NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION
BROWNFIELD CLEANUP PROGRAM (BCP) EeL ARTICLE 271 TITLE 14
NAME Brooklyn Union Gas Company (BUG) [aka KeySpan Corporation (KeySpan)l National Grid USA 1
ADDRESS 1 MetroTech Center
CITYrTOWN Brooklyn, New York ZIP CODE 11201
PHONE (718) 643-4050 FAX 718-403-3 106 E-MAIL [email protected]
NAMEOFREQUESTOR'SREPRESENTATlVE David C. Lodemore, Vice President Environmental Services, National Grid USA
ADDRESS 25 Research Drive
CITY(fOWN Westborough, MA ZIP CODE 01582
PIIONE 508-389-2989 FAX 508-389-3518 E-MAIL [email protected]
NAME OF REQUESTOWS CONSULTANT GEl Consultants, Inc.
ADDRESS 455 Winding Brook Drive, Suite 201
ClTYrrOWN Glastonbury, CT ZIP CODE 06033 rllONE 860-368-5300 FAX 860-368-5307 E-MAIL [email protected]
NAMEOFREQUESTOR ·SATIORNEY Francis J. Murphy
ADDRESS 1 MetroTech Center
CITYITOWN Brooklyn, New York Z[PCOOE 11201
PHONE 718-403-2855 FAX 718-403-3106 E-MAIL fmurphy1@keyspanenergy,com
THE REQUESTOR MUST CERTIFY THAT HE/SHE IS EITHER A PARTIC IPA NT OR VOLUNTEER IN ACCORDANCE WITH ECL § 27 -1405 (I) ElY CHECKING ONE Ol'THE BOXP..s BELOW:
DVOLUNTEER rcquC$tor who either 1) was the owner of the s ite at the lime oflhe disposal A rcqliestor olherlhun a participant, including a rcqucstorwhose liabillty arises solcly of h"711rdO ll , waste or discharge of petroleum or 2) is otherwise a perSall as a resull of ownership, operation of or involvement with the SilO sllbsC Rcqucstor Relationship to Property (check one): D Cnrrelll OWller D Potential fFuturc Purchascr DOthcr______ lfrcqucstor is not (he site OWller, requestor willlmvc access to t111~ properly thrOllghout Ilw Bel' projccl_ 0ycs (Note: proof of site access must Ix: submiuc(l for non-owners) Page 1 of 6 NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERV ATION BROWNFIELD CLEANUP PROGRAM (BCP) EeL AI{TICLE 27 r'TITLE 14 DEPARTMENT USE ONLY NAl0.E City of New York ADDRESS 253 Broadway, 14th Floor CITY/TOWN New York, NY loU' CQDE 10007 PHONE 212-7a8~2937 FAX 212-788-2941 NAME OF REQUESTOR 'S REPRESENTATfVE Robert Kulikowski ADDRESS 253 14th Floor C!TYrTOWN New York, NY ZlrCOD!' 10007 rHONE 212-788-2937 FAX 212-788-2941 j1.,.·..t... IL [email protected] NAME OF REQUESTOR'S CONSL'LTANT ADDRESS CITYfrOWN ZIP conE PHONE -FAX NAME OF REQUESTOR'S ATTORNEY ADDRESS CITYffOV'[t.i l.WCODE PHONE FAX THE REQUESTOR MU ST CERTlFY THAT lU;';SI-rE IS EITHER. A PARTICIPANT OR VOl.UNTBER ]}.i ACCORDA I.JCE WITH Eet. § 27~14(\5 (1) BY C'rlECKJNG ONE OF THE BOXES BELOW: [2]VOLUNTEER A 'cq~cstorwh{) either I) WilS" lhe Q""'Wr d IIx; site at the time of the disjXl:>al A requestor other (han a participant, ind udil1g" rcquG.ltor wh RcqUCS(()1 Rciai;(ln.hip to Properly (ChflCk "n~) ' o Po If r~ql:c,wr L~ uo! the site owner, f"'l>Je.'\()r will hav ~ ace",,", to the prOp"r!y ihf[)\]J'hout the Bep pmjccl. (N ote: prc,Ot of,ile aCCess musl be J;ub!r.i({w fot 'wn-O'<-'l1em) Page la of 6 NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION BROWNFIELD CLEANUP PROGRAM (Hep) EeL ARTICLE 27 ( TITLE J4 NAME:: Vichar, inc.! Harvie Intemaiionai ltd. ADDRESS 10 West 33rd Street ClTY/TOWN New York, NY ZlfCODt:: 10001 PHONE 212-967 ~6 666 fAX 212.868-3039 NA;"1EOfREQUE~'OR·SREPRESRNTATJVF Henry Abadl ADDRESS 10 West 33rd Street CITY/TOWN New York, NY Z!P CODE 10003 PHO:-''E 212-967-6666 FAX 212-868-3039 E·MAIL harvic@ao!.oorn NAME OF RHQUESTOR>S CCl-NSULTANT cnwrr,}WN 21I'·COI)E PHONE FAX NAME OF REQUESTOR'S ATTOR?IEY AnfJRESS lfrCODf:: FAX THE RP.\)UESTOR MUSTCERTJ1"YTHAT f l E I S~lE lS EITHER A !'AKDCll'M'T OR VOL.UNTEER l ~ ACCOROAN(:B wm! EeL ~ 2/,j4()5 (Il BY CHECK!NG ONE OF Tl-!E BOXES BELOW 0VOLUNTEBR I[ ~~;::~ .';; who:':';::::: c·i:l,ncr I) W~B tID {\WnCTO l lbe site nll.h.t:>. Il rII ,,(Jflh~ o C"It~n! Owner If ("'l'lcsior io nol the sil~. oWfi~r, r""lu~s lo! Wl ll l,avc ",",co:.,,,, tIl ! h.~ pTOp~-ny llmJughmL! the BCP pnojiX'i. (N(l]c : pmo f(J f ~ ; t::o ucce~~ /11"" t fw submill ~ d J",!>(llH'WIlt:I:l) Page Ib of 6 NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION BROWNFIELD CLEAl'l'UP PROGRAM (RCP) EeL ARTICLE 27 / TITLE J 4 DEPARTMENT USE ONlY NAME Harvie !nternaiionalltd. ADDRESS 10 West 33rd Street CITYrrOWN New York, NY lU'CODE 10001 PHONE 212-967-6666 FAX 212-868-3039 N;'.M8 OF RJ!QUflSTOR'S REPRESENT ATIV1: Henry Abadi I AHDR"SS 1 0 West 33rd Street ClTyrrOWN New York, NY ZlP CODE 10003 i PHONE 212~967 -666B FAX 212-868w3039 E-MA!L harvic@aoLcom "lAME or REQUESTOR'S CONSULTA.NT AnDRESS ZIJlCODE PHQNE ,Ii-MArL NAME elf' REQUi FAX &-MAlL THI! REQU ESTOR MUSTCf:RTJFY THAT HF.JSBE rs EiTHER A I'ARTl.Of'ANTOR VOLUNTEER IN ACCORDANCE \Vr111 Eel. § 27-!40~ (l)BY CffECKiJ-.fG ONE OF THB BOXf'-S BELOW: [Z]VOLUNTEER I'~~:;:;,~';":' ~;'~:; h''' ' .w, theown~f (l f j h0n ; lc "t tlw lime ofth~,Ji:;I' Rcqucs\Vf RclaliQm:hip to P'mrcrl)' (,bc~k Ime): I 0 Curren( OWlJer D ]'olCm,aj !l" "hw~ f'1)T~h~I><" (f~'~M.. i('f;J not the ';;lC ,"".-..: r, r~Ja>:HJr will h~ve aoxes, IU ihe pru-pcrty lhrC'ughm'llM BCP I'roje~L (NNe: ptoof Page lc of 6 ' ... ::.--. '_'-/0 '. $. '~tion n .ffop~;:;'")~ iQ rmaIiOn ~~",~j' '1C~ ~~et ,. .. ' .. i i.· -~:":: .. Carrell Gardens! Public Place MGP Site PROP ER lY NAME: -- ADIJR!'.-SSfLOCAfION Ir.!ursoctkm (If Smith Street & 5th Sireet CITYn'OWN BrOoklyn ZIJ' COO!' 11231 -- M1)NICJr AUTYIi F 1>-1 0RE nrAN ON P.:. l.I Sr ALL ), City of New York! Borough of Brooklyn cn U'>I IV Kings SHE SIZE (ACReS) 10 3 40 os .. . L "TIT UOIO ( ![OR! 70"''TAL REI' ER~. :-O CE IM 'l lI M: HOI{fZi }NTALCOI .l ECTIOr-: Mf:niQD o SURVEY [(] GI'S 0 M..,r ~Jorth A/n(lIICall Oatum j83) FOR I! AClj PA RCEL, riLL OUT n m I'(}U.DWING H , X 1,1,"-1' l!'fOR).lA 1'101'1 (1 [11'»1', !ha ~ three ;>a=I" "nacn ~ ddiliomllrlr() n nJ I "'n ) l'<1I'cc[ A 2. I ~ the require.:1 r,ropl;;rty map :.lIa thcd t.) Ihe applicarion? (applleutioll wi ll no! bt: proco:.. ;~ \!<. 1 without map) 0yes ONo 1. ISlhc property p ~ t1 ofa dcsi gnutC't] En-zone pti r.s Wtll l1() Ta~ Law § 21 (bX6),! D Yes iZINn For more illfu llna~i() n go to: hnp:/lwww .nylovcsb iz.com/Brow I I F idu_ Re dev c 10pmcn I/de riml! ,a sp. If yes, identify lIre~ (H allie) _, ..... _ >" " . _, ~""., , """ .. _--_. __ .,------_.... _------.---.-- - '- ' . D 50% 0 100% of t1lc sile i~ inUlc En-;;onc (clleek one) 1" WI'f.!!.TY m:,SU IJI'TION NARRA'l'IV!:: See Section II Attachment "--"" -- Ll~ T ()f bxistlng Easement s (lyJl<.' here ur II ttuch in formation) 1 ~: l1scmcnt I [o lder Dcscri l'lion New Yo rk Cit ~· Department of Environmental Prot(;c;tion Bond Lorai n e - Sewe r~ Parcel l. II, III Brooklyn Union Gas Company (BUG) Natural Gas Pipeline and Tunnel ~Parcel II Li st of Penni!s is.<;uc;d by the NYSDEC or USEPA Rel[)ting to the: ?1'Qpo~d Si te ( (y p ~ here or ~tlach informatiOJ1) TII[1!: '~~ lJ illl; Agency Descri2lio(J None Page 2 of (j -ATTACHMENT Brownfield Cleanup Program (Bep) lECL Article 271 Title 14] Application Carron Gardens! Public Place MGP Site Brooklyn, New York Section n. Property Information Summary Sheet: Propert)' Description Narrative The Carroll Gardens! Public Place MOP site is located at the intersection of Smith Street and 5th Street in Brooklyn, New York, 11231. The Site consists of three parcels described in Section II of the BCP application. Site ownership information is presented below. Block and Lot Owner's NamA' ",nd Address Operator's Name and Address New York City (NYC) Department of NYC DCAS Citywide Administrative Servicas Block 47 1 Lot 1 Open Spoce Lot (DGAS) 1h [Parcel l] Smith Street and 5 Street One Centre Street. 1i n Floor South Brooklyn, New York 11231 Net'" York, New York 10007 New York City (NYC) Department of CilYli\lide Adm inistrative Services Ferrara Brothers Concrete Plant BlOCk 471 Lot 100 w (DCAS) 58 5 Street [Parcel II] 1 One Centre Street, 17 " Floor South Brooklyn, New York 11231 New York, New York 10007 Vichar, Inc. HMA Warehouse Block 471 Lot 200 10 West 33"1 Street 459 Smith Street [Parcel 1111 New York, New York 10001 Brooklyn, NY 1·,231 Note: For the remainder of this application Block 47 1, Lot 1 will be referred to as Parcel I; Block 471, Lot 100 will bereferroo to as Parcel II; and Block 471, Lot 200 will be referred to as Parcel III. The site consists of 10.3 acres. Parcels I, 11 , and III are zoned for industrial and manufacturing uses, and Parcels I and n are also designated in the New York City Zoning Resolution as "Public Place", a classification that these parcels are to be used for a public purpose. The site uses are noted above. The site is in Kings County, and the latitude is 40.6764"N, and the longitude is 73.9956° W. The site location is illustrated in Figure 1, taken fi:om a portion of H United States Geological Survey Topographic Map. A general site plan is presented on Figure 2, with source documentation as noted on the figure. Figure 3 provides infonnation regarding adjacent property information. The tax map for the site is provided in Figure 4. Page 2a List of Existing Easements There are two existing easements recorded for the siTe. The City of New York has an casement for a sewer and KeySpanfNationai Grid has two easements for natural gas improvements. A description of each existing easement is provided below. Easement Holder City of New York Description - sewer easement acquired by the City of New York as successor to the City of Brooklyn pursuant to L. 1879, C. 207. A survey of Lots I, 100 and 200 by Bart1ett, Ludlam & DiU, Order No. 91039, dated and revised in 1969, shows a 72-inch sewertraversing all dU'ce lots (Block 47 1, Lots 1,100 and 200), and :mother sewer extending southerly into Lo! 100 from the southerly end of 5tb Street and joining the 72-inch sewer, which is not shown on the accompanying tax map. Easement Holder National Glid Description - utility easement burdening two contiguous areas within Lot 100 benefiting National Grid as successor to the Brooklyn Union Gas Company, set fonh in a grant from Peter Galasso, lnc. to the Brooklyn Union Gas Company dated 6/9170 and recorded on 3/9171 in Rec1469, p. 1040. Easement 1 is a right of~way roughly IS-feet wide extending southerly into un 100 from tbe southerly end of Boy! Street. The easemem is for ingress and egress aDd the installation, maintenance and operation of gas mains, service pipes, telephone and electric lines. Easement 2 provides similar rights and additional rights for buildings and fencing and for machinery and a Tulmel Shaft. Page 2b SOURCE: Map created with TOPO! ®©2001 National Geographic o 2000 4000 (www.nationalgeographic.comItopo) -----SCALE, FEET - CARROLL GAROENS/PUBLIC PLACE MGPSITE BOROUGH OF BROOKLYN, NEW YORK SITE LOCATION MAP KEYSPAN CORPORATION March 2008 , K EYS ~',CITIZENS\Ba' N'f'Ll CATION\mIZEN S-LOCATI ON ,CDR z < " •w sc Z •" "~ zw w , 0 ,I ,0 eIY , ,c ~ , "~ , 0 0 > z w 0 •Z z ~ wo 3 ~ , • 3 . 