- 1 -
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 12 TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2012
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAM MOHAN REDDY
WP NO.35080/2012 & WP NOS.35254-35369/2012 (EDN-AD)
BETWEEN
1. H CHETHAN KUMAR S/O HANUMANTHAPPA J AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS AMBEDKAR ROAD, 3RD CROSS HOLALKERE TQ, CHITRADURGA-577 501
2. BASAVARAJ G A S/O ANANDAPPA S G AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS H N HALLI, JAGALUR TQ, ANABUR (POST) DAVANAGERE-577528
3. SRINIVAS H R S/O RAMESH H C AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS MAIN ROAD, HOLALKERE TQ, CHITRADURGA-577501
4. VINAY K G S/O GOPALRAO K S AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS ARUN TAILORS CHICK JAJUR (POST) HOLALKERE TQ, CHITRADURGA 577 523 - 2 -
5. PRAJWAL D R S/O DEVENDRAPPA D K AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS KAVAL RAMAPPA EXTENSION HOLALKERE TQ CHITRADURGA 577 501
6. DARSHAN S S/O SHIVAMURTHY S R AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS ADHIVALA (POST) HIRIYURU TQ, CHITRADURGA-577511
7. VIJAYKUMAR V G S/O VEERABRAPPA G G AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS DOOR NO. 116/7 THRISHUL THEATER ROD K B EXTEN, (BADAVANE) DAVANAGERE-577002
8. DAYANANDA T S/O THIPPAIAH M AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS KODIHALLY (POST) CHALLAKERE (TQ) CHITRADURGA-577501
9. PAVAN KUMAR B R S/O RAMESH RAO AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS SHARADHA TUROTIAL CHIKKAPETE CHITRADURGA-577501
10. S PUNEETH S/O SIDDALIGSWMY AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS 2ND CROSS, NIRANJAN NILAYA KHB COLONY - 3 -
CHALLAKERE-577522
11. PRADEEP YADAV R S/O RAMANNA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS MADDUKUNTE (VILLAGE) M D KOTE (POST) HIRIYURU (TQ) CHITRADURGA 577143
12. T VENNALA S/O H THIMMANNA AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS MEDEHALLY (A D COLONY) CHITRADURGA-577502
13. PRAVEENA K S S/O SANNAKOTRAPPA A AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS BHARAMASAGARA (POST) CHITRADURGA 577 519
14. NAVEEN KUMAR P S/O PRAKASHA R AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS G P T POLYTECHNIC CHITRADURGA-577501
15. NETHRAVATHI M S/O MANJANNA P AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS HOSAKALLAHALLI, D K HATTI (POST) CHITRADURGA-577501
16. SHRUTHI I.M S/O JAGADEESH I M AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS BHARAMASAGARA (POST) CHITRADURGA-577519 - 4 -
17. BABY SHAMILI D/O MUDALAGIRIYAPPA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS GOVT. POLYTECHYNIC, HIRIYUR TQ, CHITRADURGA DIST 577501
18. HARISH KUMAR M S/O MUDALAGIRIYAPPA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS GOVT. POLYTECHNIC CHITRADURGA-577501
19. BASAVARAJU S S/O SANNA MUDDAPPA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS GOVT POLYTECHNIC CHITRADURGA-577501
20. THIPPESWAMY N B S/O BIYANNA S AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS SJM POLYTECHNIC, CHALLAKERE TQ, CHITRADURGA DIST.577501
21. NANDINI A R D/O AJJAYA H AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS GOVT. POLYTECHNIC CHITRADURGA-577501
22. RAJINI T D/O THIAPPANA K AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS MUNCIPAL COLONY 5TH CROSS KELAGOTE CHITRADURGA-577501
23. GEETHA L D/O LOKESH AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS - 5 -
MYAKULARAHALLY POST HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
24. VEDAMURTHY M S/O MURTHY N AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS HLK ROAD, SRINIVASA LAYOUT CHITRADURGA 577501
25. AJITH KUMAR P T S/O THIMMANNA P AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS IUDP LAYOUT, 6TH CROSS CHITRADURGA 577501
