April 2007 Volume 18 No. 4 Fransçois Blanchet Harpsichord a novice approach to guitar making U IL D E G OF TH W IRE OO SH D P W O M R
A K
H
E
R
W
E S
N
• •
Founded 1990 www.gnhw.org The Newsletter of the Guild of New Hampshire Woodworkers
woodturning chisels you can make • zen & the art of woodworking • housed dovetails clean rails & stiles • bevel edged bench chisels • indoor air quality square peg in a round hole • hats off to the guild
photos by Jim Seroskie
Apr 7 BIG Apr 14 Small Meetings … New Date – p3 Apr 21 Guild Meeting … Nottingham, NH – p3 May 12 Period Furniture May 26 GSWT Jun 2 BIG Jun 16 Summer Trip Jul 28 GSWT Aug 4-12 NH Craftsmen’s Fair Sept 22 Annual Meeting
Harvey Best details how he restored a badly damaged antique Georgian Oak Table Restoration president’s message by Dave Anderson
Change is the Only Constant
ike most other things in life, the member to take on the job of Sunapee to view the wares Lonly constant in the Guild is change. Wood Week Coordinator. Wendy being displayed This will be your second issue ofThe Old Mullett has accepted the job and I’m and sold by the Saw that has increased in size from 32 sure that all of you will be hearing from juried members to 36 pages. Just think, only a few years her over the next few months. Wendy of the League. ago our newsletter was 8-10 pages, all brings to the job years of experience During this event, the Guild staffs a black and white and occasionally had an in coordinating trade shows for the 20 foot by 40 foot tent. The event is insert with some pictures. Things have old Digital Equipment Corp. To our chance to interact with the public, sure come a long way to today’s full describe her professional background as showcase our skills, recruit new members, color mini-magazine. serendipitous to the Guild’s need is a bit and put ourselves in the public eye. Brian Sargent has submitted of an understatement. We sell raffle tickets for prizes made his resignation as Small Meetings I was slightly taken aback a few and donated by our members. This is our Coordinator citing other demands on months ago during a discussion about most important fund raiser for the Guild his time and his belief that there is a Sunapee with one of our members. We scholarship fund. Guild representatives need for someone with a fresh approach were talking about why so few members sell the tickets, answer questions about and ideas. I would like to publicly thank volunteer and his response was a request the Guild and act as ambassadors to Brian for the five years he has served for an explanation of – “What exactly is the public. Elsewhere in the tent, there as the person who makes the October Sunapee?” For those of you who don’t are normally two to three lathes with and March meeting work. If any guild know or aren’t really sure, what follows members demonstrating both faceplate member is interested in getting involved is an explanation. and spindle turning all day – each day. with coordinating and helping to chose Each year starting on the first In other sections of the tent, carvers will the topics for our small meetings, they Saturday in August and running for be working, someone might be making should either email, call, or approach nine days, the League of NH Craftsmen a dovetailed box, a Nantucket basket me at a meeting. This is an opportunity holds its annual craft fair on the grounds might be woven or a piece of furniture to have a voice in what programs are of Mount Sunapee State Park at the ski could be taking shape. offered in the future. area. This event draws between 20,000 The variety of skills displayed over the A few weeks ago, I was gratified and 30,000 people from all over New nine days is broad and limited only by to have a response to my appeal for a England and other areas of the country Continued on Page 13
U IL D E G OF TH W IRE OO SH D P W O M R
A K
H
Steering Committee E
R
W
E S
N •
President Dave Anderson 603-887-6267 [email protected] • Vice President David Frechette 802-633-2561 [email protected] Scholarship Committee Secretary Greg Benulis 978-314-5815 [email protected] Selection Committee John McAlevey 207-372-6455 [email protected] Treasurer Peter James 603-435-8133 [email protected] Selection Committee Peter Breu 603-647-2327 [email protected] At Large Peter Breu 603-647-2327 [email protected] Selection Committee Jack Grube 603-432-4060 [email protected] At Large Jack Grube 603-432-4060 [email protected] Member Peter Bloch 603-526-6152 [email protected] At Large Jon Siegel 603-768-5882 [email protected] Member Bob Jarrett 978-456-3928 [email protected] At Large George Saridakis 978 549-1807 [email protected] — Please send all applications to John McAlevey, Selection Committee Chair At Large Bob LaCivita 603-942-1240 [email protected] At Large Andy Young 603-672-9558 [email protected] Volunteer Positions At Large Caleb Dietrich 603-556-1629 [email protected] Books Tony Immorlica 603-673-9629 [email protected] At Large John Whiteside 603-679-5443 [email protected] Membership DJ Delorie 603-463-5996 [email protected] Old Saw Editor Jim Seroskie 603-673-2123 [email protected] Old Saw Mailing Syd Lorandeau 603-542-5295 slorandeau@verizon. net Past President Roger Myers 603-773-9634 [email protected] Shirts/Hats Peter James 603-435-8133 [email protected] Programs Sal Morgani 603-772-1006 [email protected] Small Meetings Open Position Sunapee Fair Coordinator Wendy Mullett 603-332-1039 [email protected] SubGroups Sunapee Raffle Coordinator Jim Dimick 603-228-1131 [email protected] BIG Bob LaCivita 603-942-1240 [email protected] Video Librarian John Pitrone 603-894-5893 [email protected] GSWT Jon Siegel 603-768-5882 [email protected] Video Recording Peter Bloch 603-526-6152 [email protected] Period Furniture John Whiteside 603-679-5443 [email protected] Web Master DJ Delorie 603-463-5996 [email protected]
