JustJust OneOne Fishing. BiteBite Landing. andand You’reYou’re Two totally Hooked.Hooked. different things. PETE MAINA Pro anglers will tell you, "Hooking Gander Mountain... up to a monster fish is only half the battle. Now you’ve got to land that offering the right gear to make that dream of a trophy!" That’s not the Pow’R Lok¨ muskie become time to wrestle with yoke system an obsession. your landing net! Our automatic handle/yoke DOUG JOHNSON revolutionary Pow’R Lok® alignment yoke system found on our
improved Power Catch®
and Pro Formance® landing nets provide instant engagement of “Lucky” Libby Hoene the handle and hoop Gander Mountain assembly without DICK PEARSON Pro Staff Member searching for a spring button or having to align the handle. What’s more, our Power Catch nets are so well built that they come with a lifetime warranty on the hoop and yoke! No other net can say that. The pros rely on Frabill CHAD CAIN nets, shouldn’t you?
Hours: Monday-Saturday, 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM Sunday, 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM
Innovating the outdoors FOR THE LOCATION OF THE STORE NEAREST YOU CALL: 1-800-282-5993 OR www.frabill.com • 800.558.1005 LOG ON TO WWW.GANDERMOUNTAIN.COM P.O. Box 49 • Jackson, WI 53037 MUSKIE is published monthly and is the Official Publication of Muskies, Inc. International Office: Terrie You CAN have your fish and release it, too! DuBé, International Sec., 80 State Hwy. 200, Longville, MN 56655. Ph: 888-710-8286, Fax 218-836-2087. Contents © Copyright 2005 by Muskies, Inc. All rights reserved. FITTANTE TAXIDERMY REPLICAS MUSKIE ¥ VOL. 39, NO. 7 Serving discriminating sportsmen for over 32 years Fittante Taxidermy is proud to lead the way in unsurpassed fish reproductions. We make our molds in-house and offer dozens of different sizes and positions. References are available upon request and phone orders are welcome. Serving quality minded sportsmen across the nation is our specialty. Departments Features 2 President’s Message 5 The Dunkard Creek Pig, Chris Burnette 10 How I Spent My Summer Vacation, 3 As I See It - Editor’s Desk Brad Waldera 4 Magazine Notes 16 Three Generations, 5 Letters to the Editor Dr. Eugene, Dr. Tom & ALD Dan Narsete 24 Muskie Mythology, Bob Chokola 6 International News 26 Getting New Members Involved, 7 Youth•Fisheries•Research Wayne Humphrey 13 Lunge Log 28 Showcasing Our MI Supporters- Musky Hunter Magazine, Patricia Strutz 23 Photo Contest - July Winners 29 Chapters Up Close: Twin Cities Chapter, Mike Kanaval 33 Chapter News and Views 38 Figure 8 Nets a 51” at Stonewall Jackson, 42 Member Photos Chuck Skopelja 40 Muskie Misfortunes, Weston Hunt
Life Membership: ❑ 0-29 years $600.00 ❑ 30-44 years $550.00 ❑ 45-49 years $500.00 ❑ 50-55 years $450.00 Join Muskies, Inc. ... ❑ 56-60 years $400.00 ❑ 61-65 years $350.00 ❑ 66-up $300.00. ❑ $100.00 additional to include spouse or or give a membership junior member (up to the age of 18) if purchased at same time. Junior Member (to 18): ❑ $15.00 as a gift. Regular Membersip: ❑ 1 Year-$30.00 ❑ 2 Years-$55.00 ❑ 3 Years- $80.00 “The #1 reason I choose Joe Fittante is his artistry. He Family Membership: ❑ 1 Year-$42.50 ❑ 2 Years-$80.00 ❑ 3 Years-$117.50 ❑ For Muskie Research $______is the only taxidermist I have found who can accurately reproduce the true colors and markings of a living Name ______Phone ______Name of Spouse______His painting technique separates him Address______Chapter Affiliation Choice Number ______musky. (to find the number of the Chapter you wish to join, see the Chapter News & Views section) from the rest. That is why I use him exclusively, and City & State______Zip______Junior Member(s) Date of Birth (DOB) prefer his work above all others.” Chapter Affiliation Choice Number ______Name ______DOB ______(to find the number of the Chapter you wish to join, see the Chapter News & Views section) – Joe Bucher, Old Address (for address change only) ______Name ______DOB ______Hall of Fame Angler Capture the moment City & State ______Zip______Name ______DOB ______www.fittantereplicas.com • email: [email protected] My Membership # ______Expiration Date ______Chapter Affiliation Choice Number ______Check One: ❑ New Member ❑ Renewal ❑ Address Change ❑ Gift MAIL TO MUSKIES, INC. 80 State Hwy. 200, Longville, MN, 56655 Email ______3 miles north of Antigo on Hwy. 45 • N4598 Hwy. 45, Antigo, WI 54409 ❑ VISA ❑ Discover 1-888-710-8286 Payment: ❑ Check or ❑ Credit Card: ❑ AmEx ❑ MasterCard (715) 627-7662 • 1-800-261-2327 Card # ______- ______- ______- ______Exp. Date ____ /____ Signature ______www.muskiesinc.org July 2005.....MUSKIE 1 International The President’s Message As I See It MUSKIE Magazine Staff by Greg Wells, Muskies, Inc. International President by Jim Smith Rod Ramsell, Editor Emeritus Officers Keith Ogden, Editor Emeritus Email: [email protected] MANAGING EDITOR President, Greg