Introduction Why has Greenpeace What criteria did we use to rank the The questionnaire deals with a variety of issues, including positioning towards the outcomes of the RSPO GHG Working Group, and the Existing initiatives to try and break the link between produced this Scorecard? producers? transparency of HCV assessments. Greenpeace has selected three deforestation and palm oil are not yet achieving this result. The Palm Oil Producers Scorecard gives an overview of Greenpeace has ranked some of world’s main palm oil producers topics as clear indicators of the existing progressive behaviour of If the expansion in the production of palm oil continues, GREENPEACE where palm oil producers stand based on a Greenpeace based on three main criteria: Commitment to stopping these companies: a policy to stop deforestation, a policy to stop without further environmental protection measures, it review of the steps some of the world’s biggest palm deforestation, a policy on no development on peatland, and developments on ALL peatlands, and the percentage of palm will result in the further destruction of large parts of oil producers have taken so far to limit their impact on percentage of RSPO certified production. oil products that is produced under RSPO certification. SCORECARD ON PALM Indonesia’s last remaining forests and peatlands. This will forests and peatlands. Greenpeace is providing the latest Greenpeace selected eleven of the world’s major palm oil producers If a company has taken some measures to protect peatlands, deprive forest communities of their livelihood and culture, information on the policies of palm oil producers so based on a combination of annual crude palm oil (CPO) production regardless of depth, they score a small tick. Only policies that commit cause even greater loss of biodiversity, and release even that consumer companies can take these into account and industry best practices. Following this, Greenpeace produced the company to fully stopping deforestation score a full tick, not OIL PRODUCERS - more greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. when they purchase palm oil. It is important to note that a questionnaire for those companies to fill in. Based on publicly policies that would protect certain designated forest areas, like HCVF Greenpeace is calling on palm oil producers and this Scorecard provides a review of the policies these available information, Greenpeace already provided answers for or other protected areas. If two companies have the same score, the consumers to work together to finally break the link Full Table of Company producers have put in place, and does not necessarily companies to review, verify and amend. The companies were also company with the largest production is ranked higher. between palm oil expansion and deforestation. This can be reflect operations on the ground. asked for additional information where needed. The producers mainly achieved by strengthening forest and peatland protection come from Indonesia and Malaysia, but also include Agropalma commitments and putting them into action. Responses (Brazil) and NBPOL (Papua New Guinea) as examples of current best practices.

If there was an additional Share If “Yes”, If there was Have you been Does your company requirement Annual Annual of RSPO Does your company does your Will your company an additional If your palm oil Area of conducting HCV Does your If “Yes”, does support the RSPO GHG of a carbon Crude Palm Share of certified CPO Publicly available have a policy on company adopt a forest requirement of a expansion plans extend palm oil Does your company assessments company have your company WG2 recommendation threshold Name of Palm Oil Kernel Global CPO RSPO compared to RSPO certification plan High Carbon Who conducts your HCV natural forest require policy that NO-peatland policy beyond Indonesia or concessions require suppliers’ HCV prior to new a policy on full require the same on the expansion of new for palm oil Company (CPO) Oil (CKO) production Membership company’s for all subsidiaries Value (HCV) Assessments? protection and the same protects High for new expansion, Malaysia, will your held 2011 assessments? planting and protection of policy from your plantations to low carbon production, production production (2011)5 total CPO assessment ? conservation (not policy Carbon Stock would your company above positions and (by country) development peatlands? suppliers? stock land (degraded) and would your (2011) (2011) production just primary forest)? from your forest areas? implement this policies apply globally? since 2005? avoiding peatlands? company in 2011 suppliers? voluntarily ? implement this voluntarily? Yes, our company is has already committed to this. Agropalma Group plantations