DOCSLIB.ORG

Recollection Versus Imagination: Exploring Human Memory and Cognition Via Neural Language Models

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Recollection Versus Imagination: Exploring Human Memory and Cognition Via Neural Language Models Recollection versus Imagination: Exploring Human Memory and Cognition via Neural Language Models Maarten Sapzy∗ Eric Horvitzy Yejin Choiz} Noah A. Smithz} James W. Pennebaker| yMicrosoft Research zPaul G. Allen School for Computer Science & Engineering, University of Washington }Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence |Department of Psychology, University of Texas at Austin [email protected], [email protected] Abstract My daughter gave birth to her first child. She and her husband were overwhelmed by emotions. We investigate the use of NLP as a measure ….her husband called me and then drove of the cognitive processes involved in story- her to the hospital. I joined her at the telling, contrasting imagination and recollec- hospital. When we got the hospital things tion of events. To facilitate this, we collect and got complicated. Her husband tried his release HIPPOCORPUS, a dataset of 7,000 sto- best to be with her and to keep her ries about imagined and recalled events. strong. She eventually delivered perfectly. RECALLED We introduce a measure of narrative flow and # concrete events: 7 use this to examine the narratives for imagined We recently attended a family wedding. It was and recalled events. Additionally, we measure the first time in a decade we all got together. the differential recruitment of knowledge at- …My older brother is getting PersonX tributed to semantic memory versus episodic gets married married to a rich tycoon lady. memory imagined re- (Tulving, 1972) for and He will be very happy. I hope causes called storytelling by comparing the frequency he doesn’t get too greedy. PersonX to of descriptions of general commonsense events IMAGINED # concrete events: 1 be happy with more specific realis events. Our analyses show that imagined stories have a Figure 1: Snippets from two stories from HIPPOCOR- substantially more linear narrative flow, com- PUS (top: recalled, bottom: imagined). Concrete pared to recalled stories in which adjacent sen- or realis events (in gray) are more frequent in re- tences are more disconnected. In addition, called stories, whereas general or commonsense events while recalled stories rely more on autobio- (underlined) are associated with imagined stories. graphical events based on episodic memory, imagined stories express more commonsense knowledge based on semantic memory. Fi- other hand, an imagined story about a wedding nally, our measures reveal the effect of narra- tivization of memories in stories (e.g., stories (Figure1, bottom) will largely draw from the au- about frequently recalled memories flow more thor’s commonsense knowledge about the world linearly; Bartlett, 1932). Our findings high- (Kintsch, 1988; Graesser et al., 1981). light the potential of using NLP tools to study We harness neural language and commonsense the traces of human cognition in language. models to study how cognitive processes of rec- 1 Introduction ollection and imagination are engaged in story- telling. We rely on two key aspects of stories: When telling stories, people draw from their own narrative flow (how the story reads) and semantic experiences (episodic knowledge; Conway et al., vs. episodic knowledge (the types of events in the 1996, 2003) and from their general world knowl- story). We propose as a measure of narrative flow edge (semantic knowledge; Bartlett, 1932; Oatley, the likelihood of sentences under generative lan- 1999). For example, in Figure1 (top), a recalled guage models conditioned on varying amounts of story about a birth will likely recount concrete history. Then, we quantify semantic knowledge by events from that day, relying heavily on the au- measuring the frequency of commonsense events thor’s episodic memory (Tulving, 1972). On the (from the ATOMIC knowledge graph; Sap et al., ∗ Research conducted during an internship at Microsoft 2019), and episodic knowledge by counting realis Research. events (Sims et al., 2019), both shown in Figure1. We introduce HIPPOCORPUS,1 a dataset of # stories # sents # words 6,854 diary-like short stories about salient life recalled 2,779 17.8 308.9 events, to examine the cognitive processes of re- imagined 2,756 17.5∗∗ 274.2∗∗ membering and imagining. Using a crowdsourc- retold 1,319 17.3∗ 296.8∗∗ ing pipeline, we collect pairs of recalled and imag- ined stories written about the same topic. By total 6,854 