Wells ood Grief Gertrude, by the time this issue hits Jim Smith Phone: 920-457-3720 your mailboxes it’ll be time for the Chapter 15045 W. Double Tree Way Email: [email protected] ow that the Muskie season is in full swing across the country, I’d like to challenge our membership to stand head and shoulders above the crowd. Whether you’re a Challunge. Here I am writing this and the Surprise, AZ 85374-8568 Vice President/Finances, Jim Beaty G Phone/Fax: (623) 388-3225 season just opened yesterday in Wisconsin. There are golfer or not, you have seen the commercial for a program called “The First Tee” Cell: (623) 810-9103 Phone: 618-235-3646 N some stories to be told already. I am sure all of you have Email: [email protected] golf’s youth program. In the commercial they talk about how golf builds character in the Email: [email protected] youth who participate in the program. I believe that is what Muskies, Inc. is to the Muskie heard about the Green Bay Megamuskie. It was caught Vice President/Research, Ron Mazur ASSISTANT EDITOR World – the character builder. and released before the season opened by some walleye Juris Ozols Phone: 708-458-0055 fishermen. Look for a brief story with the photos in this Email: [email protected] How does Muskies, Inc. fill this role? Don Hunt sent me a leadership style called Phone: (952) 431-4727 Gladiator Leadership, and in a nut shell it is ‘lead from the front by example’. As with the issue. What a beautiful animal! Now, there is a dream come true. This is what we’re all Email: [email protected] Vice President/Internal Affairs, Dick McPike about, dreaming that someday it may be you or me and enjoying the fact that they (world ADVERTISING MANAGER “MUSKIE” Phone: 816-436-4909 “First Tee” it’s about honesty, it’s about playing by the rules, it’s about humility and that’s character. The same goes for fishing. It’s about following the fishing rules and regulations record class fish) still do exist in our muskie waters. MHM will have a full story in their Cherek Group ¥ Scott Cherek Email: [email protected] 3902 Cribbon Avenue ¥ Cheyenne, WY 82001 wherever we fish, it’s about abiding by the boating laws and that means being safe, it’s about Aug/Sept issue. Pick up a copy and read what I am sure will be a thrilling story. Vice President/Membership, Bob Timme Talking about some excitement, there appears to be some with our brothers and sisters Phone: 307-635-8899 catch and release and good conservation practices and even down to the honesty about our Phone: 715-462-3053 on the eastern part of the country. In particular, our Three Rivers chapter. I sincerely hope Email: [email protected] on-the-water experiences. I believe that we already practice these traits. Maybe we just are Email: [email protected] all of us can come to a reasonable resolution. I believe that an Eastern Muskie Alliance PUBLICATIONS TECHNICAL MANAGER not marketing it as well as golf does. “Muskies, Inc. promotes honesty, playing by the rules, Sunray Printing Solutions, Inc. ¥ Ross Rieke Vice President/Communications, David Cates would be very good for muskies. I am just not convinced yet that those proposing it have 25123 22nd Ave. S. ¥ St. Cloud, MN 56301-9189 Phone: 574-457-3222 humility, camaraderie, and conservation. Muskies, Inc. Builds Character!” the best solution. I have talked with some folks out there and I just wish we could all sit Phone: 888-253-8808 x122 Email: [email protected] at a table together. Before I retired, I spent 35 years as a real estate broker. I always felt Email: [email protected] Treasurer, Pete Barber Motions that if I had a buyer on one side of the table and a seller on the other side, I had a “deal”. MAGAZINE DESIGN Phone: 847-726-7267 It is the collective opinion of the International Board that the following procedure for It was just a matter of getting to the closing. I know I am not speaking out of turn when Sunray Printing Solutions, Inc. - John Windschitl Email: [email protected] submitting motions be implemented and followed: I say your Board of Directors stands ready to listen. ILLUSTRATORS/CARTOONISTS Members Only Fishing Contest, Jim Bunch Motions must be submitted using the motion format that is available on the MI I have asked Patricia Strutz, one of my Field Editors and a new At-Large-Director, to Richard Gross Phone: 715-723-8343 ¥ Fax: 715-723-8354 web site. It is preferred that the motion be typed for ease of duplication and do some Public Relations work for us. She will be looking for material for press releases FIELD EDITORS Email: [email protected] legibility. It is in the best interest of MI and its members that the motions be and packages of our chapters “Hallmark” projects. We would love to be submitting your Colby Simms, Patricia Strutz Web Master, Ron Groeschl submitted 45 days prior to the board meeting. Motions will be sent to the best projects for consideration in various