8 u "0 Z 'w < \ "0 •m I \ ,>w I il" I 0 \ I \ \ , 0 \ w I \ ' I \ I , \ \ '\ ~ 1\ I I I \ ' " ~: , , , ! ," , , , • , 8 , ,• ~ ~ • , i . i , , ,· ~ ,i , ! ~ ," , "~~ ·, ~ ·,~ • , , l ! ., i , , , , , , ~ ! 5 ~ ); , ,• ,• ,• , , , , ! , , , , , , , , II !, ! I ! ! ! ! ,i ~ w~ " , I • u , ,\ ~ 0· ~ 0 , ~ , Dg i , I ~ ,t ~ ;i , ~~~ ~~ 1 ,'~ , ~ d~;i ~~ , ,8 {; ; ~.'~ , I , , .d~ "~8 , , 1-'" I • • ;- ~:I i! j ~5i ,~~ ~ ~ , I . ,}~ , • , " ! ~ 'j I ~e:~ ~' :; i y ~., , ,-1 G ~ I·,I ~; f1 , ! e,~i; C') ,1 ~ :; I ~.,:~ ' i' : ,• ". ,~ i1 8 ,,'-.'i id , 'I ~ ou A ~ ~ f', I ~ ,~ , , ~~ ~ I. B I I " :i 1~" • ~ ~ ,:1 " I ~r~ 8 ;~ I .-.--~ , ~ ~ , • ~ ~~ j '1 g, , ~e9 j •~ , ~~;~ ;~ , ":~ • ~~ :1 ~: I , :! ~;-)2; , " , j I ".-i [; , :~ ;~ , , , ,\~ : , ~ l; , "e, 1: ~ ~ ~ \i ~) :~ ~ ~d ! • , , , ;,,', • ] 5~~ ~~ , 1 • ~ yo;. , , ! , ~~ , ! , o~~ l ~ {, e, ; ~ , , , , " " ~ "* ~~~ '"~~ ~ ~;c I I I 8 f1 B N~ ~ •8 ~§ i I I I ~~~ " ~~ 1" " "eccc 'o , .:.~ LjJJ_ " ,, ' "C', :" J " "",,-,.,-- 1.3· I~' ... :'" . , .' .. : ~J.1._5Q r-r4~ ~. oJl ' SEC CO D!.·!'E :t:lJ.9J.g ~ - ·_ . _.~ ·:7 e},~ "', , ' ': SEE PAGE. 16 I :-:,,,,,..-',y C":::.' "-. ,.,. " ~ > v ,f " . h~:,\::. . :" :.' " '(--: '-:. - ,"''. ''' ·1 .. 471 -, ,( .. )', \ ,\ '\ ~\ ( \ ,, \ 0° UI--" '" .._, " " ' '0"";' - ~k. ." O~t>-~\) ~ , G(/ , \ " ,f' . " - . ,;".: 'SEESEC. , 4 S . t_ .. : .'_ " " " . GARDENSIPLELIC PLACE ' " SC"'t.I;, :,...~ ..,~ ... . M> ron CAR:~L , MGP SITE ./\ TAX ASSESSOR'S MAP 1CC 2CC BOROUGH OF BROOKLYN, NEW YORK err< OF ..,.. ' YOOK, EOOOO c.t< Of ""00"'Y" T.,," .' SSESSOO'S ~,.J' , SC.'.lE ' " • ro, "'rEO om."" ~-;J - sr... , r rrn KEYSPAN CORPORATION ADDRESS Alln: Deputy, Commissioner Lori Fie rstein, 1 Ce nlre Slreel, 17th F loor South CITVn'QWN New Yo rk ZIPCQDE 10007 PHONE 212-669-3645 FAX 212-313-3450 E·MAIL OPERATOR'S NAME (j ( different r:.""Il' ""luestor QTownerj ADDRESS ClTyrrowN ZIP cons If answering ''yes'' to any of Ihe followi ng questions, please provide an explan ation as un attachment. 1. Are OilY cllfo/'ccmcllt liC lions pending against the rcqu ~s toT reganii ng this site? D Yes 0No 2. Is the requestor subject to an existiug order relating to contamination at the s ite? DYes 0No 3. Is the requeslor subject 10 Ull outsullIding claim by the Spi ll Fund for thi s sire? D y", 12]No 4. Has the requostor been de term.ined to have violated an y provision ofECL Article 271 ' D Yes [ZI No 5. Has the n ..'qucstor previously been denied entry to the Bep? D Yes [Z] No 6. Has the requestor been flmnd in a civil proceeding to have committed a negligent or intentionally tortiolls D yes 0No act involvillg contaminants? 7. Has the requestor been convicted ofa criminal offense that in volves a violen t felony, fraud, hrilx:ry, peJj ury. DYes 0 No theft, or offense against public admillistnltion? 8. Has the requestor knowingly falsified or concealed material facts or knowingly l'ubmittcd or IT'.adc usc o f a 0 Yes 0No fal se statement in a matter before the Dcpanment? 9. Is the requestor an iodi\'idllli or entity of the type set forth in EeL 27-1407 .. 8(1) thai CUllllluttec an !lcl D Yes 0 No or failed to act, and ~uch act or faihue to act could be the basis for denial of a BCP application? 1. Is the property listed 011 tbe N:ltional Priorities List? D y" 12]No 2. Is the propelty listed Ofl the NYS Registry ofInactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Sites? D Yes 0 No If yes, please prell'ide: Site # _ Class # 3. Is the property SUbject 10 11 perulil under EeL Article 27, Title 9, other thulll.llllnterim Status faci lity? D Yes [ZI No If yes, please provide: Penuit type: EPA ill N umber: Date pennit issued: Penllit expiratio n dalc: _____ 4, Is the property subject to a cleanup order under navigation law Article 12 or Eel Anicle 1i Tilk IO? DYes 0 No If yes. please provide: Order #,______10 a Slate or federal enforcement a(,'t10n rc1awd to hazardous waste or petroleum? D Yes 0No "lrl,n"ima< an attachment. What stage is the proje<:1 starting at'~ o investigation [2] remcdiution Please auach a descripti on of Ih t:: projeCT which includes the fo llowing coruponellls: Purpose and scope of the project Estimated project schedule Page 3 of 6 ADI.)IU:SS Ann: Deputy, Commissioner Leri Fierstein, 1 Centre Streel, 17th Floor South OTYrroWN New York, New York ZlPCOIJ6 10007 PHONE 212-669·3645 F.u 212-313-3450 Of'i3RATOR'SNMru Ferrara Brothan; Concrete Plant ADDRESS 68 5th Street crrvtrOWN New York Zll't.'ODE 11231 Ihnswcring "yes" to any of the following questions, please provide an explanation as 80 aUucblllcnt. I. Are any enforcement actions pending against the requestor regarding this site? Dyes 0No 2. Is the requestor subject to an existing order relating to contamin;'ltion at the s'ite'? DYes IllNo 3. Is the requestor subject to an outstanding claim by the Spill Fund fOf'thi s site? DYes 0No 4. HaS the reqnesror!>eM detennined to nave violated any provision ofECL Article 271 DYc-5 [2]No 5. Has the requestor previously been denied entry to thf BCP'l Dy" fZ]No 6. Has the req uestor been found in a civil proceedilJg to have committed 8 negligent or intentionally tortious DYes [Z) No act involving contaminants'? 7. lla~ the requestor been eonvicted ofa criminal ofi't:ose that involvcs a vioJent felony, fnlUd , bribery, petjlD)', Dyes 0 No thd\, or offense aguinSl public administflltion? 8. Has the. requestor knowingly fah:ified or con(;cllied material fllCts or knowingly submitted or made use ofa Dyes. 0 No lilJse s(alcnu.,'nl in a maucr before the Dcpanment7 9. Is the requestor In individual or entity of the type sct forth in EeL 27. 1'407.8(1) mat oomm itlul an act Dyes 0 No o,f.Llod to.ct. and such act or failure to act could be the basis for denial of a nel' 'p"I;"ti 1. Is the property listed on tho National Priorities List? Dyes [Z] No 2. Is the property listed on the NYS Registry oflnactivc UaJ'.ardous Wastc Disposn\ Sites? Dyes 0No If yes., please provide: Site # CJ8.S$ 'If ______3. Is the property subject [0 a pennit under EeL Article 27, Title 9, other than Wllntcrim Stlltus fucility? Dyes IZiNo If yes, pleasc provide: I'ermit type: EPA lD Numbcr: ;::===-_ Dme pennil issued: Permit expirationTa dale: 4. Is the property subject to a cleanup OI'l.I.I;!I' under navigation law Article 12 or BeL Article 17 Title 101 Dyes 0No Ifyc:s, pltnse provide: Order iI,______5. Is the property subject to u mtc or federal enforcement action R)lated to hamrdous waste or petroleum? If yes, please provid.:: explanation as an attachment. \\'11111 sUlgc is the project swting at? 0 investigation 0 remediation Please attacb a description of the project ",ttich includes the fo llowing components: Purpose an d scope of the project Estimated project sclleduIe Page 3n of 6 OWNEKS NAMf. (lfdiff<:JeLll lrD"'ItX!ue,(or) iIDDR.ESS 10 West 33rC Street C1TYITOWN New York, NY ZIPCOOE 10001 PHONE 212"967~6666 fAX 212~86a· 3039 OI'ERATOR'S NAME HMA Warehouse ADDRESS 459 Smith Street crfYtTO\VN Brook!yn, NY Z!J:'C'ODE 11231 If 3nswering "yotG" to rmy of the following questions. please provide 1m explan~tion as an attachment. 1. Are any erdorcem~nt llctions pending again~i the reque8tor regarding this site? DYes [2J No 2. Is the requestor ~'Ubject to an eK:;;ting order relating to contamination at the site? DYes [2J T\ l) 3. b the reque.\ior subject to all outstanrling claim by the Spill Fund for tnis Eite? 0 Yes l.{jNo 4. Has the requeStor blOt.-'J1 dctcrlllincd 10 have violaled any provisiofl ofFeL Artidl: 27'! DYes 0 No 5. Has the req1.lesior previousiy been c\..~nied entry to the SCP'I DYes WNo 6. Has th~ rcqu;ostor been found in a civil prooe eding to hnve committed fr n.eg l ig~1ll or int(:nl~onul1y \ortjO\!~ DYes 0 No act in.vol ving contaminants? 7. Hus the requestor bet!:!l cOl1victed of ~ criminal offense th<1t involves a violent felOfJy, fmud, bribery. perjury, 0 Yes 0 No tht'[t, or offense against pub!.lc administration'! 8. Has the tequesto!' knowing~y falsified or com:eaJed materia! facts or knoy/ingly submitted or made use ora DYes [2] No false st.a!emOllt in :l matter before the Departmtlllt? 9. Is. tht requestor a,n individual or ctltity ofthc type. set forth in EeL 27-14/fl .8(f) tha t committed an I. Is the property listed on the National Prioflties Lis['r [JYe8 01\'0 2, Is the property listed on the NYS Registr'j of Inactive HazliJd,1US Vh!.~te Di~posaJ Sites? DYes [2JNo If yes, pkase provide: Site C!ass.# __ ... __ ... ___ .... __.. __ .. _ _.. .. 3. Is the property subject to a penni! under ECl Aliidc 27, Tille 9, other than an Interim Status facility? DYes i1JNo lfy::s, please provide: Pcrmil type: EPA lD Number: [)me rrermit i:;;~;TC~~:~._=== Permit MpirmioUd;te::--=_~=. 4. Is the property subjtcr fo a cleanup orda under navigation law Article 12 or EeL Ar!iei.e 17 Title 107 DYes 0No If yes, pka~ pl·ovide: Order If- 5. Is the property subject to 2 &tat(; or federal enforcement aCf ion rdJtcd to haz.art!ous waste or petmlell1n? DYes f2]No [ryes. p i cJ ~ c pf(>v ide e"planation a~ an nl:'!rhmcni. o rer:lled i~ ltion Please atredl a description oUlle project which includes the following components: Purpose ilnd :>cope of the projec! Estimated project schedule Page 30 of 6 OWNER'S NAME (if diffcrClll from ADDRESS CITYffOWN ZIP CODE PHONE FAX E·MAIL OPERATOR'S NAME from owner) ADDRESS ClTYfTOWN ZIP CODE If answering "yes" to any of the fo llowing questions, plea;;e provide an explanation as an attachment. I. Arc any enforcement actions pending against the requestor regarding this site? DYes D No 2, Is the requesTOr subject to an existing order relating to contaminalion at the silc? D Yes D No 3. Is the requestor subject to an outstanding claim by the Spill Fund for th is site? D y" D No 4. Has the requestor been determined to have violated any provision of EeL Article 27'1 D Ye> D No 5. Has the requestor previously been denied entry to Ihe BCP? DYes D Na 6, Has the requestor been fo und in a civil proceeding to have committed a negli gent or intenti ona ll y tortious D yes D No act involving contaminants? 7. Has the requestor been convicted of a cri mi nal offense that invo lves a violent felony, fraud, bri bery, perjury, 0 Yes D No theft, or offense against public administration? 8. T-Ias the requestor knowingly faJsilied or concealed material facts or knowingly submitted or made use of a D Yes O No false statement in a matter before the Department? 