MOTION NO. M2016-54 Amend Four Agreements with BNSF Railway Company to Adjust Insurance Provisions

MEETING: DATE: TYPE OF ACTION: STAFF CONTACT: Board Meeting 05/26/2016 Final Action Bonnie Todd, Executive Director Operations Martin Young, Sounder Operations Manager Jordan Wagner, Senior Legal Counsel

PROPOSED ACTION

Authorizes the chief executive officer to execute amendments to the Commuter Rail Service Agreement (Seattle to Nisqually), the Joint Use Agreement (Seattle to Tacoma), the Commuter Rail North Service Agreement, and the Joint Use Agreement (Everett to Seattle), all with the BNSF Railway Company, to adjust insurance provisions to reflect the passenger rail liability cap increase under federal law.

KEY FEATURES SUMMARY

 In December 2015, President Obama signed into law the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation Act (FAST), which among other things, raised the liability limitation for passenger rail from $200 million to $295 million for a single accident, with adjustments every five years to reflect the change in the Consumer Price Index-All Urban Consumers (49 U.S.C. §28103).  Under the four agreements with the BNSF Railway Company (BNSF), is currently required to maintain $200 million in comprehensive railroad liability insurance.  These amendments adjust Sound Transit’s contractual insurance requirements to meet the new liability cap under federal law.  The Board previously approved an amendment to the Commuter Rail South Service Agreement (through Motion No. M2015-106) that went unsigned by BNSF because of the change in liability cap law shortly after Board approval. The amendment to this agreement also includes the terms authorized by the Board in Motion No. M2015-106 for the Service Agreement and supersedes the prior unsigned amendment.

BACKGROUND

The FAST Act raised the liability cap for passenger rail accidents from $200 million to $295 million, with adjustments every five years. Under all four agreements, changes in the law regarding the liability cap for passenger rail accidents requires the parties to negotiate new insurance coverage language when the law is changed, because of the potential gap between Sound Transit’s insurance levels and the maximum possible liability for an accident.

With the December 2015 change in federal law, the parties reopened and negotiated a new level of Sound Transit insurance intended to cover uninsured liability, giving due consideration to the additional costs or savings of such a change.

Commuter Rail Service Agreement (Seattle to Nisqually) and Joint Use Agreement (Seattle to Tacoma)

Sound Transit and BNSF entered the Commuter Rail Service Agreement (Seattle to Nisqually) and Construction Agreement (Seattle to Tacoma), under which BNSF constructed improvements necessary to operate nine round trips over BNSF right-of-way between Seattle and Tacoma for 40 years. In 2010, Sound Transit entered into a purchase and sale agreement to acquire perpetual rights through “commuter rail easements” for four additional round trips over BNSF right-of-way between Seattle and Tacoma, bringing the total round trips to thirteen. When the Service Agreement expires in 2040, Sound Transit’s four round trips (on the four commuter rail easements) will be controlled under the terms of the Joint Use Agreement (Seattle to Tacoma).

The Commuter Rail Service Agreement (Seattle to Tacoma) has been amended over the years to add additional trips, and include operations over track now owned by Sound Transit between Tacoma Rail Junction and the , then between the Tacoma Dome Station and Lakewood. In November 2015, the Board approved a previous draft of the Fourth Amendment to the Commuter Rail Service Agreement (Seattle to Nisqually) to, among other things, add responsibilities relating to Positive Train Control (PTC) and dispatching and support services through Nisqually when service starts over Sound Transit’s track between Nisqually and Tacoma. BNSF did not sign the Board-approved amendment (authorized under Motion No. M2015- 106) because President Obama signed the FAST Act shortly after the Board action.

The Fourth Amendment to the Commuter Rail Service Agreement (Seattle to Nisqually) now before the Board contains all of the amendments approved in M2015-106 as well as the renegotiated insurance provisions that now require Sound Transit to have its insurance match the new liability cap under federal law, subject to renegotiation regarding future changes.

Under the Commuter Rail Service Agreement (Seattle to Nisqually), BNSF operates ten daily round trips for commuter service and supports Sounder south line special service on weekends to Seahawk, Mariners, and Sounders FC sporting events. Sound Transit will add one round trip in September 2016 and two round trips in September 2017, for a total of thirteen daily round trips.

