Attractions & Strait of Georgia Accommodation Vancouver Island & The Gulf Islands, Page 10 Every Second Thursday & Online ‘24/7’ at islandtides.com
h Canadian Publications Mail Product Sales Agreement Nº 1047655 Volume 16 Number 14 Your Coastal Community Newspaper July 29–August 11, 2004 Tide tables 2 Crabs 4 Letters 4 What’s on? 5 Irish signs 6 Saturna notes 8 Bulletin board 11 The Islands Trust: federation or co-operative? Patrick Brown During their quarterly meeting on Saturna Island in June, the Islands Trust Council once again discussed the allocation of resources (funds and staff) for local planning projects. The perennial issue centres on whether those Islands that contribute the most in property taxes to the Trust’s finances should receive, as a right, a proportionate share of the local planning budget. Local planning includes community plans, zoning, and subdivision on each Island, financed by both taxation and application fees. The larger Islands have claimed for years that they did not get Photo: Christa Grace-Warrick their share of the local planning budget, and that they were made to subsidize 350 people jammed Pender's Community Hall for a Public Hearing on a controversial Bylaw (see story below). planning for the smaller Islands. The smaller Islands claimed that it became almost impossible to obtain sufficient Galiano contamination ‘Driftwood Village’ gets a thorough airing resources to tackle any large planning More than 350 people attended a Public meeting. Kojima said that 430 of these had issue, even if the resolution of the issue spotter recognized Hearing on North Pender Island for Bylaw 141, been opposed to the development and 160 in would benefit the other Islands. The Galiano Ratepayers Association awarded Barbara the ‘Driftwood Village’ proposal to create high- favour of it. (The final number of written This subsidization of smaller Islands Littlejohn an honorary lifetime membership earlier density housing on Rural-zoned land. The submissions was 795, with 620 against the was one of the issues that led to the this summer. Littlejohn discovered pollution in community hall was overflowing through doors proposed development and 175 for it.) incorporation of Bowen Island and its Georgeson Creek in 1999. She noticed that frogs had and up stairways. The July 17 Public Hearing The issue got a good airing before the Local decision to carry out its own planning gone from a pond near her home. She and her was preceded at noon by an information Trust Committee: Wayne Wright, Em Round rather than utilizing Islands Trust staff. immediate neighbours hired an engineer to ascertain meeting about the not-yet-resolved Housing and Giselle Rudischer. Over 30 people spoke Traditionally, the Trust has allocated the reason for this disappearance of wildlife. Agreement that is dependent on Bylaw 141. against the bylaw and another eight spoke in the local planning budget through Many people stayed for the almost five hours of favour of it, some of whom wandered from the establishing specific priorities, meetings despite the heat. topic at hand but were courteously allowed to attempting to deal with issues affecting The information meeting allowed continue. Several people on both sides of the all islands, as well as the particular community members to ask searching issue addressed the Local Trust Committee for concerns of larger and smaller Islands. questions about the nature of the ‘amenity’ of a second, third, or even fourth time once the list While Trust Chief Financial Officer nine housing units to be reserved for people of speakers was completed. One speaker was Doug Levell said he has developed a over 60. The rest of the 36 units planned are for heckled for getting personal when he took aim reporting system that could allocate the sale to people over 50. Earmarking nine units at a former trustee who was present in the cost of all Local Planning effort to one for the 60-pluses is the trade-off for changing audience. Two speakers got gentle laughter Island or another, he expressed the