contests and recognition within the sportfishing CONTRIBUTING EDITORS Phone: 262-271-1002 president who will upon receiving the motion sign and date the motion before industry. We have been preaching to the choir too long. We are going to try to aggressively Brad Waldera, Dr. Eugene/Dr. Tom/Dan Narsete, Email: [email protected] disbursement. The president will issue copies to the web site, the chapter “tell our story”. Let me know your thoughts and send us your very best stuff, as in Bob Chokola, Wayne Humphrey, Patricia Strutz, Mike Kanaval, Chuck Skopelja, Chris Burnette Int. Administrative Secretary, Terrie DuBé presidents, the RVPs, the executive committee, the Magazine, the ALDs and any activities, projects, assistance to your local DNR, etc. 80 State Hwy. 200, Longville, MN 56655 committee affected, and also the finance committee if there is a perceived I hope you will enjoy this month’s issue. We have tried to pack a lot into fewer pages Phone: 888-710-8286 ¥ Fax: 218-836-2087 MUSKIE is published exclusively for the but you should also look for more articles on our web site www.muskiesinc.org. Go there, membership of Muskies, Inc. and subscriptions Email: [email protected] financial impact. The affected committee, and possibly the finance committee, will then submit impact reports with any suggested revisions that will go through staying on the “public side” and hit Magazine at the top of the page, then on the left side come with a paid membership. Muskies, Inc. is the distribution process again, this time including the author. This is not a change of the page hit member submittals. From there you are on your own. Ron Groeschl has a non-profit organization. Membership classes At Large Directors Term Expires done an outstanding job putting this section together. I am toying with an idea to publish and associated annual dues are listed on the to the by-laws. The ability to amend and introduce motions at the board meeting an on-line Ezine on our website. Ezine stands for electronic magazine and is published on form at the bottom of page one. Single copies Dick McPike ...... 2006 will remain in affect, though introduction of motions at the meeting is heavily a website. Let me know if you think this would have any possibilities. of MUSKIE magazine are available at $3.00 Dan Narsete ...... 2006 discouraged. each from the Muskies, Inc. International Well, I hope you all had a great opener and I hope you all can make the Chapter Office. I will need to have all motions by August 31st to be able to publish them in the Art Anderson ...... 2006 Challunge. Contributors grant rights for M.I. to publish magazine. We are asking everyone to cooperate with this motion procedure. It will allow I’ll be seeing a number of you at the Edward Crossman/Muskies, Inc. Symposium. It once in MUSKIE Magazine, both the print and Jack Moga ...... 2006 ❖ for a better member forum and member input. would be a good idea to get your reservations in now. Space may be limited with the on-line versions, including archives and on the Ron Mazur ...... 2006 entourage of fisheries types who will be coming. ❖ M.I. Web site. Ken Karbon ...... 2007 MISSION STATEMENT Jim Smith, Managing Editor, MUSKIE Magazine The Official Publication of Muskies, Inc. Submissions to Jim Shannon ...... 2007 “Muskies, Inc. is an active, service-oriented, non-profit organization with the single focus of improving the sport of muskie fishing for men, women, and Email: [email protected] MUSKIE Magazine Bob Timme ...... 2007 children. Persons interested in submitting articles for Jim Beaty ...... 2007 Our mission is to unite all muskie fishing interests for the promotion and publication are directed to our website www.muskiesinc.org. There they will find a Bob Osborne ...... 2007 protection of a high quality muskellunge sport fishery in the United States and Coming Next Month: link to MUSKIE Magazine. From there you Canada. will find links on the left side of the page Laura Morrison ...... 2008 We will accomplish this by supporting conservation practices and research Our Commemorative Lure Issue providing information necessary for Don Jahnke ...... 2008 based on sound scientific merit, and carried out by authorized federal or state submissions to MUSKIE Magazine. Further questions will be answered by Jim Smith, David Cates ...... 2008 agencies, appropriate academic institutions, Muskies, Inc chapters, and their ✒ The Jake Satonica Story Managing Editor. Submissions may be sent members. to: 15045 W. Double Tree Way ¥ Surprise, AZ Patricia Strutz ...... 2008 ✒ We are committed to the abatement of water pollution; maintenance of More great "Ask the Biologist" questions 85374-8568. Phone: (623) 388-3225 or you Karl Scherer ...... 