format format IMRaD IMRaD Philip Abraham Philip Abraham K E M Hospital, Mumbai The The

P D National Hinduja Hospital and Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded – James Barrie Sir

IMRaD IMRaD Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) who has something to say just now, and the only man who does not know how to say it.” Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Why Why “The man of science appears to be the only person When and ” Why Who and and What Where and

How

--Child” Elephant’s “The (1865-1936). Kipling Rudyard Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded WWWHWAW WWWHWAW “I keep six honest serving-men (They taught me all I knew) Their names are And Introduction Methods Results and Discussion

I M R a D Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded What is IMRAD? What is IMRAD? Methods description (“theory ion of IMRaD format IMRaD of ion

–– experiment discussion”) formats coexisted subject) to according Organized as in book chapters (heading Origin of scientific papers scientific of Origin Letters and experimental (descriptive) Increasing Adopt Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded History 1665 1600s and 1700s 1800s (second half) 1900s (early) 1900s (second half) History

American National Standards Institute Absolute leadership of IMRaD IMRaD introduced as standard by Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded History in 1900s • Up to 1945• 1950 to 1960• After 1965 Titles as in book chapters • IMRaD structure partially adopted 1979 IMRaD to predominate began • 1980s History in 1900s tee of Medical Journal Editors

ional conferences on scientific on conferences ional Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow publishing recommended IMRaD by publishedfirst Group”) (“Vancouver guidelines hosted site a readers and facilitate from Downloaded Background • Considered ideal outline in early 1900s • Physics adopted IMRaD in 1950s • internat II, War World After • Late 1970s, International Commit • of Wide use IMRaD benefit to editors, to may credited be Background

adoption by major journals major by adoption adoption by major journals major by adoption Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded IMRaD IMRaD What did you find? What did you do? s questions s questions ’ ’ ethods esults iscussion What does it all mean? nd

ntroductionstart? you Whydid

I M R a D Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Bradford Hill Bradford Hill Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) … think I he’s asked good questions … but, you know what … Medknow you and I can find holes in his arguments come up with a by shocker … hosted site a from Downloaded What’s news, babe? You know that guy Rakesh … done a lot of work on hepatitis E Wow! … me more … tell keep singin’, babe Starting a conversation a Starting A: B: Starting a conversation a Starting A: Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Introduction • Brief and arresting • Define nature and scope of problem, but • Do not hide inconvenient facts Introduction in current state of knowledgeof state current in ferring to previous publications

liminary work and closely related Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site papers appearing elsewhere a from Downloaded evaluate present study without re Introduction • Define lacunae and shortcomings • Key references to support background information provided • Refer to your previous pre • Adequate information to allow reader understand and Introduction down down ” ” r than in previous studies funneling funneling “ “

– gap in knowledge did you try to fill? What –resolve? to try you did controversy What Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from oh, well, it’s already out in the ) Downloaded especially why these are bette (but this may take away “surprise” element … Introduction: • Provide rationale for current study •study of aim State • May briefly state study group, design and methods used, • state principal May result/conclusion Introduction: Should be reproducible by another group

The three questions • has been done? What • did you look for? What • How was it done? Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Methods Methods method; questionnaire; ; case questionnaire; method; ? ? (drug trial / intervention; prospective / retrospective; / prospective intervention; / trial (drug is the study about? study the is species)

–genus, specify studies, animal (in subjects control and Participants – Intervention –up Follow –measure Outcome Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for of sensitivity blinded; randomized, (www.medknow.com) meta-analysis) guidelines; Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Methods: details •design Study • Setting • Who •do you did What •for look you did What Methods: details under which intervention done calculation

– Lab settings – In-patient or real life Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from (Sections and subsections help) Downloaded Methods: details Methods: • Inclusion criteria • Exclusion criteria • Sample size • Circumstances • Consent • Ethicsclearance Methods: details Methods:

ils (sufficientils reproductionfor by Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) workers) other Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Methods: interventions and tests and interventions Methods: •givereference standard, If • If new or modified, provide deta • Timing and duration of intervention •manufacturer / kits / Equipment Methods: interventions and tests and interventions Methods: Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Methods: outcome measurement outcome Methods: • Define outcome • Parameters to assess outcome •values cut-off Endpoint, •any if events, Adverse Methods: outcome measurement outcome Methods:

– Per- vs. intention-to-treat Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) duration) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Follow up • method, duration (including minimum acceptable Frequency, •drop-out or termination for Criteria Follow up Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Statistical analysis • parameters different for used Methods • Software Statistical analysis Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Methods: general Methods: • Sub-headings should be consistent with those of Results • to avoid more than 3 levels of heading Try Methods: general Methods:

en text and tables / figures / tables and text en Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Results: general •find? you did What • Should answer all points raised in Methods • No new parameters • No mismatch in numbers betwe Results: general Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Results: participants • How many screened? • How many eligible? • How many recruited / excluded? •study? completed Howmany •completeness Reasons for lack of • Compliance with therapy / protocol All subjects should be accounted for Results: participants

(sample lost, incompletelost, study) (sample icant”, “very highly significant” highly “very icant”, Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a meaningless) from Downloaded Results: data presentation data Results: • Cause of incomplete data, if any • No repetition between text and tables • No interpretation • often..) some, (most, No adjectives • n>100 if Use % only • Restrict decimal points to 1 or 2 • Provide value (“highly p of signif Results: data presentation data Results: Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Discussion: outline • findings Recapitulation of major • Discussion of major findings in light of available data • Discussion of important minor findings • Alternative explanations • Strengths and limitations of study • Implicationsfindings of • Unanswered questions and future •conclusion/ Summary Discussion: outline Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Common mistakes: Introduction mistakes: Common Common mistakes: Introduction mistakes: Common • History starting from Adam • Details of previous studies • Aggrandizement •form full without Abbreviations • Details of Results and Conclusions • with Discussion Intermix Nature 1953;171:737-8 e salt of deoxyribose nucleic acid nucleic deoxyribose of salt e atures which are of considerable of are which atures

Watson JD, Crick FHC. A structure for deoxyribose nucleic acid. nucleic deoxyribose for structure A FHC. Crick JD, Watson Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded -- Good Introduction Good “We wish to suggest a structure for th for structure a suggest to wish “We fe novel has structure This (D.N.A.). biological importance.” Good Introduction Good

/ Results Tables Figures Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Common mistakes: Methods and Results and Methods mistakes: Common •up Mixed • 17-22) range 25, age mean (e.g., data in Errors • Methods in data of Mismatch • Misinterpretation of data Common mistakes: Methods and Results and Methods mistakes: Common

dia / Maharashtra…(megalomania) Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Common mistakes: Discussion •In / world the Firstin study • Repeating results • Emphasizing strengths of study over its weaknesses •findings Inflatingof importance • Going beyond evidence and drawing unjustified conclusions Common mistakes: Discussion 1985;11:27-30 J InfJ Sci specific information, which is -- Meadows. nt growth of information of growth nt

IMRaD IMRaD Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) consta to answer is article Medknow by section of article, looking for hosted normally found in pre-established areas of the paper site a from Downloaded Benefits of • Development and changes in internal organization of scientific • IMRaD structure facilitates modular reading • Readers usually do not read in linear way but browse in each Benefits of ch to put in or leave out or or out leave or in put to ch was gospel? was gospel? IMRaD IMRaD prints Methods last and in smaller type buries explanatory footnotes within reference list

editor referred to “…shaky pillars of IMRaD”of pillars “…shaky to referred editor Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a at aim to reader of level what from Downloaded projects free from accidents and human error Science Lancet Nature Medicine You thought thought You • IMRaD suggests perfectly planned and beautifully executed • IMRaD does not tell writer how mu • • • You thought thought You hey for; how to set them out? them set to how for; hey IMRaD IMRaD thanked; who paid; who has conflicts? ) )

Kipling Kipling

"authorship" mean; how many? How long; how many parts; declamatory (or not)? (or declamatory parts; many how long; How Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Sections not covered by (but covered by (but covered by Sections not covered by Title Authorship Who is Summary best defined in advance; what does Conclusion be should Who Acknowledgments What structure; where to place it; how long? Who needs one? References How many; what are t ditors, t al t E E esus, ournal J J oses, edical M M not

D

a

R

M

I onceived ommittee of C

C Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for mmaculately (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded nternational I I 2000;321:1428 -- J Med Br IMRaD IMRaD

(recommended for Quality Improvement Reports) (recommended for Quality Improvement Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded An alternative to to alternative An •context Brief description of • Outline problem of • Key measures for improvement • Process of gathering information • and interpretation Analysis •change for Strategy • change of Effects • steps Next An alternative to to alternative An Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Abide by Instructions, but Downloaded from a site hosted by Medknow (www.medknow.com) for free. for (www.medknow.com) Medknow by hosted site a from Downloaded Scientific communication need not be oh so boring! Abide by Instructions, but a little liberty is sometimes in ord er