the zoning of the Rural parcel (normally when they trotted out old phrases that the opinion that exactly matching allowed one house and one cottage) to a newly community has heard repeated many times expenditures to tax contributions would Barbara Littlejohn (left) and Barbara Geary created zone called Rural Comprehensive 2. before. not be workable. His figures did, The British Columbia Building Corporation works Part of the proposal is also the conversion of a However, the atmosphere was like a however, indicate the extent of the yard site was found to be contaminated. Chemicals currently Commercial Accommodation zoned celebration when speakers after speaker ‘imbalance’. from telephone poles left lying on the ground and salt parcel to the Rural Comprehensive 2 zone. against the development got cheers, whistles Wednesday’s discussion ended with from the Highways Works yard winter storage had The by now well-informed crowd stayed on and prolonged clapping from the enthusiastic the matter being tabled until the leached into the aquifer. Eventually a cleanup was for the Public Hearing which began with the audience. Sentiments expressed included, that, business meeting. On Thursday, the accomplished, with BC Hydro paying $160,000 to announcement by Islands Trust Planner yes more help for seniors was needed on Trust passed a motion which would see complete the soil excavation and disposal. The loss of Robert Kojima that 590 letters had been Pender but that this development failed the wildlife that Barbara had noticed was the first TRUST, please turn to page 3 received by the Islands Trust prior to the DEVELOPMENT, please turn to page 2 indication that the area was compromised. ✐
415 EAST POINT ROAD. Immaculate bi-level home on an acre 121 FARROW ROAD. A unique land cooperative of approx 280 with 200 ft of lowbank waterfront. Priced fully furnished with acres with only 28 shares. Offered at $645,000 is an equitable Zodiac & motor for $675,000. Very private with panoramic share including this 1.5 acres homesite with tri-level home & 180° views over the Strait of Georgia. Recently remodeled separate workshop, and a share in the common land, dock and kitchen and bathrooms. Community water system has multiple wells. wharf. Breathtaking southwest ocean views to the Pender Islands. Saturna Island Realty Saturna Island Realty Joan Combes, Broker/Owner Joan Combes, Broker/Owner phone 250.539.2121 fax 250.539.5567 toll free 1.866.539.2121 phone 250.539.2121 fax 250.539.5567 toll free 1.866.539.2121 visit our website for more photos and information: www.saturnarealty.com visit our website for more photos and information: www.saturnarealty.com Page 2, ISLAND TIDES, July 29, 2004 Book Review by Robert White Sea Kayaking—How to Do It and Where to Paddle ea kayaking is reputed to be the fastest growing sport in Marine Trails for North America. I don’t know how they measure these Kayaking AT FULFORD HARBOUR Sthings so I don’t know if that is true. No matter, sea kayaking is certainly growing rapidly in popularity as the Kayak Routes of the Pacific JULY/AUGUST proliferation of books on the activity attests. New editions are Northwest Coast is an ideal now in print for two of the best known titles on the subject: Sea companion to Dowd’s book, Day Time Ht./ft. Ht./m. Day Time Ht./ft. Ht./m. Kayaking—a Manual for Long-Distance Touring by John dealing with specific sea 0645 2.0 0.6 0150 7.2 2.2 Dowd, now into its fifth edition, and Kayak Routes of the Pacific kayaking routes in British 27 1545 9.8 3.0 04 0625 8.9 2.7 Columbia, Washington TU 1805 9.5 2.9 WE 1300 3.0 0.9 Northwest Coast edited by Peter McGee, now into its second MA 2310 10.8 3.3 ME 2025 10.8 3.3 edition. State, and Oregon, of various lengths and for 0735 1.0 0.3 0250 6.2 1.9 Long-Distance Touring 28 1635 10.5 3.2 05 0750 8.2 2.5 kayakers of various abilities. WE 1940 9.8 3.0 TH 1340 4.6 1.4 The adjective ‘definitive’ is overused, but every so often a book is The coast (and book) is ME 2355 10.8 3.3 JE 2050 10.8 3.3 produced for which it is the only one