The Institute for Medical and Twin Studies, Rome, Italy

CHRONOGENETICS

Its Foundations, Scope, and Impact *

L. GEDDA, G. BRENCI

SUMMARY

Many chronological correlations in different plant and animal species, in populations, in human families, and between cotwins, prove the existence of characteristic biological times. Some such times also tend to be related to cosmic time, in which they develop and from which they are induced, resulting in peculiar composite times, such as the daily, monthly, or annual rhythms, that are the object of study of chronobiology. Beyond these examples of exogenous chronological induction, the existence of a hereditary biological time is postulated, as the basic phenomenon in the relationship between time and life. The newborn scientific branch of chronogenetics is devoted to the study of the fundamental, endogenous genetic time, with its theoretical and practical, normal and pathologic implications. To explain and interpret the mechanisms of the hereditary biological time, the authors have developed a model based on the concepts of ergon (i.e., stability of the gene) and chronon (i.e., lifespan of the information). This Ergon/Chronon System is related to the gene, bringing into focus the fourth dimension and the dynamic aspects of the unit of inheritance. The applications of chronogenetics extend to every expression of life, from the most primitive unicellular to the higher plants and animals. In the area of normal human traits, the study of the hereditary biological time contributes significantly to the interpretation of such phenomena as development, reproduction, homeostasis, and senescence. In the area of medicine, chronogenetics interpretes, unifies, and develops the temporal phenomena of inheritance. In a future perspective, chronogenetics appears to be fundamental for eugenics, preventive medicine, and prognosis.

A few years ago we discussed with our students an interesting case: two MZ twin sisters, at the age of ten years and ten months, experienced menarche in the same night, while asleep. The same physiological event may therefore take place in a synchronous, automatic way in two autonomous individuals. Recently, a province magazine reported the death of two old-aged twins, as shown in Fig. 1: these are obviously MZ twins who have died at ten-days distance one from the other. According to the information we have gathered, they both died from circulatory troubles caused by senile diabetes. Confronted with these two twin cases of physiological and pathological concordance, we may ask ourselves the two questions: (1) What is the probability that two women, born simultaneously, have menarche on the same day?

* Presented to the Fourth International Congress of Neurogenetics and Neuroophthalmology (Rome, 25-28 September 1973).

3 Acta Genet. Med. Gemellol. (1973), 22: 3-17

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 ACTA GENETICAE MEDICAE ET GEMELLOLOGIAE

FIG. 1. These two MZ cotwins both died at uiuseppe wrus f. .->- > . ^ . .. - ^ from cardiocirculatory complications of 17-1-1900 17-2-1973 17-1-1900 27-2-1973 diabetes.

(2) What is the probability that two men, born simultaneously, die from the same disease ten days one after the other ? In the case of the simultaneous menarche the random probability for this phenomenon 10 taking place at age 10 /i2 corresponds to 0.0025 = 25 x 10-". In the case of the old-aged twins, the probability of dying at age 73, at a ten-days distance, for two subjects born in 1900, being of 0.0008, and the probability of both dying from cardio­ circulatory complications of diabetes being of 0.092, the random total probability of the event is of 0.0000736 = 736 X 10"7. (Calculations based on Italian Vital Statistics, 1972.) While the probability that such events take place at random is almost nil, those who study twins are every day confronted with as many cases of physiological or pathological temporal concordance as are the MZ twin pairs they observe. Whenever twins are said to be as like as two peas in a pod, they are by the same token, though unawares, defined as isochronic, in that they have developed the same traits at the same time. Two MZ twins are not just identical statues that remain such while time goes by: they are living beings, and therefore experience a process of continuous variation — a process that in their case is synchronous at every structural and functional level. Identical twins are therefore the symbol and living example of the hereditary biological time, one and manifold, that they scan in parallel, as two violins play the same music keeping the time of the same metronome. Two MZ twins are isochronic to the point that, whenever a difference between them appears, one is led to infer that different environmental factors may have caused it. Isochronic concordance being practically nil in random individuals of the same age, whereas it represents the rule in MZ twins, there must be a cause for that. Since MZ twins share a common heredity it may be safely assumed that the latter be responsible not only for the qualitative concordance but for the chronological one as well. Our assumptions may therefore proceed as follows: (1) MZ twins are isochronic in that they are isogenic; (2) MZ twins show the existence of a hereditary, individual biological

