Myrmecological News 11 119-132 Vienna, August 2008

The causes and consequences of genetic caste determination in (: Formicidae)

Kirk E. ANDERSON, Timothy A. LINKSVAYER & Chris R. SMITH

Abstract Recently there has been an explosion of research into the genetics of caste determination, especially following the discovery of systems where queen-worker caste determination has a strong genetic influence. In this review we collate and interpret research on genetic caste determination in ants and discuss this research within the historical framework of caste determination in the social . While early researchers disagreed over the relative importance of rearing environment and genes on caste determination, the notion that caste is determined by environment had been largely supported by both theory and empirical results – until relatively recently. The growing utility of molecular markers, to- gether with breeding studies and other quantitative genetic approaches, has now demonstrated a genetic component to caste across numerous social taxa. The strength of the genetic component varies and may often remain highly conditional on the environment. In extreme cases, caste is determined almost exclusively by genotype. We review en- vironmental and genetic factors that affect caste determination, summarize recent evidence for weak and strong genetic caste determination, and discuss the evolution of these systems. Genotypes that produce queen-biased caste ratios are often described as cheaters, and here we emphasize that the evolutionary dynamics of genetic caste determination in- volves the coevolution (often antagonistic) of biasing and restorer genes expressed in interacting nestmates. The evolu- tionary importance of such conflicts over caste fate remains unclear, but in some cases may lead to widespread depen- dent lineage systems, sperm parasitism, and workerless social parasites. Key words: Polyphenism, phenotypic plasticity, genotype-by-environment interaction, social cheaters, dependent lineage, co-evolution, antagonistic selection, review. Myrmecol. News 11: 119-132 (online 25 June 2008) ISSN 1994-4136 (print), ISSN 1997-3500 (online) Received 14 April 2008; revision received 15 May 2008; accepted 16 May 2008 Dr. Kirk E. Anderson* (contact author), Department of Entomology, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA. E-mail: [email protected] Dr. Timothy A. Linksvayer*, School of Life Sciences, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287, USA. Dr. Chris R. Smith*, School of Life Sciences, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287, USA; Program in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL 61801, USA. * Authors contributed equally.

Introduction I believe that natural selection, by acting on the fertile digm that caste is determined exclusively by environment- parents, transmitted to their fertile offspring a tendency to al factors, and that royal jelly is the "queen-producing" sub- produce sterile members ... one set of workers of one size stance (MICHENER 1974). Early experiments on caste de- and structure, and simultaneously another set of workers of termination in ants also demonstrated the importance of the a different size and structure. nutritional environment (e.g., WESSON 1940, GREGG 1942, DARWIN (1859) PASSERA 1974). Such an environmentally-based process fits In social insects, the presence of sterile castes and the mech- well with simple theoretical predictions: Genes biasing caste anisms that underlie caste determination have long fasci- determination towards queen or worker development are nated biologists. A division of labor between reproduc- expected to be fixed or lost, respectively, so that little gen- tive queens and more-or-less sterile workers is a core trait etic variation for caste is maintained within populations of eusocial colonies that seems to be responsible for the (CROZIER & PAMILO 1996). However, other early research- extreme ecological and evolutionary success of the social ers inferred genetic influences on caste based on detailed insects (HÖLLDOBLER & WILSON 1990). The largest and observations of aberrant phenotypes in queens and their most complex societies are characterized by further divi- presumed offspring. For example, individuals from a col- sion of labor between workers, and these worker castes are ony of Acromyrmex leaf-cutter ants presented a mosaic of often morphologically distinct. Honey bees have long been queen and worker traits, prompting W.M. WHEELER (1937) a model system for studying reproductive caste determi- to propose that caste determination in ants was under gen- nation, and early studies established the long-standing para- etic control. Perhaps more importantly, Wheeler concluded that an understanding of caste determination in ants would over what larvae are given (MICHENER 1974), although only be realized somewhere beyond the "environment- larvae may often be capable of influencing worker provi- versus-heredity impasse". This conclusion is equivalent to sioning behavior (NONACS 1986, CREEMERS & al. 2003, acknowledging that caste in social insects is a complex KAPTEIN 2005). Such adult control of larval caste develop- phenotype, influenced by multiple interacting genetic and mental trajectories can be considered a type of parental environmental factors. Indeed, recent and mounting evi- manipulation (ALEXANDER 1974, MICHENER & BROTHERS dence from a variety of approaches supports this conclu- 1974, LINKSVAYER & WADE 2005). In some taxa, larvae sion. have relatively more control over their own caste determi- Thus, while environmental factors have long been the nation. For example, in attine ants, larvae are placed on a focus of research on morphological caste determination pile of food, though they are likely constrained in the qual- (WILSON 1971, OSTER & WILSON 1978, WHEELER 1986, ity of food they can acquire and perhaps limited in what HÖLLDOBLER & WILSON 1990, WHEELER 1991), this re- they can reach. In other taxa, e.g., Melipona stingless bees, view approaches caste in social insects from a genetic per- larvae are provided an initial bundle of food and develop in spective. Like any complex phenotype, caste has a herit- a sealed cell (mass provisioning; MICHENER 1974) decreas- able component. At the most fundamental level, the vast ing the potential for worker control of larval caste fate (RAT- number of genes (see EVANS & WHEELER 1999) involved NIEKS 2001). in the developmental process of caste determination is sub- Genetic factors: In fact, all of the "environmental" fac- ject to mutation-selection balance. Additionally, caste- tors mentioned above can have genetic components. Genes biasing alleles may experience opposing selection pres- expressed in care-giving workers and the queen can in- sure within and between colonies, potentially resulting in fluence the nutritional, microclimate, and pheromonal envir- their maintenance at intermediate frequencies. Here we re- onment experienced by larvae, and thus indirectly shape caste view genetic and environmental factors that influence caste determination (indirect genetic effects; LINKSVAYER & determination, and how these factors may interact to shape WADE 2005, LINKSVAYER 2006, 2007). Thus, genes expres- caste developmental trajectories. Our empirical founda- sed in care-giving workers have a strong potential to be tion relies primarily on the association of genetic markers caste-biasing genes. Indeed, LINKSVAYER (2006) found her- with caste phenotypes, and to this end we review studies itable variation for queen and worker effects on reproduc- demonstrating genetic caste determination (GCD) in soci- tive caste in the acorn Temnothorax curvispinosus, in- al insects. We divide this influence into two basic catego- dicating that queen and worker influences on larval caste ries according to recent data; 1) when the heritability of determination have a genetic basis and can evolve. Brood caste is intermediate, "weak GCD", environmental varia- may also influence the provisioning they receive through tion exerts a strong influence, and individual genetic vari- mechanical "begging" (KAPTEIN 2005) or chemical signal- ants differ in their probability of developing into alterna- ing (NONACS 1986, LE CONTE & HEFETZ 2008). In this tive castes and 2) "strong GCD" when caste is determined way, genes expressed in both brood and care-giving wor- exclusively or nearly so by genotype (see Tab. 1 for exam- kers interact to influence the developmental environment ples of each). Finally, we discuss the consequences of gen- and resulting caste determination. Such heritable queen, etic influences on both reproductive and worker caste poly- worker, and brood effects on caste are a prerequisite for morphism, and how these genetic influences may evolve the evolution of caste via queen-worker-brood conflict over and be maintained. caste fate (LINKSVAYER 2006, 2007, 2008). The process of caste determination is often described Factors affecting caste determination as polyphenism or phenotypic plasticity because the same Environmental factors: While early models of environ- genotype, when exposed to different environments can mental caste determination (ECD) focused on the quantity result in multiple discrete phenotypes (WHEELER 1986). and quality of food given to larvae, other environmental With strict nutritional ECD, an individual that receives factors have also been shown to influence caste determi- enough food will surpass a threshold for queen determina- nation (WHEELER 1986, 1991). For example, in many ant tion and develop into a queen, whereas an individual re- species, new queens and males are only produced at cer- ceiving less food may be below the threshold and develop tain times of the year, and environmental cues such as into a worker (WHEELER 1986). Genetic factors may raise changes in temperature associated with overwintering are or lower the queen threshold, and can influence the like- required for queen production (ELMES 1987). In some cas- lihood that an individual surpasses the threshold, but can es, these seasonal effects seem to be mediated by the quan- also influence how developing individuals respond to en- tity of hormones the queen deposits in her eggs (SUZZONI & vironmental signals. Some genetic variants may effectively al. 1980, DE MENTEN & al. 2005, SCHWANDER & al. 2008a). "ignore" environmental cues and initiate queen caste deter- Perhaps a more general maternal influence on caste deter- mination regardless of rearing environment. When differ- mination is queen pheromone that signals queen presence ent genotypes are differentially sensitive to and respond dif- and suppresses queen development (KELLER & NONACS ferently to environmental cues, there is genotype-by-envir- 1993). Such queen signals may be received directly by lar- onment interaction (G × E, FALCONER & MACKAY 1996). vae and influence their development, or may influence wor- Such G × E indicates genetic variation for phenotypic plas- ker behavior, which in turn shapes the social environment ticity, and is important for the evolutionary modification and and indirectly affects larval development. "fine tuning" of larval responses to the developmental en- Workers control many of the environmental factors that vironment (LINKSVAYER 2007). As detailed above, G × E influence caste determination. In the majority of ants and interactions are not straightforward in social insects be- vespid wasps, larvae are directly fed by workers (progres- cause the "E" term includes the highly influential social en- sive provisioning) and the workers presumably have control vironment, which is generated in part by the collective "G"