From the start of 2012 the first 51,000 ha (planted If is technically Al though we have no have been RSPO certified since HCV assessmentsof potential There is no peatland in Complies with Brazilian law area) For own plantations, well elaborated, peatland in our landstock August 2011. By August 2014, Agroplama smallholder supplier Agropalma lands. The and since 2001 deforestation Two subsidiaries are 83,86% All information is since 2008. For economically in the Amazon, if our Operations in Brazil only at this Agropalma 160,000 mt3 13,500 mt4 0.3% smallholders and the rest of the lands began. The assessments Arthur Wieczorek and Miguel Vieira company made a public Yes. in all kinds of forests Yes. Yes. Yes. 1 4,000 ha RSPO members publicly available. smallholders, since feasible and practical company, wants to expand stage but otherwise Yes. Brazil 10% also Organic supply chain will also be certified. are in line with RSPO New commitment at RSPO (primary or secondary) has under organic 2012. implemented, to other countries, any new There is a project in place to Planting Procedures and are Round Table 7. been banned. production2 company would adopt. developments of oil palms will achieve this target. publicly available. set aside peat areas wherever they are located. 78,332 ha (planted PK: Yes for forests identified as area) Yes – no planting on Yes all smallholders have All obtained from the RSPO approved HCV. In addition NBPOL is Yes on peatlands . NBPOL is in the Not at present. NBPOL New Britain 100,655 mt peat – and a public Still undergoing research Group membership of appropriate assessments – list of HCV practitioners – Lewie Dekker, All smallholders covered working on HCS assessments process of identifying low carbon does not feel that Yes. NBPOL has one uniform 95,334 ha (total 551,657 mt8 1.1% 61.53% Full RSPO certification in 2012 Yes Yes statement with the Yes on what this means in the Yes Palm Oil Ltd RSPO 100% of the supply base is Guy Williams, John Douglas are the by this policy to define HCS forests through stock land in relation to the PNG the current threshold approach land area) – producers from the PNG landscape 6 PKO: covered. main ones. a no net loss of carbon landscape suggested is realistic (NBPOL) includes sugar and ROW 9 approach. cattle7 39,820 mt Yes. As part of its FCP, GAR’s FCP focuses on no GAR is committed to development on land with high conserving HCS forest HCV assessments have carbon stock (HCS), including no areas. Upon gathering Parent company No. GAR’s FCP focuses 15.62% Note: been conducted since planting on peat land regardless of the required input (GAR) and 2 RSPO-approved HCV assessors: Yes. This is covered on its operations As part of its HCS Yes. GAR’s FCP applies to all the Golden Agri Based on RSPO GAR plans to obtain certification late 2008 Yes. GAR’s FCP seeks to No. Please see depth and HCS forest areas. Upon and feedback from all subsidiaries (PT – third-party assessors or in GAR’s Forest and applies to all the Forest Study, GAR will plantations that it owns, manages 455,660 ha11 2,152,809 mt12 487,298 mt13 4.3% certified CPO for its existing units (as of 30 June Available on request No information - RSPO New Planting conserve High Carbon Stock response to gathering the required input and stakeholders, GAR intends Yes. It is part of GAR’s FCP. Resources SMART Tbk and PT – self-assessment and peer reviewed by Conservation Policy plantations that it owns, announce its action or invests in regardless of the production as at 2010) by end 2015 Procedure was adopted (HCS) forests. Question 14. feedback from all stakeholders, GAR to develop its action plans 10 IMT) are members of third parties (FCP) manages or invests in plan in due course stake. Ltd (GAR) June 2012 in January 2010 intends to develop its action plans for how it will proceed RSPO regardless of the stake. for how it will proceed further with further with its HCS its HCS forest methodology and will forest methodology and announce this in due course. will announce this in due course. 58,934 ha Total CSPO & PK Yes. We will identify (Malaysia) 2010: produced from It is hard to agree to the high carbon stock Wilmar 221,490 ha 1,597,890 mt 14 certified mills: Time-bound plan for completion of Yes, according to EIA something which is Our policies will apply to those Available only with Non- Yes, with effect from area qualitatively (Indonesia, incl -17 3.5% Yes 550,660 mt and certification audits for all mills and - Yes Third parties - and HCV assessors’ - Yes. still unknown. What Yes operations in which we have International Disclosure Agreement. Oct 2012 through a thorough HCV plasma small- 2011: 118, 352 mt plantations by 2016. recommendations is the additional more than 50% interest. 14 assessment conducted by Limited holders)15 1,778,882 mt16 respectively. requirement? a credible consultant. 30.95% Time-bound plans for full 7 Subsidiaries are Musim Mas 87,480 Ha19 1,007,061 mt20 391,375 mt21 1.2% 64.68%23 certification for all mills up to Not available25 - No26 Third parties27 Yes partially28 No information No29 - No information No information No information No information No information 18 RSPO members22 Group 201224