The Guild of New Hampshire Woodworkers – Bringing together the diverse interests of the New Hampshire woodworking community. “The Old Saw” is published five times per year. To join the Guild, go towww.gnhw.org and click on “Membership “ to download an application form. announcements
st April 21 , 2007 – 9:30 am From Concord Route 4 East, to route 152 East, approximately 5 April Guild Meeting miles on the left. From Exeter at Renaissance Strings workshop in Nottingham, NH Route 101 West to exit 7 onto route he next Guild meeting will instruments like violins are made? If you have, then 125 North, to be held on April 21st at you don’t want to miss this meeting. route 152 West, TRenaissance Strings, the workshop Jim Robertson has been a woodworker by trade approximately 5 of Jim Robertson in Nottingham. for over 20 years. He started his violin making studies miles on the right. The regular session will be from in 1995. Formal training began in 1999 at the Violin From Manchester 9:30 am to 12:00 pm followed by Craftsman Institute under Master Violin Maker Route 101 East to exit 5, go right one hour for lunch. Jim will then Karl Roy. Jim is the assistant to Karl at the Violin onto route 102, take a left onto give his presentation from 1:00 pm Craftsmanship Institute, and dedicates the remainder route 27. Take the next right to 3:00 pm. Please remember to of his time to making and repairing bowed instruments. onto route 156 to the end where bring your own chair and lunch. In his spare time, he holds demonstrations on violin it merges with route 152, then We will have a special short making at schools and violin camps, and fiddles with approximately 1 mile on right. demo by one of our members at the Strathspey and Reel Society of New Hampshire. From Portsmouth 9:30 am so be sure to be there on Renaissance Strings is located in Nottingham, NH Route 4 West to route 125 South, time. near Rt 4 and Rt 125. It is located at 181 Stage Road, to route 152 West, approximately Main Presentation – Have Nottingham, NH, in the big barn at the corner of 5 miles on right. you ever wondered how fine Gile Road and Rt 152 (Stage Road). – Sal Morgani
th April 14 , 2007 Guild Luthiers New Special Interest Subgroup
Small Meetings Rescheduled new subgroup of the Snow storm pushes back Goose Bay Lumber Tour–9am to 11am AGuild is being formed, to March meetings to April 14th Max number of attendees is 30. The meeting will be at Goose be announced at the April 21 Bay Lumber on Rt 4, Chichester, NH. Guild meeting, with the first ue to the Nor’easter that Carl and Liddia will be giving a tour of their facility, which will organizational meeting to be hit New Hampshire March include the small vacuum kiln, log yard and lumber facility. scheduled then. We are looking D16, the three small meetings Carl will demonstrate their saw mill – weather permitting. This at the May time frame for the scheduled for March 17 have been is a chance to learn something about what happens to a tree organizational meeting. rescheduled for April 14. after it is cut down and how it is processed. The group’s focus will be lutherie, These meetings will follow the Curved Side Grain Inlays–1pm to 3pm the making of stringed instruments. same format of past year’s small Max number of attendees is 10. The meeting will be at John There is a large community of meeting venue. Instead of one Whiteside’s home shop in Fremont, NH. luthiers in the area. NH Furniture large meeting, there will be three John Whiteside has been making furniture part time for the Master Terry Moore has agreed meetings at different locations past 20 years. He is currently taking classes for guitar making to be our mentor and honorary during the day. and has offered to share what he has learned. John will demo chairman. Details of focus and The Guild’s small meeting how to make a jig to do curved decorative inlays and the pro- organization will be worked out at format has met with much success. cess of making the inlays. Come and see John’s 24x32 shop that the May meeting. This is open to all We hope you are able to take he built himself and increase your knowledge of inlay work. – beginner, amateur, and professional advantage of seeing other shops alike. Plus, given the nature of the where the venue is focused to How to Make a Cabriole Leg–9am to 11am group, part of each meeting will be individual interests. Max number of attendees is 15. The meeting will be at the devoted to jamming! You must register as there is Homestead School in Newmarket, NH. If you are interested, contact often limited shop space in each Dan Faia is a graduate of the North Bennett St. School. Dan John Whiteside, 603-679-5443 or workshop. Just contact me at balances his time between making furniture and teaching. Dan [email protected]. When 603-483-1330 or preferably by email will show how to select the wood and then lay out and cut out you call, please have some idea at [email protected]. a cabriole leg. This is a great opportunity to learn from one of of preferred meeting dates and – Brian Sargent North Bennett Street’s top teachers! times. Write to [email protected] with your questions