9. Is the requestor an individual or enti ty of the type set forth in EeL 27-1407 .8(t) that committed an act or failed to act, and such act or failure to act could be the basis for denial of a B(:P'ppl1",.10,,? L Is the property listed on the Nationlll Priorities List? DYes D No 2. Is the property listed on the NYS Registry of Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Sites? D Yes D No rryes, please provide: Site # Class # ______3. Is the property subject to a permit under EeL Article 27, Title 9, other than an Interim Status fac il ity? D Yes DNo If yes, please provide: Permit type: EPA TDNumber:-;-c-_ _ _ Date pennit issued: Permit expiration date: ____~ 4. Is the property subject to a cleanup order under navigation law Article 12 or EeL Article 17 Title 101 D Yes D No Tfyes, please provide: Order # ______5. Is the property subject to a state or federal enforcement action related to hazardous waste or petroleum? D yes DNo If yes, please provide explanation as an attachment. What stage is the project starting at? 0 investigation 0 remediation Please attach a description oflhe project which includes the following components: Purpose and scope of the project E;;timated project schedule Page 3c of 6 ATTACHMENT Brownfield Cleanup Program (BCP) [ECL Article 27/ Title 14] Application Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP Site Brooklyn, New York Section V. Property Eligibility Information The Brooklyn Union Gas Company (BUG) [aka KeySpan Corporation (KeySpan)/ National Grid USA], the City of New York, Vichar, Inc. and Harvie International, Ltd. certify that the Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP site meets the definition of a Brownfield site (real property, the redevelopment or reuse of which rnay be complicated by the presence or potential presence of a hazardous waste, petroleum, pollutant, or contaminant). The site is not: • listed on the national priorities list • listed on the New York State Registry ofInactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Sites • subject to a permit llllder EeL Article 27, Title 9, other than aninterirn status facility • subject to a cleanup order under Navigation Law Article 12 or EeL Article 17 Title 10 • subject to any other on-going state or federal enviromnent enforcement action related to hazardous waste or petroleum. Further, the applicants state that the Carroll Gardens! Public Place site is currently vacant or underutilized. Parcel I has been vacant since the City acquired the parcel in 1975. The City leases Parcel II to a concrete batch plant operator and the warehouse on Parcel III is leased to a supplier of school uniforms. In the past several years, KeySpan has documented a major source of manufactured gas plant material at the Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP site (see reports listed in Site's Enviromnental History below). This MGP source material has penetrated deep underground at the site. MGP-related material has also been found on properties to the east, across the Gowanus Canal, at depths below the bottom of the canal. However, linkage with the site has not been confIrmed and other source areas are present east and north of the canal. A major remediation, which will include construction of a barrier wall to halt the potential flow of MGP contaminants into the Gowanus Canal, has been approved by the NYSDEC. The redevelopment of the Carroll Gardens! Public Place Site is clearly complicated by the extensive MGP contamination at the site. The Carroll Gardens! Public Place site is clearly distinguishable from two former manufactured gas plant sites in Manhattan that had applied to the Brownfield Cleanup Program and were recently rejected by the Department of Enviromnental Conservation. Page 3d These are the 535 W. 19th Street, Site No. C23l056 and 76th Eleventh Avenue, Site No. C231036. First, as to neighborhood character and development pressure, the West Chelsea community where the two Manhattan MGP sites are located, was rezoned in 2005 and has consequently attracted intense development pressure and sharply rising property values. In contrast, the Gowanus Canal comdor consists of known assemblages of vacant and llllderutilized property (between 3rd Street and Douglass Streets) and traditional industrial and commercial uses (south of3rd Street), according to a recent NYC Department of City Planning CDCP) analysis. Although some developers have plans for several Gowanus sites, the Gowanus has not been rezoned and lacks the intense development pressure of West Chelsea in Manhattan. In the past 5 years, DCP has received applications for nine new buildings in the 60-block Gowanus study area. Since 2003, only three new buildings have been built and issued certificates of occupancy in the area. The completed buildings include two new hotels on Butler and Union Streets and the City's EMS station on Carroll and Bond Streets. The other permitted buildings are mostly storage facilities or offices, the Whole Foods on 3rd Street and 3rd Avenue, and a hotel on 3rd Avenue and Douglass Street. Second, as to seriousness of contamination, the Carroll Gardens! Public Place site is a source ofMGP related contaminant material that may impact a surface water body. The MGP contamination beneath the two West Chelsea sites is more limited and has not reached a surface water source. Finally, the two West Chelsea sites can be distinguished from the Carroll Gardens! Public Place site in terms of existing remediation authority. Con Edison executed a Vollllltary Agreement with DEC to remediate the two West Chelsea sites several years before those sites were applied to the BCP. In contrast, DEC's Vollllltary Agreement with KeySpan for the Carroll Gardens! Public Place site was for investigation only, not remediation. Page 3e ATTACHMENT Brownfield Cleanup Program (BCP) rEeL Article 27/ Title 141 Application Carroll Gardens/ Public Place MGr Site Brooklyn, New York Section VI. Project Description The objective of me project is to mitigate the environmental issues identified on the ~ite and facilitate potential redevelopment of the property. The NYSDEC has approved a Remedial Altematives Analysis defming a selected remedy, and a Remedial Design Work Plan presenting the details of the development of design and construction documents. These documents are attached to this BCP application. This includes additional environmental and geotecJrnical site investigations and on site pilot srudies to fimllizc the design documents. The remedy in general, includes sh,lllow excavation of contaminated soil (nominally 8 feel helow street grade) throughout the site (Parcels 1, II and III). It is expected that an excavation suppon system will be required for the work on Parcell along SID Street and about balfthe parcel~length along Smith Street. Existing foundations and below grade remnant MGP structures will be removed., some to a d'-'Plh of about 30 feet below grade on Parcel 1. A visual excavation batTier will be i.nstalled at the base of the excavations, denoti.ng the limit of clean fill and warning ofpotentiaJly impacted soil below. Excavated soil will be disposed of off site. The excavations will be backfilled with clean excavated matcl;al (as available) and clean soil from off site to about street grade and the site will be rough graded. A DNAPL containment ban·ter will be installed along the Gowanus Canal coupled with a DNAPL recovery system. Engineering and institutional controls will be implemented to identify remaining impacted soil and groundwater and deal with the monitoring and maintenance of remedial systems in place. The additional environmental and geotechnical investigations and pilot studies are estimated for completion in the third quarter of 2008 followed by the completion of the remedial design in the flrst qUClrter of 2009. The remediaJ design bid and contracting is projected for the second qua11er of 2009 followed by remedial implementation through the second quarter of 20 II. However, the estimated scbedule for these activities are tentative and could be affected by a number factors including: site access, New York City debris removal (scheduled to begin on March 17,2008 and be completed within three months), active concrete plant relocation, fom1er facilities demolition, subcontractor availability, supplemental remedial investigation on Parcel m, coordination with Ihe New York City Mayor's Office of Environmental Coordination (NYC MOEC), and review, input and approvals [Tom the NYSDEC and the New York State Department of Health. " The proposed use after the remedy will be a mixed~use development consistillg of several buildings up to 12 stories in height which will provide 500 to 600 units of mixed income housing, retail space, ancillary padcing and community facilities. This site development is projected to occur in 2011 through 2013. Page 3f To the enenl that c)tisting information/sltJciiesirep ,. Sampling Data: Indicate known cOllwminlluts and the mew!\. which 1m;, r:c.nown to haw been affft'tw: ! Soil S"ioee W M o; Soil Go< I' 'X X X Ix X X Olher VOC~ 'X X X SVOC> :x X Mctol, IX X i X X PCB, X 0,",,- IX X I , c".,," ,r. md ",,, ! " .. , "''' 'm.,," .ff. I Soli C I Sm[,,, W"" Soli Ga; I i Q,hcrYOC, , SVOC, M",b PCBs o,",,' I 4. L'IItIlCAT£ lo;OWN ORSUS!'EcrtU SOURCES OP CO~ TA~~ INANTS ' o Abc,,,,, G,-",md f i "di,, ~ nr rank o bgnoru or [' 5. INf}jCATI!: r AST LANO USES, [2] Cool (;,s M a l \~ j i1c t uj" ing [J Manub crurinl). OAsricdluraIO:,..,,1' o nry Gle""", o Sal"age Yo:(,i [JBull: Plant Ol' ;p~lin~ D5 ~r v ic eStUlkm DL1mdfill f.J "Taurll'lY o EI""lrOp l ~ i i[!g 0Unk"ow" "'"~ Owners •• /\ lis\: ofpreviol.ls OWI1er~ wi lli lWmes. liolst known ad d n::ss~s and tdeph.o n(~ numbers (describ~ requestor's relationship, if any, to each prev io!.L~ ownct l i ~tcd , lfno rtla(iortship, pu.t ''none''), ;. OperatoN A list of pTC\ious operators with names. last known addresses and ieli:phone num ber (describe requestor'''' relationship, jf any, to . r limed, irno I ' . " put "none"'). Page 4 of 6 ATTACElMIi:NT Brownfield Cleanup Program (Bep) fEeL Article 27/ Title 14] Application Carroll Gardens/ Public Place MGP Site Brooklyn, New York Section VlJ. Property Environmental History Environmental Reports A number of envrroillllental investigations reports have been completed for the site 10 date. They are as follows: • Environmental and Engineering Study, i\ssessmg the Suitability of the Gowanus Canal Site for Public Housing and Recreational Usage, Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, December 1984* • Final Report, Vacant Property Site Assessment, ComaIl Gardens, Brooklyn, TRC Environmental Consultants, Inc. October 1985* • Preliminary Assessment (PA), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, March 28, 1986 • Engineering Investigation at Inactive Hazardous Waste Sites, Pha')e I Investigations, Can-oll Gardens, Site No: 224012, Borough of Brooklyn, Kings County, final, EA Science and Technology, June 1987* • Engineering Investigation at Inactive Hazardous Waste Sites, Phase II Investigations, Carroll Gardens, Sitc No 224012, Borough ofBrooklyu. Kings County, Final, Roux Associates, Inc. September 1990* • Draft Remediallnvcstigatlon Report, Carroll Gardens! Pubic Place Brooklyn, New York Volume 1 and Volume 2. December 23,2003 • Draft Remedial Investigation RepOlt, C,moll Gardens! Pubic Place, Brooklyn, New York, Volume 1 and Volume 2. June 