suitable. Dowd’s Sea divided into eighteen 0825 0.3 0.1 0340 5.2 1.6 Kayaking—a Manual for Long-Distance Touring is certainly sections, each section 29 1720 10.8 3.3 06 0930 7.9 2.4 one of these. It really is essential reading for anyone taking up TH 2100 10.2 3.1 FR 1420 5.9 1.8 having a standard format JE VE 2110 10.5 3.2 the sport as described in the title; that is, as long-distance consisting of Map (for basic touring. Dowd brings an enormous amount of knowledge to this 0055 10.8 3.3 0430 4.3 1.3 reference), Background, 30 0920 0.0 0.0 07 1130 7.9 2.4 topic, accrued from Getting There, Trip FR 1755 11.2 3.4 SA 1505 7.2 2.2 decades of kayaking in the VE 9.8 3.0 SA 2130 10.2 3.1 Summaries, Trip 2200 most varied and 3.6 1.1 Description, and so on. Each section is by a different writer, or 0200 10.8 3.3 0520 demanding environments 31 1005 0.0 0.0 08 1345 8.5 2.6 writers, with intimate knowledge of the area covered—a total of SA 1830 11.2 3.4 SU 1605 8.5 2.6 on the globe; from the 44 trips, from Haida Gwaii (the Queen Charlotte Islands) to the SA 2300 9.5 2.9 DI 2150 9.8 3.0 arctic to the tropics; from lower Columbia River. It also includes a valuable Useful 0605 3.3 1.0 0305 10.5 3.2 the extreme tip of Contacts list, an Equipment Checklist, and so on. 01 1055 0.3 0.1 09 1515 9.5 2.9 Patagonia to the SU 1905 11.2 3.4 MO 1800 9.2 2.8 The book promotes the concept of a system of ‘marine trails’, DI 2355 8.9 2.7 LU 2210 9.8 3.0 Caribbean; from Europe to with camp sites, for outdoors recreationists using exclusively Indonesia; and just about 0405 10.2 3.1 0655 3.0 0.9 manual or sail powered craft (no motor auxiliaries). 02 1140 1.0 0.3 10 1605 10.2 3.1 every place in between, Responsible, low-impact, eco-friendly travel is the objective. MO 1935 11.2 3.4 TU 2035 9.5 2.9 including, of course, our LU MA 2240 9.5 2.9 Reference is frequently made to scenic, historical, and nature own BC coast. Let’s just say 0740 2.6 0.8 amenities, as well as to the specifics of kayaking in the regions 0055 7.9 2.4 he is a widely- 0515 9.5 2.9 1645 10.5 3.2 described. It is a highly-useful—and applicable—compendium of 03 11 2155 9.5 TU 1220 2.0 0.6 WE 2.9 acknowledged expert on ‘hands-on’ route guides. MA 2000 11.2 3.4 ME 2335 9.5 2.9 sea kayaking. However, a few minor criticisms: in the complete and ADD ONE HOUR FOR DAYLIGHT SAVING TIME Dowd shares his thorough introductory section, the various aspects of knowledge on how to cope responsible recreational travel are carefully outlined. Topics Tides Tables Courtesy of with virtually anything the such as respecting wildlife and native and cultural artifacts; Island Marine Construction average sea kayaker will preserving the environment; cautions regarding local weather ever encounter, and does so with a clear and concise style in a Floats • Ramps • Moorings • Pile Driving phenomena; safe and prudent navigation in heavy marine traffic well-structured book. But the very strength of his book might areas, and so on, are more than amply dealt with. Why, then, are Ph: 250-537-9710 Fax: 537-1725 also be viewed, by some, as a weakness. Dowd is not only a these same topics again included in each trip guide? A brief and www.islandmarine.ca kayaker, he is an adventurer, an explorer, not only of the remoter simple reference to the relevant page is all that is required, such corners of the planet (how I envy him!) but of the outer limits of as: heavy marine traffic, see p.--, or, native reserve with artifacts, what is possible in these remarkable craft. The situations which see p.