Copy of 070323 ICSID Precedents

Transnational Dispute Management transnational-dispute-management.com

This document will be updated on a Table A: basis. Please check the TDM website for the latest verson. Precedent in ICSID Arbitration 1972 - 2006

An introduction and more background by J.P. Commission information to this table can be found in the paper "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" by Jeffery P. Commission.

All of the Tables, A-E, will be updated on a regular basis, and posted on TDM. In addition, at the conclusion of the second phase (a qualitative analysis of how precedents have been treated by About TDM investment treaty tribunals over time), a collection of fully searchable issue- TDM (Transnational Dispute Management): Focusing on based precedents tables that will chart decisions on contentious issues over recent developments in the area of Investment arbitration time will be available, also on TDM. At and Dispute Management, regulation, treaties, judicial and present, the issue-based tables are as arbitral cases, voluntary guidelines, tax and contracting. follows:

Table F: Umbrella Clauses; Visit www.transnational-dispute-management.com Table G: MFN Treatment; for full Terms & Conditions and subscription rates, Table H: Waiting Periods;

Table I: Fair and Equitable Treatment; Open to all to read and to contribute and Table J: State of Necessity.

Our aim is for TDM to become the hub of a global professional and academic network. Therefore we invite all those with an interest in Investment arbitration and Dispute Management to contribute. We are looking mainly for short comments on recent developments of broad interest. We would like where possible for such comments to be backed-up by provision of in-depth notes and articles (which we will be published in our 'knowledge bank') and primary legal and regulatory materials.

Please contact Editor-in-Chief Thomas Wälde at [email protected] if you would like to participate in this global network: we are ready to publish relevant and quality contributions with name, photo, and brief biographical

description - but we will also accept anonymous ones where there is a good reason. We do not expect contributors to

produce long academic articles (though we publish a select Editor-in-Chief number of academic studies either as an advance version or Thomas W. Wälde an TDM-focused republication), but rather concise comments [email protected] from the author's professional ’workshop’. Professor & Jean-Monnet Chair CEPMLP/Dundee TDM is linked to OGEMID, the principal internet information & discussion forum in the area of oil, gas, energy, mining, infrastructure and investment disputes moderated by Thomas © Copyright TDM 2007 TDM Cover v1.1 Wälde.

TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

NUMBER OF ICSID ICSID DECISIONS, AWARD / DECISION PANEL / OTHER DECISIONS, AWARDS, CASE DECISIONS, AWARDS, AND OTHER SOURCES CITED (Date) COMMITTEE AND ORDERS CITED AWARDS, AND ORDERS CITED ORDERS CITED

I. INVESTMENT TREATY AWARDS, DECISIONS AND ORDERS (Pages 1-21)

2006

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Le Robert French Dictionary; Cambridge International Dictionary of English; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention: A Patrick Mitchell; MINE; Commentary; S. Manciaux, "Investissements étrangers et Metalclad (AF); Goetz; arbitrage entre Etats et ressortissants d’autres Etats – Middle East Cement; Trente ans d’activité du CIRDI"; Council of the 151. Decision on the Antonias Dimolitsa Patrick Mitchell v. CSOB; Salini v. DECISIONS: Gabcikovo-Nagymaros European Communities, "Community Position on Application for (President), Robert Democratic Republic of the Morocco; Fedax; Alcoa (ICJ); Case Concerning the Arbitral 16 Investment Protection Principles in the African, Annulment of the Award S.M. Dossou, Congo, ICSID Case No. (1975); Tradex Hellas; Award of 31 July 1989, 12 November Caribbean and Pacific States"; Guidelines on the (1 November 2006) Andrea Giardina ARB/99/7 (US/DRC BIT) SGS v. Pakistan; SGS v. 1991, Guinea-Bissau v. Senegal (ICJ) Treatment of Foreign Direct Investment Issued by the Philippines; Holiday Development Committee; Y. Nouvel, “Les mesures Inns; Amco Asia; Wena équivalant à une expropriation dans la pratique récente Hotels; Vivendi (2002) des tribunaux arbitraux”; A.A. Fatouros, Government Guarantees to Foreign Investors; D. Carreau and Patrick Julliard, Droit international economique; 2004 US Model BIT

Champion Trading AWARDS: Pope & Talbot Robert Briner Company and Ameritrade (UNCITRAL); United States – 150. Award (27 October (President), L. Yves International, Inc. v. Arab Champion Trading; Restrictions on Imports of Cotton and CONVENTIONS: US-Egypt BIT; ICSID Convention; 3 2006) Fortier, Laurent Republic of Egypt, ICSID Goetz; Tecmed (AF); Man-made Fibre Underwear, RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules Aynès Case No. ARB/02/9 (WT/DS24/AB/R), February 10, 1997 (US/Egypt BIT) (WTO)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: ILC Draft Articles on State Responsibility; J. Crawford, Second Report on State LG&E; Amco Asia; Responsibility; J. Crawford, The International Law LG&E Energy Corp., Vivendi; Wena Hotels; Commission’s Articles on State Responsibility; K. Tatiana B. de DECISIONS: Oscar Chinn affair, 1934 LG&E Capital Corp. and Asian Agricultural Strupp, Les règles générales du Droit de la paix; ALI, Maekelt (PCIJ); ELSI (ICJ); AWARDS: Pope & 148. Decision on LG&E International Inc. v. Products; MTD; Genin; Restatement (Third) of the Foreign Relations Law of the (President), Talbot; S.D. Myers; Lauder; CME; Liability (3 October Argentine Republic, ICSID 14 Mondev (AF); Tecmed United States; K.J. Vandevelde, United States Investment Francisco Rezek, Occidental Exploration v. Ecuador 2006) Case No. ARB/02/1 (AF); Azinian (AF); CMS Treaties: Policy and Practice; OECD, "Fair and Equitable Albert Jan van den (LCIA); Too v. Greater Modesto (US/Argentina BIT) Gas; Metalclad (AF); Treatment Standard in International Investment Law"; C. Berg Insurance Associates (1989) (Iran-US) Waste Management (AF); Schreuer, The ICSID Convention: A Commentary; E. SGS v. Philippines Gaillard and Y. Banifetami, "The Meaning of 'and' in Article 42(1), second sentence, of the Washington Convention: The Role of International Law in the ICSID choice of the law process"

DECISIONS: Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); MTD; SGS v. Gabcikovo-Nagymaros (ICJ); LaGrand ADC Affiliate Limited and Philippines; Generation CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration (ICJ); Arrest Warrant (ICJ); Avena Neil Kaplan ADC & ADMC Ukraine; Fedax; CMS Rules; PUBLICISTS: M. Weiniger & M. Page, Treaty (ICJ); Papmichalopoulos and Others v. 147. Award (2 October (President), Charles Management Limited v. Gas; Enron Corp.; Tokios Arbitration and Investment Disputes: Adding up the 12 Greece (ECHR); AWARDS: Texas 2006) Brower, Albert Jan Republic of Hungary, Tokeles; Olguin; Costs; M. Whiteman, Damages in International Law; Overseas Petroleum Co. v. Libya; van den Berg ICSID Case No. ARB/03/16 Metalclad (AF); Middle Oppenheim's International Law; I. Brownlie, Principles Petrobart; S.D. Myers, Inc.; Phillips (Cyprus/Hungary BIT) East Cement; Santa of Public International Law Petroleum Co. Iran v. Iran; Amoco Elena; CSOB International Finance Corp. v. Iran

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Biwater Gauff (Tanzania) Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The 146. Procedural Order Bernard Hanotiau Limited v. United Republic Amco Asia; Metalclad ICSID Convention: A Commentary; P. Friedland, No. 3 (29 September (President), Toby of Tanzania, ICSID Case 4 (AF); Loewen (AF); AWARDS: Glamis Gold; S.D. Myers "Provisional Measures and ICSID Arbitration"; M. 2006) Landau, Gary Born No. ARB/05/22) Aguas Argentinas; Kinnear, "Transparency and Third Party Participation in (UK/Tanzania BIT) Investor-State Dispute Settlement"; UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration

Metalclad (AF); Feldman DECISIONS: Oil Platforms (ICJ); CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Hungary-Norway (AF); Tecmed (AF); Telenor Mobile AWARDS: CME; Biloune and Marine BIT; Hungary-Cyprus BIT; Hungary-China BIT; Hungary Santa Elena; Generation Roy Goode Communications AS v. Drive Complex Ltd. v. Ghana; In the Netherlands BIT; Hungary-Spain BIT; Hungary-UK BIT; Ukraine; Waste 145. Award (13 (President), Republic of Hungary, Matter of Revere Copper and Brass, Inc. Hungary-Finland BIT; Hungary-Greece BIT; RULES: 13 Management (AF); Salini September 2006) Nicholas W. Allard, ICSID Case No. v. Overseas Private Investment Corp.; ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, v. Jordan; Plama; SGS v. Arthur L. Marriott ARB/04/15) S.D. Myers; Pope & Talbot; Tippetts; "The Concept of Expropriation under the ETC and other Philippines; Maffezini; (Norway/Hungary BIT) Starrett Housing; George E. Davidson; Investment Protection Treaties"; R. Dolzer, "Indirect Siemens; Gas Natural; Foremost Teheran Expropriations: New Developments" Suez (2006)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 1 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

MTD Equity (2005); 144. Decision on the MINE (1988); Amco Argentine Republic's Gilbert Guillaume CMS Gas Transmission (1986); Amco (1992); DECISIONS: German interests in CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Request for a Continued (President), James Company v. Argentina , Wena Hotels (2001); Upper Silesia (PCIJ); Pulp Mills on the 8 Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The Stay of Enforcement of R. Crawford, Nabil ICSID Case No. ARB/01/8 CDC Group (2004); River Uruguay (ICJ); Ekmedjian v. ICSID Convention: A Commentary the Award (1 September Elaraby (US/Argentina BIT) Patrick Mitchell (2004); Sofovich (Argentina) 2006) Repsol YPF Ecuador (2005)

Suez, Sociedad General de Aguas de Barcelona S.A., and Vivendi Universal S.A. Jeswald W. v. the Argentine Republic Salacuse (France/Argentina BIT, and 143. Procedural Order (President), RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; UNCITRAL Spain/Argentina BIT), 0 No. 2 (3 August 2006) Gabrielle Arbitration Rules ICSID Case No. Kaufmann-Kohler, ARB/03/19, and AWG Pedro Nikken Group Ltd. v. the Argentine Republic (Argentina/UK BIT), UNCITRAL

CONVENTIONS: United Nations Treaty Series; Bilateral Investment Treaty Argentina - UK; Bilateral Suez, Sociedad General de Azurix (2003); Siemens Investment Treaty Argentina - Spain; Bilateral Aguas de Barcelona S.A., (2004); Plama (2005); Investment Treaty Argentina - France; NAFTA; Vienna and Vivendi Universal S.A. DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction Jeswald W. Maffezini (2000); Salini Convention on the Law of Treaties; ICSID Convention; v. the Argentine Republic (ICJ); East Timor case, Portugal v. Salacuse v. Morocco (2001); PUBLICISTS: C. H. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention: 142. Decision on (France/Argentina BIT, and Australia (ICJ); AWARDS: Pope & (President), Enron (2004); MTD A Commentary; Report of the Executive Directors on the Jurisdiction (3 August Spain/Argentina BIT), 10 Talbot (2001); Methanex (2002); CME Gabrielle Equity (2004); CMS Gas Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes 2006) ICSID Case No. (2001) Kaufmann-Kohler, (2003); Vivendi (2002); between States and Nationals of Other States; RULES: ARB/03/19, and AWG Pedro Nikken Lanco (1998) UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules; ICSID Arbitration Rules; Group Ltd. v. the Argentine NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Argentine Republic (Argentina/UK State Reform Law No. 23,696; Argentine Convertibility BIT), UNCITRAL Law No. 23,928; Argentine Law No. 25,561; Argentine Decree No. 2074/1990; Argentine Decree No. 999/92

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Report of the Executive Directors; E. Gaillard and J. Savage, Fouchard Gaillard Goldman on International Commercial Arbitration; Statute of the ICJ; Arellano Garcia Carlos, Derecho Internacional Privado; Diccionario Juridico Mexicano; Diez Picazo, Rodrigo Oreamuno Inceysa Vallisoletana S.L. Tokios Tokeles; SPP; Fundamentos del Derecho Patrimonial; Monroy Cabra, 141. Award (2 August Blanco (President), v. Republic of El Salvador, 4 Amco Asia; Salini v. Marco Gerardo, Tratado de Derecho Internacional 2006) Burton A. Landy, ICSID Case No. ARB/03/26 Morocco Privado; Goldschmidt, Derecho Internacional Privado; Claus von Wobeser (Spain/El Salvador BIT) Constitution of the Republic of El Salvador; Foreigners Law of El Salvador; Investment Law of El Salvador; G. Born, International Commercial Arbitration; A. Redfern and M. Hunter, Law and Practice of International Commercial Arbitration; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Civil Code of El Salvador

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 2 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: BIT Argentina - USA; BIT Swiss - Azurix (2004); SGS v. Pakistan; BIT Swiss - Philippines; BIT Netherlands - Pakistan (2003); LG&E Poland; BIT Italy - Jordan; BIT Ecuador - United States (2004); SGS v. of America; BIT Argentina - France; ICSID Convention; Philippines (2004); NAFTA; VCLT; Locarno Arbitration Conventions Siemens (2004); Joy between Germany, and Belgium, France, Poland and Pan American Energy LLC DECISIONS: Mavrommatis (PCIJ); Machinery (2004); Gas Czechoslovakia; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; and BP Argentina Oil Platforms, 1996 (ICJ); East Timor Natural (2005); Plama ICSID Institution Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, Exploration Company v. (ICJ); Temple of Preah Vihear, (2005); Lanco (1998); The ICSID Convention: A Commentary; C. Schreuer, Lucius Caflisch Argentine Republic , ICSID Cambodia v. Thailand (ICJ); Barcelona 140. Decision on Maffezini (2000); Genin Travelling the BIT Route. Of Waiting Periods, Umbrella (President), Brigitte Case No. ARB/03/13 and Traction (ICJ); Interpretation of Peace Preliminary Objections 20 (2001); Salini v. Jordan Clauses and Forks in the Road; S. Schwebel, Stern, Albert Jan BP America Production Co. Treaties (ICJ); AWARDS: Pope & (27 July 2006) (2004); Enron (2004); International Arbitration: Three Salient Problems; D.W. van den Berg and Others v. Argentine Talbot (2000); Methanex (2002); CMS Gas (2003); Noble Bowett, Estoppel before International Tribunals and Its Republic , ICSID Case No. Occidental Exploration (2004); El Ventures (2005); Amco Relation to Acquiescence; P.B. Gann, The U.S. Bilateral ARB/04/8 (US/Argentina Triunfo (United States v. El Salvador) (1983); AAPL (1990); Investment Treaty Program; K. J. Vandevelde, United BIT) (1902); Eureko B.V. v. Poland (2005 Goetz (1999); Fedax States Investment Treaties: Policy and Practice; (1997); Vivendi (2002) NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Argentine Constitution; Argentine Law No. 17'319; Argentine Law No. 25'561; Argentine Law No. 25'820; Argentine Mining Code; Argentine Hydrocarbons Law; Argentine Decree 214/2002; Argentine Decree 181/2004

Vivendi (2000); Vivendi (2002); Consortium FRCC; Impregilo S.p.A. DECISIONS: Serbian Loans (PCIJ); (2005); Middle East Chorzów Factory (PCIJ); ELSI (ICJ); In CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of Cement (2002); Goetz the case of James and Others (ECHR); the Treaties; ICSID; PUBLICISTS: R. Higgins, “The (1999); Metalclad (AF) AWARDS: Lauder v. Czech Republic Taking of Property by the state: Recent Developments in (2000); Tecmed (AF); (2001); S.D. Myers v. Canada (2000); International Law”; F.A. Mann, “British Treaties for the SGS v. Pakistan (2003); Occidental Exploration; Pope and Promotion and Protection of Investments,”; UNCTAD, SGS v. Philippines Talbot; CME; Lena Goldfields v. Soviet “Fair and Equitable Treatment,”; Oxford English Andres Rigo Sureda Azurix v. Argentine (2004); Waste Union; Woodruff (US - Venezuelan Dictionary; Diccionario de la lengua española; Black’s 139. Award (14 July (President), Marc Republic , ICSID Case No. Management; Santa Mixed Commission); Neer Case (US v. 24 Law Dictionary; International Glossary of Business 2006) Lalonde, Daniel ARB/01/12 (US/Argentina Elena (2000); Feldman Mexico); BP Exploration Company Ltd. Valuation Terms, American Society of Appraisers; Hugo Martins BIT) (AF); Generation Ukraine v. Government of the Libyan Arab Christoph Schreuer, “Unjust Enrichment in International (2003); Wena Hotels; Republic; Govt. of the State of Kuwait Law"; Bryce Dickson, “Unjust Enrichment Claims: a Genin (2001); Azinian v. the American Independent Oil Comparative Overview”; G. Bonet, “L’enrichissement (AF) (1999); Mondev Company; Malek v. Iran; Int’l sans cause, droit privé et droit public”; Jason W. Neyers, (AF) (2002); Maffezini; Technical Prods. Corp. v. Iran; Sea- Mitchell McInnes & Stephen G.A. Pitel, Understanding ADF Group (AF) (2003); Land Service, Inc. v. Iran; Phillips Unjust Enrichment Loewen (AF); CMS Gas Petroleum v. Iran; Tippetts v. TAMS- (2003); Asian AFFA Consulting Engineers of Iran Agricultural Products (1990); AMT (1997)

RFCC (2001); Salini v. Morocco (2001); Pierre Tercier L.E.S.I. S.p.A. et ASTALDI CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Autopista (2001); Fedax 138. Decision (12 July (President), André S.p.A. v. Alergia , ICSID Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID 8 (1999); CSOB (1999); 2006) Faurès, Emmanuel Case No. ARB/05/3 Convention: A Commentary; Yala, Les Cahiers de SGS v. Pakistan (2003); Gaillard (Italy/Algeria BIT) L'Arbitrage SGS v. Philippines (2004); Maffezini (2000)

AES Corporation (2005); CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; 1977 BIT (Belgo- Impreglio (2005); Luxembourg Eco. Union - Egypt); 2002 BIT (Belgo- Jan de Nul N.V., Dredging Bayindir (2005); Vivendi Gabrielle Luxembourg Eco. Union - Egypt); RULES: ICSID International N.V. v. Arab (2002); LESI (2004); 137. Decision on Kaufmann-Kohler Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Report of the Exec. Republic of Egypt, ICSID Salini v. Morocco DECISIONS: Oil Platforms, 1996 Jurisdiction (16 June (President), Pierre 10 Directors on the ICSID Convention, 18 March 1965; S. Case No. ARB/04/13 (2001); Joy Mining (ICJ) 2006) Mayer, Brigitte Alexandrov, "The 'Baby Boom' of Treaty-Based (Belgo-Luxembourg/Egypt (2004); Generation Stern Arbitrations and the Jurisdiction of ICSID Tribunals: BIT) Ukraine (2003); Waste Shareholders as 'Investors' and Jursdiction Rationae Management (2004); Temporis" Lucchetti (2005)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 3 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