Commuter Rail North Service Agreement and Joint Use Agreement (Everett to Seattle)

Sound Transit first entered the Commuter Rail North Service Agreement with BNSF to operate Sounder commuter rail between Everett and Seattle in 2003. The term of the Commuter Rail Service agreement was for 12 years, with an option of five additional years, for a maximum term of 17 years. The Board authorized the five-year extension in November 2015.

The Commuter Rail North Service Agreement and Everett to Seattle Joint Use Agreement require the parties to renegotiate the contractual $200 million insurance requirement if federal law regarding liability limitations change. With the December 2015 change in federal law, the parties agreed to reopen and renegotiate a new level of Sound Transit insurance intended to reflect any resulting change in either party’s exposure to uninsured liability, giving due consideration to the additional costs or savings of such a change.

The Commuter Rail North Service Agreement will be amended to require Sound Transit to have its insurance match the new liability cap under federal law, but requires the parties to renegotiate future changes.

Under the Commuter Rail North Service Agreement, BNSF operates four daily round trips for commuter service and supports Sounder north line special service on weekends to Seahawk, Mariners, and Sounders FC sporting events. Sound Transit has a perpetual right to operate trains Motion No. M2016-54 Page 2 of 4 Staff Report

in the Everett to Seattle corridor under four commuter rail easements implemented through the Everett to Seattle Joint Use Agreement executed along with the Commuter Rail North Service Agreement in 2003. When the service agreement expires, Sound Transit could select an operator other than BNSF. In such a situation, the terms of the Joint Use Agreement (Everett to Seattle) would control.

FISCAL INFORMATION

For the additional $95 million of liability insurance coverage, the new premium, including surplus lines and taxes, has increased by an annual amount of $300,985. The prorated incremental cost for 2016 is $211,263. The increase in Sounder insurance budget will be funded from the surplus in diesel fuel budget due to favorable pricing.

The table below illustrates the budget impact of the proposed action.

Currently Year Sounder Operations Fuel and Adopted 2016 Spent and Contract Remaining Insurance budget Budget Committed to Expenditures 2016 Budget date in 2016 2016 Sounder Fuel Budget 4,327 384 1,151 2,792 Other Materials and Supplie sbudget 2,258 576 N/A 1,682 Total Sounder Operations Materials and Supllies Budget 6,585 960 1,151 4,474

Sounder Insurance Premium 1,177 625 763 -211

Budget Shortfall (211) Surplus in Fuel budget 2,792 Reminaing Fuel Budget 2,581

Notes: Sounder Operations Fuel budget is embedded in Materials and Supplies budget. Materials/Supplies, and Insurance budget can be found on page 49 of the Adopted 2016 Budget book.

SMALL BUSINESS/DBE PARTICIPATION, APPRENTICESHIP UTILIZATION, AND TITLE VI COMPLIANCE

Not applicable.

PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT

Not applicable.

TIME CONSTRAINTS

A one-month delay may not impact operations.

PRIOR BOARD/COMMITTEE ACTIONS

Motion No. M2015-106: Authorizes the chief executive officer to execute an amendment to the Commuter Rail Service Agreement with the BNSF Railway Company to incorporate changes

