PLANNING COMMITTEE Agenda Item No. APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER OFFICER DELEGATED POWERS FOR THE MONTH OF OCTOBER 2016

App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

12/0189 Reserved by Brough Discharge of conditions 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 & 9 of SITE ADJACENT TO CASTLE PARK, Mr & Mrs Jackson REFUSED Cond application 11/0607. BROUGH, ,

13/0438 Reserved by Kirkby Stephen Discharge of conditions attached to planning 1-4 GASGARTH MEWS, KIRKBY Mr Martin Bowman REFUSED Cond approval 10/0010. STEPHEN, CA17 4RY

14/1079 Outline Great Salkeld Outline planning permission for residential TOWNHEAD FARM, GREAT Peter Ousby and North APPROVED Application development to include vehicular access and layout SALKELD, PENRITH, CA11 9NA Associates (siting).

15/0255 Full Application Cliburn Proposed development of 4 No affordable houses. LEITH CLOSE, CLIBURN, PENRITH, Mitre Housing APPROVED CA10 3AG Association - Ms R Field

15/0922 Full Application Long Marton Conversion of shed to 2no dwellings and erection of FORMER RAIL GOODS RJ & SM Cowan APPROVED ancillary garages. SHED/YARD, LONG MARTON, APPLEBY,

15/0923 Listed Building Long Marton Listed building consent for the conversion of shed to FORMER RAIL GOODS RJ & SM Cowan APPROVED 2no dwellings and erection of ancillary garages. SHED/YARD, LONG MARTON, APPLEBY,

15/1072 Full Application Brough Proposed erection of a dwelling. LAND ADJ TO ATKINSONS Mr S Atkinson - APPROVED EARTHMOVERS, AUGILL HOUSE Atkinsons Earthmovers FARM, BROUGH, KIRKBY STEPHEN,

16/0054 Full Application Penrith Removal of existing Dutch barn, erection of 2no. PLUMPTON HEAD, PLUMPTON, Mr & Mrs Threlfell APPROVED Affordable dwellings (use classification C3) and PENRITH, CA11 9NP change of use and extension of 2no agricultural buildings to comprise a market dwelling (use classification C3).

16/0056 Full Application Penrith Variation of condition no 2 (plans compliance) CARLETON MANOR PARK, HIGH Cumbrian Homes APPROVED attached to planning approval 08/0295 comprising of CARLETON, PENRITH, CA11 8AL amendments to the design.

16/0174 Outline Lazonby Outline planning application for a detached dwelling INGLE NEUK, LAZONBY, PENRITH, Mr & Mrs S Middleton - APPROVED Application and garage. CA10 1AJ PS Potter Trustees

16/0299 Full Application Penrith Extension to existing residential block to create two ACORN GUEST HOUSE, Ms J Ruffley - Atkinson APPROVED additional residential units. SCOTLAND ROAD, PENRITH, CA11 Building Contractors 9HL

04 November 2016 Page 1 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

16/0302 Full Application Greystoke Proposed cattle housing, midden and bale store. NEWSHAM FARM, HUTTON ROOF, Ms Pat Elliott-Pat Elliott APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 0XX & Nigel Walker

16/0303 Full Application Greystoke Proposed sheep housing. NEWSHAM FARM, HUTTON ROOF, Ms P Elliott APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 0XX

16/0435 Reserved by Brough Discharge of conditions 3 (site establishment), 4 CHRIST CROFT, BROUGH, KIRKBY Willan Trading - Mr J APPROVED Cond (highways) and 5 (drainage) of approved planning STEPHEN, CA17 4DB Willan application 15/0948.

16/0480 Full Application Kirkby Thore Change of use of a former methodist chapel to single METHODIST CHURCH, CHAPEL Methodist Circuit - Mr B REFUSED dwelling. LANE, KIRKBY THORE, PENRITH, Thornborrow CA10 1UH

16/0482 Full Application Hartley Application for variation of condition 2 of approval KIRKBY VIEW, HARTLEY, KIRKBY Mr & Mrs Hind APPROVED 15/1158 to increase roof height and add balcony to STEPHEN, CA17 4JJ bedroom window (as revised).

16/0488 Full Application Penrith Extension and alterations to existing vehicle THE DEPOT, OLD LONDON ROAD, Council APPROVED maintenance building to provide additional office and PENRITH, CA11 8GU storage areas, all within B1 use class.

16/0620 Listed Building Penrith Listed building consent for replacement of wooden 11 ALBERT STREET, PENRITH, Mrs C Bale APPROVED window and door frames at the rear of the property. CA11 7XA

16/0652 Reserved Matters Hesket Reserved matters relating to appearance, COOPERS CLOSE, HIGH HESKET, Mrs McManus- APPROVED landscaping, layout and scale for approval 13/0746 CARLISLE, CA4 0JD McManus Builders Ltd for 11 dwellings.