DECISIONS: Mapother v. Dep't of Justice (US); Renegotiations Bd. v. Biwater (Gauff) Tanzania Grumman Aircraft Engineering Corp. Bernard Hanotiau Ltd. v. United Republic of (US); Conway v. Rimmer (UK); S. v. 136. Procedural Order CONVENTION: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration (President), Toby Tanzania, ICSID Case No. 1 SPP Sodhi Sukhdev (UK); Rogers v. No. 2 (24 May 2006) Rules; IBA Rules of Evidence Landau, Gary Born ARB/05/22 (UK/Tanzania Secretary of State for the Home BIT) Department (UK); AWARDS: Pope & Talbot (2000, 2005); BP Exploration Ltd. v. Libya

Karl-Heinz Noble Ventures, Inc. v. Böckstiegel 135. Rectification of Romania, ICSID Case No. CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration (President), Jeremy 0 Award (19 May 2006) ARB/01/11 Rules Lever, Pierre-Marie (US/Romania BIT) Dupuy

CMS Gas (2003); Suez, Sociedad General de Vivendi (2002); Lanco Jeswald W. Aguas de Barcelona S.A., (1998); Salini v. CONVENTIONS: BIT (Argentina-France); BIT Salacuse and InterAguas Servicios DECISIONS: East Timor (ICJ); 134. Decision on Morocco (2001); Azurix (Argentina-Spain); ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID (President), Integrales del Agua S.A. v. Barcelona Traction (ICJ); AWARDS: Jurisdiction (16 May 10 (2003); Enron (2003); Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The Gabrielle The Argentine Republic , Methanex; Pope & Talbot; CME Czech 2006) Siemens (2004); ICSID Convention; Report of the Exec. Directors on the Kauffmann-Kohler, ICSID Case No. ARB/03/17 Republic Maffezini (2000); Plama ICSID Convention, 18 March 1965 Pedro Nikken (France/Argentina BIT and (2005); MTD Equity Spain/Argentina BIT) (2004)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rodrigo Oreamuno Metalpar S.A. and Buen Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID Enron (2004); Camuzzi 133. Decision on Blanco (President), Aire S.A. v. Argentine Convention: A Commentary; C. Schreuer, the Course on (2005); Sempra (2005); Jurisdiction (27 April Duncan H. Republic, ICSID Case No. 6 Dispute Settlement in International trade, Investment and LG&E (2004); CMS Gas 2006) Cameron, Jean Paul ARB/03/5 (Argentina/Chile Intellectual Property; 2.3 consent to arbitration; Report of (2003); Azurix (2003) Chabaneix BIT) the Exec. Directors on the ICSID Convention, 18 March 1965

Gas Natural (2005); Amco (1983); Siemens (2004); Generation Ukraine (2003); Waste Management II (2004); Azurix (2003); LG&E CONVENTIONS: BIT (Argentina-US); ICSID; (2004); SGS v. DECISIONS: Oil Platforms, 1996 RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. El Paso Energy Lucius Caflisch Philippines (2004); (ICJ); East Timor Case (ICJ); Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; E. Gaillard, MFN, 132. Decision on International Company v. (President), Brigitte Noble Ventures (2005); Interpretation of Peace Treaties (ICJ); NYLJ, 6 October 2005; S. Schwebel, International Jurisdiction (27 April The Argentine Republic , 19 Stern, Piero SGS v. Pakistan (2003); Mavrommatis (PCIJ); AWARDS: Arbitration: Three Salient Problems, 1987; C. Schreuer, 2006) ICSID Case No. ARB/03/15 Bernardini Salini v. Jordan (2004); Methanex; Eureko B.V.; GAMI; "Travelling the BIT Route, Of Waiting Periods, Umbrella (US/Argentina BIT) Joy Mining (2004); Occidental Clauses and Forks in the Road" (2004); 2004 US Model Vivendi (2002); CMS BIT Gas (2003); Enron (2004); Lanco (1998); CSOB (1999); Tradex Hellas (1996); Mondev (2002)

Suez, Sociedad General de Jeswald W. Aguas de Barcelona S.A. Salacuse and InterAguas Servicios 131. Procedural Order (President), Integrales del Agua S.A. v. CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration 0 No. 1 (14 April 2006) Gabrielle Argentine Republic , ICSID Rules Kaufmann-Kohler, Case No. ARB/03/17 Pedro Nikken (France/Argentina BIT, and Spain/Argentina BIT)

Biwater (Gauff) Tanzania Bernard Hanotiau Ltd. v. United Republic of Plama (2005); Agip CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration 130. Procedural Order (President), Toby Tanzania , ICSID Case No. 3 (1979); Vacuum Salt Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID No. 1 (31 March 2006) Landau, Gary Born ARB/05/22 (UK/Tanzania (1994) Convention BIT)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 4 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

Aguas Provinciales de Jeswald W. Santa Fe S.A., Suez, 129. Order in Response Salacuse Sociedad General de Aguas CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration to a Petition for (President), de Barcelona S.A. and 1 Aguas Argentinas (2005) AWARDS: Methanex, 2001 Rules; PUBLICISTS: North American FTC, Statement Participation as Amicus Gabrielle InterAguas Servicios on Non-Disputing Party Participation, 7 October 2003 Curiae (17 March 2006) Kaufmann-Kohler, Integrales del Agua S.A. v. Pedro Nikken Argentine Republic , ICSID Case No. ARB/03/17

Rodrigo Oreamuno Western NIS Enterprise 128. Order Concerning (President), Jan Fund v. Ukraine, ICSID Proper Notice of Claim 0 Paulsson, Michael Case No. ARB/04/2 (16 March 2006) Pryles (US/Ukraine BIT)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; NAFTA; BIT (US- Argentina); Treaty of Friendship, Commerce and Navigatin (Italy-US); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; Impreglio (2005); SGS v. PUBLICISTS: UNCTAD, Bilateral Investment Treaties Giorgio Sacerdoti Continental Casualty Phillipines (2004); CMS DECISIONS: Oil Platforms (ICJ); 127. Decision on in the Mid-1990's; UNCTAD, IIA Series, Scope and (President), V.V. Company v. Argentina , Gas (2003); Lanco Legality of Use of Force, Yugoslavia v. Jurisdiction (22 February 7 Definition, reptrined in UNCTAD, International Veeder, Michell ICSID Case No. ARB/03/9 (1998); Azurix (2003); Italy (ICJ); Barcelona Traction (ICJ); 2006) Investment Agreements: Key Issues; F.A. Mann, Foreign Nader (US/Argentina BIT) Enron (2004); Maffezini ELSI (ICJ); AWARDS: Methanex Investment in the International Court of Justice, AJIL 86; (2000) Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, annexed to UN GA 56/83 of 12 December 2001

Repsol YPF Ecuador, S.A. Judd L. Kessler CONVENTIONS: ICSID; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, v. Empresa Estatal CDC Group (2004); 126. Procedural Order (President), Piero The ICSID Convention; P. Friedland, "Stay of Petroleos Del Ecuador 3 Mitchell (2004); Wena No. 4 (22 February 2006) Bernardini, Enforcement of the Arbitral Award Pending ICSID (PetroEcuador) , ICSID Hotels (2002) Gonzalo Biggs Annulment Proceedings" Case No. ARB 01/10

DECISIONS: Asylum case (ICJ); Nicaragua, 1984 (ICJ); Fisheries Case, UK v. Norway (ICJ); Qatar and Bahrain (ICJ); Aegean Sea Continental Shelf Case, Greece v. Turkey (ICJ); Legal CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Jordan-Italy); Statute of Status of Eastern Greenland - Denmark the Iran - United States Claims Tribunal; RULES: ICSID v. Norway (PCIJ); AWARDS: Queen's Metalclad (AF) (2000); Arbitration Rules: UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules; case Bratie v. Sweden and Norway - 26 Gilbert Guillaume Salini Costruttori S.p.A. Tecmed (AF) (2003); PUBLICISTS: Craig, Park and Paulsson, ICC March 1972; La Pradelle et Politis - (President), and Italstrade S.p.A. v. MTD Equity (2004); Arbitration; Daillier et Pellet, Droit international public; 124. Final Award (31 RAI Tome II, p. 708; Heathrow Airport Bernardo Jordan , ICSID Case No. 7 SOABI (1988); Asian Joe Verhoeven, Droit International public, Larcier; January 2006) User Charges Case; Guinea Bissau v. Cremades, Ian ARB/02/13 (Italy/Jordan Agricultural Products McNair, The Law of Treaties; Oppenheim's International Senegal; Arbitration between Sinclair BIT) (1990); Tradex Hellas Law; Waldock, Report to the ILC, 26 March 1962; Newfoundland and Labrador and Nova (1999); MINE (1989); Gotanda, Awarding Costs and Attorney's Fees in Scotia, Award of Tribunal (2001); Iron International Commerical Arbitration 1999 Mich. JIL; C. Rhine Railway Arbitration; Arbitral Schreuer, the ICSID Convention Award on 17 August 1889 between Germany and GB; Arbitral award rendered on 10 January 1927 by romanian-hungarian mixed arbitral tribunal; Island of Palmas Case

2005

Repsol YPF Ecuador, S.A. Judd L. Kessler CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration 123. Procedural Order v. Empresa Estatal CDC Group (2004); (President), Piero Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID No. 1 (22 December Petroleos Del Ecuador 3 Mitchell (2004); Wena Bernardini, Convention; P. Friedland, "Stay of Enforcement of the 2005) (PetroEcuador) , ICSID Hotels (2002) Gonzalo Biggs Arbitral Award Pending ICSID Annulment Proceedings" Case No. ARB 01/10

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 5 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

Amco (1998); CSOB (1999); LETCO (1986); CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; BIT (France- Goetz (1999); Gas Argentina); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; Natural (2005); AAPL PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; P. J. William Rowley Compañiá de Aguas del (1990); AMT (1997); Lalive, "The First 'World Bank' Arbitration (Holiday Inns (President), Aconquija S.A. and Vivendi Lanco (1998); Maffezini DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction 122. Decision on v. Morocco) - Some Legal Problems; B. Cheng, General Gabrielle Universal v. Argentine (2000); Genin (2001); (ICJ); Aerial Incident at Lockerbie Jurisdiction (14 19 Principles of Law Applied By International Courts and Kaufmann-Kohler, Republic , ICSID Case No. CMS Gas (2003); Azurix (ICJ); Arrest Warrant (ICJ); AWARDS: November 2005) Tribunals; B. Hanotiau, The res judicata effect of arbitral Carlos Bernal ARB/97/3 (2003); Enron (2004); GAMI; CME Czech Republic awards; Schwarzenberger, International Law; UNCTAD, Verea (France/Argentina BIT) Siemens (2004); AES Dispute Settlement, ICSID; International Law (2005); Sempra (2005); Commission's Draft Articles on Responsibility of States Camuzzi (2005); CMS for internationally wrongful Acts 2001 Gas (2005); Azinian (AF) (1999)

CONVENTIONS: Bilateral Investment Treaty (Turkey - Pakistan); New York Convention; Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties; ASEAN Agreement for the Impreglio (2005); AES Promotion and Protection of Investment; North American (2005); LESI (2004); Free Trade Agreement 1994; RULES: ICSID Arbitration SGS v. Pakistan (2003); Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, "Commentary on the Salini v. Morocco ICSID Convention"; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Gabrielle Bayindir Insaat Turizm (2001); Autopista (2001); Convention; UNCTAD, Scope and Definition, UNCTAD DECISIONS: US Diplomatic and Kaufmann-Kohler Ticaret Ve Sanayi A.S. v. Joy Mining (2004); Series on issues in international investment agreements; 121. Decision on Consular Staff (ICJ); Nicaragua, 1986 (President), Islamic Republic of Siemens (2004); Vivendi N. Rubins, "The Notion of 'Investment' in International Jurisdiction (14 17 (ICJ); Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); Franklin Berman, Pakistan , (2002); Camuzzi (2005); Investment Arbitration"; Report of the Executive November 2005) AWARDS: Methanex, 2005; Lauder; Karl-Heinz ICSID Case No. ARB/03/29 RFCC (2003); SGS v. Directors on ICSID, 18 March 1965; D. Carreau et al, UPS; Pope & Talbot Böckstiegel (Turkey/Pakistan BIT) Philippines (2004); Salini Droit International Economique; B. Creamdes and D.J.A. v. Jordan (2004); Plama Cairns, "Contract and Treaty Claims and Choice of (2005); Tecmed (2003); Forum in Foreign Investment Disputes"; E. Gaillard, Waste Management "Investment Treaty Arbitration and Jurisdiction Over (2000, 2004) Contract Claims - the SGS Cases Considered"; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Pakistani Act No. XI (National Highway Authority Act 1991); Pakistani Arbitration Act 1940

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Statute of the Permanent Court of International Justice; RULES: DECISIONS: Chorzów Factory (PCIJ); ICSID Arbitration Rules; ICC Arbitration Rules; Asylum Case, Colombia v. Peru (ICJ); PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention: A 120. Decision on Klaus Sachs Wena Hotels Ltd. v. Arab Delimitation of the Continental Shelf, Commentary; Craig, Park and Paulsson, International Wena Hotels (1999); Application for (President), Ibrahim Republic of Egypt , ICSID U.K. v. France (ICJ); Continental Shelf, Chamber of Commerce Arbitration; Fouchard, Gaillard 3 Wena Hotels (2000); Interpretation of Award Fadlallah, Carl F. Case No. ARB/98/4 Tunisia v. Libya (ICJ); AWARDS: and Goldmann, On International Commercial Feldman (2003) (31 October 2005) Salans (UK/Egypt BIT) Case No. 498, "Panacaviar, S.A. v Iran, Arbitration; Daly, Correction and Interpretation of & Sherkat Sahami Shilat Iran", Award Arbitral Awards under the ICC Rules of Arbitration; No. ITM 64-498-1 (1986) Craig, Park and Paulsson, Annoted Guide to the 1998 ICC Arbitration Rules; Poudret and Besson, Droit comparé de l'arbitrage international

CONVENTIONS: BIT (Netherlands-Albania); BIT (Netherlands-Estonia); BIT (Netherlands-Latvia); BIT (Netherlands-Nigeria); BIT (Netherlands-Venezuela); BIT (Netherlands-Bangladesh); BIT (Netherlands- Jamaica); BIT (Netherlands-Peru); BIT (Netherlands- Poland); BIT (Netherlands-Czech and Slovak Republic); Autopista (2001); Azurix BIT (Netherlands-Argentina); BIT (Netherlands- (2003); Cable TV (1997); Romania); BIT (Bolivia-Peru); BIT (Bolivia-Argentina); David D. Caron Aguas del Tunari S.A. v. Lanco (1998); Vacuum Vienna Convention on Law of Treaties; PUBLICISTS: 119. Decision on (President), José Republic of Bolivia , ICSID Salt (1994); Vivendi DECISIONS: Temple of Preah Vihear, G. Schwarzenberger, "Myths and Realities of Treaty Jurisdiction (21 October Luis Alberro- 11 Case No. ARB/02/3 (2000); Vivendi (2002); Cambodia v. Thailand (ICJ) Interpretation: Articles 27-29 of the Vienna Draft 2005) Semerna, Henri C. (Netherlands/Bolivia BIT) SGS v. Philippines Convention on the Law of Treaties; A. Barak, Judicial Alvarez (2004); LETCO (1986, Discretion; H. Lauterpacht, "Restrictive Interpretation 1986); Banro (2000) and the Principle of Effectiveness in the Interpretation of Treaties"; ILC Report on Work of its 8th Session; O. Spiermann, "State Interests and the Power to Waive ICSID Jurisdiction under Bilateral Investment Treaties; D. Shea, the Calvo Clause: A problem of Inter-American and International law and Diplomacy; N. Blackaby et al., International Arbitration in Latin America

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 6 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

PUBLICISTS: U. Drobnig, "Private International Law" in III Encycpledia of Public International Law; J.P. Muller and T. Cottier, "Estoppel" in II Encyclopedia of Public International Law; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; Rand, Hornick, and Friedland, "ICSID's Emerging Jurisprudence"; M. Hirsch, The Arbitration Mechanism of the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes; Webster's Third New International Dictionary; Encarta World English Aguas del Tunari S.A. v. Republic of Bolivia , ICSID Case No. ARB/02/3 Dictionary; Oxford English Dictionary; Black's Law (Netherlands/Bolivia BIT) CONTINUED Dictionary; R. Dolzer and M. Stevens, Bilateral Investment Treaties; Report of the Executive Directors in ICSID Convention, 1965; A. Broches, "The Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes Between States and Nationals of Other States"; Documents Concerning the Origin and the Formulation of the ICSID Convention; C.F. Amerasinghe, "Jurisdiction Rationae Personae Under the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of other states

SGS v. Pakistan (2003); Karl-Heinz Noble Ventures, Inc. v. SGS v. Philippines CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of Böckstiegel 118. Final Award (12 Romania , ICSID Case No. (2004); Salini v. Jordan DECISIONS: ELSI (ICJ); Chorzow Treaties; ICSID; PUBLICISTS: ILC Articles on State (President), Jeremy 5 October 2005) ARB/01/11 (2004); Asian Factory (PCIJ); AWARDS: GAMI Responsibility; S. Schwebel, International Arbitration: Lever, Pierre-Marie (US/Romania BIT) Agricultural Prodcuts Three Salient Problems Dupuy (1990); AMT (1997)

Carl F. Salans Plama Consortium Limited 117. Order on SGS v. Pakistan (2002); CONVENTIONS: BIT (Bulgaria-Finland); BIT (Cyprus- (President), Albert v. Bulgaria , ICSID Case Provisional Measures (06 4 CSOB (1999); CSOB Bulgaria); ECT; FTAA; ICSID; NAFTA; VCLT; Jan van den Berg, No. ARB/03/24 September 2005) (2000); Amco (1983) RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules V.V. Veeder (Energy Charter Treaty)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Additional Facility; Bilateral Investment Treaty (Argentine-Spain); Bilateral Investment Treaty (Argentina-USA); Bilateral Investment Treaty (Argentina-Germany); Bilateral Investment Treaty (Italy-Jordan); ICSID Convention; New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards; Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties; RULES: ICSID Rules; UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules; Andreas F. CMS Gas (2003); Gas Natural SDG, S.A. v. PUBLICISTS: Report of the Executive Directors on 115. Decision on Lowenfeld Siemens (2004); The Argentine Republic, ICSID, 1965; Aron Broches, "The Convention on the Jurisdiction (17 June (President), Henri 5 Maffezini (2000); Salini ICSID Case No. ARB/03/10 Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and 2005) C. Alvarez, Pedro v. Jordan (2004); Azurix (Spain/Argentina BIT) Nationals of Other States"; A. Lowenfeld, International Nikken (2003) Economic Law; R. Dolzer, and M. Stevens, Bilateral Investment Treaties; T. McGhie, "Bilateral and Multilateral Investment Treaties"; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Argentine Law No 23.928 on Currency Convertibility, 1991; Argentine Decree No 2/28, 1991; Argentine Ley del Gas; Argentine Decreto del Gas; Argentine Reglas Básicas; Argentine Emergency Law (Ley de Emergencia)

Maffezini (2000); Vacuum Salt (1994); Camuzzi International S.A. Enrique Gómez- CMS (2003); Enron v. The Argentine Republic , CONVENTIONS: Statute of the International Court of 114. Decision on Pinzón (President), (2004); LG&E (2004); DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction ICSID Case No. ARB/03/7 Justice; BIT (Belgo-Luxembourg/Argentina); Free Trade Jurisdiction (10 June Héctor Gros 11 Amco; Vivendi; Salini v. (ICJ); AWARDS: Methanex, 2002; (Belgo- Agreement (Chile-USA); ICSID; NAFTA; VCLT; 2005) Espiell, Henri C. Morocco (2001); Wena GAMI Luxembourg/Argentina RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules Alvarez Hotels; Azurix (2003); BIT) SGS v. Philippines (2004)

