be issued in May 2003.

8. Finally, it should be noted that - since the work of the Independent Experts commenced back in the spring of 2001 - a number of prisoners, out of the list of ‘716’, have been released simply because their terms of imprisonment had come to an end. Others, have been pardoned by Presidential Decree, further to the Independent Experts’ report to the Secretary General in 2001, and subsequent to informal contacts undertaken between the Independent Experts and the Azerbaijan authorities.

* * *

4 The Independent Experts have not yet received transcripts of judgments concerning all these cases.

As concerns APPENDICES

Please note that the following abbreviations have been used in both Appendices:

1. Information provided by Mr. Eldar E. Zeynalov, Director of the Human Rights Centre of Azerbaijan, on 1st January 2001 (For additional background information, consult document SG/Inf (2001) 34, dated 24 October 2001; internet: www.coe.int/sg )

? Unreliable data (?) Doubt in political character of arrest (??) Probably, released from detention ADP Member of Azerbaijan Democratic Party AEP Azerbaijan Labour Party AH Supporter of leader of Talysh separatists (1993-1995) Alakram Hummatov AIP Member of Islamic Party of Azerbaijan AKP Azerbaijan Communist Party Antsukh. Case on the murder of MP Ali Antsukhsky which probably was a terrorist act AXCP Member or supporter of Party of Popular Front of Azerbaijan AM Supporter of ex-President Ayaz Mutallibov AMIP Opposition Party of National Independence of Azerbaijan Boz Qurd Member of Azerbaijan National-democratic Party “Boz Qurd” (“Gray Wolf”) C-30 Case of thirty people (Elchin Amiraslanov & others) ChTP “Chagdash Turan” (Modern Turan) Party DGI Democratic Youth Union (its members were many OPON fighters) Djalil. Case of disorders in Djalilabad on November 18, 2000 Musavat Opposition “Musavat” Party Nidjat Charitable Committee of “Nidjat” OPON Mutiny of the Special Police Unit in March 1995 PG “Plot of Generals” (1995) Rasul Supporter of ex-Spokesperson of Parliament Rasul Quliyev relative Person probably arrested because of his family relation with arrested politician RQ Supporter of ex-Minister of Defense Rahim Qaziyev Sheki Case of mass protest action in Sheki 18.11.2000 SH Supporter of ex-Premier Suret Huseynov Shamsi Case of terror act against high official Shamsi Rahimov Sharur Participant of opposition armed group in Sharur region suppressed in August 1994 Terror Act of individual political terror TMMR Supporter of self-proclaimed “Talysh Mugan Autonomous Republic” (1993) XM Member of Charity Society named after Xudu Mammedov

Note: The names of prisoners are listed as : Surname Name Patronimic (with ‘oglu’)

2. Abbreviations of terms used by the Azerbaijan authorities in information provided to the Monitoring Department, DSP, as from February 2002

Abbreviation Terms used by the authorities of Azerbaijan used in the appendices as from February 2002 (emphasis added)

Re-trial: “ Cases submitted for a re-trial” Released +: “Persons released following the experts’ opinion” Released ++: “Persons released in application of expert’s opinion mutatis mutandis to column 2” [=R+] RED : “Persons whose terms of imprisonment have been reduced twice following reconsideration, based on expert’s opinion on disproportional penalty” RED+: “Persons whose terms of imprisonment have been reduced twice following reconsideration in application of experts’ opinion mutatis mutandis to column 4” [=RED] NPP “Persons not regarded by experts as political prisoners” NPP+: “ Persons detained in “similar conditions” with those in column 6” [=NPP] “Name repeated” REF “Persons which have refused from pardoning” No prisoners under these names Died “Died” Under retrieval “Under retrieval” (person not detained/criminal investigations pending) NGO? “Persons which political character of arrests is doubted by the NGO presented the list” NGO?? “Persons detained in “similar conditions” with those in column 13” [=NGO?] IRR “Cases irrelevant to the criteria determined by the experts” IMP “Persons, which release have been considered as impossible by the Commission of pardon” Under consideration “Under consideration” by the Commission on Pardons

Appendix I

List of cases to be examined by the Independent Experts in the framework of their second mandate (as from April 2002)

Introductory remarks

The present list consists of 212 cases which are to be examined by the Independent Experts. It has been established on the basis of up-dated information concerning the list of ‘716’ names, which has been provided to the Experts by the authorities of Azerbaijan and three Azerbaijan human rights NGOs in late 2002 and early 2003.

* * *

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII NN Surname, Case Politi- Date Sen- CoE Information Supplementary New Informa- Information/ Name, cal of tence No in affilia- ar- Secreta- attached to letters Information Information tion/ Observation Patronymic List tion rest riat dated 27 May provided by provided by comments s of remarks 2002* and 3 June Azerbaijan Azerbaijan provided provided 716 provided 2002**, NGOs * authorities by NGOs by the on provided by the on 19.07.2002 on authorities 20.03.02, authorities in cases where 9.10.2002, on 17.12. in letters 04.03.03 discrepancies 21.10.2002*, 2002, dated and * ‘verifications of had appeared 12.11.2002 26.12.02, 8.01.2003 02.04.03 information’ in cases (*Azerbaijan and 21.01.03, 10.01.03, of discrepancies, Foundation of Democracy 20.11.2002 25.01.03, 15.01.03, made by the 5.02.03, 16.01.03, authorities Development and Human Rights 19.02.03 10.02.03

Protection; * Decree on and 11.02.03*, ** Decree on Pardon Institute of Peace of 27 May 2002 Pardon of 18 26.03.03 17.02.03* and Democracy; October 2002 Human Rights and 19.03.03 Center of * Decree on Azerbaijan.) Pardon of 11 February 2003

1. Abbasov Ali 1 SH/ 1995 11 Under consideration Under Nidjat Firuddin oglu consideration

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 2. Abbasov Elchin 3 SH 1996 13 According Under consideration RED RED + Nariman oglu to +(unserved judgment sentence No 2-217 reduced by dated 31 half on 18 July 1996, he was October 2002) commander of 3rd sub- unit of military unit No 171 and organiser of an attack against the Dashkesan Police office 3. Abbasov 6 AXCP 1994 NPP+ NPP+ Ibrahim 4. Abdulkerimov 14 OPON 1995 12 Under consideration Under Azer Hasan consideration oglu 5. Abdullayev 22 OPON 2000 Under consideration IRR IRR Shamsi ? 6. Abulov Nadir 24 Antsuk 1997 14 NGO? NGO? Shaban oglu (?) h. 7. Adygozalov 29 PG/ 1995 12 NPP+ Adygözalov NPP+; AEP Ibad Ibad Qubad ‘Patronimic’ oglu [was] missing

8. Agaverdiyev 33 OPON 1995 10 REF REF Ilqar Agayaddin oglu 9. Agayev Ayaz 34 AXCP/ 1994 13 RED+ RED + Yunis oglu Sharur

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 10. Agayev 35 ? 1996 ? NGO? NGO? Fakhraddin Tahmaz oglu (?) 11. Agayev 37 OPON 1995 8 NGO? Agayev NGO? Ismayil(?) Ismayil

Bashir oglu 12. Ahmedov 43 AXCP 1996 12 IRR IRR Bayram Yunis oglu 13. Ahmedov Enver 45 OPON/ 1995 10 NPP+ NPP+ Nadir oglu C-30 14. Ahmedov Fuad 46 OPON 1995 13 IRR IRR Murquz oglu 15. Ahmedov 47 ADP 1998 9 IRR Ahmedov IRR Jamaladdin Djamaladdin Khudush

oglu 16. Ahmedov 49 Antsuk 1997 NGO? NGO? Mahir(?) h. 17. Ahmedov Natiq 51 OPON/ 1996 15 IRR IRR Bakhysh oglu C-30 18. Akberov Agasi 55 Rasul 2000 IRR Akberov IRR; Agasi Aga ‘Patronimic’ oglu [was] missing

19. Akberov 56 SH 1994 RED+ RED + Bayram 20. Akberov Rasim 60 Rasul 2000 IRR Akberov IRR Rasim Aga

oglu 21. Akberov Tapdiq 61 SH 1994 Akberov IRR IRR Tapdiq ‘patronimic’ Ibrahim [was] missing oglu (see judgment No 2-25 dated 17 April 1995)

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 22. Akberov 62 OPON 1995 14 IRR IRR Tavakkul Sahladar oglu 23. Alekberov Fuad 69 OPON 1998 8 RED+ (on 27 May RED + Firuddin oglu 2002) 24. Alikhanov Azer 74 OPON/ 1996 11 IRR IRR Rustam oglu C-30 25. Alirzayev 76 OPON 1995 15 Under consideration Under Maqsad Alirza consideration oglu 26. Aliyev Eldar 87 SH 1994 Lifer IRR Aliyev Eldar IRR Yusif (Usub) oglu, lifer in Gobustan prison 27. Aliyev Elkhan 88 OPON/ 1996 7 Under consideration Under C-30 Chingiz oglu consideration 28. Aliyev Eyvaz 89 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration Under Abbasali oglu Further to consideration the * * * authorities’ request for request for clarificatio clarification n (19.03.03): no received on Aliyev Eyvaz 19 March Abbasali oglu 2003, in prison; additional Aliyev Eyvaz information Telman oglu is still (OPON,1995), being sentenced on sought 29 March 1996, was released on 27 December 1998

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 29. Aliyev Ilqar 94 SH 1994 Under consideration Under Jafar oglu consideration 30. Aliyev Jafar 97 SH 1994 NPP+ NPP+ Rza oglu 31. Aliyev Mobud 101 SH/ 1994 13 IRR released Aliyev IRR Nidjat Möbud Alimürsal

oglu 32. Aliyev Sadykh 105 Terror 2000 7y.9 NGO?? Life NGO?? Mikayil oglu m. imprisonmen t;in Gobustan prison 33. Aliyev Salman 108 SH 1994 12 Under consideration Under Adil oglu consideration 34. Amiraslanov 131 Terror 1996 14 NGO? NGO? E’tibar (?) 35. Amiraslanov 133 OPON 1995 12 IRR IRR /Relativ Ilqar Samed e oglu 36. Asadov Teymur 136 AXCP 1993 12 The name no prisoner under this no prisoner under Name Under ‘Asadov name this name misspelled; consideration Seymur’ Asadov appears in a Seymur (not judgment Teymur) dated 2 May 1995 37. Ashrafov Bilas 138 OPON 1995 13 IRR IRR (Bilal) Alas oglu 38. Aslanov Khydyr 149 SH 1997 14 IRR IRR 39. Azayev Eldar 153 Sadval 1996 15 NPP+ Case NPP+ related to cases No 170, 340, 349, 654 and 655 40. Babakhanov 158 SH 1996 8 NPP+ NPP+ ?

