Environment Agency Plan
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
E n v ir o n m e n t Ag e n c y West Midlands - Tame Local Environment Agency Plan Statement of Public Consultation Summary of Public Consultation process March 1998-June 1998 E n v ir o n m e n t Ag e n c y NATIONAL LIBRARY & INFORMATION SERVICE m i d l a n d s r e g i o n 10 Warwick Road Olton, Solihull B 9 2 7 HX ENVIRONMENT AGENCY 0 4 8 9 7 0 Foreword The Environment Agency is committed to public consultation. -Within the Local Environment Agency Plan (LEAP) process, public consultation is an important building block for developing the Agency’s own action programme and in building partnerships with external organisations. We undertake an extensive public consultation exercise with local authorities, business, environmental pressure groups and amenity societies as well as with the general public. This statement presents the comments that were received during the public consultation period on the West Midlands - Tame LEAP Consultation Report. The LEAP Consultation Report and Action Plan have been produced by the Upper Trent Area of the Environment Agency, one of four areas within the Midlands Region. The West Midlands - Tame area covers all of the land that drains to the River Tame above Kingsbury and includes Birmingham, the Black Country and Solihull. If you require any further information regarding the West Midlands - Tame LEAP please contact: LEAP Planner Sentinel House 9 Wellington Crescent Fradley Park Lichfield Staffordshire WSI3 8RR Tel/Minicom: 01543 444141 Ext 4886 Fax: 01543 444161 e-mail: [email protected] Philip Burns Area Manager Upper Trent Area Contents Page 1 Review of the Consultation Process 1 2 Summary of Responses 2 3 Comments Received and the Agency’s Response 4 4 List of Errors and Omissions to the Consultation Report 36 5 Summary of Local Seminar Discussions 39 Appendices 50 West Midlands — Tame LEAP Documents:- West Midlands - Tame Consultation Report - March 1998 West Midlands - Tame Statement of Public Consultation (March 1998 - June 1998) West Midlands - Tame Action Plan - March 1999 These documents are available free from the Environment Agency’s Upper Trent Office. If you wish to obtain any copies please contact: LEAP Planner Environment Agency Sentinel House Wellington Crescent Fradley Park Lichfield Staffordshire WS13 8RR Tel: 01543 444141 1 Review of the Consultation Process 1.1 Background The West Midlands Tame LEAP Consultation Report was launched for public consultation by the Environment Agency on 25 March 1998. The consultation report and summary leaflets were given to individuals and organisations with the opportunity to comment on the report and on local environmental problems. Comments were received as letters, faxes and completed questionnaires, the questionnaires were attached to the consultation reports and summary leaflets together with pre-paid envelopes. 1.2 Informal Consultation In July 1997 the Agency wrote to 87 key groups, local authorities and other representative bodies asking for comments on the Agency’s initial list of issues and problems affecting the environment in the area. The consultation formed an important part in the development of the document. In total, 32 replies were received. All comments from this initial information gathering consultation exercise were considered and, where appropriate, were incorporated into the consultation report. A local advisory committee made up of individuals who live and work in the area supports Upper Trent Area. This committee, the Area Environment Group (AEG) takes a particular interest in LEAPs and an AEG sub-group was formed to consider the issues and draft documents. The sub-group made a valuable contribution to the development of the Consultation Report and the Action Plan. The sub-group consisted of: Dr Peter Bottom ley Regional Fisheries Advisory Committee Ian Nichol Groundwork Birmingham Duncan Wemyss British Secondary Metals Association Michael White CBI Midlands, fMI Dr Helen Whitehouse Inland Waterways Association 1.3 Formal Consultation The consultation report was launched on 25 March 1998 via a widespread local press release. The launch marked the start of a three-month consultation period that ended on 25 June 1998. During that time the report was promoted by: • Radio and TV interviews, press releases and public notices in the press. • Distribution of over 8,000 summary leaflets which included a questionnaire. • Display boards at libraries throughout the plan area. • Copies of the report placed on deposit at local authority offices and libraries. • 2 consultation seminars in Walsall and Birmingham. i g:\wordproc\scnthse\leapsWestmitis\Comments Received (jeg-klb) Summary of Responses 2.1 Responses Received A total of 76 written responses to the consultation exercise were received - 42 letters and 34 questionnaires. The response was encouraging, with those consultees who responded representing a wide cross section of interests. All letters and questionnaires were acknowledged and detailed follow-ups were sent to the majority of those who responded. All comments have been considered and where