120 Tab. 1: Taxonomic distribution of genetic caste determination (GCD) in ants.

Degree of GCD Type Subfamily Taxon References

Strong Queen-Worker DL HELMS CAHAN & al. (2002), JULIAN & barbatus & rugosus al. (2002), VOLNY & GORDON (2002)

Solenopsis geminata × xyloni HELMS CAHAN & VINSON (2003)

Vollenhovia emeryi OHKAWARA & al. (2006)

Wasmannia auropunctata FOURNIER & al. (2005)

Formicinae Cataglyphis cursor PEARCY & al. (2004)

Queen-Queen Myrmicinae Solenopsis invicta GOTZEK & ROSS (2007)

Formicinae Acanthomyops latipes × UMPHREY & DANZMANN (1998) claviger

Weak Queen-Worker Myrmicinae Acromyrmex echinatior HUGHES & BOOMSMA (2008)

Pogonomyrmex badius SMITH & al. (in press)

Temnothorax curvispinosus LINKSVAYER (2006)

Queen-Queen Myrmicinae Monomorium sp. 10 FERSCH & al. (2000)

Harpagoxenus sublaevis WINTER & BUSCHINGER (1986)

Myrmecina graminicola BUSCHINGER & SCHREIBER (2002)

Formicinae Lasius niger FJERDINGSTAD (2005)

Formica truncorum BARGUM & al. (2004)

Ectatominae Ectatomma tuberculatum HORA & al. (2005)

Worker-Worker Myrmicinae Acromyrmex echinatior and HUGHES & al. (2003), JULIAN & A. versicolor FEWELL (2004)

Pogonomyrmex badius RHEINDT & al. (2005); SMITH & al. (in press)

Temnothorax rudis STUART & PAGE (1991)

Ecitoninae Eciton burchellii JAFFE & al. (2007)

Formicinae Camponotus consobrinus FRASER & al. (2000)

Formica selysi SCHWANDER & al. (2005)

term of the individuals that form the society (LINKSVAYER LICK 2002). This stability suggests a genetic component to 2006, 2007). caste determination, yet studies manipulating aspects of the In line with the general observations of KERR (1950) social or larval environment often revealed that caste de- for Melipona stingless bees, more detailed studies revealed termination remains primarily plastic. For example, hor- that caste ratios and size proportions of other social in- monal manipulations of Melipona stingless bees drastically sects were relatively unaffected by environmental fluctu- change queen-worker caste ratios relative to genetic expec- ations (WHEELER & NIJHOUT 1984, JOHNSTON & WIL- tations (HARTFELDER 2006). Also, in a harvester ant where SON 1985, PASSERA & al. 1996, FRASER & al. 2000, BIL- genetic determination of both queen and worker castes has

121 been documented (RHEINDT & al. 2005, SMITH & al. in formed) and publication biases (negative results are pub- press) a change in the incoming food supply to colonies lished less often) there have been more reports of genetic alters colony investment into queens and workers (SMITH differences within castes compared to between queens and 2007). Thus, despite genetic predispositions, environmental workers (Tab. 1). factors may override genetic variation in the thresholds Caste biasing alleles: The majority of studies have or developmental switches that bias caste determination utilized patrilines as an easily defined source of genetic (HUGHES & BOOMSMA 2007). variation, so it is appropriate to explore how traits are in- herited from fathers and how these are then passed to sub- Overview of "weak" GCD sequent generations. Because alleles are only carried by Although colonies of most ant species are headed by a males in alternating generations, a paternally inherited al- single, once-mated queen, colonies of other species consist lele will only be in females in the next generation and then of multiple maternal and / or paternal subfamilies. Nearly both males and females two generations thence. Thus, if a a quarter of a century ago CALDERONE & PAGE (1988) de- paternal allele biases a focal female's propensity to become monstrated that colonies of honey bees could be selected a queen rather than a worker then we would expect, all else for different worker properties, and shortly after ROBINSON being equal, that female offspring of our focal female will & PAGE (1988) showed that behavioral specialists within also show a queen bias. Despite the superficial benefits of colonies tended to belong to distinct paternal sub- having an allele that favors royalty over drudgery, the re- families (patrilines). Since these landmark studies demon- sulting dynamics are not straightforward because colonies strated a heritable basis for behavior, much has been learned need to produce both queens and workers at specific times about the role of genetics in behavioral and morphological during a colony's life cycle (HÖLLDOBLER & WILSON 1990). caste specialization. However, we still have little under- Thus, alleles that strongly bias an individual toward queen standing of how inheritance of caste specialization works development may impose a genetic load on colonies when in the social Hymenoptera and how selection at both the those individuals are produced out of sync with the colo- individual and colony levels act to maintain specific caste ny's "natural cycle" (ANDERSON & al. 2006a, CLARK & al. phenotypes. We return to these issues later. 2006, SCHWANDER & al. 2006). G × E interactions and As genetic markers (RFLP, allozymes, RAPD, AFLP, maternal effects may counterbalance weak caste biasing microsatellites, etc.) have become easier to develop and use alleles and help maintain normal caste production cycles they have been more commonly employed in assaying for (SCHWANDER & al. 2008a). GCD. Researchers tend to look at whether known sources Selection for diversity: While a host of conditions have of genetic variation differ in caste production and whether been hypothesized to select for polyandry in the social there is a statistical association between genotype and caste. Hymenoptera (CROZIER & FJERDINGSTAD 2001), the data This approach has demonstrated that some form of GCD presented here suggest that diversity at caste biasing alleles exists in at least 21 ant species spanning 4 subfamilies and may select for a higher effective mating frequency or poly- that genetic bias can occur between queens and workers, gyny. Under ECD, both polyandry and polygyny increase or within the queen or worker castes (Tab. 1). As an ever in- genetic diversity within colonies, which in turn increases creasing number of studies use genetic markers to detect a conflict over caste determination and the theoretical likeli- heritable basis for caste determination, researchers must be hood that individuals, if in control of their own fate, may conscious of any variation attributable to life history traits selfishly choose reproduction over work (REUTER & KEL- or social structure. For example, workers may selectively LER 2001). Under GCD these conflicts are actually re- nurture or destroy certain genotypes depending on season. alized and traits affecting caste bias evolve (LINKSVA- Also, signatures of GCD may be confounded by maternal YER 2006). But when genes influence caste fate, colony or paternal effects when examining matrilineal or patrilin- fitness may be adversely affected by the overproduction of eal caste biases. expensive caste phenotypes which provide little return for Evidence for weak GCD: Genetic biases in caste deter- their investment (HELMS CAHAN & al. 2004, ANDERSON mination (from weak to strong) have been described in & al. 2006a, SCHWANDER & al. 2006). Under these condi- many species spanning four independent evolutionary ori- tions, colony-level selection may act to maintain efficient gins of eusociality (WINTER & BUSCHINGER 1986, ROBIN- caste ratios by removing caste-biasing alleles or by gene- SON & PAGE 1988, HARTFELDER & al. 2006, HAYASHI & al. rating pressure for polygyny and polyandry according to the 2007). Forms of caste bias include behavioral and / or mor- relative strength of the existing genetic caste bias. Where phological specialization among worker castes, morpholo- GCD is very weak (Tab. 1), colony fitness may be rela- gical variation among queens, and whether individuals be- tively unaffected by weak gyne-biasing alleles, and the gen- come queens or workers. The majority of studies describe etic load generated by "royal cheats" may simply be com- differences within either worker or queen castes, while only pensated by other genotypes in the colony which retain a few describe a heritable basis for becoming a queen rath- plasticity. If gyne-biased alleles increase in frequency in er than worker ("royal cheating"). spite of reduced colony fitness, this will generate selective Genetic biases in the determination of physical worker pressure for allelic combinations that allow the unconstrain- castes may be more common because workers are often ed expression of the worker phenotype. In a manner simi- functionally sterile and there is no (or less) conflict associ- lar to that suggested by OLDROYD & FEWELL (2007), poly- ated with the potential for reproduction (HÖLLDOBLER & andry or polygyny will increase colony fitness because it in- WILSON 1990). Although it is difficult to tally the actual fre- creases the chances that a colony ends up with a diverse set quencies of each type of genetic caste determination (among of caste-biasing allelic combinations. workers vs. between workers and queens) from the litera- Potential effects of genetic caste bias: Most research ture due to taxonomic biases (in what taxa research is per- has focused on the role of polyandry and polygyny in con-