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Intiqam Rahim oglu 41. Babakishiev 159 SH 1994 IRR IRR ? Vaqif 42. Babayev Abil 160 AXCP 1993 12 REF REF Suleyman oglu 43. Babayev Samir 163 OPON 1995 12 Under consideration Under Abdulazim oglu consideration 44. Babayev Vuqar 164 OPON 1995 12 NGO?? NGO?? Bayram oglu 45. Bagirov Enver 166 AXCP/ 1995 6 NPP+ NPP+ Bagir oglu Sharur

46. Bakayev Rasim 170 Sadval 1996 15 Bakarov no prisoner under this in prison Name NPP + Rasim name possibly Hadjimirza misspelled; oglu is could be mentioned Bakarov in judgment Rasim No 17, Hadjimirza dated 18 oglu; March alleged 1997 participatio (case of n in attack ‘Sadval’ in Qusar movement) region in June 1993 by fighters of “Sadval” movement; trial in March 1997, sentenced to 15 years’ imprison-

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII ment; case related to cases No. 153, 340, 349, 654 and 655 47. Bakhshaliyev 172 SH 1994 RED+ Bakhshaliyev RED + K. Keyan Djalil

oglu 48. Bakhtiyarov 174 OPON 1995 11 NPP+ NPP+ Huseyn Mahammad oglu

49. Bashev Ruslan 177 Sadval 1995 15 no prisoner under this in prison In a group NPP + ? name of ‘Sadval’ members Name accused of misspelled: setting an should be explosion in Baghiyev the Baku Ruslan Nagli

subway; oglu sentenced on 4 May 1996; see newspapers “Azebaycan ” of 2 April 1996 and “Xalq qazeti of 8 May 1996; case related to cases No 625, 616, 673; see judgment of

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII cases No 625 and 673;

- Other related case: Mr Mahsimov [Mehsimov] Rahib Shaval oglu, in Gubustan prison (not included in the list of 716 due to false information on his death in 1998) * * * - Name misspelled: should be Bagiyev Ruslan Nagi oglu 50. Bayramov 178 OPON 1995 Under consideration Bayramov Under Elchin Elchin consideration; Nazim ‘Patronimic’ oglu [was] missing (21.01.03) 51. Bayramov Fuad 179 OPON 1995 12 RED+ RED + Sovet oglu 52. Bayramov 181 SH 1994 10 NPP+ NPP+

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Nazim Rauf oglu 53. Budaqov 185 OPON 1995 14 IRR IRR Elkhan

54. Burjaliyev 186 PG 1995 IRR Burdjaliyev IRR; Burjali Burdjali ‘Patronimic’ Cheshmali [was] missing oglu 55. Burjaliyev 187 OPON 1995 14 NPP+ NPP+ E’tibar Ashraf oglu 56. Djabiyev 191 AXCP 1993 15 IRR IRR Samandar 57. Djafarov Djafar 193 OPON 1995 12 Further to Under consideration Under Mammed oglu the consideration authorities’ * * * request for request for clarificatio clarification n received on (19.03.03): no 19 March Djafarov 2003, Djafar additional Mammed oglu information in prison is still being sought 58. Djafarov 198 OPON 1995 11 IRR IRR Rashad Agarza oglu 59. Djafarov 200 OPON 1995 15 IRR In prison IRR Rovshan Vaqif No 1 oglu

60. Djafarov Sardar 201 AXCP/ 1994 12 RED+ (on 27 May RED + Sharur Huseyn oglu 2002)

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 61. Djafarov Vaqif 203 OPON 1995 15 RED+ RED + Yemen oglu 62. Djalilov Elman 207 SH 1994 IRR IRR ? Djalal oglu 63. Djalilov Ramiz 209 OPON 1995 15 IRR IRR Ismayil oglu 64. Emchiyev Rasul 215 OPON/ 1996 8 IRR IRR C-30 Nadjmeddin oglu 65. Eyyubov Namiq 218 OPON/ 1996 6 Under consideration Under Abdulhuseyn C-30 consideration oglu 66. Farzaliyev 219 OPON 1995 13 RED+ (on 27 May RED + Rahim (Rashid) 2002) Hasan oglu 67. Feyzullayev 222 SH 1994 12? IRR IRR ? Irakli Aydin oglu 68. Feyzullayev 223 SH 1994 12? IRR IRR ? Ramin Aydin oglu 69. Hadjiyev 227 TMMR 1993 IRR IRR Bakhtiyar Hadjiverdi oglu 70. Hadjiyev 230 TMMR 1993 IRR IRR Jebrayil Hadjiverdi oglu 71. Hadjiyev 233 TMMR 1993 12 IRR IRR Mikayil Hadjiverdi oglu 72. Hamidov Afqan 238 OPON 1995 8 REF REF ? Khan oglu 73. Hamidov Sardar 241 IH/ 1997 11 IRR IRR Relativ Medjid oglu e 74. Hamidov Vaqif 242 SH/ 1994 15 NPP+ NPP+ Meshediqara Nidjat

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII oglu 75. Hamzayev 243 SH 1994 RED+ (on 27 May RED + Firuddin 2002) Nariman oglu 76. Hasanov Eldar 248 SH 1994 10 RED+ RED + Zeynalabdy oglu 77. Hasanov Hasan 250 SH 1994 14 IRR (in prison No 1) IRR Mahammad oglu 78. Hasanov Natiq 255 OPON 1995 10 NPP+ NPP+ Asaf oglu 79. Hasanov Rasim 258 PG? 2000 Under consideration Under Qazanfar oglu consideration 80. Hasanov Yusif 260 AXCP 1996 12 NPP+ NPP+ Mirza oglu 81. Heydarov 263 OPON 1995 12 IRR Heydarov IRR Mehman Mehman

Qasim oglu 82. Humbatov 266 OPON 1995 8 IRR IRR Sakhavat Veli oglu

83. Huseynov 273 OPON 1995 6 Under consideration Under Chingiz consideration Nariman oglu 84. Huseynov 275 SH/ 1994 12 This person - “Several prisoners in prison / not a Hüseynov Hüseynov Nidjat Elkhan would under this name.” The repetition Elkhan Elkhan appear to authorities “would Huseynov Elkhan Abdulla Abdulla oglu be appreciate Komisar oglu in oglu; released ++ ; ‘Huseynov clarifications”; prison No 12 arrested in (the certificate Elkhan Komissar - classified by the 1994 and refers to a oglu’, authorities in the sentenced judgment of sentenced category ‘no prisoner on 13 the Supreme on 13 under this name’ December Court of 26 December 1995 (case February

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 1995 and of ‘Nidjat’ 1996) convicted Committee) for to 12 years’ * * * common imprison- 3 judgments law ment ; see concerning charges; newspaper persons named (It would ‘Azerbayca Hüseynov appear that n’ of 30 [Elkhan]/[Ilha the NGOs November m]: mistook 1994 and 20 - judgment of Huseynov December Hüseynov Elkhan 1995; not a Elkhan [Komissar repetition of Abdulla oglu, oglu], name of of 19 February sentenced Huseynov 1996 (no on 13 December Elkhan judgment of 26 1995 with Komissar February Huseynov oglu, 1996); former Elkhan OPON, OPON Abdulla pardoned in member, oglu August released on 17 [member of 2001 August 2001 OPON], sentenced - judgment of on 29 Hüseynov February 1996). Ilham Abdulla oglu, of 19 December 1995, ‘Nijat Committee case’, released on 13 March 2002;

- judgment of Hüseynov

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Elkhan Komissar oglu, of 13 December 1995; no relations with the ‘Nijat Committee’; in prison No 2. 85. Huseynov Fazil 277 OPON/ 1995 IRR IRR Zulfuqar oglu Shamsi 86. Huseynov 282 OPON 1995 11 no prisoner under this in prison No 11 in prison Mr Huseynov Mahmud Omur name No 11 Mahmud oglu Ömür oglu is under consideration 87. Huseynov 283 SH 1995 Lifer IRR Huseynov IRR ? Maqsud Maqsud

Vaqif oglu 88. Huseynov Nail 284 OPON 1995 11 RED+ RED + Ahmed oglu 89. Huseynov Sahib 291 AXCP 1996 11 IRR IRR Mammed oglu 90. Huseynov Tofiq 297 OPON 1995 13 IRR Under Under Panah oglu consideration consideration 91. Huseynov Vaqif 298 SH 1995 Lifer IRR IRR ? 92. Ibrahimov Avaz 302 OPON 1995 15 IRR IRR Aydin oglu 93. Ibrahimov 305 OPON 1995 15 NGO?? NGO?? Mahir Medjid oglu 94. Isganderov 314 SH 1994 14 NPP+ NPP+ Qambar Chingiz oglu 95. Ismayilov Aqil 316 SH 1998 Ismayilov Under consideration Under (Abbasov consideration;

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII ?) Aqil, ‘Patronimic’ arrested on missing 28 June 1998 [source: HRCA] 96. Ismayilov Arzu 317 SH 1994 11 IRR Ismayilov IRR; Arzu Ajdar ‘Patronimic’ oglu [was] missing

97. Ismayilov 320 OPON 1995 12 IRR IRR E’tibar Hamid oglu

98. Ismayilov 322 SH 1994 11 According to released ++ In prison released ++; information Fakhraddin available, Mr No 9 * * * Khalil oglu Ismayilov (informatio information Fakhraddin n received being verified Khalil oglu is born on 19 on August 1951 19.02.2003) and he is the former head of one of the police Departments of Gandja; he was arrested on 7 October 1994, tried from October to December 1997 by the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan and sentenced to 11 years’ imprisonment under Articles 57, 57-1, 167 part 2 and 168 part 2 of the Penal Code; in 1998 he

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII suffered from a serious form of tuberculosis necessitating treatment [source: Human Rights Center of Azerbaijan, List of prisoners (in Russian) dated 7.11.2000]. He was, reportedly, in Prison No 9 in early February 2003 (see column XI) 99. Ismayilov Ilham 324 OPON/ 1997 15 IRR IRR Ca’di oglu C-30 100. Ismayilov 325 OPON 1995 10? Under consideration Under Mehman consideration Ismayil oglu 101. Ismayilov 329 PG 1995 Under consideration Ismayilov Under Ramiz Ramiz consideration

Ismayil oglu 102. Ismayilov 330 AXCP/ 1994 15 NPP+ RED RED + Ramiz Mikayil Sharur +(unserved oglu sentence reduced by half on 18 October 2002) 103. Ismayilov 331 SH 1995 NGO? NGO? Rashid (?) 104. Israfilov Eldar 335 SH 2000 IRR IRR Yaqub oglu 105. Israfilov Israfil 337 OPON 1995 12 This name - “Several prisoners in prison / not a Arrested in Under Sultan oglu appears in under this name.” The repetition March consideration the authorities “would 1995, judgment appreciate sentenced No 12 of 3 clarifications”; on 21 May

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII June 1996 1996; ‘Case - classified by the of 9th authorities in the Company category ‘no prisoner of OPON’; under this name’ the name could be misspelled (written by trial observers); not a repetition of case No 336

106. Kalbiyev 338 TMMR 1996 10 Under consideration Under Umidvar consideration 107. Kasumov Asul 340 Sadval 1996 13 Qasimov no prisoner under this in prison Case related NPP+ Asul Rasul name to cases No oglu 170, 153, appears in 349, 654 judgment and 655; No 17, dated 18 see March judgment of 1997 the ‘Sadval’ ( case of case ‘Sadval’ movement) 108. Kazymov 344 OPON/ 1995 12 IRR IRR Mubariz Yaqub relative oglu 109. Kazymov Nail 345 RQ 1995 10 died alive; in Alive REF Shoveran oglu Gobustan prison; (information has still a few provided on months to serve 13 November in prison; 2002) appeared at the

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII retrial of R. REF Gaziyev in June 2002 as a witness. 110. Kerimov Azer 349 Sadval 1996 8 Kerimov no prisoner under this no information In prison NPP+, Azer Boris name No 11; case ‘Patronimic’ oglu related to [was] missing appears in cases No. judgment 170, 153, No 17, dated 18 340, 654 March and 655 1997 ( case of ‘Sadval’ movement) 111. Kerimov 350 OPON 1995 15 IRR IRR Dayanat ,99 112. Kerimov Djasur 351 SH/rela 1995 IRR IRR tive ‘patronimic’ missing 113. Kerimov Fazil 355 AXCP 1996 12 IRR IRR Shamil oglu 114. Kerimov 358 SH/ 1997 lifer REF REF Keramat Pasha relative oglu 115. Kerimov 363 TMMR 1993 IRR IRR Zulfuqar Alekber oglu 116. Khalilov 367 OPON 1996 10 IRR IRR ? Museyib 117. Latifov Tehran 374 Sheki 2000 Under consideration Under Sabir oglu consideration 118. Maherramov 377 SH 1995 10 Under consideration Under Arif Rahman consideration oglu 119. Mahmudov 381 AH 1994 15 IRR IRR