4

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 L. GEDDA, G. BRENCI: CHRONOGENETICS - ITS FOUNDATIONS, SCOPE, AND IMPACT

time; (3) the mechanism of this hereditary biological time is contained in the genome. Hereditary biological time is strangely ignored for two different and convergent reasons. First of all, the attention of research workers has been focused on the sideral or cosmic time, that accounts for the rhythm of hours, days, months, and years, because of the remarkable, continuous, and evident influence that cosmic rhythms exert on normal and pathologic functions of human beings. The study of these rhythms is the object of chronobiology. Secondly, hereditary biological time is ignored because Mendelian genetics has entirely devoted its attention to the inheritance of qualitative and quantitative, normal and patholog­ ic traits; and, similarly to cytogenetics and , has neither solved nor afforded the problem of the existence and the mechanism of the temporal parameter of the gene. Chronobiology is by all means a deserving science, though it fails to exhaust the problem of the relation between time and life, inasmuch as it doesn't face the most important aspect of this relation, which concerns the time of internal, rather than external, origin. Moreover, chronobiology has experimentally demonstrated that environmentally induced biological rhythms do also show hereditary characteristics, i.e., undergo a genetic control. Although true, this has eventually complicated the problem and masked the actually basic phenomenon. For instance, women living in the same environment, but belonging to different populations, in the average experience menarche at different times. Such phenomena show that the human organism's response to cosmic time has undergone an environmental selection of operative mechanism, although it remains evident that the primary nature of this time is exogenous. Hereditary biological time, instead, is an originally continuous, i.e., nonrhythmic time, that has its starting point in the zygote and involves each of the genes; consequently, it is of an endogenous nature. It is therefore very important not to mix up chronobiology and chronogenetics. The term, chronogenetics, was born in 1972 and announced in a lecture the senior author gave last September to the University of Tel Aviv (Gedda 1972). It had however been born ante litteram during the Second International Congress of Human Genetics (Rome 1961), when the same author referred to a " period of the gene " and to a " fourth dimension of the hereditary unit" (Gedda 1961). The fourth dimension of the gene comes out at the right moment, when molecular genetics has discovered that the gene, as quality of information, corresponds to the DNA molecule, and describes the latter as a three-dimensional polypeptide. It becomes easier, therefore, to think of this molecule in terms of a fourth dimension as well, represented by its duration, indicated by the amount of time of which the gene disposes in order to express itself into the phenotype. To this time, i.e., to the average life established by the gene that supports its period of informatic activity, we have given the name ergon. We have also transformed Beadle's aphorism, " one gene-one enzyme," into its chrono- genetic equivalent, " one gene-one time," in order to stress that any primary gene-product has a limited, variable, and hereditary time of delivery. Moreover, since ergon and chronon are in a causal relation and directly proportional, we have worked out a model, the " Ergon/ Chronon System," that correlates the two variables. Since 1961, a number of authors have devoted their attention to the time of the phenotype

5

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 ACTA GENETICAE MEDICAE ET GEMELLOLOGIAE