122 Fig. 2: Relationship between recombination rates and mat- ing frequency in social insects. Despite a very small sam- Fig. 1: Potential relationships for how lineages within col- ple size, r = 0.83 and P = 0.17. Data on mate frequency onies are distributed among the worker and queen castes. were taken from RHEINDT & al. (2003) and SUMNER & al. A slope, m, of 1 (dashed line) indicates "fair play", where (2004); recombination rates are from WILFERT & al. (2007). the amount of reproduction gained by a lineage is directly proportional to the amount invested in the workforce. Slopes less than 1 suggest the presence of rare cheaters such that growth / reproduction and solicitation of nutrition) while an increase in workforce investment yields a less than pro- nepotism likely involves interactions between nurses and portional representation among queens; patrilines rare the larvae such that provisioning a larva is conditional on among the workforce are "royal cheats". A slope greater the larva's genotype. In the coming years we predict many than 1 hints at nepotism where the most common lineage more studies will evaluate the slope of this relationship among workers gains a disproportionate share of reproduc- (Fig. 1); these data will be very helpful in assessing the tion, potentially by preferential treatment (queen caste in- degree of conflict within colonies and how this may play a duction) of their relatives. role in the evolution of strong genetic caste determination. Recent studies that simultaneously evaluated the role of genetics in worker-worker and queen-worker caste de- tributing to colony genetic variation, but little attention has termination suggest that genetic variation may affect caste been paid to the role of males. Assuming that a genetic determination at different critical points during develop- caste bias exists, what is the most advantageous response ment and in species-specific ways. In Acromyrmex echi- by males? Should they spread their seed across queens or natior, the patrilines that produced a greater than expected put all of their sperm in "one basket"? If the former is the number of queens also showed a large bias in which worker better strategy, it will drive increased genetic diversity be- caste (minor or major) they produced (HUGHES & BOOMSMA cause queens may need to mate multiply to acquire suffici- 2008); thus, there appears to be genetic variation at mul- ent sperm (COLE 1983, TSCHINKEL 1987, FJERDINGSTAD & tiple developmental switches. That is, some patrilines had BOOMSMA 1998, KRAUS & al. 2004), though in many spe- lower thresholds to become majors and gynes while others cies males possess more than sufficient sperm to fully in- essentially bypassed the major caste and developed as only seminate a female (WOYKE 1962). This may, indeed, be the minors or gynes. On the other hand, in the harvester ant Po- case when royal cheaters increase in frequency in a pop- gonomyrmex badius, the size of large workers and queens ulation because these males may decrease their likelihood are more similar within patrilines than either are to small of being detected by remaining rare in colonies (HUGHES workers (SMITH & al. in press), and so it appears that & BOOMSMA 2008). Moreover, males that "play fair" may there is genetic variation for becoming large. It seems that also want to decrease their probability of being parasitiz- weak GCD can evolve in different ways both within and ed; if increased investment in workers does not yield a between species. proportional increase in reproduction then donating Many genes and pathways implicated in caste determi- "too much" sperm in one place may be a poor strategy if nation have epistatic effects (RÜPPELL & al. 2004, HUNT & cheating is strong (Fig. 1). al. 2007, LINKSVAYER 2007). Recombination rates in the The unequal representation of genetic lineages in queen Hymenoptera are among the highest reported for and worker castes may assume two basic relationships, 1) (WILFERT & al. 2007), potentially decreasing the linkage lineages rare among workers are overrepresented among of many genes that are involved in caste determination. queens, and 2) the most common patrilines among wor- Although single gene function can be critical for the main- kers are overrepresented among queens (Fig. 1). The for- tenance of social structure (i.e., CSD, Gp-9; BEYE & al. mer situation is that of the "rare royal cheat" described pre- 2003, GOTZEK & ROSS 2007, GOODISMAN & al. 2008), viously (MORITZ & al. 2005, HUGHES & BOOMSMA 2008), caste determination is complex, and genetic caste biasing but the latter represents nepotism (for possible examples may entail fortuitous combinations of alleles which are see PAGE & al. 1989, HANNONEN & SUNDSTROM 2003). broken up quickly in subsequent generations. Genetic caste The underlying genetic mechanisms that could give rise to biases may be evolutionarily ephemeral, persisting for short either of these scenarios will differ as "royal cheater" lar- periods and then being broken up such that they have an vae bias their own caste fate (allocation of resources to inconsistent influence on social evolution.

123 Fig. 3: The developmental cost of strong GCD in immature colonies of DL Pogonomyrmex. Four brood nourished simultaneously by the same incipient lab colony. The pupa at the far right (d) is inter-lineage and resulted in a normal worker phenotype. The other three broods (a - c) are intra-lineage genotypes and arrested development at different stages of metamorphosis. Photo by K.E. Anderson.

In fact, increasing recombination rates may coevolve 2008) and studies on the molecular basis of parthenogen- with genetic influences on caste and polyandry. A tantaliz- esis are well underway (LATTORFF & al. 2007). ing piece of evidence for this comes from a very small Dependent-lineage (DL) Pogonomyrmex: In some pop- number of species where both recombination rates and mat- ulations of morphologically defined Pogonomyrmex bar- ing frequencies are known (Fig. 2). These four species batus and others of P. rugosus, all workers were found to vary greatly in both polyandry and recombination rate, and be heterozygous at certain genetic markers whereas the a positive linear relationship between the two exists (though gynes in these colonies were homozygous for the same mar- non-statisitically significant due to a very low sample size); kers (HELMS CAHAN & al. 2002, JULIAN & al. 2002, VOL- polyandry evolved independently in each of these lineages NY & GORDON 2002). This pattern was discovered while (KRONAUER & al. 2007), all of which are reported to have searching for the signatures of hybridization and initially some degree of queen-worker genetic caste determination thought to be associated with present sympatry between P. (MORITZ & al. 2005, TILLEY & OLDROYD 1997, HELMS barbatus and P. rugosus (JULIAN & al. 2002), or present CAHAN & al. 2002, HUGHES & BOOMSMA 2008). This find- hybridization between subspecies of P. rugosus (HELMS ing suggests that genetic caste determination is a recur- CAHAN & al. 2002). More detailed genetic markers identi- rent phenomenon, though potentially short-lived, and that fied the role of hybridization in the phenomenon (HELMS alleles that bias caste may usually be prevented from ac- CAHAN & KELLER 2003, ANDERSON & al. 2006b, SCHWAN- cumulating in discrete lineages. DER & al. 2007a). Morphology was misleading, and hybri- dization was not occurring between sub-species or spe- Overview of strong GCD cies. Oddly enough, each of the morpho-species comprised Although recent studies have highlighted additional taxa a perpetually hybridizing system composed of two cryp- representative of strong genetic caste determination (Tab. 1), tic and reproductively isolated lineages (VOLNY & GOR- the following section will focus on the best studied exem- DON 2002, HELMS CAHAN & KELLER 2003, PARKER 2004, plar; dependent lineage (DL) populations of Pogonomyr- HELMS CAHAN & al. 2006, SCHWANDER & al. 2008b). With mex seed harvester ants (see NONACS 2006). All of the more very few exceptions, inter-lineage (F1) gamete combina- recent examples of strong GCD involve some form of thely- tions produced workers and intra-lineage combinations pro- tokous parthenogenesis by the queen (PEARCY & al. 2004, duced gynes. Each system had apparently stabilized as FOURNIER & al. 2005, OHKAWARA & al. 2006, HEINZE workers and gynes representing F1 generations did not con- 2008), a reproductive mode with obvious similarities to DL tribute to the gene pool via the production of inter-lineage Pogonomyrmex systems. Parthenogenesis by queens main- haploid or diploid genotypes (SCHWANDER & al 2007b, tains linkage of alleles that bias development toward queens, SUNI & al. 2007). Thus, polyandry was obligate for both while a genetically variable workforce can be generated by the origin and perpetuation of the system because queens normal sexual reproduction. A genetically variable work- had to mate with a male of each lineage to produce both force is potentially a great advantage to the colony for ad- workers and gynes (HELMS CAHAN & al. 2002, JULIAN & apting to variable environments or maintaining division of al. 2002, VOLNY & GORDON 2002). labor (GADAGKAR 2004, OLDROYD & FEWELL 2007). Al- Nuclear markers coupled with a mitochondrial DNA though it has been known that thelytokous parthenogen- phylogeny indicate that the Pogonomyrmex barbatus - P. esis is phylogenetically widespread (CROZIER & PAMILO rugosus complex is composed of at least six independ- 1996), its role in caste determination and social evolution ently evolving lineages (HELMS CAHAN & KELLER 2003, is just beginning to be understood (SUMNER & KELLER ANDERSON 2006b, but see SCHWANDER 2007a); one P.