16/0655 Full Application Ousby Erection of 3 dwellings (retrospective). LAND AT MELMERBY HALL, Rowley Estates - Mr & REFUSED MELMERBY, PENRITH, CA10 1HB Mrs Rowley

16/0675 Advertisement Clifton Proposed advertisements in association with LAND TO SOUTH OF VALLEY Story Homes-Mr A APPROVED proposed adjacent housing development. ROAD, CLIFTON, PENRITH, McNally

16/0690 Full Application Ousby Proposed extensions to farmhouse and change of MOOR HOUSE, MELMERBY, Mr & Mrs A & J Batey APPROVED use of barn to create additional living space. PENRITH, CA10 1HA

16/0702 Listed Building Appleby Listed building consent for the attachment of rails to 16 CHAPEL STREET, APPLEBY-IN- Mr & Mrs S & J Bellas APPROVED the side of each external doorway up to a height of WESTMORLAND, CA16 6QR 1.2 meters.

16/0707 Advertisement Penrith Erection of a directional sign. LAND BY THE A686, NORTH OF Mrs L Jackson APPROVED CARLETON FARM SHOP, PENRITH,

16/0710 Full Application Bolton Development of 3 houses. STEPHENSON CROFT, BOLTON, Mr J Mullen APPROVED APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6BE

04 November 2016 Page 2 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

16/0711 Full Application Culgaith Proposed garage extension to the front elevation. OTTERS HOLT, CULGAITH, Mr & Mrs M APPROVED PENRITH, CA10 1QE Cowperthwaite

16/0715 Full Application Appleby Proposed conversion of existing stable/loft barn to 44 BOROUGHGATE, APPLEBY-IN- Mr & Mrs W.R. APPROVED domestic dwelling. WESTMORLAND, CA16 6XG Earnshaw

16/0716 Listed Building Appleby Proposed conversion of existing stable/loft barn to 44 BOROUGHGATE, APPLEBY-IN- Mr & Mrs W.R. APPROVED domestic dwelling within curtilage of a listed building. WESTMORLAND, CA16 6XG Earnshaw

16/0720 Full Application Skelton Proposed renovations and side extensions. CROWN FARM, UNTHANK, Mr And Mrs Gillett APPROVED SKELTON, PENRITH, CA11 9TG

16/0721 Listed Building Skelton Listed building consent to renovate and erect a side CROWN FARM, UNTHANK, Mr and Mrs Gillett APPROVED extension. SKELTON, PENRITH, CA11 9TG

16/0726 Listed Building Milburn Listed building consent for conversion of redundant MILBURN COURT, MILBURN, The Milburn Trust APPROVED former farm buildings to provide 5 dwellings and PENRITH, including clearance of derelict buildings to provide new garage block and shared amenity space (revision to14/0079).

16/0727 Full Application Milburn Variation of condition 2 ( plans compliance) attached MILBURN COURT, REAR AND SIDE The Milburn Trust APPROVED to planning approval 14/0078 comprising of OF MILBURN HOUSE, MILBURN, amendments to the design of unit 3. PENRITH, CA10 1TN

16/0735 Full Application Dacre Two storey side extension, rear sun room and single 2 THE PAVILION, STAINTON, CA11 Mr & Mrs G. Armstrong APPROVED storey front extension. 0EA

16/0738 Full Application Greystoke Single storey extension to existing dwelling. Change HERDWICK LODGE, MOTHERBY, Mr B Abbott APPROVED of use of former field to garden. PENRITH, CA11 0RL

16/0741 Full Application Skelton Extension of the existing bungalow and for a revised STONELEA, SKELTON, PENRITH, Mrs P Burton APPROVED footprint and layout for the existing garage. CA11 9TE

16/0749 Full Application Penrith Change of use from commercial to domestic dwelling THREE CROWNS HOUSE, Mr S Blenkinship APPROVED house. BLUEBELL LANE, PENRITH, CA11 7PH

16/0754 Full Application Appleby Proposed front entrance porch extension. 21 RIVINGTON PARK, APPLEBY-IN- Mr & Mrs R Ingham APPROVED WESTMORLAND, CA16 6HU

16/0755 Full Application Lowther Retrospective application for storage building. 7 WOODLAND CLOSE, Mr M Lamb APPROVED HACKTHORPE, PENRITH, CA10 2HY

16/0769 Notice of Intention Orton Change of use of agricultrual building to B8 storage MOOR HOUSE, ORTON, PENRITH, Mr A Hulme APPROVED use. CA10 3SA