Motion No. M2016-54 Page 3 of 4 Staff Report

related to the south line service agreement including the extension of service to Lakewood on Sound Transit right-of-way and the implementation of positive train control. [Amendment not executed] Motion No. M2015-105: Authorized the chief executive officer to execute an amendment to the Commuter Rail North Service Agreement including exercising a five-year term extension option with the BNSF Railway Company for the continued operation of Sounder north line service between Everett and Seattle. Motion No. M2010-71: Authorized the chief executive officer to execute an amendment to the Commuter Rail Service Agreement with The BNSF Railway Company for the operation of Sounder commuter rail service between Seattle and Lakewood to add four additional Sounder commuter rail weekday round trips. Motion No. M2007-98: Authorized the chief executive officer to execute an amendment to the BNSF Railway Company Service Agreement for Sounder commuter rail for the Seattle to Tacoma Corridor to permit up to six round trips before completion of Phase 2 railroad improvements under the BNSF Railway Company Construction Agreement. Motion No. M2003-136: Authorized the Chief Executive Officer to execute a First Amendment to the Commuter Rail Service Agreement between the Central Puget Sound Regional Transit Authority and the Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway Company. Motion No. M2003-135: Authorized the chief executive officer to execute a Joint Use Agreement between the Central Puget Sound Regional Transit Authority and the Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway Company for Tacoma to Nisqually Railroad right-of-way and properties. Motion No. M2003-131: Authorized the chief executive officer to execute a commuter rail service agreement between the Central Puget Sound Regional Transit Authority and the Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway Company for Everett to Seattle Commuter Rail Services. Motion No. M2003-130: Authorized the chief executive officer to execute a Joint Use Agreement between the Central Puget Sound Regional Transit Authority and the Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway Company for Everett to Seattle Commuter Rail Easements. Resolution No. R2003-22: Authorized the execution of eight agreements covering the purchase and sale of right-of-way and right-of-way interests, join use conditions and services between the Central Puget Sound Regional Transit Authority and the Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway Company (BNSF) for Sounder in the Everett to Seattle and Lakewood to Tacoma corridors. Resolution No. R99-22: Authorized the Executive Director to execute two contracts with The Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway (BNSF), each to be substantially in accordance with the basic terms for such agreements set forth in the Background and Comments attached hereto as Exhibit A. The first is a long-term contract that will provide for BNSF to operate Sounder commuter rail service between Seattle and Tacoma (Operating Agreement). The second is a contract that will specify agreed-upon capital improvements on and around BNSF’s existing railroad right-of-way, and provide for BNSF to construct those improvements and for Sound Transit to contribute approximately $200 million and other public authorities to contribute approximately $70 million to the cost of such construction (Construction Agreement).

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW

JI 4/28/2016

LEGAL REVIEW

JW 5/11/2016

Motion No. M2016-54 Page 4 of 4 Staff Report

Motion Motion

add add

The The

Tacoma). Tacoma).

When When

commuter commuter trips trips

agreement agreement

Seattle Seattle

Construction Construction

Sound Sound

necessary necessary Tacoma) Tacoma)

Commuter Commuter

additional additional

Sound Sound

With With

insurance insurance

with with

The The

language language

liability liability

authorized authorized

prior prior

cap cap The The

(through (through

These These

liability liability

Act Act required required

in in Under Under

million million

federal federal

Agreement, Agreement,

BACKGROUND: BACKGROUND: In In

Company, Company,

A A

executive executive

Nisqually), Nisqually),

MOTION MOTION

the the

motion motion

December December

additional additional

Commuter Commuter

(FAST), (FAST),

law law

over over

FAST FAST

adjustments adjustments

Board Board

the the

unsigned unsigned

the the

No. No.

Consumer Consumer

Transit Transit

Transit Transit

the the

amendments amendments

and and

to to cap cap

cap cap

law. law.

shortly shortly

December December

to to

Motion Motion

BNSF BNSF

when when

M2016-54 M2016-54

Service Service

$295 $295

costs costs

of of

rail rail

levels levels

to to

officer officer four four

Act Act

to to

Rail Rail

by by

previously previously

to to

for for

Tacoma Tacoma

maintain maintain

NO. NO.

the the

under under

the the

which which

and and

Agreement Agreement

operate operate

acquire acquire

easements) easements)

2015, 2015,

adjust adjust

trips, trips,

the the

and and

insurance insurance

raised raised

passenger passenger

amendment. amendment.

Rail Rail

agreements agreements

Service Service

Joint Joint

million million

after after

the the

or or

right-of-way right-of-way

Board Board

No. No.

and and

M2016-54 M2016-54

the the

every every

to to

Price Price

Agreement Agreement

Board Board

federal federal

savings savings

BNSF BNSF

among among

and and

law law Service Service

2015 2015

execute execute

President President

for for

insurance insurance

M2015-106) M2015-106)

adjust adjust

$200 $200

Board Board

Use Use

Joint Joint

the the

nine nine

the the

perpetual perpetual

approved approved

for for

of of

Index-All Index-All

five five

Agreement Agreement

is is

40 40

include include

(Seattle (Seattle

in in

maximum maximum

intended intended

liability liability entered entered

change change

Agreement Agreement

the the

a a law. law.

changed, changed,

rail rail

will will

Sounder Sounder

Use Use

million million

other other

years. years.

of of

Motion Motion

approval. approval.