--, would suffice. When writers repeatedly recite the whole liberally pepper the pages, and from which examples are drawn, list of ‘thou shalt not’ the overall tone risks becoming one of are often ones of extreme survival and can be quite frightening. holier-than-thou sermonizing. And please, when referring to the Although Dowd does not deliberately present it as such, it is native peoples who used these water routes in times past, could possible to infer, from the case examples given, that sea kayaking Richard J. Wey BCLS patronizing hyperbole be omitted? Statements referring to them is essentially a demanding and hazardous activity. The reader having lived here ‘since time began’ are disrespectful in their Legal, Engineering and Topographical Surveys should bear in mind that the sport can be enjoyed on many exaggeration. levels, including simple day trips in sheltered waters, and that Subdivision Planning The above items seem more attributable to editorial policy the extreme scenarios are not inevitable. This book as stated, is than to shortcomings by the writers themselves. Likewise, there primarily for those contemplating long-distance kayak were numerous irksome grammatical and typographic errors The Lord James, #4-2227 James White Blvd. expeditions. But one might hope that in future editions Dowd Sidney, BC V8L 1Z5 which should not have crept into a second edition. Finally, the could make reference, not only to the dire perils, but to some of photos illustrating the book were muddy and indistinct, perhaps Telephone 250-656-5155 Fax: 250-656-5175 the mystery and beauty he must surely have encountered, as did through the off-white paper or inappropriate image the late Bill Mason in his equally definitive books on the art of manipulation, or both—but not really acceptable by today’s wilderness canoeing. And Dowd’s considerable writing skills reprographics standards. But a highly-useful book nonetheless, would certainly be equal to the task. What are your and I look forward to an even bigger and better third edition. Whoops! Sea Kayaking: a Manual for Long-Distance Touring by John options? The ugly job of making and proofreading tables from email Dowd, Greystone Books, paperback, 276 pages. Find out from your messages (which tend to lack their original formatting) was a Kayak Routes of the Pacific Northwest Coast edited by Peter Gulf Islands’ alternative problem last issue. Nicholas Wilde tells us that a misalignment McGee, foreword by John Dowd, Greystone Books, paperback, had us reporting that Pender youngsters voting heavily for the 336 pages. ✐ energy specialists Bloc Québecois! In fact they voted heavily for the Green Party— the 15 votes were for the Greens and the Bloc received no votes! Energy Options DEVELOPMENT from page 1 definition of bona fide seniors housing; that an amenity for nine [email protected] 250-537-8371 couples did not justify the precedent for the conversion of Rural- 364 Lower Ganges Rd., Salt Spring Island UN launches online electrical contractors • solar • wind • microhydro systems zoned land to higher density zones; that seniors’ housing should ‘environmental be planned under the current OCP review and not before; that water was not adequately proven for the development; that the amenity was not a genuine amenity; that the density transfer ANCE AESEN OOFING democracy’ clearinghouse L V R between two different zones (Commercial Accommodation to 1184 SUMMIT AVE, VICTORIA The UN Economic Commission for Europe has unveiled a website that will serve as an ‘environmental democracy’ Rural) was not allowable; that the development was against the clearinghouse designed to spotlight the issues covered by the current OCP. STANDING SEAM METAL ROOFING Aarhus Convention. Those in favour spoke of people who had had to leave the FOR WATER COLLECTION SYSTEMS ‘The Aarhus Convention focuses on citizens’ involvement in Island because this kind of housing was not available. They commented that the development provided a type of housing ALSO environmental issues and their ability to gain access to information held by public authorities,’ commented UN TORCH-ON MEMBRANE, SHAKE & SHINGLE that Pender did not currently have; that they would like to move Secretary General Kofi Annan. into it when older; that more should be done for those who had 250-381-2157 CELL 250-361-5028 The clearinghouse (aarhusclearinghouse.unece.org/) is had a big hand in creating the Island’s community structures in FAX 250-383-2198 home to information available to governments, the years that they had lived