depending on heredity — such as Strehler (1962, 1964), who sees the old age as a consequence of random somatic mutations; Burch (1968), who sees involutive diseases as autoaggressive phenomena due to somatic mutations in predisposed individuals; Medvedev (1966), who sees the old age as a disordered ontogenesis caused by alterations of operative genotypes. Other authors have directly referred to the chronon concept — such as Bartalos (1971), who has studied it at a cytogenetic level in neoplasia; Rainer (1971), who has studied it in mental diseases; or Halbrecht (1971), who has studied the population variability of menarche from a chronogenetic point of view. On our part, we have tried to provide an experimental support to the phenomena shown (Gedda and Brenci 1971). Experimental work has been carried out on both drosophila and man. In drosophila, we found out that the duration of life differs in the wild and mutant types and that the crossing of different strains results in an intermediate duration of life in the hybrid. This shows that biological time is originally a product of the genotype. We have also shown that parental age in drosophila influences the duration of life in the offspring. This shows the ergon decay in the haploid condition, i.e., in the germinal phylum of gametes. The twin test was used in man for cytogenetic and growth studies. At the cytogenetic level, temporal aspects of the genotype of mitosis have been examined. As an experimental parameter, the association frequency of acrocentries was chosen, i.e., a plate disposition of indicating an inefficiency of information for euploid mitosis. A comparison of the caryograms of human twins aged 6 and 60 has shown a remarkable increase of these associations, which demonstrates the lack of information we had forecasted, i.e., the exhaustion of the Ergon/Chronon System in the diploid condition, as a result of age. Twins were also used in a radiologic study of the development of dental buds and ossi­ fication nuclei, that has shown a significantly higher time concordance in MZ vs. DZ twins, both for the teeth and for hand bones. The twin test has thus shown the hereditary nature of the temporal phenomenon under study, i.e., the genetic origin of chronon. As for the interpretation, we have suggested the following model. Once noted that the concept of gene stability, or ergon, should be distinguished from the concept of DNA-molecule stability — the former being referred to the hereditary unit while the latter is limited to the physico-chemical structure of the double helix — we consider the ergon as a global formula that allows to include all stability factors responsible for the gene stability (i.e., the ergon): (1) Redundancy, i.e., the number of repetitions of the DNA molecule representing a given gene; (2) Differential stability of the DNA molecule as a function of the variability of the number of H bonds that, information being equal, synonimy permits; (3) Repair, i.e., the gene's ability to repair the damage caused by mutation through a battery of specific enzymes. These three factors are a characteristic of the single genes and therefore easily account for the inheritance of the Ergon/Chronon System and, more generally, of biological time. We think we have in this way demonstrated the existence of a fundamental biologic and hereditary time (i.e., the time of gene), and suggested a model for the interpretation and study of chronogenetics.

6

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 L. GEDDA, G. BRENCi: CHRONOGENETICS - ITS FOUNDATIONS, SCOPE, AND IMPACT

We should now like to pass from the fundamentals of chronogenetics on to its scope, both in the Greek sense of the word (scopeo = I see) and in the English one (area of competence). The extension and competence of chronogenetics concerns life as a whole, for every living being, from virus to man, builds up itself and reproduces according to the times he has inherited and that he in turn scans and retransmits. Hereditary biological time characterizes the individual, establishing the timing of his life, i.e., of any function or disease of his organism, from mitosis and meiosis to the time and circumstances of natural death. The innumerable threads of hereditary biological time (one for each gene) mix up with the threads of cosmic time, that is rhythmic in nature and therefore transmits its own rhythms to the tissue of life. With reference to the plant kingdom, we may take an example from Linnaeus, who was able to work out an individual « calendar » based on the month and day of bloom, and a « clock » based on the hours of the day at which the flowers open (Fig. 2). The fact that the response of plant species to cosmic time be individually constant, demonstrates the existence of a biological time, strictly specific and hereditary, that interacts with cosmic time. The hereditary imprint that biological time transmits to « mixed » times as well, is illustrated by Kerner, who followed for twelve years, in the botanical gardens of Innsbruck, the bloom time of pure and hybrid willow-trees: with respect to pure parental varieties, hybrids exhibited intermediate bloom times (see Table).

TABLE

BLOOM TIME OF WILLOW-TREES (Salix) IN INNSBRUCK'S BOTANICAL GARDEN [From Kerner]

Parental species Hybrid Bloom time

(1) x (2) (3) (1) (2) (3)

Cremsensis Caprea daphnoides 17 March 16 March 18 March Mauternensis Caprea purpurea 23 16 7 April attenuata Caprea grandifolia 25 16 27 March Wimmeri daphnoides incana 26 18 17 April Austriaca grandifolia purpurea 3 April 27 7 Seringeana Caprea incana 3 16 17 capnoides cinerea incana 5 10 April 17 intermedia grandifolia incana 6 27 March 17 rubra viminalis purpurea 6 3 April 7 Kerneri viminalis incana 10 3 17 Oenipontana purpurea incana 12 7 17 auritoides purpurea aurita 14 7 19 Fenzliana retusa glabra 21 21 21 retusoides retusa Jaquiniana 21 21 21 alpigena retusa hastata 23 21 27 excelsior fragilis alba 23 13 27 Ehrhartiana alba pentadra 23 27 6 May

7

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 ar- CJk&tl LJNNJQI ;ii?8 ^ Aflcttx+Tio**.. >i i.4m*Knb» •. '«»*• i*=-'T S(iu««« ' ... . M- Ar,>*rf». ma, Mv« > * PHILOSOPHIA -*a——•— I. #*«fe« '4t.n«uiitt i, Mm BOTAN1CA ,4Hfcml»» 3-ftS/k • IN QV* 4)-lfcft»bJWal» JUJttJUXU.tt, M1JKCTIB '::": '•- • re' F/C U ft J J AWEIS. • Z ft:

-=,&£r*1'1*

lll|||lllillll||§i^

IpomoeB Convolvulus purpurea oeplum

Cerem _. \ Tragopogon p&ruvianm prateniLi

fRLra.bi.ltt \ CLchoruim jaLapa intybui

SiUna _(lymphaea noctlfura alba

ScLLLa -PnagaLLb marltlma

Ifle'aemhryanthaira OrnithsgaLum Calendula. cmtauxfiuni urcbellatum offidmlh

FIG. 2. Linnaeus's flowers « clock ».

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 L. GEDDA, G. BRENCI: CHRONOGENETICS - ITS FOUNDATIONS, SCOPE, AND IMPACT

The existence of a genetic biological time concerns all living beings, with progressively reduced variabilities of species, population, family, zygosity. The area covered by chrono­ genetics therefore extends to the entire realm of biology. Wherever life exists, hereditary units, or genes, exist as well; and wherever a gene exists, this possesses an energy charge proportional to the time of its informatic action. The life of the gene is represented by a cycle of decaying energy, that expresses itself through the time phene, i.e., through the duration of the individual hereditary trait. At this point, we may ask ourselves: what is the impact of chronogenetics on human and medical genetics? To human genetics, chronogenetics gives the formula to study the normal times of the gene; to medical genetics, it gives the interpretation and prospection of pathologic times. With reference to normal times, Fig. 3 shows the ontogenetic times of stature development

150

White-Negro mulottoes 145

American Negro

140

135

130

125

10 12 Age (years)

FIG. 3. Stature development in different populations. [Modified after Gedda et al. I960].

9

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 ACTA GENETICAE MEDICAE ET GEMELLOLOGIAE

in children from three populations: Italian (lower), American Negro (faster), and White- Negro mulattoes (even faster). This is a temporal phenomenon that should be better examined and that seems to correspond, on the dynamic plane, to the phenomenon that, on the static plane, Mendelian genetics calls heterosis (Gedda et al. 1960). With reference to senescence, chronogenetics may contribute to the solution of the etiologic problem. The different theories suggested are overcome by the observation that the diagram of senescence presents significant repetitions in members of the same family, and is concordant in twins, as is also shown by our research studies on teeth loss and white hairs in twins (Gedda and Brenci 1971). Chronogenetics explains senescence observing that gene stability decreases in the third age and that the duration of the information ends in a different way from one gene to the other in the same individual. This corresponds to the Mendelian principle of independence, and therefore takes place in a completely different way from one individual to the other, though with a reduced variability within the same family and identically in MZ twins. With regard to medical genetics, chronogenetics represents the common denominator of hereditary pathology, because — in contrast with senescence, that is uniform, since the genome decay is chronic and global — in hereditary diseases the lack of information is sporadic and anticipating. The so-called morbid genotype has a negative meaning (ex-vacuo), i.e., it corresponds to the silence of one or more genes that fail to produce the information anymore, their ergon being practically exhausted and their chronon having ended. This gap of information may be filled, either supplying from the outside a natural or artificial gene or a by-product of the missing substance, or by stimulating redundancy, repair, or substitutive genotypes. But it is too early to give therapeutic conclusions. We should now make some use of chronogenetics in order to better study genetic diseases. We have tried to afford an elementary screening based on McKusick's very good catalog of Mendelian inheritance in man (1966). Looking for any possible temporal parameter in this catalog, we were able to gather a general view of the situation, which is definitely incomplete, since the author had not the same objective as we had, but, for the very same reason, full of significance. McKusick's catalog includes approximately 1500 hereditary diseases, divided in dominant, recessive, and sex-linked. The basic chronogenetic parameter is represented by the age of onset of the disease. This is traditionally given in the medical literature, the description of any disease including, as a rule, etiology, symptomatology, course, prognosis, and treatment. Age of onset is given within the description of the course, and this detail acquires a particular importance in the hands of the geneticist. To start with, 10% of the diseases catalogued by McKusick give, more or less precisely, the age of onset. It should be added, however, that another 30 % are congenital, since fetal- life onset is also a true chronogenetic parameter. We may therefore consider that the age of onset is already known for at least 40% of hereditary diseases. In the chronogenetic perspective, the age of onset corresponds to the time at which the responsible gene stops supplying the normal information; therefore, the onset of the disease marks the end of the responsible gene's chronon. The geneticist may then verify the behavior of the same gene's chronon in family relatives. Other chronogenetic phenomena may be