design, authors of recalled stories rely on their Table 1: HIPPOCORPUS data statistics. ∗∗ and ∗ indi- episodic memory to tell their story. cate significant difference from recalled at p < 0:001 We demonstrate that our measures can uncover and p < 0:05, respectively. differences in imagined and recalled stories in HIPPOCORPUS. Imagined stories contain more commonsense events and elaborations, whereas Stage 2: imagined. A new set of workers write recalled stories are more dense in concrete events. imagined stories, using a randomly assigned sum- Additionally, imagined stories flow substantially mary from stage 1 as a prompt. Pairing imagined more linearly than recalled stories. Our findings stories with recalled stories allows us to control for provide evidence that surface language reflects the variation in the main topic of stories. differences in cognitive processes used in imagin- Stage 3: retold past. After 2–3 months, we con- ing and remembering. tact workers from stage 1 and ask them to re-tell Additionally, we find that our measures can un- their stories, providing them with the summary of cover narrativization effects, i.e., the transform- their story as prompt. ing of a memory into a narrative with repeated re- call or passing of time (Bartlett, 1932; Reyna and Post-writing questionnaire (all stages). Imme- Brainerd, 1995; Christianson, 2014). We find that diately after writing, workers describe the main with increased temporal distance or increased fre- topic of the story in a short phrase. We then ask a quency of recollection, recalled stories flow more series of questions regarding personal significance linearly, express more commonsense knowledge, of their story (including frequency of recalling the and are less concrete. event: FREQUENCYOFRECALL; see A.1 for ques- tionnaire details). Optionally, workers could re- 2 2 HIPPOCORPUS Creation port their demographics. We construct HIPPOCORPUS, containing 6,854 3 Measures stories (Table1), to enable the study of imagined and recalled stories, as most prior corpora are ei- To quantify the traces of imagination and recollec- ther limited in size or topic (e.g., Greenberg et al., tion recruited during storytelling, we devise a mea- 1996; Ott et al., 2011). See AppendixA for addi- sure of a story’s narrative flow, and of the types of tional details (e.g., worker demographics; xA.2). events it contains (concrete vs. general). 3.1 Narrative Flow 2.1 Data Collection Inspired by recent work on discourse modeling We collect first-person perspective stories in three (Kang et al., 2019; Nadeem et al., 2019), we use stages on Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk), us- language models to assess the narrative linearity of ing a pairing mechanism to account for topical a story by measuring how sentences relate to their variation between imagined and recalled stories. context in the story. Stage 1: recalled. We ask workers to write a We compare the likelihoods of sentences un- 15–25 sentence story about a memorable or salient der two generative models (Figure2). The bag event that they experienced in the past 6 months. model makes the assumption that every sentence Workers also write a 2–3 sentence summary to be is drawn independently from the main theme of used in subsequent stages, and indicate how long the story (represented by E). On the other hand, ago the events took place (in weeks or months; the chain model assumes that a story begins with a TIMESINCEEVENT). 2 With IRB approval from the Ethics Advisory Board at Microsoft Research, we restrict workers to the U.S., and en- 1Available at http://aka.ms/hippocorpus. sure they are fairly paid ($7.5–9.5/h). edge included explicitly in stories, as a proxy ࣟ ݏ ݏ ǥ ݏ for semantic memory, a form of memory that is (i) bag ଴ ଵ ௜ thought to encode general knowledge about the ࣟ world (Tulving, 1972). While this includes facts ݏ ݏ ǥ ݏ about how events unfold (i.e., scripts or schemas; (ii) chain ଴ ଵ ௜ Schank and Abelson, 1977; van Kesteren et al., Figure 2: Two probabilistic graphical models repre- 2012), here we focus on commonsense knowl- senting (i) bag-like and (ii) chain-like (linear) story rep- edge, which is also encoded in semantic memory resentations. E represents the theme of the story. (McRae and Jones, 2013). Given the social focus of our stories, we use the theme, and sentences linearly follow each other.3. social commonsense knowledge graph ATOMIC (Sap et al., 2019).4 For each story, we first match ∆l is computed as the difference in negative log- likelihoods between the bag and chain models: possible ATOMIC events to sentences by selecting 1 events