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Aliasaf (Al’asaf) 120. Mahmudov 383 SH 1997 NPP+ NPP+ Hamlet Talyb oglu 121. Mahmudov 384 SH/ 1999 NPP+ NPP+ Namiq Talyb relative ? oglu 122. Mammedaliyev 386 AXCP 1993 Lifer IRR IRR Sahib 123. Mammedov 389 OPON 1995 13 IRR IRR Adil Sabir oglu 124. Mammedov 390 AXCP 1994 14 NPP+ NPP+ Ahmed Bahlul ? oglu 125. Mammedov 394 OPON 1995 10 Under consideration Under Asger Hasan consideration oglu 126. Mammedov 395 SH 1994 Under consideration Under Dashqyn consideration 127. Mammedov 396 PG 1995 12 Under consideration Mammedov Under Djalal Djalal Feyzi consideration

oglu 128. Mammedov 403 OPON/ 1995 13 IRR IRR C-30 Hamlet Aladdin oglu 129. Mammedov 405 OPON 1995 13 Under consideration Under Ilqar Bazirkhan consideration oglu 130. Mammedov 406 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration Under Ilqar Uzeyir consideration oglu 131. Mammedov 407 SH 1997 10 RED+ (on 27 May Mammedov RED + Inqilab ? 2002) Inqilab Qiyas

oglu 132. Mammedov 417 OPON/ 1996 10 IRR IRR C-30

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Rafiq Yashar oglu 133. Mammedov 424 SH 1994 - “Several prisoners in prison No 12 Mammedov Under Saul under this name.” The Saul Abbas consideration authorities “would oglu , appreciate sentenced clarifications”; for participatio - classified by the n in the authorities in the October category ‘no prisoner coup in under this name’ Gandja in 1994, related to the ‘Nidjat’ Committee; well-known as person allegedly tortured during investiga- tion; in prison No 11 134. Mammedov 426 OPON 1995 12 NGO? NGO? Shahin Alisimiran oglu 135. Mammedov 435 SH 1994 Under consideration Under Zahid Farhad consideration oglu 136. Mammedov 438 SH 1999 Under consideration Mammedov Under Zavur Zavur Tofiq consideration

oglu 137. Melikov 444 SH 1996 13 IRR Melikov IRR; Avtandil Avtandil ‘Patronimic’

Telman oglu

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII [was] missing

138. Mikayilov 448 AXCP 1993 12 NPP+ NPP+ Djeyhun 139. Mirzayev Saday 450 SH 1996 IRR IRR ? Mammedali oglu 140. Mirzoyev Faiq 452 AH 1995 12 NGO? NGO? Agakhan oglu (?) 141. Mukhtarov 459 OPON 1995 13 IRR IRR Fazil Famil oglu 142. Mukhtarov 461 SH 1995 IRR Mukhtarov IRR Tahmaz ? Tahmaz

Nadir oglu 143. Muradov Eldar 462 SH 1994 10 Under consideration Under Elshad oglu consideration 144. Mustafayev 474 SH 1995 Lifer IRR IRR Elshad ? 145. Mustafayev 475 OPON 2000 IRR life IRR Hasan ? imprisonmen t ,now in Gobustan prison 146. Mustafayev 476 SH 1995 Lifer IRR Mustafayev IRR ? Maqsad Maqsad

Teyyub oglu 147. Nabiyev Ilham 487 OPON 1995 10 Under consideration Under Ershad oglu consideration 148. Nagiyev Elkhan 496 SH/ 1994 14 IRR RED RED + Nidjat Tahir oglu +(unserved sentence reduced by half on 18 October 2002) 149. Naibov Taleh 501 OPON 1997 7 Under consideration In prison Under

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Ibrahim oglu No 9 consideration 150. Novruzov Amin 507 SH/ 1994 12 NPP+ NPP+ Nidjat Orudj oglu 151. Novruzov 508 AXCP 1996 13 NPP+ NPP+ Ibrahim Hasan oglu 152. Nuraliyev Samir 510 OPON/ 1996 IRR IRR Relativ e 153. Omarov Valeh 514 OPON 1995 13 IRR IRR Madat oglu 154. Pashayev 519 OPON 1995 11? NGO?? NGO?? Mazahir Mahammad oglu 155. Poladov Safa 523 OPON/ 1996 lifer IRR IRR Alim oglu C-30 156. Qadimov 525 OPON 1995 15 IRR IRR Javanshir Seyfeddin oglu 157. Qafarov Aslan 527 OPON/ 1996 10 IRR IRR Beybala oglu C-30 158. Qarayev Aqil 533 SH 1994 11 Under consideration Under Soltan oglu consideration

159. Qasimov Asad 537 OPON 1995 9 IRR no information Misspelled Mr Qasimov Ismayil oglu (?) ‘Patronimic Asad Ismayil ’ Real oglu was ‘Patronimic sentenced on ’ is 10 January Ramazan 1996 by the oglu Baku City (Qasimov Court to 9 Asad years’ Ramazan imprisonment oglu) […] for In prison “domestic

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII No 11 crimes and, therefore could hardly be alleged to be ‘political prisoner’” (see letter dated 10 January 2003) * * * Qasimov Asad Ramazan oglu (name previously misspelled by NGOs), sentenced on 1 June 1998.

160. Qasimov Geray 540 SH/ 1999 11 Under consideration Under Imran oglu Nidjat consideration 161. Qasimov Oleq 543 SH 1999 IRR IRR ? 162. Qasimov 546 OPON 1995 10 NPP+ NPP+ Teyyub Saleh oglu 163. Qasimov Tofiq 547 OPON/ 1995 IRR Qasimov IRR Shamsi Tofiq Sahib ‘patronimic’ oglu [was] missing 164. Qayibov 550 AXCP 1993 lifer IRR Qayibov IRR Intiqam Intiqam

Yusif oglu 165. Qoshqarov 554 SH 1994 13 IRR IRR Aytekin 166. Quliyev Elshan 560 OPON 1995 13 IRR IRR Mursal oglu 167. Quliyev 562 SH 1994 12 IRR Quliyev IRR

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Firdousi Firdovsi

Sakit oglu

168. Quliyev Fizuli 563 Terror 2000 NGO? NGO? Djavanshir oglu (?) 169. Quliyev 566 OPON 1995 IRR Quliyev IRR; Kamran Kamran Ali ‘Patronimic’ oglu [was] missing

170. Quliyev Rza (?) 570 Rasul/ 1998 IRR Quliyev Rza IRR relative Sabir oglu 171. Quliyev Vidadi 572 AXCP 1994 14 RED+ (on 27 May RED + Heydar oglu 2002) 172. Rahimov Akif 581 OPON 1995 8? NPP+ NPP+ Gulamaly oglu 173. Rahimov Elshan 583 OPON 1997 13 IRR IRR Djavanshir oglu 174. Rahimov Faiq 584 SH 1996 11 IRR Rahimov IRR ? Faiq Feyruz

oglu 175. Rahimov Tahir 588 OPON 1995 12 IRR IRR Shahin oglu 176. Ramazanov 590 TMMR 1993 15 Pilot case - “Several prisoners in prison; NPP Avaz No 12 (the under this name.” The “Talish case” independen authorities “would t experts appreciate lacked clarifications”; information on this case -NPP and therefore did NOT examine it) 177. Ramazanov 591 SH 1996 7 IRR IRR Shamsaddin Abakar oglu

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 178. Rasulov Elchin 594 OPON 1995 9 Under consideration Under Qismet oglu consideration 179. Razimov Afqan 597 OPON/ 1996 11 IRR IRR C-30 Shammed oglu 180. Rzayev E’tibar 608 AXCP 1998 10 NPP+ NPP+ S. Oglu 181. Rzayev 612 SH/ 1994 15 Prisoner No prisoner under this no information Rzayev IRR Nidjat Maherram (?) tried on 13 name Maherram

December Ibrahim oglu 1995 182. Sadirov Yusif 617 SH 1994 12 IRR Sadirov IRR (?) Yusif

Huseyn oglu 183. Sadyqov Faiq 621 OPON/ 1996 8 IRR IRR C-30 Babakishi oglu 184. Sadyqzade 624 SH 1997 11 IRR Sadyqzade IRR; Qurban Qurban ‘Patronimic’ Agabala oglu [was] missing

185. Safaraliyev 625 Sadval 1995 15? NPP+ related to NPP+ Alfat ? cases No 177, 616, 673 186. Safarov Isabala 626 OPON 1995 13 RED+ RED + Zafar oglu 187. Salakhov Arif 633 OPON 1995 12 RED+ (on 27 May RED + Ajdar oglu 2002) 188. Salmanov 638 AXCP/ 1996 11,5 IRR IRR OPON Qulamhuseyn Salman oglu 189. Sarabi 641 ADP 1999 NGO? Sarabi NGO? Bakhtiyar (?) Bakhtiyar

Rahman oglu 190. Shafiyev Adalat 644 AXCP? 1998 11 IRR IRR (Dadan) Ali oglu 191. Shafiyev 646 AXCP 1996 13 IRR IRR

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Qazanfar Ali oglu 192. Shahmuradov 648 OPON 1995 14 NGO?? NGO?? Vidadi Orudj oglu 193. Shahmuradov 649 AXCP 1993 Lifer NPP+ NPP+ Yashar Khasay oglu 194. Sheydayev 654 Sadval 1996 13 Sheydayev NPP+ Case related NPP+ Djamaladdin ? Djamalad- to cases No ‘patronimic’ din Jadulla 170, 153, [was] missing oglu is 340, 349 mentioned and 655; in judgment see No 17, judgment of dated 18 the case March 1997 ( case of ‘Sadval’ movement) 195. Sheydayev 655 Sadval 1996 15 Sheydayev NPP+ Case related NPP+ ? Elkhan Elkhan to cases No ‘patronimic’ Jadullayevi 170, 153, [was] missing tch appears 340, 349 in and 654; judgment No 17, see dated 18 judgment of March the case 1997 ( case of ‘Sadval’ movement) 196. Shukurov Vuqar 657 OPON 1995 13 NGO?? released ++ Azizkhan oglu (“sent for compulsory medical

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII treatment under strict observation in the mental hospital of the Ministry of health” (see letter dated 8.01.03); he will not serve the rest of his sentence after treatment 197. Soltanov Soltan 659 OPON 1995 11 IRR IRR Shamil oglu 198. Suleymanov 662 SH 1994 IRR Süleymanov IRR ? Iftikhar Iftikhar

Kamil oglu 199. Suleymanov 664 SH 1995 11 NPP+ NPP+ Rasul Musa oglu 200. Suleymanov 666 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration Süleymanov Under Suleyman Süleyman consideration

Salim oglu 201. Suleymanov 667 PG 1995 13 NPP+ NPP+ Tahir Suleyman oglu 202. Tagiyev Ikram 673 Sadval 1995 15 NPP+ Tagiyev NPP+ ? Ikram Seyfulla oglu; case related to cases No 177, 625 and 616 203. Tahirov 676 OPON 2000 IRR IRR ? Aliyusif

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 204. Umarov Yusub 680 OPON/ 1996 6.5 NPP+ NPP+ C-30 Qasym oglu 205. Veliyev Babek 684 OPON 1995 15 IRR Veliyev IRR Babek Khanbaba

oglu 206. Veliyev 685 OPON 1995 13 IRR IRR Djeyhun Yaqub oglu 207. Veliyev Raqif 688 OPON 1996 13 Under consideration Veliyev Under Raqif consideration Basaret (Basharet) oglu

208. Veliyev Shahin 689 OPON 1995 13 RED+ (on 27 May Veliyev RED + 2002) Shahin

Farman oglu 209. Yagnaliyev 692 OPON 1995 14 Under consideration Under Namiq Fikret consideration oglu 210. Yahyaev 694 SH 1994 10 Under consideration Under Nariman Yaman consideration oglu 211. Yermolayev 700 OPON 1995 12 IRR Yermakov IRR; Oleg Oleg ‘Patronimic’ Nikolayevic, [was] missing Russian citizen, former member of OPON, sentenced to 12-years’ imprisonment and detained in prison No 11

I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII

212. Zeynalov 715 AM/SH 1998 No prisoner under this no information Zeynalov IRR Zeynal name Zeynal Imampasha

oglu

Appendix II

List of cases not to be examined by the Independent Experts in the framework of their second mandate (as from April 2002)

Introductory remarks

The present list consists of 504 cases not to be examined by the Independent Experts. It has been established on the basis of up-dated information concerning the list of ‘716’ names which has been provided by the authorities of Azerbaijan and three Azerbaijan human rights NGOs in late 2002 and early 2003.