Yes, except 2005 to Yes, SDP has its Three subsidiary RSPO Certification Status as at September 2009 in Sustainability Management companies are RSPO June 2012 (by Country): Indonesia. Systems and Standards SDP will adhere to all regulations Malaysia : 314,035 members: a. Malaysia – 100% certified. Yes. SDP is committed – guidelines to conserve that are relevant to new plantings. SDP will adhere to ha - b. Indonesia – 82% certified We are currently Preliminary Assessment by Internal to adhere to the New natural forest and wildlife. As you are aware the definition of Sime Darby all regulations and Indonesia : Plantations [balance 4 Strategic Units discussing an HCV Assessors and Official Assessment by Planting Procedure and And SDP is committed and "low carbon stock" land is still being Yes, our commitments encompass 2,446,692 mt32 550,326 mt33 4.8% 83% Available upon request Not applicable. Not applicable Eventually, yes. Yes policies adopted by Yes, see response in item 13. Plantation 207,889 ha - Sime Darby (mills & estates) are awaiting remediation project with Independent Assessors recognized by Principles & Criteria of complies with RSPO New discussed by multi-stakeholder all our operations. the jurisdictions within 30 Total : 521,924 Unimills certification. the RSPO Secretariat. RSPO Secretariat the RSPO on peatland Planting Procedure and groups. SDP's position on peatland Sdn Bhd which we operate. ha31 - Morakot Industries Certification The status and findings cultivation. all other environmental plantings is as stated in point 13 Public Company Assessment for the 4 Strategic of the project will regulations worldwide in above. Limited. Units completed]. be presented at the all the areas wherein we forthcoming RT10. operate.

Adhere to Malaysia and Indonesia national guidelines. NB: almost Malaysia : all of our estates Only for Primary Forest or 148,966 ha NPP and CB’s Yes; after 2005, the are established in IOI Time-bound plans for full Forestry Reserves set out Indonesia : Group membership of Notification and Report 1st development and Various third parties, recognised by HCV Peninsular Malaysia As per RSPO As per RSPO As per RSPO 686,917 mt36 165,701 mt37 1.4% 55.01% certification for all 12 mills under As per RSPO requirements No by national initiatives; and No In line with RSPO recommendations Currently not relevant for IOI. Corporation 8,059 ha RSPO Summary are published planting only in 2009 in Network and Sabah, where recommendations recommendations recommendations the group by 2013 following RSPO requirements 34 Total : 157,045 on RSPO website Indonesia peatlands are known Bhd on HCV. ha35 to be much more scarce and shallower than in Sarawak and Kalimantan. 686,075 MT 1.4% This covers the N/A Includes the production of Asian Agri HCV assessments 100,000 ha production of PT. IIS owned subsidiary PT. for our estates have All HCV assessment audits are We purchase The definition and company estates PT. IIS owned Asian Agri subsidiary HCV assessments have We purchase Fresh Fruit Management of Planting on peatland refers to Ministry estates as Inti Indosawit been conducted and connducted by RSPO accredited HCV We purchase FFBs from Forest protection refers FFBs from Forest protection refers determination of Planting on peatland refers 60,000 ha estates as PT. IIS has been an Time-bound plans for full been conducted in our Bunches (FFBs) from peatland corresponds of Agriculture regulations. The PT. IIS only currently operates in 38 well as the Subur (PT. 29.98% completed prior to assessors. Upon audit, HCV assessment smallholders to produce to the Ministry of Forestry smallholders to to the Ministry of Forestry carbon threshold is to Ministry of Agriculture Asian Agri smallholders well as the RSPO member since certification for 19 mills by 2018 estates and are publicly smallholders to produce palm to the Ministry of definition of low carbon stock land in Sumatra. smallholders IIS) does new planting and report will be reviewed by an palm oil regulations produce palm regulations still under ongoing regulations estates39 smallholder February 2006 available oil Agriculture regulations RSPO is still in process. estates (Plasma not own any development from 2005 independent third party. oil process. estates & KKPA onwards. (Plasma & scheme).40 Crushing Plant KKPA scheme).