Table Saw Blades – Is a performance and longer life. A cheap increasingly finer grits up to at least Q combination blade the best blade will cost time in sanding and will 1500 grit. My preference in sandpaper choice as a table saw blade or would most likely dull faster. Cheaper blades over 1000 grit is Meguire’s Uni-Grit. dedicated rip, crosscut and solid also usually have smaller teeth which Wet sanding is followed by buffing. surface blades make more sense? cannot be sharpened as many times. I usually start with a lambs wool head – Anon and 3M Finess-it and follow with a Jon Siegel replies: No one likes changing synthetic head (more heat) and polish. Brooks Tanner replies: Combination blades. Manufacturers play on this fact, A highly figured grain, however, will not blades that I am familiar with usually and advertise that their “combination” or stay completely flat. give a poor cut and are usually relegated “multi purpose” blades work well in every As the humidity cycles, you will to carpentry, not cabinet or furniture situation. Don’t believe it! Dedicated see the grain movement in a glancing work. They do have a purpose on the blades work best. Many woodworkers view. Often this movement is sufficient construction site, and I actually have tell me they have trouble ripping thick enough to be easily felt as you run your one in my Skill saw. A general-purpose stock, but they don’t own a rip blade. hand across the surface. blade, however, is a different matter all On a rip blade, every tooth is the same, I have had one particular piece together. A good general-purpose blade perfectly flat (square) on the top, and that was made to replicate the figure is the #1 blade used in my shop. But there are a small number of teeth on the and finish of a set of speakers that has additional blades should be added for blade. remained completely flat. This was specific work. The primary blades in my finished with polyester, the same as the shop are as follows: Bob LaCivita replies: I think having resin used with fiberglass. There is no dedicated rip and crosscut blades is the infiltration or loss of water content. The 1 Forest 40 tooth Woodworker II, ATB better way to go in an idle world. I have piece is also in a humidity controlled (alternate tooth bevel), thin kerf. General worked in shops that use this system environment. This is a mirror finish, but Purpose. I use this for a majority of my and the amount of time lost makes it has a plastic look and feel. solid wood cuts. Rips are clean and almost inefficient. I use Forrest combination If the question was not intended to too clean for a glue joint. Little clean up is blades and they work well. If you have be a finish question, but instead is a necessary for a finish edge. On cross cuts, time, rip and crosscut blades is great. If sanding question. Figured wood may be pores are left open and are not crushed, as not, go with a high quality combination tooled dead flat (sanded, scraped etc.) they should be. The negative is that feed blade. but is dead fat only until the humidity rates are slower than a dedicated rip. But changes. the cut is finer and time is saved in sanding. Smoothing Highly Figured 2 Royce 80 tooth Melamine, high ATB, thin Q Wood – What is the best way Sticker Stain – Can “sticker kerf. This is used for veneer covered sheet to smooth highly figured wood (e.g. Q stain” which has just happened goods. High tooth count together with very bird’s eye maple) to a mirror finish? (within 24 hours) be removed? I had pointy teeth minimize splintering and tear – John Whiteside wet walnut touch steel overnight out of the veneer and also leaves a smooth and had blue stain. Has the stain finish cut. Brooks Tanner replies: Figured wood penetrated deeply? Could it be 3 Wood Crafter 40 tooth, ATB, 0.125 kerf. Used is finished to mirror finish by using bleached out? – Peter Breu for solid wood cuts in thick stock (6/4 +). A the same methods as with non-figured. thicker blade will take and dissipate more Basically finish is added in multiple Bob LaCivita replies: Sticker stain is the heat and also will not distort as readily coats and is then wet sanded flat result of acids and minerals leaching out under high load. This blade also has a larger exposing any depressions as shiny spots. of wood sticks (stickers) placed between gullet below the tooth for removal of a Additional coats are added, followed by layers of drying wood before drying or larger amount of chips. wet sanding. This is repeated until the while drying (air dried). 4 CMT 24 tooth, FTG (flat tooth grind), thin entire surface is completely filled with You have a stain from metal. kerf. Rips are faster and noise is lower than finish and no defects can be seen. Depending on how deep it penetrated. with the Woodworker II. Cut quality is It should be noted that the finish You can sand, scrape or plane it out. If the acceptable, but not quite a nice as with a 40 thickness is still quite thin since a board is not to thickness, you can run it tooth. majority of the finish has been sanded through a planer. I would avoid bleaching off. because you might end up with a bigger Good quality blades will give better Wet sanding is now performed with problem. I would sand it with 220. lose yourself in time