2005 • Final Remedial Investigation Repol1, Carroll Gardens! Pub[jc Place, Brooklyn, New York, Volume 1 and Volume 2. October 2005* • Test Pit Soil Sampling A.nd DlUm Classification Results, Carroll Gardens (Public Place) Smith SU'eet and Fifth Street Borough of Brooklyn-City of New York, Metcalf & Eddy/AECOM, May 2005* • Groundwater Monitoring Well Lnspection Letter Report, Can-oll Gardens/Public Place Site [Fonner Citizens Gas Works MGP Site] Site No. V00360-2. July 6, 2005* • Groundwater Monitoring Well Abandonment Report, Carroll Gardeusl Public Place [Fonner Citizens Gas Works MGP Site] Site No. V00360-2, Brooklyn, New York December 21,2006* Page 4a • Remedial Alternative Analysis, Carroll Gardens! Public Place (Citizens Gas Works Fonner MOP Site) AOC Index No. A2-0460-0502, Site No. VD0360-2. March 22, 2007* • Final Remedial Design Work Plan, Carroll GardensIPublic Place, Brooklyn, New York, VCA Index No. A2- 0460-0502, Site No. V00360-2, September 14,2007* *Copies of the finaJ reports are attached to this BCP application. Additional analytical data have bet-"l1 collected as part of the NYSDEC-approved supplemental remedial investigation scope of work. This investigmion included soil vapor and indoor air sample coUection at Parcel flI and a further evaluation of off-site MOP-related impacts in soil and groundwater that is on-going. Once the investigations are complete, the findings will be summarized in a supplemental remedial investigation report. No other existing environmental infonl1alion, studies, reports, or other such data have been found for this site. Previous investigations have included the completion of numerous test pit excavations; installation of soil borings, soil vapor points and monitoring wells; and the collection and analysis of soil vapor, soil, and groundwater samples. Previous investigations have identified soil vapor, soil, and groundwater at the site are impacted with MGP~rel ated petroleum products, volatile organic compounds (not including chlorinated solvents), semi-volatile organic compounds, metals, PCBs, and cyanide. Tables that summarize the chemical concentrations within soil , soil vapor and groundwater reported ill the comprehensive Final Remedial Investigation Rep011 are appended to the end of this attachment. A summaty of investigations completed to date, the selected remedy, and the design approach are provided within the Final Remedial Design Work Plan, Carroll Gardens! Public 1>lacc. A copy of this document will be submitted under a separate cover. Item 5. Indicate Past Land Uses . The Carroll Gardens! Public Place lvIGP Site is cUlTently used for commercial and manufactUling! industrial purposes, or is vacant. The Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP was operating by the late 1860's and continued operatillg through the 1960' s. The Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP initiaJly occupied Parcels I and II. The Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP ex.panded operations to include Parcel f1l sometime between 1904 and 1914 and Block 468, Lot 25 by 1939. Gas holders, tar handling, fuel oil tanks, andlor other MGP production and distribution bu ildings were present on each of the lots. It should be noted that Block 468, Lot 25, is not part of this Brownfield Clean-up Program application, but will be remediated by Keyspan. Page 4b The Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP ceased operations and MGP slructures were razed in the late 1960' s. The Carroll Gardens! Public Place property was sold in 1969. Parcell! was developed as a concrete plant in 1975. In 1971, a warehouse was developed on ParccllH. According to the 1996 Sanborn map, Block 468 Lot 25 remained undeveloped through 1996. Items 6. Owners and 7. Operators Summarv A summary oftbe previous ownership and former operators are summarized by Block and Lot for each of the three parcels (Parcell, Parcell!, and Parcel HI) in the table below as pmt of this BCP application. The information provided below was prepared to address sub-sections 6.0wners and 7. Operators of the BCP application. Tax Block 471, Lot 1 Tax Block 471, Lot 100 Tax Block 471 Lot 200 Parcell Parcel II Parcel III (Open Space) (Concrete Plant) (Warehouse) 1969 Brooklyn Union 1969 Brooklyn Union Gas 1969 Brooklyn Union Gas Co. Gas Co. sold to Co. sold to sold 10 Peter Glasso, Inc. Peter Glasso, Inc. Peter Glasso, Inc. 57-57 47th Street Maspeth 57-57 47th Street Maspeth 57·57 47th Street Maspeth Queens, New York Queens, New York Queens. New York March 21, 1973 1969 1969 Sold to Sold to Peter Glasso Sold to Peter Glasso Antarenni Industries, Inc_ 79 Wheatley Road Old 79 Wheatley Road Old Smith and Huntington Streets Westbury, New York Westbury, New York Brooklyn, New York 1971 Warehouse constructed Oc19,1973 March 21,1973 March 22, 1976 Sotdlo Sold to Ms. Rose Ferrara Transferred to 7 Horizon Corporation 5 Dorey Place New York Job Development 4105 Church Street Ozone Park Authority Brooklyn, New York Queens , New York 99 Washington Avenue Albany, New York Dec. 18, 1974 July 23,1973 1971 -1984 Parcel use unknm-m City of New York takes Sold to possession Vincent Ferrara-Trusiee Joeseph Ferrara-Trustee Steven Ferrara-Trustee Jerome Ferrara, Jr. Trustee Ozone Park. Queens, New York Page 4c Current: Open Space Dec. 18 , 1974 January 2, 1985 Sold to [Carro ll Gardens/ Public City of New York takes Allegheny International Exerdse Place] possession Company Two Oliver Plaza P.O . Box 456 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15230 Mr. Irving Goldstein and Leah Goldsfein 1420 55"' Street BrooKlyn, New York 1984¥1998 47!J-, Street Photo operates at warehouse 1975 City of New York 1998 Sold to leases parcel to Ferrara Vichar, Inc, Brothers for use as concrete 10 West 33'd Street plant New York, New York 1998-Current: Used as a clothing distribution warehouse operated by HMA Warehouse 1975 Current: Used as concrete plant There was no relationship with KeySpan and its predecessors fo ll owing th e sale o[the propclties. Page 4d Brownfl&lcl Cleanup Program (I3CP) [Eel Artlcl" 211 TltIu 14) Application Carroll Gard(l~1 Public Plaee MGP SII& Brooklyn, New York Section VII. Proper1y EnviT<>"menlal History Surfacm Soil Analytica' Oata Statistical SUl11mary Min imum Coocen:ration of Cooc.. nl",tion 01 Nurnl:lef 01 Concentra!ioo 01 i)eteC\;orlS in Detections in Number 01 Detections that Exceed Numl>etof \J'1l1tyzed An"lyzed Samples NYS ReCOffiI11!!'l I'<'.lECH!I'~"'}( 8~ ' ''' r:; '!1= (~" V/,,,,,,-a,, 'ldl,lj .'ff·1c.,>\o1,W:" ~rt 1,""N \\"'!'~1 "'4''.3''''''' ' \o1! _M:lt">f.,o-I. GEI~ Page I 01 4 0Ci'-&«,," VlI _ ~~.o,,"";"' ~ " ' I'" O~ , Brownfield Cleanup Program IBCP) [Eel Artide 271 Title 141 Appllc~tlon C","oll Gardensl Pllbllc Plaee MOP SIIII Brooklyn, New York SI>CUOll VII. P,operty Eltvironm(lntal History Surface Soil Am'l)11.iul 09ta Sl~tlslical Summary M;n lmLJrT1 Cor"",,,!,.,jjon of N1Jtnt...r 01 Cone:.mlration of Delec!iom, ;n Detections iii Number of Oetsctions lila! Exceed N"",b,,'of Anaty;:ed Samples NYS Recommended Soil Cleanup ObjE!Cti~s H\li:C"""*'X>A p('\F ~lU :; "' .. ~ 0,,,, ' ",""',n,,,."k/J~wr< ; """r~:;" orr , ,,,,,,I W'1< ~~ ~<;[~O",'k, ' \II! "..,""....".. GEI ~ P ,og~ 2 01 4 1P'-fl«l,," "I,",-.l·f"""od.;"",g,,,,, [l.h Brownf1.e1d C~~nup P,g9.em jBe p ) [Ee L. Artier. 271 TItle 14J App!lcatlon Caltoll GlidenaJ Public PIK e MGP Site B'Doldyl' , Now Yor1! SeclJon VII. Prope"y E"... ionnrn',,\al Hil tory Surface Soil Anllly lical 0 . 1.. S \etj, Ucal Summary Minimum Cono8r1l:n!.l"'" of Numberor Oel!'CooM ~ I Detectioon, in Number of Dekd'CH'I1 !h at Exceed Samples N\II'>-ber oJ Anllly2a<1 S...... pet !\nlll\'l.ed S"mP'es N'l'S Reromrr~nded Soil Clnnu!) otJj(!~1 ,tn~~~ t;"' '''"",",=, {I'''''' __ '''' I<''' orilr.P''''' ' 'NW!'''''''-''' <-'''E~ ,,"I'I'''''''''" t .... GE I ~ ".3014 ~_ "" "-l._~~'" Brownfield Cleanup Pr09r~m ~8C P) (EeL Ardele 271 Title 14) Application Carroll Gardi!nsl Public Place MGP Site Brooklyn, New York S<>elion V II. Property E' w i ro ll"'l!nl~1 History Surface 5011 Analytk al Data 5tt1tlS11cal Summary M inimum Conccnt",t ion of Coocentmtion of Numb(lr oj Concentration 01 Dete<;t ions in Detech Notes; U - if)dicates rmt ~tecl ed 81 or above the reporting limit shown NA - not applicable, 9Var8ge conccntr(l1ion was not cakuleled b ec~\J~e " nl\'le was not dett!ded i" 1'I1lY samp l ~ 5 !'IY S - NcVI' YO!k Stale rllg/kg - miWi g,m",fl f l~T R I .Pn , ,,,, N:fY SPM I.;:;;r","" Go; w",I.,'Ill"""" ' l ~Pf1 , ~""?,)' ,'>1' ll'-'f'17 MJ'1f ~ ,. ~ """,~ ",/ "" VI 1-' ,." """,,,1 Paoe 4014 GEl ocr_"o MirlimuJrl Average Maximum Conc!'mtJation Concentra!ion of Detoctions in Det!l<;tians In Number of Deteclions that E ~oo ed Number 01 NYS ReC ii ,\ l ~CI .n'*''''''E Y f'r N J.(""",, r; .. •... .,. "~~o ""' O/j 'rrl ''"',''''"'<;f' , Minimum Average I fl,1"~ i mum Coocent< (Ition of CoocenbffiiOIl 01 Numbm 01 D c t ~ t lo n 5 in ~ 1 !!CtiOils in N"mber of Detections ttI .. t Exc!!ed S"mplcs NYS Reeommended Soil CICllflUP Objectives K!.TW "' ,*c_ ,*,,, sr "1<2~ ' ,", ' nO. WO<\- '·fh ·.""'..... "f'rJe",o't'0' II,"r 12':1$7 ""''1'''-'' Minimum A~erage M~)(im u m COl1(;entration 01 COOC9nlration 01 Number 01 Detecfions tha t b:ceed NYS Recommend ed Soil Cleanup Obje ctives H:II[..cltH'io"'J'8'SI' >.I KlO ,,,,, G.. w " " " . ~" ,,,, , iol d Ar1h ",;C<' \WY ' FP 11{!:1 ~7 ", !r'H.,1 rr." , ~ """ .... 1iIl -Ac!.1",,,,"p,\ · EI ~,- <.j Page 3 014 G 0Cf'-, rt:'" v~,<;O ~ ' '-'~ 'l n! HOt' 'f' ' '''' M.l Brownfield Clean"p PfU!Jram (BCP) [Eel Article VI Title 14) Application Ca rrol! Glirdansl Public Place MGP Site Srooklyn, New York SCoction VII. Property Ellvironmen l ~l His tory SUbSU rf ~ f; " Soli Analytical Oe ta Statlstlcpl Su mmary Minimum Average Maximum COllCentration of Concentration of N\lmber of Detuchons that Exceed Numbe' 01 NYS Recommended So;1Clea nup Obj ective~ Notes: U - indicates not detE c:! e ~ · \ TE C fll"'t *:!"I( eYsP N /0:;,,", <3" I'fo" ~ il Ave"I!I"I' Minl!'l'll>lll Concenlrtllion 01 M,m mum COI1.;:en\r1'lion Oe1ec.tiom In Con"cnh"lID., .... NtI'Ilber or I or An¥yZi!d !'I u~ol Detections 't\l ~Clr!'><~~~" [;[1; ... 0.." Y...... """' ..- W1~ /'IIe"""'~P 'r, \i'W'7l1.! "" ~ " ~~_'III >..to_ P8!j. 1 01 4 GE I ~ ~"""'~~+''''-l'''I)oI . Brownfield CLunup Program (BCP) [ECl Arth::le '1.71 Title 14J Applicatlofl CaITO!! GardensJ Public Place MGPSile Brooklyn, New Vorl< Section VII. ProP1!rty Environmental HI~tOl'Y Groundwater Analylkal Data Statl~tle21 Summary Minirnum CO!1«lf1trotiOl1 01 Ma<;murn Detections in Number 01 A"alyzed Sanoples N1lmtJe, of Oele<:ti WI!;\)' GEI~\:§ "'I' !:CH I'."."." ", ,!,,,,,,,,.,,,,, Go. 1>1"",,,,,.,,,,,,,,, '.;'r" '"'''''''lC'F 'rr j ~" 'T;"'; < ~E'~, "' "" W", .,,,,,,, . , ~_\ Page2or4 "eN,.""," \II "Sc Mi1 im urn COllCootralion '" M ,, ~i mum C<)l1centratk>n Oetf.\Ctlons in 0' Number 01 ! 