124 rugosus and one P. barbatus apparently with environmental types are intrinsically unable to develop as queens, hybridi- caste determination (ECD), and two pairs of lineages which zation may also relax male-male competition over repre- interbreed to form GCD colonies. In recognition of the sentation in the queen caste (JULIAN & al. 2002). Addition- population pressures generated by this reproductive mode ally, the fitness loss associated with inter-lineage mating it is referred to as a "dependent lineage" (DL) system (AN- may be offset by the competitive advantages of F1 workers DERSON 2006a, b). The dependent lineage pairs are H1 / through increased niche breadth and a subsequent decrease H2 and J1 / J2 based on discovery locations near Portal, in intra-specific competition (UMPHREY 2006, ANDERSON Arizona, USA (HELMS CAHAN & KELLER 2003). The H1 / & al. in press). Finally, a colony may benefit from heter- H2 lineage pair has the morphology of P. rugosus and the osis in hybrid workers resulting in selection for hybridi- J1 / J2 lineage pair has the morphology of P. barbatus. zation (UMPHREY & DANZMANN 1998, UMPHREY 2006, Origins of the DL system: The first breakthrough con- JULIAN & HELMS CAHAN 2006, ANDERSON & al. in press). cerning the origin of the dependent lineages focused on Persistence and maintenance of DL systems: In the site of original discovery (Portal, AZ) and revealed the mature colonies of P. rugosus and the lineage pair H1 / H2, footprints of ancient hybridization (HELMS CAHAN & KEL- gyne production is initiated by a seasonal effect (SCHWAN- LER 2003). This analysis pooled allelic data from gynes of DER & al. 2008a). During early colony growth however, de- all four dependent lineages (near Portal, AZ) and both pu- pendent lineage populations seem to differ in their abili- tative ECD species (P. barbatus from Texas and P. rugosus ties to regulate gyne production. In general the available from central Arizona), and argued that alleles found in each data indicate that either the young founding queen or in- putative ECD parent formed a unique mix of alleles in all cipient colony does not, or cannot supply gyne-destined four putative hybrid lineages H1 / H2, J1 / J2. These re- eggs a n d brood with the elements needed to complete sults suggested that ancient hybridization had played either gyne programming (Fig. 3). Data from incipient lab colo- a dominant or subordinate role in the origin, transmission, nies shows that gyne-destined genotypes either die or de- or detection of GCD. However, more extensive geograph- velop poorly during the colony founding stage and are ic and molecular sampling confirmed that lineage J2 was often culled due to arrested development or worker recog- not of hybrid origin, but had a parental-like P. barbatus nition, most disappearing as either eggs or second-instar genome (HELMS CAHAN & KELLER 2003, ANDERSON & larvae (HELMS CAHAN & al. 2004, CLARK & al. 2006, al. 2006b, SCHWANDER & al. 2007a). This was enigmatic VOLNY & al. 2006). However, over 50 % of immature colo- because the genetic signatures of the other three lineages nies (6 - 12 months old) from one J1 / J2 lab population pro- (J1, H1, H2) revealed large contributions from both of the duced many worker-gyne intercastes (sensu HEINZE 1998) putative parental ECD species (HELMS CAHAN & KELLER associated with gyne-destined programming (Fig. 4). Over 2003, ANDERSON & al. 2006b, SCHWANDER & al. 2007a). a 6 month period, one of these lab colonies averaged only This suggested a non-hybrid origin for lineage J2 (ANDER- 14 workers, but produced 15 small intercastes which were SON & al. 2006b), or that the taxonomic units chosen to re- about half the size of field produced gynes. Most inter- present the putative ECD P. barbatus ancestor were in- castes were submissive to the queen, but in two different correct (HELMS CAHAN & al. 2006), or that the evolution colonies, intercastes repeated attacked and eventually killed of the J1 / J2 lineage pair was largely unassociated with the resident queen (Fig. 5). In another well-fed colony, a the evolution of H1 / H2 (SCHWANDER & al. 2007b). cohort consisting of four intercastes cannibalized their de- Hybridization and strong GCD: The causal link be- veloping sisters in what could only be described as a feed- tween hybridization and strong GCD remains unclear ing frenzy (ANDERSON 2006c). (HELMS CAHAN & KELLER 2003, LINKSVAYER & al. It is clear that one primary constraint on GCD colony 2006, ANDERSON & al. 2006b, SCHWANDER & al. 2007a, success is early and sustained worker production that relies b, ANDERSON & al. in press). At two geographic sites on the acquisition of worker-destined sperm stores. As lev- SCHWANDER (2007a) detected interspecific hybridization els of polyandry increase, common lineage queens have within the P. barbatus-rugosus group but found no evi- less colony founding success because they randomly mate dence of GCD. Similarly, a different Pogonomyrmex hy- with increasingly more males wielding gyne-destined brid zone containing two distantly related and highly poly- sperm. However, rare lineage queens randomly encounter androus species shows that some populations are com- more worker-destined sperm while simultaneously increas- posed entirely of hybrids. But while most workers in these ing their chances of encountering a male with gyne-des- colonies are F1 hybrids, the molecular data only hints at tined sperm. As detailed above, gyne-biased sperm stores weak GCD (ANDERSON & al. in press). However, hybridi- represent a nutritional load for the incipient colony be- zation is strongly associated with reproductive GCD in the cause resources are diverted to energetically expensive fire ant Solenopsis. In hybrid zones, pure S. xyloni offspring gyne-destined brood (CLARK & al. 2006). It was suggest- have seemingly lost the genetic potential to develop as ed that the advertisement of lineage (ASHE & OLDROYD workers such that the perpetuation of a non-hybrid germ 2002) or sperm recognition (HOSKEN & PITNICK 2003) line relies on males of S. geminata to generate the F1 hy- should evolve to compensate for the genetic load that would brid worker caste (HELMS CAHAN & VINSON 2003). result from a low mating frequency. Alternatively, evolv- The fact that hybrid dynamics differ for haplodiploid ing towards a higher mating frequency would promote and eusocial species may facilitate the evolution of strong lineage coexistence (YAMAUCHI & YAMAMURA 2006). GCD under hybridization. Under conditions of polyandry While two of the lineages (J1 / J2) have significantly dif- or polygyny, sterility and reductions in fecundity can be ferent hydrocarbon profiles (VONLY & al. 2006), the geno- easily averted from reproductive offspring and shunted into types of eggs produced by newly mated queens indicate workers (HELMS CAHAN & al. 2002, JULIAN & al. 2002, that queens mate randomly, there is no sperm recognition, HELMS CAHAN & VINSON 2003). If F1 inter-lineage geno- and that initial (egg) caste ratios produced within colonies

125 Fig. 4: Worker-gyne intercastes resulting from strong GCD in immature colonies of DL Pogonomyrmex. Alitrunk mor- phology resulting from intra-lineage genome expression. Photos are not to scale; alitrunks are shown at the same size to emphasize sclerite distinctions. (c) is an inter-lineage genome which produced a normal worker alitrunk, and (a) is a field caught intra-lineage queen. (b) and (d) are intra-lineage genomes nurtured by incipient lab colonies; both had abnormal wings that were removed prior to photography. Photos by K.E. Anderson. are primarily a function of relative lineage frequencies (VOLNY & GORDON 2002). The genetic elements neces- (HELMS CAHAN & al. 2004, CLARK & al. 2006, VOLNY & sary to produce a caste functional colony require the con- al. 2006). Thus negative frequency dependent selection on tinued interaction of two reproductively isolated gene pools. colony founding success is a major factor promoting line- Selection must act antagonistically to simultaneously main- age coexistence (HELMS CAHAN & al. 2004, ANDERSON & tain a viable inter-genome (worker caste) and two viable al. 2006a, SCHWANDER & al. 2006). By the same mecha- and fertile intra-genomes (reproductive caste of each line- nism, relative lineage frequencies and mating frequency age). Each intra-lineage genome reaps the first hand bene- will influence sex ratios following colony maturity (3 - 5 fits of recombination, and may evolve towards a co-ad- years), and the strength of balancing selection may deter- apted genome. However the effects of drift, selection, and mine a frequency threshold beyond which the potential for mutation accrue independently in each lineage which may rare lineage recovery decreases sharply as rare lineage col- result in negative epistasis in inter-lineage genomes (Fig. 6). onies that attain reproductive maturity show a marked de- Strong selection should preserve sets of genes that contri- crease in gyne production due to a lack of gyne-destined bute to colony level caste determination, such that many sperm. A mathematical consideration of these obvious life- of these interacting genes may become fixed in each line- history constraints indicates that DL systems may only per- age. This fixation may also produce a genetic load via back- sist under a narrow set of conditions, with convergence of ground selection (ANDERSON & al. 2006b), when inferior lineage frequencies towards 0.5 (YAMAUCHI & YAMAMU- genes linked to the caste network have a negative effect on RA 2006). overall development. Independent lineage trajectories: Analogous to the Genetic models for GCD origin: There have been four selection acting on sexually antagonistic alleles, the con- main genetic models proposed to explain the evolution of straint imposed on each reproductively isolated gene pool strong GCD found in the Pogonomyrmex dependent line- for the continued production of the worker caste may sub- age system. Briefly, the first suggests that a single locus de- stantially restrict the adaptive evolution of each lineage termines caste, such that homozygotes at this locus develop

126 Fig. 5: The behavioral cost of strong GCD in immature colonies. The resident queen (23 mg) being attacked by an inter- caste gyne (9 mg) which was produced by a 7 month old lab colony containing only 6 workers. The gyne sustained some wing damage, but eventually killed the queen. Photos by K.E. Anderson.