minutes later is strong. But after I did the first wipe down, the color was still there and a smoothness- to-the-touch emerged that surprised me. I didn’t want to apply a second coat for fear of losing that smooth feel on the first coat. Six coats later, with wet sanding between, only enhanced the results. by Bob Oswald The last coat was applied like talcum powder to a baby. I decided to wipe it on so thin, and the Art of Woodworking so thoroughly, to rub it out even as it was still wet. ave you ever read creative, not disposed to of mind for several reasons. It had all the properties I a really good structure. I did not want to make a could have hoped for. I can book where The concept further states mistake that would ruin a only say that time passed you look up and that when you are in that loss piece of wood. Everything and I didn’t realize where it wonder where the last hour of time mode, you are using was grain matched and to went. And the project and went? The same can happen the right half. And if you can fail with one part would be the finish is the best I have in your woodworking. It call on the right half more to go all the way back to the ever done. When I look back never used to happen to me on demand, you can achieve beginning. And the finish, on this project, I find nothing but it’s starting to. It’s related more focus, more inner color balance, presentation, that I would do differently. to being too goal oriented. peace. Jumping to the end of no visible flaws were all That’s an incredible feeling. As they say in other walks, the story, I’m here to tell you, critical factors. I did have a That is woodworking! enjoy the journey, don’t worry against all opponents, that it few little problems along the The project took easily about the destination. And is absolutely true. way and was fortunate to be twice as long as was in woodworking, I believe I started to read this able to recover them. ‘necessary’. But the results that the secret is to enjoy book and the exercises they It was not a conscious are ten times better than I every step. Do each step like take you through are simple decision to be focused. It would have done in half the it is the most important one but you are guided in a way just happened. And when time. in the project. Be almost that encourages you to do I finished about two weeks And in the great balance afraid to be finished. the exercise well, not quickly. later, I knew that this is what of nature, I have subsequently On a slow day at a trade About half way through woodworking is all about. To tested my dovetail skills on a show years ago, I picked up the book a few days later, I lose yourself in a project, to four little recipe boxes. I was a book at the a local college realized that I was losing lose yourself to time, to be in a hurry to see the results, bookstore called Drawing on that sense of time while delighted with the results. and the results show it. Two the Right Side of the Brain. I doing those exercises. I am most proud of the are garbage. I’ll salvage them was learning to draw then Recently, I committed finish. Too many of us skate and store something in them. and I had heard the book to a project that stretched through that phase, hating It will remind me each time I mentioned many times. The my skills. The nature of the it. I loved every minute of it. look at them what being in a concept is that the brain has project required it to be as That first coat is true magic. hurry is worth. Two are better two functioning sections. perfect as possible and it The color first comes to life. but far from acceptable. The left half is organized, caused me to focus like I It glistens. You don’t miss Focus, enjoy, learn, methodical and time keeping. never had before. And this a spot anywhere. And the appreciate, lose yourself in The right half is abstract, project put me in that frame reluctance to wipe it off ten time. taking control of your own metallurgy Woodturning by Jon Siegel Chisels You Can Make
apparatus, or formulas which Figure 3 – Grinding a Flute. The are available to the modern round nose grinding wheel is metallurgist. Instead they were guided only by trial used to grind the flute into the and error. Yet they were able steel rod. Grind to a depth that is to make astonishing tools, swords, armor, and cutlery just a little more than half way. of every description. This is because heat treatment is can buy from any machine essentially a simple process shop supplier. I prefer this which requires only two type of steel, because it is things… consistent, easy to harden, and very low cost. • Control the amount of carbon in the iron thus making “steel”. Heat Treatment Much mystery has been • Apply heat and cold to manipulate attached to heat treatment the crystals in the iron. because it has a long and somewhat clouded history. Fortunately, the first part The discovery of how to is taken care of for us. Tool convert iron into steel and steel (which is a blended its heat treatment (Anatolia, mixture of iron and carbon, 1200 BC) is what made plus a few other additives) iron superior to bronze and is made in many varieties by ushered in the Iron Age. The steel manufacturers, and can result of this is that today be ordered from any machine 95% of all metal products are shop or industrial supply made from iron. company. “Carbon tool steel” Centuries ago, those is the direct descendant of nyone can make in your own shop. You can early smiths did not have those earliest types of steel woodturning chisels use pre-hardened high speed the advantage of micro discovered thousands of Aby following these steel (tool bit stock). This photographs, testing years ago. instructions. In doing was covered in an excellent so, you are not trying to article by Bob Rosand approximate a standard in American Woodturner, factory-made chisel. Instead Summer 2001. I do not use you are creating a “hard tip” this type of material because tool. In many ways, this is it is available only in a better than a factory chisel. limited number of sizes and The cutting edge is extremely it is expensive. Or you could hard and durable, while the use files, springs, saw blades, shank is tough and strong. etc., and this is covered by A gouge made with a short John Lucas in American flute is much more rigid than Woodturner, Spring 2001. one with the flute running But in this article, I will the whole length – Figure 1. explain how to make chisels There are many out of high carbon tool steel, approaches to making chisels such as drill rod, which you Figure 1 – A collection of carving and turning chisels made by the author. photos by Patrice Martin & Jon Siegel