01 ArKllyzed AfI " ~ l:C ! ''''''''r,,,,,-,"p'''''CL· ,", c-". ....,,....."""""' •.~ n~'''':'''''' E'''' 'H l,,-..n' M..,' ~cl'ff_~"",,'''" U " _ ''''''c~"" l Page 3 of 4 GE I ~ OCf-o',,",," '''_'''~ ·C..-"",""",.... l, ~ ~ , • •• l Brownfield Cleanup Program (BCP) [ECL Article 271 ntle 14] Application Carroll Gardensl Public Place MGP Sito Brooklyn, New York Section VII. Property Environmental Hislory Parcel l..soil Vapor Analytical Results Duplicate of NYDQt-1 CGSV-OS Sample 10: Upper Ouartile CGSV-Q7 CGSV-08 CGSV-XX CGSV.Q9 CGSV·10 CGSV-11 CGSV·1 2 CGSV-13 Date Collected. fOf Ouldoor Air 12119104 12119104 12119104 12/1910 4 12f19/CM 12/19f04 121 19/04 12119/04 . ", ,." , , ' "-' , BTEX u 3 " Toluene 3.3 I 2.9 U I 2.8 U I 2.8 U 2,; U 2.9 U 4,1 3U 2.9U Other. VDCs, Ii . ril3 ,,;, . , Trichloroethane, 1 1 1- 0.38 4.3 U 4 U 'U " ':," 8.2 , 4.1 U 4.3 U 4.3 U 4.3U Acetone 23 7.4 U 7. 1 U 7.1 U 6.9 U 11.2 7.4 U 7.6 U 7.4 U Chloroform 0.23 18;1 j 3,6 U 3.6 U 3.5 U 3.7 U 3.8U 3.9 U 3.8 U T richlorofluoromethanc 2.6 4.4U 6,2 ',,'''', " " S.2 ", 5.6 ',' 4.3 U 4.4 U 4.4 U ,6.2 " Dichlorodifluoromethane 5.1 3.9 3.7U 3.7 J 3.6U 3.8 3.9 U 3,9 U 4.2 Totrachloroethene 0." ' 1220.4,; 55.6 ·_:,:'" 55.6 52.2 S.. &~5 •.8 S.& ':- Tetrah droruran 0.2 2 •• 2.2 U 2.2 U 2.1 U 2.2 U 2.3 U 2.3 U 2.3 U Trichloroethane 0.21 9.7 , 4U 'U 3.9U 4.1 U 15;6 '- 4.2 U 4.2 U Notes U - indicates not detected at or abo";e the reporting limit shown BTEX - Benzene, Toluene, Ethylbenzene, and Xylenes VOCs - Volatile Organic Compounds uglm3 - micrograms per cubic meter NE - N9t Es tab l i~hed NYOOH Upper Quar1ile tor outdoor Air - New York Department of Health Upper Quartile value from Summary of Indoor and Outd oor Leve ls of Vol atile OrganiC Compounds from Fuel 0 11 Heated Homes in NYS, 1997·2003, Revised 11-16-04 Bold indicates compound was detected in sample Gray shadinQ indicates detected value exceeds NYDOH Upper Quartile for outdoor air "' ,\nCl'l\Poo,o Site: CGSV-01 CGSY-02 CGSV-03 CGSY-04 CGSY-05 CGSV·06 Average Depth (ltl: NYDOH 90th NYDOH 90th 0.5·1 0.5· 1 0.5-1 0.5-1 0.5- 1 0.5-1 Concentration Site 10 : % for Indoor 'Y. lor Indoor OSHA PEL CGSV-01 CGSY-02 CGSY"()3 CGSY..Q4 CGSY-05 CGSY_06 01 Sub Slab Date: Air (uglm3) Air (ppbv) (ppbv j 511412003 5114/2003 5114/2003 511412003 5114{2003 511412003 Samples {ppbv' MethodTO~14 Volatile 0 ai'ili:Com' oui'lds VOCs bv BTEX (ppbv) Benzene 15 4.70 1,000 2.0 U ,> 32' ,7.4, ,6.8 3~OJ 2;004 403 Toluene 59 15.65 100,000 li20:" 610 730 ;49(} ,, ' 190J 120 460 Efh ylbenzene 7.3 1.68 100,000 2.3 , 120 3.6 U '31 .OJ 660, 146 X !ene, m.p- 12 2.77 100,000 6:4 230 7,8 1l J~OJ 210 93 X 'Iene. 0- 7.9 1.82 100, 000 2.1 110 3.6 U 8,5 J40J 330 10' To! ", 1B TEX NE NE NE 630.8 1162 745.2 54!),} 850 3320 121 0 Other VOCs b,) Acetone 110 46.22 1,000, 000 8.2 U 21 14 U S.7U 34 U 26U 9.3 C clohex"'ne , 1 2 .65 300,000 64 140 1.10 240J 1io 125 Dichloroe!hane.l,1· 0.23 0. 057 100,000 2".1 2.3 U 3.6 U 2.2 U 8.5 U 5.6U 2.3 Oichloroethene. cis-l ,2 0.24 0.060 200,000 7.7 2, 3 U 3.6 U 2.2 U 8.6 U 8 4 Efh Uoluene. - NE NE NE 8.2 U 87 14 U 8.7 U 150J 170 70 Heplane, n- 19 4.63 NE 8.2 U 9J. 20 3$ 310J ' "0 Hexane, n- 19 5.38 100,000 230 27O , 210 200 200J 140 218" Te!r;:lchloroethene 2.' 0.428 500,000 33 26 3.6 U 20 8. 6 U 26 19 Trichloroethene 0.46 0, 089 . 500,000 15 ' 2.3 U 3.6 U 2,2 U 8.6 U 6.5 U 4.4 Trimethylbanzene, 1,2,4- 11 2.236 100,000 2.0 U 160 , 3.6 U 26 140J "0 76,3 Trimeth Ibenzene, I .3 ,S· 38 0.772 1,000 2.0 U Bj , 3.6 U 12 ' 72J 97 44 Vinyl chloride 0.23 0.090 100,000 4.3 2.3 3.6 U 2.2 U 71 " \J 13.1 15 Notes: BT€X is bemen~ . tnl"",,,,, cthylb ~02ffie, oo d _)'\erie J. e$t imllt~ d "~~Ie U - ind iC!>1e5 oot del ""led 31 {)f above Ilia I'flporting iitn ~ $he""," ppbv is pans per billic)11 ~()Iume \Jgim3 is II1i<:rowams r>er cut>ic mc1(!f Fm mll1·de1ec15, Bve'Bge cab.lali"" uses t>a lr the "'pO/lir>g limit "nil""" OSHA PEL is OcupMlol1ol Sarety ami Hl!a~h Administration P~'m;'$able E, ~po","' e Um~s NYDOH 901h % fill" Intdolll" Air_ N~w Y" rk Oep.artme rrt of He alth 90th Pe",entile vallie from summary 01 Indoor and OlltdoD! Levels o( Volatile o.!I"ni<: C"m~OIlnds fro m Fue l Oil Healed Hom<':S . ' NYS. 1997·2(lOJ , Revil;eI", r e 9U ~ !lI)' cr i leri~ is nol ~slabtisl",d Bun Sh"d.,~!bol~inQ ;odOcales an !!,"ceedooce 01 OSHA PEL Gray Shadlng'holdlng Indic91U an ,.~c ,.~ danc e 01 NYDOH 9oth ·/O for Indoor Air Page 1 of 1 I<;!rrow"",r>D·"·"'ro:"","= """"__ ,,,,~ .. "'"..,"",... , ,,.."', ""~ ' '''''' '''''''' '" ,u ",,..,,,,, GEl II! ~c"·", ,,,,, ..· ,,,"_,,,,,,,,,,,, ,, Please attach, at a minimum, the names and addresses of the following: I. The chief executive officer and planning board/dept. chair of each county, city, town and village in which the property is located. 2. Residents, owners, and occupants of the property and properties adjacent to the property. 3. Local news media from which the community typically obtains information. 4. The public water supplier which services the area in which the property is located. 5. Any person who has requcsted to be placed on the contact list. 6. The administrator of any school or day care faci li ty located on or ncar the property. 7. The location ofa document repository for the project (e.g., local library). tn addition, attach Ii copy ofa letter sen! to the repository acknowlcdging that it agrees to act as the document repository for the property. Current Use: o Residential IZlConunercial 01ndustriai IZlVacant 0 Recreational (check all that apply) (ntended Use: DUnrcstricted 0 Residential [2]Commcrcial Dlndustrial (check all that apply) Please eheck the appropriate box and provide an explanation as an attachmcnt if appropriate. Provide a copy of the local zon ing classifications, comprehensive zoning plan designations, and/or current land lise approvals. Yes No 1. Do current historical and/or recent development patterns support the proposed use? (See # 12 below D re: discussion of area land uses) 2. Is the proposed lise consistent with applicable zoning laws/maps? D 3. Is the proposed use consistent with applicable comprehcnsive community master plans, local waterfront D revitalization plans, designated Brownfield OppOltunity Area plans, other adopted land usc plans? 4. Arc there any Environmental Justice Concerns? (Sec §27~ 1415(3 )(p)). 5. Arc there any federal or state land use designations relating to this site? 6. Do the population growth patterns and projections support the proposed usc? 7. Is the property accessible to existing infrastructure? D 8. Arc there impoltant eultural resources, including federal or state historic or heritage sites or Native D American religious sites within Yl mile? 9. Arc therc important federal, state or local natural resources, including waterways, wildlife refuges, wetlands, or critical habitats or threatened If:: mile? to. Are there floodplains within Yl mile? I J. Are there any institutional controls currcntly applicable to thc property? 12. Describe on attachment the proximity to real property currently used for residential use, and to urban, commercial, industrial , agricultural, and recreational arcas. 13. Describe on attachment the potential vulnerability of groundwateno contamination lhal might migrate from the property, to wellhead proteCTion and groundwater re charge arcas. 14. Describe on attachment and of the site. Page 5 of 6 ATTACHMENT Brownfield Cleanup Program (BCP) [ECL Article 271 Title 14] Application Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP Site Brooklyn, New York Section VIII. Contact List Information: Item 1: City of New York Chief Executive Officer: Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg City Hall New York, New York 10007. Director of the Department ofCitv Planning Amanda M. Burden 22 Reade Street New York, NY 10007-1216 Brooklyn Borough (Kings COllllty) Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz 209 loralernon Street Brooklyn, New York 11201 Brooklyn Community Board 6: District Manager Craig R. Hanunerrnan 250 Baltic Street Brooklyn, New York 11201-6401 Item 2: The current owners and occupants of the Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP Site are discussed in Section III. Twenty-seven properties adjoin the site. A sununary of the adjoining owners and land uses is provided below. The properties are smrnnarized on Figure 3. Page Sa Block & Lot OWner Address Occupant/Land Use Block 468 Lot 1 Myra Gonzalez 423 Smith Street Mixed Residential and Commercial Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block468 Lot 60 Gaba-Smith Realty Corp, 11 5 Street Manufacturing! Vacant Land Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 468 Lot 59 Americo Massa 135 Street One and Two Family Buildings Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 468 Lot 58 John Sallustio 155 Street One and Two Family Residence Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 468 Lot 57 Brooklyn 13 Street Holding 175 Street Industrial and Manufacturing Company Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 468 Lot 54 Brooklyn 13 Street Holding 19 5 Street Bakery! Industrial and Company Brooklyn, NY 11231 Manufacturing Block 468 Lot 51 John Sallustio 255 Street ;~dustrial and Manufacturing 8p) Brooklyn, NY 11231 marble and granite masonry sho Block 471 Lot 104 Linda Figliolia 624 Street Industrial and Manufacturing Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 471 Lot 110 GH Management LLC 664 Street Commercial Real Estate Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 471 Lot 114 76-784 Street Realty 764 Street Parking Facility Company Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 471 Lot 116 Dominick C, Terzroli 804 Street Industrial and Manufacturing Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 471 Lot 125 Stephane Magnan 984 Street Industrial and Manufacturing Brooklyn, NY 11215 Block 990 Lot 138 KeySpan Corporation part 656 Street Utility! Gas Regulator Station of National Grid USA Brooklyn, NY 11215 (Brookl n Union Gas Co,) Block 990 Lot 21 C & A Properties 1105 Street Manufacturing!Unknown Land Use Corporation Brooklyn, NY 11215 Block 990 Lot 1 Richard Ribellino 222 Avenue IndustriallManufacturing Brooklyn, NY 11215 Unknown Land Use Block 990 Lot 69 A&R Second Avenue LLC 58 Second Avenue Industrial! Manufacturing Brooklyn, NY 11215 Block 990 Lot 369 SAG LLC 6 Street Basin Industrial! Manufacturing Brooklyn, NY 11215 Block 990 Lot 50 City of New York Law 379 Street Industrial! Manufacturing Department Brooklyn, NY 11215 Residences Block 477 Lot 8 Red Hook Loading Corp, 230 Huntington Street Concrete Plant! Manufacturing Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 476 Lot 19 p.p Huntington Street LLC 204 Huntington Street Residential! Multi-Family Walk up, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 474 Lot 25 New York City Department Smith Street! Playground of Parks and Recreation Huntington Street Brooklvn, NY 