It contains the names of persons: - not detained (released, deceased, repetition of another name); - whose cases have already been examined by the Independent Experts; and - with respect to whom NGOs were not able to provide additional information (in a situation in which the authorities indicated that the persons on the list were not detained).

* * *

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Surname, Case Political Date Sen- CoE Information Supplementary New Informa- Information/ Name, affilia- of tence No in tion ar- Secreta- attached to letters Information Information tion/ Observation Patronymic List rest riat dated 27 May provided by provided by comments s of remarks 2002* and 3 June Azerbaijan Azerbaijan provided provided 716 provided 2002**, NGOs * authorities by NGOs by the on provided by the on 19.07.2002 on authorities 20.03.02, authorities in cases where 9.10.2002, on 17.12. in letters 04.03.03 discrepancies 21.10.2002*, 2002, dated and * ‘verifications of had appeared 12.11.2002 26.12.02, 8.01.2003 (*Azerbaijan 02.04.03 information’ in cases and 21.01.03, 10.01.03, of discrepancies, Foundation of Democracy 20.11.2002 25.01.03, 15.01.03, made by the 5.02.03 , 16.01.03, authorities Development and Human Rights 19.02.03, 10.02.03

Protection; * Decree on 09.03.03 11.02.03*, ** Decree on Pardon Institute of Peace of 27 May 2002 Pardon of 18 and 17.02.03* and Democracy; October 2002 Human Rights 26.03.03 and 19.03.03 Center of Azerbaijan.) * Decree on Pardon of 11 February 2003

1. Abbasov 2 AXCP 1993 8 released ++ released ++ Bayram Abbas oglu 2. Abbasov 4 PG 1995 11 Pilot case released + released + Elkhan No 23 Pasha oglu released (1) (regarded as political prisoner by the independen t experts)

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 3. Abbasov 5 SH 1994 Name of No 4 in prison / not a Repetition Name of No 4 Elkhan (2) repeated repetition of Name of repeated No 3/716 (informatio n provided on 9.03.03) 4. Abbasov 7 TMMR 1993 released ++ released ++ Qadir 5. Abbasov 8 Musavat 2000 released ++ released ++ (Arifoglu) Rauf Arifoglu 6. Abbasov 9 SH/ 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Nidjat Rovshan 7. Abbasov 10 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Shaiq Nazim oglu 8. Abbasov 11 SH 1996 released ++ No information Released released ++ Shamshir (on 26 June 2000) (on 26 June 2000) 9. Abbasov 12 SH/ 1994 13 released ++ released ++ Zakir Nidjat 10. Abdulazimov 13 OPON 1995 11 IRR released released ++ Abdulazim (pardoned on Mahammad 11.02.03) oglu 11. Abdullayev 15 SH/ 1995 11 Abdullayev Aqil Abdullayev Aqil released ++ Nidjat Aqil Alirza Agarza oglu Agarza oglu oglu released ++ released ++ (on 27 May 2002) (on 27 May 2002) 12. Abdullayev 16 PG 1995 released ++ released ++ B. 13. Abdullayev 17 OPON 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Eldar Turman oglu

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 14. Abdullayev 18 SH/ 1996 10 released ++ released ++ Relative Muzakir Imran oglu 15. Abdullayev 19 OPON 1996 13 Pilot case RED RED Qalib Jamal No 16 oglu (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 16. Abdullayev 20 SH 1997 8 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Rashid May 2002) 27 May 2002) 17. Abdullayev 21 AH 1995 (??) released ++ released ++ Shamseddin 18. Abulfazoglu 23 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ Rashid 19. Abuyev 25 Sadval 1997 13 Pilot case NPP NPP Habib No 11 (not regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 20. Abuzarov 26 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Mazahir Mohubat oglu 21. Abyshov 27 OPON 1997 5? released ++ released ++ Mayil Khanlar oglu 22. Abyshov 28 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Ziyaddin ? Mustadjab oglu

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 23. Adygozalov 30 SH 1994 12 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Tadjir Almaz (on 18 October oglu 2002) 24. Agagulov 31 OPON 1996 8 released ++ released ++ Vidadi Mirsalekh oglu 25. Agasiyev 32 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Aliashraf Imanverdi oglu 26. Agayev 36 AXCP/ 1994 13 released ++ released ++ Sharur Hasan Nasir oglu 27. Agayev Natiq 38 AM 1994 released ++ released ++ (?) 28. Agayev Natiq 39 OPON 1995 9 released ++ released ++ Hasanaga oglu 29. Agayev 40 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ Nazim Asker oglu 30. Agayev 41 PG 1995 11 Pilot case released + released + Rafiq No 24 Abbasovich released (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 31. Ahmedov 42 SH 1994 Ahmadov Abuzar Ahmadov Abuzar released ++ ? Abuzar Bahram oglu: released Bahram oglu: Bahman oglu ++ (on 27 May 2002) released ++ (on 27 May 2002)

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 32. Ahmedov 44 OPON 1995 11 no prisoner under this in prison The name no prisoner Bunyad name could be called Mursal oglu misspelled; ‘Ahmedov e.g. could Bunyad be Mursal oglu’ ‘Ahmedov or ‘Ahmedov Bunyad Bunyad Musa Musa oglu’ oglu’

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 33. Ahmedov M. 48 OPON 1995 13 The name - “Several prisoners in prison Sentenced mentioned under this name.” The to 13 years’ Ahmedov in the authorities “would imprison- Musa Mustafa judgment appreciate ment for oglu, of clarifications”; participatio sentenced on 26 January 1996 n in the 26 January (referred to - classified by the attempted 1996, was by the authorities in the coup d’Etat released on 27 NGOs in category ‘no prisoner of March May 2002 column XI) under this name’ 1995 in (certificate is Qazakh and provided); ‘Ahmedov Agstafa Musa region; Mustafa information No other oglu’; found in prisoner under

Ahmedov newspaper this name. Musa ‘Azerbayca Mustafa n on 30 Ahmedov M. oglu’ January released++ was 1996; full released in name to be May 2002 checked in (see the column judgment XII) concerning the ‘Qazakh OPON case’ on 26 January 1996; Possibly pardoned 34. Ahmedov 50 OPON 1995 Released ++ (on 27 Released ++ (on released ++ Natiq Ahmed May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 35. Ahmedov 52 OPON 1995 The name - “Several prisoners in prison / not a Not a Ahmedov Ramazan mentioned under this name.” The repetition repetition of Ramazan in the authorities “would No 53; Teyyub oglu, judgment appreciate arrested in sentenced on of 17 June clarifications”; 1997; 17 June 1998, 1998 in the ‘case of the civilian was pardoned Six’ - classified by the involved in on 13 March (referred to authorities in the the 2002 by the category ‘no prisoner attempted (certificate NGOs in under this name’ coup d’Etat provided); it is column XI) in Qazakh- not a repetition is Agstafa; of case No 53. Ahmedov sentenced Ramazan in June Teyyub 1998 in the released ++ oglu; this person was “case of the released in Six” March 2002 36. Ahmedov 53 Antsukh. 1997 released ++ released ++ Ramazan(?) 37. Ahmedov V. 54 SH 1994 10? died died 38. Akberov 57 AXCP/ 1994 13 Pilot case released + released + Sharur Israyil Isa No 20 oglu released (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 39. Akberov Izzet 58 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ 40. Akberov 59 OPON 1995 14 RED+ released released ++ Nadir Abdul (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03)

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 41. Akhundov 63 AXCP/ 1994 released ++ released ++ Sharur Fuad Javad oglu 42. Akhundov 64 AXCP/ 1994 released ++ released ++ Ismayil Ali Sharur oglu 43. Akhundov 65 AIP 2000 Pilot case released ++ released ++ Ruhulla (?) No 19 (released during preparation of independent experts’ report) 44. Alekberov 66 OPON 1996 9 released ++ released ++ Akif Ali oglu 45. Alekberov 67 OPON 1995 13 released ++ released ++ Azer Orudj ? oglu 46. Alekberov 68 SH 1994 8 released ++ released ++ Eduard Niyaz oglu 47. Alekberov 70 SH 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Mammed Jalal oglu 48. Alekberov 71 AXCP 2000 released ++ released ++ Rafiq 49. Alekberov 72 OPON 1995 10 Under consideration released released ++ Rafiq (pardoned on Nariman oglu 11.02.03) 50. Alesgerov 73 OPON 1995 NPP+ released released ++ Jabir (pardoned on Ramazan oglu 11.02.03)

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 51. Alirzayev 75 OPON 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Aqil Kommunist oglu 52. Aliyev Adalat 77 OPON 1995 13 RED+ released released ++ Silyan oglu (pardoned on 11.02.03) 53. Aliyev 78 SH 1995 released ++ released ++ Agahuseyn 54. Aliyev 79 SH 1998 - “Several prisoners in prison / not a - No prisoner “guardian Aliyev Ahmed Ahmed under this name.” The repetition under this of the Maharram authorities “would name Industrial oglu appreciate Association released ++ clarifications”; -Aliyev ‘Azeryun’; (certificate - classified by the Ahmad sentenced provided) authorities in the Maharram for illegal category ‘no prisoner oglu storage of under this name’ released ++ weapons; (on 18 October not a 2002) repetition of No 80; could have been released 55. Aliyev 80 AEP 1995 released ++ released ++ Ahmed Baba oglu 56. Aliyev Ali 81 OPON/ 1995 released ++ released ++ Allahverdi C-30 oglu

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 57. Aliyev 82 OPON 1995 No prisoner under this No prisoner Name of No Aliashraf name; “correct name: under this name; 32 repeated Imamverdi Agayev Aliashraf “correct name: oglu Imamverdi oglu”; Agayev Aliashraf repeating name of No Imamverdi oglu”; 32 repeating name of No 32 58. Aliyev Ariz 83 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Teyyub oglu 59. Aliyev Asif 84 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ ? Nariman oglu 60. Aliyev Bayali 85 AM 1995 released ++ released ++ Khanali oglu 61. Aliyev Elchin 86 OPON 1995 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Ali oglu May 2002) 27 May 2002)

62. Aliyev Faiq 90 PG 1995 5 released ++ released ++ 63. Aliyev Feyruz 91 SH/AM 1998 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner name under this name 64. Aliyev Hasan 92 AXCP/ 1995 14 released ++ released ++ Nasir oglu Sharur 65. Aliyev 93 OPON 1995 13 released ++ released ++ Huseyn