that share noun chunks and verb phrases ∆l(si) = − [log p(si j E)− with sentences (e.g., “getting married” “Per- jsij sonX gets married”; Figure1). We then search log p(s j E; s )] i 1:i−1 (1) the matched sentences’ surrounding sentences for where the log-probability of a sentence s in a con- commonsense inferences (e.g., “be very happy” text C (e.g., topic E and history s1:i−1) is the sum “happy”; Figure1). We describe this algorithm in of the log-probabilities of its tokens wt in context: further detail in Appendix B.2. In our analyses, the P log p(s j C) = t log p(wt j C; w0:t−1). measure quantifies the number of story sentences We compute the likelihood of sentences using with commonsense tuple matches in the two pre- OpenAI’s GPT language model (Radford et al., ceding and following sentences.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Dance and the Imagination an Inspiration Turned Into a Fantasy
    Twelve Conceptions of Imagination – by Leslie Stevenson (1) The ability to think of something not presently perceived, but spatio‐ temporally real. (2) The ability to think of whatever one acknowledges as possible in the spatio‐temporal world. (3) The ability to think of something that the subject believes to be real, but which is not. (4) The ability to think of things that one conceives of as fictional. (5) The ability to entertain mental images. (6) The ability to think of anything at all. (7) The non‐rational operations of the mind, that is, those explicable in terms of causes rather than reasons. (8) The ability to form perceptual beliefs about public objects in space and time. (9) The ability to sensuously appreciate works of art or objects of natural beauty without classifying them under concepts or thinking of them as useful. (10) The ability to create works of art that encourage such sensuous appreciation. (11) The ability to appreciate things that are expressive or revelatory of the meaning of human life. (12) The ability to create works of art that express something deep about the meaning of life. Dance and the Imagination An inspiration turned into a fantasy based reality A dream envisioned and resourcefully staged Mental creative pictures coming to life Inventiveness using human movement in space Innovation and individuality whether improvised or more formally choreographed Expressive bodily ideas Experiential corporal representations Artistic power and ingenuity transposed into physical form Presentational musculo-skeletal
    [Show full text]
  • A Critical Skill for Learning Scott Barry Kaufman in Recent Years, Schools
    Imagination: A Critical Skill for Learning Scott Barry Kaufman In recent years, schools have become increasingly focused on developing “executive functions” in students. These functions—which include the ability to concentrate, ignore distractions, regulate emotions, and integrate complex information in working memory—are certainly important contributors to learning. However, I believe that in our school’s excitement over executive functions, we’ve missed out on the why of education. Another class of functions have been recently discovered by cognitive neuroscientists that-- when combined with executive functioning—contribute to deep, personally meaningful learning, long-term retention, compassion, and creativity. Dubbed the “default mode network” by cognitive scientists, the following imagination-related functions have been associated with this network: daydreaming, imagining and planning the future, retrieving deeply personal memories, making meaning out of experiences, monitoring one’s emotional state, reading fiction, reflective compassion, and perspective taking. This is an important set of skills to fall by the wayside among our students! In fact, by constantly demanding the executive attention of students for the purposes of abstract learning, we are actively robbing students of the opportunity to use the limited resource of attention for the purposes of personal reflection, meaning-making, and compassionate perspective taking. Let’s be clear: both executive functions and imagination-related cognitive processes are critical to learning. However, when these networks couple together, we can get the best learning outcomes out of students. People who live a meaningful life of creativity and accomplishment combine dreaming with doing. A common thread that runs through both grit and imagination is trial-and-error: the ability to dream, to set concrete goals, to construct various strategies to reach the goal, to tinker with alternative approaches to reaching the goal, and to constantly revise approaches where necessary.