Sound Sound

years. years.

Agreement Agreement

single single

with with

between between

amendments amendments

such such

Central Central

expires expires

accidents accidents

be be

Obama Obama

Agreement Agreement

provisions provisions

rights rights

operations operations

an an

things, things,

the the

Urban Urban

cap cap

to to

controlled controlled

that that

in in

in in

the the

In In

to to

accident, accident,

No. No.

Transit's Transit's

Under Under

a a

(Seattle (Seattle

amendment amendment

possible possible

commuter commuter

Tacoma), Tacoma),

federal federal

because because

comprehensive comprehensive

2010, 2010,

BNSF BNSF

change. change.

cover cover

for for

(Seattle (Seattle

Puget Puget

The The

Commuter Commuter

in in

Seattle Seattle

through through

went went

signed signed

M2015-106 M2015-106

(Seattle (Seattle

Consumers Consumers

raised raised

requires requires

2040, 2040,

passenger passenger

all all

to to

amendment amendment

to to

Sound Sound

(Everett (Everett

uninsured uninsured

over over

Railway Railway

unsigned unsigned

law, law,

under under

to to

contractual contractual

Sound Sound

with with

four four

liability liability

reflect reflect

the the

of of

and and

to to

under under

into into

"commuter "commuter

rail rail

Sound Sound

Nisqually) Nisqually)

the the

the the

to to

to to

track track

the the

Tacoma), Tacoma),

adjustments adjustments

the the

Commuter Commuter

Rail Rail

agreements, agreements,

Transit Transit

Tacoma, Tacoma,

round round

the the

law law

Tacoma) Tacoma)

the the

liability liability

for for

Regional Regional

the the

potential potential to to

rail rail

Company Company

for for

(49 (49

parties parties

railroad railroad

which which

parties parties

Service Service by by

Transit's Transit's

liability, liability,

now now

terms terms

Seattle), Seattle),

the the

the the

Commuter Commuter

to to

an an

passenger passenger

accidents accidents

insurance insurance

U.S.C. U.S.C.

trips trips

BNSF BNSF

and and

this this

entered entered

rail rail

Service Service

limitation limitation

Fixing Fixing

accident. accident.

owned owned

the the

BNSF BNSF

bringing bringing

reopened reopened

to to

Rail Rail

has has

of of

liability liability

gap gap

Transit Transit

easements" easements" over over

agreement agreement

Joint Joint

Agreement Agreement

every every

giving giving

(BNSF), (BNSF),

changes changes

Commuter Commuter

negotiate negotiate

four four

the the

because because

all all

§28103). §28103).

been been

Service Service

America's America's

between between

constructed constructed

from from

into into

Rail Rail

by by

with with

Agreement Agreement

requirements requirements

BNSF BNSF

rail rail

Joint Joint

Use Use

round round

for for

insurance. insurance.

five five

the the

due due

Authority Authority

Sound Sound

and and

a a

liability liability amended amended

South South

the the

$200 $200

Sound Sound

passenger passenger

in in

Agreement Agreement

total total

purchase purchase

years years

Use Use

of of

new new

consideration consideration

Agreement Agreement

also also

right-of-way right-of-way

(Seattle (Seattle

the the

Rail Rail

for for trips trips

negotiated negotiated

Sound Sound

BNSF BNSF

the the

Surface Surface

Transit Transit

million million

Agreement Agreement

Service Service

round round

four four

insurance insurance

cap cap

law law

includes includes

improvements improvements

and and

authorizing authorizing

Transit Transit

to to

North North

change change

(on (on

to to

over over

reflect reflect

Railway Railway

Transit's Transit's

regarding regarding

additional additional

to to

and and

increase increase

rail rail

supersedes supersedes

the the

meet meet

(Seattle (Seattle

trips trips

to to

between between

Transportation Transportation

Nisqually) Nisqually)

Service Service

(Seattle (Seattle

Agreement Agreement

the the

a a

between between

from from

is is

$295 $295

sale sale

four four

the the

in in

to to

SouNDTRANsrr SouNDTRANsrr

new new

the the

coverage coverage

currently currently

Page Page

to to

the the

(Seattle (Seattle

years years

liability liability

the the

the the

T T

terms terms

thirteen. thirteen.

