DOCSLIB.ORG

The Church in the Public Square in a Pluralistic Society Continuing the Discussion by James K

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Church in the Public Square in a Pluralistic Society Continuing the Discussion by James K The Church in the Public Square in a Pluralistic Society Continuing the Discussion by James K. Gruetzner David Adams, Assoc. Exegetical Professor at Concordia Seminary, St. Louis, recently developed some theses on American Civil Religion. They were originally delivered in Part IV of a presentation at the Joint Faculty/Council of Presidents meeting in St. Louis on March 1, 2002. The entire paper can be accessed at the following web address: http://det.csl.edu/faculty/adams/presentations/civilevents.pdf This response is not intended to be a lengthy discussion of his entire paper, nor even of Part IV. It is intended to encourage thought and discussion of the theses presented by Prof. Adams and the presuppositions upon which they are based. Prof. Adams' theses are numbered and italicized. My expanded theses are labeled with the corresponding number followed by a letter. Thesis 1. American Civil Religion is the state religion of the United States of America. Thesis 1A: American Civil Religion is not a religion in the traditional sense of being a way to become right with God. Thesis 1B: American Civil Religion is better described as a combination of (1) A mode of behavior concerning religious matters; and (2) the recognition capable to natural man that God exists (Ps.19, Rom.1:20). Thesis 1C: American Civil Religion is therefore part of the Kingdom of the Left Hand. Thesis 1D: Miscategorizing American Civil Religion as a religion in the traditional sense inevitably will lead to false conclusions. Thesis 2. American Civil Religion is now irreducibly polytheistic. Thesis 2A. Because American Civil Religion is not a religion in the traditional sense, traditional sense words like "polytheistic" can be categorical errors and misleading. Thesis 2B. "Polytheistic" does not describe American Civil Religion, since polytheism avers that there are a plurality of gods. American Civil Religion does not do this, for it generally holds to one God, while allowing for many different beliefs about God. The motto is not "In Gods We Trust" (plural) but the specifically singular "In God We Trust." Thesis 2C. American Civil Religion is incapable of describing the character of God. Thesis 2D. A polytheistic religious expression would be allowed within American Civil Religion. Thesis 3. American Civil Religious events bridge the gap between worship and civic events. Thesis 3A. By definition, American Civil Religion events are always civil events. Thesis 3B. American Civil Religion events may or may not allow for worship in the Christian Sense Thesis 3C. When a Christian gives witness to Christ during an American Civil Religion event, Christ is presence is shown to the world. Thesis 3D. When a Christian fails to give witness to Christ during an American Civil Religion event, the Great Commission is ignored or believed to be not applicable. Thesis 3E. The commands of Jesus Christ to be a light to the world and the salt of the earth indicate His desire that Christians give witness to Christ during American Civil Religion events. Thesis 3F. "Pray without ceasing" is not negated by the presence of American Civil Religion. Thesis 4. American Civil Religious Events are themselves a spectrum of activities. Thesis 4A. American Civil Religion events encompass a large area of activities. Thesis 4B. Events within American Civil Religion do not fall along a single axis, often can not be put into any order along any single axis. Thesis 5. Both the mission of the Church and the obligation to work for the welfare of our neighbor require the Church to be engaged with the broader society. Thesis 6. The limits and form Church's engagement with the world are shaped by the mission imperative and the necessity of faithfulness to the teachings of the Word of God. Thesis 7. To the extent that a Civil Religious Event is an event involving Christians of different confessions, participation in the event must be governed by the same principles that govern our interaction with other Christian church bodies. Thesis 7A. American Civil Religion event interactions are not interactions with other other church bodies, but are participations in civic life. Thesis 7B. American Civil Religion events, properly speaking, are not religious events but civic events. They must be treated that way. Thesis 8. To the extent that a Civil Religious Event is an event involving participants from non-Christian faith groups, participation in the event must be shaped by the requirements of the First Commandment. Thesis 8A. American Civil Religion event interactions are not interactions with other non-Christian faith groups, but are participations in civic life. Thesis 8B. American Civil Religion events, properly speaking, are not religious events but civic events. The must be treated that way. Thesis 9. To the extent that a Civil Religious Event is primarily civil in nature, participation in the event must be shaped by an appreciation of the tension between the interests of the Church and the state. Thesis 