HCV Assessment for We are cooperating with Forestry Riau plantations is Department, Bogor Agricultural Institute 216,837 ha publicly available and to assess HCV. Members of the (Planted area – public consultation on HCV Assessement assessment team are: No, although where Indofood Nucleus) Time-bound plans for full HCV Assessment was conducted for 1. Ir. H. Nyoto Santoso, MS We agree and support the adoption We will adopt the they are identified as We would consider We have adopted a no We will follow the RSPO process 2 Subsidiaries are certification for all mills under PT conducted in Rokan Hilir concessions in Riau 2. Ir. Siswoyo, M.Si of the RSPO GHG WG2 on the Principles and Criteria Agri 838,000 mt43 195,000 mt44 1.7% 23.27% No HCV we have a policy - No - depending on the peatland policy in line with for certification on all our oil palm 85,719 ha RSPO members London Sumatera Tbk and PT SIMP in February 2011 province but we haven’t 3. Ir. Heru B Pulonggono, M.Sc expansion of new plantations on low of the RSPO and ISPO Resources on protection in line requirements. Indonesian regulations. plantations. (Oil Palm and Tbk & Subsidiaries up by 2016 had any new planting 4. Handian Purwawangsa, S. Hut, M. Si. carbon stock land. certifications 41 with all HCV areas. Ltd Rubber Plasma)42 HCV assessment for program since 2005. 5. Dr. Mirza Dikari Kusrini Lonsum plantationsalso 6. Ahmad Faisal Siregar, S. Hut publicly available. 7. Sutopo, S. Hut M. Syaidina Ali, Amd PT. Astra Agro Lestari 266,706 ha46 1,268,196 mt47 25,267 mt48 2.5% None None None Available on request49 No information No information No information No50 - No - No information No information No information No information No information Tbk45

PK : 91,000 PT Darmex mt/year Suspended in 2011, Agro (Duta 155,000 ha53 432,000 mt54 0.90% suspension lifted in No Information No Information No Information No Information No Information No Information No - No - No Information No Information No Information No Information No Information 56 Palma)52 PKO : 270 mt/ 2012 day55

Acronym : Reference: CB : Certification Body 1. Agropalma Brazil replied to Greenpeace’s email and 9. New Britain Palm Oil Limited (2012) annual report 16. Wilmar (2012) sustainability report 2011 : 20. Musim Mas Group did not provide information on 22. Musim Mas Group membership status from RSPO 28. On meeting with Greenpeace, June 4th 2011 and 37. IOI (2011) annual report 2011 : 47. Astra Agro (2012) annual report 2011 : 55. PT. Darmex Agro website stated PT. Darmex Agro CPO : Crude Palm Oil returned the completed questionnaire on October 2011 : http://www.wilmar-international.com/sustainability/ CPO total production. This number is estimated website: PT Musim Mas, PT Berkat Sawit Sejati, email on October 20th 2011 Musim Mas stated http://www.ioigroup.com/Investor/ioicorp/2011_ http://www.astra-agro.co.id/images/stories/Article/ with its subsidiaries produced 91,000 MT of Palm CSPO : Certified Sustainable Palm Oil 5th 2012. http://www.nbpol.com.pg/wp-content/uploads/ resources/Wilmar%20SR%202011%20-%20FINAL. from Musim Mas’s subsidiaries(PT Musim Mas, PT Unggul Lestari, PT Inti Benua Perkasatama, that they now have a NO peat policy for new AR.pdf AnnualReport11.pdf Kernel