10

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 L. GEDDA, G. BRENCI: CHRONOGENETICS - ITS FOUNDATIONS, SCOPE, AND IMPACT t3

HI

IV T3 T4 T5 6 *7 8 9 ^0 11 +12 *13 *14

@ female with cataract; onset of l /Z 3*4 visual symptoms in adult life. case E7 #* male with cataract; onset of visual symptoms in infancy.

FIG. 4. Differential onset of cataract in the two sexes. [After Fraser and Friedmann 1967].

considered, such as the within-family correlation of chronon; its sex-linkage; its anticipation, postponement, or end; the chronogenetic typing of the disease; the influence of parental age and of birth rank. We shall now try to give a few examples of these parameters making use of literature data, other than those cited by McKusick. Let us start with the pedigree of sex-linked or sex-modified cataract (Fraser and Fried­ mann 1967: Fig. 4). Actually, cataract is not strictly sex-linked, the same symptons being present in the two sexes; however, the sex modifies the chronon of the disease, the onset being in infancy for males, but in the adult life for females. Chronon is therefore sex-linked, and the fact that it is longer in females makes us think that chronon, just as the gene itself, may be linked to the X-, that is double in females, accounting for a double ergon in the mutant gene, whereas it is single in males. The family correlation of chronon may be well shown by a pedigree collected in our Institute and shown in Fig. 5. There are five cases of intestinal polyposis with carcinomatous transformation and three cases of death probably caused by the same disease. In all the cases the onset is before 30 and the correlation consists in this young-age onset. An example of correlation in the adult life is shown by a pedigree presented by Ander­ son (1970) and shown in Fig. 6. A woman aged 43 and eight relatives are affected by uterus and colon adenocarcinoma. Onset was always in the adult age, between 34 and 51; at the time the pedigree was drawn, the fourth generation, still in the young age, was healthy.

11

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 1 rs r? 7j 7?

1 $ i 6r< ttt O fc_9 25 29 Bf ^rdrtWr

3ttt0 23 f3 "

By Intestinal polyposis

•^ Age of onset 20

Age at death J FIG. 5. Concordant age of onset in intestinal polyposis. I 91*

82 41 13 6 2r1 Wi i A T V 1 ftoira Stofroi g^o 4&r8 a $>ra ^&ra EZ on a cfncfffi cEAl iiidb fifii £ai 24 22 14 18 II 19 |5 10 20 14 10 23 22 14 7 16 14 9 17 15 9 I DIED IN INFANCY MALE FEMALE y PROBAND • O UNAFFECTED Bj # AFFECTED [I] (D REPORTED AFFECTED

FIG. 6. Concordant age of onset in uterus and colon adenocarcinoma. [After Anderson 1970],

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 L. GEDDA, G. BRENCI: CHRONOGENETICS - ITS FOUNDATIONS, SCOPE, AND IMPACT •u> • = homme O - femme n I9 ^ [B (^ = Cornea verticillata BD © = excrption urinaire pathologique = Cornea verricillala, EI angiokeratoma corporis ? i diffusum (Fabry) rs = idem + excretion urinaire pathologique 0 = probablement atteint IV 19<6 1950 1952 16 Ti ^^ = 6 enfants

FIG. 7. Concordant age of onset in Fabry's disease. [After Denden and Franceschetti 1968].

These examples of family correlation of chronon may be easily explained if time is considered as a phene, so that, in Mendelian terms, one may speak of a family correlation of the trait chronon. A typical Mendelian behavior of chronon may be found in a pedigree presented by Denden and Franceschetti (1968), showing a woman affected by Fabry's diseases (cornea verticillata and angiokeratoma), transmitting the disease to each of the two sons conceived with two different husbands (Fig. 7). In both cases the onset was at 13. This agrees with the model of X-linkage and with our interpretation that the maternal allele repeats in the two sons its temporal dimension. When different conceptions are distributed over a longer period of time, another chrono- genetic phenomenon may become apparent, as shown by a pedigree (Fig. 8) collected by Gruber (1946) and completed by Franceschetti (1967), where a female carrier of Fabry's disease has a total of fourteen conceptions, with symptoms of the disease in at least nine of these. When we pass to examine the age of onset, we find the following progression: no. 7, age 20; no. 14, age 12; no. 15, age 11; no. 16, age 9; no. 19, age 5. This is a very clear ex­ ample showing the progressive decay of chronon in the haploid set of the maternal gamete and the corresponding reduction of chronon in the offsprings' specific genotype. The considerations we have made so far only concern the age of onset, whereas the temporal parameters that may be found in the literature are various and meaningful, such as the age of exitus (that sometimes, although more rarely, may mean recovery) and its factors