11231 Block 472 Lot 48 New York City Department Smith Street! Luquer Playground of Parks and Recreation Street Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 470 Lot 20 Unknown Unknown Parking area Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 467 Lot 25 New York City Rapid 3rd Place Transportation, Subway Transit Authority Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 477 Lot 1 Finance Administrator of Smith Street Subway the City of New York Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 977 Lot 1 C & A Properties Corp, 5 Street Non-Residential Vacant Land Brooklyn, NY 11231 Block 468 Lot 25 Alfonso Figliolia 384 Street Mendon Truck Leasing! Brooklyn, NY 11231 Transportation Page Sb Item 3: The following are the local newspapers that conununity could typically obtain information: • Brooklyn Daily Eagle, 30 Hemy Street, Brooklyn NY 11201 • Park Slope Courier, Courier-Life Publications, 1733 Sheepshead Bay Road, Brooklyn, NY 11235 • Carroll Gardens/Cobble Hill Courier, Courier-Life Publications, 1733 Sheepshead Bay Road, Brooklyn, NY 11235 • The Brooklyn Paper, 55 Washington Street, Suite 624, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Item 4: Potable water used in Brooklyn is obtained entirely from the New York City Water Supply System, which is managed and operated by The City of New York, Department of Enviromnental Protection, Bureau of Water Supply, 59-17 hmction Boulevard, Flushing, NY 11373-5108. A copy of the New York City 2005 Drinhng Water Supply and Quality report is available by calling 311 or from outside New York City by calling (212) New York. To view the 2006 Statement, you may also visit DEP's web site at: www.nyc.gov/dep. Item 5: N one to report. Item 6: One private school was identified near the property: • Brooklyn Blue Feather Elementary [The Association for the Help of Retarded Children! New York City Chapter] 477 Court Street Brooklyn, New York 11231 Director of Education: Ms. Christina Muccioli The closest public schools are located approximately 0.3 miles from the site. • The Carroll School (PS 58) 330 Sruith Street Brooklyn, New York 11231. Principal: Ms. Joyce Plush Saly Telephone 718-330-9322 Page 5c • The Upper Carroll School CK447) 330 Smith Street Brooklyn, New York 11231 Principal: Lisa Gioe Cordi Telephone 718-330-9328 • The Samuels Mills Sprole School CPS 32) 317 Hoyt Street Brooklyn, New York 11231. Principal: Deborah Ann Florio Telephone 718-330-9295 In addition, the St. Mary's Roman Catholic Church, located at 469 Court Street, provides some childcare services. Item 7: Two document repositories have been identified for the project: The Brooklyn Conununity Board 6 and Carroll Gardens Branch of the Brooklyn Public Library. The Brooklyn Conununity Board 6 has volunteered to be the document repository for the project. An electronic mail confirmation is attached below. Brooklyn Conununity Board 6 is located at 250 Baltic Street Brooklyn, New York 11201. In addition, the Carroll Gardens Branch of the Brooklyn Public Library was also contacted to be the document repository for the project. The library is located at 396 Clinton Street at Union Street, Brooklyn, New York 11231. KeySpan requested and received permission from the library to serve as the document repository for the project. The letter is attached to this application. Page 5d Fw: KcySpan BCP Applicati on Page l of2 Lynn \Vill ey - {Fwd: F\'\': KcySpan ncp ApplicntionJ From: "Fr.mcis J. Murphy" Lynn -- Here is the letkr for CB6 that needs to be inserted in the BCr application. ------Original Message ------ Subject:Fw: KeySpan BCI' Application Oafc:Thu,28 Feb 2008 20:44:12 -0500 From: MeT Illyrc, Mark ::sML\1 cln tyre@cj ! yba l LnY.~.c.g.Q..'{?: To: fmUJv llY 1@keyspflnc n~rgy-.com Frank-here is ao e-mail from Hammennan on CB-6 serving as a document reposhory for the PP BCP. Marl.: ---- Original Message ---- From: Cmig R. Ham merman Hi Lee/Mark: T' m not sure that J had the correct email for Mark -- if I did n't, Lee, \.... ould you )dnoly forw ard to him? This is to conlinn that rm vo lu nteering my office to bc II local repository fo!' tbe Public Place ncr application and any supporring documents related to the application. W e are currently serving as the reposito ry for other BCP applications (i.e., Toll Brolhers, B.,ysidc Fuel Oil, Gowanus Village, {KEA, Whol e Foods, etc,) and nur community is acc ustomed to accessing documents through us. Funherrnore, the documents themselves are extremel y vu luablc to us to have 011 file as we phm for our neighborhood':; m::oos. Pk!l.Se do nOL hesitate to con tact me should you require anythi ng furth er. Best, Craig Crdig R. Hammennan District MWlager Brooklyn Communi ty Board 6 250 Baltic Street Brooklyn, NY 11201-64-0 1 l. 718.643.3027 f. 718.624.8410 W • .~ . \lt ,Brookb'J1C..B.n,.9:[g. Serving the neighborhoods of Carroll Gard elL<;/Soutb Brooklyn, Cobble Hill , Columbia Street District, Gowanus, Park Slope file :!!C;\ Docwncnls and SCllings\lwilley\LocaJ Settings\ T emp\XPGrp Wise\4 7C7C23 8eO... 2/29/2008 KeySpao Corporation Environmental Asset Management One Metro Tech Center 21" Floor Brooklyn, NY 1t201 January 7, 2008 Ms. Cheryl PoweU Brooklyn Public Library Carroll Gardens Branch 396 Clinton Street Brooklyn, New York 1123 t Re: Request to Serve as the Oocument Repository for Brownfields Clean-up Documentation Carroll Gardens/ Public Place Site Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, New York Denr Ms. Powell: KeySpan Corporation (now part of Nation Grid) is respeclful!y requesting to use the C If in tlgreement, please send a response letter via e~mail to me at [email protected] or regular mai l. The response letter from the repository is required for submittal with the application. Your cooperation in this m.atter is appreciated. [[you have (lny questions or requ ire any additional infonnation, please contact me at 718-403~3053. Sincerely, -">""_' / ./ , r '"" c_~" ,,/7. _ ~> ~-;!'~ /',~,...... KeySpan Corporation Tracey Bell Manager Enviromn enta l Asset Management c; M. Mclntyre (NYC MOEC) A. Dubison (KeyS pall) F. Murphy (KeySpan) Enc Tracey Bell Manager Environmental Asset Management National Grid I KcySpan I MetroTech Center Brooklyn, NY I 120 I tbe!l@kevspaneneroy,com Re : Request to Serve as the Document Repository for Brownl1elds Clean-up Documentation Carroll Gardensl Public Place Site Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, New Y(Irk Dear Ms. Bell, The Brooklyn Public Library, Carroll Gardens Branch, agrees to serve as a document repository for the Browntields Cleanup Program (BCP) reports for the Carroll Gardens Public Place Site (a,k.a. Citizens Gas Works Site). These documents will be kept and available at the Cnn'oll Gardens BnUlch for review by the public. Sincerely, Cheryl Powell Brooklyn Public Library ATTACHMENT BrownfieJd Cleanup Program (UCP) [EeL Article 271 Title 14) Application Carroll Gardensl Public Place MGr Site Brook1yn, New York Section IX. Land Use Factors Current Usc/lnt-ended Usc: The current land use on Parcel J is Open Space (vacant lot); Parcel II is indusnial/rnanufacturing (Fen-ara Brothers Concrete Plant); and Parcel III is a warehouse (commercial). The proposed usc of the site is for mixed-use development consisting of several buildings up to 12 stories in height which will provide 500 to 600 units of mixed income housing, retail space, ancillary parking and community facilities. Item 2: Is the proposed used consistent with applicable loning laws! maps'! The proposed development is not consistent with current zoning classification. The property will have to be re·zoned for the proposed development. Item 4: Are there Blly Environmental Justice Concerns? It is unknown if there are any Envirorunental Justice Concerns relating to Carroll Gardens! Public Place MGP Site. Item 8: Are there important cultural resources, including federal or state historic or heritage sites or Natiye American religious sites within YZ mile? The Carron Gardens Historic District is on the National Register of Hjstoric Places and located approximately y.; mile northeast of the site, There are no other important cultural resources, including federal or state historic or heritage sites proximate to the site. Item 9: Arc thCl'C important federal, state, or local natural resources, including waterways, wildlife refuges, wetlands, or critical habitats of endangered or threatened species within ~ mile? Federal \\'etlands (the Gowanus Canal) are located adjacent Lo the eastern property boundary of the site. There are no important federal, state, or local wildlife refuges or critical habitats or endangered or threatened species proximaTe to the site. The lndi311a Bat and the Seabeach Amaranth are listed as endangered species within Kings County Item 10: Are there floodplains within Yl mile? Floodplains are located on the eastern pOltion of the site on Parcel n and Parcel III. Page 5e Itenl11: Are there any institutional controls currently applicable to the property? Tbe site is currently fenced thereby restricting public access. Engineering (lnd instimtional controls are proposed as pm1 oftbe remedial design to address the remaining impacTed soil mId groundwater after the completion of remedial activities. Item 12: Describe on attachment the proximity to r eal property currently used for residential use, and to urban, commercial, industrial, agricultural, and recreat.ional areas. Adjoining land uses are described above and include induSll;al, manufacturin g, commerc ial, and residential use. Recreational facilities (St. Mary's Playgrounds) are located adjacent to the site. The adj oining land uses arc shown on Figure 3 of this application. h em 13: Describe the potential vulnerability of groundwater to contamination that might migrate from the site, including pl'oximity to well head pl'otection and groundwater recharge areas, and oilier areas identified by the Department and the Shlte's Comprehensive Groundwater Remediation and Protection Program. There are no public water supply wells wilbin 1 mile of the site. According to the NYS DOH, there are not any wellhead protcction areas or recharge areas in the vicinity of the site . The Freedom of Infonnation Act request letter nnd tbel\rySDOH response are attached. Remedial investigations have determined that the grOlUldwater at the Carroll Gardens! Public Place site is impacted. These impacts have been encountered outside the footprint oftbc property of the Carroll Gardens! ?ublic Place Site. KeySpan is curren{\ y completing supplemental remedial investigations to evalu atc Ihe extcnt of the potential impacts. Item .14 : Describe (in general terms) the geography and geology of the property on aD attachment The CalTOiI Gardens! Pllblic Place MOP site is located along the Gowanus Canal in Brooklyn, New York. The surficial site geology beneath the site consists of fill; alluvial (1Dd marsh deposits (peat, silt, clay, and sand]; glacial outwash sands inter bedded with glacial till; Gardner'S Clay; and Jarneco Gravel. Site investigations were completed to approximarely Elevation -1 60 Feel. Bedrock underlying th e site is the Fordham Gneiss. Page 5f January 6, 2007 Project No, 061140-2 1101 Raben LoCicero Records Access Office New York State Department of Health Coming Tower Room 2348 Albany, New York 12237-0044 Rc: Freedoll\ ofInformatioll Law (FOIL) Request Wellhead Protection Area Search Request Public Pl:lce Site Smith Street and 5th Street Carroll G~rdeng , Brookly.cl, New York Dear Mr. LoCicero: GET Consultants, Inc. is assisting KeySpan Corporation (now part ofNa1ionai Grid ) in the preparation of Brown fields Cb.1U-up Program (BCP) Application for the Carroll Gardens Public Place Sile located in Brookiyn, New York. The site is located at i::;(itude 40"'·40'·35" and longitude 73"~59'A4". The site is defined by the lond betwtXu Smith Street [west!, 5'h SUt:t:t [north], Huutington Street [south), lind the GOWUllUS Can!]