2008 records for muskie habits, growth, and range; and the dissemination of muskie ✒ Spotlight on your chapter may information to everyone.” ✒ Show Casing Our M.I. Supporters. Email: [email protected]. Adopted, April 2002 2 MUSKIE.....July 2005 www.muskiesinc.org July 2005.....MUSKIE 3 LETTERS TO THE EDITOR THE TO LETTERS fish but an offspring from the generations past and present. It ABOUT THE COVER doesn't get any better than that!” LETTERS TO THE The Dunkard Creek Pig The cover shows a true monster of a Muskie “Pete runs a shipping department at his by Chris Burnette caught last November by Peter Lahosky of place of employment, so I suggested that we Editors Note: Trust me, this is not a vertical hold. It is the angle Bethlehem, PA. His fishing partner Joe duplicate the same cursor position on the EDITOR (elevation) of the photographer to the subject. Look at what it would Satkowski took the photo and has this tale: look like from a front position. The fish is being held at a proper angle scale using weights to be reweighed on a Jim, “We were trolling the St. Lawrence river certified digital scale. We did so, and with and supported well. system aboard the "Fish Doctor", a the weight of the cradle subtracted, the fish Things are still hectic. We are having a n Friday, April 8, I had about an hour and a half to kill so substantial die-off of large muskellunge in the upper charter boat owned and operated by our came to 50 lb. 2.0 oz. This resolved any I thought I would go back and try to see her again. Since I St. Lawrence River at the moment. It seems to go hand-in-hand with saw her two weeks before, we had gotten an inch of rain friend Captain Ernie Lantiegne of doubt - the boat’s scale was right on the a similar problem in a couple of other species, one native freshwater O Mexico, NY. Our focus was strong as money! and the creek raised a couple of feet; finally just now coming back drum and the other exotic gobies. All the time I have for down to normal. I wasn’t sure the big fish would be in the same hole. darkness approached on the second day of muskellunge at the moment I’m spending on this, and it is a MAGAZINE NOTES MAGAZINE “Thinking back on the whole experience, I I was wrong! On about the fifth cast, she slammed the Magnum the trip. Most of the fish taken recently can only wonder if this was a once in a substantial issue. Bulldog as soon as it hit the water and the fight was on. had come at dusk or later. Pete started to I thought I might put together this short note on it for the I was fishing a hole about fifty feet wide and six feet deep. It lifetime event. But you can bet we'll be magazine, how by working together with various agencies and adjust a long line rig when the fish back to try and duplicate it again!” took me about 15 minutes to land her; at times thinking she had me slammed the Believer Plug. A lengthy Muskies Canada we’re making the best of a fairly bad situation. You wrapped on a tree or log since I just could not move her she was so battle and a two man lift of the net told Comment – a grand fish and story. But it’s may hear about this on some chat lines. I know there are pictures of heavy. At 48 inches in length, this is by far the largest fish I have dead fish on some of these, however, I do not frequent them so us this was more than your average fish. also an excellent, indeed unique photograph. caught casting as far as weight goes. I did not get a girth cannot be specific as to where they are or what they’re saying. measurement but this fish looked like it had just swallowed three
And it measured 55 1/2 inches long with Go see the “Tips and Comments” section in EDITORS THE TO LETTERS ❖ For now, footballs. I really believe the fish is forty pounds since she was full a 27 inch girth, and thick all the way to my Photo Contest column on page 23. John Casselman of eggs. the tail.” Juris Ozols Editors Note: Dr. Casselman and his researchers are heavily involved I was fishing by myself so I tied her off and flagged down a in this situation on the Upper St. Lawrence. More information will passing car. Luckily, this nice gentleman walked down to witness the “I had the cradle and scale out, ready and waiting, so in she release and took some photos as I let her go. The picture shows why went. I strained to lift the rig as Pete and Ernie watched the be forthcoming. If any of our eastern folks would like to contribute an CORRECTION: article or updates I would appreciate it. Please contact me. I call her the Pig from Dunkard Creek. Chatillion scale. Pete shouted out "It's past the 50 pound mark!" This is the biggest fish that I have ever seen in Dunkard Creek. We noted the cursor's position and then moved quickly to the The “October’s Turning Leaf Challenge” article on A few more inches and this fish could be the next state record. This photos. I kept snapping photos, as Pete and Ernie eased the big Page 30 of the June issue was authored by Hi Jim, catch has given me a whole new outlook on creek fishing. For years, MAGAZINE NOTES MAGAZINE I’ve been telling people the