9A. Since an American Civil Religion event is civil in nature, participation in the event must be shaped by an appreciation of the tension between the interests of the Church and the state. Thesis 9B. Christian participation in an American Civil Religion event can make the event a Christian event for those Christians participating. Thesis 10. Sometimes it is necessary to restrict our own freedom as Christians for the sake of others, and at other times to forgive those who err, and to do both for the sake of the unity of the Church and the mission of the Gospel. Thesis 10A. When the organizers of an American Civil Religion event attempt to restrict the Christian witness of Christian participants, it is no longer properly considered an American Civil Religion event, but an event of an established church. Thesis 10B. Christian Citizens of the United States have a civic duty to work to maintain American Civil Religion a part of the Kingdom of the Left Hand and not an established church. Thesis 10C. The scriptures do not tell Christians specifically how to relate to American Civil Religion. Different Christians will react in different ways based upon their different situations. In all cases, Christians should presume that other Christians are acting faithfully. Copyright, 2002, James K. Gruetzner This document may be freely distributed via electronic or printed means, provided it is distributed exactly as written, and this copyright notice is preserved intact. David Adams retains the copyright to citations from his paper, which are included here under the fair use provisions of U.S. copyright laws.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Christ and Culture in America: Civil Religion and the American Catholic Church
    Christ and Culture in America: Civil Religion and the American Catholic Church Author: Philip Sutherland Persistent link: http://hdl.handle.net/2345/bc-ir:107479 This work is posted on eScholarship@BC, Boston College University Libraries. Boston College Electronic Thesis or Dissertation, 2017 Copyright is held by the author, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise noted. Christ and Culture in America: Civil Religion and the American Catholic Church Submitted in partial fulfillment for the degree of Licentiate in Sacred Theology by Philip Sutherland, S.J. 4/24/17 Readers: Dr. Mark Massa, S.J. Dr. Dominic Doyle Introduction Civil religion is a necessary unifying force in a religiously plural society such as the United States, but it can also usurp the place of Christianity in the believer’s life. This is always a danger for Christianity which is can only be the “good news” if it is inculturated by drawing upon a society’s own symbols. But it must also transcend the culture if it is to speak a prophetic word to it. Ever since Bellah’s article about civil religion in America, there has been disagreement about the theological value of civil religion. Reinhold Niebuhr, James McEvoy and Will Herberg have argued that civil religion will inevitably replace transcendent religion in people’s lives. Bellah, John F. Wilson and others argue instead that civil religion is necessary to develop the social bonds that hold modern secular societies together. Civil religion produces patriotism, a devotion and attachment to one’s country, which is an important source of civic and communal identity.
    [Show full text]
  • Building the Nation: the Success and Crisis of Korean Civil Religion
    religions Article Building the Nation: The Success and Crisis of Korean Civil Religion Andrew Eungi Kim 1 and Daniel Connolly 2,* 1 Division of International Studies, Korea University, Anam-ro, Seongbuk-gu, Seoul 02841, Korea; [email protected] 2 Division of International Studies, Hankuk University of Foreign Studies, Seoul 02450, Korea * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: Civil religion refers to a country’s beliefs, symbols, and rituals that bolster national unity and strengthen its citizens’ sense of identity and belonging. However, the literature on civil religion is divided between those who attribute it to bottom-up cultural spontaneity and those who see it as an ideological top-down construction. Moreover, there has been a relative lack of scholarly attention to Korean civil religion. This paper addresses both issues by arguing that a strong civil religion indeed exists in the country and that it has been an important part of the “nation-building” process since the founding of the Republic of Korea in 1948. The paper highlights how a succession of authoritarian regimes (1948–1987) successfully mobilized a strong civil religion for political purposes. The resulting civil religion targeted economic growth as the national goal to overcome all social ills, focused on the country’s ethnic and cultural homogeneity to boost national confidence and pride, exalted its traditional religions, especially Confucianism, as repositories of Korean traditional culture, and rendered sacred meanings to national symbols such as the flag and national anthem. Even after democratization, Korean civil religion remains largely ideological, as the Korean government is heavily involved in framing, planning, sponsoring, and promoting the country’s civil religion.
