Appendix 1: 2012 State Senate Candidates Under Speaker Silver's Bill

Net Gain (or loss) Alternative 1: Net Alternative 2: Net Total Public Total Public Private Dollars Net Gain (or loss) with the Bill's Gain (or Loss) - 4K Gain (or Loss) - 4K General Dollars Same Dollars with New lost via with the Bill's Limits and Caps Contribution Limits, Contribution Limits, Senate 2012: Candidate, District & Election Election Inc/Chal Total Donors (350K Donors (350K Contribution Limits and Caps (with New 350K cap (No New 700K cap (No New Party Candidate Result l/ Open Receipts cap 1) cap 1) Limits (2K 1) (No New Donors) Donors) Donors) Donors) Bridget M. Fleming 1 DEM Y L C 157,685 350,000 350,000 27,237 322,763 341,713 335,363 341,931 Kenneth P. LaValle 1 REP Y W I 283,849 180,642 230,742 103,517 77,125 135,575 115,042 115,042 John J. Flanagan 2 REP Y W I 271,674 155,532 194,232 56,315 99,217 144,367 133,467 133,467 Lee M. Zeldin 3 REP Y W I 771,814 350,000 350,000 216,813 133,187 155,537 245,100 336,628 Philip M. Boyle 4 REP Y W O 662,205 272,364 350,000 188,139 84,225 176,611 148,514 148,514 4 DEM Y L O 117,900 127,188 189,588 24,525 102,663 175,463 112,688 112,688 Carl L. Marcellino 5 REP Y W I 294,126 191,850 240,750 55,580 136,270 193,320 172,050 172,050 Kemp Hannon 6 REP Y W I 766,962 350,000 350,000 248,053 101,947 115,897 228,242 238,044 Ryan E. Cronin 6 DEM Y L C 190,533 182,634 244,434 79,275 103,359 175,459 140,884 140,884 Jack M. Martins 7 REP Y W I 648,532 350,000 350,000 173,521 176,479 190,879 250,954 269,432 Daniel S. Ross 7 DEM Y L C 3,666 9,246 12,246 - 9,246 12,746 9,246 9,246 Charles J. Fuschillo, Jr. 8 REP Y W I 580,682 143,604 186,504 181,725 (38,121) 11,929 61,804 61,804 Carol A. Gordon 8 DEM Y L C 2,945 15,870 26,370 - 15,870 28,120 15,870 15,870 Dean G. Skelos 9 REP Y W I 1,793,202 350,000 350,000 748,517 (398,517) (382,067) (64,097) 35,477 James Sanders, Jr. 10 DEM Y W C 157,874 93,780 128,880 58,400 35,380 76,330 58,880 58,880 11 DEM Y W I 164,998 160,092 232,992 47,150 112,942 197,992 129,692 129,692 Joseph R. Concannon 11 REP Y L C 20,683 62,808 97,908 3,000 59,808 100,758 61,808 61,808 Michael N. Gianaris 12 DEM Y W I 564,566 188,016 236,316 173,230 14,786 71,136 103,516 103,516 Aurelio A. Arcabascio 12 REP Y L C 3,623 17,070 25,170 - 17,070 26,520 17,070 17,070 Jose R. Peralta 13 DEM Y W I 261,582 63,930 85,230 99,100 (35,170) (10,320) 6,330 6,330 Malcolm A. Smith 14 DEM Y W I 309,275 98,430 124,830 116,020 (17,590) 13,210 47,735 47,735 Joseph P. Addabbo, Jr. 15 DEM Y W I 470,895 258,054 343,254 201,105 56,949 156,349 139,199 139,199 Eric A. Ulrich 15 REP Y L C 1,357,647 287,880 350,000 168,300 119,580 196,200 189,580 189,580 16 DEM Y W I 365,506 97,428 128,628 136,675 (39,247) (2,847) 29,153 29,153 J.D. Kim 16 REP Y L C 32,130 66,780 85,080 5,100 61,680 83,030 65,780 65,780 David Storobin 17 REP Y L I 496,686 248,190 323,490 189,900 58,290 146,140 151,190 151,190 17 DEM Y W C 247,649 84,300 101,400 113,600 (29,300) (9,350) (6,800) (6,800) Abraham Tischler 17 OTH Y L C 9,144 43,884 86,484 - 43,884 93,584 43,884 43,884 Martin Malave Dilan 18 DEM Y W I 186,462 69,060 92,760 88,652 (19,592) 8,058 13,760 13,760 John L. Sampson 19 DEM Y W I 552,350 174,300 210,900 229,200 (54,900) (12,200) 60,600 60,600 20 DEM Y W I 131,001 24,090 32,490 32,750 (8,660) 1,140 8,090 8,090 Kevin S. Parker 21 DEM Y W I 289,747 287,304 350,000 79,634 207,670 286,816 251,450 251,450 Martin J. Golden 22 REP Y W I 1,431,319 350,000 350,000 526,798 (176,798) (151,898) 59,451 224,911 Andrew S. Gounardes 22 DEM Y L C 278,708 350,000 350,000 52,876 297,124 339,524 321,919 645,017 Diane J. Savino 23 DEM Y W I 518,285 147,270 195,270 185,350 (38,080) 17,920 50,620 50,620 Lisa Grey 23 REP Y L C 26,411 55,200 72,900 10,390 44,810 65,460 46,810 46,810 24 REP Y W I 320,254 246,348 319,548 64,560 181,788 267,188 223,603 223,603 Gary W. Carsel 24 DEM Y L C 13,457 72,228 119,928 - 72,228 127,878 72,228 72,228 25 DEM Y W I 31,112 22,440 32,340 5,000 17,440 28,990 20,940 20,940 Daniel Squadron 26 DEM Y W I 90,443 169,920 216,120 23,923 145,997 199,897 161,920 161,920 Brad M. Hoylman 27 DEM Y W O 399,975 350,000 350,000 111,074 238,926 272,026 293,424 550,222 28 DEM Y W I 261,771 325,416 350,000 59,800 265,616 306,350 300,616 300,616 David Paul Garland 28 REP Y L O 5,831 28,386 44,886 - 28,386 47,636 28,386 28,386 Jose M. Serrano 29 DEM Y W I 23,900 2,400 3,300 6,000 (3,600) (2,550) 400 400 Bill Perkins 30 DEM Y W I 50,555 69,120 95,220 10,800 58,320 88,770 63,320 63,320 Adriano Espaillat 31 DEM Y W I 299,652 238,260 321,660 93,330 144,930 242,230 191,430 191,430 Ruben M. Diaz 32 DEM Y W I 94,791 159,108 209,508 17,851 141,257 200,057 150,308 150,308