muskies from this creek were just average girl back into the water for a very strong release.” Between the Lakes member Jerrad Kalmerton, not First of all I want to tell you that my entire family enjoys the size. I never felt this water was big enough to have a forty-pound Muskie magazine! The articles and pictures make every page a must “As she swam off into the darkness, we all looked at one another. Ellen Wells as was published. fish. I have been going to Canada for years fishing Georgian Bay read!! Which brings me to the reason for writing: It was as if something just happened that was beyond words, looking for those big forty and fifty pound fish. To catch one this We apologize for the error and any inconvience it In your last release, June 2005 it is very dedicated to kids fishing size in a creek not much bigger than a ditch and so close to home something spiritual: A fifty plus pound Muskie on the St. may have caused. and had great information in it, especially the importance of wearing Lawrence, the place where it all began. Not a stocked hatchery just goes to show you never know. life vests and making sure they are a proper fit. Thank you! Chris Burnette, West Virginia Chapter 09 Muskies, Inc. But, on the very next page- page 17-( and in many pictures of kids and fish) 10 year old "Dawson" is shown driving the boat and A WORD ON NOT wearing a life vest! My 4 year old pointed this out to my ONTARIO, CANADA ‘SILVER MUSKIES’ husband and me. We had a hard time explaining this and I felt it Minnesota used to raise "Silver necessary to point this out to you. I know I don't have to lecture you Muskie Fishing in Muskies" (actually pike) as muskies or on how many people drown due to not wearing life jackets, it was used them when the appropriate just hard to see a great article ruined by the picture with no life vest. beautiful Nestor Falls EDITOR THE TO LETTERS muskie gender wasn't available for the I actually have never written a letter to the editor, but felt too hatchery in Nevis, making of course, strongly about this one. I hope I didn't offend you, keep up the great PO Box 250-P work and we will continue enjoying your magazine!! MAGAZINE NOTES MAGAZINE hybrids! Nestor Falls Silver Pike are spotty in location. My p.s. I have yet to boat one myself!! Ontario, CA POX1KO first introduction to them was in 1967 - Fish on ! - when my dad caught this "weird Joni Wohl, Chaska, MN www.allenscrowlakelodge. muskie" from Eagle Lake, Ontario of 42 com inches...a likely World Record Sillver Jim: Pike at the time. There are some waters Email: While the smiling face of Dawson Barringer was neat to see on in Ontario and elsewhere where they the June 2005 cover, it is, unfortunately, not a muskie that he is [email protected] are fairly common, but Eagle isn't one of holding! It is a very large Silver Pike, a mutation of the northern pike them. (see side bar at left). Silver Pike are not uncommon in NW Iowa; in 1-888-CROW LAKE The Hall of Fame maintains a World fact, a research paper says that 5% of the population of pike in West 1-807-484-2628 Record class for "PIKE, Blue-Silver" (they Okoboji are Silvers. Being farily familar with Silver Pike, the photo have the scientific name incorrect in the jumped right off the page at me when I got it out of the mail box 2005 record book). The all-tackle this afternoon. Look close at the fins and you can see that they are You may come as a stranger… record is 20-8. The heaviest "pole and "rounded" like pike, not sharp like muskies. line" record is 12-12 from Spirit Lake, Muskie regards,
MAGAZINE NOTES MAGAZINE Iowa!... ❖ But you will leave as a friend! Larry Ramsell
4 MUSKIE.....July 2005 www.muskiesinc.org July 2005.....MUSKIE 5 INTERNATIONAL NEWS INTERNATIONAL NEWS INTERNATIONAL NEWS 17 waters. On Sunday April many ofourmuskie muskies swimmingin are stillworld-class Megamuskie Green Bay Walleye Fisherman Releases difference!” enable ustostockalotmore fishthisyear. support. Their generous donationwill membersfortheir thank allofthePMTT that muchmoneysoeasily. Iwantto many years andI’ve never beenabletoraise I’veeffort. been chairingourrafflesfor ofourstocking donated $779insupport “dust” settled,themembersofPMTT we soldtickets. participants, When the raising moneytostockmuskiesin White Bear Lakethis fall. would, soItoldthemaboutthe Twin Cities ChapterRafflethatis tournament anglersdocare aboutour resource! They saidthatthey would liketosettherecord straightand show theMuskie worldthat rap” tournamentanglershave beengiven. Ithenaskedthemifthey to theMuskie resource?” The response wasanoverwhelming yes! of thereputation thattournamentanglersdidnotgive anythingback the group todiscussthisissue.Iaskedthegroup “If theywere tired and educationefforts. members ofvarious Muskies Inc. ourrearing chapters,andsupport didn’t care abouttheMuskie resource. Many ofthem,infact,are know manytournamentanglersandIhave