113. Decision on Gilbert Guillaume MTD Equity Sdn. Bhd. & CDC Group (2004); Respondent's Request for CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration (President), James MTD Chile S.A. v. Chile , Amco (1986, 1992); a Continued Stay of 6 Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID R. Crawford, Sara ICSID Case No. ARB/01/7 MINE (1988); Wena Execution (1 June 2005) Convention Ordoñez Noriega (Malaysia/Chile BIT) Hotels (2004) (Annulment Proceeding)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 7 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

Aguas Argentinas S.A., Jeswald W. 112. Order in Response Suez, Sociedad General de CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Salacuse to a Petition for Aguas de Barcelona, Arbitration Rules; UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules; (President), Transparency and S.A.and Vivendi 0 AWARDS: Methanex, 2001; UPS PUBLICISTS: North American FT Commission, Gabrielle Participation as Amicus Universdal, S.A. v. "Statement on Non-Disputing Party Participation", 7 Kaufmann-Kohler, Curiae (19 May 2005) Argentine Republic, ICSID October 2003 Pedro Nikken Case No. ARB/03/19

CONVENTIONS: BIT (Argentina-US); BIT (Russia- USA); BIT (Bahrain-USA); Free Trade Agreement (Chile DECISIONS: Penn Central Trans. USA); GATT; ICSID; NAFTA; RULES: ICSID (US); Martini Case (US); ELSI (ICJ); Asian Agricultural Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: E. Gaillard and Y. Gabcikovo-Nagymoros (ICJ); Products (1990); Tecmed Banifatemi, "The Meaning of 'and' in Article 42(1), Nicaragua,1984 (ICJ); Nicaragua,1986 (AF); Klöckner; Amco Second Sentence, of the Washington Convention"; W.M. (ICJ); Oil Platforms, 2003 (ICJ); Asia; Wena Hotels Reisman, "The Regime for Lacunae in the ICSID Choice Societe Commerciale de Belgique (2002); Metalclad (AF) of Law Provision and the Question of its Threshold"; R. (PCIJ); Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); CMS Gas Transmission (2000); Santa Elena Higgins, "The Taking of Property by the State: Recent Francisco Orrego AWARDS: CME; Lauder; S.D Myers; Company v. The Argentine (2000); Azinian (AF); Developments in International Law"; G.A. Borda, 111. Final Award (12 Vicuña (President), Pope & Talbot; Tippetts; Phelps Dodge; Republic , 18 AMT (1997); Genin; Tratado de Derecho Civil; R. Stiglitz, Contratos Civiles y May 2005) Marc Lalonde, French Company of Venezuelan ICSID Case No. ARB/01/8 Goetz (1999); SGS v. Comerciales; R.H. Compagnucci de Caso, Manal de Francisco Rezek Railroads; Dickson Car Wheel Co.; Sea- (US/Argentina BIT) Pakistan (2003); Vivendi Obligaciones; P. Juillard, "L'evolution des sources du Land Services v. Iran; Russian (2000); SGS v. droit des investissements"; O. Schachter, International Indemnity Case; The Torrey Canyon; Philippines (2004); Joy Law in Theory and Practice; J. Crawford, The ILC Rainbow Warrior; Compagnie Generale Mining (2004); Feldman Commission's Articles on State Responsibility; E. Wyler, de l'Orinocco; Properties of the (AF) (2002); CMS L'Illicite et la Condition des Persons Privees; J. E. Bulgarian Minorities in Greece; Orr & (2003); Azurix (2003) Alvarez, "Political Protectionism and United States Laubenheimer; Gould Marketing; International Investment Obligations in Conflict"; F.V. Lusitania Garcia Amador, "The Changing Law of International Claims"

Azurix (2003); Vacuum Salt (1994); Lanco (1998); CMS (2003); Enron I (2004); Enron II CONVENTIONS: Statute of the International Court of (2004); Mondev (AF) Justice; Argentine Law No. 25561; Bilateral Investment (2002); Vivendi (2002); Camuzzi International S.A. Treaty (BLEU-Argentina); Free Trade Agreement (Chile- Francisco Orrego SGS v. Pakistan (2003); DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction v. The Argentine Republic , USA); ICSID Convention; North American Free Trade 110. Decision on Vicuña (President), Maffezini (2000); Goetz (ICJ); ELSI (ICJ); Advisory Op. ICSID Case No. ARB/03/2 Agreement; Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties; Jurisdiction (11 May Marc Lalonde, 19 (1999); Asian Concerning Western Sahara (ICJ); (Belgo- RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: 2005) Sandra Morelli Agricultural Products Serbian Loans (PCIJ); AWARDS: Luxembourg/Argentina McNair, Law of Treaties; J. Barberis, "Reflexions sur la Rico (1990); Genin (2001); Methanex, GAMI BIT) coutume internationale"; E. de la Guardia, "Derecho de Joy Mining (2004); Wena los Tratados Internacionales"; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Hotels (2002); SGS v. Convention: A Commentary Philippines (2004); MTD Equity (2004); Generation Ukraine (2003); LG&E (2004)

Azurix (2003); Vacuum Salt (1994); Lanco (1998); CMS (2003); Enron I (2004); Enron II (2004); Lucchetti (2005); Mondev (AF) (2002); DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction CONVENTIONS: ICSID; Statute of the International Vivendi (2002); SGS v. (ICJ); ELSI (ICJ); Advisory Op. Francisco Orrego Sempra Energy Court of Justice; BIT (Argentina-USA); Free Trade Pakistan (2003); Concerning Western Sahara (ICJ); 109. Decision on Vicuña (President), International v. The Agreement (Chile-USA); NAFTA; VCLT; RULES: Maffezini (2000); Goetz Nuclear Tests Case (ICJ); Serbian Jurisdiction (11 May Marc Lalonde, Argentine Republic , 20 ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: McNair, Law (1999); Asian Loans (PCIJ); AWARDS: Methanex, 2005) Sandra Morelli ICSID Case No. ARB/02/16 of Treaties; J. Barberis, "Reflexions sur la coutume Agricultural Products GAMI; Differens Concernant le Rico (US/Argentina BIT) internationale"; E. de la Guardia, "Derecho de los (1990); Genin (2001); Filetage a l'interieur du Golfe de Saint- Tratados Internacionales" Joy Mining (2004); Wena Laurent Hotels (2002); SGS v. Philippines (2004); MTD Equity (2004); Generation Ukraine (2003); LG&E (2004)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 8 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: Bilateral Investment Treaty (Argentina-USA); ICSID Convention; NAFTA; RULES: Vivendi (2000) Vivendi ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C.F. (2002); CMS Gas (2003); Amerasinghe, "The Jurisdiction of the International Azurix (2003); LG&E Pierre-Marie Dupuy Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes"; R. AES Corporation v. The (2004); Enron I (2004); 108. Decision on (President), Karl- DECISIONS: Case Concerning East Kovar, "La competence du Centre International pour le Argentine Republic , Siemens; SGS v. Pakistan Jurisdiction (26 April Heinz Böckstiegel, 14 Timor (ICJ); Abbott Laboratories v. reglement des differends relatifs aux investissements . . ICSID Case No. ARB/02/17 (2003); SGS v. 2005) Domingo Bello Gardner (US); AWARDS: Methanex ."; G.R. Delaume, "La Convention pour le relgement des (US/Argentina BIT) Philippines (2004); Janeiro differends relatifs aux investissements entre Etats et Enron II (2004); Holiday ressortissants d'autres Etats"; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Inns; Amco; Kaiser Convention; NATIONAL LAWS AND Bauxite; Lanco (1998) REGULATIONS: Argentine Executive Decree No 570/01; Argentine National Emergency Law No 25.561

Mihaly (2002); Klöckner (1983); Salini v. CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Bilateral Morocco (2001); Asian DECISIONS: Oil Platforms, 1996 Investment Treaty (Italy-Pakistan); Bilateral Investment Agricultural Products (ICJ); Ambatelios (ICJ); Legality Use of Treaty (Germany-Pakistan); Bilateral Investment Treaty (1990); AMT (1997); Force, 1999 (ICJ); AWARDS: ICC (Switzerland-Pakistan); Geneva Protocol on Arbitration Lanco (1998); CMS Gas Gilbert Guillaume Preminiary Award in Case no. 4983; Clauses, 1923; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; Impregilo S.p.A. v. Islamic (2003); Azurix (2003); 107. Decision on (President), ICC Interim Award in Case No. 5029 PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; Republic of Pakistan , Enron (2004); Vivendi Jurisdiction (22 April Bernardo 19 (1986); McHarg, Roberts, Wallace, C.F. Amerasinghe, Jurisdiction of International ICSID Case No. ARB/03/3 (2002); RFCC (2001); 2005) Cremades, Toby T. Todd v. Iran, Award 282010853-1; Tribunals; Report of the Executive Directors on ICSID, (Italy/Pakistan BIT) Cable TV (1997); SGS v. Landau Blount Brothers Corp. v. Iran; Hazra et 1965; Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties; Philippines (2004); SGS al v. Iran; Howard Neelds, Tammen & Articles of the International Law Commission on State v. Pakistan (2003); Wena Bergendorff v. Iran; Ian McHarg v. Iran; Responsibility; NATIONAL LAWS AND Hotels (1999); Joy Ethyl Corp. REGULATIONS: Pakistan Water and Power Mining (2004); RFCC Development Authority Act; Swiss Code of Obligations (2003); Metalclad (AF); CDSE (2000)

DECISIONS: Mavrommatis (PCIJ); Salini v. Jordan (2004); Oil Platforms Case, 1996 (ICJ); Carl F. Salans Plama Consortium Limited 106. Decision on SGS v. Philippines Nottebohm Case (ICJ); Case CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of (President), Albert v. Bulgaria , ICSID Case Jurisdiction (08 February 5 (2004); Siemens (2004); Concerning Rights of Nationals of Treaties; ICSID; PUBLICISTS: Bamberger, Lineham, Jan van den Berg, No. ARB/03/24 (Energy 2005) Maffezini (2000); America in Morocco (ICJ); Anglo- and Walde, "The Energy Charter Treaty in 2000" V.V. Veeder Charter Treaty) Tecmed (2003) Iranian Oil Co. Case (ICJ); Ambatielos (ICJ); AWARDS: Methanex

DECISIONS: Mavrommatis (PCIJ); Electricity Company of Sofia (PCIJ); Interpretation of Peace Treaties (ICJ); South West Africa (ICJ); Peru First Transitory Corporate Court Specialized in Public Law, 19 January 1998 (Peru); CONVENTIONS: Bilateral Investment Treaty (Peru- Peru Specialized Public Law Court of Thomas Chile); ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Lima, 6 February 1998 (Peru); Peru Buergenthal Empresas Lucchetti, S.A. CMS Gas (2003); Rules; NATIONAL LAWS ANS REGULATIONS: 105. Decision on Sala Corporativa Transitoria (President), and Lucchetti Peru, S.A. v. Maffezini (2000); Asian Lima Acuerdo de Consejo 258, 16 August 2001; Lima Jurisdiction (07 February 4 Especializada en Derecho Público, 4 Bernardo M. Peru , ICSID Case No. Agricultural Products Acuerdo de Consejo 259, 16 August 2001; Lima 2005) March 1998 (Peru); Peru Sala Cremades, Jan ARB/03/4 (Peru/Chile BIT) (1990); CSOB (1999) Acuerdo de Consejo 111, 25 September 1997; Lima Corporativa Transitoria Especializada Paulsson Acuerdo de Consejo 126, 21 October 1997; Decree No. en Derecho Público, 18 May 1998 126-97-MML (Peru); Peru La Sala Corporativa Transitoria Especializada en Derecho Público, 11 September 1998 (Peru); Peru Primer Juzgado Corporativo Transitorio Especializado en Derecho Público, 9 December 1998 (Peru)

Tokios Tokelés v. Ukraine , Maffezini (1999); Amco DECISIONS: Aegean Sea Continental CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration 104. Order No. 3 (18 Lord Mustill ICSID Case No. ARB/02/18 4 (1983); Casado (2001); Shelf Case (ICJ); Case Concerning Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID January 2005) (Lithuania/Ukraine BIT) Banro (2000) Passage Through the Great Belt (ICJ) Convention; The New Shorter Oxford English Dictionary

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 9 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: Bilateral Investment Treaty (Italy- Algeria); ICSID Convention; Energy Charter Treaty; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Salini v. Morocco Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; D. Carreau and P. (2001); RFCC (2001); Juillard, Droit International Economique; M. Bouhacene, Fedax (1997); CSOB Droit de la cooperation industrielle; C.B. Lamm and A.C. DECISIONS: Bridaes et al. v. Consortium Groupement (1999); SGS v. Pakistan Smutny, "The Interpretation of ICSID Arbitration Pierre Tercier Government of Turkmenistan (US); 103. Decision on L.E.S.I.- DIPENTA v. (2003); SGS v. Agreements"; K.-H. Bockstiegel, Arbitration and State (President), André Italian Cour de Cassation, 26 July 1996, Jurisdiction (10 January Algeria , ICSID Case No. 11 Philippines (2004); Enterprises; Articles on Responsibility of States for Faurès, Emmanuel no 6774 (Italy); Italian Cour de 2005) ARB/03/08 (Algeria/Italy Autopista (2001); Internationally Wrongful Acts, annexed to UN GA 56/83 Gaillard Cassation, 27 September 1997, no 9509 BIT) Maffezini (2000); Tradex of 12 December 2001; Oppenheim's International Law; (Italy); AWARDS: Metalclad Hellas (1999); Vivendi; S.M. Schwebel, "On Whether the Breach by a State of a Southern Pacific Contract with an Alien is a Breach of International Law; Properties (1992) NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Algerian Civil Code; Algerian Decree no 93-12, 5 October 1993; Algerian Decree no 91-434, 9 November 1991; Italian Civil Code

2004

DECISIONS: Czech Supreme Court, 7 October 1998; Czech Supreme Court, 26 November 1998; Czech Supreme Court, 27 October 1999; Czech Supreme Court, 15 November 2000; CONVENTIONS: Agreement on Economic Czech Supreme Court, 7 February Ceskoslovenska Obchodni Cooperation between Czechoslovakia and Yemen; BIT 2001; Czech Supreme Court, 5 Hans van Houtte Banka, a.s. v. The Slovak (Czech Republic-Slovak Republic); ICSID; RULES: November 2002; Slovak Regional 102. Final Award (29 (President), Piero Republic , ICSID ICSID Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL LAWS AND 2 CSOB (1999, 2000) Court Bratislava, 6 May 1998; Slovak December 2004) Bernardini, Andreas Case No. ARB/97/4 (Czech REGULATIONS: Czech Civil Code; Czech Procedural Supreme Court, 13 September 1999; Bucher Republic/Slovak Republic Code; Czech Commercial Code; Slovak Civil Code; Slovak Regional Court Bratislava, 7 BIT) Slovak Commercial Code; Slovak Resolution No. 937, June 2001; Slovak Supreme Court, 19 1993 September 2001; Slovak Regional Court Bratislava, 20 January 2003; Slovak Supreme Court, 12 March 2003; Slovak Court Proceedings, "Mykoprogres"

CONVENTIONS: New York Convention; ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; MINE (1989); Wena 101. Decision on the Antonias Dimolitsa Patrick Mitchell v. PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention: A Hotels (2001); Wena Stay of Enforcement of (President), Robert Democratic Republic of Commentary; P. Lalive, "Concluding Remarks" in IAI 6 Hotels (2002); Amco the Award (30 November S.M. Dossou, Congo , ICSID Case No. Annulment of ICSID Awards; C. Schreuer, "Three (1986); Amco (1992); 2004) Andrea Giardina ARB/99/7 Generations of ICSID Annulment Proceedings"; P. CDC Group (2004) Friedland, "Stay of Enforcement of the Arbitral Award Pending ICSID Annulment Proceedings"

SGS v. Pakistan (2003); SGS v. Philippines (2004); Maffezini (2000); DECISIONS: Anglo-Iranian Oil (ICJ); Gilbert Guillaume Salini Costruttori S.p.A. Salini v. Morocco US Nationals in Morocco (ICJ); 100. Decision on (President), and Italstrade S.p.A. v. CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Italy-Jordan); BIT (2001); Consortium Ambatielos (ICJ); Oil Platforms, 1996 Jurisdiction (09 Bernardo Jordan , ICSID Case No. 9 (Jordan-USA); BIT (Jordan-UK); VCLT; ECT; RULES: RFCC (2003); Wena (ICJ); Legality of Use of Force November 2004) Cremades, Ian ARB/02/13 (Italy/Jordan ICSID Arbitration Rules Hotels (1999); Vivendi (Yugoslavia v. Italy) (ICJ); AWARDS: Sinclair BIT) (2002); Joy Mining Young hi Oo Trading Pta; UPS (2004); Mondev (AF) (2002)

Maffezini (2000); Asian DECISIONS: Anglo-Iranian Oil (ICJ); Andrés Rigo Sureda Agricultural Products US Nationals in Morocco (ICJ); ELSI Siemens v. Argentina , 99. Decision on (President), Charles (1990); Tecmed (AF) (ICJ); Ambatielos (ICJ); Barcelona CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of ICSID Case No. ARB/02/8 Jurisdiction (03 August N. Brower, 7 (2003); AMT (1997); Traction (ICJ); Case Concerning East Treaties; PUBLICISTS: ILC Report on MFN Clauses; (Germany/Argentina BIT) 2004) Domingo Bello AGIP SpA (1979); Timor (ICJ); AWARDS: American Commentary on ILC Draft Articles Janeiro Vivendi (2002); Southern International group v. Iran; Ebrahimi v. Pacific Properties (1992) Iran

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 10 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

Enron (2004); CMS (2003); Genin (2001); Mondev (AF) (2002); Francisco Orrego Enron and Ponderosa Vacuum Salt (1994); CONVENTIONS: ICSID; VCLT; BIT (US-Argentina); 98. Decision on Vicuña (President), Assets v. Argentine DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction Vivendi (2002); Azurix NAFTA; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; Jurisdiction (Ancillary Héctor Gros Republic , ICSID Case No. 11 (ICJ); ELSI (ICJ); Dole Foods (US); (2003); Wena Hotels PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention: A Claim) (02 August 2004) Espiell, Pierre-Yves ARB/01/3 AWARDS: GAMI; Lauder (2002); SGS v. Pakistan Commentary Tschanz (US/Argentina BIT) (2003); SGS v. Philippines (2004); Salini v. Morocco (2001)

CONVENTIONS: UN Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods; ICSID Convention; BIT Maffezini (2000); CMS (United Kingdom-Egypt); RULES: ICSID Arbitration (2003); Azurix (2003); Rules; PUBLICISTS: Report of the Executive Directors SGS v. Pakistan (2003); on the ICSID Convention; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Salini v. Morocco Convention: A Commentary; C.B. Lamm, "Jurisdiction (2001); CSOB (1999); of the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Francisco Orrego CSOB (2000); Fedax DECISIONS: Nuclear Tests Case, Disputes"; I.F.I. Shihata and A. Parra, "The Experience of Joy Mining Machinery 97. Award on Vicuña (President), (1997); Atlantic Triton 1974 (ICJ); Eastern Greenland Case the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Limited v. Egypt, ICSID Jurisdiction (30 July William Laurence 18 (1986); Alcoa (1975); (PCIJ); AWARDS: Filetage du Golfe Disputes"; P. Lagarde, "L'internationalite du droit de vue Case No. ARB/03/11 2004) Craig, C.G. Amco Asia (1993); SGS de Saint-Laurent (1986); UPS; de l'ordre international"; P. Kahn, "L'internationalite du (UK/Egypt BIT) Weeramantry v. Philippines (2004); Methanex; Lauder point de vue de l'ordre transnational"; C. Witz, Vivendi (2000); Vivendi "L'internationalite et le contrat"; H.A.Grigera Naon, El (2002); Genin (2001); Estado y et Arbitraje Internacional con Particulares; E.S. Wena Hotels (2002); Romero, "ICC Arbitration and State Contracts"; P. Weil, Lanco (1998); Southern "Problemes relatifs aux Contracts passesentre un Etat et Pacific Properties (1992) un Particulier"; Garanties bancaires et procedure arbitrale, Cautions et garanties bancaires; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Egyptian Civil Code