    [Show full text]
  • HOW to UNDERSTAND AMERICAN CIVIL RELIGION William Doverspike, Ph.D
    HOW TO UNDERSTAND AMERICAN CIVIL RELIGION William Doverspike, Ph.D. Drdoverspike.com 770-913-0506 Religion, derived from the Latin religionem American Civil Religion (nom. religio), can be defined as “a personal set or institutionalized system of religious attitudes, The term American Civil Religion was coined beliefs, and practices” (Merriam-Webster, n.d.). by Professor of Sociology at the University of The word religio may originally derive from California, Berkeley, Robert Bellah (1927- ligare (bind, connect), probably from a prefixed 2013), who was internationally known for his re-ligare (i.e. re [again] + ligare [to work related to the sociology of religion. His reconnect]). Literally, religion refers to the ties 1967 article entitled “Civil Religion in that bind. America,” which was published in the Journal of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, Religious practices include a variety of rituals, sparked controversial debates in the field of sermons, sacrifices, feasts, initiations, prayers, American sociology in the late 1960s and early music, and other aspects of a culture or society. 1970s. The topic of civil religion (which has All religions have sacred histories and also been called civic religion) became a major narratives, which are preserved in sacred focus in articles and at religious sociology scriptures and holy places that give a meaning conferences. The debate reached its peak with to life. the American Bicentennial celebration in 1976. The concept of civil religion was first Civil religion is distinct from traditional introduced by the French philosopher Jean- indigenous or tribal religions, although Jacques Rousseau (1895), who used the term in traditional religious officials and ceremonies Chapter 8, Book 4 of The Social Contract.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    Introduction Sungmoon Kim and Philip J. Ivanhoe Like many before and since, 1967 was an eventful year and especially so in America. There were half a million American troops fighting in Vietnam, the civil rights movement was calling on and inspiring all Americans to live up to their high ideals, feminist thinkers and activists were overturning the persistence of patriarchy, the counterculture movement was in full swing, and Robert Bellah first published “Civil Religion in America.” However one views the excesses and shortcomings of this year and the decade in which it occurred, there is no denying that 1967 marked a period when a new and revealing sense of national self-consciousness began to dawn across the land. Americans were forced to step back from the ongoing activities of individual and national life and the larger events occurring around the world and reflect upon who they were and the direction in which they and their country were heading. This reflection was often painful, at times traumatic, and resulted in a very different trajectory for the nation and its people. Bellah’s essay was not only a part of this process, a cause of these developments, but it also captured what was going on in the hearts and minds of the American people at this critical juncture in their history. He argued that apart from the various institutionalized religions of America, there was a “religious dimension”1 to American culture, what he called “American civil religion.”2 This civil religion lacks the formal institutional structure of more familiar religions; it has no headquarters, mailing address, hierarchy, or designated leader, and yet it can be found throughout the culture and commands a special kind of reverence.
