Tourism Destinations Under Pressure
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Tourism destinations under pressure Challenges and innovative solutions 2017 Fabian Weber, Juerg Stettler, Julianna Priskin, Barbara Rosenberg-Taufer, Sindhuri Ponnapureddy, Sarah Fux, Marc-Antoine Camp, Martin Barth Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts Institute of Tourism ITW Roesslimatte 48 6002 Lucerne, Switzerland Lucerne, May 2017 Study conducted by Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts in collaboration with WTFL university partners. Tourism destinations under pressure Page 2/214 Contributions and Authors Case & country University Authors Baku, Azerbaijan Azerbaijan Tourism and Prof. Shalala Mammadova Management University Cozumel, Mexico Universidad de Monterrey Dr. Blanca Alejandra Camargo Great Barrier Reef (GBR), University of Queensland Dr. Gabby Walters Australia Karen Hofman Juist, Germany Harz University of Applied Prof. Dr. Louisa Klemmer Sciences Prof. Dr. Sven Gross Kasane, Botswana Botho University Simon Lloyd Dr. Kgosietsile Velempini Lombok, Indonesia Sekolah Tinggi Pariwisata Beta Budisetyorini Bandung (STP) Pita Ratna Sari Dicky Arsyul Salam Muskoka, Canada University of Waterloo Ashley Gallant Dr. Karla Boluk Ohrid, Macedonia University of St. Kliment Prof. Dr. Ivanka Nestoroska Ohridski, Faculty for Tourism Prof. Dr. Naume Marinoski and Hospitality Prof. Dr. Sasho Korunovski Prof. Dr. Simona Martinoska Prof. Dr. Katerina Angelevska- Najdeska Prof. Dr. Risto Reckoski Prof. Dr. Danijela Miloshoska Rigi, Switzerland Lucerne University of Applied Barbara Rosenberg-Taufer Sciences and Arts Julia Huilla Soweto, South Africa University of Johannesburg Dr. Milena Ivanovic Maisa Adinolfi Vyasha Harilal Vienna, Austria MODUL University Vienna Igor Gula Prof. Dr. Dagmar Lund- Durlacher Project team Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts (HSLU) Dr. Fabian Weber Prof. Dr. Juerg Stettler Prof. Dr. Julianna Priskin Barbara Rosenberg-Taufer Sindhuri Ponnapureddy Sarah Fux Prof. Dr. Marc-Antoine Camp Prof. Martin Barth Tourism destinations under pressure Page 3/214 Content Management Summary ................................................................................................................. 5 1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 7 1.1. Aims & research questions ................................................................................................... 7 1.2. Method ............................................................................................................................... 8 1.3. Project phases ................................................................................................................... 11 2. Literature review .................................................................................................................. 12 2.1. Overtourism/ Overcrowding .............................................................................................. 12 2.2. Carrying capacities ............................................................................................................. 12 2.3. Challenges & solutions ....................................................................................................... 13 3. Cases .................................................................................................................................... 15 3.1. Overview of cases .............................................................................................................. 15 3.2. Baku (Azerbaijan) ............................................................................................................... 18 3.3. Cozumel (Mexico) .............................................................................................................. 27 3.4. Great Barrier Reef (Australia) ............................................................................................. 40 3.5. Juist (Germany) ................................................................................................................. 50 3.6. Kasane (Botswana) ............................................................................................................ 66 3.7. Lombok (Indonesia) ........................................................................................................... 75 3.8. Muskoka (Canada) ............................................................................................................. 93 3.9. Ohrid (Macedonia) ........................................................................................................... 107 3.10. Rigi (Switzerland) ............................................................................................................. 123 3.11. Soweto (South Africa) ...................................................................................................... 139 3.12. Vienna (Austria) ............................................................................................................... 155 4. Results ................................................................................................................................ 174 4.1. Similarities & differences ................................................................................................. 174 4.2. Challenges & solutions ..................................................................................................... 187 4.2.1. Drivers of overcrowding ................................................................................................ 188 4.2.2. Factors determining carrying capacity ........................................................................... 190 4.2.3. Challenges of overtourism ............................................................................................. 192 4.2.4. Solutions ....................................................................................................................... 194 4.3. Limitations of the study ................................................................................................... 197 4.4. Conclusions & recommendations ..................................................................................... 198 4.4.1. Summary of results ....................................................................................................... 198 4.4.2. General conclusions ...................................................................................................... 200 4.4.3. Recommendations ........................................................................................................ 201 5. References ......................................................................................................................... 203 6. Annex ................................................................................................................................. 206 6.1. Analysis framework ......................................................................................................... 206 6.2. Technical Appendix .......................................................................................................... 211 Tourism destinations under pressure Page 4/214 List of figures Figure 1: Comparative case study design ....................................................................................... 9 Figure 2: World map with cases analysed .................................................................................... 15 Figure 3: Different aspects of overtourism ................................................................................. 187 Figure 4: Basic model of a tourism destination ........................................................................... 188 Figure 5: Drivers of overcrowding .............................................................................................. 189 Figure 6: Factors determining carrying capacity ............................................................................ 190 Figure 7: Challenges of overtourism ............................................................................................ 192 Figure 8: Solutions ..................................................................................................................... 194 Figure 9: Components analysed ................................................................................................. 198 List of tables Table 1: Overview of cases........................................................................................................... 16 Table 2: Key figures of tourism in countries ............................................................................... 175 Table 3: Country rankings .......................................................................................................... 175 Table 4: Tourism demand in destinations analysed (2015) ......................................................... 177 Table 5: Carrying capacity affected ............................................................................................ 180 Table 6: Drivers of overcrowding ............................................................................................... 189 Table 7: Factors determining carrying capacity ............................................................................. 190 Table 8: Challenges of overtourism ............................................................................................ 192 Table 9: Solutions .....................................................................................................................