26. ARBAZ AMEERUL AZAM D/O SAIF UR RAHMAN AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS MUNICIPAL COLONY KELAGOTE, CHITRADURGA-577501
27. RAVIKUMAR V S/O VENKATESHA AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS SJM POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE CHALLAKERE TQ, CHITRADURGA DIST-577501
28. SACHIN G S S/O SHIVASHANKAR AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS 5TH MAIN, P J EXTN., DAVANAGERE PIN NO 577002
29. PRADEEP KUMAR C M S/O MURIGENDRAPPA K B AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS CHIKKABENNUR - 6 -
CHITRADURGA TQ, & DIST.577501
30. RAGHU C S/O CHANDRAPPA AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS NERALAGUNDI, HONNALI TQ DAVANAGERE DIST.577501
31. BASAVARAJ C S/O CHINNAPPA AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS GOVT. POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE CHITRADURGAF-577501
32. ASHOK KUMAR T J S/O JAYANNA T E AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS THANDAKOLUR TQ. SIRA TQ, TUMKUR-576023
33. RUDARAMUNI C G S/O GURUBASAPPA C K AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS ATTIGERE POST DAVANAGERE TQ K& DIST 577002
34. RUDRASWAMY N S S/O N V SHANMUKAPPA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS SONDEKOLA POST CHITRADURGA TQ & DIST. 577501
35. CHANDRASHEKARA V S/O VENU T AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS JANATA COLONY, 1ST CROSS GANDINAGARA, CHALLAKERE TQ. CHITRADURGA DIST 577501 - 7 -
36. YOGANANDA REDDY T N S/O VEERAREDDY AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS ST. MARYS POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE FORT ROAD, CHITRADURGA-577501
37. PRADEEP YADAV J S/O JAYANNA V AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS BEHIND VIJAYALAXMI MEDICAL AGENCY JOGIMATTI ROAD, CHITRADURGA-577501
38. VIJAYA SHIVA D S S/O SHIVALINGAPPA D AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS IUDP LAYOUT, 4TH CROSS CHITRADURGA-577501
39. VEENA K P S/O PALANNA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS KALUVESALLY, CHALLAKERE TQ. CHITRADURGA DIST.577501
40. SHASHIKUMAR G B S/O G S BASAVARAJAPPA AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS GVP COLLEGE CHITRADURGA-577501
41. YATHIRAJU S/O N SHANKARAPPA AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS A H GUDDADEVARA MATA KAMANA BHAVI LAYOUT, FILTERHOUSE ROAD POST OFFICE BANK CHITRADURGA 577501
42. NADEEMKHAN I S/O I ISMAIL KHAN - 8 -
AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS MOLAKALMURU POST CHITRADURGA TQ. & DIST. 577 501
43. MADHUKUMARA Y T S/O THIMMAREDDY AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS VENKATAPURA POST MOLAKALMURU TQ. CHITRADURGA DIST 577501
44. NAVENKUMAR G S/O VAJJINAPPA B AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS GVP COLLEGE CHITRADURGA-577501
45. RAKESH H M S/O MURUDAPPA H B AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS CHANNAGIRI TQ. DAVANAGERE DIST. 577002
46. KIRAN PATIL G P S/O PANCHAKSHARI G D AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS KUMBALUR, HONNALI TQ. DAVANAGERE DIST-577002
47. ARUN KUMAR H B S/O MALLIKARJUNA H B AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS HIREMEGALAGERE PSOT HARAPANAHALLI TQ. DAVANAGERE DIST 577002
48. SATISHKUMAR K T S/O M KARIYAPPA AGED ABOUT 28YEARS 5TH CROSS, SHEKARAPPA LAYOUT - 9 -
AAVARAGERE POST DAVANAGERE DIST. 577002
49. CHARANARAJA B S/O BUJJINAPPA AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS ST. MARYS POLYTECHNIC CHITRADURGA-577501
50. SACHIN D S S/O D V SITARAMAREDDY AGED ABOUT 18 YEARS DYAMANALLI POST CHITRADURGA TQ. & DIST. 577501
51. KIRANBABU R S/O RAJANNA L AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS T R NAGARA CHALLAKERE CHITRADURGA DIST. 577501
52. MANJUNATHA T S/O THIMMANNA AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS S R ROAD, P W D QUARTRES CHALLAKERE TQ. CHITRADURGA DIST. 577 501