    [Show full text]
  • The Damned Neighbors Problem: Rousseau's Civil Religion Revisited
    religions Article The Damned Neighbors Problem: Rousseau’s Civil Religion Revisited Micah Watson Department of Political Science, Calvin University, 3201 Burton SE, Grand Rapids, MI 49546, USA; [email protected] Received: 15 April 2019; Accepted: 25 May 2019; Published: 29 May 2019 Abstract: Near the conclusion of The Social Contract, Jean-Jacques Rousseau starkly proclaims that no state has been founded without a religious basis, and thus if he is right, every political community must grapple with the tension between the conflicting claims of the divine and the mundane. Because Christianity cannot solve this tension, Rousseau calls for a new religion, a civil religion. Whereas most of the academic treatment of civil religion follows various paths beginning with Robert Bellah’s original 1967 article, this essay explores more deeply the contours of Rousseau’s original articulation of the problem to which civil religion is his proposed solution. The essay concludes by suggesting that we can find important elements of Rousseau’s approach still alive and well in American politics and culture today. Keywords: civil religion; Jean-Jacques Rousseau; tolerance; social cohesion; Christianity; religion and politics 1. Introduction The academic treatment of civil religion as a cultural and religious phenomenon began with Robert Bellah’s 1967 Daedalus article, “Civil Religion in America” and continued in earnest for some time as sociologists, political scientists, historians, theologians, and religious studies scholars joined the discussion, some attempting
    [Show full text]
  • Civil Religion and Cultural Competency
    Here, There, and (Almost) Everywhere: Civil Religion and Cultural Competency Vivian-Lee Nyitray University of California Education Abroad Program Abstract: When preparing students for study abroad, understanding the religious dimension of the target country/culture is generally viewed as essential for cultural competency training. What is generally left unexamined is the civil religious culture that might be operative. This essay first provides an introduction to the concept as it was introduced by sociologist Robert Bellah and developed in the American context, followed by brief examples from Europe and Japan. "…wee must Consider that wee shall be as a Citty upon a Hill, the eies of all people are uppon us….” -John Winthrop, in a sermon entitled "A Modell of Christian Charity," delivered in 1630 aboard the Arbella en route to the Massachusetts Bay Colony (quoted in Bellah 1992, 15) "I've spoken of the shining city all my political life, but I don't know if I ever quite communicated what I saw when I said it. But in my mind it was a tall, proud city built on rocks stronger than oceans, wind swept, God-blessed, and teeming with people of all kinds living in harmony and peace ... ." - Ronald Reagan, Farewell Address to the Nation, January 11, 1989 Introduction As a member of the Religious Studies faculty at the University of California, Riverside, I was asked regularly to teach Religious Myths and Rituals, a lower-division course that enrolled several hundred students. As an Asianist, I felt ill-qualified to teach a course that served not only as an introduction to the study of religion but also as an examination of religious belief and practice in selected racial/ethnic minority populations in the US.
    [Show full text]
  • [Review] / Albanese, Catherine L
    BOOK REVIEWS Albanese, Catherine L. Sons of the Fathers: The Civil Religion of the American Revolution. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1976. 274 pp. $1 5.00. Ever since Robert N. Bellah began publishing his sociological essays on civil religion the subject has caught the attention of scholars in many disciplines. The recent bicentennial has turned this interest to the American Revolution. One of a number of writers looking at the religious aspects of this era, Catherine L. Albanese, Associate Professor of Religion at Wright State University, uses a history -of-religions methodology to study the origins of the American civil religion. Assuming that the perceived religion of a people is a smaller component of the "real" religion, Albanese argues that the Revolution was in itself a religious experience that provided the fundamental basis for the American civil religion. The patriots lived out an inner myth that symbolized this religious experience. Regarding themselves as analogous with both ancient Israel and their Puritan fathers, they saw the present as in peril of decline. Moving forward to arrest this decline, they more and more made America a transcendent object of religion and came to supplant their ancestral fathers as its creators. This religious experience revealed itself in a number of ways. Rituals developed that dramatized the myth of newness. In the process of creating such symbolic forms as the liberty tree the patriots discovered that they were their own men, the makers of history. Although at the beginning of the war they talked much about the Lord of Battles intervening on their behalf, by the conflict's end the patriots were placing more emphasis upon their own involvement with liberty and their own virtues as the basis of their freedom.