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 66. Aliyev 95 Rasul/ 2000 released ++ (on 23 in prison Former Aliyev OPON Iskender May 1998) OPON Iskender is certificate provided policeman; mentioned as a arrested in witness in 2000; his judgments of trial started cases No 55 in October and No 60. 2000; He could be Now ‘wanted’ in hiding; see judgments of cases No 55 and 60. 67. Aliyev Jabir 96 SH 1994 7 released ++ released ++ (Yabir) 68. Aliyev Kamil 98 OPON 1995 Aliyev Kamil Shasha Aliyev Kamil released ++ Shamo oglu ? oglu: Shasha oglu: released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on May 2002) 27 May 2002) 69. Aliyev 99 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Khanlar 70. Aliyev 100 AEP 1995 (??) “Under retrieval”: “Under Mammedali not detained and not retrieval”: yet tried (in hiding) not detained and not yet tried (in hiding) 71. Aliyev 102 AXCP/ 1994 released ++ released ++ Niftaly Sharur Allahverdi oglu 72. Aliyev Oqtay 103 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ 73. Aliyev Rasim 104 OPON 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Aziz oglu

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 74. Aliyev Sahib 106 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Latif oglu 75. Aliyev Saleh 107 SH 1997 8,5 released ++ released ++ Sabir oglu 76. Aliyev Samed 109 AXCP 1996 released ++ released ++ (?) 77. Aliyev Shaiq 110 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Nariman oglu 78. Aliyev Shaiq 111 OPON 1995 8 Name of No 110 Name of No Nariman oglu ,96 repeated 110 repeated 79. Aliyev Siradj 112 OPON 1995 released ++ (on 22 released ++ (on released ++ Mammed ? January 1999) 22 January 1999) oglu 80. Aliyev Siradj 113 OPON 1995 Name of No 112 Name of No Mammed repeated 112 repeated oglu 81. Aliyev 114 AXCP 1994 13 Name of No 115 Name of No Siyafar Djalal ? repeated 115 repeated oglu 82. Aliyev 115 AXCP/ 1994 12 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Sharur Siyafar Jalal May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 83. Aliyev 116 OPON/ 1995 15 died died C-30 Telman Dilenchi oglu 84. Aliyev Yusif 117 AXCP 1994 8 died died Suleyman ? oglu 85. Aliyev Zahid 118 OPON 1995 12 NGO?? released ++ released ++ Qalibiyyat (on 18 October oglu 2002) 86. Aliyev 119 OPON 1995 13 released ++ released ++ Ziyaddin Nureddin oglu

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 87. Allahverdiyev 120 OPON 1995 Name of No 33 in prison Name of No Name of No Ilqar repeated 33 repeated 33 repeated Agayaddin oglu 88. Allahverdiyev 121 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Mubariz Siyasat oglu 89. Allahverdiyev 122 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Vuqar Murtuz oglu 90. Almammedov 123 OPON/ 1996 10 Under consideration released ++ released ++ C-30 Adil Hadji (on 18 October oglu 2002) 91. Alvandov 124 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Musa 92. Alyyev Arif 125 OPON 1995 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Khyndy oglu (on 18 October 2002) 93. Alyyev Asif 126 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Aslan oglu 94. Alyyev Fazil 127 SH 1994 released ++ (on 14 released ++ (on released ++ Isa oglu November 2001) 14 November 2001) 95. Alyyev Qalib 128 Sheki/ 2000 released ++ released ++ Musavat 96. Alyyev Vuqar 129 OPON 1995 died died Samed oglu 97. Amirahmedov 130 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Vuqar

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 98. Amiraslanov 132 OPON/ 1996 lifer Pilot case IMP IMP C-30 Elchin No 5 Samed oglu (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 99. Amirov 134 OPON 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Erastun Bilal oglu 100. Amrahov 135 OPON 1995 6 released ++ released ++ Hasret Oqtay oglu 101. Asadullayev 137 TMMR 1993 released ++ released ++ Ilham Saleh oglu 102. Askerov 139 OPON 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Agayar Rasul oglu 103. Askerov 140 Musavat/ 1994 released ++ released ++ Sharur Allahverdi 104. Askerov 141 OPON 1995 10 released ++ released ++ ? Elman Yusif 105. Askerov Fuad 142 OPON 1995 released ++ (on 30 no information released ++ Asker oglu January 1999) 106. Askerov 143 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Habil Ali oglu 107. Askerov 144 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Kamandar Qashchy oglu 108. Askerov 145 SH 1996 10 died died Samandar Maherram oglu

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 109. Askerov 146 OPON 1995 released ++ (on 23 no information released ++ Shahin Arif January 1999) oglu 110. Aslanov 147 SH 1994 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Ilham Ismayil May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 111. Aslanov Isa 148 OPON 1998 released ++ released ++ Alyannagi oglu 112. Aslanov 150 SH 1997 released ++ released ++ Natiq Aslan oglu 113. Atayev Fazil 151 OPON 1995 11 Name of No 127 no information Name of No Isa oglu (released) repeated 127 repeated 114. Avazov Ilqar 152 OPON 1995 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Mahmud oglu (on 18 October 2002) 115. Azayev Natiq 154 OPON 1995 14 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner Hasanaga ? name under this oglu name 116. Azimoglu 155 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ (Ashrafoglu) Ilyas 117. Azimov Nadir 156 RQ/SH 1994 died died Bahram oglu /97 118. Azizov Tahir 157 OPON 1995 11 died died 119. Babayev 161 AXCP 1994 11 released ++ released ++ E’tibar ? 120. Babayev 162 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Natiq Qahraman oglu 121. Bagirov Bagir 165 SH/ 1994 12 NPP+ released ++ released ++ AXCP Agali oglu (on 18 October 2002) 122. Bagirov 167 SH 1994 released ++ released ++

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Kamil 123. Bagirov Nadir 168 TMMR 1993 RED+ released released ++ Israfil oglu (pardoned on 11.02.03) 124. Bagirov 169 SH 1994 10 NPP+ Released released ++ Samir Vilayat (certificate oglu provided on 20 November 2002) 125. Bakhshaliyev 171 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration released ++ released ++ E’tibar (on 18 October Telman oglu 2002) 126. Bakhshaliyev 173 OPON 1995 10 Under consideration released released ++ Sarvan (pardoned on Niftaly oglu 11.02.03) 127. Baladjanov 175 OPON 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Adygozal Mammed oglu 128. Balamammed 176 OPON 1995 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner ov Rufat name under this name 129. Bayramov 180 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Natiq Ismet (on 18 October oglu 2002) 130. Bayramov 182 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Vuqar Kamil oglu 131. Bilalov Saqif 183 OPON/ 1995 released ++ released ++ AXCP 132. Broyev 184 AXCP/ 1995 13 released ++ released ++ (Burayev) Sharur Siyafar Safar oglu 133. Dadashov 188 AH 1995 released ++ released ++ Miri

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 134. Dadashov 189 OPON 1996 6 IRR released released ++ Samir Rafiq (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 135. Dadashov 190 OPON 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Vuqar Isa oglu 136. Djabrayilov 192 OPON 1995 12 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Azer Veli (on 18 October oglu 2002) 137. Djafarov 194 OPON 1995 11 IRR released released ++ Djafar (pardoned on Nureddin 11.02.03) oglu 138. Djafarov 195 TMMR 1993 released ++ released ++ Elshan Dashdamir oglu 139. Djafarov 196 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Mayis (on 18 October Fakhraddin 2002) oglu 140. Djafarov 197 OPON 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Nureddin Ilham oglu 141. Djafarov 199 OPON 1995 Name of No 198 Name of No Rashad repeated 198 repeated Agarza oglu 142. Djafarov 202 OPON 1995 12 Under consideration released released ++ Shahin (pardoned on Mammed 11.02.03) oglu 143. Djalalov 204 AXCP 1994 14 released ++ released ++ (Djalilov) Shahin Djalal oglu 144. Djalalov Azer 205 Rasul/ 2000 “Under retrieval”: no information “Under OPON

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII not detained and not retrieval”: yet tried (in hiding) not detained and not yet tried (in hiding) 145. Djalilov 206 OPON 1998 Released ++ no information released ++ Elchin 146. Djalilov Ilqar 208 SH 1994 IRR released ++ released ++ Djalal oglu ? (on 18 October 2002) 147. Djavadov 210 SH 1994 13 NPP+ released released ++ Aqil Haqverdi (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 148. Djibishov 211 OPON 1995 Under consideration released released ++ Shahraz (pardoned on Fakhraddin 11.02.03) oglu 149. Efendiyev 212 Rasul 1998 3 released ++ released ++ Firdovsi Islam oglu 150. Efendiyev 213 AM/SH 1996 4 released ++ released ++ ? (??) Muzaffar 151. Efendiyev 214 Rasul 2000 Pilot case IMP IMP Natiq Islam No 7 oglu (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 152. Eyyubov 216 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Ahmed Zavir oglu 153. Eyyubov 217 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Eldar Qambar oglu

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 154. Farzaliyev 220 SH 1994 11 released ++ released ++ Zaur Namiq oglu 155. Fazili Ashraf 221 Rasul 2000 “Under retrieval”: no information “Under not detained and not retrieval”: yet tried (in hiding) not detained and not yet tried (in hiding) 156. Gulmirzayev 224 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ ? Elshad Veli oglu 157. Hadjiyev 225 AM 1996 9 Pilot case released + released + Adil No 8 Khanbaba released oglu (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts)

158. Hadjiyev 226 OPON 1995 11 There is no Name should be in prison Hadjiyev released ++ Aydin ‘Hadjiyev spelled “Tagiyev Aydin * * * Alovsat oglu Aydin Aydin Alovsat oglu”; Alovsat - Hadjiyev Alovsat Released ++ (on 19 oglu: Aydin Alovsat oglu’ in the March 1997); former oglu is neither judgment of 26 certificate of the policeman mentioned in January release of Mr Tagiyev of OPON; the judgment 1996 provided in group of of 26 January (referred to persons 1996 nor in the by the sentenced ‘Azerbaijan’ NGOs in on 26 gazette of 30 column XI) January January 1996; 1996; case related to - Hadjiyev

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII case No 48; Adalet Mehrali see also oglu was newspaper sentenced on ‘Azerbayca 26 January n’ of 30 1996 and January released on 28 1996 December 2000;

- Tagiyev Aydin Alovsat oglu” released ++ (certificate provided) 159. Hadjiyev 228 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Elchin Hadji oglu 160. Hadjiyev 229 AXCP 1995 15 Pilot case NPP NPP Fahmin No 10 (not Ahmedpasha regarded as oglu political prisoner by the independent experts) 161. Hadjiyev 231 SH 1998 Haciyev Ceyhun Haciyev Ceyhun Hadjiyev released ++ Jeyhun Maharram: released Maharram: Djeyhun ++ (on 27 May 2002) released ++ (on Rashid oglu: 27 May 2002) released ++ (on 18 October 2002) 162. Hadjiyev 232 OPON 1997 released ++ released ++ Khaladdin 163. Hadjiyev 234 OPON/ 1997 died released died Nadir Relative

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 164. Hadjiyev 235 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Qurban Huseynaga oglu 165. Hadjiyev 236 AM 1994 (??) released ++ released ++ Shamil (?) 166. Hadjiyev 237 IH/ 1997 released ++ released ++ Tofiq Relative 167. Hamidov 239 IH/ 1995 14 Pilot case Re-trial Re-trial Boz Qurd Iskander No 1 Medjid oglu (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) re-tried 168. Hamidov 240 SH 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Nusreddin Hamid oglu 169. Hamzayev 244 OPON 1995 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner Firuddin name under this Yilduz oglu name 170. Haqverdiyev 245 OPON 1995 10 Released ++ (on 28 no information Released released ++ Seymur December 2000) Qasim oglu 171. Hasan Toku 246 AXCP 1993 10 released ++ released ++ Salekh Zaki oglu 172. Hasanov Akif 247 SH 1994 12 RED+ (on 27 May released released ++ Bandar oglu 2002) (pardoned on 11.02.03) 173. Hasanov 249 SH 1997 7 Hasanov Elshad Ali in prison Released released ++ Elshad ali oglu: released on 25 from prison oglu June 2001 No 14 Certificate provided