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Bilateral L. Yves Fortier Investment Treaty (Italy-United Arab Emirates); 95. Decision on (President), Soufraki v. United Arab RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL LAWS Jurisdiction (07 July Stephen M. Emirates , ICSID Case No. 0 DECISIONS: Nottebohm (ICJ) AND REGULATIONS: Italian Law No. 555, 1912; 2004) Schwebel, Aktham ARB/02/7 (Italy/UAE BIT) Italian Law No. 91, 1992; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, El Kholy The ICSID Convention: A Commentary

Maffezini (1999); Maffezini (2000); Maffezini (2001); CMS CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Bilateral (2003); Mihaly (2002); Investment Treaty (USA-Turkey); RULES: ICSID Zhinvali (2003); Fedax Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: UNIDROIT Principles PSEG Global, Inc., The (1997); CSOB (1999); of International Commercial Contracts; C. Schreuer, The Francisco Orrego North American Coal CSOB (2000); Holiday DECISIONS: Eastern Greenland ICSID Convention: A Commentary; NATIONAL 94. Decision on Vicuña (President), Corporation, and Konya Inns; Lanco (1998); SGS (PCIJ); Nuclear Tests Case (ICJ); LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Turkish Constitution; Jurisdiction (04 June L. Yves Fortier, Ingin Electrik Uretim ve 21 v. Pakistan (2003); AWARDS: UPS; Methanex; Aminoil Turkish Law No. 6224, 18 January 1954, Concerning the 2004) Gabrielle Ticaret Limited Sirketi v. Vivendi (2002); Salini v. Award; Lauder Encouragement of Foreign Capital; Turkish Law No. Kauffmann-Kohler Turkey , ICSID Case No. Morocco (2001); Genin 3096, 1984; Turkish Law No. 3996, 1994; Turkish Law ARB/02/5 (US/Turkey BIT) (2001); Genin (2002); No. 4493, December 1999; Turkish Law No. 4501, 22 Azurix (2003); Wena January 2000; Turkish Law No. 4628, March 2001; Hotels (2002); Mondev Turkish Foreign Capital Framework Decree, 1995 (AF) (2002); Enron I (2004); Aguas del Aconquija (2000)

Santa Elena (2000); Middle East Cement (2002); Mihaly (2002); CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Chile-Malaysia); BIT Andrés Rigo Sureda MTD Equity Sdn. Bhd. & Metalclad (AF) (2000); (Chile-Denmark); BIT (Chile-Croatia); NAFTA; VCLT; 93. Final Award (25 May (President), Marc MTD Chile S.A. v. Chile , DECISIONS: Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); 9 Tecmed (AF) (2003); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL LAWS 2004) Lalonde, Rodrigo ICSID Case No. ARB/01/7 AWARDS: CME; Biloune Maffezini (2000); AND REGULATIONS: Chilean Foreign Investment Oreamuno Blanco (Malaysia/Chile BIT) Azinian (AF) (1999); Law; Chilean Resolution Nos. 14/2003, No. 39/1997 AMT (1997); CMS (2003)

Tatiana B. de CMS (2003); Azurix Maekelt (2003); Compañía de 92. Decision on LG&E v. Argentina , ICSID (President), Aguas del Aconquija CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Argentina-US); Jurisdiction (30 April Case No. ARB/02/1 6 DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction (ICJ) Francisco Rezek, (2000); Lanco (1998); PUBLICISTS: Report of the Executive Directors 2004) (US/Argentina BIT) Albert Jan van den MINE (1988); Mobil Oil Berg (1989)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 11 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

Mondev (AF) (2002); Maffezini (2000); Waste CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Lithuania-Ukraine); BIT Management (AF); SGS (Argentina-USA); BIT (Switzerland-Philippines); BIT v. Philippines (2004); (the Netherlands-Venezuela); BIT (UK-Egypt); BIT Vivendi (2002); Amco (Ukraine-USA); VCLT; ECT; RULES: ICSID Asia (1983); Kaiser Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Report of the Prosper Weil Bauxite; SOABI; Executive Directors on the ICSID Convention; C. 91. Decision on (President) (Diss. Tokios Tokelés v. Ukraine , DECISIONS: Mavrommatis Case Autopista (2001); Wena Schreuer, The ICSID Convention: A Commentary; A. Jurisdiction (29 April Op.), Piero ICSID Case No. ARB/02/18 18 (PCIJ); Barcelona Traction (ICJ); Hotels; CMS Gas (2003); Broches, "The Convention on the Settlement of 2004) Bernardini, Daniel (Lithuania/Ukraine BIT) AWARDS: Tippetts SGS v. Pakistan (2003); Investment Disputes Between States and Nationals of M. Price Banro (2000); Loewen Other States"; C.F. Amerasinghe, "Interpretation of (AF) (2003); Fedax Article 25(2)(b) of the ICSID Convention"; G.R. (1997); Tradex Hellas Delaume, "ICSID Arbitration and the Courts"; M. Hirsch, (1999); Salini v. The Arbitration Mechanism of the International Centre Morocco (2001); Holiday for the Settlement of Investment Disputes Inns

PUBLICISTS: D.O. O'Connell, International Law; C.F. Amerasinghe, "The jurisdiction of the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes"; Jennings and Watts, Oppenheim's International Law; R. Tokios Tokelés v. Ukraine , ICSID Case No. ARB/02/18 Dolzer and M. Stevens, Bilateral Investment Treaties; I. (Lithuania/Ukraine BIT) CONTINUED Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law; P. Lalive, "The First World Bank Arbitration (Holiday Inns v. Morocco)"; L. Sohn and R. Baxter, "Responsibility of States for Injuries to the Economic Interests of Aliens"; Draft Articles on State Responsibility

DECISIONS: Oil Platforms, 1996 (ICJ); Case Concerning Legality of Use of Force (Yugoslavia v. Belgium) (ICJ); LaGrand (ICJ); Certain Phosphates in Nauru (ICJ); Land and Maritime Boundary between Cameroon and CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of SGS v. Pakistan (2003); Nigeria (ICJ); AWARDS: Yaung Chi Treaties; ICSID; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID SGS Société Générale de Vivendi (2002); Fedax Ahmed El-Kosheri OO Trading (ASEAN); Woodruff Case Convention: A Commentary; P. Weil, "Problemes relatifs Surveillance S.A. v. (1997); Fedax (1998); 90. Decision on (President), James (US-Venezuela Mixed Commission); aux contrats passes entre un etat et un particulier"; J. Republic of the Philippines, Gruslin (2000); CSOB Jurisdiction (29 January Crawford, Antonio 10 North American Dredging Co. of Texas Karl, "The Promotion and Protection of German ICSID Case No. ARB/02/6 (1999); Mihaly (2002); 2004) Crivallero (Supp. (US-Mexico General Claims Investment Abroad"; UNCTAD, Bilateral Investment (Switzerland/Philippines Salini v. Morocco Decl.) Commission); Flanaga, Bradley, Clark Treaties in the mid-1990's; I. Shihata, "Applicable Law in BIT) (2001); Lanco (1998); & Co. v. Venezuela; Mexican Union International Arbitration: Specific Apsects in the Case of Mondev (AF) (2002) Railway Ltd. v. United Mexican States; the Involvement of State Parties" El Oro Mining & Railway Co. v. United Mexican States; Greek Government v. Vulkan Werke; UPS; Russian Indemnity Case; ORDERS: The MOX Plant Case, Order No. 3

PUBLICISTS: F.A. Mann, "British Treaties for the Promotion and Protection of Investments"; M.N. Leich, "Contemporary Practice of the US relating to International Bilateral Investment Treaties"; R. Dolzer and M. Stevens, Bilateral Investment Treaties; A. Parra, "Provisions on the Settlement of Investment Disputes in SGS Société Générale de Surveillance S.A. v. Republic of the Philippines, Modern Investment Laws, Bilateral Investment treaties ICSID Case No. ARB/02/6 (Switzerland/Philippines BIT) CONTINUED and Multilateral Instruments on Investment"; J. Crawford, The ILC's Articles on State Responsibility; I. Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law; C.F. Amerasinghe, Local Remedies in International Law; T.L. Stein, "Jurisprudence and Jursists' Prudence: The Iranian- Forum Clause Decision of the Iran-US Claims tribunal

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 12 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

Lanco (1998); Compania de Aguas del Aconquija (2000); Vivendi (2002); Mondev (AF) (2002); Gruslin (2000); Goetz (1999); Metalclad (AF) DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of Francisco Orrego Enron and Ponderosa (2000); Wena Hotels (ICJ); LaGrand (ICJ); Arrest Warrant Treaties; PUBLICISTS: J. Crawford, The ILC's Articles 89. Decision on Vicuña (President), Assets v. Argentine (2002); CMS Gas (2003); (ICJ); AWARDS: Ethyl Corp.; Pope & on State Responsibility; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Jurisdiction (14 January Héctor Gros Republic , ICSID Case No. 16 Salini v. Morocco Talbot; Lauder; CME; Martini Case Convention: A Commentary; P. Lalive, "The First World 2004) Espiell, Pierre-Yves ARB/01/3 (US/Argentina (2001); Genin (2001); (Italy v. Venezuela); Trail Smelter Case Bank Arbitration (Holiday Inns v. Morocco) - Some Tschanz BIT) Olguin (2000); (US v. Canada); Rainbow Warrior Legal Problems" Benevenuti & Bonfant (1980); Asian Agricultural Products (1990); AMT (1997); Klöckner (1983)

2003

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Italy-Morocco); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Robert Briner Jennings & Watts, Oppenheim's International Law; E. Consortium R.F.C.C. v. Vivendi (2002); Genin; (President), Gaillard, Journal du droit intrernational (2002); J.C. 88. Final Award (22 Kingdom of Morocco , Azinian; Metalclad (AF); AWARDS: Norwegian Shipowners Bernardo 7 Thomas, "Reflections on Article 1005 NAFTA: History, December 2003) ICSID Case No. ARB/00/6 Maffezini; Fedax; Santa Claims; Ethyl Corp. Cremades, Ibrahim State Practice and the Influence of Commentators"; (Italy/Morocco BIT) Elena Fadlallah ASIL, Fair and Equitable Treatment under NAFTA's Investment Chapter; UNCTAD, Fair and Equitable Treatment

Rodrigo Jijón DECISIONS: The Last Temptation of Letort (President), IBM World Trade CONVENTIONS: BIT (US-Ecuador); ICSID Salini (2003); Fedax Christ, Series C No. 73 (IACHR); 87. Decision on Alejandro Ponce Corporation v. Republic of Convention; PUBLICISTS: I. Brownlie, Principles of (1997); SGS v. Pakistan Action of nonfulfillment against the Jurisdiction (22 Martínez, Leon Ecuador, ICSID Case No. 5 Public International Law; S. Rosenne, The law and (2003); Vivendi (2000); Republic of Colombia, process No. 03- December 2003) Roldós Aguilera ARB/02/10 (US/Ecuador practice of the International Court, 1920-1996; Max Vivendi (2002) 11-97 (And.) (Diss. Op.) BIT) Sorensen, Manual on Public International Law;

Vivendi; Salini (2001); DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction CONVENTIONS: ICSID; NAFTA; BIT (Argentina- Andres Rigo Sureda Azurix v. Argentine Lanco (1998); Wena (ICJ); ELSI (ICJ); AWARDS: 85. Decision on US); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: (President), Elihu Republic , ICSID Case No. Hotels (2002); CMS Gas Woodruff v. Venezuela; North Jurisdiction (08 8 K. Vandevelde, United States Investment treaties, Policy Lauterpacht, Daniel ARB/01/12 (US/Argentina (2003); Benevenuti and American Dredging Co. of Texas v. December 2003) and Practice; C. Eagleton, The Responsibility of States in H. Martins BIT) Bonfant; Waste United Mexican States; Starret Housing International Law Management (AF) (2000) v. Iran

Champion Trading CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of Company, Ameritrade Robert Briner Treaties; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID 84. Decision on International, Inc., James DECISIONS: Nottebohm (ICJ); (President), L. Yves Convention: A Commentary; Shihata/Parra, "The Jurisdiction (21 October T. Wahba, John B. Wahba, 0 AWARDS: Case No. A/18 of 6 April Fortier, Laurent Experience of the international centre for settlement of 2003) Timothy T. Wahba v. Egypt , 1984 (Iran-US) Aynes investment disputes"; Documents Concerning the Origin ICSID Case No. ARB/02/9 and the Formulation of the Convention (US/Egypt BIT)

Jan Paulsson Generation Ukraine, Inc. v. Tradex Hellas; Vivendi; CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration DECISIONS: Certain German Interests 82. Final Award (16 (President), Eugen Ukraine , Award, ICSID Holiday Inns; Lanco; Rules; PUBLICISTS: P. Lalive, "the First World Bank 7 in Polish Upper Silesia (PCIJ); September 2003) Salpius, Jurgen Case No. ARB/00/9 CDSE; Feldman (AF); Arbitration (Holiday Inns v. Morocco) - Some Legal AWARDS: Tippetts (Iran-US) Voss (US/Ukraine BIT) Middle East Cement Considerations"

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 13 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

DECISIONS: JJ Ryan & Son, Inc. v. Rhone Poulenc Textile (US); AWARDS: Pennzoil Exploration and Production Co. v. Ramco Energy ltd., CONVENTIONS: ICSID; NAFTA; BIT (Switzerland- Vivendi (2002); Patrial Award in ICC Case No. 7319 of Pakistan); PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID Klöckner (1985); Tradex 1992, Judgment No. 8375 of 16 Convention: A Commentary; P. Lalive, "The First World Hellas (1996); Salini November 1987; Selwyn Case (British- Bank Arbitration (Holiday Inns v. Morocco)--Some Florentino P. SGS Société Générale de (2001); Lanco (1998); Venezuelan Mixed Claims Legal Problems"; R. Dolzer and M. Stevens, Bilateral 81. Decision on Feliciano Surveillance S.A. v. Islamic Holiday Inns; SPP; Commission); Socaciu v. Romania Investment Treaties; A. R. Parra, "The Scope of New Jurisdiction (06 August (President), André Republic of Pakistan , 18 Genin; Amco Asia; (Romanian-Austrian Mixed Arbitral Investment Laws and International Instruments"; C.N. 2003) Faurès, Christopher ICSID Case No. ARB/01/13 Benevenuti & Bonfant; Tribunal); Jean-Baptiste Caire Case Brower and J.D. Brueschke, The Iran US Claims Thomas (Switzerland/Pakistan BIT) Fedax; CSOB; Wena; (French-Mexican Mixed Claims Tribunal; P. Weil, "Problemes Relatifs aux Contrats Mihaly (2002); ADF Commission); E-Systems v. Iran & Passes Entre un Etat et un Particulier"; NATIONAL (AF); Maffezini; Loewen Bank Melli (Iran-US); Lauder, CME; LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Pakistan Arbitration (AF) (2003) Ethyl Corp. v. Canada (UNCITRAL); Act UPS (UNCITRAL); Appellate Body Report, EC Measures Concerning Meat and Meat Products (WTO)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; VCLT; NAFTA; BIT (Argentina-US); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: J. Sulkowski, "Questions Juridiques soulevees dans les Rapports Internationaux par les Variations de Valeur des Signes Monetaires"; C. Maffezini (2000); Fedax Anzorena, "Personalidad de las Sociedades"; ILC (1997); AAPL (1990); DECISIONS: Barcelona Traction Preliminary Report on Diplomatic Protection; D.J. Francisco Orrego CMS Gas Transmission AMT (1997); Goetz 80. Decision on (ICJ); ELSI (ICJ); Decision of the Bederman, "Interim Report on Lump Sum Agreemetns Vicuña (President), Company v. Argentina , (1999); Lanco (1998); Jurisdiction (17 July 12 Governing Council on Business Losses and Diplomatic Protection of Persons and Property"; Marc Lalonde, ICSID Case No. ARB/01/8 Geni (2001); Vivendi 2003) of Individuals (UNCC); AWARDS: G.H. Alrdich, The Jurisprudence of the Iran-US Claims Francisco Rezek (US/Argentina BIT) (2000, 2002); Wena CME, Pope & Talbot Tribunal; C.N. Brower and J.D. Brueschke, The Iran-US (2002); Olguin (2000); Claims Tribunal; ILA Commitee on Diplomatic Metalclad (AF) (2000) Protection of Persons and Property (2000); J. Crawford, The ILC's Articles on State Responsibility; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Argentine Laws No. 25.561, No. 23.928; Argentine Decrees No.1090/02; No.1570/01

Prosper Weil Tokios Tokelés v. Ukraine, 79. Order No. 1 (1 July (President), Piero CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration ICSID Case No. ARB/02/18 0 2003) Bernardini, Daniel Rules (Lithuania/Ukraine BIT) Price

Compañiá de Aguas del 78. Decision on L. Yves Fortier Aconquija S.A. and Supplementation and (President), James Amco; Genin; MINE; Universal v. Argentine CONVENTIONS: ICSID; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, Rectification of R. Crawford, José 6 Klöckner; Maffezini; Republic, ICSID Case No. The ICSID Convention: A Commentary Annulment Decision (28 Carlos Fernandez CDSE ARB/97/3 May 2003) Rozas (France/Argentina BIT)

2002

SGS Société Générale de 77. Decision on Florentino P. CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Surveillance S.A. v. Islamic Azinian (1999); Vivendi DECISIONS: Societe Drexel Burnham Disqualification of Feliciano Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: D. Hascher, ICC Republic of Pakistan , 5 (2002); Amco (1982); Lambert Limited et autres c. Societe Arbitrator (19 December (President), André Practice in Relation to the Appointment, Confirmation, ICSID Case No. ARB/01/13 Zhinvali (2001); GAMI Philipp Brothers et autres (France) 2002) Faurès Challenge and Replacement of Arbitrators (Switzerland/Pakistan BIT)