The Campaign Finance Institute * www.CampaignFinanceInstitute.org Appendix 1: 2012 New York State Senate Candidates Under Speaker Silver's Bill

Net Gain (or loss) Alternative 1: Net Alternative 2: Net Total Public Total Public Private Dollars Net Gain (or loss) with the Bill's Gain (or Loss) - 4K Gain (or Loss) - 4K General Dollars Same Dollars with New lost via with the Bill's Limits and Caps Contribution Limits, Contribution Limits, Senate 2012: Candidate, District & Election Election Inc/Chal Total Donors (350K Donors (350K Contribution Limits and Caps (with New 350K cap (No New 700K cap (No New Party Candidate Result l/ Open Receipts cap 1) cap 1) Limits (2K 1) (No New Donors) Donors) Donors) Donors) J. Gustavo Rivera 33 DEM Y W I 381,009 288,720 350,000 142,504 146,216 224,996 206,284 206,284 Jeffrey D. Klein 34 DEM Y W I 1,334,116 349,674 350,000 595,803 (246,129) (232,603) 34,709 34,709 Andrea Stewart-Cousins 35 DEM Y W I 286,030 344,628 350,000 76,250 268,378 292,000 302,628 302,628 Ruth H. Thompson 36 DEM Y W I 154,566 126,660 168,960 30,750 95,910 145,260 113,660 113,660 George S. Latimer 37 DEM Y W O 714,303 350,000 350,000 155,297 194,703 244,353 262,753 612,753 Bob Cohen 37 REP Y L O 1,198,799 350,000 350,000 347,750 2,250 20,450 160,000 205,658 38 DEM Y W I 658,386 350,000 350,000 219,609 130,391 148,441 231,775 237,119 Janis A. Castaldi 38 REP Y L C 17,607 12,780 17,880 9,000 3,780 9,730 9,780 9,780 William J. Larkin, Jr. 39 REP Y W I 320,695 189,660 272,760 72,475 117,185 214,135 148,360 148,360 Christopher W. Eachus 39 DEM Y L C 47,319 88,710 161,610 10,439 78,271 163,321 82,410 82,410 40 REP Y W I 1,412,961 350,000 350,000 338,200 11,800 79,000 172,438 522,438 Justin R. Wagner 40 DEM Y L C 402,233 350,000 350,000 100,871 249,129 294,579 288,851 638,851 Stephen M. Saland 41 REP Y L I 1,014,308 534,540 700,000 489,025 45,515 240,525 14,550 199,090 Terry W. Gipson 41 DEM Y W C 223,841 350,000 350,000 60,227 289,773 325,973 311,207 389,037 Neil A. DiCarlo 41 CON Y L C 45,132 70,464 113,064 15,450 55,014 104,714 59,514 59,514 John J. Bonacic 42 REP Y W I 481,484 269,676 350,000 173,555 96,121 193,495 169,534 169,534 Roy J. McDonald 43 IND Y L I 977,824 700,000 700,000 431,595 268,405 328,355 51,650 401,650 Kathleen A. Marchione 43 REP Y W C 559,331 318,126 486,126 186,689 131,437 327,437 191,910 191,910 Robin Andrews 43 DEM Y L C 87,358 240,408 347,508 9,500 230,908 355,858 238,408 238,408 Ed Gilbert 43 CON P PL C 