never metanyone who myself.for mesinceIamatournamentparticipant Ihave gottento Muskiesentiment amongafew fishermen. This hasbeenconfusing TwinSupport Cities Rearing Efforts TournamentPMTT Participants MUSKIE 6 Avid rod and Power Pro 8#line. is further impressiveis further isthatRyan was castingwitha7 sidearoundweighed 63lbs. 77.15 lbs.Andontheconservative What released thehugefishbacktoBay. measurements Ryan andhisfriendsJoe SchmidtandEric Haataja Ryan landedamonstermuskie.Quickly takingphotosand a 20-30minutestruggle Dempsey’s Rapala.After when somethingateRyan somewhere inGreen Bay fishermen were casting th Yes Mrs.Jones there By Jim Smith Twin Cities Chapter01 John Newman “Tournament Anglersmakinga Over thenext30minutes,withhelpofseveral otherPMTT Most expressed oftheparticipants theirconcernaboutthe“bad So, inApril, attheCave Run PMTT Tournament, Iaddressed In years I’ve thepastfew noticedagrowing anti-tournament The fishmeasured 55”x33-1/2”.High side,thisfishcouldhave three walleye .....July 2005 Rapala, trollingforwalleyes. Megamuskie. caughton8#lineanda Ryan Dempseywithhis55x33.5GreenBay 1 / 2 ’ St. Croix oSna rnig If itgetstoSunray priortothe15 to Sunray Printing. Thenitissent process timeistwoto4weeks, basedontheworkload. Thenormal It is sentto Terri DuBe andprocessed asitalwayswas. systemofrenewals works Thenew thisway. earliest opportunity. in mindthatIdohave alifeoutsideofMIthiswillbedoneatthe Keeping to hear, butitwillbearightanswer tothebestofmyability. It mightnotbetheanswer you want solution oranswer, Ipromise! I WILL however, getbacktoyou assoonpossiblewitha rod. up andseemeinpersonwe willdiscussitintheboatover afishing $ are saved onthenext twonotices,by us andyou, winwin. Right off, your nextcopyofMuskie &mailed to You, themember She then processes itandissenttoSunray Printing. It isthenputin If itislaterthenthe15 printing ofMusky. (their cutoffdateforthemagazine)yourcards new willbeinthenext [email protected] 462-3053 ore-mailmeat You can reach meat12677NNeumaier Rd.Hayward, WI 54843,Ph. 715 Believe methey do. They have enoughtodo,sotheytellme. directly tome,not Terri DuBe, Jim Smith, Greg Wells orJim Beaty. questions andproblems dealingwithmembershipsshouldcome From now onall tomakeitwork. committee andIare goingtotry Anywayhere ishow the How doIgetmyselfintothesethings? vice presidentthe new oftheMembership andMarketing Committee. Membership CommitteeUpdate ouradmiration. certainly as Ihave optedtorespect theirpublicationandletyou read itthere. August/September issueMUSKYHUNTERMagazine. Pick upacopy talking aboutit. reproduction displayed inthenearfuture. Iamsure hewouldenjoy reproduction madeby Fittante Taxidermy andwillhave this is Eric enjoyment. whosentmethesephotosforyour viewing 414-546-4627. You’ll enjoy someofhisotherfishing talentstoo. It from Southern WI. Checkouthisweb siteatwww fish wascaughtoutofEric Capitan Haataja, aguideandCharter of trophy huntersconverging onLakeMichigan. Manitoba, Canada.Good move. We don’t needtowatchastampede the pictures “Photo Shopped” withabackground from somewhere in Oh itwascaughtinGreen Bay, butRyan wasastuteenoughtohave respectfurther theextenthehasgonetokeepthislocationasecret. anyone whocanrelease suchafishandbeabletotellhisstory. I timeweis whatallofusare headout.Iadmire lookingforevery M Simple right,again,notlikely. can allgofishinginpeace. Thenwe patience andforyou members. togosignup10,000new Now allIneedfrom you, themembershipisalittle Iamhere towork foryou and I intendto. But we willtry. right, probably not. Sounds simple happen thenjumponmeandIwillyell atthem. If thisdoesnot us (theinternational)andyou (themembership). processing elsewe by save everyone moneythatcanbebetterusedby By renewing withyour firstnoticeandproper ontime expected. other words shouldgoas jumponthefirstnoticeandeverything In feel thewaitistoolongthenyell atme,that’s whatI’m here for. If thathappensand you notice you willprobably dosomewaiting. magazines, 60and30dayspriortotheexpirationdate.After third expiration dateandyour secondandthird noticeswillalsobeinthe to you inthemagazinefourmonths(120days)priortoyour However your firstrenewal noticewillbesent month togetyou. embership R Send memberformandmoneyto renewal ornew Terri DuBe. First, letmeintroduce myself. My nameisBob Timme andIam Congratulations gentlemen,you have ourutmostrespect and Here willbeappearinginthe isanothertip. Acompletestory Ryan isemployed atRocky Outdoor Gear. He ishavinga I willhowever give you avalid tip. The gentlemenwho’s boatthe As you canimaginealotofcontroversy surrounds thisfish. This BobTimme, VP Membership &Marketing Committee ene wal P r ocess; th it willtakeanother Love aMuskie, th .wibig of themonth fish.com or come and David’s foramore article completeanswer. After reading Elmer andMichael’s answers pleasegotoChris elsewhere inthisissue. written amore completeresponse tothisquestioninanarticle