    [Show full text]
  • Destination Imagination Is Proud to Host Our Annual Education Conference at the Westin Park Central Hotel in Dallas, TX, July 25-26, 2014
    Destination Imagination is proud to host our annual education conference at the Westin Park Central Hotel in Dallas, TX, July 25-26, 2014. This year, Ignite will feature more than 30 different workshops and learning opportunities for educators that focus on emerging trends and proven strategies for engaging students in innovative and creative learning. Below are just a few of the more than 30 sessions that will be available to educators at the Ignite 2014 Innovation for Education Conference. The Invention Experience How do you inspire and excite students in the classroom? Use the Invention Experience! In this workshop, teachers will be trained on the successful 6-step invention process used by startups and technology inventors across the world. Each workshop is a hands-on guided tour through the process of invention and entrepreneurship. Teachers will learn how to fit their existing lesson plans into an “invention mindset” and use the simple 6 step process to engage students in any content area you’re teaching! At the conclusion of the workshop, teachers will leave with an Invention Guidebook and a set of worksheets that they can use with their students that will turn any lesson plan, into a hands-on, exciting experience for students of any age! The Invention Experience was developed by two Silicon Valley education entrepreneurs with the support of Microsoft and the Lemelson Foundation. Playful Learning: Bringing Game-Based Learning to Your Classroom! Play is how we learn best. An entire world of games exists to support learning that hasn't been at a teacher’s fingertips—until now.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    Cambridge University Press 978-0-521-86288-2 - Memory in Autism Edited by Jill Boucher and Dermot Bowler Excerpt More information Part I Introduction © Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org Cambridge University Press 978-0-521-86288-2 - Memory in Autism Edited by Jill Boucher and Dermot Bowler Excerpt More information 1 Concepts and theories of memory John M. Gardiner Concept. A thought, idea; disposition, frame of mind; imagination, fancy; .... an idea of a class of objects. Theory. A scheme or system of ideas or statements held as an explan- ation or account of a group of facts or phenomena; a hypothesis that has been confirmed or established by observation or experiment, and is propounded or accepted as accounting for the known facts; a statement of what are known to be the general laws, principles, or causes of some- thing known or observed. From definitions given in the Oxford English Dictionary The Oxford Handbook of Memory, edited by Endel Tulving and Fergus Craik, was published in the year 2000. It is the first such book to be devoted to the science of memory. It is perhaps the single most author- itative and exhaustive guide as to those concepts and theories of memory that are currently regarded as being most vital. It is instructive, with that in mind, to browse the exceptionally comprehensive subject index of this handbook for the most commonly used terms. Excluding those that name phenomena, patient groups, parts of the brain, or commonly used exper- imental procedures, by far the most commonly used terms are encoding and retrieval processes.
    [Show full text]
  • Perceptual Imagination and Perceptual Memory: an Overview
    OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 04/05/2018, SPi 1 Perceptual Imagination and Perceptual Memory An Overview Fiona Macpherson The essays in this volume explore the nature of perceptual imagination and perceptual memory. How do perceptual imagination and memory resemble and differ from each other and from other kinds of sensory experience? And what role does each play in perception and in the acquisition of knowledge? These are the two central questions that the essays in this volume seek to address. One important fact about our mental lives is that sensory experience comes in (at least) three central variants: perception, imagination, and memory. For instance, we may not only see the visible appearance of a person or a building, but also recall or imagine it in a visual manner. The three types of experience share certain important features that are intimately linked to their common sensory character, many of which distinguish them from thought. Among these features are their apparent presentation of external objects or events (rather than propositions about them), their perspectival nature, that is that they present the world from a certain point of view, and their connection to one (or more) of the sense modalities, such as by having some modality- specific content and phenomenal character. But there are also important differences among the three types of sensory experiences. Most notably, there is usually taken to be a fundamental divide between perceptions, on the one hand, and recollections and imaginings, on the other. Perceptual experiences are typically taken to be distinct from imaginative and mnemonic ones in that they present objects with a certain sense of immediacy.