Heat Treatment Made Easy wrote two excellent books with lots of hardening transformation has taken When the steel is heated to the good information on hardening and place as planned. red-hot temperature of 1450 degrees F, tempering with simple equipment. How can you test the hardness the crystal structure changes. If then They are The Making of Tools (ISBN without a $5,000 testing machine? The allowed to cool slowly, it goes back to its 0-442-29360-7) and The Modern most common method used by general original form. But if it is cooled quickly Blacksmith (ISBN 0-442-29363-1). mechanics is the file test. Simply use an (hundreds of degrees per second), that Although woodturning chisels are ordinary file on the workpiece. If the is, quenched in liquid, it will become different from sculpting chisels, these file “bites” and scratches the steel and set into a new crystalline form and thus books are a great starting point. there are some shiny filings produced become hard. This process is called However, now I purchase new (no matter how small), then the steel hardening and it works best if the steel tool steel to make my chisels. It didn’t is not hardened. If on the other hand, has around 0.9% carbon. take long before I realized that I had the file slides over the workpiece as if After the hardening, the piece may invested too much labor in the forging the file had no teeth, then the steel is be too hard and brittle to be safely and grinding of the tools, only to have hardened. Note that this action will used. It is possible to take away some them fail later because of imperfections ruin the file. It is best to keep a few (controlled) amount of the hardness in (cracks), or in the heat treatment throwaway files on hand for this test. the second part of the heat treatment process. I realized that compared to process called tempering, which is this labor, the cost of new tool steel is Shaping the Chisels softening. minimal. Grinding the bevel on some chisels, Some authors refer to the whole heat such as skews and scrapers is a simple treating process as tempering, and this Which Steel to Buy operation. The only additional thing is confusing. Hardening and tempering Steel that is near one percent you will need to make your own chisels are separate processes within the heat carbon and is specially formulated to is a very course grinding wheel. treatment. be hardened is called “tool steel”. You should not attempt to use the Before hardening, the steel can be Basic carbon tool steel comes to same grinding wheel for shaping the easily cut with a hack saw or machined, two varieties – a type to be quenched in steel as you use for routine sharpening. but after applying the heat treatment water W-1, and a type to be quenched These are distinctly different processes, described here, carbon tool steel can in oil O-1. The latter type O-1 is and require different tools. For shaping attain great hardness, which, if you somewhat more expensive, but is less steel, I recommend a 24 to 40 grit want to get technical, is in the 60s on likely to crack in the quenching process. wheel. This will allow you to shape the the Rockwell C scale. In other words, Also O-1 comes in rectangular shapes point of a rough blank in a few minutes in the fully hardened state (called as well as round, while W-1 usually with a minimum of heat build up. Martensite) it cannot be filed, sawn, comes only in rounds (referred to as or scratched by any steel tool. It is not “drill rod”). W-1 is still my favorite Making Gouges machinable, and can only be worked for making turning chisels, because Grinding the flute into a gouge is with abrasives. I make both skews and gouges from more complicated than making skews One of the most amazing things round stock, which is very inexpensive. or scrapers. It requires the use of a about this hardening process is that For example, one piece of 3/8˝ drill rod grinding wheel with a convex radius it is reversible. By simply heating the (36 inches long) cost $3.15, and is long which matches the shape of the flute. steel as before (to 1450 F), but cooling enough to make four chisels. That’s it slowly, the steel is made soft again. $0.79 per chisel! That is the opposite of hardening, and is called annealing. Fast cooling makes Sources for Tool Steel it hard, and slow cooling makes it soft. MSC Industrial Supply Co. This process can be reversed a number 800-645-7270 www.mscdirect.com of times if necessary until eventually ENCO the carbon evaporates from the surface. 800-873-3626 www.use-enco.com
Using Known When you receive your tool steel, Tool Steel vs Unknown Scrap Steel you may want to take a small piece At one time, I thought it was clever through the hardening process just for to beat the system and make tools out practice and then test it to see if the of free pieces of high-carbon steel – springs, axles, etc. I had been influenced Figure 2 – Dressing the Wheel. The diamond by Alexander Weygers, a wood dressing tool is used to form the grinding sculptor who took up blacksmithing in order to make better chisels. He wheel to a round nose.