10,000 - - 6,000 (6,000) (6,000) (2,000) (2,000) Neil D. Breslin 44 DEM Y W I 382,539 233,730 337,830 102,931 130,799 252,249 182,430 182,430 Shawn Morse 44 DEM P PL C 158,125 130,734 220,434 73,936 56,798 161,448 89,798 89,798 Peter A. LaVenia, Jr. 44 GRN Y L C 1,861 9,966 18,366 - 9,966 19,766 9,966 9,966 Elizabeth O'C. Little 45 REP Y W I 285,859 172,644 225,744 39,677 132,967 194,917 157,827 157,827 George A. Amedore, Jr. 46 REP Y L O 898,228 310,308 350,000 231,790 78,518 139,510 175,793 175,793 Cecilia F. Tkaczyk 46 DEM Y W O 260,772 334,014 492,114 118,839 215,175 399,625 249,514 249,514 Tom Dolan 46 DEM P PL O 6,760 28,110 40,710 - 28,110 42,810 28,110 28,110 Monica Miranda 46 DEM P PL O 2,437 12,372 23,772 - 12,372 25,672 12,372 12,372 Joseph A. Griffo 47 REP Y W I 179,477 252,558 350,000 19,940 232,618 350,960 244,558 244,558 Patricia Ritchie 48 REP Y W I 239,332 275,550 350,000 48,656 226,894 318,044 251,375 251,375 Amy M. Tresidder 48 DEM Y L C 29,751 44,310 62,010 1,700 42,610 63,260 44,310 44,310 Hugh T. Farley 49 REP Y W I 156,171 158,004 241,404 27,850 130,154 227,454 140,404 140,404 Madelyn C. Thorne 49 DEM Y L C 17,084 74,304 122,604 - 74,304 130,654 74,304 74,304 John A. DeFrancisco 50 REP Y W I 614,647 240,504 293,004 185,371 55,133 116,383 143,346 143,346 James L. Seward 51 REP Y W I 591,507 357,150 503,550 172,469 184,681 355,481 266,455 273,605 Howard Leib 51 DEM Y L C 13,188 42,228 59,628 - 42,228 62,528 42,228 42,228 JAMES BLAKE 51 REP P PL C 10,400 29,064 44,364 1,500 27,564 45,414 29,064 29,064 Thomas W. Libous 52 REP Y W I 1,411,182 350,000 350,000 598,517 (248,517) (233,467) 20,283 75,997 John P. Orzel 52 DEM Y L C 11,809 60,132 100,932 - 60,132 107,732 60,132 60,132 David J. Valesky 53 DEM Y W I 414,067 194,394 274,794 136,250 58,144 151,944 120,544 120,544 Michael F. Nozzolio 54 REP Y W I 480,612 251,832 350,000 122,375 129,457 247,075 207,932 207,932 Sean T. Hanna 55 REP Y L O 1,164,646 216,306 340,206 162,600 53,706 198,256 118,906 118,906 Ted O'Brien 55 DEM Y W O 516,995 230,790 339,990 134,200 96,590 223,990 139,090 139,090 Joseph E. Robach 56 REP Y W I 408,804 100,380 137,280 110,140 (9,760) 33,290 48,680 48,680 Catharine M. Young 57 REP Y W I 488,878 308,646 350,000 137,871 170,775 235,979 246,721 246,721 Thomas F. O'Mara 58 REP Y W I 222,275 254,310 341,010 29,350 224,960 326,110 249,310 249,310 Patrick M. Gallivan 59 REP Y W I 285,045 245,106 320,106 59,521 185,585 273,085 216,747 216,747