    [Show full text]
  • Graphic Designing: an Critique Imedpub Journals
    iMedPub Journals 2020 www.imedpub.com DOI: 10.36648/ijircce.05.03.02 Graphic Designing: An Critique Saloni Srivatava Sanskriti University, India Corresponding author: Saloni Srivatava, Sanskriti University, India, E-mail: [email protected] Received date: July 29, 2020; Accepted date: August 22, 2020; Published date: September 15, 2020 Copyright: ©2020 Saloni Srivatava. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Basic elements of graphics designing: There are six elements of graphic designing: 1) Line 2) Shape In this paper we study overall view about the graphic 3) Texture 4) Color designing. In this paper history of graphic designing 5) Value is mentioned and also its role is explained. There 6) Space are six basic elements, six basic principles and six rules for graphic designing which are explained here 1). The Line: Lines are considered to be essential part of for the learner to get the enough knowledge about designs based upon different line styles such as dashed, the graphic designing. The main part for designing dotted etc. They can vary based upon their color, thickness. the graphic is to know about the color theory, color length (short or long), straight or curved etc. Lines are used models and resolution for the images which are also as delimiter between different parts of a design and for explained in this paper. In the end we explained bringing users attention to a specific portion in overall some of the applications of graphic designing.
    [Show full text]
  • Practices of Imagination: Learning from the Vision of Thadious Davis
    Bryn Mawr College Scholarship, Research, and Creative Work at Bryn Mawr College English Faculty Research and Scholarship English 2019 Practices of Imagination: Learning from the Vision of Thadious Davis Mecca Jamilah Sullivan Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.brynmawr.edu/engl_pubs Part of the English Language and Literature Commons Let us know how access to this document benefits ou.y This paper is posted at Scholarship, Research, and Creative Work at Bryn Mawr College. https://repository.brynmawr.edu/engl_pubs/32 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Mecca Jamilah Sullivan (2019). “Practices of Imagination: Learning from the Vision of Thadious Davis.” Women's Studies. DOI: 10.1080/00497878.2019.1639506 Practices of Imagination: Learning from the Vision of Thadious Davis Mecca Jamilah Sullivan In her 1988 Essay “Expanding the Limits: The Intersection of Race and Region,” Thadious Davis traces late twentieth-century black writers’ acts of what she terms “historical imagination,” in which moments of creative and geographic return to southern regional pasts open new possibilities for black identification (9). This prefigures her path-breaking work in Southscapes: Geographies of Race, Region, and Literature, in which imagination works alongside–and, at times, in a tension with – memory and history to produce sites of black regional identity in the Deep South. Throughout the creative production of “southscapes,” Davis argues, black southern artists, “by means of a spatial imagination, locate themselves within a relationship to ‘homeplace’ … ” in the South, subverting dominant racist ideologies and thus “claim[ing] the very space that would negate their humanity and devalue their worth” (Southscapes 19).