Florentino P. SGS Société Générale de Feliciano Surveillance S.A. v. Islamic CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of 76. Procedural Order No. (President), André Republic of Pakistan , 0 Treaties; PUBLICISTS: ILC Articles on State 2 (16 October 2002) Faurès, Christopher ICSID Case No. ARB/01/13 Responsibility Thomas (Switzerland/Pakistan BIT)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: ILC Articles on Responsibility of Compañiá de Aguas del States for Internationally Wrongful Acts; C. Schreuer, L. Yves Fortier Aconquija S.A. and Lanco (1998); MINE The ICSID Convention; C.N. Brower and J.D. 75. Decision on (President), James Universal v. Argentine (1989); Salini (2001); AWARDS: Woodruff Case, American- Brueschke, The Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Annulment (03 July Crawford, José 4 Republic, Waste Management (AF) Venezuelan Mixed Commission (1903) (1998); Claims Settlement Declaration, 19 January 1981, 2002) Carlos Fernandez ICSID Case No. ARB/97/3 (2001) Iran-US Claims Tribunal Reports; C. Amerasinghe, Rozas (France/Argentina BIT) "State Breaches of Contracts With Aliens and International Law" (1964); R. Jennings and A. Watts, Oppenheim's International Law (1992)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 14 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: P. Lalive, "The First World Bank Arbitration Holiday Inns. v. Morocco, Some Legal Problems"; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; S. DECISIONS: Prince von Pless (PCIJ); Rosenne, The Law and Practice of the International Holiday Inns; LETCO Victor Pey Casado and Pajzs, Casky, Esterhazy (PCIJ); Court, 1920-1996; C. de Visscher, Aspects recents de Pierre Lalive (1986); Amco (1983); President Allende Barcelona Traction (ICJ); Certain droit procedural de la Cour internationale de justice 74. Decision on (President), Klöckner (1983); Atlantic Foundation v. Republic of Norwegian Loans (ICJ); Right of (1966); H. Lauterpacht, The Development of Jurisdiction (08 May Mohammed 9 (1986); SOABI (1984); Chile , Passage on Indian Territory (ICJ); International Law by the International Court; J. Lang, "La 2002) Bedjaoui, Galo Tradex Hellas (1996); ICSID Case No. ARB/98/2 Nicaragua, 1984 (ICJ); Nicaragua, 1986 Jonction au Find des Exceptions Preliminaires devant la Leoro Franco AMT (1997); Olguin (Spain/Chile BIT) (ICJ); Lockerbie (ICJ); Nigeria- CPIJ et la CIJ" (1968); G. Abi-Saab, Les Exceptions (2000) Cameroon (ICJ) Preliminaires dans la Procedure de la Cour Internationale (1967); F. Ammoun, "La Jonction des Exceptions Preliminaires au fond en Droit International Public"; E. Grisel, Les Exceptions d'Incompetence et d'Irrecevabilite dans la Procedure de la Court International de Justice

Middle East Cement CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Karl-Heniz Shipping and Handling Co. AAPL (1990); Wena Rules; PUBLICISTS: A.R. Parra, "Applicable Böckstiegel 73. Final Award (12 S.A. v. Arab Republic of Hotels (2000); Metalclad Substantive Law in ICSID Arbitrations Initiated Under (President), Piero 4 April 2002) Egypt, ICSID Case No. (AF) (2000); CDSE Investment Treaties, News from ICSID (2000); B. Cheng, Bernardini, Don ARB/99/6 (Greece/Egypt (2000) General Pinciples of Law as Applied by International Wallace, Jr. BIT) Courts and Tribunals (1987)

72. Decision on Request Genin, Eastern Credit L. Yves Fortier for Supplementary Limited, Inc. and A.S. (President), Meir CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Decisions and Baltoil v Estonia , 0 Heth, Albert Jan Rules Rectification (04 April ICSID Case No. ARB/99/2 van den Berg 2002) (US/Estonia BIT)

CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties; PUBLICISTS: Aron Broches, "Bilateral Investment Protection Treaties and Arbitration of Sompong Investment Disputes; A.R. Parra, "Provisions on the Sucharitkul Mihaly International Settlement of Investment Disputes in Modern Investment 71. Final Award (15 (President), Andrew Corporation v Sri Lanka , Klöckner (1983); AMT 2 Laws, Bilateral Investment Treaties and Multilateral March 2002) Rogers, David ICSID Case No. ARB/00/2 (1997) Instruments on Investment; R. Dolzer, and M. Stevens, Suratgar (Conc. (US/Sri Lanka BIT) Bilateral Investment Treaties; World Bank Discussion Op.) Paper, Submission and Evaluation of Proposals for Private Power Generation Projects in Developing Countries, 1999

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; PUBLICISTS: J.L. Simpson and Hazel Fox, International Arbitration, Law and Practice; Report of the Executive Directors on Wena Hotels (2000); Konstantinos D. the ICSID Convention; W. Michael Reisman, The Klöckner (1985); Amco DECISIONS: Ruling on the Kerameus Wena Hotel Limited v. Arab Regime for Lacunae in the ICSID Choice of Law 70. Decision on Asia (1986); MINE application for cassation No. 1885 for (President), Republic of Egypt, ICSID Provision and the Question of Its Threshold; I. Shihata, Annulment (05 February 9 (1989); SPP (1992); the 50th judicial year, Hearing No. 50 Andreas Bucher, Case No. ARB/98/4. "Egypt" in Individual Rights and the State in Foreign 2002) Atlantic Triton (1986); (Egypt); AWARDS: North-Eastern Francisco Orrego (UK/Egypt BIT) Affairs; Egypt State Information Service, Foreign CDSE (2000); Maffezini Boundary Case, US-CAN (1831); Vicuña Investment; J. Gotanda, Awarding Interest in (2000); SOABI (1984) international arbitration; W. Laurence Craig, The Final Chapter in the Pyramids Case: Discounting an ICSID Award for Annulment Risk" 2001

Compañiá de Aguas del DECISIONS: AT&T Corporation v. CONVENTIONS: ICSID; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, Aconquija S.A. and Saudi Cable Co. (UK); In re The ICSID Convention; Vienna Convention on the Law 69. Decision on James R. Crawford, Universal v. Argentine Amco (1982); Zhinvali Medicaments and Related Classes of of Treaties; M. Tupman, "Challenge and Disqualification Challenge to President José Carlos 2 Republic, (2001) Goods (UK); AWARDS: Phillip of Arbitrators in International Commercial Arbitration"; (03 October 2001) Fernandez Rozas ICSID Case No. ARB/97/3 Brothers; ICC arbitration, judgment of Fouchard, Gaillard, and Goldman, "Traite d'arbtirage (France/Argentina BIT) 28 June 1991 comemrcial international" (1999)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 15 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, ICSID Review; L. Collins, "Provisional and Protective Measures in International Litigation"; Ch. Brower, R.E. Goodman, "Provisional Measures and the Protection of ICSID DECISIONS: Electricity Co. of Sofia Jurisdictional Exclusivity against Municipal Victor Pey Casado and Pierre Lalive (PCIJ); Competence en matiere de Proceedings"; P. Friedland, "Provisional Measures in President Allende 67. Decision on (President), Holiday Inns; Maffezini; pecheries (UK contre Islande) (ICJ); ICSID Arbitration; A.R. Parra, "The Practices and Foundation v. Republic of Provisional Measures (25 Mohammed 4 AGIP SpA; Atlantic LaGrand (ICJ); Anglo-Iranian Oil Co. Experiences of ICSID in Conservancy and Provisional Chile , September 2001) Bedjaoui, Galo Triton (1999) (ICJ); Congo v. Uganda (ICJ); Measures in International Arbitration"; Mendelson, ICSID Case No. ARB/98/2 Leoro Franco AWARDS: Rockwell v. Iran; E- "Interim Measures of Protection in cases of Contested (Spain/Chile BIT) Systems v. Iran Jurisdiction"; M. Hudson, The PCIJ; G.R. Delaume, "ICSID Tribunal and Provisional Measures-- A Review of the Cases" (1986); O. Sandrock, "The Cautio Judicatum Solvi in Arbitration Proceedigns or the Duty of an Alien Claimant to Provide Security for the Course of the Defendant" (1997)

Rodrigo Oreamuno (President), Olguín v Paraguay , ICSID 66. Final Award (26 July CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Francisco Rezek, Case No. ARB/98/5 1 Maffezini (2000) 2001) Rules Edmardo Mayora (Peru/Paraguay BIT) Alvarado

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Italy-Morocco); PUBLICISTS: G.R. Delaume, "Le Centre International pour le reglement des Differends relatifs aux Investissements (CIRDI)"; L.J. Bouchez, "The Prospects Robert Briner Salini Construtorri S.p.A. Asian Agricultural for International Arbitration: Disputes Between States 65. Decision on (President), and Italstrade S.p.A. v Products 1990); and Private Enterprises"; K.-H. Bockstiegel, "Arbitration Jurisdiction (16 July Bernardo Morocco , 4 Maffezini (2000); Fedax and State Enterprises: Survey on the National and 2001) Cremades, Ibrahim ICSID Case No. ARB/00/4 (1998); Alcoa Minerals International State of Law and Practice"; E. Gaillard, Fadlallah (Italy/Morocco BIT) (1975) Note in JDI 1999; I.F.I. Shihata and A.R. Parra, "The Experience of the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes" (1999); C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; D. Carreau, Th. Flory, O. Julliard, Droit International Economique (1990)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Italy-Morocco); PUBLICISTS: G.R. Delaume, "Le Centre International pour le reglement des Differends relatifs aux Investissements (CIRDI)"; L.J. Bouchez, "The Prospects Robert Briner Asian Agricultural for International Arbitration: Disputes Between States Consortium R.F.C.C. v. 64. Decision on (President), Products (1990); and Private Enterprises"; K.-H. Bockstiegel, "Arbitration Kingdom of Morocco , Jurisdiction (16 July Bernardo 4 Maffezini (2000); Fedax and State Enterprises: Survey on the National and ICSID Case No. ARB/00/6. 2001) Cremades, Ibrahim (1998); Alcoa Minerals International State of Law and Practice"; E. Gaillard, (Italy/Morocco BIT) Fadlallah (1975) Note in JDI 1999; I.F.I. Shihata and A.R. Parra, "The Experience of the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes" (1999); C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; D. Carreau, Th. Flory, O. Julliard, Droit International Economique (1990)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (US-Estonia); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: R. Dolzer and Genin, Eastern Credit L. Yves Fortier AMT (1997); Amco M. Stevens, Bilateral Investment Treaties (1995); I. Limited, Inc. and A.S. 62. Final Award (25 June (President), Meir (1990); Asian Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law; Baltoil v Estonia , 3 DECISIONS: ELSI (ICJ) 2001) Heth, Albert Jan Agricultural Products Oppenheim's International Law; NATIONAL LAWS ICSID Case No. ARB/99/2. van den Berg (1990) AND REGULATIONS: Law of the Central Bank of the (US/Estonia BIT) Republic of Estonia; Law on Credit Institutions; Law on Credit Institutions

Francisco Orrego Maffezini v. Kingdom of Vicuña (President), 59. Rectification of Spain , ICSID Case No. CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Thomas 0 Award (31 January 2001) ARB/97/7 (Argentina/Spain Rules Buergenthal, BIT) Maurice Wolf

2000 )

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 16 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (UK-Egypt); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Egyptian Civil Code; PUBLICISTS: A.V. Freeman, Responsibility of States for Unlawful Acts of Their Armed Forces; Ian Brownlie, Principles of Wena Hotels (1990, DECISIONS: German Interests in Public International Law; G.C. Christie, What 1999); AMT; Asian Polish Upper Silesia (PCIJ); Constitutes a Taking of Property Under International Monroe Leigh Wena Hotel Limited v. Arab Agricultural Products AWARDS: Tippets, Abbett, McCarthy, Law; Harvard Draft Convention on the International 58. Award (08 December (President), Ibrahim Republic of Egypt, ICSID 8 (1990); Amco Asia Stratton v. TAMS-AFFA (Iran-US); Responsibility of States; G. Aldrich, The Jurisprudence 2000) Fadlallah, Don Case No. ARB/98/4 (1984, 1986); SPP Alan Craig v. Ministry of Energy of Iran of the Iran-US Claims Tribunal; P. Lalive, Transnational Wallace, Jr. (UK/Egypt BIT) (1993); Metalclad (AF) (Iran-US); Gentini Case (Italy- (or Truly International) Public Policy and International (2000) Venezuela Mixed Claims Commission) Arbitration; I. Fadlallah, L'ordre public dans les sentences arbitrales; J.G. Wetter, Interest as an Element of Damages in International Arbitration; F.A. Mann, Compound Interest as an Item of Damage in International Law; J.Y. Gotanda, Awarding Interest in International Arbitration

Ceskoslovenska Obchodni Amco (1983); Holiday Thomas CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Czech Republic-Slovak Banka v. The Slovak Inns; Klöckner (1983); 57. Decision on Buergenthal Republic); PUBLICISTS: P. Lalive, "The First World Republic, ICSID Case No. SOABI (1988); Tesoro Jurisdiction (01 (President), Piero 5 Bank Arbitration (Holiday Inns v. Morocco). Some Legal ARB/97/4 (Czech Petroleum Corp. v. December 2000) Bernardini, Andreas Problems" (1980); Cohen D., Arbitrage et Groupes de Republic/Slovak Republic Trinidad and Tobago Bucher Contrats (1997) BIT) (CONCIL.)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Gruslin v. Malaysia, Rules; PUBLICISTS: M. Planiol, and G. Ripert, "Traite Award, ICSID Case No. 56. Final Award (27 DECISIONS: El Salvador v. Honduras pratique de droit civil francais; NATIONAL LAWS Gavan Griffith ARB/99/3 0 November 2000) (ICJ) AND REGULATIONS: Luxemburg Civil Code; (Belgo- Malaysian Securities Industry Act; Malaysian Companies Luxembourg/Malaysia BIT) Act

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (France-Argentina); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: L. Condorelli, "L'imputation a l'etat d'un fait internationalement illicite: solutions classiques et nouvelles tendances" (1984); A. Brotons, Derecho Compañiá de Aguas del Francisco Rezek Internacional (1997); Vallejo, La Responsabilidad Aconquija S.A. and (President), Internacional (1997); Sorenson, Manual of Public 55. Award (21 November Universal v. Argentine Azinian (1999); Lanco Thomas 2 International Law (1968); Dinh, Droit International 2000) Republic, (1998) Buergenthal, Peter Public (1999); ILC, First Report on State Responsibility; ICSID Case No. ARB/97/3 D. Trooboff C. Schreuer, "Commentary on the ICSID Convention" (France/Argentina BIT) (1996); History ICSID Convention; J. Gotanda, "Awarding Costs and Attorney's Fees in International Commercial Arbitrations" (1999); A. Redfern and M. Hunter, Law and Practice of International Commercial Arbitration (1991)

CONVENTIONS: Convention on Environmental Francisco Orrego Impact Assessment in a Trans-Boundary Context (1991); Vicuña (President), Maffezini v. Spain, ICSID PUBLICISTS: P. Sands, Principles of International 54. Award (9 November DECISIONS: Lopez Ostra v. Spain Thomas Case No. ARB/97/7 0 Environmental Law (1995); R. Mateo, "The 2000) (ECHR) Buergenthal, (Argentina/Spain BIT) Environmental Law System"; L. Brinkhorst, "European Maurice Wolf Environmental Law: an Introduction: (1999); Codigo Civil, Article 1214 (1999)

Rodrigo Oreamuno Eudoro Olguín v. Asian Agricultural 52. Decision on (President), CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; PUBLICISTS: Paraguay, ICSID Case No. Products (1990); Tradex Jurisdiction (08 August Francisco Rezek, 4 R. Dolzer and M. Stevens, Bilateral Investment Treaties ARB/98/5 (Peru/Paraguay Hellas (1996); AMT 2000) Eduardo Mayora (1995) BIT) (1997); CSOB (1999) Alvarado

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 17 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; BIT (Argentina-Spain); BIT DECISIONS: Mavromattis Palestine (Chile-Spain); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; Concessions (PCIJ); Anglo-Iranian Oil PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, "Commentary on the ICSID Francisco Orrego Company Case (ICJ); East Timor Case Convention. Article 25" (1997); ILC Draft Articles on 47. Decision of the Vicuña (President), Maffezini v. Spain, ICSID Asian Agricultural (Portugal v. Australia) (ICJ), State Responsibility; C.F. Amerasinghe, "Local Tribunal on Objections Thomas Case No. ARB/97/7 3 Products (1990); CSOB Interhandel Case (ICJ); United States Remedies in International Law"; G. Fitzmaurice, The to Jurisdiction (25 Buergenthal, (Argentina/Spain BIT) (1999); AGIP SpA (1979) National in Morocco (ICJ); Magno Law and Practice of the International Court of Justice, January 2000) Maurice Wolf Santovincenzo v. James F Egan (US); 1951-1954: Points of Substantive Law; A. Broches, "The AWARDS: Ambatielos Claim (Greece Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes: v. United Kingdom) Some Observations on Jurisdiction" (1966); I. Brownlie, System of the Law of Nations

1999

Francisco Orrego 45. Decision on Vicuña (President), Maffezini v. Spain, ICSID CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Provisional Measures (28 Thomas Case No. ARB/97/7 2 Holiday Inns; MINE Arbitration Rules October 1999) Buergenthal, (Argentina/Spain BIT) Maurice Wolf

CONVENTIONS: Bilateral Investment Treaty (UK- Egypt); ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Report of the Executive Directors on ICSID, 1965; Aron Broches, "The Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States"; A. Lowenfeld, International Economic Law; R. Dolzer, and M. Stevens, Bilateral Monroe Leigh Wena Hotel Limited v. Arab 44. Decision on Investment Treaties; C.F. Amerasinghe, "Jurisdiction (President), Ibrahim Republic of Egypt, ICSID Jurisdiction (29 June 1 Amco Asia (1983) Ratione Personae under the Convention on the Fadlallah, Hamzeh Case No. ARB/98/4 1999) Settlement of Investment Disputes Between States and Ahmad Haddad (UK/Egypt BIT) NAtionals of Other States"; A, Broches, "Bilateral Investment Protection treaties and Arbitration of Investment Disputes"; C.B. Lamm, "Jurisdiction of the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes"; G. Delaume, "Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States"

PUBLICISTS: G. Delaume, "ICSID Arbitration: Practical Considerations"; C. Schreuer, Commentary on the ICSID Convention; P. Peters, "Dispute Settlement Arrangements in Investment Treaties"; M. Hirsch, The Arbitration Mechanism of the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes; A. Broches, "Bilateral Investment Protection treaties and Arbitration of Investment Disputes"; C.B. Lamm, "Jurisdiction of the Wena Hotel Limited v. Arab Republic of Egypt, ICSID Case No. International Centre for Settlement of Investment ARB/98/4 (UK/Arab Egypt BIT) CONTINUED Disputes"; G. Delaume, "Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States"; G. Delaume, "ICSID Arbitration: Practical Considerations"; C. Schreuer, Commentary on the ICSID Convention; P. Peters, "Dispute Settlement Arrangements in Investment Treaties"; M. Hirsch, The Arbitration Mechanism of the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties; Bilateral Investment Treaty (Czech Republic-Slovak Republic); RULES: ICSID Rules of Procedure for Arbitration Proceedings; Ceskoslovenska Obchodni Thomas PUBLICISTS: I. Brownlie, Public International Law; B. Banka v. The Slovak DECISIONS: Nicaragua, 1984 (ICJ); 43. Decision on Buergenthal Amco Asia (1983); Asian Cheng, General Principles of Law as Applied by Republic, ICSID Case No. Nicaragua, 1986 (ICJ); North Sea Jurisdiction (24 May (President), Piero 3 Agricultural Products International Courts and tribunals; Report of the ARB/97/4 (Czech Continental Shelf Cases (ICJ); Nuclear 1999) Bernardini, Andreas (1990); Fedax (1997) Executive Directors of the World Bank; A. Broches, "The Republic/Slovak Republic Tests Case (Australia v. France) (ICJ) Bucher Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes BIT) between States and Nationals of Other States"; C. Schreuer, "Commentary on the ICSID Convention: Article 25"; UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 18 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules; ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: B. Cheng, General Principles of Law as Karl-Heinz Tradex Hellas S.A. v. DECISIONS: ELSI (ICJ); AWARDS: Applied by International Courts and Tribunals; Böckstiegel Amco Asia (1984); Asian 42. Award (29 April Albania, ICSID Case No. Amoco et al. v. Iran (Case No. 56); Otis NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Albanian (President), Fred F. 3 Agricultural Products 1999) ARB/94/2 (Albania/Greece Elevator Co. v. Islamic Republic of Iran Land Law No. 7501 of 19 July 1991; Albanian Fielding, Andrea (1990); Fedax (1997) BIT) (Case No. 284); Protiva Case Investment Protection Law, 1992; Albanian Law No. Giardina 7594 of 4 August 1992; Albanian Law No. 7764 of 2 November 1993; ICSID Convention