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII

174. Hasanov 251 OPON/ 1996 6 Under consideration Released released ++ C-30 Ilham Abuzar (certificate oglu provided on 10.10.2002) 175. Hasanov 252 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration released released ++ Ilham Bashir (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 176. Hasanov 253 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ Ilham Surkhay oglu (?) 177. Hasanov 254 SH/ 1997 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Relative Maqsud (on 18 October 2002) 178. Hasanov 256 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Niyaz Akif oglu 179. Hasanov 257 ADP 2000 Hasanov Ramiz Zakir no information released ++ Ramiz oglu (sentenced in 1993): released ++ (on 19 October 2001) 180. Hasanov 259 AXCP 1994 9 Hasanov Yadulla Hasanov Yadulla released ++ ? Yadulla Qambar oglu: released Qambar oglu: Qambarali ++ (on 27 May 2002) released ++ (on oglu 27 May 2002) 181. Hasanov 261 OPON 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Zakir Sahib oglu

182. Heydarov 262 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Asaf Kerim oglu 183. Heydarov 264 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ Qurbanali

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII

184. Heydarov 265 OPON 1995 11 released ++ (see no information released ++ Rizvan information attached to Bayram oglu letter of 27 May 2002) 185. Hummatov 267 TMMR 1993 Lifer Pilot case Re-trial Re-trial /5 Alakram No 2 Alekber oglu (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) re-tried 186. Huseynov 268 AXCP/ 1994 8y.8 Name of No 259 Name of No (Hasanov) Sharur m. repeated 259 repeated Yadulla Qambar oglu 187. Huseynov A. 269 OPON 1998 8 Name of No 272 no information Released Name of No ? repeated 272 repeated 188. Huseynov 270 SH/ 1997 11 died died Nidjat Abulfaz Ajdar oglu 189. Huseynov Ali 271 AXCP/ 1994 11 released ++ released ++ Sharur Faraj oglu 190. Huseynov 272 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Araz Huseyn oglu 191. Huseynov 274 OPON 1995 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner Elchin name under this Salman oglu name 192. Huseynov 276 OPON 1995 9 Released ++ (on 17 in prison Released released ++ Elkhan August 2001) Abdulla oglu Certificate provided 193. Huseynov 278 SH 1998 released ++ released ++ Fuzuli 194. Huseynov 279 PG/ 1995 11 Pilot case IMP IMP

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Huseynbala AEP? No 25 (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 195. Huseynov 280 SH 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Ilham Abdulla oglu 196. Huseynov 281 AXCP 1996 released ++ released ++ Jeyhun Jumshud oglu 197. Huseynov 285 SH 1995 died died ? Nariman 198. Huseynov 286 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ Nariman 199. Huseynov 287 TMMR 1993 released ++ released ++ Qudrat Iltifat oglu 200. Huseynov 288 TMMR 1993 released ++ released ++ Ramiq Baldadash oglu 201. Huseynov 289 SH/ 1994 9? Under consideration died died Ramiq Nidjat (certificate Huseyn oglu provided on 20 November 2002) 202. Huseynov 290 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ Ramiz 203. Huseynov 292 SH 1994 10 released ++ released ++ Shahin Mammed oglu 204. Huseynov 293 SH/ 1997 released ++ released ++

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Shohrat relative Davud oglu 205. Huseynov 294 SH 1997 lifer Pilot case IMP IMP Suret Davud No 17 oglu (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 206. Huseynov 295 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Tahir (?) 207. Huseynov 296 SH 1994 11 no prisoner under this in prison No 11 Huseynov released ++

Taleh name Taleh Ajdar (pardoned on oglu ; 11.02.03) released on 11.02.03 208. Huseynov 299 OPON 1997 9 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Veli May 2002) 27 May 2002 Alihuseyn oglu 209. Huseynov 300 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Vuqar Faiq oglu 210. Ibadov Aliaga 301 AH/ 1995 released ++ released ++ Relative 211. Ibrahimov 303 OPON 1995 11 Released ++ (on 27 Released ++ (on released ++ Chingiz May 2002) 27 May 2002) Shamil oglu 212. Ibrahimov 304 OPON 1996 8 Released ++ (on 27 Released ++ (on released ++ Ilqar Nadir May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 213. Ibrahimov 306 OPON 1996 released ++ released ++ Tahir ? 214. Ibrahimov 307 OPON 1995 9 released ++ released ++ Yashar Ziyad

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII oglu 215. Ilyasov Bahat 308 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Hidayat oglu (on 18 October 2002) 216. Ilyasov Raqib 309 AXCP 1996 released ++ released ++ Yusif oglu 217. Imranov 310 RQ/AH 1994 Lifer Pilot case released + released + Nariman No 14 Shamo oglu released (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 218. Isayev 311 OPON 1995 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner Asiman Ilyas name under this oglu name 219. Isganderov 312 PG/ 1995 released ++ released ++ Fazil relative 220. Isganderov 313 AH 1995 released ++ released ++ Hasanaga 221. Ismayilov 315 TMMR 1993 released ++ released ++ Aflatun Ibrahim oglu 222. Ismayilov 318 OPON 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Azer Akif oglu 223. Ismayilov 319 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Azer Ilyas oglu 224. Ismayilov 321 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Fakhraddin Djamaladdin oglu 225. Ismayilov 323 AXCP 1996 released ++ released ++

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Hashim 226. Ismayilov 326 SH/ 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Nidjat Mehman Sabir oglu 227. Ismayilov 327 OPON 1995 8 Released ++ (on 27 Released ++ (on released ++ Nadir May 2002) 27 May 2002) Mushtaba oglu 228. Ismayilov 328 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Ne’mat ? Azizkhan oglu 229. Ismayilov 332 AXCP 1996 released ++ released ++ Sabir 230. Ismayilov 333 OPON 1995 13 IRR released released ++ Vaqif Djamal (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 231. Ismiyev 334 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Israfil Rustam oglu 232. Israfilov 336 ADP 1995 released ++ released released ++ Israfil (?) 233. Kanev Amur 339 SH/ 1995 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner Kamal oglu AM? name under this name 234. Kazymov 341 OPON/ 1996 lifer Pilot case IMP IMP C-30 Arif Nazir No 15 oglu (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 235. Kazymov 342 AH 1995 released ++ released ++ Djamal 236. Kazymov 343 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Ilham 237. Kerimov 346 OPON 1995 8 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ ,96 Abulfat May 2002) 27 May 2002) Mammed oglu 238. Kerimov 347 AH 1995 released ++ released ++ Amirali 239. Kerimov 348 OPON 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Arzu Mustafa oglu 240. Kerimov 352 SH/ 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Elmar Shamil Nidjat oglu 241. Kerimov Emil 353 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Heydar oglu 242. Kerimov Emil 354 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Nariman oglu 243. Kerimov Ilyas 356 OPON 1995 12 no prisoner under this no prisoner under no prisoner Mazahir oglu name this name under this name 244. Kerimov 357 AXCP 1994 9 released ++ (on 12 no information released ++ ? Ismayil September 1999) Mammedtagi oglu 245. Kerimov 359 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ Kerim (?) 246. Kerimov 360 OPON 1995 12 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Qiyas (on 18 October 2002) 247. Kerimov 361 PG 1995 released ++ released ++ Ramiz 248. Kerimov 362 OPON 1995 11 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Taleh Talyb May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 249. Khalilov 364 Antsukh. 1996 12 NGO?? Released released ++ ? Abdulmedjid (certificate

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII (?) provided on 10.10.2002) 250. Khalilov 365 OPON ? ? no prisoner under this in Gobustan Former After new Bahadur name prison OPON verifications, member, no prisoner sentenced under this for name participatio n in the ‘March coup of 1995’, was in Gobustan prison in October 2000 251. Khalilov 366 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Khalil Sabir oglu 252. Khalilov 368 TMMR 1993 Xalilov Sulduz Xalilov Sulduz released ++ Sulduz Ibrahim oglu: released Ibrahim oglu: Ibrahim oglu ++ (on 27 May 2002) released ++ (on 27 May 2002) 253. Khaliqov 369 OPON 1995 Xashalov Elçin Ali Xashalov Elçin released ++ Elchin Adil oglu: Ali oglu: oglu released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on May 2002) 27 May 2002) 254. Khanlarov 370 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Fuzuli Zakir oglu 255. Khasmammed 371 OPON/ 1996 4 released ++ released ++ ov Ilqar Ahad C-30 oglu 256. Khudiyev 372 OPON 1995 11 Xudiyev Camaladdin Xudiyev released ++ Djamaladdin Idris oglu: released ++ Camaladdin Idris Yunis oglu (on 27 May 2002) oglu: released ++

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII (on 27 May 2002) 257. Latifov Azad 373 Sheki/ 2000 NPP+ Latifov Azad released ++ Musavat Abdulkerim (pardoned on oglu released 11.02.03) 258. Layudjov 375 OPON 1997 released ++ released ++ Mahoma ? 259. Madatov Alik 376 SH 1994 11 Under consideration released released ++ Hadjibala (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 260. Maherramov 378 OPON 1996 6 released ++ released ++ Bakhtiyar Ali oglu 261. Maherramov 379 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Elbrus Ilyas oglu 262. Maherramov 380 OPON 1995 7 released ++ released ++ Yusif Masim oglu 263. Mahmudov 382 OPON 1995 12 NGO?? released ++ released ++ Aqil Akif (on 18 October oglu 2002) 264. Mamiyev 385 OPON 1995 12 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner Aydin name under this name

265. Mammedov 387 OPON 1995 released ++ (on 15 no information released ++ Abbas Yaver January 1999) oglu 266. Mammedov 388 AXCP 1994 11 released ++ (on 12 no information released ++ ? Abulfaz January 2002) 267. Mammedov 391 SH 1994 11 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Alik Djamil May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 268. Mammedov 392 ADP 1996 (??) released ++ released ++ Allahverdi

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 269. Mammedov 393 SH 1994 12 released ++ released ++ Araz 270. Mammedov 397 OPON 1995 no prisoner under this no information Misspelled no prisoner E’tibar name ‘patronimic under this Oskald oglu ’ ;real one name is Dekald oglu. Released 271. Mammedov 398 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Elbrus Mammedali oglu 272. Mammedov 399 OPON 1995 Mammadov Elçin Mammadov Elçin released ++ Elchin Masim oglu : released Masim oglu : ++ (on 27 May 2002) released ++ (on 27 May 2002) 273. Mammedov 400 AXCP 1995 9 released ++ released ++ Faiq Alik? ? Oglu

274. Mammedov 401 SH/ 1994 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner Nidjat Guloglan name under this name 275. Mammedov 402 SH 1994 8 released ++ released ++ Hadjirahim Samed oglu

276. Mammedov 404 AXCP 1996 released ++ released ++ Hasan 277. Mammedov 408 AXCP 1994 released ++ released ++ Intiqam Abdulla oglu 278. Mammedov 409 Antsukh. 1996 no prisoner under this no information Died in Died Islam (?) name 1999 (certificate provided) 279. Mammedov 410 SH 1994 released ++ (on 11 no information released ++ ?

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Khayaladdin March 2002) Tapdiq oglu 280. Mammedov 411 OPON 1995 13 released ++ released ++ Mammedali Israfil oglu 281. Mammedov 412 TMMR 1993 died died Naib Bahadur oglu 282. Mammedov 413 AXCP 1995 released ++ released ++ Qafar ? 283. Mammedov 414 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Qalib 284. Mammedov 415 ADP 1998 5 IRR Released Released ++ Qurban Djalal (informatio (certificate oglu n received provided) on 5 February 2003) 285. Mammedov 416 SH 1995 no prisoner under this no information no prisoner Rafiq ? name under this name 286. Mammedov 418 AXCP 1994 7 released ++ released ++ Rahib ?