$200 $200

under under

change change

to to

million, million,

the the

round round

level level

new new

to to

1of3 1of3

chief chief

the the

and and

to to

to to of of

Motion Motion

would would

Agreement Agreement other other

Everett Everett

in in

Mariners, Mariners, commuter commuter

future future Under Under

The The

insurance insurance

additional additional

agreed agreed

resulting resulting

the the

The The

regarding regarding

Service Service

Sounder Sounder

Sound Sound

17 17

Commuter Commuter

September September

trips trips

Seahawk, Seahawk,

Under Under

cap cap

the the

insurance insurance

The The

Tacoma. Tacoma.

through through

106) 106)

responsibilities responsibilities

to to

and and

Tacoma Tacoma

the the

the the

years. years.

parties parties

Board Board

Commuter Commuter

Commuter Commuter

under under

Fourth Fourth

Lakewood. Lakewood. for for

than than

Everett Everett because because

No. No.

control. control.

changes

the the

Commuter Commuter

the the

to to

Transit Transit

to to

agreement agreement

commuter commuter

Nisqually Nisqually

change change

commuter commuter

and and

Rail Rail

M2016-54 M2016-54

Seattle Seattle

The The

BNSF BNSF

reopen reopen

costs costs

liability liability

match match

Commuter Commuter

BNSF. BNSF. service service

Mariners, Mariners,

Commuter Commuter

contains contains

provisions provisions

federal federal

to to

in in

Rail Rail

2016 2016

Amendment Amendment

to to

2003. 2003.

renegotiate renegotiate

Sounders Sounders

Junction Junction

Board Board

. .

first first

President President

Rail Rail

Rail Rail

North North

or or

Seattle Seattle

relating relating

did did

In In

the the

in in

Joint Joint

limitations limitations

and and

In In

and and

and and

Rail Rail

savings savings

law, law,

when when

entered entered

service service

November November

either either

was was

When When

all all

rail rail North North

such such

North North

not not

new new

and and

authorized authorized

Rail Rail

that that

two two

Service Service

Rail Rail

renegotiate renegotiate

supports supports

Service Service

of of

Use Use

and and

subject subject

between between corridor corridor

sign sign

to to

for for

FC FC

Amtrak Amtrak

to to

Obama Obama

Sounders Sounders

the the

a a

liability liability

the the

party's party's

North North

Service Service

now now

round round

the the

Service Service

Service Service

Positive Positive

of of

and and

situation, situation,

the the

Agreement Agreement

the the

the the

12 12

sporting sporting

change. change.

the the

amendments amendments

contractual contractual

such such

service service

Agreement Agreement

2015, 2015,

years, years,

Agreement Agreement

require require

to to

Commuter Commuter

Tacoma Tacoma

Commuter Commuter

supports supports

Sounder Sounder

under under

Service Service

the the

trips trips

service service

Board-approved Board-approved

Everett Everett

cap cap

exposure exposure

signed signed

renegotiation renegotiation

a a

Agreement Agreement

Agreement Agreement

Agreement Agreement

a a

Train Train

FC FC

new new

five-year five-year

the the

events

change. change.

With With

the the

under under

with with

in in

agreement agreement

four four

Sound Sound

executed executed

sporting sporting

September September

Agreement, Agreement,

Dome Dome

starts starts the the

Board Board

and and

Sounder Sounder

terms terms

level level

north north

$200 $200

Control Control

and and

the the

an an

Rail Rail

Rail Rail

(Seattle (Seattle

commuter commuter

approved approved

to to

. .

federal federal

FAST FAST

Sound Sound

Seattle Seattle

option option

extension extension

uninsured uninsured

Transit Transit

December December

of of

will will

and and

Joint Joint

(Seattle (Seattle

over over

million million

line line

Station, Station,

North North

approved approved Service Service

of of

regarding regarding

events. events.