annually and produce around 270 tons of EIA : Environment Impact Assessment 2. On the Agropalma Brazil website, the company downloads/2012/04/New-Britain-Palm-Oil-Limited- pdf PT Berkat Sawit Sejati, PT Agrowiratama, PT. PT Agrowiratama, PT Wira Inno Mas, PT. Mentari plantings. It’s on the NPP public summary for PT 38. Asian Agri replied to Greenpeace’s email and 48. Astra Agro (2012) annual report 2011 : per day FCP : Forest Conservation Policy stated that they own 39,000 hectares of plantation. NBPOL-AR-2011-FINAL.pdf 17. Wimar answer – for PKO production, In Wilmar Unggul Lestari, PT. Mentari Pratama) on annual Pratama Agrowiratama in Sambas, West Kalimantan - http:// returned the completed questionnaire on October http://www.astra-agro.co.id/images/stories/Article/ http://www.darmexagro.com/index. FFB : Fresh Fruit Bunch http://www.agropalma.com.br/eng/agropalma.asp In annual communications of progress report to sustainability report 2011, they only provide communications of progress report to RSPO for 23. Using the RSPO ACOP 2011/2012, Musim Mas www.rspo.org/?q=page/1843. But Musim Mas 2nd 2012. AnnualReport11.pdf php?option=com_content&task=view&id=40&Item GAR : Golden Agri Resources RSPO for 2011/2012,NBPOL stated that Annual PKO information about Palm Kernel production (413,554 2011/2012 Group certified CPO (PT Musim Mas, PT Berkat reluctant to send the policy (letter from Director of id=65 GHG : Green House Gases 3. Agropalma Brazil annual communications of 39. Asian Agri Website 49. Meeting with Greenpeace, June 16th 2011 89,245 mt mt) http://www.rspo.org/file/ACOP2012-OM_GRW%20 Sawit Sejati, PT Agrowiratama, PT. Unggul Lestari, Strategic and Planning No. Dir. Of S&P/001/XII/2010 56. RSPO website accessed on March 12, 2012 ha : Hectare progress report to RSPO for 2011/2012 http://www.asianagri.com/index.php http://www.rspo.org/sites/default/files/ACOP2012_ http://www.wilmar-international.com/sustainability/ Submitters(3).pdf PT. Mentari Pratama) dated 16th December 2010) to us and still not made 50. Meeting with Greenpeace, June 24th 2011 http://www.rspo.org/gc/2935 HCS : High Carbon Stock http://www.rspo.org/file/ACOP2012-OM_GRW%20 GRW_1-0016-04-000-00-47.pdf resources/Wilmar%20SR%202011%20-%20FINAL. Last reported CPO production projection for other http://www.rspo.org/file/ACOP2012-OM_GRW%20 public, we therefor listed “Yes, partially to this. 40. In annual communications of progress report to 51. Meeting with Greenpeace, June 16th 2011 HCV : High Conservation Value Submitters(3).pdf 57. Did not respond to Greenpeace emails and please 10. GAR replied to Greenpeace’s email and returned the pdf subsidiaries (PT Siringo-Ringo, PT Sinar Agro Raya, Submitters(3).pdf 29. Meeting with Greenpeace, June 4th 2011 RSPO for 2010/2011, PT Inti Indosawit Subur the mt : Metric Ton 52. Darmex Agro did not respond to Greenpeace emails. see “How The Palm Oil Industry Cooking The 4. In annual communications of progress report to completed questionnaire on August 23rd 2012. PT Bahana Nusa Interindo, PT Indo Makmur Sawit) flagship company of Asian Agri Group Annual CPO NBPOL : New Britain Palm Oil Limited RSPO for 2011/2012, Agropalma Brazil stated that 18. Musim Mas did not completed