West African Monsoon Dynamics Inferred from Abrupt Fluctuations of Lake Mega-Chad
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
West African monsoon dynamics inferred from abrupt fluctuations of Lake Mega-Chad Simon J. Armitagea,1, Charlie S. Bristowb, and Nick A. Drakec aCentre for Quaternary Research, Department of Geography, Royal Holloway University of London, Egham, Surrey, TW20 0EX, United Kingdom; bDepartment of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Birkbeck College, University of London, London, WC1E 7HX, United Kingdom; and cDepartment of Geography, King’s College London, Strand, London, WC2R 2LS, United Kingdom Edited by Thomas Dunne, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA, and approved May 11, 2015 (received for review September 12, 2014) From the deglacial period to the mid-Holocene, North Africa was decrease in humidity since the LGM (6). These three scenarios, characterized by much wetter conditions than today. The broad timing (i) abrupt onset and termination, (ii) gradual change, and (iii)abroad of this period, termed the African Humid Period, is well known. trend with shorter-term variability, are supported to a greater or However, the rapidity of the onset and termination of the African lesser extent by climate models in which an enhanced WAM is linked Humid Period are contested, with strong evidence for both abrupt and to summer-season insolation in the Northern Hemisphere, which gradual change. We use optically stimulated luminescence dating of peaked around 10 ka and then gradually declined (7–9). Abrupt dunes, shorelines, and fluviolacustrine deposits to reconstruct the changes in North African climate can be simulated by biogeophysical fluctuations of Lake Mega-Chad, which was the largest pluvial lake in feedbacks (7), whereas a gradual change in rainfall is simulated by a Africa. Humid conditions first occur at ∼15 ka, and by 11.5 ka, Lake coupled transient simulation model (9), where vegetation feedbacks Mega-Chad had reached a highstand, which persisted until 5.0 ka. Lake are muted and more localized. Alternatively, a “flickering switch” levels fell rapidly at ∼5 ka, indicating abrupt aridification across the may be simulated, in which the climate system and ecosystems in entire Lake Mega-Chad Basin. This record provides strong terrestrial North Africa have two stable configurations, a green state and a evidence that the African Humid Period ended abruptly, supporting desert state, with strong centennial-scale fluctuations across the the hypothesis that the African monsoon responds to insolation forcing transition due to nonlinear biogeophysical feedback (10). In addition, in a markedly nonlinear manner. In addition, Lake Mega-Chad exerts many studies attribute arid–humid (humid–arid) transitions at strong control on global biogeochemical cycles because the northern individual sites to the northward (southward) migration of the EARTH, ATMOSPHERIC, ’ (Bodélé) basin is currently the world s greatest single dust source and intertropical convergence zone (ITCZ) in response to preces- AND PLANETARY SCIENCES possibly an important source of limiting nutrients for both the Amazon sionally driven increases (decreases) in summer-season insolation Basin and equatorial Atlantic. However, we demonstrate that the final amounts in the northern low latitudes. However, several recent desiccation of the Bodélé Basin occurred around 1 ka. Consequently, studies have indicated that at least some arid phases observed in the present-day mode and scale of dust production from the Bodélé the African paleoclimate record are due to in situ weakening of Basin cannot have occurred before 1 ka, suggesting that its role in rainfall associated with the ITCZ (11–13) or contraction of this fertilizing marine and terrestrial ecosystems is either overstated or rainfall band in an interhemispherically symmetric manner (14). geologically recent. Although existing proxy and climate model data yield important insights into the drivers and mechanisms governing WAM African monsoon | Lake Chad | dust | African Humid Period strength, the paucity of regional-scale terrestrial records inhibits the evaluation of competing theories (15). he West African monsoon (WAM) is key to our understanding We present a regional-scale record of north central African Tof the African climate system and the impacts of future climate moisture balance, derived by optically stimulated luminescence change upon its population. Climatically, the WAM is a major (OSL) dating sedimentary deposits associated with the rise and component of the global monsoon belt, which regulates moisture fall of Lake Chad and its earlier incarnation, paleolake Mega- availability in the low latitudes and is sensitive to climate dynamics Chad. The latter was the largest freshwater lake in Africa and in both the high latitudes and the tropics. From a human per- spective, the WAM represents the dominant control upon agri- Significance cultural productivity in a densely populated region that is heavily reliant on subsistence agriculture (1). The broad pattern of WAM – dynamics since the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) is