appropriate and practicable, were incorporated into the Action Plan. During the consultation process and via the responses, many organisations expressed an interest in working in partnership with the Agency towards resolving issues highlighted in the report. We received many helpful and welcome suggestions. Errors and omissions were also highlighted, and these are summarised at the end of this report. The consultation process has given the Agency a more comprehensive understanding of the issues and options presented in the LEAP and of the public's concern in the area. The information received in the 34 questionnaires was analysed and each of the 26 issues placed in order of importance and popularity. The most important issues were: Issue 1 Biodiversity Issue 6 Investment by Severn Trent Water Limited to improve water quality Issue 16 Litter and the aesthetic pollution of rivers and canals Issue 20 Sustainable Waste Management The most popular issues were: Issue 3 Enhancement of watercourse corridors in urban areas for wildlife Issue 6 Investment by Severn Trent Water Limited to improve water quality Issue 12 Contaminated Land Issue 16 Litter and the aesthetic pollution of rivers and canals Issue 20 Sustainable Waste Management The responses received indicate that watercourse improvements in terms of water quality, improved aesthetic appearance, the creation of wildlife habitats and better access to the waterside are major concerns to the local community. There is also a general concern about waste production and its disposal. The letters and questionnaires raised a number of new issues that included: • Provision of bends/meanders in rivers • Implications to the environment of large scale use of genetically modified organisms • Industrial development in the green belt from Minworth along the A38 corridor to Bassetts Pole • Transportation of radioactive waste through and over the West Midlands • New housing developments on greenfield/brownfield sites and the provision of proper public transport when greenfield sites are unavoidable • Canalside improvements away from the high profile areas of Gas Street Basin and the National Indoor Arena • The proposed restoration of the Dudley No.2 canal • Proposals for improved access to the Titford canal • Production of Water Level Management Plans 2 s»:\wordproc\sentlisc\leaps\wcstmiiIs\Comments Received fjeg-klb) Summary of Responses The Agency has considered the responses received and the new issues raised. With the exception of Water Level Management Plans (incorporated as a new issue) the suggested issues have not been included in the action plan. Some are already covered by the everdav work of the Agency or, as in the case of canal restoration, the Agency has limited responsibility or funding available for such schemes. Others, such as housing developments and transport, are outside the remit of the Agency. Changes to existing issues are identified in the activity tables in Section 4 of the Action Plan. The plan reflects a balance between the opinions expressed and the need to ensure a feasible and workable plan. 3 g:\wordproc\senthse\leaps\westmids\Comments Received (jeg-klb) 3 Com men Is Received and Agency’s Response Organisation/ Section Comments . Response Individual Anonymous Issues Limitation on population growth. This is an issue for local planning authorities. The Agency rccognises that higher population density tends to increase pressures on the environment. (See Issue 1 in the Action Plan). General Not enough trees in area or in plan. Comment noted. The Agency supports tree planting provided that it does not cause harm to the local environment. Anon General Government Policy of giving grants to foreign This is an issue for the government. The Agency developers to come to Britain should not apply to would, in principle, support a policy that encouraged greenfield sites. Grants should be to help clean vacant brown field development in preference to greenfield old industrial sites. (Offered a choice between the two development. automatically means greenfields will be chosen). General Birmingham already employs 50% more than ils This is an issue needing regional and local working resident population (workers from outside consideration. The Agency would in principle, Birmingham). This means unnecessary travelling hence support integrated planning measures that minimise pollution. New jobs should be where a shortage exists, traffic. not given to greedy Birmingham. New Issue Birmingham City Council plans for industrial This is an issue for Birmingham City Council. The development in green bell from Minworth all along A38 Agency does not generally support the release of to Bassetts Pole. green belt for urban development. Anon General Urban wildlife slill requires non-public areas to breed Comments noted. This will be addressed in Issue 3 of away from people and dogs. the Action Plan. 4 g:Vwor(Jproc\scnllisc\lcaj>s\\v»:siiiiiils\CommL*ii[s RtxdvLd (jcy-klb) 3 Comments Received and Agency’s Response Organisation/ Section Comments Response Individual Mr C Ashmore New Issues Slowing down rivers in places by widening or giving Comments noted.