Submission from the NZ Newspaper Publishers' Association

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Submission from the NZ Newspaper Publishers' Association Submission from the NZ Newspaper Publishers’ Association October 15 2015 The New Zealand Newspaper Publishers’ Association welcomes the opportunity to comment on the document, Content Regulation in a Converged World. The Newspaper Publishers’ Association represents 26 daily and Sunday newspapers and their websites. They include The New Zealand Herald, The Dominion Post, The Press, Otago Daily Times, Sunday Star- Times, Herald on Sunday, stuff.co.nz, nzherald.co.nz and odt.co.nz. A full list of members is attached. Our comments are directed specifically at Option 2: Voluntary code – no regulatory intervention and Option 6: A new Media Content Standards Act. Content standards – then and now The newspaper industry and the national journalists’ union collaborated in the early 1970s to support the establishment of the New Zealand Press Council which is now an incorporated society. From its inception in 1972, the Press Council has adjudicated on complaints according to its statement of principles (code of ethics). To ensure its independence, the council has always been chaired by a former judge and has a majority of public (non media industry) members. Because of its more than 40 years’ experience, the council can also rely on an established body of precedent decisions. As well as acting as a watchdog over media behavior and receiving complaints from the public, the council also has a key responsibility in defending, and advocating, freedom of expression, enhanced by a free press which this association believes to be fundamental to the health of a properly functioning democracy. Independence of the media is interlinked with freedom of expression which is why New Zealand publishers have never favoured State involvement in any complaints handling structure. The council is fully funded by its media and union subscribers and is no drain on the public coffers. It is non-legalistic, easily accessible to the public and responds quickly to complaints. The council is held in high regard by its media subscribers who regard it as a professional slight to be subject to an “upheld” decision. Where a complaint is upheld, the council requires the offending publication or website to publish the council’s decision in a prominent position. It can also instruct an offending website to take down the article complained of. The council, in its latest constitution, also has the power to censure an offending publication, website or individual, such censure to be published in a prominent position. The council does not have the power to impose fines. The complaints process is widely publicised by the media industry with a brief item advertising the council’s existence, and how to make a complaint, published every day by daily newspapers and weekly and monthly by subscribing weekly newspapers and magazines. Similar publicity is afforded by subscribing digital media. The council is also recognised and understood by the public. An average of 150 complaints are received per year. Many complaints are minor in nature and subject to an informal mediation process conducted by the council’s staff. About half the complaints are elevated to the formal jurisdiction process, with the complaint being heard by the full council. Media members of the council (the minority) must stand down where a complaint is directed at their employing media organisation. Members of the Newspaper Publishers’ Association have been part of the rapidly changing media landscape and have strongly supported the Press Council evolving to better reflect these changes. Key moves have been the council’s expansion of its remit in 1998 to include magazines, and a further expansion a year later to hear complaints about content appearing on subscriber publishers’ websites. More recently, the council rewrote its constitution in 2014 to provide tougher sanctions against offending content, and to allow for a wider membership including a new status of associate member for independent newspaper, magazine and website publishers. The latter includes bloggers. Several have now joined up. Strengths The newspaper industry sees the strengths of the Press Council to be its: - Jurisdictional independence from publishers - Voluntary membership - Buy-in from publishers and acceptance of the council’s complaints process - Ongoing demonstration that self-regulation works - Relatively low cost - Lack of financial dependence on the State Proof of the Press Council’s effectiveness can be seen in the responsible nature of the New Zealand press (in its wider sense). The New Zealand media are largely free from the examples of egregious behavior sometimes demonstrated by newspapers and websites in other countries, notably the UK and Australia. Existence of the Press Council exercises an undeniable restraining influence on New Zealand media behavior. In short, the system works. The future While the media industry here will continue to evolve, the Newspaper Publishers’ Association remains confident in the ability of the Press Council to be nimble-footed, to adapt to change, and to maintain public confidence. And in the face of possible changes flagged in the discussion document, the Newspaper Publishers’ Association reiterates the old adage, “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” But if there is a tide of opinion in the future that favours the development of a new standards model, then the NPA requests that it be involved meaningfully in any discussion process. This association’s bottom line will continue to be based on self-regulation, voluntary membership, low cost and no State involvement. Michael Muir OBE President New Zealand Newspaper Publishers’ Association 39 Market Place PO Box 2941 Auckland 1140 New Zealand Newspaper Publishers’ Association List of members: The New Zealand Herald The Dominion Post The Press Otago Daily Times Ashburton Guardian Bay of Plenty Times The Taranaki Daily News Rotorua Daily Post Manawatu Standard The Gisborne Herald The Greymouth Evening Star Hawke’s Bay Today The Marlborough Express The Nelson Mail The Northern Advocate The Southland Times The Timaru Herald Waikato Times Wairarapa Times-Age Wanganui Chronicle The Westport News The Wairoa Star Whakatane Beacon Sunday Star-Times Sunday News Herald on Sunday .