04 November 2016 Page 3 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

16/0771 Full Application Skelton Proposed agricultural machinery store. INTACK HOUSE, MIDDLESCEUGH, Mr Fisher-WH Fisher & APPROVED IVEGILL, CARLISLE, CA4 0QF Son

16/0773 Listed Building Alston Listed building consent to demolish existing facilities South Tynedale APPROVED block and replace with new accessible facilities, café PRESERVATION SOCIETY, Railway Preservation and kitchen. STATION HOUSE, STATION ROAD, ALSTON, CA9 3JB

16/0781 Listed Building Listed building consent for the installation of oak ACORN BANK, TEMPLE SOWERBY, Miss S Dennett APPROVED coach gates into existing arch in courtyard. PENRITH, CA10 1SP

16/0783 Full Application Dacre Proposed single dwelling. SNUFF MILL LANE, STAINTON, Mr Bruce Armstrong- APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 0ES Payne

16/0784 Full Application Great Salkeld Proposed refurbishment and single storey extensions STONEY GREEN, NORTH DYKES, Mr & Mrs K Sutton APPROVED including external and internal alterations. GREAT SALKELD, PENRITH, CA11 9ND

16/0785 Full Application Penrith Siting of four storage containers for domestic and 29 BOWERBANK WAY, PENRITH, Mr S B Thompson APPROVED general storage. CA11 9BQ

16/0787 Outline Culgaith Outline planning application for the erection of LAND AT LOANING HEAD, LAND Church Commissioners APPROVED Application residential development including associated access OFF STATION ROAD, CULGAITH, for - Mr M and amenity spaces. PENRITH, Naylor

16/0790 Advertisement Appleby Advertisement consent for the display of 3 no. signs. FOUR SEASONS, CHAPEL STREET, Mr A Smyth - Walkers APPROVED APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, Funeral Directors CA16 6QR

16/0794 Advertisement Tebay Proposed display of 2 no. internally illuminated JUNCTION 38 MOTORWAY Ms Elaine Clark - APPROVED advertisements. SERVICES, OLD TEBAY, PENRITH, Westmorland Ltd CA10 3SS

16/0795 Full Application Skelton Proposed extension to dwelling. LOW WATERS, IVEGILL, CARLISLE, Mr & Mrs Burbury APPROVED CA4 0PW

16/0801 Full Application Culgaith Playground development. KIRKLAND AND Kirkland & Blencarn APPROVED VILLAGE HALL, BLENCARN, Recreation Room PENRITH, CA10 1TX Committee

16/0802 Full Application Hesket Erection of detached garage. WOODLANDS, SOUTHWAITE, Mr J Askew APPROVED CARLISLE, CA4 0NB

16/0803 Full Application Kirkby Stephen Change of use from commercial (gymnasium) to POTLANDS HOUSE, SOUTH ROAD, Mr P Bowman APPROVED residential. KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4SY

04 November 2016 Page 4 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

16/0808 Tree Works Penrith T3 Oak: 1) Crown raise all around to 4-5m above 27 THE PARKLANDS, PENRITH, Mr P Huggett APPROVED (TPO) ground level, shortening branches to suitable CA11 8TF growing points; 2) Shorten back branches over garage to create 3-4m seperation distance; To allow light into garden and air circulation; Tree Preservation Order No 123, 2005, The Parklands, Penrith.

16/0809 Full Application Stainmore Proposed single storey front extension. LOW FIELD, SOUTH STAINMORE, Mr & Mrs A Masters APPROVED KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4DJ

16/0810 Cert. of Lawful Penrith Lawful development certificate for installation of , Network Railways APPROVED customer information screen, CCTV and ULLSWATER ROAD, PENRITH, Infrastructure Ltd replacement PA system infrastructure. CA11 7JQ

16/0812 Listed Building Newby Listed building consent for the installation of 2 no. SOUTH VIEW, NEWBY, PENRITH, Mr D Leese APPROVED velux windows to rear of dwelling. CA10 3EX

16/0817 Reserved by Greystoke Discharge of conditions 3 (caravan) and 4 (drainage) LAND AT GREYSTOKE GILL, Mr & Mrs D Morrison APPROVED Cond attached to approval 16/0347. GREYSTOKE, PENRITH,

16/0822 Full Application Penrith Removal of condition 3 (local occupancy) attached to 38 WOODLANDS, BRIDGE LANE, Mr M Oakley APPROVED approval 05/1008. PENRITH, CA11 8GW

16/0828 Notice of Intention Castle Sowerby Proposed agricultural lean-to building. WELL HOUSE, HESKET Mr D Strong APPROVED NEWMARKET, , CA7 8HT

16/0830 Full Application Penrith Erection of single storey side extension for additional 1 SPRING BANK, GRAHAM Mr D Dryden APPROVED living accommodation and garden store. STREET, PENRITH, CA11 9LD