Sound Sound

(PTC) (PTC)

along along

expires, expires,

amendment amendment

the the

be be

south south

Act Act

Everett Everett

special special

to to

law, law,

Sound Sound 2017, 2017,

Transit Transit

Use Use

of of

BNSF BNSF

in in

amended amended

in in

Service Service

to to

Joint Joint

rail rail

Nisqually) Nisqually)

insurance insurance

shortly shortly five five

to to

2003. 2003.

then then

Agreement Agreement

with with

M2015-106 M2015-106

and and

Transit Transit

in in

but but

have have

Sound Sound

line line

liability, liability,

Agreement Agreement

2015 2015

a a

easements easements

future future

Nisqually), Nisqually),

for for

Sound Sound

November November

to to

service service

Transit's Transit's

additional additional

Use Use

previous previous

operates operates

has has

requires requires

the the

dispatching dispatching

special special

between between

Seattle Seattle

a a

Agreement Agreement

The The its its

after after

(authorized (authorized

change change

to to

total total

Transit Transit

insurance insurance

Agreement Agreement

a a

Commuter Commuter

changes. changes.

giving giving

to, to,

requirement requirement

insurance insurance

Transit Transit

perpetual perpetual

require require

term term

on on

(Seattle (Seattle

the the

among among

as as

service service

of of

track track

(Everett (Everett

draft draft

the the

four four

Joint Joint

BNSF BNSF

implemented implemented

years, years,

2015. 2015.

the the

weekends weekends

thirteen thirteen

well well

will will

in in

due due

Board Board

of of

and and parties parties

could could

with with

federal federal

Tacoma Tacoma

Sound Sound

daily daily

of of

between between

the the

intended intended

Use Use

under under

add add

match match

other other

Rail Rail

as as

consideration consideration (Everett (Everett

to to

operates operates

right right

on on

the the

for for

support support

to to

if if

Commuter Commuter

action. action.

BNSF BNSF

Nisqually) Nisqually)

the the

round round

federal federal

Agreement Agreement

daily daily

select select

weekends weekends one one

Seattle} Seattle} a a

North North

to to

Fourth Fourth

to to

Transit Transit

to to

law, law,

Motion Motion

things, things,

maximum maximum

the the

renegotiated renegotiated

Dome Dome

renegotiate renegotiate

through through

Nisqually Nisqually

Seahawk, Seahawk,

to to

operate operate

round round

to to

round round

to to

ten ten services services

trips trips

the the

an an

new new

reflect reflect Service Service

law law Seattle) Seattle)

operate operate

Amendment Amendment

Page Page

to to

add add

No. No.

operator operator

now now

daily daily

Rail Rail

Station Station

parties parties

to to

trip trip

to to

for for

liability liability

trips. trips.

require require

have have

the the

trains trains

term term

the the

M2015-

any any

and and

2 2

before before

in in

round round

of of

its its

of of 3 3

Motion Motion

Board Board

~athrYfliOf"es ~athrYfliOf"es

APPROVED APPROVED

meeting meeting

under under Agreement Agreement

Rail Rail

Railway Railway

chief chief

It It

MOTION: MOTION:

is is

hereby hereby

North North

executive executive

No

Administrator Administrator

federal federal

. .

thereof thereof

Company, Company,

M2016-54 M2016-54

Service Service

(Seattle (Seattle

moved moved

by by

law. law.

officer officer

the the

held held

Agreement, Agreement,

by by

to to

Board Board

to to

on on

adjust adjust

the the

is is

Nisqually), Nisqually),

May May

authorized authorized

Board Board

of of

insurance insurance

the the

26, 26,

and and

of of

Central Central

2016. 2016.

the the

the the

the the

to to

Joint Joint

execute execute

Central Central

provisions provisions

Joint Joint

Puget Puget

Use Use

Use Use

'"D©UL '"D©UL

Puget Puget

amendments amendments

Sound Sound

Agreement Agreement

Agreement Agreement

to to

Board Board

DolN DolN

reflect reflect

Sound Sound

Regional Regional

Constantine Constantine

Chair Chair

the the

(Seattle (Seattle

Regional Regional

to to

(Everett (Everett

passenger passenger

the the

Transit Transit

Commuter Commuter

to to

to to

Transit Transit

Tacoma), Tacoma),

Authority Authority

Seattle), Seattle),

rail rail

Authority Authority

liability liability

Rail Rail

the the

at at

all all

Service Service

a a

with with

Commuter Commuter

cap cap

regular regular

that that

Page Page

the the

increase increase

the the

3 3

BNSF BNSF

of of 3 3