Recommended publications
  • AGMANZ New Volume 6 Number 3 August 1975
    w ’ , ' o. KEN eonsev " " - ‘ " ‘ P.O. Box 9120 WELLINGTON NEW ZEALAND (04) 850-696 AGMANZ NEWS Canterbury lssue The Art Galleries & Museums Association at New Zealand Volume 6 Number3 August 1975 AGMANZ NEWS vol 6 no 3 The Art Galleries and Museums august 1975 Association of New Zealand contents administration 46 Robert McDougall Art Gallery President: Bruce Hamlin B.D. Muir ‘ National Museum Private Bag 43 Lyttieton Historical Museum Wellington. Telephone — 59-609 Chatham islands Museum Secretary: Constance Kirkcaldie 49 Rangiora and District Early Records Society New Zealand Academy of Fine Arts 50 Langlois-Eteveneaux House and Museum Private Bag Wellington. 52 The Ferrymead Museum Telephone — 59-267 John S. Shanks Treasurer: Mrs M. Gibson-Smith 54 Progress on the Hundredth Anniversary Wing PO. Box 6853, of Canterbury Museum Auckland 1. Roger Duff Telephone — 74650 ext. 633 55 Pneumatically formed fibreglaSs diorama shells Editor: Ken Gorbey Bryan Shore PO. Box 1382, Who You Should Know — 15 Hamilton. 58 George Packwood Telephone — 84-119 58 Carol Quirk 59 Melvin Day 59 Frank H. Dickinson 60 Still more museums copy for the news J.C. Yaldwyn New Zealand News Manuscripts may be submitted to the Editor at any 65 Vincent Van Gogh in Auckland time. Copy should be typed, double spaced and 65 Tour of US. Museums ideally on A4 paper. The Editor cannot undertake 65 Maori carving from New York to extract copy from newsclip supplied by contrib- Letters to the Editor utors. Photographs for publication should be glossy 66 Museum catalogue markings and of a fair size. Photographs are reproduced by a 66 Proliferation of small museums and reduction process and therefore small prints are accreditation difficult to publish.
    [Show full text]
  • Letters to the Editor Guidelines
    Letters to the editor Guidelines Do you feel strongly about a child poverty issue? Write a letter to the editor using our simple letter writing techniques, list of email addresses and examples of sample letters (family income assistance, housing, health, education, gambling etc): • All newspapers require your name, personal address and daytime telephone number. • Do not send your letter as an attachment. Use cut and paste. • Check the word length accepted by the newspaper (usually around 150 words). Longer letters may be published but could be edited in a way you do not agree with. • The brevity of letters means you can only make one or two points. Make sure your arguments are set out in a logical way. • Get someone unfamiliar with the issue to read the letter – does it make sense to that person? • Stick to the issues and avoid personal attacks (even if you are responding to a personal attack). • Try to respond to an issue as soon as possible. • Proofread your letter carefully and check your word length. • Letters can be emailed –put letter to the editor in the subject line. • If you have any questions or want a letter to the editor checked, email [email protected] Email addresses of main daily papers Letter to editor in subject line/cut and paste text Ashburton Guardian [email protected] Bay of Plenty Times [email protected] Dominion Post [email protected] Daily News [email protected] Daily Post [email protected] Gisborne Herald [email protected] Greymouth Evening Star [email protected] Hawkes Bay Today
    [Show full text]
  • 5. Climatic Hazards