! [e[t~t]. A section of the ncp applicztion requests input regarding the information well head protection and re;;harge areal> in the vicinity of the site, To fulfill this, we reque.st thai you search New YOfk State Department of Health intonnation regarding any wellhead protection areas and gro undwater recharge [lreas near in the vicinity oft.he Cartoll Gardens Public Place Site. Please provide the distance to the nearest wdlhead protection area if one is no: located at the Site. Thank you vcry much fOf your assistance in this matter. IfYOll should have any qu.estions, please do not hesitate to caiL Sin(:erely, GE[ CQNSULTANTS, INC. C_ • ...-:?-- // .?;~ ~ '·' ·' Lynn Wil1ey ~. Project Scientist GEl Cousult am., (",o. 455 Willuirlj; );l (uok nti,, ~, Sui re 2ll! , Gla.,m"bmy, ConUCCIlcm OiS()J3 861l3(i8.5300 f,~ MiI).J\ie.53iJ7 STATE OF NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH Coming Tower The Governor Nelson A. RocI\efelier Empire Stal e Plaza A lbany, New Yor'r: 12237 Richard F. Daines. M.D. Wendy E. Saunders Commissioner Chief of Staff January 30, 2008 Lynn ","lIey GEl Consultants 455 Winding Brook Drive Sulie 201 Glastonbury, CT 06033 RE : FOIL #08-01 -054 Smith and 5~ Street Dear Ms. ","lley: Your request, under provisions of the Freedom of Information Law (FOIL), for environmental information regarding a specified site has been completed. The files in the responsible program unit have been reviewed and the attached memo forwarded to our office. Because the Department does not maintain files identifying all properties by street address or geographic codes we are unable to verify that no incidents involving toxic materials have occurred at the site in question. It is suggested that you also contact other organizations with responsibilities in this area such as the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, local health units, city/village code enforcement units, etc. It is possible that they may have relevant information on this site. re y ..,:c-' -;;OC;;'Ha_re_ _ ___ G :c,, 7 ~-rtec&rds Access Office JPOldme Enclosure ~ NI 'SlN~c1n SN08 13Q I I . . '-. ', Hi =' ;In pi I! \ ' "\ .... wi, o. ~Ij _, ~~ l U,' "~ ~.~ : "..',....'.. ~~~""•• '... r,rll.::::.c._1 STATE OF NEW YORK - DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM TO: Mr. Robert LoCicero, Records Access Officer Records Access Office Corning Tower, Room 2348 FROM: Dawn E. Hettrick, Senior Sanitary Engineer ,: . Bureau of Environmental Exposure Investigation SUBJECT: FOIL REQUEST #08-01-054 DATE: January 29, 2008 REQUESTOR SITE LOCATION Lynn Willey Wellhead Protection GEl Consultants, Inc. Public Place Site 455 Wind ing Brook Drive, Suite 201 Smith and 5th Street Glastonbury, CT 06033 (Site #V00360-2) Carroll Gardens, Kings County The files in the Bureau of Environmental Exposure Investigation and th e Bureau of Toxic Substance Assessment have been reviewed. Although the subject site is currently being investigated under the State's Voluntary Clean-up program, the request is specifically for well head protection and no documents or other information responsive to this request were found. If you have any questions, please contact me at (518) 402-7880. cc: FOIL file Site #V00360-2 File \\Cehm'J2\VOL 1\CEHIDEHI\BEEI\Usersldeh02\FOIL· ncinfo.DOC ( By rcqu.c);wr who IS an md ivldual) I h.c reby ,d firm thut infolilMil Oll provided on (h iS form :tntl it ~ ,llt,Khml'llt~ i~ tnll: .lIltl comrktc 10 Ill.:: hes t of my ~nowkdg ~' i'lll(t bdid. I am uware tl1at any fa lse staiCIlle"n lllJ3de !u:n:m I~ r lluj~h"bk n~ ,I C I,h,S i\ mlsdememlOf purs ua nt 10 s('(" lioll 2 10.45 orille Pena l L~ w. DUlc: Prim Naill'::: (By an rcq ll e~lll r ot her th:m an mdlvidll:;l) r h<:rl'by ,lIfiml [ilal l :m l ~I.(~.. .e9flt..IJf' .~ .t { li! k) of 1!a.U.c.. .. __ .Jclltit y): I h ~ 1 I am allli1 ol"lud by Ihill entity 10 mnke thi s nppli'::Jti oll; tlHl llhi.; ~ I p r licatio 'l was prepared by m~· o r tHl d t,· ))IY supo.:fv ision and directi on: 11n tl that IIl fOnnalion provided on thl> form and its illwdullcnls 151nl{· and complete [0 [he bt-st of my kllowkdg<.." ,ml! bcli.:f. r am aware thai ;my false ~ l a l emen1 Ini'l de herein is punis ha ble as a C l a~s A , ~ e'lJ1Ol' ~llrr a Jl l lO S SU l1 l\lITTAL li~FOR .\1ATIO\: T h n'c (3) complete copies 111'';- rrq\llrcd. Two ( :! ) COP '('S, olle paper copy wilh tlfi~ i ll al s ign Chicf, Sile Com rol Section New York St;l[e Department of tllVilOnnK'111ll1 COII $CrVilli()1l [) ,v i .~1()n of Em'lronmenlal Rcmcdiuti o ll 625 Broadway Albany, NY 12233-7020 One (1) pnper copy llIust be sent 10 thc DEC regi')l1al contact in the re g,ionnl o ffice- covi:'li ng lh!.' COIIIll)' ill which 1.11(' Sill' is Iocillcd. Plc a~c check Ollr wci:1s ile fo r the addr e~s of om regional o njc c~: Ilt ll. :i/www.d ec.ny.govillbo11li776 .html f'()R t)~"ARTME "r tJSf. 01\ 1. Y lIef'SITE r &A CODK:______1.':,\ 0 ol"n c ~.: ___ _ Page 6 of 6 (By requesTOr who is an individuaJ) I hereby affirm that informatioll provided 011 thi~ form and il~ attachnrenti is true and complete to the best of my knowledge and belief- I am aware that any false statement made herein is punishable as a Class A misdemeanor pursuant to section 210.45 oflhe Penal Law. Date: ____ Signature: ______---_-_-- Print Name: (By an requestor othl;:f than an individual) CIt1( ~IC~ ~.f eNlIll€o"""'~1"At.- c.c~IlDlN.fJ(TIOIJ I hereby affinn that I that 1 3m authorized by that entity to make this application; thai this and direction: and that information provided on this fonn and ils ' , and belief. I am aware that any false "iatemeni made herein is punishable as a of the pffia! Law. j'nnt Name:~~\ '\<.. KuL'~U)Sl:t SUBMITTAL INFORMATION: Three (3) complete copies are required . • Two (2) copies; one paper ropy wi th original signatUJ\'::s and one electronic copy in Portable Document Format (PDF) on a CD or diskette, must be scnt to: Chief. Site Control Section New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Division of Environmental Remediation 625 Broadway Albany, NY 12233·7020 One (l) paper copy must be sellt to the DEC rcgionol contnLl ill the regional office covering the county in which the site is !ocuted. PI"ast:!i cheek our website for the address of our regional offices: http://www.dec.ny.goviaboutfi76.html FOR DEI'AUTMENT USE ONl.Y eCl' srn: T&A cont:: ______LEADOf'FICE;C-~ ______ Page 6c of 6 Sto.fCIIlcnt of-Certification' and Signatures (By l'equC$lor 'Nho is ,m individual) I I!~rchy llHirm thai iniDrmation provid"d on th i ~ form ,md i l~ aHach ments i~ trw:- ,:md comple~c to the bc~t o f my knowledge rmd be!ie£. ! am aware thm any false statement made herei n is punishable liS J Class A misdelllfiu\O!' purstJatlt to ~cc t i()ll 21 !l .4S ot" tbe Pcnal Law, ",,' Jl i, f; S,,,,,,,,,,!' t~)J~ , 1\Y1tiJ;~L r,i,,' N,m,.i:kAlt 'L flt,6t:>L (By ,JIl rctjl! '~:>lOf other lhi"ln fin individual) IJ J hereby afnfrn tha t 1 amfkf;;~SLl)g_t!rjl i \k) otVU::4l1t<.. IIv(1:llliiy); thl [urn alllhorizcJ by thai en ti lY ID make thi~ ftppilca!iDn; Illftt til is npplicfltion w~s prepared by m~ or under m)' sllpervisioll :lnddirection: ;md Ih~1 infonlmtiol1 provided on ihis forlll3nd its attachments is true and cOlTIpi ek to the be;;l n!' :ny k nowk~dgc nnd beiief, I am 3.WMG i.ha; ~ny raise STa!ement made ilcr <:i n i~ puni~h8b1<: liS a C(c. s ~ /I, I lli~dem<.",;mor PUlSlIllJlt \0 Seciioli 2;0.45 of tl K' Penal LJW Om, ::11'4:/ ii S;"",",,'( +~=~:~~f~~P{~A-,_p'm ( N"m< ~ifE;f:,i !cyAMJ) j SU13MITTAL INVORMAT10N : Thrct (3) complete copic:; arc rcq\ l j f~d. Two (2) copies, olle P One (I) p Page 6c of 6 (By requestor who is Jll i ndividl)~I) I hereby affirm (h ~ t information provided on this form ;mri Il~ al r ilt'hmctl[~ IS tt' L!e and complc1 c tCl li1c best of my knowledge and helief. I am aware th~ \t any fa lse .~latelllen t mad", herein is I'unj s h ~b le as ~ Class A misdemeanor p u r~mlll t to seclion 21O A5 or lile Penal Law. . , I , "'" 3/U-jI28 S ; '''01''~'<~ :\<:~{~ +\ ,il1.":.~,:::.- P,;", N'm'j:{&-Nt..'LJltAPI______ (By un reque3ior other thil:! lin U1d l ... rdll~l) V j _ D:uc:J/-1.klt2_~ I'rilltName: ~~( ~_!_ SUBJ\tITT AI" JNfORl\IA nON: Three (3) complel;: copie" arc requircd. Two (2) COPIes. olle Ila pcr copy wim original s ignalurec: and one el«tronic copy in Portable Document Format (PDf) Oil a CD or diskette, must be sent to: Chief, Sitl: Conlrol Scction New York State Dcpartme:nt uf Envirollrnl'J)tHl Conscrva tion Division of Environmental R~mcdiat io l1 625 Broadway AlballY, NY 12233·7020 One (I) [}ilper copy must be sen! to !lle DEC regional contact ill the regional office covering the !.!ounty in which the ~~IC is located. Plea.'c check OLlr websitc for th e address of our regional offices: httpJ/www.dcc.ny.gov/aho'Jtf776,hlml fOR Dr.rARTME .... T liS~: Q.'H, \' 8C1' SITET&A CO DI:: ______ P'ge 6c of 6 APPLICA n ON INSTIW CTlONS Pn.)vldmg co mpkte mt"m1Kl1JOIl will allo'o\- ler the qUIck review lind c(lllsi{kr:l1IOrl oflll.:- applu:allcm. Inco mplete appl ic ations will b" plflced ull hold wh il ~ the IlHssmg tn lQl'Olltion 15 requCli led. In th is I egan!. en~ lI rc that :l lt reC]ucsle.i In fo rm N OI~ : T(l ilUU il IlilTly Lv an \:Xl ' l ll1 ); Be l' Agrccmcnl and/or A I )I' ); ~ S E.CTI ON I It EQliESTO R I I\' FOI~ i' M TI ON Prm'"k I'", nam.... ,,' IhL' p,' r~""lsl'('OIuy «;'1'IC~(lng p.il rt ,crpauOIi in (Ill' Bel' Ilf mO l"e th,ln Oll~, a;:adl adri i; i o~ol sh(,~I~ wllh ~'~qu c H('d ,,;')rmJlu)ll. Ifan L.L(. { h~ membcr~'''''''llC r", rl."l1"~ n~'"'t (0 b;,: p"OI'ntl'd on a 'l.'pal1ll~ an"d1tncm) Th" fe qll~~(Or IS !Ill' p ~rson or emily ;:eeking D~raflll1Cl1I (evk,,, ,111(1 appr.l\·al "r l h~ ",,,,~di~ 1 progra m. Prov id<: Ih " r" 'l"es! ,lI"~ maili,,!: add,,''''' In<.i t~I~ J.' h PI"v vi(k th e nnnl<' llf tilt rcq ll~ ,r t)r' , Il \l : h tl~ i l( tl l\:: p r e;<; ~ nt" !l v " T hi ~ I,' t h~ P" ' ~ \» )' t" whom ~ l l CO,. Ie~ p (J ll d~ ncc , Il(lli ~ ~,; , (' 1 ~ will GQ o; ~ll1. This i:; 1h~ [1~ I1' (\ r Whll ",oi l in II~ T ~ d JS the O>llt",:t pClwn ;1< tl,e H.CA l~cprc . ~n'ali v e AJ drcf.