287. Mammedov 419 SH 1995 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Roman Musa May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 288. Mammedov 420 AXCP/ 1994 10 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Sharur Rovshan May 2002) 27 May 2002) Djamil oglu 289. Mammedov 421 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Sahib Asadulla oglu 290. Mammedov 422 SH/ 1994 10 released ++ released ++ Sahib Nidjat Mammed

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII oglu 291. Mammedov 423 SH 1995 Under consideration released released ++ Samed (pardoned on Bahadur oglu 11.02.03) 292. Mammedov 425 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Seymur Qafar oglu 293. Mammedov 427 AXCP 1994 6 released ++ released ++ Shamil ? Mammed oglu 294. Mammedov 428 SH 1994 7 released ++ released ++ Siyavush (?) 295. Mammedov 429 SH 1997 released ++ (on 19 in prison No 2 Released ? released ++ Tanryverdi July 1998) died ? Manaf oglu Certificate provided 296. Mammedov 430 OPON 1995 13 released ++ released ++ Tofiq Emin oglu 297. Mammedov 431 OPON 1995 NPP+ released released ++ Vidadi (pardoned on Ahmed oglu 11.02.03)

298. Mammedov 432 OPON 1995 11 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Vusal Shirin May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 299. Mammedov 433 OPON 1995 11 No prisoner under this no information Possibly, no prisoner Yadulla name liberated under this Elmar oglu name 300. Mammedov 434 Relative 1997 released ++ released ++ Yunis (?) 301. Mammedov 436 OPON 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Zahir Zakir oglu 302. Mammedov 437 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Zaman Nadjaf ?

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII oglu 303. Mammedqulu 439 OPON 1995 RED+ released released ++ yev Rasim (pardoned on Yusif oglu 11.02.03) 304. Mansurov 440 OPON 1995 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Rovshan (on 18 October Mansur oglu 2002) 305. Masimov 441 SH 1997 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner Azer name under this name 306. Mehdiyev 442 AXCP/ 1995 released ++ released ++ Hakimeldostu Sharur Bayram oglu 307. Mehdiyev 443 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Malik Ismayil oglu 308. Melikov Sabir 445 OPON 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Zakir oglu 309. Migraliyev 446 Sadval 1994 (??) released ++ released ++ Nabi 310. Mikayilov 447 OPON 1995 Mikayilovun Anar Mikayilovun released ++ Anar Azer Qazax oglu: released Anar Qazax oglu: oglu ++ (on 27 May 2002) released ++ (on 27 May 2002)

311. Mirzayev 449 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Oqtay Rafayil oglu 312. Mirzayev 451 AM 1995 (??) released ++ released ++ Vladimir ( ?) 313. Mirzoyev 453 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ ? Rafiq Suleyman oglu 314. Mirzoyev 454 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Ramiz ?

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 315. Mirzoyev 455 SH 1998 12 Name of No 450 Name of No ? Saday repeated 450 repeated Mammedali oglu 316. Mirzoyev 456 AH/ 1995 released ++ released ++ Shamsaddin Relative 317. Muartiyev 457 AM/ 1997 Muftiyev Dementi Muftiyev released ++ Dementy H? Zalimxanoviç: Dementi released ++ (on 27 Zalimxanoviç: May 2002) released ++ (on 27 May 2002) 318. Mukhtarov 458 SH/ 1995 released ++ released ++ XM Ahmed Ali oglu 319. Mukhtarov 460 PG 1995 (??) released ++ released ++ Rasim (?) 320. Muradov 463 AXCP/ 1995 died died Kamran OPON 321. Mursalov 464 OPON 1996 released ++ released ++ Rovshan Novruz oglu 322. Murshudov 465 AH 1995 (??) released ++ released ++ Sakit 323. Musayev 466 OPON 1996 9 released ++ released ++ Aydyn Djahan oglu 324. Musayev Idris 467 OPON 1996 9 released ++ released ++ /C-30 Firuddin oglu 325. Musayev 468 PG/ 1996 released ++ released ++ Relative Natiq 326. Musayev 469 OPON 1995 9 released ++ released ++ ? Natiq Volodya oglu 327. Musayev 470 OPON/C 1997 6 NPP+ released ++ -30 Qadir Asad (certificate oglu provided)

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 328. Musayev 471 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Sardar 329. Musayev 472 OPON 1998 3 released ++ released ++ Shirzad 330. Mustafayev 473 OPON 1995 12 NGO?? released released ++ Bakhtiyar (pardoned on Aziz oglu 11.02.03) 331. Mustafayev 477 OPON 1995 11 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Nizami Ibadat May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 332. Mustafayev 478 OPON 1996 8 released ++ released ++ Rashad Qurban oglu 333. Mustafayev 479 AXCP 1995 6 released ++ released ++ Sattar Mustafa oglu (?) 334. Mustafayev 480 OPON 1995 12 RED+ released released ++ Shahin Iman /Relative (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 335. Mustafayev 481 AXCP 1993 12 Pilot case released + released + Siyavush No 9 Firudin oglu released (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 336. Mustafayev 482 OPON 1995 13 NGO?? released released ++ Vuqar Qurban (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 337. Mustafayev 483 OPON 1995 8 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ ? Yaver May 2002) 27 May 2002) Maherram 338. Nabiyev 484 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Ahmed Movsum oglu 339. Nabiyev 485 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Aydin 340. Nabiyev 486 OPON/ 1996 6 released ++ released ++ C-30 Eldar Amirshah oglu 341. Nabiyev Ilqar 488 SH 1997 released ++ (on 10 in prison No 2 Could have released ++ Mustafa oglu October 1998) been Certificate provided released 342. Nabiyev 489 OPON 1996 10 Released ++ ( on 27 Released ++ ( on released ++ Qudrat May 2002) 27 May 2002) Mushirovano vich 343. Nabiyev 490 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Sahib Khudayar oglu 344. Nadjafli Req- 491 OPON 1995 12 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Nurulla May 2002) 27 May 2002) Qanbar oglu 345. Nadjafov 492 OPON 1997 released ++ released ++ ? Maherram 346. Nadjafov 493 OPON 1996 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Mikayil May 2002) 27 May 2002) Vahid oglu 347. Nadjafov 494 OPON 1995 11 Names of Nos 198 no information Name of No Rashad and 199 repeated 198 repeated Agarza oglu 348. Nagiyev 495 SH 1994 11 released ++ released ++ Ehtiram Tahir oglu 349. Nagiyev 497 AXCP/ 1994 12 NPP+ released ++ released ++ Huseyn Sharur (on 18 October Mammedyar 2002)

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII oglu 350. Nagiyev 498 SH/ 1995 10 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Nidjat Mehman May 2002) 27 May 2002) Tahir oglu 351. Nagiyev 499 AXCP/ 1995 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner OPON Tariel ( ?) name under this name 352. Nagiyev 500 SH 1994 12 NPP+ released ++ released ++ Yusif Niftaly (on 18 October oglu 2002) 353. Namazov 502 OPON 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Asaf Isfahan oglu 354. Namazov 503 OPON 1995 11 NPP+ released released ++ Shakir Ali (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 355. Nasibov 504 OPON 1996 7 Under consideration Name of No Name of No Name of No ? Taleh Ibrahim 501 repeated 501 501 repeated oglu repeated 356. Nazarli 505 SH 1995 12 released ++ released ++ Chingiz Qazanfar oglu 357. Nazarov 506 AM/ 1998 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner Djamal SH? name under this name 358. Novruzov 509 OPON 1997 released ++ (on 11 no information; released ++ Qurban December 2000 ? ) probably released 359. Nuriyev Faiq 511 OPON 1995 11 RED+ released ++ released ++ Azan oglu (on 18 October 2002) 360. Nuriyev 512 OPON 1995 13 no prisoner under this in prison No 2 Released no prisoner Mirzalatif name under this Arif oglu name 361. Nuriyev 513 OPON 1995 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner Shirin name under this Djebrayil name

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII oglu 362. Orudjov 515 SH/ 1995 10 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Nidjat Djeyhun (on 18 October Tofiq oglu 2002) 363. Orudjov 516 AXCP/ 1995 released ++ released ++ OPON Elchin 364. Orudjov 517 AXCP/ 1995 released ++ released ++ OPON Ilham 365. Pashayev 518 OPON 1995 11 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Ilham Vaqif May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 366. Pashayev 520 OPON 1995 5 released ++ released ++ Musallim 367. Piriyev 521 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Aladdin ? Surkhay 368. Pirquluyev 522 OPON 1995 released ++ (on 29 no information released ++ Shaiq Ismet January 1999) oglu 369. Puladi Elkhan 524 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Ibrahim oglu

370. Qadirov 526 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Sadiq Alesker oglu 371. Qafarov 528 OPON 1995 8 NGO? released released ++ Nariman (pardoned on Amanshah 11.02.03) oglu (?) 372. Qalibov Arif 529 SH 1994 10 released ++ released ++ 373. Qambarli 530 AXCP 1996 released ++ released ++ (Qanbarli) Bunyamin Nagdali o. 374. Qambarov 531 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Rovshan

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 375. Qambarov 532 OPON 1995 released ++ (on 10 no information; released ++ Shakir December 1999) probably Nushiravan released oglu

376. Qarayev 534 OPON 1995 11 NGO? released ++ released ++ Salekh (on 18 October Ismayil oglu 2002) (?)

377. Qaribov Arif 535 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Yusif oglu ? 378. Qasimov 536 AM 1995 8 Name of No 537 in prison / name Name of Name of No Asad ? repeated not repeated No.537 537 repeated repeated 379. Qasimov 538 AXCP/ 1993 12 released ++ released ++ Aydin Madat ChTP oglu 380. Qasimov 539 AM 1996 (??) released ++ released ++ E’tibar (?) 381. Qasimov 541 TMMR 1993 released ++ released ++ Hokmulla 382. Qasimov 542 AXCP 1994 released ++ released ++ Jebrayil Nariman oglu 383. Qasimov 544 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Qasim Kamil oglu 384. Qasimov 545 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Rasim Kamil oglu 385. Qasimov 548 OPON 1995 11 released ++ (on 17 in prison No 11 Misspelled Released ++ Vuqar Qasim January 1995) ‘patronimic (Mr Qasimov oglu Certificate provided ’real Vuqar Qasim ‘patronimic oglu was

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII ’ is Novruz “released oglu; in because of his prison No illness on 17 11 ; January 1995”) see letter dated Qasimov 10 January Vuqar 2003; Novruz Qasimov oglu Vuqar Novruz released on oglu 11.02.03 released ++ (pardoned on 11.02.03) 386. Qasymov 549 Sheki/ 2000 Under consideration Qasimov released ++ AMIP Farzali Farzali (pardoned on Ashraf oglu 11.02.03) released 387. Qaziyet 551 Sheki 2000 died died Djovdat Shahid oglu

388. Qaziyev 552 AXCP/ 1993 lifer Pilot case Re-trial Re-trial RQ Rahim No 3 (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) re- tried 389. Qaziyev Sabir 553 AXCP/ 1994 released ++ released ++ Hamza oglu Sharur 390. Qulamov 555 Sheki/ 2000 IRR Qulamov released ++ ADP Elxan

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Elxan Mammed (pardoned on oglu released 11.02.03) 391. Quliyev Asaf 556 AXCP 1994 9 released ++ released ++ Ali oglu 392. Quliyev 557 AXCP 1993 released ++ released ++ ? Bashir 393. Quliyev 558 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Chingiz 394. Quliyev 559 OPON 1995 8 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Elkhan Eldar May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 395. Quliyev 561 AXCP 1994 11 released ++ released ++ Faradj Ibrahim oglu 396. Quliyev 564 Terror 2000 5y.7 Name of No 563 Name of No Fuzuli m. repeated 563 repeated Djavanshir oglu (?) 397. Quliyev Isbat 565 TMMR 1993 released ++ released ++ 398. Quliyev 567 SH 1994 10 died died Mehbaly 399. Quliyev 568 OPON 1995 9 released ++ released ++ Mirzalatif Arif oglu 400. Quliyev 569 AH 1995 released ++ released ++ Rovshan 401. Quliyev 571 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Sherif Gurshad oglu 402. Qurbanov 573 TMMR 1993 Pilot case released ++ released ++ Ajdar No 13 Mammed (released oglu during the preparation of the independent