    [Show full text]
  • Essay AMERICAN CIVIL RELIGION
    Essay AMERICAN CIVIL RELIGION: AN IDEA WHOSE TIME HAS GONE ?? Frederick Mark Gedicks Symposium, “Civil Religion in the United States and Europe: Four Comparative Perspectives” International Center for Law and Religion Studies J. Reuben Clark Law School Brigham Young University Provo, Utah March 12-14, 2009 I. INTRODUCTION: THE OXYMORON OF AMERICAN CIVIL RELIGION The idea of civil religion is closely associated with Rousseau, whose Social Contract argued that “a State has never been founded without religion serving as its base,” and then went on to consider the kind of religion that properly grounds the civil order.2 American sociologist 1 Visiting Professor of Law, Notre Dame Law School; Guy Anderson Chair & Professor of Law, J. Reuben Clark Law School, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah; [email protected]. 2 JEAN-JACQUES ROUSSEAU, ON THE SOCIAL CONTRACT bk. IV, ch. 8, at 99 (Hackett, Donald A. Cress trans. & ed. 1983). This was also the view in Britain and the American colonies at the time that Rousseau wrote. See Frederick Mark Gedicks & Roger Hendrix, Uncivil Religion: “Judeo-Christianity” and the Ten Commandments, ** W. VA. L. REV. ***, 279 & nn.17-20 (2007). -1- Robert Bellah adapted Rousseau to an insightful and provocative argument about civil religion in the United States. The American civil religion, declared Bellah, is a set of general religious beliefs shared by most Americans and consistent with the particular theologies of most “American” religions. It includes beliefs in the existence of God, in his special inspiration
    [Show full text]
  • The Gospel in Singapore - the Impact of Civil Religion and Civil Law
    Concordia Seminary - Saint Louis Scholarly Resources from Concordia Seminary Doctor of Philosophy Dissertation Concordia Seminary Scholarship 4-1-2015 The Gospel in Singapore - The Impact of Civil Religion and Civil Law Mark Madson Concordia Seminary, St. Louis, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.csl.edu/phd Part of the Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion Commons Recommended Citation Madson, Mark, "The Gospel in Singapore - The Impact of Civil Religion and Civil Law" (2015). Doctor of Philosophy Dissertation. 71. https://scholar.csl.edu/phd/71 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Concordia Seminary Scholarship at Scholarly Resources from Concordia Seminary. It has been accepted for inclusion in Doctor of Philosophy Dissertation by an authorized administrator of Scholarly Resources from Concordia Seminary. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE GOSPEL IN SINGAPORE THE IMPACT OF CIVIL RELIGION AND CIVIL LAW A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of Concordia Seminary, St. Louis, Department of Systematic Theology in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Mark J Madson April 2015 Approved by Dr. Thomas Manteufel Advisor Dr. Robert Kolb Reader Dr. Victor Raj Reader © 2015 by Mark James Madson. All rights reserved. This dissertation is dedicated to my wife Elizabeth. I do not despise the grace of God, for if righteousness is through the law, then Christ died in vain. Galatians 2:21 CONTENTS ILLUSTRATIONS
    [Show full text]
  • Religion in a Revolutionary Society
    RELIGION IN A REVOLUTIONARY SOCIETY AMERICAN ENTERPRISE INSTITUTE'S DISTINGUISHED LECTURE SERIES � ll Peter L. Berger America's leading sociologist of religion, is professor of sociology in the graduate school of Rutgers University. PETERL. BERGER RELIGION IN A REVOLUTIONARY SOCIETY Distinguished Lecture Series on the Bicentennial This lecture is one in a series sponsored by the American Enterprise Institute in celebration of the Bicentennial of the United States. The views expressed are those of the lecturers and do not necessarily reflect the views of the staff,officers or trustees of AEI. All of the lectures in this series will be collected later in a single volume. revolution · continuity · promise RELIGION IN A REVOLUTIONARY SOCIETY Delivered at Christ Church, Alexandria, Virginia on February 4, 1974 American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research Washington, D. C. © 1974 by American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, Washington, D.C. ISBN 0-8447-1306-6 Library of Congress Catalog Card Number L.C. 74-79895 Printed in the United States of America he title of this address, as it was given to me, implies a formidable assignment-no less than the overall consideration of the place of religion in contemporary America. I have some reservations about applying the adjective "revolutionary" to American society. But, minimally, it refers to something very real in that society-namely, its quality of rapid and far-reaching change-and for this reason I describe our present society, not just that of 1776, as revolutionary. This quality of change makes my assignment all the more difficult. It is a source of constant embarrassment to all commen­ tators and forecasters.