questionnaire, only was in 2008 by company’s certification body 24. Meeting with Greenpeace, June 4th 2011 30. Sime Darby replied to Greenpeace’s email and production is 962,476 53. Darmex Agro stated total planted area as of 2009: Planet, 2007” Greenpeace International report on NPP : New Planting Procedure Annual PKO production is 28,324 mt 11. GAR (2012) annual report 2011 : referred Greenpeace to RSPO website. http://rspo.org/files/resource_centre/ 25. Meeting with Greenpeace, June 4th 2011 returned the completed questionnaire on September http://www.rspo.org/sites/default/files/ACOP%20 155,000 Ha Duta Palma clearing deep peatlands. PNG : Papua New Guinea http://www.goldenagri.com.sg/pdfs/Annual%20 3rd 2012. http://www.rspo.org/file/ACOP2012-OM_GRW%20 19. Musim Mas Group did not provide information on RSPOINFORMMM2.pdf 26. Musim Mas has subsidiaries which have 2011-PT%20Inti%20Indosawit%20Subur_2011.pdf http://www.darmexagro. 58. Did not respond to Greenpeace emails and please PK : Palm Kernel Report/GAR_AnnualReport2011.pdf Submitters(3).pdf Oil Palm concession size. This number is estimated 21. Musim Mas Group did not provide information on already been operating without completed HCV 31. Sime Darby (2011) annual report 2011 : 41. Indofood Agri replied to Greenpeace’s email and com/index.php?option=com_ see Greenpeace analysis: Duta Palma concession PKO : Palm Kernel Oil 5. Global palm oil production in 2011 reported 12. GAR (2012) annual report 2011 : from Musim Mas Group’s subsidiaries(PT Musim PKO total production. This number is estimated assessments. PT Globalindo Alam Perkasa (GAP) http://www.simedarby.com/downloads/pdfs/SDB/ returned the completed questionnaire on August content&task=view&id=6&Itemid=8 maps overlapped tiger habitat PT. IMT : PT. Ivo Mas Tunggal 50,518,000 Mt http://www.goldenagri.com.sg/pdfs/Annual%20 Mas, PT Berkat Sawit Sejati, PT Agrowiratama, PT. from Musim Mas’s subsidiaries (PT Musim Mas, only completed a full HCV assessment on March Annual_Report/Sime_Darby_AR2011.pdf 10th 2012 In annual communications of progress report to (WWF report: Sanderson, E., J. Forrest, C. Loucks, PT. ISS : PT. Inti Indosawit Subur Based on Oil World Data Base June 2012 by ISTA Report/GAR_AnnualReport2011.pdf Unggul Lestari, PT. Mentari Pratama) on annual PT Berkat Sawit Sejati, PT Agrowiratama, PT. 2011. See executive summary of company’s HCV 32. Sime Darby (2011) annual report 2011 : RSPO for 2010/2011, Darmex Agro stated that the J. Ginsberg, E. Dinerstein, J. Seidensticker, P. PT. SIMP : PT. Salim Ivomas Pratama 42. Indofood Agri (2012) annual report 2011 : Mielke GmbH 13. GAR (2012) annual report 2011 : communications of progress report to RSPO for Unggul Lestari, PT. Mentari Pratama)on annual assessment in http://www.gaiacommoditas.com/ http://www.simedarby.com/downloads/pdfs/SDB/ company’s oil palm concession size is 6,244.59 Ha Leimgruber, M. Songer, A. Heydlauff, T. O’Brien,G. ROW : Rest Of World http://indofoodagri.listedcompany.com/misc/ar2011. http://www.goldenagri.com.sg/pdfs/Annual%20 2011/2012 communications of progress report to RSPO for WP/?page_id=347&lang=id. Annual_Report/Sime_Darby_AR2011.pdf http://www.rspo.org/sites/default/files/ACOp%20 Bryja, S. Klenzendorf and E. Wikramanayake. 