o qzrql6T sTl*o,rr RIGHT TO H INFORMATIOT{

ITANAGAR

BEFORE THE COURT OF DR.JORAM BEGI, STATE CHIEF INFORMATION COMMISSIONER

No.APlC-177 /2019 Dated, ltanagar the 21't April' 2O2O

Under Section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005

Appellant Respondent

Shri NyamiYorpin, Shri Dagyom Ango, Village Karle, PIO-cum-Executive Engineer, P/O Monigong, Electrical Division , P/S Vs District Lower Siang, District Shi-Yomi, Arunachal , .

Dated of hearin gz 2L't APril' 2O2O,

ORDER

Whereas, an appeal under Section 19(3) of RTI Act, 2005 has been received from Shri Nyami Yorpin, Vice President, All Arunachal Pradesh Anti-Corruption Association (AAPACA), Village Karle, P/O Monigong, P/S Mechuka, District Shi-Yomi, Arunachal Pradesh, for non-furnishing of information, by the P|O-cum-Executive Engineer, Electrical Division Aalo, District West Siang, Arunachal Pradesh, as sought, by the appellant under section 6(1) of RTI Act, 2005 on 09107 /2019.

Whereas, the 1't hearing was held on 2L" January, 2020.ShriDagyomAngo,PlO- cum-Executive Engineer, Electrical Division Aalo, was present during the hearing. The Appellant Shri Nyami Yorpin was found absent. The PIO informed the Commission that he has newly joined to the present post and was not aware of the RTI application submitted by the Appellant through the speed post. However, after receiving summon notice from the Commission on 5tn January'2020 he has furnished all the information to the Appellant on L0tn January'2020. He also assured the Commission to fix the responsibility on the official for not putting up the RTI application in time.

Whereas, the Commission to ascertain satisfaction of the Appellant fix next date of hearing.

Whereas, the 2no hearing was held on 18th February' 2020. Shri Dagyom Ango,plO- cum-Executive Engineer, Electrical Division Aalo, and the Appellant Shri Nyami yorpin were present during the hearing. The Appellant informed the Commission that he had been to office to collect information but was informed that some information were yet to be arranged. So, he had asked the staff to bring all the information during the hearing. The Plo had brought the information in the court. Contd..p..2 -2-

Whereas, the Commission cautioned the PIO for misleading the court. During the first hearing the PIO had informed that all the information have already been furnished to the Appellant. However, thaf,-ommission asked the Appellant to receive the information and convey his satisfaction or dissatisfaction in the next hearing.

Whereas, the 3rd hearing was held on 17th March' 2020. Shri Dagyom Ango, PIO-cu m-Executive Engineer, Electrical Division Aalo, was present during the hearing. The Appellant Shri Nyami Yorpin was found absent. The PIO informed the Commission that the Appellant had conveyed that he is satisfied with the information furnished to him but the Appellant is not satisfied with the work executed in the ground.

Whereas, the Commission giving an reasonable opportunity to the appellant and to hear from the Appellant fix the next date of hearing'

Whereas, the 4th hearing was held through Vido / Audio Conferencing on 21" April' 2020. Shri Dagyom Ango,PlO-cum-Executive Engineer, Electrical Division Aalo, and the Appellant Shri Nyami Yorpin attended through audio conference as due to network problem video conference could not take place. The Appellant informed the commission that all the information have been furnished by the Plo and he is satisfied with the information furnished by the PlO.

Therefore, the case is hereby disposed of. sd/- (Dr.Joram Begi) State Chief Information Commissioner Arunachal Pradesh Information Commission 2020 Memo No.APJC't77lz0tg Dated, ltanagar the APril' Copy to: Aalo, 1. Shri Dagyom Ango, PIO-cum-Executive Engineer, Electrical Division District Lower Siang, Arunachal Pradesh, 2. Shri Nyami Yorpin, Vice President, All Arunachal Pradesh Anti-corruption District Association (AAPACA), Village Karle, P/O Monigong, P/S Mechuka' Shi-Yomi, Arunachal Pradesh, 3. The Computer Programmer, APIC, to upload in website' 4. Case file.

Aru nacha I Pra m m issio n