The Campaign Finance Institute * www.CampaignFinanceInstitute.org Appendix 1: 2012 New York State Senate Candidates Under Speaker Silver's Bill

Net Gain (or loss) Alternative 1: Net Alternative 2: Net Total Public Total Public Private Dollars Net Gain (or loss) with the Bill's Gain (or Loss) - 4K Gain (or Loss) - 4K General Dollars Same Dollars with New lost via with the Bill's Limits and Caps Contribution Limits, Contribution Limits, Senate 2012: Candidate, District & Election Election Inc/Chal Total Donors (350K Donors (350K Contribution Limits and Caps (with New 350K cap (No New 700K cap (No New Party Candidate Result l/ Open Receipts cap 1) cap 1) Limits (2K 1) (No New Donors) Donors) Donors) Donors) Mark J. Grisanti 60 REP Y W I 1,649,232 350,000 350,000 415,142 (65,142) (15,892) 59,355 409,355 Charles M. Swanick 60 CON Y L C 109,935 46,110 57,210 49,800 (3,690) 9,260 19,060 19,060 Michael L. Amodeo 60 DEM Y L C 137,401 220,980 328,980 43,500 177,480 303,480 193,280 193,280 Michael H. Ranzenhofer 61 REP Y W I 519,458 316,362 350,000 157,305 159,057 210,595 244,437 244,437 Justin M. Rooney 61 DEM Y L C 2,620 2,460 3,660 - 2,460 3,860 2,460 2,460 George D. Maziarz 62 REP Y W I 1,078,705 700,000 700,000 288,381 411,619 482,619 210,232 560,232 Johny Destino 62 REP P PL C 15,788 24,768 41,268 3,774 20,994 40,244 23,028 23,028 Timothy M. Kennedy 63 DEM Y W I 950,616 350,000 350,000 384,293 (34,293) (343) 128,651 350,613

1 There were 8 Senate candidates who particpated in a primary and general election. They have an aggregate contribution limit of $4,000 and a public funds cap of $700,000. The calculations reflect that.

The Campaign Finance Institute * www.CampaignFinanceInstitute.org