    5. CLIMATIC HAZARDS Reference: West Coast Regional Council: Natural Hazards Review 2002, DTec Consulting Christchurch (the DTec Report) Climatic Hazards are caused by one or a combination of: A. heavy rainfall B. hail C. thunder & lightning D. strong winds – tornadoes E. snow & ice F. droughts G. wildfires Past examples of these are: a. Heaviest rain recorded on WC found at WCRC rain gauge upper Cropp River. Less heavy rain recorded at Niwa rain gauge at Taipo River by highway b. Hail effects on White Heron colony near Whataroa, Press 2001 c. Thunder & Lightning constant January 1995 in Greymouth area: Snowflake Factory struck/burnt down d. Strong winds: Katabatic winds Waiho – Whataroa areas, Nov.1975. Tornadoes: Small ones occur regularly along coast in vicinity of Hokitika and Greymouth. e. Snow & Ice: are a problem in winter at times in Rahu, Lewis, Otira Pass Areas. Problem is usually for road / communication links to West Coast f. Drought: Degree of this on WC can be ascertained by scanning rainfall records any year. Example seen in effect on Greymouth water supply over summers of 1998 to 2001 g. Wildfires: Limited sporadic newspaper data but more in records at Greymouth Fire Station: (Note also fires due to spontaneous combustion, e.g. of coal) NB There is less organized data on Climatic Hazards overall but plenty anecdotally, particularly in Newspaper records. Studies of these hazards lend themselves well to research. The excerpts on following pages are from DTec Report pp 110 - 119 CLIMATIC HAZARDS Introduction The previous chapters have dealt with the more obvious natural hazards in the region.
    [Show full text]
  • THE BATTLE for HAPPY VALLEY News Media, Public Relations, and Environmental Discourse
    THE BATTLE FOR HAPPY VALLEY News Media, Public Relations, and Environmental Discourse Saing Te A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Philosophy in Communication Studies, Auckland University of Technology, 2010. ...the specific character of despair is precisely this: it is unaware of being despair. SØREN KIERKEGAARD, The Sickness Unto Death ii Table of Contents Abbreviations v List of Tables vi List of Figures vi Attestation of authorship vii Acknowledgements viii Abstract ix 1. Introduction 1 Overview of chapters and their purpose 1 News Media Organisations and Public Relations 5 Framing and Environmental Discourse 7 The Corporate Response to Environmental Criticisms 9 Theoretical and methodological considerations 10 Method 18 2. News Media, Public Relations and Environmental Discourse 22 The News Media Domain 22 The Public Relations Industry 26 Public Relations and the News Media 32 The News Media and Public Relations in New Zealand 33 News Frames and Environmental Discourse 39 Reframing Environmentalism: The Corporate Response 43 Conclusion 49 3. Mining, Environmental Concerns, and the Corporate Response 52 Mining and the Environment 52 Coal Mining 54 Anti-Coal Activism and the Corporate Response 56 Development of the Environmental Movement in New Zealand 63 Conclusion 70 iii 4. From State Coal Mines to Solid Energy 72 Overview of New Zealand‟s Coal Industry 72 Shifting Structures of Official Environmental Discourse 83 Political Machinations and „Dirty Tricks‟ 94 Conclusion 109 5. The Cypress Mine Project 111 The West Coast Economy 111 Stockton Mine 113 The Cypress Extension of Stockton Opencast Mine 115 Local Responses 118 Environmental Groups 122 Issues surrounding the Cypress Mine Project 126 Conclusion 130 6.