13

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 ACTA GENETICAE MEDICAE ET GEMELLOLOGIAE

I St}

I ffl l f p It 111 «*•<• TJJJJ- »»-• T v 5s i s» i i 4' &"# f r 4* /f a a s t? s H i iae» w. ists iw9 ns BM MI SK iSs i»» IMP NGO t» wit no ! i *?_ T±JLJL „__£. J • homnrw O » femme 113] • ComoA vsrticillata. ant*ob*r*toma no • Cornea wticillata carport* tfiffuwm (Fafcrj* DC •

Arbr* gtfn&Jlogiqua de cornea verticitlata (d'aprft* GRUBCR. 1946. ramiiu z)

[ ] complete par A Th. FRANCGSCHETTI. 1987.

FIG. 8. Progressively anticipating age of onset in Fabry's disease. [After Franceschetti 1967].

of anticipation and postponement, the times of expression that represent the hereditary component of a larger picture that medicine calls course. Special Pathology may foresee and set up a chronogenetic control of every disease, and may lead to finding out that chronogenetic variability has made different names be given to the same disease. For instance, according to a classification of some lipid storage diseases, Tay-Sachs disease corresponds to the infantile form of amaurotic idiocy, whereas Bielschowsky-Jansky disease corresponds to the late infantile one, Batten-Vogt-Spielmeyer's disease to the juvenile form, and Kufs disease to the adult form (Berman 1973). Chronogenetics may unify what the clinical picture seems to divide. From an individual point of view, chronogenetics has a definite impact at three levels: eugenics, preventive medicine, and clinical medicine. In this Congress, one section is devoted to eugenics, under Prof. Klein's chairmanship. Therefore, we have a special occasion to say that the eugenic forecast should not only be

14

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 L. GEDDA, G. BRENCI: CHRONOGENETICS - ITS FOUNDATIONS, SCOPE, AND IMPACT

qualitative, i.e., referred to the hereditary diseases presented by the family branches, but chronologic as well, in that the risk to the couple also concerns the age of onset. This is important, because, on the one hand, the risk may thus be better evaluated; while, on the other hand, after the marriage has been celebrated, the risk itself may disappear when the calculated age of onset is passed. Chronogenetics may help preventive medicine by finding out the age of danger and setting up measures to detect and correct the disease before its clinical manifestation. After the manifestation of the disease, chronogenetics may give a doctrinal and practical basis to prognosis; the latter may be considered as a chronogenetics ante litteram practiced since the times of Hippocrates. We should finally like to observe that chronogenetics marks the passage from a static to a dynamic view. Obviously, Mendelian genetics, as well as cytogenetics and molecular genetics, have all afforded the study of the sequence of hereditary phenomena: this is, however, a study of discontinuous stages, where the continuum of a dynamic action is lacking. The difference is similar to that existing between describing a phenomenon through a series of slides and describing it through a moving picture. Chronogenetics has this kind of efficiency because it follows the continuum of the information in the time, its incidence, its variability, and the different consequences of its action in the different times of life. With chronogenetics, a dynamic view is realized through which every genetic phenomenon appears to be the effect of the various presence or absence of a flux of information distributed all over any autonomous individual and any part of it capable of autonomous life.