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis an Investigation of Imagination in Public
    THESIS AN INVESTIGATION OF IMAGINATION IN PUBLIC EDUCATION Submitted by Marcus W. Viney English Department In partial fulfillment of the requirements For the Degree of Master of Arts Colorado State University Fort Collins, Colorado Spring 2013 Master’s Committee: Advisor: Pamela Coke Cindy O’Donnell-Allen Rodrick Lucero ABSTRACT AN INVESTIGATION OF IMAGINATION IN PUBLIC EDUCATION Current literature concerning the role of imagination in education widely ignores the perspectives of students and teachers. This qualitative study aims to examine these perspectives through interviews with two language arts teachers and three students in two secondary school contexts. My research questions were: (1) What role does the imagination have in secondary education? (2) To what extent does the imagination deserve our attention as teachers? (3) What types of instruction, activities, and learning environments support student imagination? Participants reported that imagination plays a crucial role in education and offered several ideas about how best to cultivate imagination in the classroom. Given these findings I conclude that it is imperative that imagination receives more attention from educators and researchers. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................... 1 LITERATURE REVIEW ............................................................................................................... 6 WHAT IS THE IMAGINATION? ............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Family Handbook
    FAMILY HANDBOOK IMAGINATION LEARNING CENTER | FAMILY HANDBOOK 1 2 IMAGINATION LEARNING CENTER | FAMILY HANDBOOK 1. WELCOME 4 2. ABOUT IMAGINATION LEARNING CENTER 5 2.1 Company History 5 2.2 Mission Statement 5 2.3 Philosophy of Education 6 2.4 The Educational Team 7 2.5 Our Programs 8 2.6 Hours of Operation 9 3. FAMILY PARTNERSHIP 10 3.1 Open Door Policy 10 3.2 Grievance Policy 10 3.3 Confidentiality 11 3.4 Helping Hands Program 11 3.5 Written Communication 12 3.6 Babysitting 13 4. ADMISSIONS 14 4.1 Admission Process 14 4.2 Tuition and Fees 16 4.3 Leaving the Center 18 5. DAILY PRACTICES 20 5.1 Arrival and Departure 20 5.2 Daily Schedule 20 5.3 Outdoor Play 21 5.4 Meal Times 22 5.5 Quiet Times 22 5.6 Classroom Transitions 22 5.7 Special Programs 23 5.8 Birthdays 23 6. HEALTH, SAFETY & EMERGENCY PROCEDURES 24 6.1 Health Practices 24 6.2 Safety Procedures 27 6.3 Emergency Management 30 7. GUIDANCE POLICIES 32 7.1 Behavior Management 32 7.2 Time-Outs or Time-Ins? 33 7.3 Tantrums 34 7.4 Biting 34 IMAGINATION LEARNING CENTER | FAMILY HANDBOOK 3 1 WELCOME ImagiNation Learning Center Family, Welcome to ImagiNation Learning Center! We are delighted that your family has chosen our center for your child’s care and early childhood education. While we know that no teacher can replace the love and understanding of a parent or anoth- er family member; we have a primary responsibility to respect, support, and pro- mote your child’s individuality and self-esteem.
    [Show full text]
  • Memory, Imagination, and the Cognitive Value of the Artsq
    Consciousness and Cognition Consciousness and Cognition 13 (2004) 254–267 www.elsevier.com/locate/concog Memory, imagination, and the cognitive value of the artsq Memory has many aspects which psychologists have not discovered, but of which the poet, who constructs its image, is aware. But the poet is not a psychologist; his knowledge is not explicit, but implicit in his conception of the image. The critic, analyzing the way the remembranceÕ of the virtual Past is made, is the person who is in a position to discover the intricacies of real memory through the artistic devices that achieve its semblance. —Susanne K. Langer, Feeling and Form The theory of art is really a prolegomenon to the much greater undertaking of constructing a concept of mind adequate to the living actuality. —Susanne K. Langer, Mind: An essay on human feeling, Vol. 1 1. Voluntary and involuntary memory in Proust’s theory of art and consciousness In a fitting tribute to William James’s vision of psychology, Russell Epstein (2004) proposes that the arts can contribute to the scientific study of consciousness through the resources they provide for investigating the phenomenology of conscious experience. Epstein makes sensitive use of Proust’s novel, The Remembrance of Things Past, to argue that the task of the writer is to ‘‘convey experience truly’’ (Epstein, p. 218), which for Proust meant creating a work of literary art that makes explicit ‘‘the whole nexus of associations, memories, and emotions’’—usually present in the ‘‘fringe’’ or background of consciousness—that gives each experience its unique ‘‘savour and significance’’ and therefore constitutes its ‘‘essence’’ (Epstein, p.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Imagination in Perception