-<'. ell C"ns"ll~nl 'bill" Con~\tl l ~nl address., dl. I' ro~ld~ Ihe mulllr;g add r.::'Is.. Idcphnrc IHllnber, fa).. nllmhcr ~nd c-l1mi l nddle\<., A!I"m~y :,,/.,0)[' A tl t. rn ~y JlddlC-SS, ~ t c PII I"I ICIp~n !i'V ()Iun tec r C~ l' tl ti C d tl R ~I; ' lio nsl . ip to PropeTly TIn: ~ uc s tor I.~ requ"c,j 10 ill,mtlfy ,1., r.: 1 ~l i ol\shlp 10 the property (p""~n).lIs own",. CU JH.1H OW P,C,.. e IC). If ll,,,, rtt]" ",lor i .~ no! Ihe ownc!'. p"..... r SEe n ON 11 I'ROPERT Y I Nf.OlO-lATtO I" SUMMA[{\' SU EET j'I'(Wltic ~ n ~ l1l c for 1 1 , ~ p,0pe ,.t;.', Tht! ","'''' w uld bt' Jll (\Wll<: " '~ mllm , \' \ \ l" r~1lt 0" h i sro r,,~ al opn at i()M ( I.e" A lie F OlllJlllrc} or th'< g ~n~ L" n l 1() ~lIl l PIt,H' id" a Wed addn.-;;". cllyl!(\I'n, ~ Olln l)' , %IP code GJS I ~fo nnauo n Provide !he [;ltItude &IId lo " ~iI U d ,, (~ Tax m~p information Pro viti\! Ihe tax parcdl><.:Cliuui'., I,;..,:k/l ,)t 'lifo mm1l011 anu ma r . T:I), m ~ r InfCrtnllll (lIl Im y ~tc " bw ;nn ( iront till: tn x (\!s ~ ss('r '~ ,)tfic~ , Fa il'lre 10 illc\udc the mnp (('lllid ""StI lI in Ihe "p pilt!lllll.lII 1>e1 118 . 1c~ml.,j In comple!e. Anach a ~O\"\ l y I,U Illap Vil lh nJC'llilli.:r nll nJo.:,.:., ~, I I) r l~ wlth :my iigllrcs nceded to show the loc~ li 'lrl and bot!l"ia"'"s 01' lh" propt; rty, Jllctlld;; a USGS 7.5 min1l1e quad mn p Oil .... hid llhc I'ropcny appe!lrs. Tv: map rdalionship M,p Pro",,!.; tt p".>pc:ny ba:;;: nl;lp(&) !~ Mny p~rlUT tiT PW\ ICITy "'~" I'll />1 I1C-' If,u ....II:>! pel,Tn,;lgc' ~ u r ,11 10'1 ''''11<)11 on 1-3\.7(>;>(,,_ gO lu 1~! I" ,'i" ":'!",!\),:ltl\- ~"' b\lC ' \\nIHTll"'I!F,>II,~~~ill!.~!, l irl~fl'.'.!lu!..sIl, SECT ION 111 C UIlREi\ T I'IHWUnV C)WNF.IVON:RATOR INFOR!\1ATIO;\' Own~T /l. lml~ Provide Ihc n.,"'" " f,h", mlTenl UWlIe, .,, 1' I I ,,~ pWI'c-rty (If dlr l c~Jl1 [rom Ih \' rt'qtlc~or) Lb l;ill p;;rncs !loldbg nr, IUle .....'lolm Ih ~ pr('JX'r1y, SF,C 1'IO"l IV 'I< EQUESTOH HIGIBILrI" IN IiOHI'IA'I ION As 0 ~tE:1ll';1! n" dchm:!ll1. P'-O\, ',) l' l'OIllIJklc Qnd ,lcl An:: mly enfor,x,noent ~ c t ;"n,; rel ~lin!i-lO the p.ovoscd hro"'nfld d PfQ I'<,,,ly I)l:lldiug "gn,ns! tin' l eG ltCSIOI'! E ,X I Slll1~ Unler I. thc rC4Ue5tor prne"lIy " ' I !1jc ~116;1n " ",kr r," 1!1~ ill\'C,llgatioll, i'Clllovul <>r I'emcdiuli():l .jf tbe CO nllllllll1al101l ~I I ll~ profl<: rty? O litstliliding Spi ll h ind Clnl m I ~ Ihc rc q\l C~l () r Sllhje<:l to an 'l"l$ t :'n~ in ~ claill1 hy the Spill Fllll,)" A lly < 1 ".'l i ( " I~ l!!g;Jl dll1g w li ~ lh cr a 1" 1It)' IS ~ l!hjtXl (0" ' 1)1 11 cl aim should 11<.' tlls':'!1~:;~d 11"111 tllc Spill Fu nd Adll1mISlr~lOl' !Ins d\ ~ ,e'-lu~'!'wr h~Ul d~l~ m\ll , ed 111 :II) lldmllliSlmllvc, civ,1 Qr cnm ' Il"IIl I'OCt(din~ !(o Ix in vlOlal;n)) of i} ~n y proV Is ion of the ... ubjt~t IJw, j,) ;'\ny relared om.::, or ,Idc'>nimllion. iii) uny "'lj:~l n hon nnj)I.'lIlenting Tltk I':, (or iv) &lIy ~1ll1l1u ~!a:utc, r<'l~'Ilbl i on v f thc Sl a :~ or f~-daa l go~emn1enl , H'S\), prov,de an a rlanarion On a SO:Jlnldt t: anachlll<.'n t P~\'1 0 li-' ocr denml 1135 the requestor P"" iUII~I~ ~1'1)II~tI fo r ""oJ h<''C1l tlcllled cmry 1l1to Ihl: Bl.P',' If S Has the re qllc,\Ul' b~':Il fllll itci In a i!1ViI pr oee~d in); to hav~ commiltcil il n~!:ligcllt {' I' int enll(ln~l l y i O l1io n ~ II{'! Invtl lvln g the flillldl ing, ,IN I" g, t~;l li llg , d i ~ l'o ~ i ll~ or transport ing <)f COnlllll1l mll1!S? (rimlnal C(l llVlct ; OIl~ II ,IS ,I,e ,e'I"esior rn,c" con~i c te,1 "r ,. ,'I m"nnl ('II'~ ' l~ I) ilJV ol"mg tile IH1ll1tlins, "firing. trcallng, ,hsJl'<'!'ii'lg or lnillspuninl( of c('ntmnllla m ~, 0,· ") (h at Invol"",s ~ violent felony, (" ," t1, brihe'y, I''''J'''Y , !hdl, ur olTell:lC ag"ins\ public "dmilllslrnt,Ol) (as that tc , m ,S \",cd III f\rtidc 195 of the I'en,l11 .~ lw) ,mder federal I;-r,v ill the In",,, orany Malc'! Ha~ Ihe ""-l " "~ lor kno ..... illyJy t;,\:iilkd ~In h.:tncnts or cont-e.-' Ied m,uefT al faCT!: til any mallC r withm 'he JunS{h t'tloll ofrhc IJcJX!mm:ll1. or suhmittcd II fa l~ e ~ t a lCmenl or mad~ u.~(' of or mad ... :1 ffl l\>: ~ lat ell1ell l. In cO!!t1c<:lio;1 Willi an}' d"":I1",,,nl Of appl ico1 liun s tl blmll~..r (u I!IC [lcJ};lr1:m~nl. 2 S ECTION \ ' I'ROI' EHTY ELlC IIlIUTY INFon;\HT IO .... A,;I Wl.l ~" I :c' a.!.!'!',;llUbalL. pnw,dc (."{)mrlct~ .• n,1 dct;,ilcd ,,,(.m,,,,t, ... ,, on I"" 'I)I)"> ~ Iv Ih,'loltllWlIlll ~h.!hil ; l)' q~~'ll(l!\, ;11\';\\'C IC.i III the' nf(,nn,II;\'c Ii;~ permi,sible tll .. dcl ~ II\'~ "p~ ~'lfI C ~ c~T i ()~~ Llf <:xlst lng pr(\p erty ,. t r olt~, h(,\\'c ~ ~t , ;1 i~ "\~ (I",,~: ~,tl 111,,1 1b..T II,f'Hm "T ioll lx' >LlltlilHln7.,'ti , 'Ihf ()Lll I ,n ~ lldow i, fJ'I)" ltinl 10 ML"'rmlll ,~r)1Hlr>ri~. le in fmnnli" 'l ~ CF; RCl.,\ J Nt> l. L ;~1or.!! Is Itny r<>WOIl Of lhc prop~r1Y IiST~rt (1I 11h( N;l P(ln,l l PIiOl;li~~ Li,ljN?l. j .~l.Iblish~d lOmb U::H CLA" 11' ,0, providc 1<.. I"v~ n' mrnm'Jli... " l{(."g l ~lI)' L'silog H ~~ Jn~ !,<-m io" of litO' properly ~""'I lJ ~'Cn Ir,,!c...! "!llh.: f'.~\\1 Ynrk ST;lIe Hq!;m,,' ,)rJ"acl;v~ Ha7ar JKRA O()e.,~ , ht p«'I'",l), h"Y ~. t Rc;uUI t'(' CSeS of llli~ ~p!)Ii.m i o" Inl<:r;", ~Iat\l~ (lIdlllK-s tlf\' nOI d;-,;omcd !n b ~ $UbJ,'I;l 10 ~ RCRA pemHt, F"""'gOrokl Is lb~ pf F "for[c"'~1I! lU·lIonl'eluJlllg Is [he PTI.lper1), Sllht(:c l loa" ~ llfor~c", en l ;"'!Ion "Iltl",r Alllde 21, T,!k>~ 7 or '.loflhc Eel. or ,1\lt SECTION VI PRO,I Ee'!' UESCHlI"l lOi" i\~ (l :;0;1) 181>, ~ ml £l lI!l .! 1I IlrOvlde (',()nll ) I <:\'(~ <>IU! delalkd mform ,'li un " l1O\l l Ihe proj<:cr , indu(lill:; (lic ptlrpOH' (If' !he proj ~~t . pror-:.:scd !lS~ ~ ticr rf,lI1c,llt1T ion (\11(1 ' he e,llm,,\<:,i proiec,t sc.b<"d"le, SfCTIO l'" vn I'ROPEIHV E'lVlnOo'l\'IF,NT AL BISTORY Env'mnll1enl nl KCl)OrlS S\lmm~ ri l'<: the f(:, njt, 1)1' all previo", ~""inmm""l: , f ,t\ldic~ , me ll1L!mg lL ny r'has~ (tlr I ' b£~ II In" c sr l l!~f'<)O~ ~s \'ve il us tnnps i'nd d iH~, Thc , \lIlHnary ;;;1(>uld ,ndude infO!'I1l:itl ull conceroll118 P[' 5! \i;C::S, known or ,\mp~ct" J cOll lnmill;nioi< , Jnd the nm n"s "f :lIl y known pn l1l,II':' ~(m l:l lnlllan t 8 10 b~ a (hl l' c~,~cd, CO l'i¢s of 81 1 e l1 vi r S"'nphn)! Oa:lI Provldc stable ofkoown CQnUl lll1nanl. (f'(om "'~ 'r (J l i ! l l!- ~11{! ;! l!:ll) SIS) at !hc I'rt)p.:rty "'lill !he mn~,"~\lm COnCCllll'Uu(orl dCl~'t!:1! nnd lhc llled,a 111 whirh e ~ eh C S \I S red~ Known or SIl~r~c c~ \1 SOllT CC~ of I lId i c,:~H' tilly kn(owll or susp.:c;r:d >t'Jt ,,~e~ of C Pas l Land U3CS Indicate 1),1S1 land tLo;es Owner> i'ro",(1\' !he numes. addlc~s aud I)~<"l~ ml mb~I 'S Q( all pr~V!OILS owner>, "lcll1(ling 11 .\lnte "'~1l 1 a~ to Jny reial i on~hif' ()f tlle r~ l]u ~s I OI' to :1" >' prior ()Wll er(,) O»",atofS Provide the n~me.s, ;Iddrer..~ ~IH! phone m"nbeJ~ of [.11 prc~i\ ) lJs op~ m tor" in c llJd m~ J ~1~t~me lU a!; to ~ n y Icb1l0nship orlile requc'hlr 10 ~ n)' pnor ()per.lt()r(s) S[Crr ON VIII COr-.'TACT I('; FORMAT IO'l [,,,,, ide Ih(' (Ianl\~ und oddn-;5e;; Df lh~ pat1lcs tIll the Site C011I:;.,,1 Li.~t (SCLl T ht SCI. (ol1sis!~ .)f (i) ! 1 1~ ~1l 1 c'!' n<'Clltt.c o fli(~r Ilml plilnnlllg oolH',lIdcpl, chairpersoll (If each r.Ollnty, r.i t}', town, and vil!n ge in whicll the ,It;: IS lo .'ulcd; 11) r~sjdenl.:i, owners, ~!lU OCCU p3nt, of the ~ ;t e An d I H" !~" l i~, illlJlledintcly ~dj a l'e m to ihc site; in) local ncws media frOlll which 'he community typi caUy ob!ain~ iliformaLlon: i~) the public walcr supplIer which services the art[1 in which Itlc ~i!c 'S lo~ntcd; ~) a'IY per!i,m .",ho h:!,; r e qu~ s tcd 10 toe placed on I h~ SeL; and, vi) 11r" ' lO h'linislrlllor o r ~lI y !;Chool or dny ~!in: bcili!)lloc!!cd On N !l(:M li>c ~' k Al.\o, pruvi(ie Ihe name and :Nldn:~ (If,, docume1lt r~""""I!(lI'Y' along wllh a copy ofa letter scm tu The rcposi'ory ~ckn J SECTIO'l IX LAN D l'SE f ACTORS ,:lclluly llle rum:nt usc (,\I~l>(lry, Aml.:.h l ~\lmm~' ry of ('(!rre,,1 buslll""~ 1 11IC1l< I ",dU~ IS tll~ prop(ls('d \t.\C '~()[lSi~ l ~fi l wllh hl sT "r l(~ 1 ,lIldhlr ~' l\ nC": u~"d \1 r l1\' !l 1 p" 'lerll~ 1"(11 II..., 11~l gj lborh , ... )d',1 {SC(' " ,·\dj.1(:Crll Usc," ricsrrlf>1ill" bdlJw ) I, the 1 >Il'>IlU5~" pos;-r<"lllc, lo~ l i \l)\ U~~ t'O I ISIS l ~nl wnh 1<1<:,,1 ~Ulllrl)'.. rl~1 1Il"lg ,1nd m~ I )~" i'rcwi(k rdn'" nl d,\Cument.lt 01' 5ur-pmling the C.uusI~lcn,·y C0 11l pr~htt1sil'~ Plan.; I ~ the propo~d )' Are l h:." ,' ~ lI y feue !"I,1 01 SWle Ill nd I I S~ (k,; l gn n lln n ~ r cl;l1in ~ 10 lh~ pl"oper l y ~ I ryes. cxp i ll in I d~nl' Ii- wh ~ lh cr I h ~ growth [' F ~ I~ ' l n g IOfrJslrucllIrc Is Ihe pmpcI1y ~ccessrble 10 "XI~r i ng infru.lrwt,,!(· (hlg,",w~r s. llllhnc;, sewer and wa.leI lincs. etc)'! ( 'nl1!ll'n l rt:""'J11;~.s An.: lher(' nnporlRnt rullllral re ~oltr(:t:$ , , ~du d \llg f~d era l;)f .,Mi c hl .~t(mc or heril.1gc .';It.:s or '\!arivc AII1~II.:a Jl reli;1:ious si!e$ \~ i l hl:1 ',4 mile of fh t site" If }'C5, !!"'pbin. Nnmra l R~WUfC <:'~ Are tl,,~,c ;mrmt~'" federal Sf ~ !o:: 01 local naluml r('S I'\O\KI I' lni tis 1 11~lltlll""tal Conim]; Does r l l~ pro p,'ny h ~v c Jny itlStitH ti" nn i C(llllrol , 1fl1 IHJsed .5 p"rl \11' II ""m~I I "<1 jJIVI!.f AtI~ '" ~ d~."cnpli o n of l h ~ g,'IlCl'll lland \I:;':., (unrCSlr;od, ~l(lel'lll a l, commercjal. iodu.>",«1. n~ I; Ct1 t ' u ra l . recrr.lliollal, mlxcrl, nrb ~ o, e l ~_ l in '''c 'II!!";) Providing Dil ~rca m:lp dcplcnng U$~~ r3 tt~ IxSl 3pproach.. Grounriwaier vu lner.abiliTy llc.<;I;n be the potr') I ~,(f1O!1 f'm gr~ m ()"5\; nb~ (ill ge n~ral leflll;;) lhe gCO!!I'a rhy nn!! geo logy ofli1e pr(lpcrty i,,, all ~\! ~, \" h",""~ SIGN ATURE I'AG~: The Rcqm:.'"'' Il\n .~l 5 ig\llh ~ ~ "pli,(l li,)() , HilI I h~' "' Sli ll t\' ln ~ n NG ,\IT,, C I-IM ENTS ,\ NJ) REMINDERS J::nsurt rhat Ibe altachmcnts are mcludcd wllh the JH1 pcr COPy and on Ihe CD Wilh lhe da:tro",c cupy l11!:lud" " copy ofa dearly i {i~Jll j r. ..d pulllic slI n'c)' fm'p for Ih" propel1y (c.g. Ihe prvpcrty shown 011 3 11I1I"I;On of tile n:ic"nn! L-SGS (opogra))hlc m:lp; pill! m~Il ' till)' he ltse<.l thf run,II'1(\:pcrl;CS), ~ del"i l",\ map Ih"l cI~; l1l y illdic~tc; llw oo ull En~\rrc lha r " 'pponing d oc\lm"'T1I~ li o[) It~ s lt~ One Icgibl" [l3pcr wpy with origillill si~ I\; lluro;, nnd all a': C<..Jlllp<1llym g aml(l)mcllls ~)\d (llle ef<:C1fGllK should be sen1 10. Chief. Site C{ll)tn)1 Secli(ln, New York Slale Dep;"lrn<::11 1 o f Etw ir(JIlJllcnlal COl lS~t"I'~IIOI), D ~v islon of Envuo!lm~nlal Rcmcdl:tuon, 625 Bro3 (hv;oy . Albany, NY 12233"7020 O ne PJp<:T oopy Mtbe apphcallOn with all :tccmnp:mying a ll Elcc lru1llc ~"(' py :\ COln pl ~tcd (s igne 4