REFERENCES Anderson D.E. 1970. Genetic varieties of neoplasia. Franceschetti A.Th. 1968. La cornea verticillata In: Genetic Concepts and Neoplasia. A Collec­ (Gruber) et ses relations avec la maladie de tion of Papers Presented at the Twenty-Third Fabry (angiokeratoma corporis diffusum). Oph- Annual Symposium on Foundamental Cancer thalmologica (Basel), 156: 232-238. Research, 1969. [pp. 85-109]. Baltimore: The Fraser G.A., Friedmann A.I. 1967. The Causes of Williams & Wilkins Company. Blindness in Childhood. A Study of 776 Chil­ Bartalos M. 1971. Time factor in cytogenetics and dren with Severe Visual Handicaps, [pp. 57-69]. neoplasia. Acta Genet. Med. Gemellol. (Ro­ Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press. ma), 20: 350-358. Gedda L., Serio A., Mercuri A. 1960. II Meticciato Berman E.R. 1973. Tapeto-retinal degenerations di Guerra e Altri Casi. Roma: Istituto Mendel. and disorders of lipid metabolism. Proc. 4th Gedda L. 1961. Genetica clinica. Proc. 2nd Int. Int. Congr. Neuro-Genet. and Neuro-Ophthal- Congr. Hum. Genet., Rome 6-12 September 1961. mol., Rome 25-28 September 1973. Acta Genet. [pp. 911-919]. Rome 1963: Istituto Mendel. Med. Gemellol. (Roma). [In the course of pub­ Gedda L., Brenci G. 1971. Chronology of the gene. lication]. Acta Genet. Med. Gemellol. (Roma), 20: 323- Burch P.R.J. 1968. An Inquiry Concerning Growth, 349. Disease, and Ageing. Edinburgh: Oliver & Gedda L. 1972. Twin studies in genetics. Acta Boyd. Genet. Med. Gemellol. (Roma), 21: 265-269. Denden A., Franceschetti A.Th. 1969. Cornea Ver- Gedda L., Brenci G. 1974. Cronogenetica, l'Eredi- ticillata: Ein Symptom des Morbus Fabry-Ander- ta del Tempo Biologico. Milano: Mondadori EST. son. Ber. Dtsch. Ophthalmol. Ges., 69: 145- Halbrecht I., Sklorowski E., Tsafrir J. 1971. Menar- 148. che and menstruation in various ethnic groups

15

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 ACTA GENETICAE MEDICAE ET GEMELLOLOGIAE

in Israel. Acta Genet. Med. Gemellol. (Ro- Problems of Heredity, Development and Age- ma), 20: 384-391. ing. Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd. Linnaeus C. 1763. Philosophia Botanica. [p. 278]. Rainer J.D. 1971. Chronological parameters, twin : J.T. Trattner. studies, and mental diseases. Acta Genet. Med. McKusick V.A. 1966. Mendelian Inheritance in Gemellol. (Roma), 20: 359-372. Man. Catalogs of Autosomal Dominant, Auto- Strehler B.L. 1962. Time, Cell, and Ageing. New somal Recessive, and X-Linked Phenotypes. York: Academic Press. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press. Strehler B.L. 1964. Advances in Gerontological Medvedev Zh.A. 1966. Protein Biosynthesis and Research. New York: Academic Press.

RIASSUNTO Molte correlazioni di tempi nelle singole specie animali e vegetali, nelle popolazioni, nelle famiglie della specie umana e fra individui gemelli dimostrano I'esistenza di tempi biologici caratteristici. Alcuni di questi appaiono a loro volta correlati al tempo cosmico nel quale si sviluppano e dal quale ricevono delle induzioni che producono dei tempi misti particolari come i ritmi giornalieri, mensili, annuali di cui si occupa la cronobiologia. Oltre questi aspetti di induzione cronologica di natura esogena, e come fenomeno basico dei rapporti fra tempo e vita, bisogna ammettere I'esistenza di un «tempo biologico ereditario ». Per lo studio del tempo genetico fondamentale di natura endogena e delle sue implicazioni dottrinarie e pratiche, normali e pato- logiche, e nata recentemente la cronogenetka. In ordine al meccanismo del «tempo biologico ereditario » e stato elaborato un modello basato sui con­ cetti di ergon (o stabilita del gene) e di chronon (o durata dell'informazione), che viene riferito al gene e per- mette di focalizzare la quarta dimensione e le caratteristiche dinamiche dell'unita ereditaria. Le applicazioni della cronogenetica abbracciano tutte le espressioni della vita: protisti, vegetali e animali. Nel settore umano normale lo studio del tempo biologico ereditario porta un valido contributo all'interpreta- zione dello sviluppo, della riproduzione, dell'omeostasi e della senescenza. Nel settore medico la cronogenetica interpreta, unifica ed estende i fenomeni temporali dell'eredita. Nella prospettiva dei futuribili la cronoge­ netica e di fondamentale importanza per l'eugenica, per la medicina preventiva e per la prognosi.