53. RAMANUJA R J S/O R JAGADEESHAPPA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS KHB COLONY, LILG 24 C K PURA CHITRADURGA-577501
54. KISHAN C S/O CHANDRAPPA K AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS KELAGOTE, MUNICIPAL COLONY - 10 -
5TH CROSS, CHINNAPPALAYOUT SAI NILAYA, CHITRADURGA-577501
55. PAVANKUMAR R S/O RAMANJINAYALU P AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS JANATA COLONY, AMBEDKAR BHAVAN CHALLAKERE TQ. CHITRADURGA DIST.577501
56. PRITAMAGOUDA MUDEGOUDRA S/O HANUMANTAGOWDA MUDEGOUDRA AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS BAPUJI POLYTECHNIC SHABANUR, DAVANAGERE-577002
57. AMITH R S S/O SURESH KUMAR R S AGED ABOUT 18 YEARS OPP. KEB OFFICE HADIDI ROAD DAVANAGERE DIST. 577002
58. AKASH LAXMAN CHOTANNANAVAR S/O LAXMAN CHOTANNANAVAR AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS BAPUJIL POLYTECHNIC, SHABANUR DAVANAGERE 577002
59. GIRISH HANCHINAL S/O S G HANCHINAL AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS BAPUJI POLYTECHNIC, SHABANUR DAVANAGERE-577002
60. VIDYA S B D/O BASVARAJAPPA AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS SHIVAPURA (P) HOLLKERE(T) - 11 -
CHITRADURGA DIST. 577 501
61. SOWMYA G D/O GAVIRANGAIAH AGED ABOUT 18 YEARS K C PALYA CHIKKANAYAKANA HALLI(T0 TUMKUR DIST
62. RAGAVENDRA T S/O THIPPESWAMY M AGED ABOUT 26 YERS SHEKKARAPPA LAYOUT AVARAGERE POST DAVANAGERE DIST-577002
63. SUHAS H P S/O PRABHAKAR H S AGED ABOUT 18 YEARS #2110/2, 3RD MAIN 3RD CROSS, M C C BLOCK DAVANAGERE DIST-577002
64. VIJAYAKUMARA M K S/O MANTHAPPA K V AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS A V NAGAR BETHURRU ROAD DAVANAGERE DIST-577002
65. LINGARAJ ASUNDI S/O THIPPESHAPPA ASUNDI AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS RANEBENNUR POST HAVERI DIST-581123
66. SUNIL S P S/O PRABHU S AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS CHIKKAMMANAHALLI EXTENSION - 12 -
DAVANGERE DIST-577002
67. SIDDESH N S/O S NAGARAJ AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS ANAGODU PSOT DAVANGERE DIST-577002
68. SRINIVAS BABU M S/O G MARANNA AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS JANATHA COLONY CHALLAKERE(T) CHITRADURGA DIST-577501
69. MADHU SUDHAN S P S/O PRASAD S S AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS MARADIHALLIK POST CHITRADURGA DIST-577501
70. LOHITHA M B S/O M R BHARATESH REDDY AGED ABOUT 18 YEARS MARADIHALLI POST CHITRADURGA DIST-577501
71. SHARATHA H L S/O UMESH L AGED ABOU 20 YEARS LAKSHMI SAGARA CHITRADURGA DIST-577501
72. BASAVARAJ K P S/O K B PARAMESHVARAPPA AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS HADADI POST DAVANGERE DIST-577002 - 13 -
73. RANJITH HEGADE S/O RAMESH HEGADE AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS HARIHARA(T) DAVANGERE DIST-577002
74. NANDA K M D/O K M SHANMUKHA SWAMY AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS NEAR GNANA BHARATHI SCHOOL HOOLLKERE ROAD CHITRADURGA-577501
75. DARSHAN KUMAR A G S/O A M GURUBASAIYA AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS ADIVALA POST, HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
76. YAMUNA BAI S D/O SHANKARANAIK AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS HOSAYALNADU POST HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
77. SINDHU N D/O NIJALINGAPPA N AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS KALLAHATTY POST HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
78. SRINIVAS J N S/O NINGAPPA J N AGED ABOUT 17 YEARS GOVT POLYTECHNIC HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501 - 14 -
79. RAVI G S/O GURUBASAPPA T AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS ADIVALA POST HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
80. GOUSIYA BANU H A D/O SYED ASIFULLA AGED ABOUT 22 YEAS SIDDNAYAKA CIRCLE HIRIYURT(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