It is easy to round the edge of a oxide grinding wheels are better than Procedure grinding wheel to any radius desired the old fashioned gray wheels. They are 1 Cut the steel to length. Use a hack with a diamond dressing tool. Many softer, and as the surface breaks away, saw. Allow for one or two inches to woodworkers do not own diamond they continuously expose sharp grains of go into the handle. Lightly chamfer dressers because they incorrectly abrasive. Therefore they grind with less the cut edge on a grinder or belt. think they are expensive. In fact, small heat build up, and since they are “friable,” diamond dressing tools (1/4 carat) cost they are easy to shape with a dresser. I 2 Drive the steel into the handle. only about $6. If you own a grinding have found that the least expensive are Nothing could be easier than fitting wheel, then you should own a diamond 7˝ diameter wheels designed for surface a round rod into a handle. If your dressing tool. The tool consists of a grinding machines. They are available in chisel is made from flat stock round steel rod (about 6˝ long) with a 1/4˝ and 1/2˝ thickness for under $10. The however (for example a 1/4˝ x 3/4˝ diamond attached to one end. only catch is that they have a hole size skew chisel), you will have to make of 11/4˝. This means that you will have to a tang on the end which fits into Source for Diamond Dressers make a bushing to reduce the hole size the handle. If you have a way to hot ENCO to fit your grinder. Of course it is best to forge, this is the best. Another way 800-873-3626 www.use-enco.com go into the machine shop and make one is with a metal cutting band saw, out of metal, but perfectly good reducers but if you don’t have one, just grind To use the diamond dressing tool, can be made out of maple. the material away with a very coarse place it on the tool rest of your grinder wheel. and work it slowly the same way you What You Need for Making Chisels would use a small scraper to turn wood 1 Tool steel – either round rods or rectangular 3 Rough grind the point. Skews, flat – Figure 2. flat stock chisels, parting chisels, beading Always use a dust mask or a collector 2 Hack saw tools, etc. are easy to grind. Grinding because there will be a lot of abrasive 3 A very coarse grinding wheel for “roughing” the flute in a gouge however, takes dust produced. Be careful that only the the shapes some time – Figure 3. When diamond touches the grinding wheel 4 Several thin grinding wheels rough grinding the chisel at this and do not to let the wheel touch any stage, you do not have to worry 5 A diamond tool for dressing grinding wheels part of the metal rod or you may grind about overheating because the heat into round profile shape for grinding flutes away the metal which is holding the treatment comes later. Follow all diamond in place – the diamond will 6 Propane Torch (or two) – MAPP is better safety procedures for grinding wheels fall off. 7 Magnet and always use a guard even if one is not shown in the photos. 8 Water Wheels for Grinding Flutes 9 Motor oil In recent years, woodworkers have 10 Chisel handle – turn your own 4 Heat the steel to 1450 degrees F. discovered that white and pink aluminum You can tell when you have reached this temperature because a magnet will no longer stick to the steel. While heating the steel, touch the magnet in quick jabs. Do not let the magnet get hot or it will be ruined.
As you heat the steel, the first thing you notice is oxidizing of the surface and several colors are seen. These are the tempering colors, and are not important for now, as we pass through this temperature range (about 500 degrees F) on the way up to 1450 degrees F.
Figure 4 –Heating to the Hardening Temperature (1450 degrees F). Notice that the magnet and the quenching liquid are within inches of the torch.
Figure 5 – Tempering Colors. The first tempering color to be seen is light straw, and this is sufficient for woodturning chisels.