there; and that only this developer nongovernmental organizations, students, academics and the could make it happen and the opportunity would be lost forever Serving the Gulf Islands for 21 Years ✐ general public. if the bylaw was not passed. It should be noted that a number of speakers strongly against the proposal identified themselves as seniors who did not think the development was in the Island’s best interest. The Bylaw will now get turned down or it will receive 2nd and 3rd reading by the Local Trust Committee who will be Complete Rainwater Harvesting Systems meeting next on Thursday, July 29 at St Peters Parish Hall. ✐ Roof-to-Tap Design
The MountainView (1320 sq. ft.) • Polypropylene-lined COFFEE’S ON Steel Cisterns— COLD BEVERAGES TOO! MATERIAL LOCKUP COMPLETE Stop by before or after you walk the Mouat Park Trails. New $100,165 4,000-30,000 gallons $35,305 $52,210 perennials, waterplants and pond fish now in. • Roof Washers CALL TODAY FOR YOUR WE’LL QUOTE FREE PLAN BOOK. FROM ANY PLAN. • Gravity Filters
Bob Burgess 250-246-2155 gallery, nursery & www.rainwaterconnection.com CAMPGROUND. 305 Rainbow Rd • 250-537-4346 [email protected] DESIGN • SALES • INSTALLATION www.harvestcedarhomes.com VISA, MASTERCARD, AMEX ISLAND TIDES, July 29, 2004, Page 3
PORT BROWNING MARINA, CAFE & PUB
SPRING HOURS: Café: Weekdays 7am–8pm daily Early Bird Special $4.95 (7–9am) Sat & Sun 8am–8pm Pub: Open from Noon daily Liquor Store: Open from Noon–9pm daily
Live Music: July 30/31 & Aug 1–Mighty Joe Young August 6/7–Stretch 629-3493 • www.portbrowning.com • [email protected]
Island Markets are in full swing! Salt Spring vendors have created their FUEL-EFFICIENT, COST-EFFECTIVE WOOD HEATING own ‘Simply Salt Spring—island made’ label. Hiroshima Day - a reminder to take action Jan Slakov A quarter of a century; that’s how long Salt for the proliferation of ‘defence’ contractor Spring Island has been organizing events to profits and excuses to go to war. mark Hiroshima Day, August 6. This day in A document produced by the Project for the remembrance of a great tragedy is a blow to New American Century states outright that Serving the Gulf Islands and Greater humans’ self-image as upholders of peace. BMD is not truly a ‘defensive’ weapon, but is Victoria for over 25 Years That citizens continue to organize designed to enable the US government to themselves to mark this terrible anniversary continue to use might to impose its will Sales / Installations and use it to reflect on how to prevent other acts wherever and whenever those who are of inhumanity is reassuring. Indeed, even directing US foreign policy see fit. though we live in a time of unprecedented Here is a quote from that document: Ark Solar Products Ltd. threats to survival of humanity and life in ‘Effective ballistic missile defenses will be the #6 – 1950 Government Street, Victoria, BC general, we also have reason for hope. As central element in the exercise of American Phone: (250) 386-7643 Anatol Rapoport remarked, ‘the coexistence of power and the projection of US military forces the war system and the human race seems no abroad.... Even if such enemies [weak states] longer possible.’ Many people all over the world are merely able to threaten American allies seem to recognize this and seem to be willing to rather than the United States homeland itself, dedicate themselves to building trust instead of America’s ability to project power will be deeply 5",)# /4)#% fear, to prevent war, and to find nonviolent compromised.’ 0 . ways of resolving conflict. When those in power propose ideas such as Salt Spring’s event will take place on BMD in the name of ‘defence’, we must ask Monday, August 9, the anniversary of the ourselves how we could truly work to promote Nagasaki bombing, at the Peace Park in security. All we need do is look at the golden 3OUTHERN 'ULF )SLANDS Ganges. Beginning at 6pm there will be family rule , fundamental to virtually all of the world’s activities: peace poster-making, a game, and major belief systems: do unto others as you &ERRY