    [Show full text]
  • Daily Newspapers
    10 The Northern Advocate (N) Daily Newspapers Whangārei Published: Morning Mon-Sat Page size: Compact Mon-Fri 1 The New Zealand Herald (N) Broadsheet Sat Auckland Published: Morning Mon-Sat 11 Bay of Plenty Times (N) Page size: Compact Mon-Fri Tauranga Broadsheet Sat Published: Morning Mon-Sat Page size: Compact Mon-Fri 2 Waikato Times (S) Broadsheet Sat Hamilton Published: Morning Mon-Sat 12 Whakātane Beacon (I) Page size: Compact Mon-Fri Whakātane Broadsheet Sat Published: Morning Wed & Fri 10 Page size: Compact 3 Taranaki Daily News (S) New Plymouth 13 Rotorua Daily Post (N) Published: Morning Mon-Sat Rotorua Page size: Compact Mon-Fri 1 Published: Morning Mon-Sat Broadsheet Sat Page size: Compact Mon-Fri Broadsheet Sat 4 Whanganui Chronicle (N) Whanganui 14 The Gisborne Herald (I) Gisborne Published: Morning Mon-Sat 2 Page size: Compact Mon-Fri 11 12 Published: Afternoon Mon-Sat Broadsheet Sat Page size: Compact 5 Manawatū Standard (S) 14 15 Wairoa Star (I) Palmerston North 13 Wairoa Published: Morning Mon-Sat Published: Morning Tues & Thu Page size: Compact Mon-Fri 15 Page size: Compact Broadsheet Sat 3 16 Hawkes Bay Today (N) 6 Wairarapa Times Age (I) 16 Hastings Masterton Published: Morning Mon-Sat Published: Morning Mon-Sat Page size: Compact Mon-Fri Page size: Compact 4 Broadsheet Sat 7 The Dominion Post (S) 5 17 The Westport News (I) Wellington Westport Published: Morning Mon-Sat Published: Afternoon Mon-Fri Page size: Compact Mon-Fri 6 Page size: Broadsheet Broadsheet Sat 18 Greymouth Star (I) 8 The Nelson Mail (S) 7 Greymouth
    [Show full text]
  • Public Version Fairfax / Nzme Response to Submissions 29
    PUBLIC VERSION FAIRFAX / NZME RESPONSE TO SUBMISSIONS 29 JULY 2016 INTRODUCTION 1. NZME Limited 1 (" NZME ") and Fairfax NZ Limited (" Fairfax ") have had the opportunity to review the public submissions to the Commerce Commission (" Commission ") in response to the Commission's Statement of Preliminary Issues dated 14 June 2016 (" SOPI ") in relation to the Fairfax / NZME application (the " Application ") seeking approval to merge the New Zealand operations of NZME and Fairfax (the "Transaction "). 2. Fairfax and NZME's responses and observations in relation to the submissions and the key points contained in them are set out below. Appendix Two also contains an overview of the recent Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2016 and The Pew Research Center State of the News Media 2016 report that reinforce the acceleration of the trends identified in the Application. SUMMARY 3. The Commission received 49 submissions in total. Once duplicated submissions from a single person / economic entity are removed, there are fewer than 40.2 This is a low number of submissions on a high-profile transaction involving media. 3 4. All the submissions were from competitors, journalists, or academics / public policy lobby groups. That is unusual when measured, for example, against the range of submissions received by the Commission on its last high profile authorisation. 4 It is however not surprising. In traditional competition analysis, if competitors are opposing, it is often an indicator that the merger will be pro-competitive,5 as the merged entity is potentially expected to provide a better offering to customers (in this case, consumers and advertisers). 5.
    [Show full text]
  • In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand Ca233/2012 [2013]
    IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND CA233/2012 [2013] NZCA 428 BETWEEN RAYMOND BRUCE SMITH Appellant AND FRANCIS THOMAS DOOLEY First Respondent AND MOHAMMED SHAHADAT Second Respondent Hearing: 3 July 2013 Court: O'Regan P, Stevens and Wild JJ Counsel: P A McKnight and A J Romanos for Appellant R K P Stewart and J P M Scott for First Respondent No appearance for Second Respondent Judgment: 13 September 2013 at 10 am JUDGMENT OF THE COURT A The appeal is allowed. B The declaration made by the High Court is set aside. C The first respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis plus usual disbursements. ____________________________________________________________________ REASONS OF THE COURT (Given by Wild J) SMITH V DOOLEY CA233/2012 [2013] NZCA 428 [13 September 2013] Table of Contents Para No Introduction [1] Background [6] Events leading to Mr Dooley suing Mr Smith for defamation [9] Issues On Mr Smith’s appeal [36] On Mr Dooley’s cross-appeal [37] ISSUES ON MR SMITH’S APPEAL The six alleged meanings [38] The defence of truth [57] The defence of qualified privilege: ill will [73] Improper advantage: recklessness [83] Discretion to grant a declaration [92] Second cause of action [106] ISSUES ON MR DOOLEY’S CROSS-APPEAL Mr Dooley bearing some responsibility [113] Finding about a telephone call [118] Award of solicitor and client costs [123] Only 70 per cent? [124] Joint and several liability for costs? [130] 30 per cent of the costs awarded apportioned to Mr Smith? [133] Taxation of costs? [135] Result [137] Costs [140] Introduction [1] The appellant, Raymond Smith, appeals against a judgment of the High Court declaring that he had defamed the first respondent, Francis Dooley.