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII experts’ report) 403. Qurbanov 574 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Azer Ismayil oglu 404. Qurbanov 575 OPON/ 1996 6 released ++ released ++ Elkhan C-30 Qurban oglu 405. Qurbanov 576 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration released released ++ Hadji Ali oglu (pardoned on 11.02.03) 406. Qurbanov 577 OPON/ 1996 5 released ++ released ++ C-30 Ilqar Tahir oglu

407. Qurbanov 578 OPON 1996 8 released ++ released ++ Rafael 408. Qurbanov 579 AH/ 1995 (??) released ++ released ++ Ramiz relative 409. Rafiyev 580 SH 1995 13 released ++ released ++ Elchin 410. Rahimov Arif 582 TMMR 1993 released ++ released ++ Mashallah oglu 411. Rahimov 585 OPON 1995 13 released ++ released ++ Hasanaga Hasan oglu 412. Rahimov 586 OPON 1995 12 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Ilqar Ajdar May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 413. Rahimov 587 OPON/R 1998 (??) released ++ released ++ Mehdi elative ? 414. Rahimov 589 OPON 1998 released ++ (on 9 no information released ++ Tariel January 2001) 415. Rashidov Ali 592 SH 1994 10 released ++ released ++ Misirkhan

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII oglu 416. Rasulov Ali 593 AEP/ 1995 released ++ released ++ Relative Mahammad oglu 417. Rasulov 595 AM/ 1998 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner SH? Shakir name under this name 418. Rasulov Yusif 596 AH 1995 (??) released ++ released ++ 419. Rufullayev 598 OPON 1995 9 released ++ released ++ Afraddin ,96 Alisa oglu 420. Rustamov 599 OPON 1995 12 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner Ehyar name under this Djavanshir name oglu 421. Rustamov 600 OPON 1995 No prisoner under this no information Rustamov Rustamov Elchin name Elchin Elchin Boyukaga Boyukaga oglu oglu released ++ (certificate provided) 422. Rustamov 601 OPON 1996 7 died died Hadjy Nedji oglu 423. Rustamov 602 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Mazahir ? Nasib oglu 424. Rustamov 603 OPON 1995 12 NGO?? released released ++ Qabil (pardoned on Shakhali oglu 11.02.03) 425. Rustamov 604 Djalil./ 2000 released ++ released ++ Musavat Rustam 426. Rustamov 605 SH 1997 released ++ (on 1 in prison No 6 Accused of released ++ Ruzi December 2001) participatio (Certificate Certificate provided n in the provided) ‘October

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII coup’, also accused of murder on 25 May 1994; doubt that was released; no such information 427. Rzayev Ali 606 AH 1995 (??) released ++ released ++ 428. Rzayev 607 PG 1998 died died Bahram Mammedrza oglu 429. Rzayev Ilqar 609 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ 430. Rzayev Ilqar 610 OPON 1995 11 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Abulfat oglu May 2002) 27 May 2002) 431. Rzayev Imran 611 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ /Nidjat (?) 432. Rzayev 613 OPON 1996 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner Nariman name under this Qurban oglu name 433. Rzayev Sabir 614 AXCP/ 1994 15 NPP+ released ++ released ++ Sharur Huseyn oglu (on 18 October 2002) 434. Rzayev 615 AXCP/ 1994 9 released ++ released ++ Vilayat Sharur Huseyn oglu

435. Sadgarov 616 Sadval 1995 15 no prisoner under this in prison Sadqarov no prisoner Sulhaddin ? name Sulhaddin; under this case name; related to cases No name not 177, 625, mentioned in

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 673; see judgment of judgment of cases No 625 cases No and 673 625 and 673 * * * Safarov Sulhaddin (name was misspelled); Died in detention 436. Sadykhov 618 SH 1996 released ++ released ++ Abulfaz 437. Sadyqov 619 SH/ 1996 released ++ released ++ Relative Djalil 438. Sadyqov 620 TMMR 1993 Released ++ (on 27 Released ++ (on released ++ Djavanshir May 2002) 27 May 2002) Diyashar oglu 439. Sadyqov 622 SH/XM 1994 released ++ released ++ Rahim Hasan oglu 440. Sadyqov 623 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Vidadi (?) 441. Safarov 627 SH/XM 1995 released ++ released ++ Maherramali ? Safar oglu 442. Safarov 628 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Nizameddin 443. Safarov Qara 629 AXCP 1994 11 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Ziyaddin oglu ? (on 18 October 2002) [NB: release not mentioned by NGOs] 444. Safarov 630 OPON 1995 Name of No 200 no information Repetition Name of No Rovshan repeated of name 200 repeated

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Vaqif oglu No 200 Detained in prison No 1 445. Safarov 631 IH/ 1997 released ++ released ++ Subkhan (?) relative 446. Safikhanov 632 SH 1995 15 Pilot case IMP IMP Ilqar Aziz No 18 oglu (regarded as political prisoner by the independen t experts) 447. Salakhov 634 OPON 1995 10 Under consideration Salilov released ++ Eldaniz Eldaniz (pardoned on Beylar oglu Beylar oglu 11.02.03) released 448. Salimov 635 OPON 2000 died died Sultan ? 449. Salmanov 636 OPON 1995 RED+ released ++ released ++ Araz Asker (on 18 October oglu 2002) 450. Salmanov 637 OPON/ 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Elchin Khalil DGI oglu 451. Samedov 639 OPON 1995 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner Eldaniz name under this name 452. Samedov 640 Sheki/ 2000 Pilot case NPP Samedov Vahdat Sadiq No 21: not Sadiq Vaqif Samedov regarded as oglu Sadiq Vaqif political released oglu prisoner by released ++ the independen (pardoned on t experts. 11.02.03) But their

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII opinion was fomulated before the end of his trial on 11 July 2001 453. Sepkhanov 642 AM? 1996 released ++ released ++ Veli 454. Shabanov 643 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Zulfuqar ,96 Sabir oglu 455. Shafiyev 645 OPON 1995 11 died died Azad Niyazi oglu 456. Shahmuradov 647 OPON 1996 7 released ++ released ++ Mahammad Nasib oglu 457. Shahtakhtinsk 650 OPON 1995 11 NPP+ released released ++ y Famil Aslan (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 458. Shamilov 651 SH 1994 NPP+ Shamilov released ++ Safar Safar Avaz (pardoned on oglu released 11.02.03) 459. Shamilov 652 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Shamil 460. Sharifov 653 OPON 1995 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Samed May 2002) 27 May 2002) Qazanfar oglu 461. Shirinov Azer 656 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ 462. Shykhlarov 658 OPON 1995 released ++ released ++ Rovshan Tofiq oglu 463. Suleymanov 660 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Arif 464. Suleymanov 661 SH 1995 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Elshan May 2002) 27 May 2002)

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII Qasham oglu 465. Suleymanov 663 RQ 1995 (??) released ++ released ++ Rasim 466. Suleymanov 665 OPON 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Saleh Tahir oglu 467. Sultanov 668 OPON 1996 8 released ++ released ++ Ismayil Haqverdi oglu 468. Sultanov 669 OPON 1995 11 Name of No 659 Name of No Sultan Shamil repeated 659 repeated oglu 469. Suri Barhuda 670 OPON 1999 IRR Transferred to released ++ (Pirhuda) Iran (certificate provided on 10.10.2002) 470. Sysoyev 671 PG 1995 12 Pilot case released + released + Anatoly No 22 Evgheniyevic released h (regarded as political prisoner by the independent experts) 471. Tagiyev Eldar 672 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Misirkhan oglu 472. Tagiyev 674 AXCP 1994 released ++ released ++ Ramiz (?) 473. Tagiyev 675 OPON 1995 10 died died Shamistan Beyistan oglu 474. Talybov 677 AXCP/ 1994 released ++ released ++ Sharur Shirzad Ali

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII oglu 475. Turabov 678 SH 1994 11 released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on released ++ Rasim Rafiq May 2002) 27 May 2002) oglu 476. Ukalayev 679 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Ramazan 477. Veledov 681 OPON 1995 10 IRR released released ++ Qabil Adil (pardoned on oglu 11.02.03) 478. Veliyev Adil 682 OPON 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Abdulla oglu 479. Veliyev Araz 683 OPON 1996 9 released ++ released ++ Veli oglu 480. Veliyev 686 OPON 1995 9 released ++ released ++ Javanshir Jahangir oglu 481. Veliyev Musa 687 AXCP/ 1994 released ++ released ++ Sharur 482. Veliyev 690 OPON 1995 10 Valiyev Shöhrat Valiyev Shöhrat released ++ Shohrat Nüsrat oglu: released Nüsrat oglu: ++ ( on 27 May 2002) released ++ ( on 27 May 2002)

483. Veliyev Vaqif 691 OPON 1995 No prisoner under this no information Name of No Name of No Basaret oglu name 688 688 repeated repeated 484. Yahyaev Aly 693 SH 1994 12 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Safarali oglu (on 18 October 2002) 485. Yaqubov 695 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Fakhraddin 486. Yaqubov 696 SH 1994 released ++ released ++ Mohubbat 487. Yaqubov 697 OPON 1995 11 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Osman Sany (on 18 October oglu 2002)

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII 488. Yaranaqov 698 OPON 1995 Qarapapaqov Pirvali Qarapapaqov released ++ Pirveli Ziraddin oglu: Pirvali Ziraddin released ++ (on 27 oglu: May 2002) released ++ (on 27 May 2002) 489. Yaranaqov 699 OPON 1995 13 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner Vaqif name under this name 490. Yolchuyev 701 AXCP/ 1995 released ++ released ++ OPON Fazil 491. Yusibov 702 OPON 1995 10 released ++ released ++ Vaqif Asad 492. Yusifli Valeh 703 Sheki/ 2000 released ++ released ++ YAP 493. Yusifov Arif 704 OPON 1997 Yusifov Arif Sozali Yusifov Arif released ++ ? oglu: Sozali oglu: released ++ (on 27 released ++ (on May 2002) 27 May 2002) 494. Yusifov 705 OPON/ 1995 released ++ (Case no information released ++ Nureddin Boz Qurd dismissed on 1 June 1998) 495. Yusifov 706 SH 1994 IRR There might IRR Rovshan be several persons named Yusifov Rovchan; this one was a high official close to S. Huseynov; there is no proof that he was arrested; apparently, he emigrated to Israel and

II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII died there; he’s not in prison 496. Yusifov Vaqif 707 OPON 1995 10 Name of No 702 Name of No Asad oglu repeated 702 repeated 497. Zahidi 708 SH/ 1995 11 released ++ released ++ Nidjat Huseyn Qarash oglu 498. Zamanly Ali 709 AXCP/ 1994 released ++ released ++ Sharur 499. Zeynalov 710 SH 1994 IRR Released released ++ Djalal (certificate provided on 13 November 2002)

500. Zeynalov 711 Rasul/ 2000 No prisoner under this no information no prisoner OPON Elchin name under this name 501. Zeynalov 712 OPON 1995 8 released ++ released ++ Hidayat Kerim oglu 502. Zeynalov 713 Djalil./ 2000 released ++ released ++ Iman Musavat 503. Zeynalov 714 SH 1994 7 released ++ released ++ Matlab 504. Zulfuqarov 716 OPON/ 1996 12 Under consideration released ++ released ++ Faiq Zulfuqar AXCP (on 18 October oglu 2002)