2006. RSPO : Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil 6. NBPOL replied to Greenpeace’s email and returned pdf Report/GAR_AnnualReport2011.pdf http://www.rspo.org/file/ACOP2012-OM_GRW%20 2011/2012 While PT Maju Aneka Sawit (MAS) and PT Unggul 2011%20-%20PT%20Darmex%20Agro.pdf Setting Priorities for the Conservation and RT 10 : 10th Annual Roundtable Meeting On Sustainable Palm Oil the completed questionnaire on October 12th 2012. 33. Sime Darby (2011) annual report 2011 : Submitters(3).pdf http://www.rspo.org/file/ACOP2012-OM_GRW%20 Lestari (UL) only started HCV assessment at 43. Indofood Agri (2012) annual report 2011 : 54. PT. Darmex Agro website stated that total Recovery of Wild Tigers: 2005-2015.The Technical RT 7 : 7th Annual Roundtable Meeting on Sustainable Palm Oil 14. Wilmar replied to Greenpeace’s email and returned http://www.simedarby.com/downloads/pdfs/SDB/ 7. New Britain Palm Oil Limited (2012) annual report Last reported planted area for other subsidiaries (PT Submitters(3).pdf least in March 2009. See company’s HCV assessor http://indofoodagri.listedcompany.com/misc/ar2011. production of Crude Palm Oil (CPO) is around Assessment. WCS, WWF, Smithsonian, and NFWF- SDP : Sime Darby Plantation the completed questionnaire on October 10th 2012. Annual_Report/Sime_Darby_AR2011.pdf 2011 : Siringo-Ringo, PT Sinar Agro Raya, PT Bahana Nusa Last reported PKO production projection for other correspondence with local NGO. http://nordin- pdf 36,000 Mt each month STF, New York – Washington, D.C.) WG GHG2 : RSPO 2nd Working Group Green House Gas http://www.nbpol.com.pg/wp-content/uploads/ 15. In Wilmar annual report 2011, Companies Oil Palm Interindo, PT Indo Makmur Sawit) was in 2008 by subsidiaries (PT Siringo-Ringo, PT Sinar Agro Raya, journal.blogspot.com/2008/12/konflik-pt-ssm- 34. IOI replied to Greenpeace’s email and returned the 44. Indofood Agri (2012) annual report 2011 : http://www.darmexagro. downloads/2012/04/New-Britain-Palm-Oil-Limited- concession size is 247,081 Ha company’s certification body PT Bahana Nusa Interindo, PT Indo Makmur Sawit) musim-mas-group-dan.html?zx=4ecc6827a2d691d9. completed questionnaire on September 18th 2012. http://indofoodagri.listedcompany.com/misc/ar2011. com/index.php?option=com_ NBPOL-AR-2011-FINAL.pdf http://www.wilmar-international.com/sustainability/ http://rspo.org/files/resource_centre/ was in 2008 by company’s certification body 35. IOI (2011) annual report 2011 : pdf content&task=view&id=1&Itemid=2 resources/Wilmar%20SR%202011%20-%20FINAL. RSPOINFORMMM2.pdf 27. Gaia commoditas is among Musim Mas’s HCV 8. New Britain Palm Oil Limited (2012) annual report http://rspo.org/files/resource_centre/ assessors. http://www.ioigroup.com/Investor/ioicorp/2011_ 45. Astra Agro did not respond to Greenpeace emails. 2011 : pdf RSPOINFORMMM2.pdf AR.pdf http://www.gaiacommoditas.com/WP/?page_ 46. Astra Agro (2012) annual report 2011 : http://www.nbpol.com.pg/wp-content/uploads/ id=347&lang=id 36. IOI (2011) annual report 2011 : downloads/2012/04/New-Britain-Palm-Oil-Limited- http://www.astra-agro.co.id/images/stories/Article/ http://www.ioigroup.com/Investor/ioicorp/2011_ AnnualReport11.pdf NBPOL-AR-2011-FINAL.pdf AR.pdf