into gynes and heterozygotes develop into workers (VOL- NY & GORDON 2002). The next states that the dependent- lineage system arose due to recent hybridization between ECD P. barbatus and ECD P. rugosus, and GCD is the result of incompatibilities between two interacting nuclear loci brought together by inter-specific hybridization (HELMS CAHAN & KELLER 2003). Under this model, double hetero- zygote females retain bi-potency, but almost always devel- op into workers because double homozygote females are genetically predestined to develop into gynes and mono- polize colony resources, or otherwise prevent most hetero- zygotes from developing into gynes. This model provides a genetic mechanism for the origin of the system, but un- like previously thought, bipotency has been lost in both intra-lineage and inter-lineage crosses (HELMS CAHAN & al. 2004). A third model suggests that GCD may originate through mutation of a gene with a major influence on caste determi- nation, e.g., a repressor allele in the caste regulatory net- Fig. 6: Hypothesized dependent lineage co-evolution. The work (ANDERSON & al. 2006b). This model stresses the "V" represents the accrual of genetic divergence over time premise that developmental networks are highly conserved, due to differences in drift, mutation and selection experi- but network interruptions are evolutionary labile (ABOU- enced independently by each lineage (A and B). Each HEIF & WRAY 2002, GOODISMAN & al. 2008). In the hete- arm of the "V" contains patrilines (dotted) and matrilines rozygous state the mutant repressor allele generates a slight (solid). Diploid genome expression is "B" when plasticity propensity to become a queen. In the homozygous state remains for both workers and queens, "Q" when only this mutant allele precludes worker development and re- queens result and "W" when only workers result. Time from sults in a queen phenotype. Thus the allele behaves as a lineage isolation is represented by the length of vertical "selfish" genetic element because it biases its possessor to- arrow. Following isolation, lineage "B" becomes reliant on ward queen development, and thereby increases its repre- "A" for the production of a worker caste. Near the top, a sentation in the reproductive caste relative to other alleles. diploid genome combination becomes unable to produce a As the frequency of such a repressor increases, it would worker caste potentially resulting in inquiline parasitism result in strong selective pressure to retain an efficient caste or localized extinction of the DL system. repressor (or repression network) in the same population, potentially generating genome evolution analogous to a gen- eral modification / rescue system (WERREN 1997). One sta- mic (i.e., mitochondrial) and nuclear genes (LINKSVAYER ble resolution may be genome partitioning and the evolu- & al. 2006). Offspring with matching nuclear and mito- tion of dependent lineages seen in Pogonomyrmex (ANDER- chondrial genes, resulting from intra-lineage matings are SON & al. 2006b). biased to develop into gynes, while individuals with mis- The fourth model assumes that the ancestors of the matched nuclear / mitochondrial genes, resulting from inter- two dependent lineages diverged for interacting cytoplas- lineage matings develop only into workers. This model ex-

127 plains the maintenance of distinct mitochondrial lineages, held at very low frequency. As described above, polyan- and is also biologically compelling because queens likely dry may reduce this constraint because if a single male pas- require higher metabolic rates than workers (see EDER & al. ses on the caste-biasing allele, only a fraction of the off- 1983), so it makes sense that queens have coadapted com- spring produced by the colony will possess the allele. Thus, binations of mitochondrial and nuclear genes while wor- in polyandrous populations, caste-biasing alleles may reach kers have disrupted cyto-nuclear combinations (LINKSVA- a higher equilibrium frequency. Furthermore, in polyan- YER & al. 2006). drous populations, lineages of parasitic cheater genotypes A recent study shows that maternal effects influence that strongly bias caste may evolve (LINKSVAYER & al. caste in both ECD and GCD Pogonomyrmex populations 2006). The dependent lineage system may represent one sta- (SCHWANDER & al. 2008a). STRASSMANN & QUELLER ble result of two lineages with strong caste biasing geno- (2008) proposed that conflict between queens and develop- types that parasitize each other (ANDERSON & al. 2006b). ing larvae over caste fate explains the origin of strong GCD. In some cases, strong caste biasing parasites may lead to the Although not explicitly stated in their formulation, this evolution of workerless social parasites that rely on the model also involves epistasis, between maternal and lar- workforce of distinct host lineages (Fig. 6). In these cases, val genes. As queens transmit both their cytoplasm and mat- conflict occurs between interacting parasite and host line- ernal effects to their offspring, the maternal effect model ages, or lineages that are simultaneously both host and par- is very similar to the cyto-nuclear model and in some situ- asite in the case of the dependent lineage system (ANDER- ations can also lead to the maintenance of distinct mito- SON & al. 2006b, LINKSVAYER & al. 2006). When inter- chondrial lineages. STRASSMANN & QUELLER (2008) also breeding lineages are fixed for alternate biasing and re- describe a scenario of queen-larva conflict over caste fate storer alleles, hybridization may break up matching bias- for the evolution of weak to strong GCD, and below we ing / restorer complexes and reveal cryptic evidence of con- explain how this model complements previously proposed, flict (ANDERSON & al. 2006b, LINKSVAYER & al. 2006). and very similar scenarios (ANDERSON & al. 2006b, LINKS- Conclusions and perspectives VAYER & al. 2006). GCD systems reveal the genetic complexity hidden in the Weak to strong GCD, royal cheaters, and social para- reproductive modes of social organisms, from reproduc- sites tively isolated dependent lineages (as in Pogonomyrmex, Weakly caste-biasing nuclear genes ("royal cheater genes", see previous section), to male and female gene pools be- HUGHES & BOOMSMA 2008) may spread in a population ing nearly separate (as in Wasmannia, FOURNIER & al. but incur a cost at the colony level because colonies pro- 2004), to the inability of queens to produce new queens duce gynes at the expense of workers, required for colony (as recently described in a termite, HAYASHI & al. 2007), maintenance and growth (ANDERSON & al. 2006b, LINKS- and other unexpected situations (SUMNER & KELLER 2008). VAYER & al. 2006). These alleles may simply be held at As pointed out in recent reviews (KELLER 2007), caste low frequency or may spread, depending on the balance phenotypes resulting from GCD are probably far more of selection between selfish cheater genotypes and non- common than currently appreciated because our current biasing genotypes within colonies (Fig. 1), and selection knowledge reflects taxonomic research bias, and efficient between colonies for maximal colony survival and pro- techniques permitting molecular detection are relatively re- ductivity. If caste-biasing cheater alleles spread, restorer cent. GCD may be common because genetically hetero- mitochondrial or nuclear alleles may be favored and spread, geneous colonies are susceptible to cheaters and caste dif- removing the caste bias (ANDERSON & al. 2006b, LINKS- ferentiation involves a multitude of genes interacting at VAYER & al. 2006). Over the long term, populations may many levels, all of which are exposed to mutation, recom- cycle between caste-biasing nuclear genes that effectively bination, and drift followed by subsequent selection bias. are selfish cheater genes (favored by within-colony selec- Additionally, the evolution of GCD may be facilitated by tion between different offspring genotypes), and mitochon- conflict over reproduction and the selective benefits of drial or nuclear genes that remove the caste bias and are within-colony genetic diversity. favored by colony-level selection that maximizes colony Although many studies have identified genes and path- productivity (ANDERSON & al. 2006b, LINKSVAYER & al. ways expressed differently in queens and workers in spe- 2006). Such cycling can be described as antagonistic co- cies with ECD (GOODISMAN & al. 2008), little is known evolution or conflict. In theory such caste-biasing and re- of the functional genomics that underlie either weak or storer loci could include any sort of interacting loci, such strong GCD. Elucidating the proximate mechanisms re- as nuclear-nuclear or cyto-nuclear loci expressed within sponsible for GCD is an obvious next step for caste de- larvae, a locus expressed in queens and a locus expressed in termination research. Intuitive starting points are the met- larvae, or queen-worker loci (LINKSVAYER & WADE 2005, abolic pathways that translate nutrition into growth, for ANDERSON & al. 2006b, LINKSVAYER & al. 2006, LINKS- example the insulin signaling pathway, which is associ- VAYER 2007, 2008). STRASSMANN &QUELLER (2008) de- ated with the synthesis and release of juvenile hormone scribed how caste-biasing and restorer alleles may be ex- (WHEELER & al. 2006), and plays a diverse role in caste pressed in developing larvae and queens, respectively (i.e., determination (AMENT & al. 2008). However, we pre- queen-brood conflict). dict that there are many mechanisms biasing caste deter- In populations with colonies headed by single, singly- mination across social insect species; furthermore, as sug- mated queens, caste-biasing alleles transmitted from the gested by HUGHES & BOOMSMA (2008), genetic variation queen or her mate will be present in at least half of their for different mechanisms may occur even within a species. offspring. Any bias these alleles cause may strongly impact While even less well understood, variation for genes ex- colony productivity so that strongly-biasing alleles may be pressed in nestmate queens, workers, and brood may also