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; International Convenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights; Statute of the ICJ; BIT (Belgium-Luxembourg-Burundi); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: A. Parra, "Provisions on the Settlement of Investment Disputes in Modern Investment Laws, Bilateral Investment treaties and Amco Asia (1984); Asian Prosper Weil Goetz and others v Multilateral Instruments on Investment"; C. Schreuer, 41. Award Embodying Agricultural Products DECISIONS: Nicaragua 1984, 1986 (President), Burundi, ICSID Case No. "Commentary on the ICSID Convention"; P. Weil, "Les the Parties' Settlement (1990); AMT (1997); (ICJ); Aerial Incident at Lockerbie Mohammed ARB/95/3 5 clauses de stablisation ou d'intangibilite inserees dans les Agreement (10 February AGIP SpA (1979); (ICJ); ELSI (ICJ); Wimbledon (PCIJ); Bedjaoui, Jean (Belgo- accords de developpement economique"; I.F.I. Shihata, 1999) Southern Pacific AWARDS: Palmas Island Denis Bredin Luxembourg/Burundi BIT) "Recent Trends Relating to Entry of Foreign Direct Properties (1992) Investment"; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Burundi Decree-Law No. 1/30, 1992; Burundi Implementing Measures, Ministerial Ordinance No. 750/415, 1992; Burundi Ministerial Ordinance No. 750/184, 1995; Burundi Ministerial Ordinance No. 750/184, 1995

1998

CONVENTIONS: Bilateral Investment Treaty (Argentina-Germany); Bilateral Investment Treaty Bernardo Cremades (Argentina-Switzerland); Bilateral Investment Treaty Lanco International Inc. v Asian Agricultural 40. Award on (President), (Argentina-UK); Bilateral Investment Treaty (Argentina- Argentina, ICSID Case No. Products (1990); AMT Jurisdiction (08 Guillermo Aguilar 5 USA); ICSID Convention; Vienna Convention on the ARB/97/6 (1997); MINE; SOABI; December 1998) Alvarez, Luiz Law of Treaties; NATIONAL LAWS AND (US/Argentina BIT) Mobil Oil Olavo Baptista REGULATIONS: Argentine Law No. 24; Argentine Resolution No. 669; Argentine Resolution No. 710; Argentine Decree No. 1194

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Bilateral Investment Treaty (the Netherlands-Venezuela); RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; ICSID Administrative Francisco Orrego Fedax N.V. v Venezuela, and Financial Regulation; PUBLICISTS: I.F.I. Shihata, 39. Award (09 March Vicuña (President), ICSID Case No. ARB/96/3 0 "Applicable Substantive Law in Disputes Between States 1998) Meir Heth, Robert (Netherlands/Venezuela and Private Foreign Parties: The Case of Arbitration B. Owen BIT) under the ICSID Convention"; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Venezuelan Commercial Code; Venezuelan Law on Public Credit

1997 CONVENTIONS: Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties; Bilateral Investment Treaty (the Netherlands- Venezuela); Mexico-Colombia-Venezuela Free Trade Agreement; Convention Establishing the Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA); RULES: ICSID Rules of Procedure for Arbitration Proceedings; ICSID Rules Governing the Additional Facility; PUBLICISTS: Francisco Orrego Fedax N.V. v Venezuela, Amco Asia; Aloca C. Schreuer, "Commentary on the ICSID Convention"; 38. Decision on Vicuña (President), ICSID Case No. ARB/96/3 Minerals; Kaiser Bauxite; ICSID, Documents Concerning the Origin and the Jurisdiction (11 July 6 Meir Heth, Robert (Netherlands/Venezuela LETCO; SOABI; Holiday Formulation of the Convention; Report of the Executive 1997) B. Owen BIT) Inns Directors on the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States; C.B. Lamm and A.C. Smutny, "The implementation of ICSID Arbitration Agreements"; A. Broches, "The Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes: Some Observations on Jurisdiction"; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Venezuelan Law on Public Credit

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 19 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

PUBLICISTS: C.F. Amerasinghe, "The Jurisdiction of the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes"; G.R. Delaume, "ICSID and the Transnational Financial Community"; I.F.I. Shihata, "Towards a Greater Depoliticization of Investment Disputes: The Roles of ICSID and MIGA"; P. Lalive, "The First World Bank Fedax N.V. v Venezuela, ICSID Case No. ARB/96/3 Abitration (Holiday Inns v. Morocco) - Some Legal (Netherlands/Venezuela BIT) CONTINUED Problems"; A. Broches, "Choice-of-law provisions in contracts with governments"; A.R. Parra, "The scope of new investment laws and international instruments"; A. Escobar, "Introductory Note on Bilateral Investment Treaties Recently Concluded by Latin American States; ICSID, "World Bank Guidelines on the Treatment of Foreign Direct Investment"

Sompong CONVENTIONS: Bilateral Investment Treaty (US- American Manufacturing AWARDS: Caire, Jean-Baptiste, Case Sucharitkul Zaire); ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration 37. Award (21 February and Trading, Inc. v. Zaire, (France-Mexico Claims Commission); (President), Herbert 0 Rules; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: 1997) ICSID Case No. ARB/93/1 Youman, Thomas Y, Case (US- Golsong, Keba Zairian Ordinance Law No. 69-044; Zairian Code of (US/Zaire BIT) Mexican Claims Commission) Mbaye Investments; Zairian Code of Procedure

1996

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Bilateral Investment Treaty (Greece-Albania); Brussels Convention on Jurisdiction and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil and Commercial Matters; RULES: Karl-Heinz Tradex Hellas S.A. v. ICSID Arbitration Rules; UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules; 35. Decision on Böckstiegel Albania, ICSID Case No. Southern Pacific PUBLICISTS: ICSID, Documents Concerning the Jurisdiction (24 (President), Fred F. 1 ARB/94/2 (Albania/Greece Properties (1985) Origin and the Formulation of the Convention; December 1996) Fielding, Andrea BIT) UNCITRAL Model Arbitration Clause; NATIONAL Giardina LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Albanian Decree on Foreign Investment; Albanian Law No. 7594; Albanian Law No. 7406; Albanian Law No. 7512; Albanian Law No. 7496; Albanian Law No. 7764

1990

DECISIONS: Wimbledon (PCIJ); ELSI (ICJ); United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran Case (ICJ); Corfu Channel (ICJ); AWARDS: CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Bilateral Adams v. Naylor; Alabama Claims Investment Treaty (Sri Lanka-United Kingdom); Bilateral Arbitration (UK/USA); Ambatielos Investment Treaty (Sri Lanka-Switzerland); Vienna Case (Greece v. UK); Amoco Convention on the Law of Treaties; RULES: ICSID International Finance Corp. v. Islamic Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Eagleton, The Republic of Iran; Asylum Case Responsibility of States in International Law; Ralston, (Colombia v. Peru); Baldwin Case Asian Agricultural Law and Procedure of International Tribunals; Hall, Ahmed El-Kosheri (Panama/USA); Barron Case Products Ltd. v. International Law; Wayne Sachs, "The 'New' U.S. (President), (Mexico/USA); Belgian Claims Case; 30. Award (27 June Democratic Socialist Bilateral Investment Treaties"; Gudgeon, "United States Berthold Goldman, 0 Blumenkson Case (Mexico/USA); 1990) Republic of Sri Lanka , Bilateral Investment Treaties: Comments on the Origin, Samuel K.B. Asante Brawman Case (USA v. Turkey); ICSID Case No. ARB/87/3 Purposes and General Treatment Standards"; Wilson, (Diss. Op.) Britanic Property Case (UK v. Spain); (Sri Lanka/UK BIT) U.S. Commercial Treaties and International Law; OECD Case Concerning the Payment of Draft Convention on the Protection of Foreign Property; Various Serbian Loans Issued in Harazti, Some Fundamental Problems of the Law of France; Cayuga Indians Case Treaties; Bowett, "State Contracts with Aliens"; R. (UK/USA); Chapman Case Lillich, "Interest in the Law of International Claims"; (Mexico/USA); Chistern Case; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Sri Competence of the General Assembly Lankean Constitution and Conditions for the Admission of a State to Membership in the UN (Admissions Case); Dania Bebelish Case (Netherlands/Venezuela)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 20 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

AWARDS: El Triumfo Case (El Salvador); Elton, GC, Case (Mexico/USA); Fabiani Case; Franqui Case (Spain/Venezuela); Hardman Case (UK v. USA); Healy Case (USA v. Turkey); Home Insurance Company PUBLICISTS: Marjorie M. Whiteman, Damages in Case (Mexico/USA); Howland Case International Law; Ignaz Seidel-Hohenveldoern, (USA/Venezuela); Kummerow Case L'Evaluation des Dommages dans les Arbitrages (Germany/Venezuela); Mead, EE, Case; Transnationaux; C.F. Amerasinge, State Responsibility Melillea-Ziar, Ben Kiran Case; Mendel for Injuries to Aliens; F.V. Garcia-Amador, The Case (Germany/USA); Oriental Changing Law of International Claims; M.Bedjaoui, Navigation Co Case (Mexico/USA); "Responsibility of States: Fault and Strict Liability", Parker Case (Mexico/USA); Phelps Encyclopedia of Public International Law; K. Zemanek, Asian Agricultural Products Ltd. v. Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Dodge Corp. v. Islamic Republic of Responsibility of States: General Principles; I. Brownlie, Lanka , ICSID Case No. ARB/87/3 (Sri Lanka/UK BIT) CONTINUED Iran; Pinson Case (France/Mexico); System of the Law of Nations, State Responsibility- Part Poggidi Case (Italy/Venezuela); I; Bin Cheng, General Principles of Law as Applied by Richards, George David, Case International Courts and Tribunals; Duruard V. Sandifer, (Mexico/USA); Sambiaggio Case Evidence before International Tribunals; Alwyn V. (Italy/Venezuela); Sarrapoulos Case Freeman, Responsibility of States for Unlawful Acts of (Bulgaria/Greece); Smith Case Their Armed Forces; I.M. Sinclair, "The Principles of (Mexico/USA); Spanish Zone of Treaty Interpretation and Their Application By the Morrocco Claims; Tanger Horses English Courts"; I. Brownlie, Principles of Public Cases; Timor Island Case (Netherlands International Law; Denza and Brooks, ICLQ (1987) v. Portugal); Treaty of Limits Case (Costa Rica v. Nicaragua); Upton Case (USA/Venezuela); Van Boken Case (Haiti/USA); Victor A. Ermerins Case (Mexico/USA)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 21 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

II. NON-INVESTMENT TREATY AWARDS, DECISIONS AND ORDERS (Pages 22-32)

2006

DECISIONS: Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); Soleimany v. Soleimany (UK); Westacre Investments Inc. v. SPDR CONVENTIONS: ICSID; New York Convention; UN Holding Co. Ltd. (UK); OTV v. Convention Against Corruption; Inter-American Hilmarton (UK); Tinsley v. Milligan Convention Against Corruption; African Union (UK); Armagas Ltd. v. Mundogas (UK); Convention on Preventing and Combating Corruption; Kuwait v. Iraqi Airways (UK); Lemenda Council of Europe Criminal Law and Civil Law trading Co. Ltd. v. African Middle East Conventions on Corruption; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Petroleum Co. Ltd (UK); Holman v. Rules; PUBLICISTS: A. Sayed & Prof. Crivellaro, Johnson (UK); Saunders v. Edwards Arbitration Case Law on Bribery; A. Sayed, Corruption Gilbert Guillaume World Duty Free Company (UK); Howard v. Shirlstar Computer in International Trade and Commercial Arbitration; UN 149. Award (4 October (President), Andrew Limited v. Republic of World Duty Free (2001); Transport (UK); Tribe v. Tribe (UK); Declaration Against Corruption and Bribery in 2 2006) Rogers, V.V. Kenya, ICSID Case No. Amco Asia Ex. p. Blackburn (UK); LogicRose v. International Commercial Transactions; E. Gaillard, Veeder ARB/00/7 Southend United (UK); Milan Court of Trente Ans de Lex Mercatoria - Pour une application Appeal decision dated 4 December sélective de la méthode des principes généraux de droit; 1992 (Italy); Paris Court of Appeal in UNCITRAL Model Law; P. Lalive, Transnational (or European Gas Turbines Sa v. Westman Truly International) Public Policy and International International (France); Swiss Federal Arbitration; ILA Report on International Commercial Tribunal in W. v. F. and V. Arbitration on Public Policy as a Bar to Enforcement of (Switzerland); AWARDS: ICC Case International Arbitral Awards; J.G. Wetter, Issues of no. 1110; ICC Case No. 3916; ICC Corruption Before International Arbitral Tribunals; Case no. 6401; ICC Case No. 7664; Chitty on Contracts; Treitel, the Law of Contract ICC Case no. 3913; ICC Case no. 5622; ICC Case no. 7047; ICC Case no. 8891

SOABI; Amco Asia CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID (1984, 1986); CSOB Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The L. Yves Fortier Duke Energy International (1999, 2000); Cable TV; ICSID Convention: A Commentary; Lalive, "The First 125. Decision on (President), Pedro Peru Investments No. 1 Ltd SGS v. Philippines; World Bank Arbitration"; E. Gaillard, "Introductory Note Jurisdiction (1 February 14 AWARDS: Methanex Nikken, Guido S. v. Republic of Peru, ICSID Salini v. Jordan; Plama; to Decision of the Ad Hoc Committee" in Amco Asia; 2006) Tawil Case No. ARB/03/28 Holiday Inns; Klöckner; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Maffezini; Azinian (AF); Constitution of Peru; Civil Code of Peru; Legislative Tecmed Decrees Nos. 662, 674, 757

2005 CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; VCLT; NY Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Bin Cheng, General Principles of Law as Applied by International Courts and Tribunals; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; P. Mayer "To What Extent Can an Ad Hoc Committee Review the Factual Findings of an Arbitral Tribunal?"; Peter D. Trooboff, DECISIONS: Hedley Byrne & Co. Ltd "To What Extent May an Ad Hoc Committee Review the v. Heller & Partners Ltd (UK); ESSO Amco Asia (1983); Amco Factual Findings of an Arbitral Tribunal Based on a Charles N. Brower Petroleum Co. Ltd v. Mardon (UK); CDC Group plc v. Republic Asia (1986); Klöckner Procedural Error"; A. Broches, Observations on the 116. Decision on (President), Howard Marine and Dredging Co. Ltd of the Seychelles, ICSID (1985); MINE (1989); Finality of ICSID Awards; C.H. Schreuer, Three Annulment (29 June Michael Hwang, 7 v. A. Ogden & Sons (Excavations) Ltd Case No. ARB/02/14 Vivendi (2002); Wena Generations of ICSID Annulment Proceedings in 2005) David A.R. (UK); National Commercial Bank Hotels (2002); CDC Annulment of ICSID Awards; M.B. Feldman, The Williams (Jamaica) Ltd. v. Hew (UK); Lloyd's Group (2003) Annulment Proceedings and the Finality of ICSID Bank v. Bundy (UK); Smith v. Eric S. Arbitral Awards; D.A. Redfern, ICSID - Losing its Bush (UK) Appeal?; W.M. Reisman, The Breakdown of the Control Mechanism in ICSID Arbitration; David D. Caron, Reputation and Reality in the ICSID Annulment Process: Understanding the Distinction between Annulment and Appeal; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: UK Companies Act 1985; UK Misrepresentation Act 1967 2004

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 22 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention: A Commentary; ICSID, Documents Concerning the Origin and Formulation of the Convention; Official Notes to ICSID Arbitration Rule 52; J.J. Van Hof, Commentary of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules: The Application by the Iran-US Claims Tribunal; CDC Group (2003); M. Pellonpaa and D.D. Caron, The UNCITRAL Charles N. Brower Amco Asia (1983, 1983, Arbitration Rules as Interpreted and Applied; CDC Group plc v. Republic 96. Decision on Whether (President), 1985, 1986, 1992); UNICTRAL, Report of the Working Group on of the Seychelles, ICSID or Not to Continue Stay Michael Hwang, 10 MINE (1989, 1997); Arbitration on the Work of its Fortieth Session; Case No. ARB/02/14 and Order (14 July 2004) David A.R. Southern Pacific UNICTRAL Working Group II, Settlement of Williams Properties (1993); Wena Commercial Disputes: Preparation of Uniform Provisions Hotels (2003) in Interim Measures of Protection, Note by the Secretariat; Paul D. Friedland, Provisional Measures in ICSID Arbitration; Paul D. Friedland, Stay of Enforcement of the Arbitral Award Pending ICSID Annulment Proceedings; Jan Paulsson, ICSID's achievements and prospects; W. Laurence Craig, The Final Chapter in the Pyramids Case: Discounting an ICSID Award for Annulment Risk

2003

DECISIONS: National Commercial CDC Group plc v. Republic Bank (Jamaica) Ltd. v. Hew (UK); 86. Award (17 December of the Seychelles, ICSID CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Anthony Mason 0 Smith v. Bush (UK); Lloyd's Bank v. 2003) Case No. ARB/02/14 Arbitration Rules Bundy (UK); National Westminster Bank Plc v. Morgan (UK)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention: A Commentary; S. Schwebel, International DECISIONS: Accion Commercial S.A. Arbitration: Three Salient Problems; E. Gaillard, (Venezuela); Diques y Astilleros "Chronique des sentences arbitrales CIRDI"; Draft Nacionales (DIANCA) (Venezuela); Articles on State Responsibility of the ILC; P. Friedland LETCO (1986); Wena Gabrielle AWARDS: General Dynamics and E. Wong, "Measuring Damages for the Deprivation Hotels; Vivendi (2002); Kaufmann-Kohler Autopista Concesionada de Telephone Sys. Ctr. v. Iran (Iran-US); of Income-Producing Assets: ICSID Case Studies"; A. Amco Asia; Metalclad 83. Award (23 (President), Karl- Venezuela CA v. Bolivarian Gould Marketing, Inc. v. Iran (Iran-US); Westberg, "Compensation in Cases of Expropriation and 12 (AF) (2000); AAP September 2003) Heinz Böckstiegel, Republic of Venezuela, Sylvania Tech Sys. Inc. v. Iran (Iran- Nationalization: Awards of the Iran-US Claims Tribunal; (1990); AMT; SPP; Bernardo M. ICSID Case No. ARB/00/5 US); Levitt v. Iran (Iran-US); Dadras G.H. Alrdich, The Jurisprudence of the Iran-US Claims Benevenuti; AGIP; Cremades International v. Iran (Iran-US); Karaha Tribunal; O. Sandrock, "Compound Interest in SOABI; CDSE Bodas v. Perusahann Pertambangan; International Arbitration"; J. Ortscheidt, La reparation du Delagoa Bay and East African Railway dommage dans l'arbitrage commercial international; N. Co. Affolder, "Awarding Compund Interest in International Arbitration"; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Venezuelan Decree Law No. 138; Venezuelan Resolution No. 57