81. SAHANA RANI R D/O RANAGASWAMY E AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS SIDDNAYAKA CIRCLE HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
82. SANTHOSH R S/O REVANA SIDDAPPA M C AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS BAPUJI POLYTECHNIC CHITRADURGA DIST.577501
83. PARUSHURAM B S/O MLULLAYA BABU AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS GOVT POLYTECHNIC HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
84. BABITHA L D/O LAKSHMANA READDY N R AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS GANDHI NAGAR 1ST CROSS CHITRADURGA DIST.577501 - 15 -
85. SWETHA M D/O MAHANTHAPPA T AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS KASHETTIHALLI POST CHENNAGIRI (T) DAVANAGERE DIST. 577002
86. RASHEEDA BEGUM R H D/O HUSEN PEER AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RANGENAHALLY POST HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA DIST. 577501
87. NAGAPPA R S/O RAMANNA AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS HARTIKOTE POST HIRIYUT(T) CHITRADURGA 577501
88. PRAVEEN R S/O RAVI R AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS HOSAYALNADU POST HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA 577501
89. SHIV KUMAR P I S/O THIPPESWAMY P AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS GOVT POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE HIRIYUR CHITRADURGA-577501
90. PUNEETH KUMAR S S/O SHIVAMURTHY M AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS GOVT POLYTECHNIC - 16 -
INGALADALU 0POST CHITRADURGA 577501
91. SYEDZUBEER S S/O SYED AHMED AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS MARIKANVE HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
92. MUSTHAQ K S/O KHALEEL SAB B AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS BEHIND MUBARZK MASJID HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA 577501
93. KIRAN KUMAR S S/O SOMASHEKARAPPA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS GOVT POLYTECHNIC HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
94. NAVEEN T S/O THIMMANNA T AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS BEHIND BDO OFICE 3RD CROSS TRIVENI NILAYA CHALLKERE (T) CHITRADURGA 577501
95. BAKKESH SARANGAMUT J S/O S M JAYAPRAKASH AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS BAKKESH NILAYA # 2009/207 RANGANATH BADAVANE DAVANAGERE DIST.577002 - 17 -
96. VIJAY KUMAR P S/O PAPANNA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS VEERADHIMANA HALLI POST CHALLKERE (T) CHITRADURGA-577501
97. SHIVAMMA R D/O BARAMMAIH AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS S J M POLYTECHNIC CHALLKERE (T) CHITRADURGA 577501
98. VISWANATHA S S/O SHARANAPPA K AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS NEAR USTAVAMBA TEMPLE DODAPETE CHITRADURGA-577501
99. MADHU J S/O JAYANNA D AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS G M ASHWATHA REDDY NAGAR JAGALUR (T) CHITRADURGA 577501
100. SHIVANANDA S S/O SHARANAPPA D AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS K B EXTENSION NEAR CHURCH CHITRADURGA-577501
101. MANJUNATHA D S S/O SHANMUKAPPA D M AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS ST MARYS POLYTECHNIC - 18 -
CHITRADURGA-577501
102. G M THIPESWAMY S/O MAHANTHESH AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS ST MARYS POLYTECHNIC CHITRADURGA-577501
103. ABDUL AZEEZ GUBBI S/O CHAMAN SAB AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS ST MARYS POLYTECHNIC CHITRADURGA-577501
104. AVINASH G T S/O THIPPESWAMY K G AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS RAMAGHATTA POST HOLLKERE(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
105. MANJUNATHA T S/O THIPPESWAMY H AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS K B EXTENSION NEAR CHURCH CHITRADURGA-577501