128 strongly influence caste trajectories of developing larvae AMENT, S.A., CORONA, M., POLLOCK, H.S. & ROBINSON, G.E. (LINKSVAYER 2006, 2007). Advances in molecular biol- 2008: Insulin signaling pathways are involved in the regula- ogy have already made medium to large scale sequencing tion of worker division of labor in honey bee colonies. – Pro- fast and cheap (e.g., TOTH & al. 2007) which makes the ceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United transition to more detailed studies of developmental gene States of America 105: 4226-4231. expression feasible for non-model species. In the foresee- ANDERSON, K.E., GADAU, J., MOTT, B.M., JOHNSON, R.A., AL- able future, the application of bioinformatics to caste deter- TAMIRANO, A., STREHL, C. & FEWELL, J.H. 2006b: Distribu- mining pathways may bring us a step closer to under- tion and evolution of genetic caste determination in Pogono- standing the molecular basis of social evolution. myrmex seed-harvester ants. – Ecology 87: 2171-2184. ANDERSON, K.E., GADAU, J., MOTT, B.M., JOHNSON, R.A., AL- Acknowledgements TAMIRANO, A., STREHL, C. & FEWELL, J.H. 2006c: Reproduc- This project was supported by NIH-IRACDA-PERT post- tive division of labor. – Bulletin of the Ecological Society of doctoral award to KEA, a NSF postdoctoral fellowship to America 87: 194-195. TAL, and a Graduate College Fellowship from the Univer- ANDERSON, K.E., HÖLLDOBLER, B., FEWELL, J.H., MOTT, B.M. sity of Illinois to CRS. The suggestions of Diana Wheeler & GADAU, J. 2006a: Population-wide lineage frequencies pre- and two anonymous reviewers improved the manuscript. dict genetic load in the seed-harvester ant Pogonomyrmex. – Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the Un- Zusammenfassung ited States of America 103: 13433-13438. In jüngster Zeit nahm die Erforschung der Genetik von ANDERSON, K.E., NOVAK, S.J. & SMITH, J.F. in press: Popula- Kastendetermination drastisch zu, insbesondere nach der tions composed entirely of hybrid colonies: Bidirectional hy- Entdeckung von Systemen mit starkem genetischem Ein- bridization and polyandry in harvester ants. – Biological Jour- fluss auf die Königinnen-Arbeiterinnen-Determination. In nal of the Linnean Society. diesem Übersichtsartikel stellen wir Forschungsergebnisse ASHE, A. & OLDROYD, B. 2002: Genetic determination of caste in zur genetischen Kastendetermination bei Ameisen zusam- harvester ants. – Trends in Ecology and Evolution 17: 448-449. men und interpretieren sie, auch im Zusammenhang mit BARGUM, K., BOOMSMA, J.J. & SUNDSTRÖM, L. 2004: A genetic der historischen Entwicklung dieser Forschungsrichtung component to size in queens of the ant, Formica truncorum. bei sozialen Insekten. Frühe Wissenschafter waren sich da- – Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 57: 9-16. rin uneinig, wie die relative Bedeutung der Umwelt wäh- BEYE, M., HASSELMANN, M., FONDRK, M.K., PAGE, R.E. & OM- rend der Aufzucht auf der einen und der Gene auf der HOLT, S.W. 2003: The gene csd is the primary signal for sex- anderen Seite für die Kastendetermination sei. In Folge ual development in the honeybee and encodes an SR-type pro- und bis vor kurzem hatte sich aber eine breite Unterstützung tein. – Cell 114: 419-429. für die Auffassung gefunden, dass die Umwelt ausschlag- BILLICK, I. 2002: The relationship between the distribution of wor- gebend sei, basierend auf theoretischen Überlegungen und ker sizes and new worker production in the ant Formica neo- empirischen Ergebnissen. Die zunehmende Verfügbarkeit rufibarbis. – Oecologia 132: 244-249. von molekularen Markern, zusammen mit Zuchtergebnis- BUSCHINGER, A. & SCHREIBER, M. 2002: Queen sen und anderen, quantitativ-genetischen Hinweisen, hat and queen-morph related facultative polygyny in the ant, Myr- jetzt ermöglicht, eine genetische Komponente in der Kas- mecina graminicola (Hymenoptera, Formicidae). – Insectes tendetermination bei zahlreichen Taxa sozialer Insekten Sociaux 49: 344-353. nachzuweisen. Die Stärke der genetischen Komponente CALDERONE, N.W. & PAGE, R.E. 1988: Genotypic variability in variiert und ist offensichtlich häufig stark von der Umwelt age polyethism and task specialization in the honey bee, Apis abhängig. In extremen Fällen wird die Kaste fast ausschließ- mellifera (Hymenoptera, Apidae). – Behavioral Ecology and lich vom Genotyp bestimmt. Wir fassen Umwelt- und ge- Sociobiology 22: 17-25. netische Einflüsse auf die Kastendetermination zusammen, CLARK, R.M., ANDERSON, K.E., GADAU, J. & FEWELL, J.H. einschließlich jüngster Nachweise von schwacher und star- 2006: Behavioral regulation of genetic caste determination in ker genetischer Kastendetermination und diskutieren die a Pogonomyrmex population with dependent lineages. – Ecol- Evolution dieser Systeme. Genotypen, die königinnenlas- ogy 87: 2201-2206. tige zahlenmäßige Verhältnisse der Kasten zueinander be- COLE, B.J. 1983: Multiple mating and the evolution of social be- dingen, werden häufig als Schwindler bezeichnet. Wir be- havior in the Hymenoptera. – Behavioral Ecology and Socio- tonen hier, dass die evolutive Dynamik von genetischer biology 12: 191-201. Kastendetermination die Koevolution (oft als Antagonis- mus) von Genen, die Königinnenlastigkeit bedingen, und CREEMERS, B., BILLEN, J. & GOBIN, B. 2003: Larval begging be- haviour in the ant Myrmica rubra. – Ethology Ecology and solchen, die die Zahlenverhältnisse wieder ausgleichen, Evolution 15: 261-272. in miteinander interagierenden Nestgenossen involviert. Die evolutive Bedeutung solcher Konflikte das Schicksal CROZIER, R.H. & FJERDINGSTAD, E.J. 2001: Polyandry in social von Kasten betreffend, bleibt ungeklärt, aber es könnte zu Hymenoptera: disunity in diversity? – Annales Zoologici Fen- weit verbreiteten Systemen untereinander abhängiger Li- nici 38: 267-285. nien, zu Spermienparasitismus und zu arbeiterinnenlosen CROZIER, R.H. &PAMILO, P. 1996: Evolution of social insect Sozialparasiten führen. colonies: Sex allocation and kin selection. – Oxford Univer- sity Press, Oxford, 306 pp. References DARWIN, C. 1859: On the origin of species by means of natural ABOUHEIF, E. &WRAY, G.A. 2002: Evolution of the gene net- selection. – Murray, London, 490 pp. work underlying wing polyphenism in ants. – Science 297: DEMENTEN, L., FOURNIER, D., BRENT, C., PASSERA, L., VARGO, 249-252. E.L. & ARON, S. 2005: Dual mechanism of queen influence ALEXANDER, R.D. 1974: The evolution of social behavior. – An- over sex ratio in the ant Pheidole pallidula. – Behavioral Ecol- nual Review of Ecology and Systematics 5: 325-383. ogy and Sociobiology 58: 527-533.