2001

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; PUBLICISTS: P. Lalive, "The First World Bank Arbitration (Holiday Inns v. Morocco) --Some Legal Problems"; C. Schreuer, The ICSID Convention; C. Schreuer, Commentary on the ICSID Convention (1997); A. Broches, "The Convention Gabrielle Holiday Inns; Cable TV on the Settlement of Investment Disputes Between States Kaufmann-Kohler Autopista Concesionada de (1996); Klöckner (1983); 68. Decision on and Nationals of Other States" (1972); C.F. Amerasinghe, (President), Karl- Venezuela CA v. Bolivarian Amco (1983); LETCO Jurisdiction (27 9 "Jurisdiction Rationae Personae under the Convention on Heinz Böckstiegel, Republic of Venezuela , (1986); LETCO (1986); September 2001) the Settlement of Investment Disptues Between States Bernardo M. ICSID Case No. ARB/00/5 SOABI (1984); Vacuum and Nationals of Other States" (1974/75); P.C. Szasz, "A Cremades Salt (1994); Banro (2000) Practical Guide to the Convention on Settlement of Investment Disputes" (1968); B. Cremades, "Arbitration Between States and investors: Some Jurisdiction Issues" (2001); C.F. Amerasinghe, "Interpretation of Article 25(2)(b) of the ICSID Convention" (1993)

Tanzania Electric Supply Kenneth S. Rokison Company Limited v. 63. Final Award (12 July (President), Charles CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Independent Power 0 2001) N. Brower, Andrew Rules Tanzania Limited , ICSID Rogers Case No. ARB/98/8

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 23 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

Tanzania Electric Supply Kenneth S. Rokison 61. Decision on All Company Limited v. (President), Charles Further Remaining Independent Power 0 N. Brower, Andrew Issues (24 May 2001) Tanzania Limited , ICSID Rogers Case No. ARB/98/8

Tanzania Electric Supply Kenneth S. Rokison 60. Decision on Tariff Company Limited v. (President), Charles CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration and Other Remaining Independent Power 0 N. Brower, Andrew Rules Issues (9 February 2001) Tanzania Limited , ICSID Rogers Case No. ARB/98/8

2000

Banro American Resources, CONVENTIONS: ICSID; PUBLICISTS: "History of Prosper Weil Inc. and Societe Aurifere the ICSID Convention, Documents Concerning the 53. Award (1 September (President), Carveth du Kivu et du Maniema Origin and the Formulation of the Convention on the 0 2000) [EXCERPTS] Harcourt Geach, SARL v. Democratic Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Alioune Diagne Republic of the Congo , Nationals of Other States"; Christoph H. Schreuer, ICSID Case No. ARB/98/7 "Commentary on Article 27 of the ICSID Convention"

L. Yves Fortier Compania del Desarrollo 51. Rectification of (President), Elihu de Santa Elena, SA v. 0 RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules Award (08 June 2000) Lauterpacht, Republic of Costa Rica, Prosper Weil ICSID Case No. ARB/96/1

Tanzania Electric Supply DECISIONS: Investors Compensation Kenneth S. Rokison 50. Decision on Company Limited v. Scheme Ltd. v. West Bromwich PUBLICISTS: Chitty on Contracts; RULES: ICSID (President), Charles Preliminary Issues (22 Independent Power 0 Building Society (UK); Kammins Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL LAWS AND N. Brower, Andrew May 2000) Tanzania Limited , ICSID Ballrooms Co. Ltd. v. Zenith REGULATIONS: Tanzanian Evidence Act Rogers Case No. ARB/98/8 Investments (Torquay) Ltd. (UK)

AWARDS: American International Group et al. Islamic Republic of Iran and Central Insurance of Iran (Case No. 2) (Iran-US); Aminoil Case; Fabiani's CONVENTIONS: ICSID; PUBLICISTS: J. Westberg, Case; Flexi-Van Leasing, Inc. v. Islamic "Applicable Law, Expropriatory Takings and Republic of Iran (Case No. 36) (Iran- Compensation in Cases of Expropriation: ICSID and Iran- US); Kuwait v. Aminoil, Mariposa United States Claims Tribunal Case Law Compared" L. Yves Fortier Compania del Desarrollo Development Co. Case (US-Panama (1993); F.A. Mann, "Compount Interest as an Item of 49. Award (17 February (President), Elihu de Santa Elena, SA v. General Claims Commission); Damage in International Law" (1990); G. Arangio-Ruiz, 0 2000) Lauterpacht, Republic of Costa Rica, Norwegian Shipowners Claims; Phillips ILC Commission on State Responsibility (1989); Prosper Weil ICSID Case No. ARB/96/1 Petroleum Co. v. Iran (Case No. 39) Christie, "What Constitutes a taking Under International (Iran-US); Spanish Zone of Morocco law" (1962); Whiteman, Digest of International Law; Claims; Starrett Housing Corp. v. Iran NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Costa-Rican (Iran-US); Sylvania Technical Systems, Law Thirty-Six; Costa-Rican Legislative Decree Seventy- Inc. v. Iran (Iran-US); Tippetts, Abbett, Eight; 22 USC, 2378, Helms-Burton Amendment McCarthy, Stratton v. TAS-AFFA (Iran- US); the Affaire des Chemins de Fer Zeltweg-Wolfsberg

Arghyrios A. Societe d'Investigation de Fatouros 48. Award (19 January Recherche et d'Exploitation NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: French (President), Pierre 0 2000) [EXCERPTS] Miniere v. Burkina Faso, Civil Code Tercier, Séna ICSID Case No. ARB/97/1 Agbayissah 1999

Tanzania Electric Supply CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Kenneth S. Rokison 46. Decision on Company Limited v. Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: P. Friedland, (President), Charles Provisional Measures (20 Independent Power 1 Atlantic Triton "Provisional Measures in ICSID Arbitration"; N. Brower, Andrew December 1999) Tanzania Limited , ICSID NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: UK Rogers Case No. ARB/98/8 Arbitration Act

1997

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 24 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

AWARDS: Amoco International v. Iran (Case No. 56) (Iran-US); Bagot Pneumatic Tyre Co. v. Clipper Cable Television of Nevis, Pneumatic Tyre Co.; Kelner v. Baxter Woodbine A. Davis Ltd. and Cable Television and Others; Melhado and Another v. 36. Award (13 January (President), Arthur of Nevis Holdings, Ltd. v. Alcoa Minerals; Holiday The Porte Alegre, New Hamburgh, and 4 1997) A. Maynard, Rex Federation of St Kitts and Inns; Klöckner; LETCO Brazilian Railway Co.; Natal Land and McKay Nevis, ICSID Case No. Colonization Company Ltd. v. Pauline ARB/95/2 Colliery and Development Syndicate Ltd.; Newbourne v. Sensolid (Great Britain); Northumberland Avenue Hotel Co., Re

1994

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Institution Rules; ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: ICSID, Documents Concerning the Origin and the Foundation of the Convention; C.F. Robert Y. Jennings Vaccum Salt Products Amco Asia; Holiday Inns; Amerasinghe, "Jurisdiction Ratione Personae Under the 34. Award (16 February (President), Charles Limited v. Government of DECISIONS: North American Co. v. 5 Klöckner; SOABI; Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes 1994) N. Brower, Kamal the Republic of Ghana , SEC (US) LETCO Between States and Nationals of Other States"; C.F. Hossain ICSID Case No. ARB/92/1 Amerasinghe, "The International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes and Development Through the Multinational Corporation"; G. Delaume, "ICSID Arbitration: Practical Considerations"

PUBLICISTS: G. Delaume, "Le centre international pour le reglement des differends relatifs aux investissements"; P. Lalive, "The First World Bank Arbitration - Holiday Inns. v. Morocco"; P. Szasz, "A Practical Guide to the Convention on Settlement of Investment Disputes"; E. Gaillard, "Some Notes on the Drafting of ICSID Arbitration Clauses"; A. Broches, "The Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes Vaccum Salt Products Limited v. Government of the Republic of Ghana , Between States and Nationals of other states"; M. Hirsh, ICSID Case No. ARB/92/1 CONTINUED "The Arbitration Mechanism of the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes"; A.A. Berle, "Control in Corporation Law"; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Ghanaian Companies Code Act 1963 (Act 179); Ghanaian Law No. 287; Ghanaian Mineral and Mining Law, P.N.D.C.L 153; Ghanaian Arbitration Act 1961, (Act 38); Ghanaian Investment Code 1985 1993 NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Robert Y. Jennings Vaccum Salt Products Constitution of the Republic of Ghana, 7 January 1993; 33. Provisional Measures (President), Charles Limited v. Government of 0 Ghanaian State Lands Act 1962; Ghanaian (14 June 1993) N. Brower, Kamal the Republic of Ghana , Administration of Lands Act 1962; Ghanaian Law No. Hossain ICSID Case No. ARB/92/1 287

1992

DECISIONS: Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); Eduardo Jiménez German Interests in Polish Upper de Aréchaga Southern Pacific Properties Silesia Case (PCIJ); AWARDS: Amoco (President), (Middle East) Limited 32. Award (20 May International Finance Corp. v. Islamic Mohamed Amin [SPP(ME)] v. Arab 1 Klöckner 1992) Republic of Iran; Kuwait v. American Elabassy El Mahdi, Republic of Egypt , ICSID Independent Oil Company (Aminoil); Robert F. Case No. ARB/84/3 Northrop Corp. v. Triad; Phillips Pietrowksi, Jr. Petroleum Company, Iran v. Iran

1990 31. Decision on Supplemental Decisions Rosalyn Higgins Amco Asia et al. v. CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration and Rectification of 5 (President), Marc Republic of Indonesia , 0 Rules June 1990 Award (10 Lalonde, Per Magid ICSID Case No. ARB/81/1 October 1990)

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 25 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

DECISIONS: Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); ELSI (ICJ); Eddy Hans (Indonesia); CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; European Engel (ECHR); Sramek (ECHR); Convention on Human Rights; RULES: ICSID Jospandojo (Indonesia); Fabiani Case; Arbitration Rules; ICSID Administrative and Financial PT Savoy Homan Hotel v. Indonesia; Regulations; PUBLICISTS: Draft Convention on the Bayerische HNL Vermehrungsbetriebe International Responsibility of States for Injuries to GmbH et al. (ECJ); Yayasan Tjie On Jie Aliens; F.A. Mann, "The Consequences of an Jan v. Indonesia; Golder Case (ECHR); International Wrong in International Law"; D. O'Connell, Banco Nacional de Cuba v. Farr (US); International Law; A. Freeman, The International AWARDS: American International Responsibility of States for Denial of Justice; E. Rosalyn Higgins Amco Asia et al. v. 29. Second Award on the Group Inc. v. Islamic Republic of Iran; Borchard, The Diplomatic Protection of Citizens Abroad, (President), Marc Republic of Indonesia , 1 Klöckner Merits (05 June 1990) Amoco International Finance Corp. v. or, the Law of International Claims; C. Gray, Judicial Lalonde, Per Magid ICSID Case No. ARB/81/1 Islamic Republic of Iran; Aris Gloves Remedies in International Law; I. Seidl-Hohenveldern, Inc. v. United States; Chattin Case "L'evaluation des dommages dans les arbitrages (USA v. Mexico); De Sabla Claim transnationaux"; US Restatement (Third) of the Foreign (USA v. Panama); Said Wachdin v. Relations Law of the United States; NATIONAL LAWS Perseroan Terbatan NV Aniem; AND REGULATIONS: Indonesian Civil Code; Sapphire International Oil Company v. Indonesian Law No. 1 of 1967; Indonesian Decree No. National Iranian Oil Company; Sedco 63/1969 on Regulations and Procedures for Exercising Inc. v. National Iranian Oil Company; Control over Capital Investments; Indonesian Decree No. Shufeldt Claim (USA v. Guatemala); 54/1977; US Foreign Assistance Act 1965 Soekartin v. Indonesia

AWARDS: Starret Housing Corporation v. Iran; Texaco Overseas Petroleum (TOPCO) and California Asiatic Oil Company v. Government of the Libyan Arab Republic; Walter Fletcher Smith Case (USA v. Cuba); Horst Claim (Horst v. USA); Idler Case (USA v. Venezuela); INA Corp. v. Islamic Republic of Iran; John King Seng v. Head of Kabupaten et al.; Amco Asia et al. v. Republic of Indonesia , ICSID Case No. ARB/81/1 Josopandojo Case; Kuwait v. American CONTINUED Independent Oil Company (Aminoil); Libyan American Oil Company (LIAMCO) v. Government of the Libyan Arab Republic; Martini Case (Italy v. Venezuela); May Case (Guatemala v. USA); McCurdy v. The United Mexican States (USA v. Mexico); Phelps Dodge Corp. v. Islamic Republic of Iran; Phillips Petroleum Company, Iran v. Iran

1989

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; New York Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; Sompong Maritime International PUBLICISTS: Starck, Droit Civil: Obligations; Chartier, 28. Decision on Sucharitkul Nominees Establishment v. Klöckner (1985); Amco La Reparation du Prejudice; A. Weill and F. Terre, Droit Annulment (22 (President), Aron 2 Republic of Guinea, ICSID Asia Civil--Les Obligations; H. McCormack, Arbitration in December 1989) Broches, Kéba Case No. ARB/84/4 Combined Transportation; UNCITRAL Model Law; Mbaye NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: French Civil Code; Guinea Decree of 6 March 1972

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 26 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

DECISIONS: Air New Zealand v. Commerce Commission; Auckland Regional Authority v. Mutual Rental Cars; AV Pound & Co Ltd. v. MW Hardy & Co. Inc.; Bank Line Ltd. v. Arthur Capel and Co.; BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd. v. Shire of Hastings; Bremer Vulkan Case; Brierly Investments Ltd. Case; Chang Wing-siu v. R.; Charrington & Co. Limited v. Wooder; Commissioner of Police v. Ombudsman; Dandy Power v. Mercury PUBLICISTS: Finn, "Equity and Commercial Mobil Oil Corporation, Marine; Davis Contractors Ltd. v. Relationships"; B.H. MacPherson, "Joint Ventures as a Graham Speight Mobil Petroleum Company Fareham Urban District Council; 27. Findings on Liability, Separate Concept"; R.A. Ladbury, Commentary on (President), Inc, Mobil Oil New Zealand Denmark Productions Ltd. v. Boscobel Interpretation and Allied 0 MacPherson's Joint Ventures as a Separate Concept"; Maureen Brunt, v. Her Majesty the Queen in Productions Ltd.; Denny, Mott & Issues (04 May 1989) Hogg, Liability of the Crown in Australia, New Zealand Stephen Charles Right of New Zealand , Dickson Ltd. v. James B. Fraser & Co. and the United Kingdom; Donald and Heydon, Trade ICSID Case No. ARB/87/2 Ltd.; Devenport Borough Council v. Practices Law Robbins; Dominion Rent A Car v. Budget Rent A Car Systems; Dowling v. South Canterbury Electric Power Board; E.I. Du Pont de Nemours & Co. v. Federal Trade Commission; Edmonds Food Industries Ltd. v. WF Tucker and Co. Ltd; Fawcett Properties Ltd. v. Buckingham County Council; Foley v. Classique Coaches Ltd.; Hampstead & Suburban Properties Ltd. v. Diomedous; Hillas & Co Ltd. v. Arcos Ltd.

Hospital Products Ltd. v. US Surgical Corporation; Howard Smith Industries Pty Ltd. and Adelaide Steamship Industries Pty Ltd, Re; Kyprianou v. Cyprus Textiles Ltd.; Macdonald v. Longbottom; MacKay v. Dick; Maritime National Fish Ltd. v. Ocean Trawlers Ltd.; Media Council of Mobil Oil Corporation, Mobil Petroleum Company Inc, Mobil Oil New Australia (No 2), Re; Morphett Arms Zealand v. Her Majesty the Queen in Right of New Zealand , ICSID Case Hotel Pty Ltd. v. TPC; New Zealand No. ARB/87/2 CONTINUED Shipping Company Limited v. Societe des Ateliers et Chantiers de France; Offshore Mining Co Ltd. & Ors v. Attorney General of New Zealand; Outboard Marine Australia Pty Ltd. v. Hecar Investments Ltd; Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd. v. Miller Steamship Co Pty Ltd

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 27 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

Paal Wilson and Co A/S v. Partenreedere Hannah Blumenthal; Prenn v. Simmonds; Queensland Co- Operative Milling Association Ltd. v. Defence Holdings Ltd; Queensland Electricity Generating Board v. New Hope Collieries Pty Ltd; R. v. Gush; Radio 2UE Sydney v. Stereo FM; Re Nudgee Bakery Pty Ltd's Agreement; Reardon Smith Line Limited v. Hansen- Tangen and Others; River Wear Mobil Oil Corporation, Mobil Petroleum Company Inc, Mobil Oil New Commissioners v. Adamson; Roberts v. Zealand v. Her Majesty the Queen in Right of New Zealand , ICSID Case Bury Commissioners; Schuler AG v. No. ARB/87/2 CONTINUED Wickman Machine Tool Sales; Scott v. Rania; Tillmans Butcheries Pty Ltd. v. The Australasian Meat Industry Employees' Union; Tooheys Ltd, In re; Tooth & Co. Ltd, In re; TPC v. Nicholas Enterprises Pty Ltd.; Tru Tone Ltd. v. Festival Records; United Dominions Corporation v. Brian Pty Ltd; Upper Hunter County District Council v. Australian Chilling and Freezing Co. Ltd; Weddel Crown Corporation v. Commerce Commission

1988

CONVENTIONS: ICSID; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: R. David, L'Arbitrage dans le commerce international; Cheng, General Principles of Sompong International Law; de Visccher, Aspects recents de droit Sucharitkul 26. Second Decision on Amco Asia et al. v. DECISIONS: Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); procedural; Documents Concerning the Origin and the (President), Jurisdiction (10 May Republic of Indonesia , 0 AWARDS: Pious Fund Case; Orinoco Formulation of the ICSID Convention; Abi-Saab, Les Arghyrios A. 1988) ICSID Case No. ARB/81/1 Steamship Company Case exceptions preliminaires dans la procedure de la Cour Fatouros; Dietrich internationale; Millar, "The Premises of the Judgment as Schindler Res Judicata in Continental and Anglo-American Law"; Lauterpacht, Private Law Sources; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Delaware General Corp. Law

DECISIONS: Railway Traffic Between Lithuania and Poland Case (PCIJ); Phosphates in Morocco Case (PCIJ); CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; BIT (US-Egypt); Mavrommatis Palestine Concessions RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Case (PCIJ); Electricity Company of Report of the Executive Directors on the ICSID Sofia and Bulgaria Case (PCIJ); Covention; M. Davis, Business Law in Egypt; G. Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); German Delaume, Le Centre International pour le Reglement des Eduardo Jiménez Interests in Polish Upper Silesia Case differends relatifs aux investements; M. Amadio, "Le de Aréchaga Southern Pacific Properties (PCIJ); Constitution of the Maritime contentieux international de l'investissement prive et le (President), (Middle East) Limited Safety Committee (IMO) Case (ICJ); Convention de la banque mondiale du 18 mars 1965"; A. 25. Jurisdiction (No. 2) Mohamed Amin [SPP(ME)] v. Arab 1 Amco Asia Temple of Preah Vihear, Cambodia v. Broches, "The Convention on the Settlement of (14 April 1988) Elabassy El Mahdi Republic of Egypt , ICSID Thailand (ICJ); Nicaragua (ICJ); Investment Disputes: Some Observations on (Diss. Op.), Robert Case No. ARB/84/3 Nuclear Tests Case (ICJ); Aegean Sea Jurisdiction"; P. Reuter, Reflexions sur la competence du F. Pietrowksi, Jr. Continental Shelf Case, Greece v. Centre; P.H. Leboulanger, "Etat, politique et arbitrage, Turkey (ICJ); Anglo-Iranian Oil l'affaire du plateau des pyramides"; El Kosheri, Company Case (ICJ); Cour de Arbitration and Doemstic Laws: Egyptian Laws; R. Cassation, Case No. 716 of Judicial year Kovac, "La competence du Centre"; L. Levy, La 47 (Egypt); AWARDS: Saudi Arabia v. nationalite des societes; NATIONAL LAWS AND Arabian American Oil Company REGULATIONS: Egyptian Code of Civil Procedure (Aramco); Affaire des forets des Rhodope central