    [Show full text]
  • The New Zealand Gazette 1661
    AUG. 31] THE NEW ZEALAND GAZETTE 1661 New Zealand Apple and PeO/l' Marketing Board Notice to Mariners No. 49 of 1950 Marine Department, HOLESALE prices for apples and pears will be made known Wellington, N.Z., 29th August, 1950. W to the wholesale trade by the methods of public advertisiug and circular. It is the intention of the Board to advertise details NEW ZEALAND.-NoRTH ISLAND.-WHANGAPARAOA of alterations, if any, to wholesale prices of apples and pears in the Live Shell Practice Provincial and Metropolitan newspapers set out below:- Particulars of live shell practice which has been arranged are Auckland .. Auckland Star. as follows :- N.Z. Herald. Ashburton Ashburton Guardian. (a) Dates of shoot: 9th and 10th September, 1950. Blenheim .. Marlborough Express. (b) Duration of shoot: 0800 to 1600 hours daily. Christchurch Ohristchurch Press. (c) Place: Whangaparaoa. Ohristchurch Star·Sun. (d) Danger height: 10,000 ft. Dannevirke Dannevirke Evening News. (e) Danger area bounded by- Dunedin Evening Star. Lat., 36° 32'·5 S. ; long., 175° E. Otago Daily Times. 36° 37' s.; 174° 49' E. Gisborne .. Gisborne Herald. 36° 36' s.; 174° 48' E. Greymouth Grey River Argus. 36° 31' S.; 174° 47' E. Hamilton .. Waikato Times. Authority: Army Department, 23rd August, 1950. Hastings .. H.B. Herald Tribune. Hawera Hawera Star. W. C. SMITH, Secretary. Invercargill Southland Times. (M. 25/1400.) Southland Daily News. Masterton Wairarapa Times Age. Napier Daily Telegraph. Nelson Nelson Evening Mail. Land Declared an Infected Place Under the Swck Act, 1908 (Notice New Plymouth Taranaki Daily News. No. Ag. 4906) Taranaki Herald. Oamaru Oamaru Mail.
    [Show full text]
  • NZMJ 1510.Indd
    ARTICLE The role and functions of community health councils in New Zealand’s health system: a document analysis Gagan Gurung, Sarah Derrett, Robin Gauld ABSTRACT BACKGROUND: Community/consumer health councils (CHCs) are a relatively new phenomenon in New Zealand. CHCs are usually established within district health boards (DHBs) to help address gaps in community engagement in the health sector. Little is known about the establishment, structure, roles and functioning of these councils. AIM: To undertake a literature review, including grey literature, related to the structure, roles and functioning of CHCs in New Zealand. METHOD: A document analysis of the New Zealand-focused website materials and newspaper articles related to CHCs was conducted. Data were analysed thematically using a qualitative content analysis approach. RESULTS: The search identified 251 relevant web sources and 118 newspaper articles. The main role of the CHCs appeared to be to advise and make recommendations to their respective DHBs (and DHB governance and management structures) about health service planning, delivery and policy. All CHCs discussed in the identified sources comprised di erent demographic backgrounds and expertise. Although the CHCs were mainly engaged in information sharing and consultation, their influence on DHB decision-making could not be determined from the sources. CONCLUSION: This is the first study of CHCs throughout New Zealand investigating their roles, structure and type of engagement. As the concept is evolving and more CHCs are being established, this information may be useful for future CHCs. With increasing longevity of CHCs in New Zealand, future studies could usefully investigate CHCs’ potential to represent the health interests of their local communities, and their influence on DHB decision-making.