106. DAYANANDA KUMAR H A S/O ANJINAPPA G AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS K B EXTENSION NEAR CHURCH CHITRADURGA-577501
107. D H MANJUNATH S/O HANUMANTHAPPA AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS CHIKAJAJUR POST HOLLKERE(T) - 19 -
CHITRADURGA-577501
108. UMESHA B R S/O RAMAPPA AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS BASAVAPURA POST CHANNAGERI(T) DAVANAGERE DIST. 577002
109. RAGINI H L S/O LOKAPPA AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS BASAVAPURA POST CHANNAGERI(T) DAVANAGERE DIST. 577002
110. SOUMYA D N D/O NAGARAJ D AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS RAMPURU POST MOLAKALMURU (T) CHITRADURGA-577501
111. H N LINGARAJ S/O H N NEELAPPA AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS P B ROAD BARAMASAGARA CHITRADURGA-577501
112. DEVARAJ S M S/O MANJAPPA S B AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS HALAGAWADI POST SEEGEHALLY CHITRADURGA-577501
113. SALETH RAJESH L S/O LAZER M AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS - 20 -
MARY ROAD CHURCH STREET HIRIYUR(T) CHITRADURGA-577501
114. RAKSHITHA H S D/O SHIVARAMU H J AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS VETBVL POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE BANGALORE-560029
115. NAVEEN H P S/O PRABHAKAR AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS SHREE MALLIKARJUNA POLYTECHNIC CHITRADURGA-577501
116. PAVAN S N S/O DR NAGENDRAPPA AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS SIDARANAPPA EXTENSION 2ND CROSS, HOLALKERE CHITRADURGA-577501
117. VINAY M S/O H J MURUGESH AGED ABOUT 18 YEARS MEDEHALLY CHITRADURGA-577501. .. PETITIONERS
(BY SRI P H VIRUPAKSHAIAH & SRI PRATAP KUMAR O., ADV.) AND
1. STATE OF KARNATAKA REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF SECRETARY EDUCATION DEPARTMENT GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA VIDHANA SOUDHA BANGALORE-560001 - 21 -
2. DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF TECHNICLA EDUCATION PALACE ROAD BANGALORE-560001
3. THE ADDITIONAL SECRETARY GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA EDUCATION DEPARTMENT(TECHNICAL EDUCATION) M S BUILDINGS DR B R AMBEDKAR VEEDHI BANGALORE-560001
4. THE PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE CHITRADURGA-577501
5. THE PRINCIPAL GNANA VIKAS POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE CHITRADURGA-577501
6. THE PRINCIPAL SJM POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE CHITRADURGA-577501
7. THE PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE HIRIYUR TALUK, HIRIYUR CHITRADURGA DISTRICT-577509
8. THE PRINCIPAL ST. MARYS POLYTEHNICL COLLEGE CHITRADURGA
9. THE PRINCIPAL SJM POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE CHALLAKERE CHITRADURGA DISTRICT-577501 - 22 -
10. THE PRINCIPAL SREE MALLIKARJUNA POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE CHITRADURGA DISTRICT-577501
11. THE PRINCIPAL D R R POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE DAVANGERE-577002
12. THE PRINCIPAL BAPUJI POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE SHABANUR, DAVANGERE-577002
13. THE PRINCIPAL RURAL POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE HANUSABANVI, DAVANGERE-577002
14. THE PRINCIPAL V E T B V L POLYTECHNIC COLLEGE BANGALORE-560029
... RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI R. OM KUMAR, AGA.)
THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED CIRCULAR DATED 24.7.12 ISSUED BY R2. VIDE ANNX-A AND THE LETTER DATED 10.7.12 ADDRESSED BY THE R1 VIDE ANNX-B AND THE CIRCULAR DATED 2.8.10 ISSUED BY R2. VIDE ANNX-D.
THESE WRIT PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING: - 23 -
ORDER
Recording the submission of learned counsel for the parties, petition is disposed of in the like terms in the order dated 10.9.2012 in W.P.Nos.32330-437/2012.
Sd/- JUDGE
PL