well known, North Africa was wetter 15,000 5,000 years ago than today, with with initially arid conditions being replaced by a more humid wetlands and lakes formed in the Sahara due to an enhanced monsoon. We reconstruct the lake-level history of Lake Mega- phase, sometimes termed the African Humid Period (AHP), Chad, when it was the largest African lake, and demonstrate that which lasted from the deglacial period to the mid-Holocene. this humid period ended abruptly 5,000 years ago, indicating that However, paleoclimate proxy data from North Africa and adjacent the African monsoon exhibits a nonlinear response to insolation areas of the Atlantic provide contrasting evidence for the rate and forcing. The northern basin of Lake Mega-Chad, currently the timing of these changes, leading to uncertainty over the controls world’s greatest dust source, became dry around 1,000 years ago. upon WAM dynamics. Prior to that time dust output from the northern basin would West African Monsoon Dynamics have been limited, and suggestions that this dust plays an im- portant role in fertilizing Atlantic and Amazonian ecosystems are The widely cited terrigenous dust record from Ocean Drilling either overstated or only true for the last thousand years. Program (ODP) site 658C indicates abrupt onset and termination of the AHP at 14.8 and 5.5 ka, respectively (2). In contrast, records Author contributions: S.J.A., C.S.B., and N.A.D. designed research, performed research, from Lake Yoa within the Sahara (3–5) and the Gulf of Guinea analyzed data, and wrote the paper. (1) are interpreted to indicate gradual aridification over the past The authors declare no conflict of interest. 6 ka, with pollen data suggesting the onset of full desert conditions This article is a PNAS Direct Submission. at 2.7 ka. Reviews of lake-level change within the southern Sahara 1To whom correspondence should be addressed. Email: [email protected]. and Sahel indicate additional millennial to centennial changes This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10. superimposed on the broad pattern of increase and subsequent 1073/pnas.1417655112/-/DCSupplemental. www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1417655112 PNAS | July 14, 2015 | vol. 112 | no. 28 | 8543–8548 Downloaded by guest on September 30, 2021 probably the largest pluvial lake on Earth. During the Early to samples below 287 m only constrain lake levels in the basin mid-Holocene wet phase, Lake Mega-Chad attained an area where they were collected, except that the lakes in both basins of 361,000 km2 (16–18) and a depth of up to 160 m (Fig. 1). must be below the elevation of the BEG sill at that time. Both Paleolake Mega-Chad has the potential to provide an important basins contain (formerly) submerged aeolian dunes, extensive record of WAM dynamics because it is (i) sensitive to changing relict shorelines, and fluviolacustrine sediments indicative of past moisture balance due to its shallow depth and large surface area; lake fluctuations. We used OSL and radiocarbon dating of these (ii) dominated by fluvial inputs, unlike smaller North African deposits combined with existing records from the basin to doc- lakes where groundwater can dominate; and (iii) Located in ument the fluctuations of Lake Chad and construct a regional- north central Africa, thereby integrating moisture from tropical scale record of WAM variability. and desert latitudes (Fig. 1 A and B). In addition, Lake Chad potentially acts as a climate driver in itself, projecting tropical Fluctuations of Paleolake Mega-Chad moisture ∼1,000 km northward during humid periods, thereby A reconstruction of Lake Mega-Chad levels, based upon new providing an efficient moisture source in the absence of long- and published OSL and radiocarbon ages (sample details are range atmospheric moisture delivery (19) and allowing dust provided in SI Appendix, Table S1), is presented in Fig. 2. Sus- production in the Bodélé Depression during arid periods (20, tained aridity in the period immediately after the LGM is evident 21). This dust production may further enhance aridity by sup- in both basins. Transverse dunes are preserved in the Chad Basin pressing rainfall (22). This dual role as alternate moisture and between 19 and 16 ka (NG33-36), whereas barchan dunes are dust source is made possible by the geography of the paleolake preserved under freshwater diatomite in the Bodélé date from 17 Mega-Chad catchment, which feeds two interlinked basins (Fig. to 15 ka (CH16, 22, and 51). The transverse dunes on the bed of 1C). The southern (Chad) basin contains present-day Lake Chad Lake Chad are indicative of drier than present-day conditions in and is fed primarily by the tropical catchments of the Chari the Chari catchment before ∼16 ka. A single age of 19 ± 2ka River. The northern (Bodélé) basin is presently hyperarid and is (NG41) for fluvial sands at Dalori Quarters in the Chad Basin fed either by Saharan catchments or by overflow from the Chad suggests elevated lake levels at that time. There are no analytical Basin via the Bahr el Ghazal (BEG) sill at an elevation of 287 m reasons for doubting the accuracy of this age.