one. Curtis Wagner andDavid Wahl from Illinois have question toanswer inabriefmanororcolumnsuchasthis Editors Note: Biologist the Ask www.muskiesinc.org reservoirs). environments (man-made lakes and manage theminartificial Ohio, we usestocksfrom thelocaltributariesofOhio River but have beenaltered over timealready, foronereason oranother. In genetic stocksdeveloped in.Many ofthestocksthemselves may man thattheynolongerresemble the naturalenvironments these identified. Unfortunately, manyhabitatshave beensoaltered by possible andavoid mixingthesegeneticstockswhentheycanbe agencies needtousethisinformationtheirbenefitwhenever tributaries toalargerwaterbody, likeLakeErie. Management population. Sometimes thesestockscanbeasclosetwoadjacent better intheirnaturalhabitatthanageneticstockfrom another genetic terms,let’s andgrow justsaythesestocksshouldsurvive of timethrough naturalselection. Without goingintoalotof subspecies cancontainmanydifferent stocksofmuskie. recognized astheOhio, Mississippi andGreat Lakes. These different distributional differences, are thethree subspeciescommonly groupings, basedmore onmorphologicalandgeographical separate populationsofmuskie.Are you stillwithme? The general would now becalledageneticstockbasedondifferences in the basicconcepts.Iwouldguess,whatyou are callingastrain Y Elmer W. Heyob, Jr - Ohio DNR Ohio - Jr W.Heyob, Elmer Please Emailyourquestions to: our muskiecountry. opinions fromavariety of biologiststhroughout order toobtainadiversity ofanswersand different biologiststoanswer yourquestionsin Eachmonthwewill drawupon (state) biologist. attempt toobtainaresponsefromyourlocal question isastatespecificquestion,wewill their questionstoourpanelofbiologists.Ifyour NOTE: M.I.membersareencouragedtosubmit Fisheries Biologist 2 Elmer Heyob Jr. A geneticstockdevelops inaspecifichabitatover alongperiod First, letmesay, Iamnotageneticistbutbelieve Iunderstand o u [email protected] This month’s questionisanextremely difficult t h • Fisheries stocks, andtheimpacts,ifany, ofpaststocktransfers. allow formuchgreater understandingofthe relationships among and applicationofhigh-resolution micro satelliteDNAmarkers will within therangeofspeciesIn years, thedevelopment thenext few there are numerous distinctstockswithineachmajorwatershed similar enoughtopermitthetransferamongnative stocks.Likely, mistake toconsiderallpopulationswithintheMississippi tobe Valley, pike).It northern allopatric/sympatric(wrt wouldbea to fishfrom largerregions, e.g..,Great Lakes,Mississippi, Ohio term “strain” hasnootherbiologicalmeaning–itiswrongly applied Lake andSt. Lawrence strainrefer onlytotheparental source. The geographic sources. Thus, thetermChautauqua, Shoepack, Leech products derived from aparticular – usuallythisdescribeshatchery behavior are well documented. differences ingrowth, temperature perferenda andspawning adapted tolocalconditions–amongpopulations,heritable is now theMississippi Valley. Afterthesepopulationsdispersed,they thelastglacialadvance somewhere inwhat population thatsurvived muskypopulationsare derived fromcontemporary asingle of favor withscientistswhostudyfishes. sub-species ofmuskellunge.Indeed thetermhasgenerallyfallenout been thatofasingle“monotypic” species. There are norecognized has The prevailing amongichthyologists inthepastcentury view spotted, clearorbarred individualscould occurinanybodyofwater. recognized by their colouration.Subsequently, that itwasobserved thought toinhabitdistinctlydifferent regions andcouldbe m ohiensis species. ( ohioensis proposed three species(Eso resulted inavariety (1854) ofdescriptive schemes.Kirtland traitsofthemuskellunge variation intheappearanceandlifehistory the pikefamily. He can [email protected]. ofmuskellunge,andothermembers of evolution, managementandecology Michael isapplyingDNAmarkers toquestions associatedwiththe Unitand Conservation ofNatural oftheOntario Ministry Resources. University. He works outoftheDNAlaboratory oftheAquatic Biodiversity Michael Butler isadevoted muskieanglerandaPh.D. candidateat Trent Michael Butler - Ph.D. Candidate,Trent University Candidate,Trent Ph.D. - Butler Michael when stockingaspecificlakeorfishery? Why aregeneticstrainsanimportantconsideration species? Ifnotwhatisthedistinction? Define “strain”.Isastrainthesameassub Q: Fisheries managers indifferent jurisdictionsmayrefer tostrains revealed andfurther Recent thisview that DNAstudiessupport As foragreat manywidelydistributed fishspecies,geographic River area. River drainage,andthe“barred”fromOhio Wisconsin, the“spotted”fromMississippi there werethree;the“clear”fromnorthern Discuss muskellungestrains.We usedtofeel ). Jordan andEverman (1896-1900)demotedthese tosub- Esox masquinongy masquinongy Esox masquinongy ). These presumed branchesofthe • R e x masquinongy s e , July 2005..... E. m.immaculatus a , E immaculatus Esox r family tree were c MUSKIE 7 h and and
E. E
.