    S. Afr. J. Philos. 1996, 15(4) 133 The role of imagination in perception Michael Pendlebury Department of Philosophy, University of the Witwatersrand, Private Bag 3, WITS 2050, Johannesburg, South Africa Received April 1996; revised May 1996 This article is an explication and defence of Kant's view that 'imagination is a necessary ingredient of perception itself' (Crifique of Pure Reason A1 20, fn.). Imagination comes into perception at a far more basic level than Strawson allows, and is required for the constitution of intuitions (= sense experiences) out of sense impressions. It also plays an important pact in explaining how it is possible for intuitions to have intentional contents. These functions do not involve the application of concepts, and I offer a schematic account of how they are carried out by preconceptual syntheses. Hicrdie artikel bied 'n uiteensctting en verdediging van Kant se beskouing dat verbeelding 'n noodsaaklike bestanddeel van persepsie is (Kritik der reinen Vernunff Al20, vn.). Verbeelding funksioneer in persepsie op 'n mcer basiese vlak as dit waarvoor Strawson toelaat, en dit is noodsaaklik vir die konstitusie van intu'isies (= sintuiglik ervaringe) op basis van sin- tuiglike indrukke. Verbeelding speel ook 'n bclangrike rol in die verduideliking van hoe dit moontlik is vir intu'isies om in- tensionele inhoud te h&.Hierdie funksies behels nie die toepassing van konsepte nie en ek bied 'n skematiese uiteensetting van hoe hierdie funksies uitgevoer word deur voorkonseptuele sinteses. In a well-known footnotc in the Transcendental Deduction in A,' lcctual mental capacities as 'proto-concepts'. I would like to Kant makes the intriguing claim that 'imagination is a necessary stress that I think that the operation of imagination in perception ingredient of perception itself' (A120, fn.), Strawson, in his is inseparable from the excrcise of proto-concepts so understood, paper 'Imagination and Perception' (Strawson 1970),2 suggests and nothing in this article should be taken to gainsay this.
    [Show full text]
  • Imagination and Memory: Does Imagining Implausible Events Lead to False Autobiographical Memories?
    JournalPsychonomic Bulletin & Review 2006, ??13 (?),(5), ???-???764-769 Imagination and memory: Does imagining implausible events lead to false autobiographical memories? KATHY PEZDEK Claremont Graduate University, Claremont, California IRIS BLANDON-GITLIN California State University, Fullerton, California and PAMELA GABBAY Claremont Graduate University, Claremont, California Previous studies have reported that imagination can induce false autobiographical memories. This finding has been used to suggest that psychotherapists who have clients imagine suspected repressed memories of childhood sexual abuse may, in fact, be inducing false memories for the imagined events. In this study, at Time 1 and then, 2 weeks later, at Time 2, 145 subjects rated each of 20 events on the Life Events Inventory as to whether each had occurred to them in childhood. One week after Time 1, the subjects were told that 2 target events were plausible and 2 were implausible. They were then asked to imagine 1 plausible and 1 implausible target event. Plausibility and imagining interacted to affect occurrence ratings; whereas imagining plausible events increased the change in occurrence ratings, imagining implausible events had no effect on occurrence ratings. Over the past decade, there has been an abundance of (cf. Garry, Manning, Loftus, & Sherman, 1996; Garry & research in cognitive psychology on false memories. A Polaschek, 2000), in which imagining events on the Life PsycINFO search of the empirical publications in cogni- Events Inventory (LEI) increases belief that the events oc- tive psychology conducted through January 2004, using curred in one’s childhood. the subject heading “false memory,” produced 198 ar- Pezdek, Finger, and Hodge (1997) have suggested one ticles, all published since 1993 (Pezdek & Lam, 2007).
    [Show full text]