16/0835 Advertisement Penrith Advertisement consent for 4 no. internally illuminated HOMEBARGAINS, ROBERT VIRTUE T J Morris Ltd APPROVED signs. BUILDING, ULLSWATER ROAD, PENRITH, CA11 7JQ

16/0856 Notice of Intention Skelton Proposed agricultural building. LANDSFOOT, CALTHWAITE, Mr S Armstrong - Mr T APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 9PT Armstrong & Son

16/0857 Tree Works Penrith T1 Sycamore: Remove the lower branch on the left, LONSDALE VILLA, FELL LANE, Ms J Ruffley - Atkinson APPROVED (TPO) the small 3 inch branch on the right and stubs; T2 PENRITH, CA11 8AA Building Contractors Ltd Ash: Remove the lowest branch on the left; T7 Oak: Remove lower overhanging limb and smaller limb back to the section where it had been originally trimmed; Due to excessive shading and amenity value of the development under construction; Tree Preservation Order No 173, 2016, Lonsdale Villa, Penrith.

04 November 2016 Page 5 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

16/0858 Tree Works (CA) Penrith 1) Remove Cherry tree leaning into T10 Yew; 2) LONSDALE VILLA, FELL LANE, Ms J Ruffley - Atkinson APPROVED Remove overhanging branch from Ash on the PENRITH, CA11 8AA Building Contractors Ltd northern side to T10 Yew; Works to trees in Penrith New Streets Conservation Area not covered by TPO173.

16/0859 Tree Works (CA) Penrith Remove dying Elder tree to ground level; Reduce FAIR BANK, GRAHAM STREET, Mr Mark Bowes APPROVED Laurel as depicted in photograph provided; Penrith PENRITH, CA11 9LE New Streets Conservation Area.

16/0860 Tree Works (CA) Appleby Remove Sycamore tree (due to instability and BONGATE MILL FARMHOUSE, MILL Cricket Kemp APPROVED damage to retaining wall); Appleby Conservation HILL, APPLEBY-IN- Area. WESTMORLAND, CA16 6UR

16/0861 Tree Works (CA) Penrith 1) Birch: Reduce branches to gain 1m clearance of 21 ARTHUR STREET, PENRITH, Susan Davies APPROVED 20 Arthur Street; 2) Holly / Rhody / Weeping Ash: CA11 7TU Cut back to side of flags on top of wall (20 Arthur Street); 3) Green Gauge: Crown raise lower branches off wall (20 Arthur Street) and retain upper canopy; Penrith New Streets Conservation Area.

16/0862 Tree Works (CA) Penrith Silver Birch tree: Fell due to excessive shading to MOLOGERS, WORDSWORTH Mr Trevor Keith APPROVED small garden; growing into communication wires and STREET, PENRITH, CA11 7QY low amenity value; Penrith New Streets Conservation Area.

16/0864 Reserved by Milburn Discharge of condition 4 (sample materials) attached RYLUKEAN BARN, MILBURN, Mr S Johnson APPROVED Cond to approval 16/0566. PENRITH, CA10 1TW

16/0865 Householder 4m x 4m footprint rear extension. 2.5m eaves, 3.5m 1 SALKELD ROAD, LANGWATHBY, Mr J Dulson APPROVED PD/PN ridge. Mostly glazing down to a dwarf wall, with slate PENRITH, CA10 1ND roof.

16/0875 Non-Material Penrith Non material amendment to approval 16/0117, FRENCHFIELD, BROUGHAM, Mr F Glassford APPROVED Amend comprising of relocation of garage door and addition PENRITH, CA10 2AA of quoins to sunroom and porch extensions.

16/0876 Non-Material Hesket Non-material amendment to approval 12/0714 to SPRINGTHWAITE, CALTHWAITE, Mr A Benson APPROVED Amend repace glass roof with slate roof on conservatory. PENRITH, CA11 9QX

16/0893 Reserved by Castle Sowerby Discharge of condition 3 (drainage) attached to LOW CURRIGG, SEBERGHAM, Alan Stobart-Fuel and APPROVED Cond approval 16/0553. CARLISLE, CA5 7DX Distribution

04 November 2016 Page 6 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

In relation to each application it was considered whether the proposal was appropriate having regard to the Development Plan, the representations which were received including those from consultees and all other material considerations. In cases where the application was approved the proposal was considered to be acceptable in planning terms having regard to the material considerations. In cases where the application was refused the proposal was not considered to be acceptable having regard to the material and relevant considerations. In all cases it was considered whether the application should be approved or refused and what conditions, if any, should be imposed to secure an acceptable form of development.

04 November 2016 Page 7 of 7