To see the oxide coating, you must, before tempering, remove the black scale which formed in the hardening stage. Use an oilstone or some fine sandpaper At some point, you will see the 5 Quench in water or oil. As you until the surface is bright at least metal start to glow. The temperature take the chisel from the flame to on one side. of the first noticeable glow (blood the quench, do it instantly so there red) will vary depending on how is no time for it to cool off en route. You should stop at the first bright it is where you are working. Have the quench liquid within tempering color which is yellow In a darkened room, it will be inches of the location where you (440 degrees F). Subsequent about 1000 degrees F, but in bright are heating. As the chisel enters the colors correspond to these light, it could be 1200 or 1300 F. liquid, swish it vigorously in a temperatures – straw = 480, You should start checking with a circle. Continue the motion until brown = 510, purple = 540, blue magnet at this point. Do not let the cooling is complete – about 5 = 580. These represent greater the temperature drop as you do the seconds. Use either water or oil degrees of softening. Tempering magnet test. Keep the temperature according to the type of steel. beyond yellow or straw will reduce rising. The color gradually changes the edge holding properties of from dark red to cherry red – 6 Draw the temper. Tempering is the the chisel, but might be necessary Figure 4. When the first inch or so reheating of the chisel this time to for some chisels such as those for of the chisel is glowing evenly and a much lower temperature (300° mortising deep holes. the magnet does not stick at all, to 600° F) to remove some of the you are ready to quench the steel. hardness and brittleness. Not all 7 Finish grind. As with all carbon chisels need to be tempered. You steel tools, do not let the steel Steel above 3/8˝ diameter may be will lose some hardness in the get above the tempering color difficult to reach temperature with tempering. But chisels with very (yellow) during finish grinding an ordinary single propane torch acute edges need to be tempered to or the hardness will be lost. If – MAPP is better. Two torches prevent the edges from chipping. you let the steel get to the purple working together will handle up The right temperature is judged by or blue color, even for an instant, to 1/2˝ thick steel. Oxyacetylene, comparing the color of the oxide it is ruined, and will have to be however, is ideal for larger sizes. coating – Figure 5. rehardened. Therefore when you grind the tool, keep the point of the chisel cool by using light pressure, and cooling in water if necessary. If the chisel sizzles when it hits the water, it’s too hot!
I hope this article has helped to “demystify” heat treating and tool making for you. I have found there is nothing more satisfying than turning wood with chisels I made myself.
Figure 6 – Drilling the Handle. After the drilling, the work is placed between centers, and the tailstock center fits the drilled hole. by Geoffrey Ames a super-slick trick to make a super-strong joint Housed Dovetails This article appeared in the Dec 2006 issue of Popular Woodworking and is reprinted with permission
Geoffrey builds 18th century period furniture and teaches at the Homestead Woodworking School
he housed dovetail joint is mechanically sound, historically correct for 18th century casework and a hallmark of fine craftsmanship. It provides an accurate means of locating drawer dividers and runners, and is quite useful when making shelves. If you can mill stock straight and square, control stock thickness, make dados and operate a router, you can make this joint. When assembling case pieces or shelves, you will have little need for glue, screws or nails. Dados alone have little mechanical strength, but with the addition of a dovetail socket and dovetail tenon, the joint is properly aligned and quite strong. This joint allows cases to be made without face frames. When the housed dovetail joint is used for shelving, the shelves are prevented from cupping because the shelves are Editor’s Note held flat in the straight, shallow dados. A number of GNHW members Much of my work replicates 18th-century case pieces have published material in the such as chests and highboys. For years, I made furniture by commercial press over the years. laying out the housed dovetail joinery, carefully handsawing, It is a measure of our good then chiseling the dovetail sockets. This slow and inefficient fortune to have access to these process tested my patience enough that I began my search for accomplished and articulate a quicker, more accurate method. professionals in our midst. I like to make the housed dovetail joint with a dado roughly Generally, The Old Saw policy is 1⁄8˝ deep. The dado is used to align and strengthen drawer to avoid reprinting such articles runners or shelves. By housing the shoulders of runners or in favor of original material or shelves, the joint doesn’t invite gaps like a half-blind dovetail occasional refreshed material joint, as seen in the drawing on the next page. from other non-commercial publications. Searching for a Solution However, when this article by As I tried out different methods, I built numerous sleds and GNHW member Geoff Ames was edge guides, but my only success required the use of a sled and brought to my attention, I found two matching routers – one fitted with a 3⁄4˝ O.D. straight bit, it to be compelling and one that 3 the other with a ⁄4˝-14° dovetail bit. fit well with a series of recent My search for a simple solution led me to milling all the and future articles on joinery. I dados prior to routing the dovetail sockets. But aligning the anticipate the use of commercial dovetail bit with the dado was not possible because a standard reprints to be infrequent; 3⁄4 1⁄8 however, I would appreciate ˝ guide bushing was too deep for the ˝-deep dado, and 3⁄4 any feedback you’d care to offer. the ˝ dovetail bit interfered with or would shear the guide – Jim Seroskie bushing. Then it occurred to me that what I really needed was photo by Al Parrish a shorter guide bushing. 5IFIPVTFEEPWFUBJMJT 8JUIUIFIPVTFEKPJOU FWFO TUSPOHBOEGPSHJWJOH JGUIFUFOPOJTNJTDVU UIF HBQJTFBTZUPIJEFBOEUIF KPJOUJTTUJMMTUSPOH "IBMGCMJOEEPWFUBJMJT NVDITUSPOHFSNFDIBO JDBMMZUIBOUIFEBEP
"EBEPBMPOFPGGFST MJUUMFTUSFOHUIBOEOP 8JUIBIBMGCMJOEEPWFUBJM MPOHHSBJOUPMPOHHSBJO JGUIFUFOPOJTNJTDVU UIF HMVJOHTVSGBDF HBQJTPCWJPVTBOEUIFKPJOU JTXFBLFOFEø
Combining a dado joint with a half-blind dovetail The 3⁄4˝ outside-diameter guide bushing must be reduced to yields a superior joint for casework. The weaknesses protrude less than 1⁄8˝. This allows the base of the router to of both joints are eliminated. lay flat on the workpiece.
