WP No.60638/12

IN THE HIGH COURT OF

CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD

DATED THIS THE 7 DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2012

BEFORE

THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE AJIT J.GUNJAL

WRIT PETITION NO.60638 OF 2012 (GM-KSR)

BETWEEN:

I. MALLAPRABHA VIDYAVARDHAKA SANGH (R) PARISHWAD TALUK DIST: BY ITS SECRETARY CHANDRAGOUDA MALLANAGOUDA PATIL AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS R 0 DEVALATIII TALUK: KIIANAPUR DIST: BELGAUM

2. MALLAPRABIIA VIDYVARDHAKA SANGII (R) PARISHWAD TALUK: KHANAPUR 01ST: BELGAUM BY ITS CHAIRMAN SHRI, ASHOK GURUSIDDAPPA ANGADI AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS R 0 PARISH WAD TALUK: KIIANAPUR DIST: BELGAUM, PETITIONERS

(BY SRI.SANJAY S K()TAGERI, ADV.)

APPROPRIATE

WRIT

227

4.

(BY

3.

AND:

2.

1.

TALUK:

AT

BY

MALLAPRABHA

DIST: (R) AGED AT:

DIST:

SAMBARAGI THE

SHRI. THE

R/O DIST:

BY THE

MALLAPRABHA AND

(R) BELGAUM

HAVLOCK

BELGAUM. CAMP

SOCIETY,

HAVLOCK

SMT.K.VIDYAVATHI

OF

THIS

PARISH

PARISHWAD

ITS

PARISHWAD

ITS

IN

PARISHWAD,

HIREMUNAVALLI

THE

REGISTRAR

ENGQUIRY

REGISTRAR

DEPUTY

BELGAUM

BELGAUM.

BELGAUM

CHANDRASHEKAR

ABOUT

BELGAUM.

THE

SECRETARY.

CHAIRMAN

KHANAPUR

PETITION

CONSTITUTION

BELGAUM

WAD,

ROAD,

ROAD

NATURE

WRIT

REGISTRAR

68

VIDYVARDHAKA

VIDYVARDHAKA

GROUP

GROUP

OFFICER

TALUK:

YEARS

OF

TALUIC:

OF

CAMP

IS

OR

SOCIETIES

AGA

SOCIETIES

FILED

OF

KHANAPUR

KHANAPUR.

B$SAVANNEPPA

FOR

ORDRE

OF

OF

:2:

CERTIORARI

UNDER

CO-OPERATIVE

INDIA

Ri

OFFICE

SANGH

SANGH

&

OR

R2)

PRAYING

ARTICLES

OR

DIRECTION,

RESPONDENTS

WP

ANY

No.60638/12

TO

226

ISSUE

OTHER

AND

BY A

lie

inasmuch

hearing,

Advocate

2.

and a

HEARING,

ISSUED QUASHING

NO.DRL/

P.

memo

in

4.

a

3.

The

2.

THIS

Memo

narrow

BY

Smt.Vidvavathi

Even

SONO/

with

seeking

is

learned

THIS

as

RESPONDENT

directed

THE

PETITION

the

is

though

consent,

compass.

DAY.

MA,V.VA.SAM/

granted

subject

dispensation

counsel

ENDORSEMENT

THE

to

the

COMING

take

at

K.

it

COURT

matter

ORDER

NO.

appearing

matter

his

is

learned

notice

1

10/VICHARANCE/

taken

risk.

HEREIN

of

MADE

of

ON

notice

is

Additional

the

DATED

for

up

listed

for

THE

FOR

AS

writ

respondents

the

for

to

PER

WP

for

FOLLOWING:

petition respondents

05.12.2011

petitioner

final

PRELIMINARY

Government

No.60638/12

preliminary

ANNEXURE

1

1-12.

disposal

would

1

files

and

IN 3

contested

initiated

members

Section

approval

Act. Village

accepting and

1960.

The

also

8.

7.

6.

4.

5.

have

Suffice

25

The

Suffice

Both

It

said

in

of

the

the

by-laws

was

is

the

of

respect

registered

petitioner

society

proceedings.

change

the

the

the

by

it

said

it

to

to

were

rival case

Karnataka

certain

of

Sangha.

say

was

report.

say

the

a

and

amended

groups

that

of

registered

that

Sangha

conduct

the

:4:

persons

other

an

certain

Societies

petitioners

entered

inquiry

under

and

members

on

of

who

changes

14.8.1969.

the

were

was

the

Registration

appearance

WP

were

Sangha

that

repealed

of

sought

approved

No.60638/12

took

Parishwad

the

not

under

to

place

4

said

Act,

and

BPT

the

be by

parties

only their

parties petitioner

contention is

dispute

the

society.

required petitioner genuine

respondent

30.07.2011

required

petitioner

a

rights

9.

11.

10.

one

to

to

Prima

society.

between

Ultimately

to

I

approach

Prima

is

line

that

approach

have

to

be

of

has

No.1

indicating

that

as

be

resolved

facie,

order

the

the

well

facie

not

heard

settled

The

and

two

respondent

the

the

learned

I

rejecting

as

applied

dispute

the

am

said

it

the

in

factions

Civil

the

the

that

in

inquiry

appears

a

also

Civil

report

respondent

a

Civil

learned

State.

:5:

Court.

Civil

his

counsel

the

the

of

inter

No.1

Court

Court.

in

the

officer

mind

was

that

report

Court.

petitioner-society

counsel

respect

se

view

before

sent

for

appearing

there

No.1

inasmuch

between

files

and

Nevertheless

that

WP

adjudication

for

appearing

directing of

informed

directing

is

a

No.60638/12

the

approval

the

report

a

them

for

as

dispute

serious

same

is

it

the the

the

the

the

for

on

of

is

to

is St. a

to

order

the

No.1

to

an

Having

accept

why

order

view

inasmuch

(iv)

(iii)

(ii)

(i)

is

12.

perused

passed:

the

that

it

or

Indeed,

the

The

respondents

Rule notify

consideration respondent Annexure-P The

Needless

Petition

is

report

reject

the

required

extent

as

the

is

matter

impugned

matter

whenever

the

he

the

is

issued

of

communication

to

indicated

allowed.’

is

the

to

inquiry

is

say

3

requires

required

petitioner

be

in

quashed.

and

Inquiry

and

stands

No.1

respondent

a

accordance

a

4.

reasoned

communication

report.

above.

statutory

made

remittance

to

officer

at

apply

as

remitted

for

Hence,

Annexure-P.

absolute

order

No,

with

xvell authority

is

WP

his

1

to

not

fresh

shall

the

indicating

law.

No.60638/12

mind

respondent

as

to

to

at

accepted.

following

I

passes

either

am

as of

Advocate

ssI file

memo

Smt.K.Vidyavathi,

appearing

of

appearance

for

respondents

within

learned

:7:

four

Additional

weeks.

1

&

2

WP

is

JUDGE

permitted

No.60638/12

Government

Sd/ to -a