YOUTH-fisheries-research YOUTH-fisheries-research YOUTH-fisheries-research YOUTH-fisheries-research YOUTH-fisheries-research YOUTH-fisheries-research III) What is a population? analysis, to compare the genetic relatedness among multiple Desjardins, M.D.G. 1996. Molecular genetic variation in muskellunge (Esox Continuing with the idea of geographically and genetically populations from throughout the muskellunge range. Currently, masquinongy) and northern pike (Esox lucius) from watersheds in the Ask the Biologist – Cont’d studies are also being conducted by Canadian researchers, exploring Upper Midwest. M. Sc. Thesis, University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois. isolated stocks, the concept of a population can be developed. YOUTH-fisheries-research Processes that result in stocks can also cause locally isolated or genetic relatedness among muskellunge (and other esocidae) Hanson, D. A., R. F. Strand, D. D. Post, W. H. LeGrande, and S. Fillbach. Curtis P. Wagner and David H. Wahl partially-isolated group of individuals within the stock of a species. populations (Butler, personal communication). 1983. Muskellunge electrophoresis study. Pages 9-13 in MUSKIE. These locally isolated groups of individuals within the stock are Throughout the 1990’s, research was conducted within the Koppelman, J.B. and D.P. Philipp. 1986. Genetic applications in I) What is a species? termed populations. Upper Mississippi River drainage exploring growth and survival muskellunge management. Pages 111-121 in G.E. Hall, editor. Few things in nature are as simple as black and white. Grey areas Now that an understanding of the genetic hierarchy has been differences among populations within the stock (Younk and Strand Managing Muskies. American Fisheries Society, Special Publication 15, Bethesda, Maryland, USA. abound and this is where the really interesting nuances of the natural established, we see that a species can be made up of multiple 1992; Margenau and Hanson 1996; 1997). Around the same time, world occur. Pick up a standard biology textbook and you will find geographically isolated or partially-isolated stocks and, in turn, stocks researchers in Illinois were evaluating differences in metabolism and Margenau, T.L. and D.A. Hanson. 1997. Performance of Leech Lake, species defined many ways such as “a particular kind of organism, its are made up of multiple locally isolated or partially-isolated growth, as well as food consumption and conversion efficiency among Minnesota, muskellunge in a Wisconsin Lake. Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources Research Report 175 175: 1-11. members possessing similar anatomical characteristics and having the populations of individuals. population and stocks of young-of-year muskellunge in a laboratory ability to interbreed” or “a group of related individuals that are setting (Clapp and Wahl 1996). Multiple populations from each stock Margenau, T.L. and D.A. Hanson. 1996. Survival and growth of stocked actually or potentially capable of interbreeding; a group of organisms IV) How many stocks of muskellunge are there, were included in the study. Currently, studies are underway in Illinois muskellunge: effects of genetic and environmental factors. Wisconsin constituting a single gene pool.” A good definition of a species might evaluating growth and survival among populations and stocks in field Department of Natural Resources Research Report 172 172: 1-11. be “consisting of naturally occurring groups of individuals that can and how do they differ? settings (e.g. experimental ponds and reservoirs), as well as a radio- Nelson, J.S. 1999. Editorial and introduction: the species concept in fish interbreed and that have a common evolutionary history.” However, As the suggested delineation of muskellunge stocks are presented, telemetry study investigating potential physiological and behavioral biology. Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 9: 277-280. nature can be thought of as existing on a continuum of genetic it is important to realize and remember the genetic variation and differences among stocks (Wagner and Wahl, unpublished). Wagner, C.P. and D.H. Wahl. Illinois Natural History Survey, University of complexity and organization. Current genetic techniques allow for continuum discussed earlier. Any ‘line-drawing’ among groups of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois. [email protected] the measure of actual ‘genetic distance’ between any two organisms or organisms can be arbitrary and/or guided by the research questions at VI) Are the results of the studies accepted by Younk, J.A. and R.F. Strand. 1992. Performance evaluation of four YOUTH-fisheries-research YOUTH-fisheries-research group of organisms. We know, and can now describe using an actual hand. That being said, there is currently an accepted delineation of muskellunge Esox masquinongy strains in two Minnesota lakes. muskellunge stocks within the scientific community. fisheries biologists, or are there significant Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Section of Fisheries