Venice Distinguished Itself from the Other Italian City States by Being A
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
OCTAVIA REINCARNATED: BUSENELLO’S AND MONTEVERDI’S L’INCORONAZIONE DI POPPEA JACQUES BOOGAART Venice distinguished itself from the other Italian city states by being a republic, without a court and its luxurious display of theatrical spectacle; it was a much envied commercial town, governed by its wealthy oligarchy in a complex manner of election in order to prevent the predominance of a single family. During the seventeenth century its prosperity was already in decline but the city still attracted hosts of foreigners and functioned, as it still does, as a place to divert the senses, especially during its famous Carnival which started at the feast of St Stephen (26 December) and ended on Shrove Tuesday. When in 1637 the opera L’Andromeda was performed by the travelling company of Francesco Manelli and Benedetto Ferrari in the (already existing) Teatro San Cassiano this was something of a nouveauté which was enthusiastically received and followed up in the succeeding years by many new works composed by Venetian librettists and musicians. Operas were performed in commercially exploited theatres where everyone who could afford a ticket attended; Venetian opera differed in this from court opera where admission was on invitation. 1637 may be thus called the birth year of public opera. Since the theatre directors – mostly members of the aristocratic class – were entrepreneurs, out for profit, they did not waste much money on lavish decorations, variety of instrumental colours, choirs and ballets, as had been the case with court opera which had to show off the wealth of the prince. Instead they concentrated on the most popular attraction: famous singers, accompanied by a small number of continuo instruments and a few strings. Stage settings were sumptuous, often with virtuosic machinery, but also standardized so as to be usable for more than one particular occasion. 38 Jacques Boogaart Although the genre was new to Venice, the city already housed a famous composer of opera. In 1613 the procurators of San Marco had appointed Claudio Monteverdi (1567-1643) as the basilica’s maestro di cappella. This position required the performance and composition of church music. Nevertheless, as his letters testify, his greatest interest remained the composition of theatrical music for which in his Mantuan years he had won great renown throughout Italy; he did not “let a day pass without making something in the genre of theatrical song”.1 Yet Monteverdi was not quick to respond to the new challenge of public opera; not before 1640 did he rework his famous Arianna from 1608, originally written for the Gonzaga court (the music of which is lost except for the famous Lamento), for performances on the Venetian stage. Only thereafter did he compose, probably stimulated by his friend, the librettist Giacomo Badoaro, in quick succession three operas in a wholly new style, Il ritorno d’Ulisse in patria (1640, libretto by Giacomo Badoaro), Le nozze di Enea e Lavinia (1641, libretto probably by Michelangelo Torcigliani, music lost) and, in the year of his death at the age of 76, L’incoronazione di Poppea.2 No opera from the seventeenth century has provoked so much dissent as L’incoronazione di Poppea, first performed during Carnival 1643 in the Teatro SS. Giovanni e Paolo, to a libretto by the Venetian aristocrat and lawyer Gian Francesco Busenello (1598-1659), and set to music by an aged and sickly Monteverdi, with, as is generally assumed, additions and modifications by younger composers.3 The ongoing discussion caused by the uncertain status and evaluation of the sources sometimes goes even so far as to deny Monteverdi’s authorship for almost all of the music,4 but in general scholars 1 Letter to Alessandro Striggio, 4 April 1620: “...non mancherò alla giornata di far qualche cosa in tal genere di canto rapresentativo...”, in Claudio Monteverdi: Lettere, dediche e prefazioni, ed. Domenico de’ Paoli, Rome 1973, 163. Where not otherwise indicated, translations are my own. 2 Between L’Arianna and his last operas several theatrical works are known to have been performed but they are for the most part lost: see Tim Carter, Monteverdi’s Musical Theatre, New Haven, CT and London, 2002, 197-236. 3 The additions include the famous final duet of which the text is certainly not by Busenello and the music probably not by Monteverdi. For the authorship of the music, see especially Alan Curtis, “La Poppea impasticciata, or Who Wrote the Music to L‘Incoronazione (1643)?”, Journal of the American Musicological Society, XLII/1 (1989), 23-54. 4 As for example in the CD-booklet by Stefano Aresi accompanying the recording Il Nerone, ossia L’incoronazione di Poppea, by La Venexiana, dir. by Claudio Cavina, .