RESUME Bien des correlations chronologiques chez differentes especes d'animaux et vegetaux, chez les populations, les families humaines et les jumeaux, prouvent l'existance de temps biologiques caracteristiques. Certains de ces temps tendent aussi a se rapporter au temps cosmique, dans lequel ils se developpent et par lequel ils sont induits, resultant en des temps composites caracteristiques, tels que les rythmes journaliers,mensuels,ou annuels, qui sont l'objet d'etude de la chronobiologie. Au-dela de ces examples d'induction chronologique exogene, l'existance d'un temps biologique hereditaire est postulee, en tant que phenomene fondamental dans les rapports entre le temps et la vie. La nouvelle disci­ pline scientifique de la chronogenetique est dediee a l'etude du temps genetique endogene fondamental, avec ses implications theoriques et pratiques, normales et pathologiques. Afin d'expliquer et interpreter les meca- nismes du temps biologique hereditaire, les auteurs ont developpe un modele base sur les concepts d'ergon (stabilite du gene) et de chronon (duree de l'information). Ce Systeme Ergon/Chronon se rapporte au gene, dont il defini la quatrieme dimension et les aspects dynamiques. Les applications de la chronogenetique touchent toutes les expressions de la vie, a partir des organismes unicellulaires les plus primitifs jusqu'aux animaux et vegetaux superieurs. Dans le secteur des caracteres humains normaux, l'etude du temps biologique hereditaire donne une contribution significative a ['inter­ pretation de phenomenes tels que le developpement, la reproduction, l'homeostase et la senescence. Dans le secteur de la medecine, la chronogenetique interprete, unifie et developpe les phenomenes temporels de l'heredite. Dans une perspective avenir, la chronogenetique parait comme fondamentale dans l'eugenique, la medecine preventive et le pronostic.

16

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546 L. GEDDA, G. BRENCI: CHRONOGENETICS - ITS FOUNDATIONS, SCOPE, AND IMPACT

ZuSAMMENFASSUNG

Viele chronologische Korrelationen bei einzelnen Tier- und Pflanzenarten, bei menschlichen Populationen und Sippen sowie bei Zwillingen zeugen fur das Vorhandensein charakteristischer biologischer Tempi. Einige davon scheinen ihrerseits vom kosmischen Tempo abzuhangen, in dem sie sich entwickeln und das ihnen die Induktionen fur besondere gemischte Tempi verleiht, wie es zum Beispiel die Tages-, Monats- und Jahresrhythmen sind, mit denen sich die Chronobiologie beschaftigt. Ausser diesen Aspekten chronologischer, exogener Induktion und als grundlegendes Phanomen des Verhalt- nisses zwischen Zeit und Leben muss man zugeben, dass auch ein « erbliches biologisches Tempo » existiert. Eine ganz junge Wissenschaft, die Chronogenetik, befasst sich mit dem endogenen grundlegenden Erbtempo und seinen theoretischen und praktischen Auswirkungen in der Physiologie sowohl als in der Pathologie. Zur Erforschung des Mechanismus dieses « biologischen Erbtempos » wurde ein Modell ausgearbeitet, das, auf die Konzepte «Ergon» (Genstabilitat) und « Chronon» (Informationsdauer) gestutzt, sich aufs Gen bezieht und eine genaue Bestimmung der vierten Dimension und der dynamischen Merkmale der Erbeinheit zulasst. Die Anwendungsmoglichkeiten der Chronogenetik umfassen alle Lebensausserungen: protistische, pflanz- liche, tierische. Auf den Menschen angewandt liefert das Studium der biologischen Erbzeit einen wertvollen Beitrag zum Verstandnis der normalen Entwicklungs-, Reproduktions-, Homoostase- und Altersprozesse. Auf medizinischem Gebiet werden die zeitlichen Erbphanomene durch die Chronogenetik gedeutet, geeint und ausgedehnt. Im Hinblick auf die zukiinftigen Generationen ist die Chronogenetik vom Standpunkt der Eugenik, der Praventivmedizin und der Prognose von grundlegender Bedeutung.

Prof. Luigi Gedda, Istituto di Genetica Medica e Gemellologia Gregorio Mendel, Piazza Galeno 5, 00161 Roma, Italy.

17

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.40.219, on 26 Sep 2021 at 14:26:58, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1120962300017546