129 EDER, J., KREMER, J.P. & REMBOLD, H. 1983: Correlation of cyto- HELMS CAHAN, S. &KELLER, L. 2003: Complex hybrid origin of chrome c titer and respiration in Apis mellifera: adaptive re- genetic caste determination in harvester ants. – Nature 424: sponses to caste determination defines workers, intercastes 306-309. and queens. – Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology B 76: HELMS CAHAN, S.,PARKER, J.D.,RISSING, S.W.,JOHNSON, R.A., 703-716. POLONY, T.S.,WEISER, M.D. & SMITH, D.R. 2002: Extreme gen- ELMES, G.W. 1987: Temporal variation in colony populations etic differences between queens and workers in hybridizing of the ant Myrmica sulcinodis: II. Sexual production and sex Pogonomyrmex harvester ants. – Proceedings of the Royal So- ratios. – Journal of Ecology 56: 573-583. ciety of London B- Biological Sciences 269: 1871-1877. EVANS, J.D. & WHEELER, D.E. 1999: Differential gene expres- HELMS CAHAN, S. &VINSON, S.B. 2003: Reproductive division sion between developing queens and workers in the honey bee, of labor between hybrid and nonhybrid offspring in a fire ant Apis mellifera. – Proceedings of the National Academy of Sci- hybrid zone. – Evolution 57: 1562-1570. ences of the United States of America 96: 5575-5580. HÖLLDOBLER, B. &WILSON, E.O. 1990: The ants. – The Belknap FALCONER, D.S. & MACKAY, T.F.C. 1996: Introduction to quan- Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 732 pp. titative genetics. Edition 4. – Longmans Green, Harlow, Essex, UK, 464 pp. HORA, R.R., DOUMS, C., POTEAUX, C., FENERON, R., VALENZU- ELA, J., HEINZE, J. & FRESNEAU, D. 2005: Small queens in the FERSCH, R., BUSCHINGER, A. & HEINZE, J. 2000: Queen polymor- ant Ectatomma tuberculatum: a new case of social parasitism. phism in the Australian ant Monomorium sp.10. – Insectes – Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 59: 285-292. Sociaux 47: 280-284. HOSKEN, D.J. & PITNICK, S. 2003: Do queens select sperm? – FJERDINGSTAD, E.J. 2005: Control of body size of Lasius niger Trends in Ecology and Evolution 18: 107. ant sexuals – worker interests, genes and environment. – Mole- cular Ecology 14: 3123-3132. HUGHES, W.O.H. &BOOMSMA, J.J. 2007: Genetic polymorphism in leaf-cutting ants is phenotypically plastic. – Proceedings FJERDINGSTAD, E.J. & BOOMSMA, J.J. 1998: Multiple mating in- creases the sperm stores of Atta colombica leafcutter ant queens. of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences 274: 1625-1630. – Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 42: 257-261. HUGHES, W.O.H. & BOOMSMA, J.J. 2008: Genetic royal cheats in leaf-cutting ant societies. – Proceedings of the National FOURNIER, D.,ESTOUP, A.,ORIVEL, J.,FOUCAUD, J.,JOURDAN, H., LE BRETON, J. & KELLER, L. 2005: Clonal reproduction by Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 105: males and females in the little fire ant Wasmannia auropunc- 5150-5153. tata. – Nature 435: 1230-1234. HUGHES, W.O.H.,SUMNER, S.,VAN BORM, S. &BOOMSMA, J.J. FRASER, V.S.,KAUFMANN, B.,OLDROYD, B.P. &CROZIER, R.H. 2003: Worker caste polymorphism has a genetic basis in Acro- 2000: Genetic influence on caste in the ant Camponotus con- myrmex leaf-cutting ants. – Proceedings of the National Aca- sobrinus. – Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 47: 188-194. demy of Sciences of the United States of America 100: 9394- 9397. GADAGKAR, R. 2004: Sex ... only if really necessary in a femi- nine monarchy. – Science 306: 1964-1965. HUNT, G.J., AMDAM, G.V., SCHLIPALIUS, D., EMORE, C., SARDE- SAI, N., WILLIAMS, C.E., RUEPPELL, O., GUZMAN-NOVOA, E., GOODISMAN, M.A.D., KOVACS, J.L. & HUNT, B.G. 2008: Func- tional genetics and genomics in ants (Hymenoptera: Formi- ARECHAVALETA-VELASCO, M., CHANDRA, S., FONDRK, M.K., cidae): The interplay of genes and social life. – Myrmeco- BEYE, M. & PAGE, R.E. Jr. 2007: Behavioral genomics of logical News 11: 107-117. honeybee foraging and nest defense. – Naturwissenschaften 94: 247-267. GOTZEK, D. & ROSS, K.G. 2007: Genetic regulation of colony social organization in fire ants: an integrative overview. – Quar- JAFFE, R.,KRONAUER, D.J.C.,KRAUS, F.B.,BOOMSMA, J.J. & terly Review of Biology 82: 201-226. MORITZ, R.F.A. 2007: Worker caste determination in the army ant Eciton burchellii. – Biology Letters 3: 513-516. GREGG, R.E. 1942: The origin of castes in ants with special ref- erence to Pheidole morrisi FOREL. – Ecology 23: 295-308. JOHNSTON, A.B. & WILSON, E.O. 1985: Correlations of varia- tion in the major minor ratio of the ant Pheidole dentata (Hy- HANNONEN, M. & SUNDSTRÖM, L. 2003: Worker nepotism among menoptera, Formicidae). – Annals of the Entomological Soci- polygynous ants. – Nature 421: 910. ety of America 78: 8-11. HARTFELDER, K., MAKERT, G.R., JUDICE, C.C., PEREIRA, G.A.G., JULIAN, G.E. &FEWELL, J.H. 2004: Genetic variation and task SANTANA, W.C., DALLACQUA, R. & BITONDI, M.M.G. 2006: Physiological and genetic mechanisms underlying caste devel- specialization in the desert leaf-cutter ant, Acromyrmex versi- opment, reproduction and division of labor in stingless bees. color. – Animal Behaviour 68: 1-8. – Apidologie 37: 144-163. JULIAN, G.E.,FEWELL, J.H.,GADAU, J.,JOHNSON, R.A. &LARRA- HAYASHI, Y., LO, N., MIYATA, H. & KITADE, O. 2007: Sex-linked BEE, D. 2002: Genetic determination of the queen caste in an ant genetic influence on caste determination in a termite. – Sci- hybrid zone. – Proceedings of the National Academy of Sci- ence 318: 985-987. ences of the United States of America 99: 8157-8160. HEINZE, J. 1998: Intercastes, intermorphs, and ergatoid queens: JULIAN, G.E. & HELMS CAHAN, S. 2006: Behavioral differences who is who in ant reproduction? – Insectes Sociaux 45: 113-124. between Pogonomyrmex rugosus and dependent lineage (H1/ H2) harvester ants. – Ecology 87: 2207-2214. HEINZE, J. 2008: The demise of the standard ant (Hymenoptera: Formicidae). – Myrmecological News 11: 9-20. KAPTEIN, N., BILLEN, J. & GOBIN, B. 2005: Larval begging for food enhances reproductive options in the ponerine ant Gnamp- HELMS CAHAN, S.,JULIAN, G.E.,RISSING, S.W., SCHWANDER, T., togenys striatula. – Animal Behaviour 69: 293-299. PARKER, J.D. &KELLER, L. 2004: Loss of phenotypic plas- ticity generates genotype-caste association in harvester ants. KELLER, L. 2007: Uncovering the biodiversity of genetic and re- – Current Biology 14: 2277-2282. productive systems: Time for a more open approach. – Ame- HELMS CAHAN, S.,JULIAN, G.E.,SCHWANDER, T. &KELLER, L. rican Naturalist 169: 1-8. 2006: Reproductive isolation between Pogonomyrmex rugosus KELLER, L. & NONACS, P. 1993: The role of queen pheromones and two lineages with genetic caste determination. – Ecology in colonies of social insects: Queen control or queen signal? – 87: 2160-2170. Animal Behaviour 45: 787-794.