    [Show full text]
  • Investor Briefing
    INVESTOR BRIEFING JUNE 2016 DISCLAIMER You must read this disclaimer before reading or making any use of this document While reasonable care has been taken in compiling this presentation, none and the accompanying material or any information contained in it. of NZME, APN nor any subsidiary, director, employee, agent or adviser of NZME or APN (to the maximum extent permitted by law) gives any warranty or This presentation has been prepared as at 16 June 2016 to provide a general representation (express or implied) of the accuracy, completeness or reliability overview of the New Zealand business of APN News & Media Limited (APN) in of the information contained in it, nor takes any responsibility for it. The conjunction with the proposed demerger of Wilson & Horton Limited (NZME) information in this presentation has not been and will not be independently from APN. It has been prepared solely for informational purposes and does not verified or audited. purport to be complete or comprehensive and does not constitute financial product, investment, tax or other advice. This presentation should be read in This presentation contains historical financial information of APN after applying conjunction with the Explanatory Memorandum that was released to ASX and pro forma adjustments that were considered appropriate to reflect the indicative NZX on 11 May 2016 which can be found on the APN website (www.apn.com.au). effect of the Demerger as described in the Explanatory Memorandum. This presentation is not a product disclosure statement or other offering The financial information in this presentation: document under the laws of New Zealand or any other jurisdiction or law.
    [Show full text]
  • Media List (Updated 15 July 2016)
    MEDIA LIST (UPDATED 15 JULY 2016) Newspaper Sport Editors Newspaper Email Address Phone Number Ashburton Courier [email protected] 03 308 7664 Auckland City Harbour News [email protected] 09 926 9104 Bay of Plenty Times [email protected] 07 577 7770 Central Leader [email protected] 09 926 9104 The Christchurch Star [email protected] 03 379 7100 Dominion Post [email protected] 04 474 0070 Eastern Courier [email protected] 09 272 7017 Fielding Herald 06 323 5839 Gisborne Herald [email protected] 06 869 0633 The Greymouth Star 03 769 7913 Hawke's Bay Today [email protected] 06 873 0800 Horowhenua Mail [email protected] Hutt News [email protected] 04 589 7622 Manawatu Guardian [email protected] 06 357 5053 Manawatu Standard [email protected] 06 355 8817 Manukau Courier [email protected] 09 272 7017 The Marlborough Express [email protected] 03 520 8928 Nelson Mail [email protected] 03 546 2873 New Zealand Herald [email protected] 09 379 5050 North Shore Times [email protected] 09 489 4189 The Northern Advocate [email protected] 09 470 2875 Northern News / Harbour News [email protected] 09 407 0050 Oamaru Mail [email protected] 03 433 0535 Otago Daily Times [email protected] 03 479 3524 The Press [email protected] 03 943 2752 Rangitikei Mail [email protected] 06 327 8671 Rodney Times [email protected] 09 426 5024 Rotorua Daily Post [email protected] 07 348 6199 Rotorua Review [email protected] The Southland
    [Show full text]
  • Nineteenth Century New Zealand Novels and Novellas Published As Serials in New Zealand, Australian and British Newspapers and Pe
    Nineteenth Century New Zealand Novels and Novellas Published as Serials in New Zealand, Australian and British Newspapers and Periodicals and Never Published as Monographs: A Checklist J.E. TRAUE Additions, corrections and comments are invited. Please send details to [email protected] “It is to the old newspapers that we must go if we want to see the beginning of colonial fiction … there are in the dusty files of these and other journals many stories of colonial life which have never struggled out of the papers into book form.” Clara Eyre Cheeseman, “Colonials in Fiction,” NZ Illustrated Magazine 7 no. 4 (1 January 1903): 274. A New Zealand novel is defined as one first published in New Zealand, or with a significant reference to New Zealand or written by an author resident in New Zealand. Where a serial carries the byline “Written specially for,” “Specially written for” or “Written expressly for” it is assumed that the author is resident locally within New Zealand unless there is evidence to the contrary. In general, fictional works appearing in three or fewer episodes are excluded. Fiction written for children is not included. Airlie, pseud. Author of short stories published in the Saturday Advertiser in September 1879 and New Zealand Mail, 1895-97. Identified as “a young lady,” NZ Mail, 5 June 1880. Esther. A New Zealand Story. By Airlie. New Zealand Mail, 12 Jun-10 Jly 1880 (Short romance set in Wellington (5 instalments) and southern New Zealand) A. M. See Pyke, Vincent A. M. K. See Kavanagh, Arthur McMurrough A. M.
    [Show full text]