The first step is to mill all of the dados Use the modified guide bushing and a Use the same guide bushing and a 3⁄4˝ to a depth of 1⁄8˝ with a 3⁄4˝-diameter 3⁄8˝ straight bit to prepare the socket dovetail bit to finish the dovetailed straight router bit. for cutting the dovetail. part of the joint.
Get a standard 3⁄4˝ O.D. A Simple Formula Porter-Cable router-guide To successfully make the bushing and reduce the housed dovetail joint, there protruding guide to slightly are a few milling, tooling and less than 1⁄8˝. You can cut the setup requirements. The dado excess off with a hacksaw, must be a minimum width and then file or grind the cut of 3⁄4˝ to allow a 3⁄4˝ guide edge smooth. bushing to ride into the dado Now you can set up your to create the dovetail socket. router with the modified The dados should be slightly guide bushing and a 3⁄4˝-14° more than the depth of your dovetail bit as seen in the modified guide bushing. photo at right. The bottom The stock thickness for the edge of the dovetail bit should drawer dividers or shelves protrude a bit less than 1⁄2˝ should be the same as the As you slide the router along the edge, the guide bushing and below the guide bushing for width of your dados. dovetail bit will enter the dado together. a total depth of about 5⁄8˝. After milling all the Be sure your stock is thick dados with a 3⁄4˝-diameter When you have pre-cut sequence of the cuts you enough to prevent routing straight router bit, set up all the sockets, switch your need to make. through your workpiece. I the router with the modified router setup to the dovetail The router is slid along recommend using 13⁄16˝ or 3⁄4˝ guide bushing and a 3⁄8˝- bit. Securely clamp your the face of the case side, from 7⁄8˝ stock for case sides. The diameter straight bit. Clearing workpiece to your bench, left to right. The dovetail bit drawing at the top of this out the socket with this bit lock your router bit depth, and the guide bushing locate page shows the proportions will reduce the amount of and turn on your router. the dado and enter the dado and appearance of the material the dovetail bit will The photos above show the at the same moment. Keep finished housed dovetail. have to remove. the router base firmly down 12
on the case side and carefully guide the router into and out of the socket without lifting the tool from the work. Slide the router up to your stop line then retract. If you turn off the router while it is in the socket the dovetail bit may be pulled down and ruin your work. Cleaning out the socket with a 3⁄8˝ bit prior to routing the dovetail socket helps prevent this. You’ll likely experience some tear-out where the router exits the socket. Make your workpiece about 1⁄8˝ wider than the finished dimension to allow for edge cleanup. Any tear-out is easily removed by a few passes over the jointer. On to the Matching Tenon This clamping jig lets me quickly make the tenons without adjusting the router setup. The work Of course the dovetail socket is clamped vertically below the Masonite guide. requires a matching dovetail tenon. With an easy solution to making the female part of the joint, I looked for an equally simple method to cut the dovetailed tenons on the end of the drawer divider or shelf.
Dovetail Tenon Clamping Jig
YcEJBEPWFUBJMCJU 4MPUJOHVJEFQJFDFBEKVTUT UPTFUEPWFUBJMUFOPOXJEUI
c c Masonite
8PSLQJFDF &EHFPGHVJEFDPMMBSSVOT POFEHFPGc.BTPOJUF
1 The secret to this jig is the ⁄8˝-thick Masonite guide piece. This matches the depth of the dado. The only adjustment needed is to move the guide piece in $MBNQTUSJQ or out to establish the finished width of the dovetail tenon.
7FSUJDBMGFODF I came up with this jig that uses is precarious and shaky at best. the same 3⁄4˝ x 14° dovetail bit and An alternative is a horizontally router setup. mounted router, but my method The common method used to uses a simple and easy-to-make jig create dovetail tenons is to mount as seen above. the same dovetail bit used to rout When setting up the vertical the sockets in a router table and run dovetailing jig, make some trial c c the long narrow dividers vertically, passes on scrap the same thickness twice at each end. This method Continued on Page 13 African Padauk … by Caleb Dietrich 180 BF – All 16’ long &OR