130 KERR, W.E. 1950: Genetic determinants of castes in the genus PASSERA, L. 1974: Differenciation des soldats chez la fourmi Phei- Melipona. – Genetics 35: 143-152. dole pallidula NYL. (Formicidae: Myrmicinae). – Insectes KRAUS, F.B., NEUMANN, P., VAN PRAAGH, J. & MORITZ, R.F.A. Sociaux 21: 71-86. 2004: Sperm limitation and the evolution of extreme polyan- PEARCY, M.,ARON, S.,DOUMS, C. &KELLER, L. 2004: Condi- dry in honeybees (Apis mellifera L.). – Behavioral Ecology and tional use of sex and parthenogenesis for worker and queen Sociobiology 55: 494-501. production in ants. – Science 306: 1780-1783. KRONAUER, D.J.C., JOHNSON, R.A. & BOOMSMA, J.J. 2007: The RATNIEKS, F.L.W. 2001: Heirs and spares: caste conflict and ex- evolution of multiple mating in army ants. – Evolution 61: cess queen production in Melipona bees. – Behavioral Ecology 413-422. and Sociobiology 50: 467-473. LATTORFF, H.M.G., MORITZ, R.F.A., CREWE, R.M. & SOLIGNAC, REUTER, M. & KELLER, L. 2001: Sex ratio conflict and worker M. 2007: Control of reproductive dominance by the thelytoky production in eusocial Hymenoptera. – American Naturalist gene in honeybees. – Biology Letters 3: 292-295. 158: 166-177. LE CONTE, Y. & HEFETZ, A. 2008: Primer pheromones in social RHEINDT, F.E., STREHL, C.P. & GADAU, J. 2005: A genetic compo- Hymenoptera. – Annual Review of Entomology 53: 523-542. nent in the determination of worker polymorphism in the Flo- LINKSVAYER, T.A. 2006: Direct, maternal, and sibsocial genetic rida harvester ant Pogonomyrmex badius. – Insectes Sociaux effects on individual and colony traits in an ant. – Evolution 52: 163-168. 60: 2552-2561. ROBINSON, G.E. & PAGE, R.E. Jr. 1988: Genetic determination of LINKSVAYER, T.A. 2007: Ant species differences determined by guarding and undertaking in honey-bee colonies. – Nature 333: epistasis between brood and worker genomes. – Public Library 356-358. of Science One 2: E994. RÜPPELL, O., PANKIW, T. & PAGE, R.E. Jr. 2004: Pleiotropy, epi- LINKSVAYER, T.A. 2008: Queen-worker-brood coadaptation rath- stasis and new QTL: The genetic architecture of honey bee er than conflict may drive colony resource allocation in the ant foraging behavior. – Journal of Heredity 95: 481-491. Temnothorax curvispinosus. – Behavioral Ecology and Socio- SCHWANDER, T., HELMS CAHAN, S. & KELLER, L. 2006: Genetic biology 62: 647-657. caste determination in Pogonomyrmex harvester ants imposes LINKSVAYER, T.A. & WADE, M.J. 2005: The evolutionary origin costs during colony founding. – Journal of Evolutionary Biol- and elaboration of sociality in the aculeate Hymenoptera: Mat- ogy 19: 402-409. ernal effects, sib-social effects, and heterochrony. – Quarterly SCHWANDER, T., HELMS CAHAN, S. & KELLER, L. 2007a: Char- Review of Biology 80: 317-336. acterization and distribution of Pogonomyrmex harvester ant LINKSVAYER, T.A., WADE, M.J. & GORDON, D.M. 2006: Genetic lineages with genetic caste determination. – Molecular Ecol- caste determination in harvester ants: possible origin and main- ogy 16: 367-387. tenance by cyto-nuclear epistasis. – Ecology 87: 2185-2193. SCHWANDER, T., HUMBERT, J., BRENT, C.S., HELMS CAHAN, S., MICHENER, C.D. 1974: The social behavior of the bees; a com- CHAPUIS, L., RENAI, E. & KELLER, L. 2008a: Maternal effect on parative study. – Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, female caste determination in a social insect. – Current Biol- Cambridge, MA, 404 pp. ogy 18: 265-269. MICHENER, C.D. & BROTHERS, D.J. 1974: Were workers of eu- SCHWANDER, T., KELLER, L. & HELMS CAHAN, S. 2007b: Two social Hymenoptera initially altruistic or oppressed? – Pro- alternate mechanisms contribute to the persistence of interde- ceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United pendent lineages in Pogonomyrmex harvester ants. – Mole- States of America 71: 671-674. cular Ecology 16: 3533-3543. MORITZ, R.F.A., LATTORFF, H.M.G., NEUMANN, P., KRAUS, F.B., SCHWANDER, T., ROSSET, H. & CHAPUISAT, M. 2005: Division of RADLOFF, S.E. & HEPBURN, H.R. 2005: Rare royal families in labor and worker size polymorphism in ant colonies: the im- honeybees, Apis mellifera. – Naturwissenschaften 92: 488-491. pact of social and genetic factors. – Behavioral Ecology and NONACS, P. 1986: Ant reproductive strategies and sex allocation Sociobiology 59: 215-221. theory. – Quarterly Review of Biology 61: 1-21. SCHWANDER, T., SUNI, S., HELMS CAHAN, S. & KELLER, L. NONACS, P. 2006: Interspecific hybridization in ants: at the in- 2008b: Mechanisms of reproductive isolation between an ant tersection of ecology, evolution, and behavior. – Ecology 87: species of hybrid origin and one of its parents. – Evolution doi: 2143-2147. 10.1111/j.1558-5646.2008.00387.x OHKAWARA, K., NAKAYAMA, M., SATOH, A., TRINDL, A. & SMITH, C.R. 2007: Energy use and allocation in the Florida har- HEINZE, J. 2006: Clonal reproduction and genetic caste differ- vester ant, Pogonomyrmex badius: are stored seeds a buffer? ences in a queen-polymorphic ant, Vollenhovia emeryi. – Biol- – Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 61: 1479-1487. ogy Letters 2: 359-363. SMITH, C.R., ANDERSON, K.E., TILLBERG, C.V., GADAU, J. & SU- OLDROYD, B.P. & FEWELL, J.H. 2007: Genetic diversity promotes AREZ, A.V. in press: Caste determination in a polymorphic so- homeostasis in insect colonies. – Trends in Ecology & Evolu- cial insect: nutritional, social and genetic factors. – American tion 22: 408-413. Naturalist. OSTER, G.F. & WILSON, E.O. 1978: Caste and ecology in the so- STRASSMANN, J.E. & QUELLER, D.C. 2008: Social evolution: ant cial insects. – Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 352 pp. eggs lacking totipotency. – Current Biology 18: R299-R301. PAGE, R.E. Jr., ROBINSON, G.E. & FONDRK, M.K. 1989: Genetic STUART, R.J. & PAGE, R.E. Jr. 1991: Genetic component to di- specialists, kin recognition and nepotism in honey-bee colo- vision of labor among workers of a leptothoracine ant. – Natur- nies. – Nature 338: 576-579. wissenschaften 78: 375-377. PARKER, J.D. 2004: A major evolutionary transition to more SUMNER, S., HUGHES, W.O.H., PEDERSEN, J.S. & BOOMSMA, J.J. than two sexes? – Trends in Ecology and Evolution 19: 2004: Ant parasite queens revert to mating singly. – Nature 83-86. 428: 35-36. PASSERA, L., RONCIN, E., KAUFMANN, B. & KELLER, L. 1996: In- SUMNER, S. & KELLER, L. 2008: Social evolution: Reincarnation, creased soldier production in ant colonies exposed to intra- free-riding and inexplicable modes of reproduction. – Current specific competition. – Nature 379: 630-631. Biology 18: R206-R207.

131 SUNI, S.S., GIGNOUX, C. & GORDON, D.M. 2007: Male parentage WESSON, L.G. 1940: An experimental study on caste determina- in dependent-lineage populations of the harvester ant Pogo- tion in ants. – Psyche 47: 105-111. nomyrmex barbatus. – Molecular Ecology 16: 5149-5155. WHEELER, D.E. 1986: Developmental and physiological determi- SUZZONI, J.P., PASSERA, L. & STRAMBI, A. 1980: Ecdysteroid titer nants of caste in social Hymenoptera: evolutionary implica- and caste determination in the ant Pheidole pallidula (NYL.) tions. – American Naturalist 128: 13-34. (Hymenoptera, Formicidae). – Experientia (Basle) 36: 1228- WHEELER, D.E. 1991: The developmental basis of worker caste 1229. polymorphism in ants. – American Naturalist 138: 1218-1238. TILLEY, C.A. & OLDROYD, B.P. 1997: Unequal subfamily pro- WHEELER, D.E., BUCK, N. & EVANS, J.D. 2006: Expression of in- portions among honey bee queen and worker brood. – Animal sulin pathway genes during the period of caste determination Behaviour 54: 1483-1490. in the honey bee, Apis mellifera. – Insect Molecular Biology TOTH, A.L.,VARALA, K.,NEWMAN, T.C.,MIGUEZ, F.E.,HUTCHI- 15: 597-602. SON, S.K.,WILLOUGHBY, D.A., SIMONS, J.F., EGHOLM, M., HUNT, WHEELER, D.E. & NIJHOUT, H.F. 1984: Soldier inhibition in the J.H., HUDSON, M.E. & ROBINSON, G.E. 2007: Wasp gene ex- ant Pheidole bicarinata: Inhibition of soldier development by pression supports an evolutionary link between maternal be- adult soldiers. – Journal of Insect Physiology 30: 127-135. havior and eusociality. – Science 318: 441-444. WHEELER, W.M. 1937: Mosaics and other anomalies among ants. TSCHINKEL, W.R. 1987: Relationship between ovariole number – Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 95 pp. and spermathecal sperm count in ant queens: a new allometry. – Annals of the Entomological Society of America 80: 208-211. WILFERT, L., GADAU, J. & SCHMID-HEMPEL, P. 2007: Variation in genomic recombination rates among animal taxa and the case UMPHREY, G.J. 2006: Sperm parasitism in ants: selection for in- of social insects. – Heredity 98: 189-197. terspecific mating and hybridization. – Ecology 87: 2148-2159. WILSON, E.O. 1971: The insect societies. – Belknap Press of Har- UMPHREY, G.J. & DANZMANN, R.G. 1998: Electrophoretic evid- ence for hybridization in the ant genus Acanthomyops (Hyme- vard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 548 pp. noptera: Formicidae). – Biochemical Systematics and Ecology WINTER, U. & BUSCHINGER, A. 1986: Genetically mediated queen 26: 431-440. polymorphism and caste determination in the slave-making ant, Harpagoxenus sublaevis (Hymenoptera, Formicidae). – Ento- VOLNY, V.P. &GORDON, D.M. 2002: Genetic basis for queen- worker dimorphism in a social insect. – Proceedings of the mologia Generalis 11: 125-137. National Academy of Sciences of the United States of Ame- WOYKE, J. 1962: Natural and artificial insemination of queen rica 99: 6108-6111. honeybees. – Bee World 43: 21-25. VOLNY, V.P.,GREENE, M.J. &GORDON, D.M. 2006: Brood pro- YAMAUCHI, A. & YAMAMURA, N. 2006: Persistence of symme- duction and lineage discrimination in the red harvester ant (Po- trical social hybridogenesis in haplodiploid Hymenoptera. – gonomyrmex barbatus). – Ecology 87: 2194-2200. Journal of Theoretical Biology 240: 24-31. WERREN, J.H. 1997: Biology of Wolbachia. – Annual Review of Entomology 42: 587-609.

132