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 28 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules; IRAN-US Claims Tribunal Rules; PUBLICISTS: Gautron and Rougevin- Baville, Droit Public du Senegal; A. de Laubadere, Traite de Droit Administratif; Bockel, Droit Administratif; DECISIONS: Libya/Malta Continental Mazeaud, Lecons de Droit Civil; Viney, La Shelf Case (ICJ); Nicaragua, responsabilite: conditions; J-P Tosi, Le droit des Jurisdiction (ICJ); KIng of Spain's obligations du Senegal; Code of Civil and Commercial Arbitral Award, Honduras v. Nicaragua Obligations; Report of the Executive Directors on the Aron Broches Societe Ouest Africaine des (ICJ); Elbs v. Administration des ICSID Convention; J-F Lalive, Recueil des Cours. 1983; 24. Award on the Merits (President), Kéba Betons Inudstriels [SOABI] 1 Amco Asia Chemins de Fer d'Alsace Lorraine K-H Bockstiegel, "Les regles de droit applicables aux (25 February 1988) Mbaye (diss. op.), v. State of Senegal , ICSID (France); Cass. Civ. 1st, 16 March arbitrages commerciaux concernant des Etats ou des J.C. Schultsz Case No. ARB/82/1 1966, Garantie Mutuelle des enterprises controlees par l'Etat"; B. Cremades, G.R. Fonctionnaires (France); Cass. Civ. Delaume, in L'arbitrage international soixante ans apres, 2nd, 20 January 1971, Garantie reagrds sur l'avenir, CCI 1984; R. David, L'arbitrage dans Mutuelle des Fonctionnaires (France) le commerce international; J-P Regli, Contrats d'Etat et arbitrages entre Etats et personnes prives; Vocabulaire Juridique, 1987; "Encyclopedie juridique de l'Afrique"; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Article 6 of Senegalese Law 72/43, 1972; Senegal's Code of Government Obligations

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Donald E. Zubrod Maritime International DECISIONS: MINE v. Guinea (US); Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL LAWS AND 23. Award (06 January (President), Jack Nominees Establishment v. 0 AWARDS: AAA Award, MINE v. REGULATIONS: French Civil Code; Federal 1988) Berg, David K. Republic of Guinea, ICSID Guinea (1980) Arbitration Act (US); Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act Sharpe Case No. ARB/84/4 (US); Louisiana Civil Code

1986

Bernardo M. Liberian Eastern Timber Cremades Corporation [LETCO] v. 22. Rectification (19 (President), Jorge Government of the 1 LETCO June 1986) Gonçalves Pereira, Republic of Liberia , ICSID Alan Redfern Case No. ARB/83/2

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; PUBLICISTS: A. Broches, "The Convention for the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States"; Documents Concerning the Origin and DECISIONS: Application for Review Formulation of the Convention; Verdross-Simma, of Judgment No. 158 of the United Universelles Volkerrecht; Rosenne, "Equitable Principles Nations Administrative Tribunal, and the Compulsory Jurisdiction of International "Fasla" Case (ICJ); Arbitral Award Tribunals"; Pirotte, "La Notion d'Equite dans la Ignaz Seidl- made by the King of Spain on 23 Jurisprudence Recente de la CIJ"; W. Friedman, "The 21. Annulment Decision Hohenveldern Amco Asia et al. v. December 1906 (ICJ); Case concerning North Sea Continental Shelf Case: A Critique"; Pirrung, Annulling the 20 (President), Holiday Inns; Klöckner Republic of Indonesia , 3 Honduras v. Nicaragua (ICJ); Barcelona Die Schiedsgerichtsbarkeit nach dem November 1984 Award Florentino P. (1985); Amco Asia ICSID Case No. ARB/81/1 Traction (ICJ); Corfu Channel Case Weltbankubereinkommen fur Investitionsstreitigkeiten; I. (16 May 1986) Feliciano, Andrea (ICJ); Judgments of the ILO Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law; Giardina Administrative Tribunal upon Jimenez de Arechaga, "International Law in the Past complaints made against UNESCO Third of a Century"; P. Lalive, "The First World Bank (ICJ); AWARDS: Finnish Shipowners' Arbitration, Some Legal Problems"; Parra, "The Claim (Finland v. Great Britain) Screening Power of the ICSID Secretary General"; Rosenne, Procedure in the International Court; Report of the ILC, 1975; UN GA Res. No. 3281 (XXXIX); Hartono, Some Trans. Problems of Foreign Investment in Indonesia

NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Amco Asia et al. v. Republic of Indonesia , ICSID Case No. ARB/81/1 Indonesian Foreign Investment Law; Indonesian Law No. CONTINUED 1 of 1967; Indonesian Presidential Decrees Nos. 54/1977, 63/1969

Pieter Sanders Atlantic Triton Company DECISIONS: Atlantic Triton v. (President), Jean- Limited v. People's CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID 20. Award (21 April Guinea, Cour d'appel, Rennes, 1984 François Prat, Revolutionary Republic of 0 Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL LAWS AND 1986) (France); Atlantic Triton v. Guinea, Albert Jan van den Guinea , ICSID Case No. REGULATIONS: French Civil Code Cour de cassation, Paris, 1986 (France) Berg ARB/84/1

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 29 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

DECISIONS: American Life Insurance Company v. Emmanuel Sandy (Liberia); Insurance Company of Africa v. Fantastic Store (Liberia); Levin v. CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Juvico Supermarket (Liberia); Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Lew, "Applicable Law AWARDS: Sapphire International Oil in International Commercial Arbitration"; Higgins, "The Bernardo M. Liberian Eastern Timber Company v. National Iranian Oil Taking of Property by the State: Recent Developments in Cremades Corporation [LETCO] v. Company; Shufeldt Claim (USA v. International Law"; Culp, "Sources of Liberian Law"; US 19. Award (31 March Amco Asia (1983); (President), Jorge Government of the 2 Guatemala); Greek Telephone Restatement on the Law of Contracts; UN Resolution 1986) Holiday Inns Gonçalves Pereira, Republic of Liberia , ICSID Company Arbitration; Aminoil v. the 1803 (XVII) Relating to Permanent Sovereignty over Alan Redfern Case No. ARB/83/2 Government of Kuwait; Lena natural resources; Berlowitz, Concessions and Incentives Goldfields Company v. Union of Soviet in Liberia; NATIONAL LAWS AND Socialist Republics; Libyan American REGULATIONS: Liberian General Business Law; Oil Company (LIAMCO) v. Liberian Code of Laws Government of the Libyan Arab Republic; Robert May v. Guatemala (Guatemala v. USA)

1985

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Documents Eduardo Jiménez Concerning the Origin and Formulation of the de Aréchaga Southern Pacific Properties DECISIONS: Egypt v. SPP, Paris Convention; NATIONAL LAWS AND (President), (Middle East) Limited Court of Appeals, 1984 (France); SPP v. REGULATIONS: Egyptian Law No. 60, 1971; Egyptian 18. Jurisdiction (No.1) Mohamed Amin [SPP(ME)] v. Arab 0 Egypt, District Court, 1984 Law No. 90, 1971; Egyptian Law No. 2, 1972; Egyptian (27 November 1985) Elabassy El Mahdi, Republic of Egypt , ICSID (Netherlands); AWARDS: SPP v. Law No. 1, 1973; Egyptian Law No. 43, 1974; Egyptian Robert F. Case No. ARB/84/3 Egypt, 1983 (ICC) Ministerial Decree No. 212, 1975; Egyptian Decree of Pietrowksi, Jr. the Prime Minister, No. 91, 1975; Egyptian Ministerial Decree No. 96, 1977; Egyptian Presidential Decree No. 475, 22 May 1975

DECISIONS: Arbitral Award made by Klöckner Industrie-Anlagen the King of Spain on 23 December GmbH, Klockner Belge, SA Pierre Lalive 1906 (ICJ); Case concerning Honduras and Klockner CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Statute of the (President), Ahmed v. Nicaragua (ICJ); AWARDS: Trail 17. Annulment, Award Handelsmaatschappij BV v. ICJ; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL Sadek El-Kosheri, 2 Holiday Inns; Klöckner Smelter Arbitration (USA v. Canada); (03 May 1985) Republic of Cameroon and LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Cameroonian Civil Ignaz Seidl- North Eastern Boundary Between Societe Camerounaise des Code Hohenveldern Canada and the United States Award Engrais SA , ICSID Case (1831); Orinoco Steamship Company No. ARB/81/2 Case (PCA)

1984

DECISIONS: German Interests in Polish Upper Silesia Case (PCIJ); CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; VCLT; Statute of Chorzow Factory (PCIJ); Barcelona the International Court of Justice; PUBLICISTS: ILC Traction (ICJ); Printing and Numerical Draft Articles on State Responsibility; D.P. O'Connell, Registering Co. v. Samp (UK); International Law; C. Rousseau, Droit International Robinson v. Harman (UK); Hadley v. Public; B.A Wortley, Expropriation in Public Baxendale (UK); Stees v. Leonard (US); International Law; Institut de Droit International, AWARDS: Sapphire International Oil Annuaire 1952; J. Ghestin, Traite de droit civil, Les Company v. National Iranian Oil Obligations, Le contract; La formation du contrat sous la Company; Saudi Arabia v. Arabian direction de Rene Rodiere; A.G. Guest, Anson's Law of Berthold Goldman American Oil Company (Aramco); Contract; E.A. Farnsworth, Contracts; Restatement Amco Asia et al. v. 16. Award on the Merits (President), Isi Shufeldt Claim (USA v. Guatemala); (Second) of Contracts; UN GA Resolution 1803/XVII, Republic of Indonesia , 0 (20 November 1984) Foighel, Edward W. Texaco Overseas Petroleum (TOPCO) 1962; E.A. Fransworth, "The Past of Promise: An ICSID Case No. ARB/81/1 Rubin and California Asiatic Oil Company v. Historical Introducton to Contract"; A. Von Mehren and Government of the Libyan Arab J. Gordley, The Civil Law System; NATIONAL LAWS Republic; Lena Goldfields Company v. AND REGULATIONS: Indonesian Corp. Tax Union of Soviet Socialist Republics; Ordinance; Indonesian Tax Law on Interest, Dividend Libyan American Oil Company and Royalty; US UCC; Indonesian Law No. 6; (LIAMCO) v. Government of the Indonesian Decrees of the President of the Republic Nos. Libyan Arab Republic; Lighthouses 63/1969, 21/1973, 54/1977; Italian Civil Code; Dutch Arbitration (France v. Greece); Civil Code; Indonesian Civil Code; French Civil Code; Norwegian Shipowners' Claims Indonesian Foreign Capital Investment Law; Indonesian (Norway v. USA); Starret Housing Law No. 12 Corporation v. Iran (Iran-US)

Aron Broches Societe Ouest Africaine des CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID 15. Jurisdiction (01 (President), Kéba Betons Inudstriels [SOABI] Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Report of the 0 August 1984) Mbaye, Jean van v. State of Senegal , ICSID Executive Directors of the World Bank on the Houtte Case No. ARB/82/1 Convention

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 30 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

1983

Berthold Goldman 14. Decision on Amco Asia et al. v. (President), Isi CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Provisional Measures (09 Republic of Indonesia , 0 Foighel, Edward W. Arbitration Rules December 1983) ICSID Case No. ARB/81/1 Rubin

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; Statute of the DECISIONS: Diversion of Water from ICJ; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: the Meuse Case, Netherlands v. Report of Executive Directors on the ICSID Convention; Belgium (PCIJ); Cour de Cassation, M. Amadio, Le contentieux international de l Sect. Soc. decision of 1 June 1950 I'investissement prive et al Convention de la Banque (France); Sirey 51.89, comment by Mondiale du 18 mars 1965; A. Broches, "The Brunet (France); Cass. Soc., decision of Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes Klöckner Industrie-Anlagen 21 October 1954, Jurisclasseur Between States and Nationals of Other States"; Szasz, "A Eduardo Jiménez GmbH, Klockner Belge, SA periodique, comment by Oubliac and Practical Guide to the Convention on the Settlement of de Aréchaga and Klockner Juglart (France); Cour de cassation, Investment Disputes"; C.F. Amerasinghe, "The 13. Award (21 October (President), Handelsmaatschappij BV v. 1 Holiday Inns decision of 27 January 1970, comment International Centre for the Settlement of Investment 1983) William D. Rogers, Republic of Cameroon and by A. Huet (France); Court de cassation, Disputes and Development Through the Multinational Dominique Societe Camerounaise des 1ere, decision of 5 March 1974 Corporation"; G. Delaume, "Le Centre International pour Schmidt (Diss. Op.) Engrais SA , ICSID Case (France); 74 Jurisclasseur periodique, le Reglement des Differends Relatifs aux Investissements No. ARB/81/2 comment by J. Voulet, who also cites (CIRDI); Esmein, Traite pratique de droit civil francais; the decision of the Cour de cassation, Cassin, De l'exception tiree de 'inexecution dans les 3eme, of 12 March 1969, Cass Civ., rapports synallagmatiques"; A. Weil, Droit Civil, Les 3eme, decision of 6 May 1979 (France); obligations; J. Voulet, Jurisclassuer periodique; P. AWARDS: Fertilizer Corporation of Reynaud, Preface to J.F. Pillebout, Recherches sur India l'exception d'inexecution; Planiol, Traite elementaire de droit civil

PUBLICISTS: Capitant, La cause dans les obligations; Saleilles, Theories generale de l'obligation d'apres le project de Code Civil allemand; Mazaued, Lecons de droit civil; J.F. Pillebout, Recherches sur l'exception Klöckner Industrie-Anlagen GmbH, Klockner Belge, SA and Klockner d'inexecution; P. Lalive, "The First World Bank Handelsmaatschappij BV v. Republic of Cameroon and Societe Arbitration"; NATIONAL LAWS AND Camerounaise des Engrais SA , ICSID Case No. ARB/81/2 CONTINUED REGULATIONS: Cameroonian Investment Code; Cameroonian Law No. 60164 promulgating the Investment Code; Cameroonian Law 64/LF/6; Cameroonian Law 66/LF/5

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: The Law Relating to Berthold Goldman 12. Decision on Amco Asia et al. v. DECISIONS: Temple of Preah Vihear, Estoppel by Representation (Spencer, Bower, and (President), Isi Jurisdiction (25 Republic of Indonesia , 1 Holiday Inns Cambodia v. Thailand (ICJ); Maclaine Turner, 3rd ed. Butterworths); NATIONAL LAWS Foighel, Edward W. September 1983) ICSID Case No. ARB/81/1 v. Gatty (UK) AND REGULATIONS: Indonesian Law No. 1; Rubin Indonesian Foreign Capital Investment Law; Decree of the President of the Republic of Indonesia

1980

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Arbitration Rules; ICSID Administrative and Financial Rules; NATIONAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS: Jørgen Trolle Benvenuti & Bonfant srl v. People's Republic of Congo Constitution, 24 June 1973; DECISIONS: Tribunal de Grande 11. Award (08 August (President), Rudolf Government of the People's People's Republic of Congo Company Law; People's 0 Instance of Paris, Order of 23 December 1980) Bystricky, Edilbert Republic of the Congo , Republic of Congo decree No. 6127/MC/DGC/DGP of 3 1980 (France) Razafindralambo ICSID Case No. ARB/77/2 October 1975; People's Republic of Congo decree No. 75/508 of 9 November 1975; People's Republic of Congo Fundamental Act of the Military Committee of the Party; French Civil Code; French Decree of 28 September 1897

10. Award issued Ivan Wallenberg Guadelupe Case Products embodying the (President), Elihu Corp. v. Federal Military 0 Settlement Agreement Lauterpacht, Pieter Government of Nigieria , (22 July 1980) Sanders ICSID Case No. ARB/78/1

1979

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 31 of 32 TABLE A: PRECEDENT IN ICSID ARBITRATION 1972 - 2006 (As of December 1, 2006) (in reverse chronological order, divided by basis of jurisdiction)

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID Jørgen Trolle AGIP SpA v. Government of Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL LAWS AND 9. Award (30 November (President), René- the People's Republic of the REGULATIONS: French Civil Code; Constitution of 0 1979) Jean Dupuy, Fuad Congo , ICSID Case No. the People's Republic of the Congo; Fundamental Act of Rouhani ARB/77/2 the Military Committee of the Party; Gov't of the Congo Ordinance No. 6/75

1977

Adriano Gardella SpA v. Pierre Cavin 8. Award on the Merits The Government of the CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID (President), Jacques (29 August 1977) Republic of the Ivory 0 Arbitration Rules; NATIONAL LAWS AND Michel Grossen, [EXCERPTS] Coast , ICSID Case No. REGULATIONS: Civil Code of the Ivory Coast Dominique Poncet ARB/74/1

1975

7. Decision on Jørgen Trolle Alcoa Minerals of Jamaica, Jurisdiction and (President), Inc. v. Government of 0 UNPUBLISHED, identical to decision in Kaiser Bauxite Competence (06 July Michael Kerr, Fuad Jamaica , ICSID Case No. 1975) Rouhani ARB/74/2

CONVENTIONS: ICSID Convention; RULES: ICSID 6. Decision on Jørgen Trolle Kaiser Bauxite Company v. Arbitration Rules; PUBLICISTS: Report of the Jurisdiction and (President), Government of Jamaica , 0 Executive Directors; NATIONAL LAWS AND Competence (06 July Michael Kerr, Fuad ICSID Case No. ARB/74/3 REGULATIONS: Jamaica's Bauxite (Production Levy) 1975) Rouhani Act, 1974

Reynolds Jamaica Mines, 5. Decision on Jørgen Trolle Ltd. and Reynolds Metal Jurisdiction and (President), Company v. Government of 0 UNPUBLISHED, identical to decision in Kaiser Bauxite Competence (06 July Michael Kerr, Fuad Jamaica , ICSID Case No. 1975) Rouhani ARB/74/4

1974

4. Decision on Existence Holiday Inns SA, and Scope of Certain Sture Petrén Occidental Petroleum Liabilities deriving from (President), J. Corporation v. Government 0 UNPUBLISHED their Contractual Forster, Paul Reuter of Morocco , ICSID Case Relations (23 September No. ARB/72/1 1974)

Holiday Inns SA, 3. Further Decision on Sture Petrén Occidental Petroleum Jurisdiction and (President), J. Corporation v. Government 0 UNPUBLISHED Admissibility of Claims Forster, Paul Reuter of Morocco , ICSID Case (12 May 1974) No. ARB/72/1

1973 Holiday Inns SA, 2. Decision on Sture Petrén Occidental Petroleum Jurisdiction (01 July (President), J. Corporation v. Government 0 UNPUBLISHED 1973) Forster, Paul Reuter of Morocco , ICSID Case No. ARB/72/1 1972 Holiday Inns SA, 1. Decision on Sture Petrén Occidental Petroleum Provisional Measures (02 (President), J. Corporation v. Government 0 UNPUBLISHED July 1972) Forster, Paul Reuter of Morocco , ICSID Case No. ARB/72/1

/ / Jeffery P. Commission, "Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Empirical Backing" TDM (2007) Page 32 of 32