    [Show full text]
  • American Civil Religion: the History and Evolution of a Sociological
    Loyola University Chicago Loyola eCommons Dissertations Theses and Dissertations 1979 American Civil Religion: The iH story and Evolution of a Sociological Concept Gail Gehrig Loyola University Chicago Recommended Citation Gehrig, Gail, "American Civil Religion: The iH story and Evolution of a Sociological Concept" (1979). Dissertations. Paper 1867. http://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss/1867 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at Loyola eCommons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Loyola eCommons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License. Copyright © 1979 Gail Gehrig AHERICAN CIVIL RELIGION: THE HISTORY AND EVOLUTION OF A SOCIOLOGICAL CONCEPT by Gail Gehrig A Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Loyola University of Chicago in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy December 1979 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Appreciative acknowledgments are made to the following individuals for their assistance and advice concerning this study: Dr. Robert J. McNamara, Rev. Thomas M. Gannon, S.J., and Dr. Ross P. Scherer. ii VITA The author, Gail Gehrig, is the daughter of Dick Simms Gehrig and Letittia Mason Gehrig. She was born on October 25, 1946, in Kansas City, Missouri. Her elementary education was obtained in the public schools of Lexington, Missouri. Her secondary education was obtained at Lee's Summit High School, Lee's Summit, Missouri, where she graduated in 1964. In September, 1964, she entered the University of Mis­ souri, and in August, 1968, received the degree of Bachelor of Arts with a major in sociology.
    [Show full text]
  • The Relevance of the Concept of Civil Religion from a (West) German Perspective
    religions Article The Relevance of the Concept of Civil Religion from a (West) German Perspective Jana Weiss * and Heike Bungert * Department of History, University of Münster, Domplatz 20-22, 48143 Münster, Germany * Correspondence: [email protected] (J.W.); [email protected] (H.B.) Received: 13 April 2019; Accepted: 30 May 2019; Published: 3 June 2019 Abstract: The paper argues for the continued importance and usefulness of the term “civil religion” in light of the (West) German discussion and the situation in Europe. For non-Americans, and especially for Germans for whom terms like “political religion” are tied to the National Socialist past, the concept of civil religion helps explain the relationship of religion and politics, both in modern democracies in general and in Germany and the United States in particular. Keywords: civil religion; political religion; political theology; USA; Germany; Europe; transnational; Holocaust; migration 1. Introduction “Obama as Pontifex maximus” ran the headline of a German newspaper in 2013 explaining to its readers that the U.S.-American inauguration was the “high mass” of the nation’s civil religion (Main 2013). Time and again, Germans and Europeans marvel at what they consider to be the bizarre mix of religion and politics on the other side of the Atlantic. They have trouble understanding how the U.S. experience is interpreted in a religious frame. Over the last decade, some German journalists have started using the term “civil religion” to help their readers understand U.S. political rituals (Schwartz 2009; Liebert 2017). By (re)introducing the concept of civil religion and applying it to U.S.-American society in the late 1960s, Robert N.
    [Show full text]